Skip to main content
Loading video...

Kathmandu, Thunder Road, Ancient Knowledge, I'm the Boss, Thebes - Ranked and Reviewed

Transcript 22:52

hey everybody and welcome to another chairman of the board ranking video this is where I take a look at the last five new to me board games and I talk about them in order of preference now before I get started please be sure to check out the sponsor of the show kendra. co.uk who are my goto online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order at number five I have Thunder Road Vendetta so if you are a regular viewer of the channel you might know that a game like this and my personal tastes are a bit like chalk and cheese it's not normally the kind of game that I go for but I was willing to go to this one with an open mind to see what it was like I'd heard a lot of good things about it over the years now or over the time it's been out um and I thought you know what this could be a lot of fun because I've heard again lots of good things um unfortunately this didn't quite turn out the way that I wanted it to and despite me seeing a lot of Merit in the way that the game works I it's a simple kind of racing game but that is basically built on the foundation of chaos there's very little autonomy over this game as you are rolling dice you're allocating those dice to um each of your three separate cards the remaining die will be put on a basically a special action or could be used to boost the speed Etc of your other cars and you're moving along these different terrain types you're barging into people you're going over hazards which can kind of tip your car over and

basically it's a lot of dice rolling and trying to see what happens again pure carnish just happens as you're flying off the board cars are being eliminated left right and Center um and if you're going into this game wanting control um you know best player winning that kind of experience then you're simply not going to get it if anything the game did not um outstay it's welcome it works at a really nice pace so you know from the get-go cars are being you know getting eliminated and before you know the the end of the game is there but despite me again appreciating what the game does especially in terms of the Thematic ties as you get these big dramatic moments of cars again doing crazy things um then you know I can definitely appreciate it from that angle we can see why people who like that kind of game would appreciate this one but for me again I do like more control I do like more eurocentric style games and this game is the polar opposite of that so not a cond condemnation on the game at all it's just simply the wrong game for the wrong type of gamer so that is Thunder Road Vendetta at number five at number four I have thieves so this is a game that I've had on my want to play list for quite some time now because it is from that bygone Dusty dry Euro era and I love the theme of this one the idea of being these excavators going around the ancient world pulling up these ancient artifacts to score points love that concept and actually on paper I actually do like some of the mechanisms as it is

one of the forefathers of the time track system where different actions will take you a different amount of time and of course as long as you are furthest behind on the time track you'll get to take more actions back to back now this game actually the way it played out was quite frustrating and and probably not for a lot of the reasons why you might assume um for example this game is does rely on a lot of card drafting as you are collecting these cards it will get you books that will make you more proficient at diving or you know Excavating certain regions on the board now unfortunately the drafting pools are very small and what normally happens is that on your turn there's nothing you really want um and then you might pick a card it's not really a card that you want and it'll refill with a card that the next really good for the next player or then you might spend all your time traveling from one side of the board to the other um wasting all that time and then on the next player's turn the card you wanted appears in the place you've just left so again very swingy in that regard and some people it's just going to fall on the lap of and some people are going to get the hard shoulder in terms of how those cards come out now I think a lot of the um criticisms I see on this game is the pure luck Factor when it comes to drawing tokens from these bags because basically the more knowledge you gain through these cards will mean that you get to dive into these bags more often pull more chits out and not spend too much time doing it whereas you know at the start of the game if you want to start diving into these bags you might only get to say

pick up one token and that would cost you like eight time which is not a good ratio at all and again the more knowledge you get the more efficient that gets but despite that you are still hit with quite a huge luck Factor because these bags are filled with black sand tokens which are obviously just a waste of effort but hidden in there are all the points tokens now I do like the kind of passive Balancing Act of do I want to start Excavating earlier although my knowledge might not be great at least all the artifacts are still there um but again I'm going to waste a lot of time doing it and it's a huge risk or do I want to get really proficient get to draw a lot more tokens a lot better ratio but by that time other people might have ransacked that area and there's simply nothing left for you to get and as the game goes on of course more and more tokens are gone making it a lot more difficult to get the tokens that you need um so very swingy in terms of what you'll draw um and not only in terms of the cards but also in terms of the artifacts I thought the balancing of how long the time scales take is a little bit off and you can waste a lot of time or spend a lot of time not taking a turn because you had a poor action that spent a lot of time and everyone has to catch up with you meaning you're not doing anything at all so lots of downtime here as well so sadly I think um you know a lot like a lot like the theme would suggest this one hasn't aged well I think um you know the the all the new designs have really outpaced this one

