Skip to main content
Loading video...

Episode 97 - Looking Back On Old Reviews

Transcript 1:02:42

you're listening to the broken meele show a podcast that speaks passionately about board games for the benefit of those who play them my name's Luke Hector best known for the broken meeple YouTube channel and I'm an everyday gamer just like you and I'll be talking about reviews top 10 and just about anything that connects me to board games as long as I have a tea or coffee in hand that is so grab a cup relax and enjoy and remember it's only a game hi everyone this is episode 97 and H the camera down just a tiny bit cuz it's a little darker in here and that's mainly because I'm just trying to keep the sunlight out cuz I want this room to stay reasonably cool so I'm not sweating buckets by the time I finish this episode yeah 97 we're almost up to 100 and well I say 100 100 of this particular series I mean it's not like this is the 100th podcast episode I probably went over that Milestone donkey years ago but you know just in terms of the broken meol show format we're nearly up to 100 I was thinking about what to do for it and I've come up with a decision basically the patreons have suggested an offline Q&A so normally I do these q&as live and just get questions on the Fly this time I'm going to do an offline one so they're they're giving me a bunch of questions and I'm just going to answer as many of them as I can in you know as much detail as I can in the time and just go through all of those in the hund episode so yeah that'll just be one big mishmash of Q&A but at least I won't be distracted by trying to run a live stream or or you know say hi to people and stuff like

that I'll be able to just sort of concentrate on it you know by myself and maybe that will improve the quality of the answers we shall see but yep that's definitely on the cards otherwise I'm just trying to get by with you know work mainly in the summer you know I don't like the summer it gets hot it gets humid and sweaty in the UK and it's just not for me especially when we get heat waves like we did the other day and work has been every bit as annoying as it can be with not just workload but other developments I can't go into specific reasons but suffice to say you know big brother is watching you and I'm not a fan of that so uh you know it's it just like I don't know annoyances and I'm expecting things to improve dramatically on that front probably by probably by the end of September I think you know or maybe by the end of August if I'm fortunate you know I just think that I just need to get through the summer period because the summer period is a bit more hectic for me than in most I would normally expect for my job but it makes that December is you know it makes December a little bit easier by comparison and of course I still am going to go on this Cruise in December so on like the probably the worst month of the year I'm not there for most of it so um happy days so you there's good times ahead I just got to Soldier on and move forward I mean it's not so much that you know there's no I mean there's legit stuff for what's going on there legit reasons but I think it's more that rather than oh God oh God oh God it's just I got a flick a switch in my head and start adapting to this new way of doing things and it's not my style of doing things you know I have to change person personality wise quite a bit when

I go to work because I am not naturally an accountant but uh they need a super accountant and so I need to flick a switch and become a super accountant and it's just not my style but hey it pays the bills that's what I need to do uh otherwise though for the channel uh think's not too bad I mean I didn't release a ton since the last uh podcast mainly I've been focusing on some reviews which I've had recently so um peacemakers uh from snowell design that finally I was allowed to release the video for that one and that's not done too bad actually about 2 and a half thousand views since mid July so yeah I mean it could be could be better could be worse but I think that's a pretty decent for a game that I think a lot of people probably haven't even heard of but by all means give that one a watch and I've just done two reviews one for dog park and its expansions so you know dog Park's not doing too great on the views and the the expansion is doing even worse I mean I mean I know I only put that up what like 3 days ago but it's got less than 500 views and this is the kind of the problem I have with the beyond the base game series sometimes I get that they're useful and I get that they are you know they're decent to do I mean I try not to spend too much time editing on those ones so they're a bit quicker to put out but they're very hit and miss as to whether anybody wants to watch them I mean you know 500 views is not worth doing the video in the first place I might as well have just done a podcast excerpt on it but you know it's a and it's a recent expansion for a game that I thought was popular so you'd think more people would have seen seen it but here there but then in contrast I

remember doing a review years ago on the above the big top uh or on the big top expansion for carcassone like a really late expansion I don't think anybody cared about and it got 12,000 views by now I mean I know that was years ago but even then I remember it getting over 10,000 views within a short space of time and I have no idea how that happened you know an expansion that surely no one cared about and it got 12,000 views I mean YouTube algorithm doesn't make sense you know people views just turn up on videos that are so random and weird you'd think how on Earth is this getting views but I don't know I if I understood the algorithm that well or if I was able to manipulate it in any way I can guarantee you uh this this channel would be doing a lot better than it was so it's just weird obscurities like that but by all means check out these two videos and you know I'll just have to maybe just you know maybe I'll just chalk that down to experience and saying maybe I should have just done a podcast review on that one but uh you know live and learn but there's more stuff on the way so uh Terminus is getting a review soon the big heavy game from inside up games uh wild Gardens has been sent to me I am playing through that at the moment so that will get a review uh I also have uh what else do I have um ah I'm forgetting what I've got which is not a good thing oh yes I wanted to do a couple of different uh videos for some of the other Series so uh top 10 tips for board game clubs has been it's been done I just need to edit it now and then that can go up so so that's basically top 10 tips for running a board game club using

the experiences I have with my free uh board game clubs that I've had dealings with as good examples so I'm hoping that will be a pretty cool video for some and yes there will be uh there will be good things and bad things in there so you're just going to have to deal with it uh what's the other one and yes I want to do a another best and worst off episode and for that one I'm choosing check game editions so that one should be a pretty good one to do first I'm trying to think there must have been another review I was doing it's not just I mean there's Terminus and wild Gardens but I know there's others I know oh yeah well Empire's end you know that I'm going to talk about in this video briefly and you know possibly you know a couple of expansions there's more stuff on the way it's just the case of getting it done which I've not had a huge amount of time recently but uh that will change um there's going to be a bit more free time in the next couple of weeks and so should be able to make a start on those lovely drinky drinky drinky because my throat's a bit it's not sore but it's a little bit dry and itchy this morning so I need to be a little bit careful but this episode probably won't be too long so yeah more to come but by all means check out the content and uh you know obviously help thank you everyone for supporting the channel it's it's Soldier on basically Soldier on and keep moving right uh what's first on the agenda well uh just to talk briefly about a couple of things that I have played and you know I'm probably going to do a video review for one of these I don't know if I'll do a vi video for the

