Top Historical Games of 2023 with Dan Bullock
Transcript
all right we are live uh hopefully there are people out there in our stream uh to say hello to us and also I do believe we're starting on time um which Eat Your Heart Out Fred Servo oh fighting words it's always fighting words with Fred I love it I think it's I love Fred I only fight with Fred because I adore him if I don't like you I don't engage with you at all so yeah I always assume that if someone isn't picking on me there's something wrong like the Rapport isn't quite quite where it needs to be yet right makes sense indeed indeed uh but hello everyone out there hopefully we'll uh get some more people kind of streaming in in the next few minutes uh I don't think anybody expects streams to start on time uh but uh Dan and I are here to talk about our top historical games of 2023 they don't have to have come out in 2023 but we have to have played and enjoyed them in 2023 you think that's fair I think it's fair it's also impossible to verify which makes it fun for us right we could have just made up anything um I'm just going to pretend that I didn't know what code names was or something until till this year and that is also in fact a historical game um it's about spies it's a code it's a it's it's definitely about the soe during World War II yeah I never even thought of it as being
like Espionage Cold War themed why not you could you could make anything historical if you want to yeah I think I think that that's that's something we could definitely make happen and in our rebranding of popular games to make them less popular yes by calling things historical you automatically just decrease the cool Factor yeah several notches that's what my nephews tell me when I introduce games
to so when I um when I do not actually hide the fact that I have a YouTube channel for my students but they never watch it because I tell them that it's about historical board games and they do not care from that moment it's fantastic it's safe you probably call them out you could call individuals out who are um known problems uh s of source of displeasure um a behavioral handful whatever classroom nuisance just be like I can name names no one will ever know it's buried deep in the recesses of my historical board gaming channel honestly I'm pretty sure the biggest behavioral problem in my classroom is
me so it's okay it's okay oh man all right so do you just want to get down to business sure we get down to business I know that on time is the new um abrasive so that both they're going to be like top four what's going on I I love that we're just gonna like hit them where it HTS it's great I um I just put it in Fred's Discord because salt the wound yes for those who are unaware apparently there is a rebel Fury playthrough today on home and we decided independently of knowing this um to to do our do our thing on and Liz was gonna host a little top five games of 2023 so of course now we're going to just be playing Rebel Fury starting three minutes sooner than their playthrough does yes exactly we won't have Mark Herman but so we'll be playing it incorrectly but I think that's okay I fine as long as we start first we know that their playthrough hasn't started yet so yes uh so we did accidentally cross post like cross schedule with Fred from hu days we do feel bad about it but I'm also just gonna take this opportunity to Raz him before we get down of business yeah yeah it's just
that's what friends do we do at the beginning the middle and then twice again at the end Double Tap oh man all right so let's let's do get down to business though because I do want to talk about all these games I know that you like play cooler things than me um so who who should go first do you want to go first as the guest I will go first as the guest and then if any of these that I enter in my top five are not to your liking you can simply veto them and just let make gently aware that they are in fact not one of the top five games and that you did not like voice your displeasure however you'd like I think that'll be fun yes yes I can cancel you actually I have a hat for cancellations I love it so subtle I love it the subtlety of it is great and not enough Tri corn hats being worn um I agree let's bring back um I mean I won't be the one to do it but I I applaud applaud the attempts um on the various channels to to bring the hats back every time I'm listening your podcast Liz I'm assuming you're wearing a hat of some kind I can't see it but I know it's there exactly a Jedi spiritual hats it's just there it's Force hat yes um so my first uh pick uh for top five games from last year is actually and I'm I'm not going to have the boxes for all of them because I've loaned two of them out
which is hilarious but I do have glorious chance Gina Willis because what's more fun than fighting out the naval campaign of the War of 1812 if there's something I don't know what it is I mean appar only four other things this is stop that quit um so I find it fascinating that after ages of there being no games on this topic then of course two came out um within months of each other this year of course um Gina wills's through Legion war games and then um Ken rael's um game 1812 war for the Great Lakes uh came out on Compass which I have not tried yet but it has a beautiful map I will get to everything eventually so help me God but um what I love about Gina Willis's game so this is her first uh solo design she co-designed um uh Skies of of Britain with Jeremy white for GMT which also came out this year um but this design was actually in the pipeline with Legion before she started it and I believe she actually had initially started this game as a kind of thought exercise or something to do with like Miniatures so it's pretty bizarre because I never think about Miniatures at all when I'm playing this so what's cool about it it accentuates and emphasizes just the
naval component of the War of 1812 in the Great Lakes which is so weird because living on the Great Lakes as I do like I find it really bizarre to imagine campaigns being waged against the British there um it's very interesting because that is the entirety of the scope you might be responsible for transporting troops to and from a place but the land battle is all abstracted away you really don't have any responsibility to it your focus is purely unable you can play as either the Americans or the Brits both campaigns have their own constraints and they are uniquely weird but the asymmetry doesn't really involve learning to sets of rules you're basically just learning one set of rules the game does have two Rule books but the two Rule books are just for reference purposes so that way when you're looking up things they don't always have to explain what it means to be British and what it means to be American looking up rule 3.1 or whatever um it's really cool there are It's like got a nice kind of unfolding story and this will not be to everyone's taste but one of the things I like is almost every game averages one big confrontation at some point um with an enemy Fleet it's often not at a time of your choosing it's not the most ideal deal timing for the campaign so sometimes you kind of hit what you think is the climax of your uh solo session um in the middle