and it the luck factor is simply too much um but I would love to see a reimplemented version of this or a second edition because I do think the framework is there just make the the car drafting a little bit more open so you have a bit more control and tighten up a few of the extra mechanisms to not let the luck Factor play too big of a part so a bit of a shame um yeah quite fr experience that is thieves at number four at number three I have I'm the boss another game from yester year you know Sid Saxon design one of the forefathers of the negotiation genre of games and one that I've wanted to play for a long time so this one you are simply um moving around this Rond Del essentially and wherever this pornland is going to be what the players are going to negotiate for so for example one of these location might say where you need two technology cards you need a a politics card and whatever different categories there are and what you're going to do is that once that particular location has been settled on all the other players can throw in their two cents about what they're willing to contribute to the deal and what they want in return because the more difficult these deals are to achieve the more dividends there are to spread out amongst the players so know if a particular player is in charge and they are are really short on one particular um card that they need and you have it you might say yeah I'll give it to you so you don't waste your entire 10 but I

want a good healthy amount in return for that that's pretty much the bones of the game there's a good potential for negotiation here and the coolest aspect of it is the I'm the boss card which means that if negotiations aren't essentially going your way you can smash this carard down and hijack the whole negotiation to say you know I'm making the deals now and I get the final set that was definitely the best part of the game and there were some real good um interactions when those cards came into play some of the other things are a little bit too lucky about what you might have um and I also thought that these player placards that would be shared amongst the players sometimes felt a little bit too powerful and could it would mean that you could often get too much of the deal done yourself so I would have liked to have maybe seen those be diluted down a little bit so that other players are almost mandatory to be involved in the deals um still quite an abrasive game if especially if you want to play it that way but I suppose that goes hand in hand with the game like this and all than all I think it's aged well but my only issue is that it is competing directly with some other games that I think are simply better um in particularly in particular I am talking about Chinatown which you guys might know is one of my favorite games of all time this game offers the same experience but the negotiation isn't quite as rich and in ch game like Chinatown you do have a bit more autonomy and a few different PES you can pull from to leverage those deals and

this one is simply a matter of do I have the card or do I not have the card so I think this one again has been overtaken by similar and better designs but in a vacuum this one will probably still be in my collection but again the competition is just too tight for I'm the boss so that is I'm the boss at number three at number two I have ancient knowledge now this is a card driven engine building game um with a really neat structure actually if I have to um really give the game the most praise it would be in respect of that simple turn structure and the bones of the game because this one despite having so much scope of different Combos and things to do it really is broken down into a really nice structure as in playing cards from your hand which don't even cost anything they simply um you know you can play them directly you know sometimes you have to give up other cards but there isn't a currency per se in this game um then you are triggering any end of round cards and then you are sliding all the cards down from the kind of right hand side to the left hand side and kind of like a typewriter fashion which kind of demonstrates the passing of time as this knowledge is flowing through your civilization and Grading and going you know into um you know ancient times but when these cards are active on your player board they give you some kind of ongoing ability which can synergize with each other um but the downside of that is that generally speaking the more powerful cards you