other one so first off I want to mention um Vindication so this could be a beyond the base game video in the future but again this is the same problem I think I have with dog part New Tricks I just don't think anybody will watch it not enough people own this game and not enough people need a review of the expansions because frankly they've already got the kickstarter box set so why do they need me to talk about the expansions but I am trying to you know I've got some friends now who really like Vindication and so you know we're playing it a bit more often lately than I have been in the last year or so which means that I'm able to try out some of these expansions so we briefly tried out this uh villages and hamlets one the red box from the expansion I'm still not the biggest fan of the first one that came out what was it the guilds leaders and alliances one but I always I really wanted to try this one Vindication Chronicles and I have tried it as of yesterday I've tried it but you know it's certainly not the easiest thing to get out I had to learn a few rules and obviously uh prep things for it and I was looking forward to this one because this one was injecting a decent amount of theme into the game like it gave you almost a kind of semi Choose Your Own Adventure style uh progression where every time you got a new card you got a little story you chose an outcome and it allowed you to tick something on your little legendary character sheet which meant you could get special powers and bonuses later on and even better there was also event cards that changed the layout of the map or mess things up like you know you can't visit this place anymore cuz Bandits have overthrown it so you now need to spend attributes to

get rid of them you know cool stuff like that they like to add a bit more atmosphere to what is essentially a Euro Cube pushing game now I have played it we played it with four people and my thoughts are a little mixed um I do like the fact that it gives you a bit of thematic story element and a little bit more of a you know kind of like a I would say like a you know a more formatic approach to the game I'm going to see if I can get some photos up in a minute of like the game I was actually playing but the problem that this game has is that it is certainly a bit on the table hog side um that is definitely hang on almost got it almost got it come on I'm relying on Google photos here here we go so this is the actual uh game in question so you can see that the map is not too much different from everyone else you know we still got the tiles out but there's a lot more pieces I've shoved all over the place and because events have come out that have said like all right the pet managerie is got pets on the loose and you got to go return them uh you know the Inn has some dark agents there and you can't visit the Inn until you get rid of them and you know a few other things have come up but this map at the moment is probably the cleanest it ever looked you know it certainly was a bit more uh you know problematic before but the the rest of the stuff I mean you've got to have cards of these legendary powers out you've got to have these three tiles with event cards on them and you can see the text is not big so trying to read these at a distance is impossible you know big box of event big cards of

events here all these little markers that you put on the board to substitute all right this is where an event's happening and then you've got the fire wind Festival which you won't be able to see really in the picture but it's like another board I've put off to the side that you can visit and it's just the it just takes up a lot of space on this table and this was a biggish table and we were struggling to fit everything on it just becomes a bit of a cluttered mess now the event cards are a cool thing I mean they've got as you can see there's massive load of flavor text there and then it's got an effect in the white box and then there's a a heroic deed that you can do as a free action which involves spending attributes and you get to take out the event and you get rewards for doing it these are a cool addition but the biggest problem I had especially as I was playing this four player is that this takes the length and fiddlin of the game to an obscene level especially if you play with four because you normally only have to track two events in a fre player or less game you have to braise it to three events in a four player game and frankly it's too much I think you need to make it two events no matter what it's just too much to track the board gets clutched with these markers there's too much to do and you're reading these out constantly because as soon as one gets done another one pops out with whole new effects and whole new flavor text to read and it just takes ages to get through it and becomes a fiddly mess on top of that you've also got the problem that every time you get a card in this game you know so I take a purple card I take an orange card I take a green card whatever you now have to read a

Chronicles card to that player and that is again a small card of flavor text with two outcomes and a result but imagine you've got to do this for every single card acquisition you get holy moly um this really elongates the game because I mean every time you have anything when you've got to read out story elements it just prolongs the game because you got to read these out all the time and it slows things down and it means the downtime becomes insane and H it's it's a problematic with four now I can see this expans you know I need to try this now solo to see if it works there and I think it's going to work a lot better in Solo because there's a little shroud thing that you put the card in so you can't see the outcome so you could basically treat it like Choose Your Own Adventure but solo it's easier to track to events by yourself I don't have to read out to people I can just read it to myself and I reckon as a solo player it will really enhance this game for me but in multiplayer I think this really needs to be capped with three players who know the game well I mean on this one I even had to teach one guy the game from scratch so that didn't exactly help but yeah just there's a lot going on I mean the firewi festival board is such a tacky add-on as well you when you're on the edge of the map you can visit it you can give them the token rewards you get for doing events and stuff you can spend there and it gets you a token which gives you a bonus I mean it's a simple inclusion but it's just waste of space to need it really it's just it's just stuff for stuff's sake and there's even a secondary function of the firewi board to spend

conviction on and it's not even worth it it's not worth going there to use your your conviction it's better spent elsewhere so what's the point in even teaching the rule that I mean yes you can take it out of the game and it wouldn't make much difference you know it just means there's slightly less things to spend Renown tokens on but I guess that would unbalance the Renown if you took it out but again it just seems like unnecessary faf so you know so far I don't mind Chronicles but I do think it's going to be a bit restricted as to when it can be used I I mean if you want an epic length game and you don't mind a lot of Lux swing because that is another problem this uh these events really do swing luck quite a bit you know that the you know the events could shut down entire areas and you might re really need him to go to that area and it's like well you can't do it until the events resolved but if I've got a waste time doing that well people don't then they are in a better State than me it's just you know these can really be a little bit too much in a multiplayer game the legendary Powers as well I mean there's six different colors and there's six different legendary Powers I would argue that I mean they're all powerful I would argue some are better than others though and so that's going to make people sort of gun for specific colors so yeah it's a bit of a hit-and Miss expansion and I think this is one problem Vindication has it's one of the rare examples where I think the base game is perfectly fine I don't need an expansion in this game the the base game was perfectly fine by itself and all you needed to do was just bolster each of the respective decks with more stuff I don't need lots of different decks with all different rules I make exceptions of

things like the pet managerie CU I really like the pet managerie and that but I don't like the loot cards they the rules on them are weird and fiddly and don't make sense you know I don't like uh the cursed and treachery cards I just think they're not good you don't want like negative interaction in the game and a lot of these expansions just add so much extra complexity and time and setup the game's already a long setup Chronicles is an even longer setup because you got to get all the cards and events and stuff like that out and change how you like choose locations it's a bit much I think Vindication is perfectly good as a base game only and I don't think you need the expansions I think you'll do just fine with the normal components and I would still happily play it without an expansion you know you say oh I've got normal Vindication but I haven't got any expansions and I still play it it still sounds pretty cool so yeah I'm kind of in two minds about this one and I have also briefly played the hamlets expansion as well I can't say too much about it at the moment but the the whether I do a video on the Chronicles and the Hamlet expansion remains to be seen because I just don't think enough people own this game to really talk about it in much detail so if I do do a beond the base game video I think it will be a very quick one a very short one but again I just think it's going to be one of those gets like 500 views Max and nobody else looks at it so even though if I look on uh Board Game Geek pretty much nobody has talked about Chronicles and I suspect even less about the others I mean here we go yeah there's literally like two V one video

or sorry like two videos a review from a Russian uh content creator and a preview from you know board game Co which you know previews I don't care about anyway so literally nobody has talked about this you know other than this Russian person nobody's talked about it from a review perspective but again I just don't think that enough people would really care so it's kind of odd but as I say I still like Vindication I just think it's one of those games that has suffered quite a bit from bloat right okay cool BL me it is hot in here already right let's talk about uh briefly I want to talk about Empire's end now Empire's end is going to get a full review um that one will get a full review because the patreons have requested it I gave him a choice of games for me to look at and the Empire Z came out on top so this will get a full video I just want to talk briefly about my first impressions of it um I need to let the thoughts solidify and play at other player counts but I've played at a free player count and the pro well I was about to say problems no there's good and bad stuff to this but a little bit of background here this is ranked 2,429 board game gek that suggests to me it's not that popular a game but then I read a bunch of Critic reviews on here and I saw you know vinger femur and the usual previews and Dice Tower and stuff like that and they all praise it like crazy they're like eight out of 10 nine out of 10 you know they love it in some cases what do you expect they say

nothing but good things about everything so what exactly do you expect but the I thought okay okay so the critics are saying a lot of good stuff but most of the user ratings are kind of seven Max 6 out of 10 five out of 10 there's a lot of people that aren't fans and and I thought this might be like a kind of Rotten Tomatoes thing where you know the critics love it but the uh users don't and so this one is interesting to me to have a look at and I have played it and as me the you know the person that will tell it how it is I have suspicions that the critics have overhyped this one a bit it's not that it's a bad game at all it's got good elements to it it's basically to put it in one respect it's the no thanks bidding system if you've ever play no thanks with the whole um I bid to not take this car because I don't want to take it same sort of deal except you're bidding on disasters for your civilization so basically you know your civilization has locations that are going to get blown up by disasters but you're bidding to not take the disasters themselves and if you do then you have to flip the tile over it's not worth any VP and you don't get like cool Innovations and um um sorry cool bonuses for it but if you do take disasters you get to put the Innovation underneath another location and it gives you a cool bonus to use during the game so there is a tug there is a kind of like a choose your battles thing of like well you know what I'm willing to let this disaster go through because I like this ability I can always repair it later you know that the way of thinking it is quite punishing I mean it really does throw quite a lot of disasters on you and you have to be aware that you are going to

have stuff like you know blown up on a regular basis but you know it's well done it's got a good insert it's uh looks good you know good quality components and such and the there are like I say there are good stuff I like the bidding system from no thanks I think it's a cool um like tensioning of like oh will they will they will they take it before it comes back around to me I don't know uh I like the cool Innovation abilities that can let you customize your civilization a little bit and you know these little aspects are good but there are some bad aspects and I don't think the critics mention these enough firstly it does give a feeling of being punished a lot because after all you're getting disasters at your left and right now you can argue that that is kind of the focus of the game and it is so it's diminished a little bit but here's some things about it this game for a start quote 45 to 60 Minutes on the box I cannot begin to stress how much of a complete lie that is this is not a 45 to 60 Minute game this is a 60 to 90 minimum game I mean 60 minutes if you're playing this with two players but from what I've heard two players isn't that good a game so we'll come back to that one but you know we played a free- player game and it still took us at least an hour and and a half for players I could see this going to 2 hours easily and some people have played it for 2 hours and it's just 90 minutes plus for this game is too long because there's too many lucky swingy outcomes here you know the innovations that you draw from the deck um to play on later turns are totally random you might draw abilities

that are great for you you might draw stuff that's useless the disasters are random as well they affect a random location on your board and you might have be in a position where it's constantly affecting the same problematic area that you can't afford to let go and for somebody else it's like oh well it's only attacking my farm I don't really mind if I take this so I can just let this one carry on a bit and so you end up you know like players are unfairly punished or better off purely by luck of the draw and this sort of luck of the draw is not good enough in a game that's 90 minutes to 120 Minutes long it needs to be a 45 minute game for this amount of luck and I think it would have been brilliant if it did but because it's this long that much luck is a problem and and you know it's it's going to be a case of me playing this a bit more and deciding whether those luck aspects kill the game or whether I can forgive those to a point because the rest of it is good and there are some other good elements to it I do like the bidding system but the player interaction is a bit lacking because in no thanks you have a very clear thing of what you're trying to do there is a there is a card in front of you you don't want points and it you know and you can tell instantly if another player would likely want it or not here though it's difficult to tell whether another player would likely Let It Go through or not and you don't have that much information to go on and because the resources are hidden so that you can't see what people are bidding it's not like you can really gauge if uh you know players have got the resources