sometimes a little bit at the beginning and sometimes right at the very end um but that keeps the tension up pretty High because you never know what's going to happen I thought it was really a pretty impressive first first design from anyone I would never show anyone there's a couple first designs by the way in my top five this year I would never show anyone my first design never ever under any circumstances so anytime someone publishes one of them and it turns out great I'm like God bless them that's awesome yeah see I'm lucky because my first design was just with David I knew it was fine but um I've I've also started making my own like strange Little Creations and uh you know what though I I actually have enjoyed like allowing myself that vulnerability like I showed my weird agripina game to C worly at Pax unplugged and it was actually a really good experience that's awesome it was cool like people are actually really nice I think to the game designers are good to each other so I would trust like another game design person that I knew was going to like have something interesting to say within with an early design I think but yeah it can be it can be a double-edged sword because sometimes they know they'll be designing trying to trying to help with a design like feature for your game and you're like please just tell me Impressions I'm only taking Impressions please stick to the kind of
feedback I asked you for positive only and I'm oh so before my number five did you have any um honorable mentions you want to slip in before we get moving um I I did have one that I think I'm gonna I'm gonna get out of the way right now actually so um loral Commander was one of my favorites um this year and it's kind of part of what I love about it is I have a soft spot for team based War Games there aren't enough of them I just want there to be more in general but I I really liked it but I hesitated putting it on this list because Modern Warfare hypothetical conflicts things like that I just don't think of those games as historical even though they draw from recent conflicts in terms of platform systems and what is specifically being modeled in the games so I kind of hesitated to put that in a historical space but if it was like a top five war games for this year I think our guy would have made it um but yeah I I thought it was it shows off like Sebastian's experience with design and I have only played through two of the scenarios and I'm getting my ass handed to me every time I play them I have not sniffed a win in this game and I may never but I've enjoyed it enough to keep bring it back to the table so that's awesome I'm you know what I'm gonna allow that I think that inspired by recent history is gonna should count we'll count it very benevolent and permissive ruler I
appreciate broad broad definitions all right so I actually before I get into my number five I had two honorable mentions um one because it's not out yet is uh Molly house which I'm really looking forward to playing more I can't wait to try Ricky's solo version of it but I was just so pleased with the plays that I had of it this year um because it's such a cool integration of theme and mechanism and I thought that the way they handled informance was it actually turned out really good like I know that through the games development there was a lot of kind of um difficulties related to that I think it's come out well um but just the whole vibe of that game is on point from what I can see and so I'm I'm really excited to play a game that like feels like a a tough competitive board game but it's also about parties having the best secret parties in gay beeses I'm here for this I think it's gonna be a really really cool like thing to try with more people once it's in wider circulation I Lov I got to try it only once um in this latest iteration at um SD uh histon and I I love that that kind of a Continuum of joy and guilt how it yes sort of frames um Victory and standing for the players and I also love that there was a lot of incentive for trying to
facilitate other Joy instead of it just being like sort of a always being a selfish kind of uh typical competitive kind of game mechanic because if you don't throw some Joy the way of your compatriots it just incentivizes um bad behavior and it could spell Doom for the Molly house and I thought that that was a really clever wrinkle but yeah that informance mechanic is really nice that was good I was really happy with it my other so just by virtue of how often I've been playing it lately I can't not mention votes for women because I've played like I've got three games of votes for women going on right now and I've played like six or seven in the past like since it came out on rally the troops I like I did a stream of it because I was gonna do stream but now I can't stop I've been playing the crap out of votes for women and what's really bad is I've gotten pretty good at playing the opposition so I'm like yeah I can't wait to get on here and Crush my right to vote again like oh no you and Kevin are just despicable people bodying folks on rally the troops suppressing the movement it's a shame it's really a shame I don't know games are about exploring that other part of yourself uh but yeah why don't you tell your rally the true story of this week since we were talking about it before the stream oh well I so I went from not having gotten a try it yet which is kind of ridiculous because I've been at a
numerous cons where Tori was there there Dem I don't know what kind of lazy putts I am that that I still couldn't make that happen but um so I went from not having played it at all um despite having a copy to then playing it three times probably in the first two days that it was up on rally the troops um and I have kind of an issue with having Games available on my computer because it kind of gets in the way of my work and design and all other stuff I need to do so I'm very bad at having the discipline to put them away so I played three quick games in short order and then I was like all right I need to take a rally of the troops break and I need to like not have that I was lamenting to Liz about my magic the Gathering problem from a year ago and I just I can't I can't be on Arena ever again like I'm never going to get anything done games got to come out we got people people we got things to do podcasts to edit there's like stuff that's got to come out so it's bad it's real bad it's bad uh my actual number five was played online uh because I finally got in my Grail game this year of like finding people to play with me finding people to teach me I can't wait to do it again I've mentioned it on my multiplayer one to my video on this channel which is Republic of Rome I had dreamed of playing it and you know I know it's new to me right here in 2023 that things old is dirt for by game standards but it was so good it was such a messed up experience of like wanting to preserve the Republic but also hating that some
