World Order - Round the table discussion & review
Transcript
We've just finished a four-player game of world order and we're now going to have a round the table discussion to tell you what we think about it. Bearing in mind, full disclosure, if you are just watching this review video, I have a professional relationship with the publisher. They sent me this as a copy of the game, so I didn't pay for this and I have done some paid work for them. We have just completed a playthrough video which if you're interested in watching it is on the channel now. It's a full fourplayer playthrough. And yeah, we're now going to talk about what we thought about it. So, first of all, the play time. It is a three and a half, four hour game, potentially longer. I've heard some groups six hours for their first game, which to be honest, if you don't know the game and you guys all did your research and read the rule books and you had an idea and you're all experienced gamers. If you put yourself in four people who are not as experienced gamers as you are when none of them really knew the rules, it is going to slow down.
So, I have heard some people take six hours for their first game. It's a three and a half, four hour game once, you know it, but you didn't you hadn't played it before. So, I I think we did really well to get it done. And the weird thing about this game, and I had this same impression because when I played it two years ago,
I played the game and it felt like it was going, "Oh, I do a card, I do a thing, right, that's it." It felt like it was going really smoothly and then you're like,
it's been four hours.
It doesn't feel like 4 hours. And not every game has that. A lot of 4hour 4hour games feel like 4 hours.
Yeah.
So yeah, it's a 4hour game, but it doesn't feel like 4 hours. And I want to touch on the reasons why it doesn't feel like 4 hours.
Any thoughts?
There's not much down time.
Yeah.
Yeah.
You're thinking about your turn.
Mhm.
A lot.
Yeah.
So by the time you've thought what you want to do, it's come around to your next turn.
Yeah.
Yeah. I think a lot of the actions are quite kind of quick and simple and even the ones where you get multiples, it's kind of like get some tanks, do something with them kind of none of it, even though it's long and there's stuff lots of stuff going on, none of it feels particularly kind of
um I was say crunchy, but I don't really mean crunchy. Like it it doesn't feel like overly complicated. It's not a lassera game where an action is five steps that takes you five minutes to resolve. The actions are
improve relations with the country,
spend diplomacy, take the card, done.
Some of your turns can be really quick. Trading can be a bit longer.
Um, so touching on the no downtime, my view on that is because I was always engaged with the game.
Yeah. So there was downtime when you were taking your turns, but a I am planning ahead and b I am paying attention to what's going on. Yeah,
because I play a lot of Euro games where there is almost no player interaction and I'm okay with them. I'm fine with them.
But this game,
that's this is the player interaction game. You have to watch what the other people are doing both in case of the tanks, the placing of the cubes on the board, which countries they're about to take. So, I I have felt engaged with this game every minute except when I went downstairs to make a cup of tea, even though it's a four-player game, and there was downtime when I wasn't taking my turn. But that that's why I think this game plays or feels like it takes less time than it does.
I quite I quite like how the tanks are. It's kind of like you're not openly like fighting, so you're not moving around. you're losing points every round if it affects you rather than like losing stuff. So, it feels a bit less like damaging. Take that. You just have to pay attention to the fact that it's kind of there. And
yeah,
um yeah, it just feels a bit less mean that way.
I I for me, I think that is a genius part of the design. absolute genius that you are. This is not a war game.
Yeah. Yeah.
It's got little plastic tanks and you put them on the board, but at no point is anybody attacking anybody else.
Yeah.
This represents the world in 2010 where there is a buildup of military forces. And what does that do? It It's a threat.
Yeah. And the and the fact that
the way that they've done it is it knocks points off the players who are invested in that region rather than getting points for you.
Yeah.
And it's a psychological thing. I'm losing points every round because of
the threat of enemy military presence in that area. So it's a very thematic rule that they've done within the the scope of a game design. And I think they I think that that part of the game is brilliant. Yeah.
So I'm glad you like that bit as well
because a lot of people when they see tanks on the board they think oh yeah roll move roll from dice blow the tanks up.
Not at all. It is literally military pressure in the various um parts of the game. And I I like this idea because the reason I did this is because it came up when I was demoing it at UK Games Expo that the Cuba card was on top. And I went, "Look, Cuba, the Americans can't become friends with Cuba."
And everybody went, "Oh, yeah, that makes sense." And I said, "But look,
China and Russia, if they become friends with Cuba, Cuba will allow them to build a military base there
because they [clears throat] don't like the Americans." So I did that as an example, and I encouraged the China player to do that just to show what had happened. Yeah.
And the fact that you didn't do anything about it. Was it the same reason as I didn't do anything about this?