to bid on certain disasters because it does various to what you're allowed to bid and so the game almost becomes a bit of a memory game and memory games are not popular with the masses generally and I don't think it should be a memory game I think it should should be public resources you know you should know whether somebody has a bunch of axes because it will give you an educated guess as to whether they're likely to keep bidding to not take the disaster or whether they're going to have to do it if I let it go forward so you know there's that that aspect but then you could argue that makes it too predictable and it's just the game feels like it's got a few problems and the critics have not mentioned a lot of these they I mean they've gone like oh yeah this is eights this is nines really enjoy it you know really good and it's just H I'm a little bit wary I wonder if they were impressed with the like the really good inser and box a bit too much or maybe because it's a John declair design that people are being a little forgiving because John declair is quite popular designer among a lot of uh people so and no I say I like John decl games Mystic Veil and Empire empire no sorry Edge of Darkness and space bace I like a lot of his games but but John declair has also done a few bad ones you know everyone played downfall I think it was called the one where it was setting a radioactive Wasteland yeah play downfall and tell me that he he always makes good games so yeah I'm just a bit suspicious on this one but I will do a full video on it I will solidify my thoughts after more plays I'm a little concerned that um you know two player is not going to be particularly good

there's no solo mode in this not that I particularly want one but there isn't one and I wonder if this is going to be one of those kind of like fragile games where you know if you get the right setting in the right mood it's going to work but then it could also so kind of backfire in your face we shall have to see but for now my thoughts are kind of mixed and I do reckon that there is an element of overhyping by Critics on this one uh but we'll see in the future there will be a full video I promise you right all right let's talk about the topic for this one mainly because it could take a while to get through this topic and because my throat is weird and itchy today maybe because of yesterday cuz I I went to my Board Game Cafe and I I was playing game all day with the mates and I taught Vindication with Chronicles I taught Pulsar 2849 and I taught Empire's end takes out on the throat when you got to teach a lot of long games okay so uh yeah maybe I'm just recoiling from that but I want to talk about a topic that uh one of the patrons actually suggested for like the the 100 episode but I wanted to talk about it a little bit now because I think this one requires a bit more time essentially they asked me to look back on Old reviews and suggest whether uh the those reviews were what you call you know whether those reviews would change now so you know obviously back in 20134 when I started the channel and started doing reviews I was doing them on WordPress I think or whatever was it

WordPress it was whatever I think it was just called blogger whatever their competitor was at the time and I did a written blog page that page no longer exists now I deleted it a long long time ago because once I started doing YouTube and you know so that one's gone but then I started doing videos on YouTube and some of them I've retained some of them I think I've just missed them out I I tried to delete them you know I tried to sort of go right from 2017 onwards this is the videos I'm happy for people to watch but the really old stuff I'm like oh God I'm kind of embarrassed by a lot of the old videos they really are particularly bad when I think about my old stuff so if I bring up my content uh back here up there if I go to date and sort by the other direction so yeah here we go so these videos I think I forgot to delete but these are amateurish I mean look at this I mean this green laser font and a solid solid side of color and then the picture of the game it's like oh God I mean I was just starting I was young and naive okay I wasn't wasn't particularly good at this sort of thing and as you can say the views vary from pathetic to ridiculous um but the other thing was was that I mean bear in mind this is like a decade and that old I mean 3,000 people wanted me to review an an Ika shelf kind of weird and I had 12 what 13,000 views for how to play on Ghost Stories the problem is I got a couple of rules wrong in it so you know that's only so useful and I used to do unboxing videos as well I hate unboxing videos so why did I bother

doing them I think I was trying to chase a fad at the time going oh other people seem to do well unboxing videos I'll do it and it was a waste of time cuz none of them were any good so yeah the these ones I am probably going to delete in the near future there's not that many of them I think these are ones that just missed the mark so you know cuz I want kind of want things to start from yeah I want sort of like 2017 uh videos to be like the initial bit uh yeah yeah dormant status on the channel yeah so I I I did videos up to a point and then I had a bit of a break and then I started season two and then you know when did that one come out yeah 2017 so 2017 was kind of when the YouTube channel started going proper and like I say some of these old videos are like still amateurish and still embarrassing but hey the exist and oh look there's that carcassone under the big top here you go yeah 12,600 views for an expansion nobody gave her rats monkeys about a rat monkeys toss about it's like why on Earth was that popular I do not get it at all it's one of the life Mysteries but yeah a few games I reviewed yeah yokoh and Coliseum quadropus Sentry spice Road Baron Park I mean there's definitely a few of those but I am definitely going to delete the these 2014 ones here yeah these ones need to go so I'll get on with that a bit later but yeah you know I've been doing this for quite a while and uh you know sadly I'm not in the 100,000 subscribers and big name thing I'm still just a you know relatively small fry but it's been a long slog it's been a lot of work a lot of effort and it's just as I

say the fruits of my labor some of it I'm proud of some of it I'm not so what I'm going to do under request from Bailey thank you for the uh suggestion is that I'm not some of these will be some of these videos here but I know that I did reviews earlier than 2014 from the Blogger page but I obviously have deleted that page but I can go onto my board game geek and look at ratings that I gave for games back in like 2013 and 14 and haven't updated since so some of them were reviews some of them weren't so this is going to be a bit of a mix but I'm basically going to go back and look over some of those games and what ratings I gave them and kind of decide if I was doing them now like if I was going to review them now has that rating changed but also based on the scaling because bear in mind back then I just did a top 10 scaling and I don't know if I had a specific system for how it worked I might have just kept it on whatever Board Game Geek had but now I've got my own scale for 10 you know with the you know benchmark excellent great good above average average below average bad uh you know terrible awful whatever you know so you know those 10o scales so would those have changed and would they apply to my scale now so it's just kind of a trip down memory lane so the first one that I'm going to take a look at particularly let me uhop I want to go to Broad Game Geek here we go let's take a look at flasho fire rescue flasho fire rescue I think is the first game I ever reviewed like the absolute

first game and this was the really cool Co-op game where you're putting out fires I still own all the stuff for it it's in the Box behind me but I have not brought this out in a long long time I think this was something I gave like a 10 out of 10 at the time like I said this was a fantastic game I love it and I was playing it a lot back then you know and I still think it's a solid game now but I think my rating has been updated in some recent years down to an 8 out of 10 now if I was looking back on this one I mean the good side is that it's a simple game to play it's pretty much p mic level rules uh it's a great theme and the theme is represented pretty well I mean fire is unpredictable you don't know what it's going to do uh you know the teamwork is there it's definitely down to the wire at times you know sometimes you can just get completely hosted yes that does happen but it's just a really solid Co-op and part of me wants to get out again now it does get a little clunky at times particularly with expansions you know the rules were not perfect it's Indie board in games um I don't want to see why don't why do people put up pictures of punched boards and stuff like that on Board Game Geek I want to see pictures of the game in Play stop giving me pictures of punch boards and rubbish uh but yep so you've got H they got meatles on this one this is interesting but yeah the fire spreads throughout the different rooms and you've got to save uh pass people from being burnt alive and take them out to an ambulance the fire spreads by dice roll so there's a random element to it with me this one I

still would probably give an eight I still find this to be a very fun game and it's a good intro game because you can play an experienced one with rols or you can play the family game which is preset and no special powers so this is this caters for a wide audience and even though it probably could use the second edition you know maybe to clean up some of the rules add a bit more easy you know yeah clean up the rules add modules for expansion but make them clean so they can be integrated easier and uh definitely clean up some of the rolls you know make them bit more balance that kind of thing I think this would benefit from a second addition and also up the component quality like this is something I would like to see on Kickstarter actually yeah they've kickstarted expansions of the game why can't they Kickstart a second edition where they completely you know you don't have to go full castles of burgundy awakened Realms nonsense on it but I think for what you know they did to raah and what they've done to other sort of second edition games I think this one could really benefit for me but eight out of 10 would still suit uh it's a great game you know I don't think it's quite distinction level anymore there is still you know some issues with it that back then I probably was a little bit like yay yay games because it was just starting off but and the fact that I haven't played it in a long time obviously speaks volumes but it's still a solid game uh it would still qualify I think as great in my opinion uh now let's talk about a game that I absolutely hated back then and I think this is the oldest rating I have on my board game geek um because some of them have been updated but this

is the latest the earliest one that I haven't updated Kingdom Builder oh my god do I hate this game um this game I actually rated A 1 out of 10 like I considered this to be the absolute garbage now I probably do need to be a little bit more realistic on that because yes I do think this game is garbage I think it is boring I think it is too restrictive I mean you literally get one card to dictate where you can go on this map and if you don't draw a card that you need then basically life sucks for you it looks horrible I mean look at that board that is terrible artwork if you can even call it artwork um you've just got a bunch of wooden houses there is no theme it is dry as a bone it's it's not a good game and yeah your special power here is not going to make me like this I mean look at that that is terrible it's a clip art you know this is from Queen games and it does have its fans but I am most certainly not one of them now one out of 10 Luke that's maybe pushing it a bit far I mean if I had to be realistic and rate it these days I mean as much as I do hate this game like I really do just find it dull and boring H one out of 10 is obviously a bit unrealistic but I would still probably be giving this at least a like something like a maybe not necessarily a two but certainly a three out of 10 I would consider this to be bad on my scale like bad not below average below average is a game that I could still play Bad is a game that I most likely will not play I mean it could even be

down to a two I honestly consider this to be pretty terrible you I don't find it fun I don't find it interesting I don't find a decision making you know interesting because you're basically restricted to one card which really sucks yes the map is variable I mean that's nice but then that's not really that noticeable when you play the games yeah it's nice having these little special powers but again they're pretty basic and boring I mean this is set I mean they they do this thing and then they set it in like medieval England with like Lords and Fire armors and knights and stuff and it's like you choose a boring setting and then you make it a boring game but one out of 10 is a bit harsh it would probably closer to a three out of 10 now I would consider it to be bad but I can see why some people would get into it and like I say one out of 10 is like pretty much like unworkable as a game like it truly is the worst of the worst and that sort of stuff would be reserved for things like exploding kittens for example but uh you know this one probably not one but still it would probably be a three out of 10 10 I mean this one really I just do not like um Marvel legendary Marvel legendary now this one's interesting because I have sold my entire Marvel legendary cor collection although I have retained the alen one now this one is still on my rating as eight out of 10 a great game that was probably better off in the early days but the rating would definitely have gone down since and easily probably at like about six out of 10 and I think if

I was reviewing it now I think overall the game would probably still get about a six out of 10 above average uh because the the it's a good it's an all right deck builder but the problem is is that there was several problems firstly when it got bloated it just became a nightmare to set this thing up and actually get it out you know it took a lot of T but the actually playing this game in general required a ton of setup because you had to build the hero deck by shuffling in a bunch of these hero sections and then you had to do the same with the villain de and like put in the scheme and do the setups for that and by the time you set it up it took forever but then when you had to take it apart oh my God you had to sort out all these cards and it just got really finicity and annoying the power creep was also problematic with the expansions and even just the uh Heroes and the villains that in the base game I mean some Heroes were certainly a lot better than others in terms of power level but the villains I mean there were some villains that were a cakewalk and then there were some schemes and villains that literally were nonon impossible like they were were impossible to beat ever and that is a problem with a game when you make the difficulty curve so extreme particularly when this is a deck builder so therefore there's going to be a decent amount of luck involved here you know it's not like this is a game you can play with skill it's a deck builder where there is a ton of draw card draw luck and it's you know it's fun and it definitely has its moments but also the fact that you're mixing all these Heroes together so I'm not playing a Spider-Man deck I'm playing a deck where I put in a few Spider-Man cards and then decide to put