body else was going to get credit from the people for being the general at the Battle so like we were literally calculating how to give people just enough Legions so they could probably win the war but maybe they would die and like having to run that through like the Senate um you know getting jealous when other people were given offices and like arguing that it was your turn to get an office you have to actually argue that out in this game and so it'd be like no it's my turn to be censored this year this person's been censored this many times it's like no but you're Prestige you your numbers is getting too high you know we can't let you get all the glory and it just becomes such a mess it's such a deeply it it's one of those games that as a game I'm not actually sure that any individual thing you're doing is any fun I don't know if that makes sense like oh you know I'm gonna get some income and then I'm gonna argue with everybody and then we're gonna do some math and then we're gonna roll some ties but it's the human baseness that it brings out that like is just so there there's something that's so pleasing about also cartago Dinda asked is absolutely correct Eric but um but it was it just really brought things out of me that games normally don't because I'm normally a solo gamer and I realized like what a monster I really can be from playing Republic of Rome and also how Roman it really felt like from reading about the Republic starting to crumble and like what people were saying about each other the kind of fights they had the game just really
captured the nasty ambitious mess of it all and I would play it again right now it was great it's it's an interesting kind of Touchstone for a lot of designers right and I think that it's also one of those games sort of like diplomacy in that um how much of the game is Just situated outside of the game yeah like very in it's in the vicinity but it doesn't quite feel feel um uh raw and mechanical in the way that some of their plays are and this is something I think about a lot when playing people's Cooperative designs is like how much we're negotiating with each other how heads up it is and like how much we actually interact and talk versus how much of the game is just you know my friend yelling at me to do X because they're quarterbacking and I'm so useless at reading the board situ so this didn't make my list maybe Majors but um we've got a commenter saying that Mr President is his favorite recent history game yeah didn't make mine I I actually think that um it's kind of an interesting case of a game that's super complex and expensive and really difficult to table because it's both very very long and Solitaire and um I don't want to get cancelled by Liz which is a fear that of us live with every day but um I don't really play solitary
games that are quite that lengthy in general because I can't have something set up on my table for that long for me I what no one eats when they have games uh you know I'd like to play some more Mr President before I make a judgment on how good I think it is but I will say it almost hurt me to play it because it was so nostalgic in a way like it made me think of when I had more faith in our presidency and an America's role in the world and so like I enjoyed it but it was also like wow I remember when I used to watch the news and feel more like this as opposed to just like despair so I think it might be like too recent for me like I don't think my heart too soon too soon I mean what is it it's 2012020 right 20 yeah and but like you know I was Voting I graduated high school in 20 4 I cast my first vote when I in a presidential election when I was in college um you know I followed all that stuff avidly for a long time and so like it's weird because it's like playing when my political activity started in my life if that makes sense so it's kind of an interesting it's a really interesting experience to play it because you know of course it cuts out right before Co right well I mean also it's I think with such a long design process I I don't remember the first GMT like what year
the first uh GMT uh weekend of the warehouse I went to was yeah but I know that game had an update there was like a design update about it and it had to be when I was like the first year I was like probably taking uh no motherland without to Publishers so just like to think that it's been kind of in the pipeline somewhere in that way it's it's just it has to wrap up sometime I if the design process lasts longer than FDR's presidency that's just too long I think for like for me it would be for me it would drive me nuts to have a game that take take much longer than that so I totally understand oh man so what's your number four my number four um I'm going to change I'm swapping two numbers oh my God I I do that all the time I'm like done it like already twice this video go for it I do feel a little weird because it's it's another war game and it just just shipped like in the past like month so uh downfall which is uh John Butterfield and Chad Jensen um Chad Jon pass before he finished this game John Butterfield kind of took up the mantle and uh co-designed uh the game um yeah and uh I think I'm a little hazy on exactly who the developer was that game or how much development I think it was a bit of a group effort probably with Kai Jensen and John Butterfield to kind of CLE together um it's really so one of my
favorite things about John Butterfield games and Chad Jensen Games is that how um it inserts friction into places that most war games let you have a lot of control and so I kind of like when say an event will just sort of screw up your plans because you didn't plan for it and it's sort of conversed to like how when you're playing a carard driven game sometimes you have the sense of like I can make the event happen before I play the event or after like there's like a little bit of added flexibility that they just never give to you and I love that in Combat Commander when I'm just minding my own business trying to pick somebody up across the battlefield like you know I mean like go go run run and reinforce a position and then I just get shot by a sniper because of some dumb card that popped at the exact wrong time and I just love that I just love being screwed by system like repeatedly and that that is lovely and I think enemy action has that same thing when you're trying to like hit your opponent um I I think that that kind of team up is pretty pretty badass this is this is like a really interesting collaboration and um is a fantastic idea for those who don't know in downfall one player plays the Western allies in their Western Front as well as OK which is half of the axes facing the East front and then the other player plays the East front and okw which is the half of the axis facing the West so we get to kind of like uh split the uh unpleasant task of having