play will come with these knowledge tokens on them which you are trying to kind of extract from these cards before they wither away because every bit of knowledge on those cards that is um taken off the board by the passing of time is going to start building up negative points so you're constantly trying to figure out ways to again harness all that as quickly as possible they're trying to synergize cards with each other and so on so not only are you trying to manage your hand of cards but there are also some public cards available which will give you other engine building benefits um and different things to collect and synergize with other cards and Etc and you got permanent abilities you've got end of game abilities end of round actions and so on so different lots of different moving Parts here for different experiences each time you play now the game itself is quite subtle um this game isn't a bombastic game you know when you think of lot a lot of other engine building car driving games you get these big boisterous turns that will give you lots of power powerful things you can do this one is a little bit more rained in again a little bit more subtle with what you can do but there are still a lot of um you know a lot of clever decisions to be made um and the game actually does put you under a lot of pressure as well because sometimes you can bite off a bit more than you can chew it puts you under stress at certain times because you might not be able to get everything you want done and then you by clever play you can get everything you want done so I do like the way this game does reward um playing things in certain orders and you know generally speaking the best

player will win in a game like this my main bug bear in this game is very similar to what I just mentioned with thieves where the card the pool of cards that you're drafting from is quite small and basically the way it replenishes can be quite frustrating because you could be saving towards something and then a player will draft one of those cards from the center of the table which are like your technology cards and the remaining one that you wanted is just taken off the board and you didn't really have a say so also particularly when it comes to the second half of the game which you're getting end of game scoring cards the game sometimes rewards you for things that you weren't anticipating so for example it might say um you can take this card if you have three of these particular um monuments in your ancient area and three of these particular monuments you had no idea that that card was going to come out and some player unwillingly played all those cards and had them you know passed through time and they could take those cards and give them a a really healthy amount of amount of points and nobody really knew that was going to happen so I felt like this game was like neck and neck the whole way I played it and everyone played equally but it worked out in the favor just by happen stance that the the winning player managed to play all those cards during the game and those end game scoring cards just came out so in that respect I felt like that was quite jarring and it was quite swingy now I haven't played this much at all so maybe that will start to level

out the more I play it but that particular experience did leave me feeling not disgruntled but I thought that it it kind of hurt the game um just that little bit and I thought that yeah you can play as well as you like but you know it's going to come down to Which special technology cards come out who's going to determine the winner so again I'm not terribly experienced with this game I could be wrong but from the slight few times I've played it it does seem to be that can be a factor of course the more you play this one you might start to know those cards a bit more but as it stands you know I play a lot of different games rather than playing the same game time and time again um that one is going to leave a little bit of a a sour taste in my mouth so um again game structure decisionwise fantastic a really well-designed game maybe can be a little bit long if you drag your heels but I think as long as players are playing with a good Tempo I think the the statements that are out there about this game taking too long are maybe a little bit overstated I don't think it's too bad at all we played a three-player game in this recently and only took us about 75 minutes if that and that's including a teach which I think is perfectly fine for a game of this depth but yeah I would love to see that be maybe a wider open pool of cards so that people can strategize a bit more and just not react tactically on decisions they had no idea where they were making at the beginning of the game so that is ancient knowledge at number two and finally at number one who would have guessed is the Stefan

Feld game with Catman do so this is the newest of his design from the city collection um so this isn't a reprint it's a brand new one um and it's a racing adjacent game and to be honest if I put um a few games out there to compare it to you're probably going to get a good idea what this game is all about so this is kind of Stephen feld's take on a game like the Quest for Lorado and also a game like foot Footprints um for me these three games kind of feel quite similar um in this one it's as you'd expect with the Fel game it is a lot more Point salad um and it's also dice driven so unlike these other games I've mentioned this one doesn't use cards at least not in the traditional sense of driving the game it does does use dice so basically you're going to set out this big map of these modular tiles which will show different terrain types different things you can visit and at the start of your turn you're going to roll six dice those dice are going to correspond to a independent Resource as well as showing how far you can move um in terms of the pit value so you roll a five you can move five spaces in a straight line essentially um now what you're trying to do is of course you're trying to race to Catman do the first player there will get a healthy amount of points but of course you are trying to visit certain things along the way by visiting these temples getting more points as you go collecting maps and trying to slot them together to get some extra points and you're taking