in a couple of Iron Man cards and then a couple of you know Ghost Rider cards and you don't really feel like you've got a deck that's personified to a hero it's just random I mean it's basically the equivalent of playing something like DC deck builder game from cryptozoic and so a lot of that theme is lost there are games that do this a lot better like Sentinels and the Multiverse and I think if i' played it now and reviewed it I would go yeah this is fine but I think those setup times and just the sort of weird detraction from theme would make me just go oh yeah this is a typical deck builder nothing particularly special I think it was probably one of the first deck builders I played so there was probably an element of that that went into it CU I love the mechanic and this would be one of the first instances where I'd seen this mechanic in action but nowadays loads of deck builders exist and this one has become dated I don't think that this measures up against most deck builders in existence now and so I struggled to give it a seal of endorsement it probably would only get a six and I know that would uh you know sicken some people but I sold the whole collection you know it's gone big crate's gone so uh you know I certainly was getting a little bored with it all right what else uh for sale for sale I don't think I reviewed this one but it is definitely one of my oldest ratings I gave this one a five out of 10 so this is the like a really old yeah 1997 an old card game where you basically or off these different uh houses like you like

varying degrees of quality and you basically auction for these and then the second half of the game it flips on its head and you auction the money money cards in order to you know sell your houses for a really good profit and whoever has the most money wins neat concept but auction games are a little bit you know dull for me I don't tend to go for them quite often you know they maybe they've got a new fancier version but it is pretty basic components although it is 1997 in a small card game so I guess you can't be too hard in it for that but I just sort of found it a bit boring really I mean the you could get into a situation where you just can't physically do well like you're on the back foot and if you oh somebody's done the Star Wars themes one interesting but you know you get to a point where you just can't physically win like you know you're going to lose this game and I know it's not a long game but you would have been nice if there was like some way to catch up in that but nah some sometimes you can just be in a situation where the the best cards come out to auction at the right time and you just have it it you just have it your way but it's not a terrible game it's not you know bad in any way I just don't find it particularly great either I mean I'll play it but I'll certainly never seek it out I think my rating of a five still stands really I think this is a five out of 10 for me it's average does the job but it's not a game that I would want to seek out or really gun for okay all right what else we got on the list uh oh God Brussels 1893 this is an old uh did I review this

one I feel like I might have reviewed it briefly this does feel familiar not a video but I feel like I might have done a written one of this but Brussels 1893 I gave this one a five five out of 10 what was I thinking Luke seriously what was old Luke thinking when he gave this a five out of 10 I must have been forgiving on this one because this one is easily a lot lower for me and not maybe not like one or two out of 10 I think this would actually head down to the three out of 10 maybe four out of 10 if I was being a little bit generous it's definitely out of five five is average suggesting that I will play the game but I played this back then and found it really boring like this was super dry fairly restrictive and fairly mean you know you're mean to other players in this one and I don't know I just found it the setting is boring the theme isn't there it's just a dry Euro and there's just nothing it is flavorless it's the definition of a bland ice cream flavor like not even vanilla it's just literally ice on a cone but I tried it recently with the Remake so they printed out a second edition or something like that and uh with the expansion included uh I think uh oh was it yeah my good friend uh yeah my good friend taught it to me and you know Hillmar from Iceland and he wanted to demo it at Essen last year and he did and I said all right you know I'm on a thing where I'm trying out older games I used to hate to see if I like them more I think I hate it more now than I did back then clearly because

if I gave it a five out of 10 this is easily like a three out of 10 for me I just find this to be a bad uninteresting game there's just no nothing in it to pull me in and I mean at most it would get a four but even a four out of 10 game I would still find something of interest in this this one I have nothing of interest but it's not terrible enough for me to get really angry about it you know to say oh yeah this really ticks me off but there's just nothing in here to make me go yay that's great everything just seems pretty me and I mean the old version looks absolutely terrible in terms of its uh you know looks and graphic design I'm curious actually can I find a new one uh Brussels uh is it 1893 or was it 18 no there was one that came out is it this one Bella op something here we go yeah reimplements yeah so this is the new one uh that I think I played and certainly it looks about as dull as the other one yeah I mean theyve didn't exactly do much to increase the uh the appeal and looks for this game but they they probably improved it from a graphic design perspective to make it a bit clearer to see what's going on but still I just don't like this game I just find it Bland I find it boring I find it too mean I find it too punishing but for the most part it's just flavorless and so yeah five out of 10 I think I was being generous back then I would rate this now on my current scale a three don't like it uh let's see what else we

got uh cockroach poker oh blind me yeah I definitely reviewed this one on the written version and uh cockroach poker cockroach poker royal is that the one I found yeah here we go cockroach poker royal called blimy I've still got this in my collection I think yeah I've got it in one of my little uh tubberware containers that I've like migrated cards to this one I gave an eight out of 10 I still stand by that if I rated this game now I would still give it an eight possibly even a nine I just really love this game and I get why some people would hate it if you don't like bluffing games this game is not going to be for you at all but I really enjoyed this I mean it's just a simple premise you know give a card to a player face down make a claim about what type of vermin creature it is and they decide whether to believe you or not they can call you out as a liar they can call you out as telling the truth or they can look look at it and pass it to someone else that's it and basically you're trying to avoid getting four of the same type in front of you and then you lose that's the game but this is a great fun laugh I mean you know if you like bluffing games this is perfect because you're psyching each other out you're you know doing I star Downs your you know your you know you've got Mets building from game to game like what do you think of this person do you think they're trustworthy you know you you've got people like me Hamming it up like crazy going it's like yeah it's totally this yeah he he's telling you lies you I see it I see it in him you know you can trust me but not that guy yeah he's trying to screw you and it's just a lot of fun for a silly banter party card game but I'd still give it a

solid rate it would still get an eight for me and possibly even a nine I'd possibly want to give this a seal of Distinction because it is just that fun for a light bluffing game it's easy doesn't take long the rules are simple and you know the Royal version adds the Royal cards which makes it even more sort of scary to get those at times and yeah it's just and there's no winner it's a case of avoid being the one loser so there's a bit of you know that kind of alleviates the whole like you know people just there to win type thing you know so there there's a lot of cool things about this and it's a simple little card game haven't played it in a while um I think I need to rectify that situation and bring it to a game club every now and again but yeah I if anything I think I would be more generous to this one than before so I think it's definitely worth a shot I wonder if you can still get it these days hopefully you can all right what else have we got uh oh blimy did I give that yeah not great okay well let's move on to those ones a bit later let's go on to Forbidden Desert now I definitely did a video on this one and Forbidden Desert is an old uh you know it's one of the it's the second in the Forbidden Trilogy uh I think well not even Trilogy it's a quad tril Now isn't it yeah so Forbidden Island Forbidden Desert forbidden sky and then this new one Forbidden Jungle which I still haven't even tried that one haven't heard great things about it I mean given how much praise desert got

and how much praise Island gets sky was a bit of a dud and I hear pretty much nobody talk about jungle so not too fussed about that but for in desert I gave a seven out of 10 I said it was a good game a good co-op and I kind of would stay on that really I mean there's certainly a lot to talk about from a good perspective saying that oh yeah it's got some of these cool pieces and it's relatively cheap and it uh you know certainly does have you know that teamwork aspect it's down to the wire at times like really you know really tough particularly when you go on the higher difficulties but you know it is random you know the game could just hose you at a moment's notice you know there's only so much you can predict but it's pandemic level rules I mean it's the same as pandemic you know the game could just hose you without even trying but the rules are simple and the roles are cool and it definitely does generate a lot of discussion between players as to what it is you need to do the items are cool to find every now and again uh there's definitely a timer aspect and so yeah I mean I'd still give this one a seven you know you could argue that maybe it could get to an eight but as much as I give it props for a lot of stuff it does right I haven't played any of these forbidden games in a long time and I feel that they're just getting a little bit dated you know not to say that they're bad but I've wanted to play other co-op games rather than this one but if somebody wanted to play Forbidden Desert and it was the voted one on the table I'd still play it so it would definitely at least need a seal of

endorsement for me to say this is a recommended game and certainly if you are starting out like building up a collection and you want some you know nice cheap ones for non- gamers then Forin desert is a great one to go for I can't like recommend it enough but yeah it is kind of a a little bit on the you know old side like there's stuff that's come out that I prefer to play but this one's still pretty solid at a seven out of 10 frankly you know I would still consider it to be good okay uh what else oh blamy let's go on another one I don't like uh power grid oh boy Power grit currently an old rating haven't updated it I've rated this a two would I and I know that's going to anger a lot of people two out of 10 would I change that rating though I really don't like power grid at all I mean this is an auction game where the auctions drag on for ages and just don't seem to finish but it's you know it's not the most like best looker I hate the fact that you've got a tissue paper over half the board when you're playing at lower player counts that's always a pain really the only thing I like in the game is the supply and demand resource Market which actually makes a bit of thematic sense and is a cool thing in most games so I'm I'm fine with that but everything else about this game I just really don't like it's long especially when you got a lot of players it just takes forever it's pseudo knockout where you can literally at the moment's notice be cut out of specific route connections on

here and if that happens you are done like you are no way to recover if you start off badly in this it you know so it's very mean very long very Cutthroat very restrictive those are things I don't like in games two 10 though I don't know the difference between something like this and uh Brussels and Kingdom Builder is that Kingdom Builder is a painful game for me to play like I really don't like it but mostly it's just boring like there is so little flavor in it that I find it a terrible game and certainly it probably enraged me a bit more back then but I think these days I'd have to be realistic and go all right it doesn't really induce a ton of anger it's just flavorless and boring this one can induce anger like this one really does annoy me me to play it because I just don't like a lot of stuff in it I mean yes I like the resource management system in it but that's it and that's a small aspect of the game the auctions and this root connection are the bigger aspect and it's just not nice you got paper money the components are awful they haven't updated this I mean come on could you have not done a a reimplementation second edition of this with better components than that would that be doable they've had expansions with different Maps as if I could care I this one does invoke a lot of anger you I really don't like this game at all would I change it from a two though two does seem really really harsh I mean two is terrible on my scale like terrible like

I don't find really anything good about it I would refuse to play it outright I don't want to see it again maybe it would stay as a two it's really is one that I would hate but I can think of worse designed games than this exploding kittens and stuff like that so maybe it could go to a three out of 10 but it would definitely never get to a four this is not one I would call below average this would be at least at the bare minimum bad for me but whether it would also go down to terrible because of the negative feelings that it generates for me is another story all right let's talk about the positive one uh let's see positive one on the list that I've looked at before come on let's have a look there's got to be something there to be fair a lot of these ratings in the old are kind of seven five six so if anything maybe I was a bit more of a Critic over some things back then uh come on it's going to be another one um okay how about this one uh bang the dice game this was quite an old one that I did so I gave this one I think an 8 out of 10 originally I think I've updated it to a seven lately and I think that's probably accurate I still think this is a fun party game roll the dice and shoot each other a little bit of bluffing here and there but it can drag on a little bit and the problem with these roles is that it doesn't take more than like 5 Seconds to figure out who's who really I mean unless the deput is playing really weird you should be able to figure out you know sort of who's on

your side there you can certainly easily figure out the Outlaws because at some point they've got to keep shooting the sheriff they can't sit there and do nothing cuz then the sheriff just gets super powerful the renegade's a more interesting person to play but the problem is winning as the Renegade is so damn hard that it's just fundamentally unbalanced in that respect though I did once win I can't remember this goes up to seven or eight players is it eight players yeah won an eight player game as a renegade damn I was proud of that I was really proud of that one but it is not easy to win as the Renegade period it's so difficult so getting that person kind of also kind of means an auto lose 6.9 is not a particularly High average rating even though it is 797 on here note that I think Empire end has had a lower average rating and yet was ranked 249 I don't get how the rating system works but yeah this one uh I mean I gave it an eight originally I think maybe that was a little bit generous I'd certainly possibly give this a seven but I haven't played in a while it and it did get better I think with the first expansion and so the first expansion probably props up to a seven maybe these days I'd probably give it a six and say it's above average it does the job but it's not one that I tend to bring out very much anymore I think it's kind of um overstayed it's welcome to a point you really do want a lot of players in the game it does not play very well with anything less than six players frankly it yeah it does have some problems it would probably be somewhere in the above average category for me all right any