to manage the the Nazi factions while simultaneously getting to push with the fronts it does portray it as though it feels pretty fragile it's going to collapse at some point somebody's going to get in there and it's just basically a race to see who's going to get in there so no matter what you get to see the collapse of the aess which is fantastic uh I actually managed to play this twice um first play was a little bit abbreviated was our kind of get our feet weight white and learn the system and the second play was more of a now we know what we're doing and getting to immerse ourselves in it but I'm really impressed with it and I'm very excited to have more time with it next year awesome now I'm curious how dare you no kidding that's why I have you on here because you'll mention stuff that I won't have played I'll be really excited all right uh so you definitely played uh my number four though uh because I really loved the gods will have blood I really did so y' Dan made a weird Boutique game this year he only made like 200 copies I set an alarm so I could make sure that I backed it on game found on time because I was afraid I wouldn't get a copy um but um the gods will have blood is I mean it's kind of a literary game too I guess in the sense that it's inspired by a novel called the gods will have blood but I'm going to call it historical because you know the novel also is set in that period yeah it's like roughly yeah like historical fiction is kind of that shady shitty spot but we're gonna go with it I think because I think what you captured
in the game was really cool so for those of you who have not played it um it is a game about kind of running show trials during the French Revolution and you've done well you're like on the little tribunal uh but you're trying to maintain your status uh with in the revolution and you're trying to maintain the legitim the legitimacy of the court and at the same time there are people who are going to like go up for um for execution that you really don't want to die so like a friend a lover like people that you just really don't want to see die and so you are trying not to lose your soul by killing people that you want to kill you also don't have full control over what's happening because you get to have some decision in the process but you're also part of a court and so the more people die the more momentum goes into the bag and so you get like kind of into killing people as a group and like you can't stop and I thought that was just a really interesting premise did you have anything to add at me it's your game I have a question what kind of magistrate were you Liz were you were you lenient a lot of Mercy I I I had a hard time because it was like I would trying to be mean a couple times and then start trying to show Mercy before it was too late but sometimes it still was it's like it's like like okay let me okay I'm going to kill kill kill okay let me pump the brakes pump the brakes kill kill kill oh pump the brakes again gotta stop got to stop um let's let's let's show some self-control of people um but I really liked that you could kind of get
swept away with what was going on and so it was partially about your decisions partially was out of your hands but I think that's how it would feel I feel like it really created like sort of chaos of being part of something like that that I thought was really I thought it was just an interesting an interesting uh design and I also liked how it's just small it is it says a lot with like not a lot of words and like if you know if it was a if it was a piece of writing it'd be short and Punchy well thank you for that I I do think um if you have a game that has a somewhat reduced decision space you can kind of ruminate more on the other things it's doing which um I know that some of us like very meaty puzzly things but I think it's like a time and place I don't know that you really want to spend two hours murder overseeing the uh condemnation of all these people right like I think it'd be a little bit grueling but I mean if I got to look at people's trial stuff in detail and then condemn them I feel like that would feel really good but but only if there's no danger to me as the judge you know has oh I see how it is okay then I'm a role model but it was it was good work um I'm the only thing that I'm sad about with that one is that uh there's too much cursive on the cards and that it's not
going to get a bigger pray round or maybe it will one day I don't know where you're at with that but yeah I don't know I haven't I haven't decided yet kind of wait and see I dug it I also do dig like a little Boutique projects hipstery and all the all the best ways hey you treat it like a a Zen almost I don't know I I've liked a lot of games like that you know I remember I was really inspired I got to say when um uh Matilda's uh turn coats came out and I got my copy of that initially everything about the presentation of that made it mean more to me than my cool matte finish boxes that were all mass-produced and then sent from China to me I mean the k as various kickstarters fulfilled I I loved the the feel and look of turn coats and it really did kind of nudge me a bit more and like maybe putting a little extra effort and also it's an opportunity to be political about how you're making a game instead of just being political in the statement a game makes like trying to find vendors that could do things in more Eco conscious way and then also trying to get you know as much of it fulfilled here in the states and kind of assembled here as possible so it was a cool opportunity um am I up I'm up aren't I you are up what's your number three my number three is endurance I do not have the box but this is where I would hold it it's zabel Holland's endurance about the Shackleton expedition began in 1914 and ran a