It was just I had other priorities to do that. And that's I I was going to reflect on that like you were saying you're losing two points every round.
But you can make that up in other ways. You go, well, I'm going to engage over here. Score this. Scoring comes up. Score points from putting the cubes out.
Yeah.
If I'm doing this stuff instead, I'm kind of missing out. I lost I think 22 points over the course of the game for this.
And then yet
And yet
yeah that's Yeah.
So another thing that I like about the game and this has only become apparent to me now having properly played a four-player game is that the different strategies. So the game is asymmetric in that each player board is slightly different. It's got the perfect level of asymmetry for me. Um, Russia's got its own objective which you want to get tanks on the board. If you decide to play Russia and say, "I'm not going to bother playing tanks on the board." You can't. You've got to do that. China has to play to its strengths. You two have to play to your strengths. But within that, you have so many different options. the cards that you pick up. I didn't need to have gone for this, but I decided I'm going to try and get to here because I know it's really hard to do and I wanted my own personal objective was to try and get to the end because I've never seen it done.
Uh, and it was very close at the end, but the only reason I was able to do it is that I produced three of them myself and then I bought two of them in and that was the five I needed. Um,
I was going to do the same thing cuz I had this left over and some money, but then when
you do something else that I believe is nine points as well. Well,
yeah,
I'd have had to spend that. So, that would have only been nine.
Yeah.
Um, and therefore, the two were the same and this one impacted other players and meant I kept more money, which might matter for scoring the money. So,
Prosperity, you got yours to the max. You got yours to the max. We were both one short.
Almost there. Yeah.
But again, it was such a close game.
Yeah. And at one point I was like, "This game is not going to be close at all." There's going to be a massive,
it's really hard to judge,
massive shift in.
But I guess for you as well, long-term doing that when you were losing points from something else. It's like, I'm doing this. I know I'm getting points out of this.
And this one was great. So my my plan from the start was to try and get to the end. And at stage four, I get this card. And that meant that I could take those early risks and put on these leftmost spaces knowing that at some point later on hopefully if I can get this before I can move it out quickly. Yeah.
Because otherwise I I would have lost in in two areas.
So if that card is in the game then I think you're safer to to put it on there. But when you were all putting your things on the one pointers at the start I was like but there's four five. But that was the right thing to do here. That won you the game. Yeah.
Well, not just that, but that meant doesn't matter what anybody else does, [clears throat] you're getting the nine points for that.
Well, twice.
And the fact that in this game there's a change with you score points for cumulative cubes there. Yes. That's different from there's a lot of stuff with because this is effectively area control. It is.
But most games it's a thing of
doesn't matter how many you've got in there. You just do [clears throat] you have the most
whereas it's one point per cube. So
yeah, it can absolutely be worth it. And probably also means that I might have played this differently actually because I think maybe we forgot to say that until a while later or something.
Well, I forgotten.
Yeah. Yeah. Um because of the fact that I'm trying to sort of maintain control to avoid losing points. It's like, oh, okay. And then I will get points for cubes there. So maybe that's a better way to go about it.
Yeah. As it turned out, it didn't.
You were you were storming it halfway through the game,
but then your cube started getting removed in places.
Points lost. Yeah.
Yeah. So, let's talk about Hijgemony because this is the publishers's second game after Hijgemony. It was always going to be a hard act to follow. And people's thoughts on Hijgemony.
You've not played it?
No, I don't.
I did it once, but
it's a top game. It's a top 10 game for you. Right. So, Hijgemony, and I' I've said this many times before. Hgemony for me is one of the two best games that came out in 2024.
It's an absolute masterpiece of a game, and anybody who's played it and knows about it will see how much of a of a great game it is, but it's not even in my top 10 of that year because it's too much for me. I am somebody who doesn't get on well with high levels of asymmetry in games for various reasons. And although I can respect Hmony for being an amazing game, really, really amazing game, it's not a game that I would ever actually want to play again. I've played it four or five times, I think. And for me, the learning curve that I would have to go through to play it again and then I'd end up playing a game and find that one player was playing the wrong rules because they didn't. It relies on all of the people having the same experience and all knowing the rules of their game. And if you have that, it will be an amazing experience. I will very very rarely get myself into that situation.
This This is the game for me. I absolutely love this game. I think it's got the right mix of player interaction. I love the general card play. The card play mechanism is great. The the level of asymmetry in this game is perfect for me. We're all playing the same game. We're all playing with the same rules, but mine's slightly different here, and I've got a a slightly better trade card in my deck, and you've got a slightly better card. So that for me this is the good level of asymmetry that I want in a game. There are some people who would argue that this isn't an asymmetric game. But there are levels of asymmetry.
Hgemony and Root and Defense of Proon 3 are up there.
Yeah.
And then you've got this down here which is asymmetric but only a little bit. So yeah, for me
you know there's a lot of people who've said, "Oh, this game is not a patch on Hijgemony." And in some respects it isn't. This isn't Hijgemony. It's not as crunchy. It's not as complicated. It's not as detailed, but this is this is the game out of the two. I will probably never play Heny again, but this is a game that I would absolutely very much like to play more of. I just think it's great. Um, and this is the base game.
I haven't played the solo mode. There are bots, so if you have fewer than four players, there's bots which randomly add cubes to the board. And you can play the solo game with three bots if you want to. Uh there's also an expansion for this which I've heard mixed things about because it has global events which are all based on real things that happened. But you might have oh there's a trade war between China and America so they can't trade for a round
and then you might have been playing
which is like oh wait so those are realistic events but they can swing the game a little bit in one way or the other. Um I' I've not looked at them. I'm just going off what other people have said. Anything else anybody wants to talk about about the game? You've played Hijgemony and it's a top 10 game.
Yeah.
Give us your comparisons of this against Hijgemony then.
Um, so I'm the opposite to you in that I prefer that Hijgemony is more asymmetric because for me the beauty of that game is how all of them interact with each other. But I do agree with you that there's a bigger barrier to entry in that one in that I think probably the main reason it was able to grow for me to that level is I got to play it quite a lot in succession which meant I understood how they work together. If you know you know playing hegemony once a year and you come back to it again you're like right what what's going on again. Yeah.
So that is a flaw as it were and
a feature. Yeah, it well it's one of those things that it is and it isn't a flaw. You know, it's it's great that it has the depth to it that you can have that, but it is always going to be
a barrier for some people, which is a shame.
Yeah.
Um,
this one,
I have to say I felt more positively on a second play of this. Yeah.
I mean, I some stuff has presumably changed since like two years ago that I played this UKG. Um it doesn't it doesn't feel as much just like it's just another euro as I it's not
it's it's still quite euroy
um
and you know it's it's again because I'm comparing it to Germany it's always going to fall down a little bit
but it's always going to get compared to it it visually looks like it it's from the same designers it's from the same public so it is going to get compared
but it's still a good game on its own definitely say So, and would like to play it more having played it.
I just I love the theme. Like I think one of the things that puts me off hijgemony is that the theme is a turn off.
Okay. Interesting.
For me, whereas this being like I know it's not
ancient history, but like Yeah. and the history kind of geog geopolitical
thing but taking it a bit more away from just being about
sort of classical things that can get a bit depressing.
Yeah, exactly. But the the way that all of like the countries work together in the regions and things like that and effects is of like the the kind of global politics more than again a military even though part of it is that is is really interesting and it is for me I love asymmetry in games. This is about the right level
because for something I won't play a lot. Yeah,
Paul mentioned root.
Um, I feel like Germany about that that it's not that it's a bad thing, it's just too far when you don't play it enough because like I'm not only learning what I need to do, I'm learning what everyone else is doing and how that affects or how I need to react to that. And
I was just very fortunate that I went to conventions where I was in that spot of going to a lot when it was, you know, the darling place. It's like, okay, I just keep getting games of this, meaning it's going in
and it's getting better and better.
Yeah. Then it's going to it's not going to have that same.
So, what's interesting about the setting for Hijgemony is it's not based on a real place.
It's all realistic socioeconomic whatever,
but it's not it models society, but it's a it's a it's a made up place.
Yeah.
This is real.
Yes. Yeah.
And if you read the research book, which I was just looking for, and I've I've put it on my shelf somewhere. Um, but this is set in 2010. And one thing that I have a lot of respect for with games designers is when they put into the effort to make things right.
Yeah.
Yeah.
And I'm going to mention Uvo Rosenberg games at this point. People might think, why is he talking about U Rosenberg? Um, but when you look at Feast for Odin and and we've recently been playing the Danes and you look at the extra book that comes with the game that people don't read and it tells you all about the Vikings and where they went and why they liked to eat green beans and all of and there's all of this historical stuff and then you look at the game and you're like, "Oh, that's why that's there." And just to give you an idea, I took over a place called Rusk Gilda in in the Danes, which isn't out yet, but I've done a playthrough video of it. And um I had to put pieces on a particular part of the board, and then I had to place a ship there, but I didn't get any points for it. And I'm like, what is this? And then I went on to Wikipedia afterwards, and the Vikings took control of it. And then what they did is they sunk ships in the harbor. They deliberately sunk a whole load of ships so nobody else could get in.
And that's represented in the game. Bringing it back to this, every single one of these countries, how much they are valued at, what they import, what they export. Yeah. It's all accurate as of 2010.
Yeah.
And the stuff you're saying about the bases that can be built there,
the bases that can be built allowed. I I I didn't realize that I'd done this until the end of the game when I looked at them all and it's like I've literally gone in the EU or you could do it with America into the Emirates, built the military bases in the Middle East as that is. And
yeah,
and once you've played this game
once, maybe twice, you next time you'll be looking to improve relations. You won't just be you'll be looking and you'll be going, "Oh, wait a minute. So I was I was trying to take ones where I could well I took Mexico so you didn't get the second Mexico card but also I could export two mobile phones to Mexico. So I had this grand plan of I'd just produce loads and loads of mobile phones and when I exported them I'd export one two three four five six I'd export like eight.
Yeah.
And it turns out I never had that many
and I needed them for this.
Yeah. But I was struggling because I could do three exports and I only ever really did two because I didn't have stuff. Now, what I should have done is I should have been looking at other cards and going, "Oh, wait a minute. They want they want wheat. I've got an excess of wheat." And things like that. So, you actually look at there's a lot of information on the cards. Yeah.
And and I I like that bit. Um, one of the issues that this game might have with certain people, and I haven't heard this of an issue, but it was something that I was concerned about when I was demoing this at UK Games Expo, is it's a little bit too close to what's going on.
Yeah.
And the fact that we're having to buy energy from Russia because it's cheap and it's got lots of it. And then Russia uses that money and builds tanks
and we're like h so if you are somebody who is is going to feel a bit uncomfortable by the nature of what is happening in this game because of what is now happening in the world um then this might not be the game for you.
But I haven't come across anybody who h that has been a problem. I just know that, you know, when when Russia says, "Oh, yeah, and I'm gonna take Barus and I'm gonna build a military base in Barus and and I'm gonna put some tanks here." And you think, "Oh, yeah, we we know where this is going."
But the fact that all of the superpowers are having to buy energy from Russia.
Yeah.
And you don't realize that, but this is the world. This this is how it was and to some extent still is.
Yeah.
Um
and it's just fascinating. And I was there I browsed through this extra source book which was all written by you know professors and scientists and everything else. And this whole game was actually based on um one of the designers wrote a thesis
about the world and that was the basis for this game.
Um and that thesis is published at the back of it. So yeah I I yeah I really like the game.
The the thing that there's variability in these quite
with the expansion we Okay. Right. So if you had the expansion then that could be a bit like I think that in multiple plays but I got that card and that one was really good so I'll do that and you just end up doing the same
if you felt that route worked for you of doing the same thing.
You could randomize them to to mix that up. Yeah. And I think there's a few more cards for that deck as well. I think can't quite can't quite remember
on your on your comment about that sort of like the risk of it being a bit too real. Mh.
I feel like there's a little bit of probably going to be self- selection though. I think the people who are going to be interested in this game are probably like, "Oh, no, that's just interesting." Like there might be a pressing aspect of it, but
it's a kind of understanding that yeah,
the world is like that. It has these
many many gears all working together and
and the fact that the Middle East North Africa is worth more points, you know, it's it's most valuable area. So,
yeah.
Yeah,
I think that's it. I don't think we've got anything uh more to say on it. So, we'll we'll wrap up this video. Thank you very much to everybody who has been watching live. So, for those people who are still with us, I really really appreciate all of the comments in the chat. There are some people like me who are content creators, who do YouTube videos, who don't really appreciate people pointing out mistakes that they've made. Uh I do. I I really do. So, I have to say a big thank you to those people in the chat because your comments of Mark forget to get a point. Chris forgot to do
that has helped us play this game more accurately. There's nothing worse than playing a 4-hour game and getting to the end of it and going, "Oh, wait a minute. I forgot to do this the entire game." So, yes, thank you very much to everybody who has joined us in the chat. Um, this video and the one that I did earlier on today, uh, these have not been sponsored playthroughs. This is effectively a day off work for me. Not been paid for any of this. So, thank you very much to all of my Patreon supporters for funding the channel and helping make these playthroughs possible. If you like the content that I create and you want to support me, patreon.com/gaming rules. Other than that, we will wrap things up. I will say thank you very much, E3. I hope you have a shorter journey home than it took you to get here. Uh, but I hope it was worth it. So, yes, thank you very much. Cheers everybody. Good night. Bye-bye.