more let me say five minutes until we get to the hour mark so okay let's have a look uh although yeah sorry if my screen looks a little bit orange at the moment it's just a bit dark in here so that's why uh but let's see oh okay how about this one tales of the Arabian Knights this was an old one I reviewed definitely I think did a video on this one I gave this originally I think an eight when I first um reviewed it but I've noticed that my rating has been updated to a six I mean this could actually go lower I think now because the premises sounds cool the idea that you go around the board and you come up with all these funny stories it's Choose Your Own Adventure style thing and all this random funny stuff happens to you that's all well and good the problem is is that the game is entirely random like there is no like cohesion as to what you decide to choose to do and you know what actually happens I mean it's cool that you can basically say right you find a beggar and then you can decide whether to like you know you choose your encounter reaction choices like beat enrich Rob avoid question attack follow higher you know that kind of thing and so you know there was some cool aspects to the story Parts but it's mainly played for Giggles there's not really any strategy or anything like that because it doesn't really work and part of the problem is that you're meant to get a balance of the story points and

personal points I forget what they're called but uh you basically have two separate points that you're aiming for the problem is is that it's totally random as to when you get them there's not like you can tell from a particular encounter that I'm going to get these types of points there is no way so you literally just wander around hoping you'll get them and you whether somebody gets them before you is entirely based on random chance so that all sounds good until you realize that this game easily takes about 90 minutes to two hours to finish particularly with a lot of players CU you're obviously reading out a lot of stories so this is a game that can take anywhere around two hours that is 100% luck based oh boy I think giving this one seven or an eight in the past would have been literally just me being on a high from some of the laughter moments in it but if I was thinking objectively now you know tell it how it is honest reviews this would struggle do I think even get a six I think this would probably be down to a five you know it's it can provide some laughs and if you are willing to spend some time playing basically just a luck fest with some stories it can give some enjoyment but it badly needs some fixes to make it actually so that there's decisions to be made and it's not just like pick a random thing and see what happens so you know it needed something to give it a bit of structure but as it stands this game doesn't really have any structure it's just choose an outcome and see what happens and there's you know I mean you could beat a beggar and it turns out to

be some evil Sorcerer And it's like oh thank God you beat the beggar but then there could be you know another beggar you find and you choose to beat them and it's like you just beat a harmless beggar you monster so there's no way to tell what type of outcome you will get and so why would you and this is ranked 615 I think that's because nobody's played it in ages so it's got its original rating and now no one's tried it but I mean if I go on the average rating here ratings breakdown so some crazy people vote at 10 which is a little bit insane most people are kind of in the 87 sixes Mark you know and then through 5 4 3 2 1 but if always been objective I think eight is really um pushing it I just don't see how a two-hour game that's a total luck Fest can be something like an eight out of 10 I just would not go that high so if I was rating this now probably a five out of 10 an average game has its moments but fundamentally from a design perspective it's not particularly good all right my throat is getting a little bit dry we're getting up to the hour mark I think we'll leave it there but yeah suffice to say as I look back on some of my older reviews there is definitely some that would change these days and both positive and negative like some would go down in value some would go up in value and yeah putting something has a one out of 10 is kind of a you know bit harsh you know I mean one out of 10 is a really terrible awful experience and that's kind of exploding kittens for me and stuff like that but games I hate like you know brass and power grid Imperial steam uh Kingdom

Builder as I said uh you know a few of these game you know Brussels and stuff then one out of 10 would not be justified for those you know they are probably three out of 10 for the most part just being bad games but you know and I would probably be a little bit more you know appealing for that sense but I still wouldn't be able to make them below average because below average still represents a game that you could get me to play I just wouldn't necessarily be wanting to but those games I wouldn't want to play at all so they've got to be at least a three out of 10 bad but you know below average for those I just don't think would work bear in mind I gave SE teer a four out of 10 right so that is a below average game for me a four out of 10 you could convince me to still play Septima if absolutely necessary but I definitely would be like is there really nothing else I mean anything else we could play and it's like okay fine we'll play a game of Septima and I'll get something out of it those are the games I won't get anything out of but then there's also some of those positive ones where I'll go oh yeah I gave this a 10 or I gave this an eight or a nine or something and then I think some of them I'd stick with but then some of them I'm like hm not so sure maybe they should have come down a bit where I'm a bit more consistent with older reviews is probably the stuff that's in the middle like five or six out of 10 the stuff I found kind of average or above average on my new scale back then kind of feels kind of average and above average now like it wouldn't necessarily get any worse but I don't think it would necessarily get any better but typically ratings are going to fluctuate more with higher extremes and lower extremes than

the stuff in the middle the stuff in the middle would generally be quite stable but hopefully that was a bit of an interesting thing to you so obviously Yesa keep those questions coming on the patreon uh post that I put up because obviously I will CCT a bunch of them for the uh hund episode for the broken me show but other than that I'm going to sign off now treat my throat do some shopping and that I really do think my throat's just in a bad way so which causes a bit of a problem because I was hoping to do a bit more recording of other episodes today but maybe I might just have to take a break for today do them during the week and maybe concentrate on editing the top 10 board game club tips actually that'd be good I get that video out first and that would work but yeah I think I might just have to take a break and let the throat settle for the rest of the day so thanks for listening to this podcast hope you enjoyed by all means thank you for supporting the show and helping uh you know the show become what it is after what like a decade now kind of ridiculous uh so thanks for watching if you're like a lifelong fan since a decade ago then BL me I can thank you a lot for that but uh be curious if anybody has actually been watching the show since the days I did it on Blogger or the first time I did it on YouTube that would be quite you know that would be quite a surprise I think most people are a bit more recent but you know for all of you I love it that you do watch the show and get some enjoyment out of it cuz it does obviously justify the work that goes into doing it it's basically like having a second part-time job it's not an easy JK and uh there's a lot of opposition there's a lot of uh problems in the industry when it comes to content creation where you know it's a bit of a battlefield but Soldier on it's still

worth it it's still a good laugh but you know there are times where you know I do wonder what would have happened if life was a bit different but that's you could dwell on that for ages and never be truly satisfied the fact of the matter is this is life as it is now so soier on move forward take care love you all bye for now see you soon

Progress saved