little long um it's my feel bad game of the year I love feeling bad playing that game but um where man where to start it's so it's so interesting so I think it has two really fascinating design arguments it's making um the one that I was actually most interested in is about when we model history in a game where how do we want to incorporate it do we want the historical outcome to be the outcome that happens the most often when playing or in the case of shackleton's expedition do we treat it like this miracle Hail Mary Hoin one type shot that is so unbelievable to try to even like reproduce and like replicate that the challenge is kind of about creating a model that can facilitate the historical outcome but won't produce it most of the time and I thought that the way the game kind of presented it's uh it's kind of thesis or one of its two thesises was that um if a model allows for the historical outcome to happen that's kind of what we're looking for in a game if we're playing like some weird World War II game and Poland cannot be invaded for whatever reason it's just impossible to invade Poland You' be like what's going on here like what's happening so I think that it's it's um really impressive in
that regard and then the other one was other aspect of it that I found um interesting was the unwillingness to Define Victory conditions and I think that's because um well I'm has like design notes laying out why that is but for for my my impression when I was playing it was that um we already are used to kind of creating our own Victory conditions in like a say role playing game atmosphere and to me this was a little bit more akin to like a tabletop role playing experience probably than a board game because I know what kind of survival I'm aiming for which is everybody makes it out okay I know that if I fell short of that while everything else is like a sadder version of that I there's still some there's not acceptable loss but there's still like the kind of ending that you could be mostly satisfied with and I think that that was an interesting choice um but it was a very unique game it was a very amabel game and um uh what a it was just like an interesting experience because I played it and I did poorly and and I can see someone being like wow this is a very tough topic I felt like I was kind of put through the emotional ringer playing it but at the same time a couple weeks afterward I'm still thinking about the game a fair amount yeah and that that was I played it I think the summer for the first time
and I haven't picked it up since then but I've been thinking about it sporadically in the months that followed and to me that's what I love about a good game is just how much I mentally revisit it even when it's very far away nice nice uh so we'll get back to endurance in a moment but for now my number three is uh land in Freedom uh by Alex Knight because solo it's fine but multiplayer I mean I mentioned this in another video recently but my god um you know uh I really I really um I I again we mentioned kind of with Republic of Rome um how we kind of have games bring things out of us I think what I like the best about Lan in Freedom uh was that it kind of um got me to a place of extreme selfishness and frustration with the selfishness of others in a way that few games really ever do like I normally expect to be screwed over in a game or like you know people do mean stuff like um you know Pax unplugged I absolutely held I had to switch out um in a game of imar with somebody else who was going take over for me cuz I had to be somewhere but I had an extremely irritating card to play and I literally waited like I waited until after everybody had just gotten back from a bathroom break to play the card because I just had to be that much of a little and I couldn't help it and so like I'm used to people being mean and when we're playing games but there's something about land and freedom that's
just it just makes it so much extra frustrating because like we're all fighting fastest together we're supposed to do this together and look at you you betrayed me like you know you're so selfish and that's why we all lost or like I gave so much and now you're leading the Republic what is this BS this is terrible um and so the fact that the game kind of really brings out true emotional response as opposed to just like I'm playing a game I'm playing a game and it was competitive like good move buddy um yeah I think that that's what makes it special like you know normally you know I play multiplayer games playing solo um you know I like to think a lot about emotional experiences of games and I think I've really started to warm especially to multiplayer games that kind of caused something really raw to happen during gameplay if that makes sense also brand wants to say you look like you knew I'd be a camera and I look like I forgot Brand's just jealous that he doesn't look like either of us um you have like your yours is more like the behind the scenes like commentary direct commentary with the director type of vibe mine is like the Press photo taken taking alongside railroad tracks looks weird like what was he posing for what's going on yeah you look always got it Carri it off I just got through my first day of school with students and I'm just glad I'm alive so did it we're just gonna go he did it was but yeah I mean I I really want games to do something to me if that makes sense and so L and freedom really did so for those of you who've not played Lon Freedom um it's available
from blue panther Alex Knight is the designer uh it was his first game like speaking of great first games Jesus Christ um but he it's a semi Cooperative game we all different factions in Spain you are uh fighting fascists and you're also trying to make sure that your version of government is the one that like emerges at the end of the war um and so you have to keep fascism under control but you're also trying to do things that are going to add your own influence to a bag that you're pulling from to see who ends up with the most you know Swagger at the end of the game if you make it at all but Dan I'm assuming you've played it I of course I've played it it's actually number two on my list oh perfect because endurance is my number two so we'll just boom Oh man so we didn't even know we didn't even know we were on the same we really didn't it came together like right near the end um yeah I I think it's great I love and hate the bag of Glory a lot it does everything it's supposed to do um I think I think Alex definitely sidesteps uh some issues that you typically run into in a three player game yeah um the initi one of the things that I think is um there's a lot of things I I I love the way the iconography on the cards for each of the individual faction decks can be played to a tableau I thought that Tableau play was really clever and neat um and kind of crunchy in a way that I
hadn't really seen very much before and I love how winning the initiative helps you seed one of your we'll call them Swagger points Liz I like that a lot Swagger points into the bag of Glory I mean will the moderates have more Swagger than the Communists find out after this probably almost never like do moderates ever really no they're have Mojo I mean it's a little tough right because they've got two tracks to to tug on but cost-wise it's about the same right but they I think that the um I love that the initiative gets you to seed the bag but then when you act first you sort of our um begrudgingly forced into the position of being the bullwark against you know the uh the oncoming kind of um you know fascist hords and so you you usually have to take care of whatever the test is and then the next person will have do that maybe and then they'll half screw you over a little bit and whoever's last will just screw everyone over a lot yeah and and hopefully snag initiative so the next turn they can pay it forward and be the bull workk and do and do do all the grown-up stuff that they kind of uh recused themselves from in the previous round I so I think that's like a really great system I I thought that that was a really impressive um first design um I don't think I don't think it's like a a problem but I it is a it is a very fast
playing game it's like a 90 minute 2our experience it's super tight the table talk is always great people wishing ing death on their compatriots um if they don't go get them a beer and whatnot is like kind of part for the course there right oh yeah oh yeah I'm still mad at David Thompson most selfish communist in the world hold on your hate Liz hold on your hate I just let it flow through me know I was gonna say I I think that the my my one thing that I've noticed uh playing that game is that uh any kind of flavor text for events or for personality cards it's always there for whatever players choose to engage with it um but in that game I feel like there's very little reading text on cards it's mostly iconography but it does drive home the theme of infighting being like what is imperiling this Republican movement which is already in dire St to begin with so I think that that that's what comes across and for for being the only Spanish Civil War game I'm aware of that models that factional in fighting instead of portraying the civil is just a two- party head-to-head war game right um I found that really fascinating and and and very cool so yeah very impressive good job Alex yeah good job Al to all of our alexes that are here I don't know what Alex's are on here but I assume that there's always like two or three alexes hanging out so yeah all the alexes that are here or will be here we love
you um so my number two was endurance for a lot of the reasons you basically summed it up really well but you know ml's games just get me like I really I love how raw she's willing to be with her games I just feel like it really is something cool and I think endurance in particular is special for her because she's talked a lot about how um she couldn't finish the game before her transition and then afterwards like it was like her own Survival Story like mirrors the the survival story of actual Shackleton Expedition and so like trying to evoke that miracle I think it's such an interesting mirror commentary right on a person a personal experience and a historical event um but I also just I don't know the way that she brought in things like entertainment and like trying to keep your spirits up I just thought were particularly good in that game and I love the willingness to experiment with u with no one condition um I've been pretty interested in uh That Others May Live I've been like starting to play that uh getting ready to review it and again it's one of those where it's not so much win or lose it's like can you can you live with the fact that you couldn't save somebody and I feel something something to that that's you know uh Holland Spiel is really like kind of hitting a pulse point for me right now you recently played heading forward didn't you I did that was really interesting it's frustrating um like once you get good at the game I think I mentioned in my review it's almost like as you get better at the game you lose the effect of the
game I think that's true because you get immersed a little bit more in the kind of the mechanis in the system and kind of the proceedings so it's sort of like then you're just trying to solve the puzzle more then you're getting immersed in like kind of thematic play right which is a little weird it's like um and I think this is by the way common in in a lot of what could be very cool thematic um solitary game sometimes where it's sort of like they hand you a slinky and then shortly after they straighten it it's like I don't know what to do with this weird wire I I know when I had it at first first it was very cool and fun and now I've just yeah turned it into something kind of goofy um my bad okay so before we go to number one uh I've been saving this question so sario from the chat wanted to know uh just about um the gods will have blood how do it feel to control all aspects of production so we'll just have a quick interlude to get his question answered and we'll move on I think I highly recommend it if you can pull it off it's pretty pretty excellent I had the opportunity to kind of like try a bunch of different vendors out that produce different components and then nobody could do everything I wanted the exact way or at the exact price point that I wanted to keep everything manageable and keep cost from getting out of control but I did um think that being able to pick the best of each thing and then put it all in the Box felt great if you've
ever so if you ever had like a game go out let's say a sticker sheet get cut weird and then you heard about it for like the next six months of your life or if uh you ever had a publisher and they produced a counter sheet that's exact same color as your board so it Blends in as if it fell fell into the abyss it's really I highly recommend it def definitely worth trying nice uh and then just one more thing so Brant from armch drons has mentioned um that we should look up death can wait from a uh US Army commanded general staff College it's like a game somebody do did it for their Master's thesis and it's about how to run a field hospital and deal with the casualties as they're coming in oh I would be very interested in trying something like that that sounds really it sounds brutal but I would try it like just because it hurts doesn't mean I'm not gonna be interested in trying it so yeah um so out of curiosity what's your number one one yeah moment of truth moment of truth from nuts publishing got a lot of deep got a lot of deeper Cuts Publishers uh it's weird coming Nineveh uh it's the battle for mosul 2017 between Iraqi forces and dash Isis forces um designed by as far as I can tell two two designers that had never produced a commercial game before and
then I think it was developed by Brian train and RX brinan so that's pretty good Gig if you can get your game developed by a couple Pros like that yeah um it's a block game but I still like it is that the way to say it steuart he won't be it's interesting because uh I think what really drew me to it was it's it's got some similar aspects to um downfall in that I feel like it inserts friction in places that war gamers are not used to seeing it and it models um a bit of how you are how the population of a place is incorporated into a conflict and even though they don't have representation on the board they're represented in this event deck along with collateral damage and aspects like that so this event deck um Liz has like numbers on the top of each card every time in combat that number is rolled you interrupt the action of what's going on and then you resolve the event immediately and it's just like both by the first I I would say like 30 minutes into the first game it's just the size of disgust on both sides of the table every time this thing popped because we had no idea who was going to impact we just knew everything in the deck is like some kind of bad thing some sort of like horrible Choice
love that about it that was that's my bread and butter feeling bad all the time and then um it has an interesting um measure for victory where um you're looking at resolving the SE on mosul through um there's like three values that we're tracking it's casualties collateral damage and then time how long does it take for Iraqi forces to secure mosul again um and a high score is good for Isis and a low score is good for the Iraqi forces but everybody's got a objective card for their side that they play in secret at the start of the game and whatever they emphasize of those three tracks that value will be doubled at the end of the game for the scoring and if both sides pick the same thing it will be tripled when we tot scores so sometimes you think you're being really slick because you've got a good plan minimize collateral damage things go kind of sour and they go the other way and then it turns out both you and your opponents prioritize collateral damage and there's a whole lot of it just like what an amazing game love it um so it was very cool I liked it a lot and um it kind of gave me some ideas of how we something I wanted to see in like some more war games about representing um civilian populations and kind of non um non-combatant folks yeah and um I I had a talk with um Natalia like a a few weeks ago um for my podcast about how
model like that stuff and she was bringing up like all these great kind of professional war games they' played where there'd be things like where you couldn't actually have have your um forces in Supply if you didn't have um a sympathetic populace surrounding you or near you it was sort of like almost like borderline partisan activity that would just basically be kind of undercutting your efforts and so it got me thinking a little bit more about how that gets modeled in games and wanting to see that like a little bit more says my number one nice yeah my number one is uh it's I I would say it's actually probably the most commercial game in the list but I just really liked it uh it's not about bulges I'm sorry we we always we have to get the Battle of the Bulge there but it is World War II uh and I picked it because I immediately got like design in when I played it and then I played it a bunch of times uh and it was Halls of hegra okay um Halls of hegra from um stet games and it is basically it's a it's like a sour it's a tower defense like Siege game it's solitire only um and it mixes worker placement and bag building like with that Tower Defense so you are um you're playing some Norwegians who are trying to fend off some early World War II German attacks and you have basically little worker placement pieces
that you're putting in little slots about around different actions on the board that you want to take and one thing that's so frustrating is it's like there's so many actions that look good but you're just never gonna have enough people to take them off so it's like oh I could do this this this oh wait no I can't I can do like two things damn it um uh and then of course as you go you know people get demoralized people get um you know they get hurt it takes forever to get them out of the infirmary uh there's a recovery period so you can have a big chunky turn but then you used everybody and you're like oh do I want to been supplies to like refresh more people right now do I want to wait it out um and then meanwhile like the attacks from the Germans are like gaining an intensity during this time and they're damaging all your stuff and so I I compared it to Home Alone in my review because it's like it's like you make your plan and like you try to shore everything up you're like okay I can go here I can do this I can prepare this I can remove this potential damage to me you know I can get all these people I can get ready um you know so you feel like that Preparatory kind of segment of the game which I enjoy because it feels like I'm hunkering down like I'm one of those people in a video game too where I'll just kind of watch guard movements or whatever forever I like to make a plan it just feels like there's something about that that I particularly enjoy so you have a couple turns to plan and then like it's on and the Germans start to show up and so you have to um to balance like am I prepping correctly am I responding well in the moment am I aware of what could happen it's really hard to win the game um I will say that if you get horrible draws early in the game and you don't get enough people in
with you um you're not going to win the game but I love just the act of doing it like I love the bag building aspect there's a couple different bags that things come out of you could put more misses in the hit bag so it you know it makes it more likely you're not going to get damaged um this the actual workers coming out of the uh the um the worker bag are like really interesting like you're just constant like I just really found it an engaging experience it's one that I've played a bunch of times I I'm thinking about it I'm like oh maybe I'll play that again tonight and so it's really my number one in the sense of like it's what I want to sit around and play of an evening and like there's just no disputing the appeal of something like that I really it's a really really enjoyable take on Tower Defense and like I like Tower Defense games in general and because this one was different and special therefore I was like super into it um so Brant wants to say too many options for resources sounds just like 80% of Ryan lockets games I'm not gonna comment on that but um I I really like TOS of hegra it's really really good um I thought it was such a smart implementation of of bag bag Poole plus plus Tower Defense would you characterize this year's designs or releases rather is
being a great year to reach into a bag or I'm just kind of curious if you had a little Zippy not as good not as good as next year because night witches is coming with a great pair of bags for you to reach into U no I am forever I actually really like back pole I'm really glad that it's a mechanism that's hot now because I really enjoy it I think it's um I I think it's a really good way to deal with randomization and chance without totally having it be about dice um and also I mean I I I feel like I like dice but I do feel like a lot of people are more interested in probability these days that doesn't cut like the thing about a bag right is that you know that your results are in there as opposed to like you could just roll bad the whole night and so I I like bag pull because I feel a greater sense of responsibility and a greater sense of like failure Asos to well the dice just screwed me it's like you know that what you need is in that bag yeah and you just didn't get it like there's a certain I I feel like it's different we just arrived for the spicy dice chat I don't know I think the bag talk might be a little more spicy it depends and uh how you define spicy I
suppose I I can you know I I definitely find it interesting how many designs I play every year that still are very heavily riing on dice despite the fact that I've really haven't ever been super enthusiastic about playing dice heavy games but I also understand it like you know like if you play like a lot of War games if you came up playing a lot of DnD and like tabletop Ro playing games dice are usually just sort of part of it so that's why I've been like really intrigued by like a lot of the tarot driven like solo RPGs and like all these different Mechanics for resolving option you know kind of resolving like actions and also like seeing too um how the kind of quander that you run into when you're playing a game where you're drawing a card from a deck to resolve an action or you're drawing from a bag this this idea of like drawing without replacement like how that changes the ads just seems a little bit more needy to me and like fun because it it's constantly screwing with my math which is already poor to begin with but now now I'm being pushed to its limit you know what I mean like yeah like David and I leaned into that hard for night witches as people will hopefully discover next year uh but yeah I really like that awareness of what's in the bag awareness of what you've pulled having to keep recalculating the odds I really enjoy that I also I actually do enjoy randomization through decks as well um I
really like I like knowing that there are good and bad things in there and just wondering which I'm G to pull and then it's like well I've had my good luck so now what's gonna go wrong or I've had a string of bad luck I know something good will happen to me eventually oh crap I just drew the shuffle card right cleaned it up it's just back back to square one indeed um Brent wants to know if we played zerat I have not um I have it is excellent and I am very excited for um the next game uh seder city um from Tim denum not sure when that's coming out I think it was delayed a little bit um but fingers crossed for q1 2024 excellent I recommend by the way anyone check out zerod it's a great little two-player game uh plays very brisk very fast but lots of nice decisions and it has a popular you do have like two Sid kind of fighting um for different objectives but there's a populace um it's like takes place in Afghanistan there's like a populace that gets represented on the board in a really interesting way and I I think that it's very cool I think Brian train made like a variant for it of course he did and it has a option for being able to play as the populace which is really intriguing but I have not got a try yet I don't know if anyone here has I'd be very interested to hear how that plays nice nice all right so I feel like so
just to kind of sum up um you know Dan you've been in the historical game space for a while how do you do you think that 2023 has been a good year for the historicals I think it's been pretty good I um am always it's weird how every year I think very highly of what's coming next year and then the next year comes and I'm still thinking highly of the next year so I think I'm just I definitely feel spoiled right now to see games like Battle of Versa coming out yeah for example like weren't we just talking about like a fashion game the last time we had our little stream it's like I'm just getting everything I've ever wanted basically just by being alive and being in the hobby it's it's pretty great and I don't know I I think that it it measured up is a pretty good year overall yeah I'm gonna agree with that I feel like played some really really good games this year actually in a way I feel like this is the I think this is the year I've just even though not everything I played this year was from 2023 I feel like 2023 has just been a great year of gaming for me in general and then a lot of the releases from this year I also really really liked like I'm feeling very positive about historical gaming at this particular moment in my gaming life so I'm feeling optimistic for 2024 as well I'm very excited about whatever's next and I'm really happy with a lot of the play experiences I had this year did you feel like the stream was too positive should we have dwell
instead on the 17 most disappointing historical games that's the next stream everyone tune in again next week as we Liz is just kidding we don't know when Fred's next stream is so we don't have any idea when to plan it we'll have to we'll have to figure out if we could get he's got like a paper planner I know this we'll have to send someone to infiltrate the moment he announces his next stream let's just plan worst games we won't even talk about that but people show up because worst games is a clickbait so it'll just happen yeah like the biggest most disappointed audience ever which is what you deserve
that's it's one thing to throw sand in people's face but it's another thing to tell them that that's what they deserve and now you know why I don't play multiplayer games very often oh oh man uh so on that note I suppose we'll draw this stream to a close we should definitely do something again soon absolutely uh without these Jokers heckling us or anything like that we could just play um play votes for women when I'm supposed to be working or something yeah we could do that oh man so everybody who's here thank you so much for being here it's so nice to have like a little afternoon stream I really appreciate it Dan thank you as always for coming on this is always a blast and uh Happy gaming everybody thanks for having me Liz thanks everybody have a good one