photographs by landing on certain terrain types which will match this common pool of animal cards um I like the scoring mechanism there which reminds me of Glenn Mo where if you basically the player with the most is going to score points for each of their cards depending on the player the player with the least so for example if one player had one card and another player had say five cards the difference is going to be how many points each card is worth so you kind of want to stay up with a pack when it comes to taking those photograph cards um also you are collecting equipment cards which will give you gamebreaking rules such as traveling straight through mountains or taking a right turn or you know a taking a right angle turn because again normally you are restricted to only move in a straight line um so I like the way that each of those equipment cards felt extremely powerful and they were definitely worth having um and I do like the way that you can plan your turns here because I suppose I think a lot of the thing that people will criticize with this game is is that it does feel a little bit rigid because you are again moving in a straight line so naturally it means that you might move this way and then get way to where you need to go and in order to get to the next um modular of T you'll need to completely diverge and spend your whole time just kind of straighten straightening up which can feel a little bit plotting at times but through the use of those equipment cards you can kind of get around that and make up ground on where your opponents might be all in all the car the game is mainly

driven at least from a point um sense in terms of set collection so again you're getting points based on the sets of cards you're getting um these Yak tiles you're shedding by um by landing on particular terrain types again visiting these locations um and so on so yeah it was very Point Solly getting points from here and that and here and that um but for some reason I am Charmed by this game and you know I am a massive stepen fan stepen Feld Fanboy so do take that into consideration but I like the way that it all comes together and it does have some interesting decisions to be made especially when it comes to trading off which dice to use because not only are you considering you know the the distance you're traveling but you need to factor in the resources that these dice give you because not only each the dice you select to move is going to determine the resource you get which is going to be a huge factor in how many points you get because you know if you need equipment cards you're going to need to use the brown Dy if you want the animal cards you're going to need to use the purple dies if you want to um move more efficiently across certain tiles you'll need to collect these Compass um the compass tokens because you need to shed them or not move at all and so there's lots of different things you need to balance and consider here to keep your supplies stocked up and I also like the fact that you're not always rewarded to kind of travel the fastest because you're going to miss so many opportunities along the way and also the more Pips you spend you go lower in turn

priority the next turn so again there's different things you can factor in there as well so I think if you love Stephen Feld games this one's still might be jarring because it's not his usual fair and if you like the higher end of the Spectrum in terms of complexity in in Feld games like you know your traun um your even your burgundies or even more advanced than that then this one might leave you wanting a little bit because it is a lot more tailored towards say a Gateway plus um group it's not I wouldn't say it's Gateway because there are still some felian you know Euro mechanisms but it definitely doesn't have the Strategic depth or the richness of some of the you know more famous fa designs but it's definitely does have his his trademark you know all the Hallmarks and when you play this game it does feel like a fail game I want I want that's probably the best way to say it um so all in all I like this one I think is a lot of fun it it does get a commendation at this time is it going to stand up to the longevity of repeated plays um I think it will I'm not entirely sold on that and I think I will be doing a disservice if I don't compare this to these other games I've mentioned um like the quest of El Dorado and um and Footprints because they are so similar I think right now and maybe this is recency bias um I would put this one at the front of those because I do

think there's just a little bit more interesting things going on and deck building isn't my preferred mechanism I do find it a little bit more um a little bit more laborious than being just selecting a dice and moving it that way um and I do like the different layouts you can have in this one and so on there's different that that modularity is there um but I think this one can be or will be more polarizing and there's going to be a lot of Fel fans that will bounce off of it because it doesn't have that richness as I mentioned before but still as it stands right now I I'm I'm all in I really like it and I'm enjoying my plays of it and hopefully that won't change because I do find it very charming and I do like that tradeoff of racing to the end but also trying to visit all the hot spots along the way and there's even that additional pressure where the end of the round these clouds will start to encroach from board to board um and can even like overtake the players which will can actually start to rack up these exhaustion tokens um to make your turns less productive and even waste an entire turn so lots of things going on here more than I can probably summarize but at the same time I'm sure you've got a gist of the game um so that is Catman do by stefen Feld at number one so there we have it that concludes the video hopefully you have enjoyed it if you have please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too and for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved