Episode 135: Gaia Project, Topiary, Codenames Disney, Passport to Culture
Transcript
hey this is Marty if you've been listening to this show for a while you know that one of Tony's favorite words is meat which is why in this episode we're introducing the neat sound effect which sounds like this so every time he says Nate you'll hear this sound and let's see how many times Tony says neat over the course of an episode and we'll reveal the results at the end now on with the show rolling dice and taking names is sponsored by the broken token creator of high-quality gaming accessories and storage solutions visit them online at the broken token calm hey y'all it's time for another episode of rolling dice and taking names today the guys give you the results of their year-end survey there's a scurry report with mark and Nate where they reviewed the Gaea project and Wayman MRSA must be wrong here wait and there is a 5-minute initiative with me where we talked about topiary well we look forward to hearing that mari and welcome to a new year of rolling dice and taking names 2018 is upon us and this is episode number 135 the answer to our life I'm Tony and this is Marty and we are ready to start a brand new year I am in my plush new studio all excited trying to find everything Marty as you had to wait 20 minutes is Omar you'll get this Marty got found these headphones I got to set this up so I appreciate you being patient with me yeah it was like I'm
ready to go I'll look for my headphones oh all right come back later oh did I leave my power cable over there for my recorder no all right guy could get batteries then it comes back off our power cable okay it's a work in progress man we're working on we're trying to make it happen here but more importantly give me a fun fact about the Backstreet Boys Backstreet Boys suck so how was your holidays no come on now one of the comments from our awesome survey well somebody says I need to get more relative I need to get out of the 70s and 80s out of music do they not realize that's what we listened to growing up and you came right with a Backstreet Boys song ack-ack Street Boys okay hold on so the thing they were like mid-90s they were the boyband rights when the board the in sinks the you know those guys what was the boys to men I was just totally out of pop music at that point and in fact when you sent this song I had no clue what it was I wouldn't listen to it I still didn't know it and I got no fax for ya I told you my fact they suck well I won't sit back here with on the couch and enjoy the microphone right in the studio chair and you're just leaving back and enjoying life and if you'll note in the new recording studios the color of the furniture is green so guess what we have the green room okay I will say this I'll give correct people course
I've already turned this all because I said something bad about the Backstreet Boys look just because I wasn't a big boy band doesn't mean those guys didn't have talent oh yeah those guys could sing they were somewhat manufactured I did read the story behind where a few of those guys were in a band together and then a producer wanted to create a band and he had hundreds of people of audition he picked up one of the guys from that band and over the course of the audition he actually brought in the other band members that he was already singing with so they were already together but it was somewhat manufactured they can't sing and I have to give credit where credit is due with NSYNC Justin Timberlake is a pretty freaking talent to do yeah yeah dance the guy can sing and I am honestly looking forward to this year's Super Bowl halftime where he's gonna be performing again hopefully without a wardrobe malfunction this time that will probably be to them and most people who know probably don't know what happened with Janet Jackson in the wardrobe I'm sure they do and the whole reason for the three second or five second delay on live TV now because of that because that wasn't it the reason why I picked this song was I spent Oh a good 40 minutes trying to find a song about gaya house pulling up some of the weirdest sounding stuff I'm like I had no clue what you mean guy a project well that's the game we're going to talk about well guy a project I saw again you couldn't come up with any sci-fi theme songs to ground control to
Major Tom we've used Rocket Man done we did Rocket Man I'm pretty sure cuz well I know we've we do science fiction if we have it well let's we can we use that one later but that was like okay fine well let's go with the survey and this song talks about you know the answers to our life and that's what the survey provided answers to our life okay so this relates to the survey that our annual survey that we're gonna be talking about later in the show we're going to go over our answers and the survey which was also the entry to a two hundred dollar gift card to funding in games the winner has been contacted and we can't wait to see what they do with it I know hopefully they'll pose some awesome pictures maybe they'll spins and share some love down here maybe you know $10 I could use another few IKEA shells so you got all your games in have you unboxed them yet not all of them you still have a box of mine the special box and I forgot to give you that the other night yes you do you have a place do you have a place for them now well okay so first off you've got the nice IKEA it's not the PAC system right offer you what you got is that the calyx yeah and for those of you who don't have an IKEA basically IKEA has common words for all of their cabinetry and you can say oh I got the packs and everybody knows exactly what you're talking about well I've got the I call it the AL got al G ot he reminds me of the Rubbermaid hanging shell system you know I'm talking about their remain hanging [ __ ] yes yes the wire mesh shelves it you know when you put it when you put a
bottle on it tips over so when I'm into my first house I remember when they told me they said just so you know all your I'm sorry this is funny all your closets have ventilated shelving and I thought wow that sounds really cool vintage shelving is just those wire shells I see how it is why our shells man that's it some reason 50 lated shelving it's like ooh my closet has like air conditioning and stuff's like no we just put in these cheap wire shelves instead of the real nice ones but almost like okay so I've got to come up with some Shelley so about this Rubbermaid stuff and I was like okay I'm gonna have to do this this and this I'm gonna have to hang these vertical shelves that do this header bar gotta put up all these shells they come in these various sizes I found the location for it in now everything is going to go well and I started thinking about now I discovered that the alga system works about the same at half the cost okay and so I'm hanging these shells and everything I mean it looks decent but I got so depressed last night Marty what's that a total of twelve normal moving boxes of board games and I know then everybody's like oh my god twelve old they're not that big they're medium sized moving boxes and I'm putting them on the shelf so I'm like I got a ton of space here and then suddenly I'm like wait a minute I'm running out of space and I still got four boxes left to go not including the one that's got mechs vs. minion at your house which is a beast but I got a shell for that they come with this shelf that
I think is over 23 inches deep so it's gonna work great what works great for my Star Trek's Starfleet captain's ascendancy mechs vs. minion Ticket to Ride 10th anniversary all those will fit on that shell something all this and I'm like and honestly don't worry about it we'll get more shelves I'm go really more ship that means I can get more games she's like no that's not what that means I'm my Oh fine but sorry but I've almost got them all unpacked but then I really got panicky really panicky uh-oh why I couldn't find a box that had a very special game in it Oh Lord are you gonna say strike we've been doing this podcast way too long you know in the moment are you saying that it's like I'm running through a whole list of games and we mean strike strike yeah I couldn't find that box in that well it also has Star Trek is saying the scene and I'm like oh crap where is that and always also got striking it's also got my broken token Carcassonne organizer who I haven't put together yet I'm like oh man where is that box I couldn't find it I was freaking out just because you know you you catalogue everything it's amazing I bet I could take games off your shelf and you knew exactly which one they were but I was like where is it where's and I finally found it last night around 1:00 a.m. so oh good yeah how'd you found I know I know because it wouldn't I would not be complete without strike in fact there was a couple references to strike in our
survey comments somebody put like gladiators rule or something like that and somebody said something like even though you may like Tupperware I still like you guys something like that hey since you got room on the shelves then maybe I need to give you the game that cge just sent me out of the blue they sent us a copy of the Excel version of code names did you see a picture I posted this on Twitter by any chance the exit extra-large no I missed that this box is about two feet tall by one foot wide and it contains every code names in it has contains pictures code names duet code names and the cards the work cards are a little bit bigger than postcard size do they just make that special for us knowing that the fonts might be challenging to us are you saying you did see my tweet I have not been on Twitter you know me I know but what's so funny my tweet was hey agnostic did did he respond back no he did not I may have ticked him off you didn't take ignite we get on it nah see in portal games because we talk about how the font is so small on some of his cards so it's a running joke we have and then he brought us a magnifying glass to to play one year at their origins and stuff so it's always been kind of a running joke so here it comes this huge neighbor codenames where the words on the cards about three inches four inches long by like a inch and a half high you can't miss them so I had to put a little dig in there to
agnostic he didn't respond so we may have lost a sponsor well wait a minute he recently reposted me reading crazy cards with a magnifying glass at origins he did do that yes he did out of the blue I suddenly show up on his Twitter and I'm like what is this stuff but that's okay even now I'm having to turn on more lights to read I'm embracing it the eyes are not the same hey speaking of code names you said you played marvel I did play marvel over Thanksgiving okay well I got codenames Disney nice is it picture in words like marvellous yes it is you're not kidding if Marvel or Disney it can be hard yes which which side the pictures of the words we played picture side that is hard like you did where you suggested a word had that had nothing to do with the Marvel content you just suggested a word that could link everything based on a commonality and I was telling people that when we were playing code names Disney I said don't think of it like Disney eight you've got to think beyond that and that's hard to do mm-hmm so my daughter was playing along and unfortunately I can definitely tell she's my daughter because she and I think a lot alike and we won easily but she looked at it I didn't she goes Jerry three and I gave Jerry three Jerry three and and the person who's playing with me because I don't understand I'm going Jerry three G and I look down there's a
mouse nice yeah I go okay so and I was forget the mouse from Dumbo that was that Mouse okay yes and then I'm looking and then there's another Mouse on a card it's in the one of the back pictures boom there's another Mouse and then I forget another thing there sure enough there was another representation of a mouse I mean why didn't she say mouse because there was something that wouldn't that would lead me to the bad word and she probably couldn't sort of like Mickey because Mickey was probably on a card somewhere or something like that or that's a really good clue I would immediately go into Jerry Seinfeld and I've been looking for like soup and oh yeah by the way by the way reference to that on the last episode of it gosh I made a reference where I said love the Drake somebody and our guild got it love the Drake is from an episode of Seinfeld so thank you for that person in the guild who you got that that's where that reference comes from and I think this would cost me to get Rick Rolled call somebody want me to go look at it I was going looking at clicked on it yeah Scott you got me yeah okay okay I gotta make a confession I know we haven't got to the survey part yet but on our survey we had a place where you could leave a comment and I just copied the comments over to another spreadsheet so I could read through them real quick there was a link to a YouTube I went crap we just got spammed I thought it was like a robot spam spamming an ad for something I clicked on it I got rickrolled oh nice they were
waiting on me yeah they were but they got me instead so whoever that was congratulations you got me honestly thought it was gonna be like a spam bot you know where they'll send you a link for some sort of advertisement video or something but no it was just a well-intentioned rickroll that don't work so on our vacations you do anything fun I started a pandemic legacy season two baby I gotta find some players don't want your family play there's only two of us what you could play with - can I can i play with you you can't I don't see why not so so we got to play before we played the the first game this isn't giving anything away this is the base rule occurred - right when you open the box what I love about this game toy is this game takes place like 70 years in the future after legacy season one mm-hmm you know in regular pandemic the cubes are diseases you're trying to get rid of here the beginning dynamic is its supply cubes you're trying to put on the board so you can never let a place run out of cubes again that's not giving anything away that is like right out of the box that's what you do first game even for your set up games I'm not giving any secrets but I think it was a really cool idea that the flip that on its ear where you got to get supply cubes and actually put them into areas and there are areas when you flip over the infection deck instead of placing cubes it's actually pulling cubes off the board you know I might have seen this somewhere this type of I might have was in the beta and whose name is they on the rulebook did you
highlight that name is your name in the rulebook yes I'm a tester patrick hillier tweeted it out and said here are some awesome marguerite is on there and I forget who else but get the rulebook you'll see my name oh dude that's great I remember that being posted but I totally forgot to look for that in the rule book I guess I guess the NDA is gone I don't have to worry about the NDA anymore we got won't be arrested but now you can't give away these secrets that you may know either so you still got to keep it on the down-low but anyway we're looking to afford to play through it again we did lose our first game and everybody said how did you lose your first game because it was so easy well somehow we lost or just leave me alone so we're going to kind of progressively go through this we're playing with my older son who's you know back from college so we can only play when he's here so we did get that I kicked off and that was fun of course the boys got tons of Games Workshop stuff for Christmas your basement was littered with that stuff you saw it didn't you it was insane they got a bunch of age of sigmar stuff which is what they're into and they've been assembling and painting all week long and I got to give him credit number one those GW models look great and they're doing an incredible job painting so that's what they've been doing most the time and I just been down there kind of watching them I was painting up some of the shaped spire models that I got the the Sepik regard the skeletons when that and enjoying yet that end I'm glad to say don't shake your head because I think you may have just ordered the base set of shade spire
or getting ready - I'm not gonna order to base it I'm gonna order mark rum kale from the scurry report the base set and I may order the skeleton skull why do I need the base what explain okay explain to me you have the base why do I need the base unless you just want the board and those extra cards if you just want to just monkey around by a faction that you won't get this cave and you're gonna be fine you theoretically don't need you have to borrow somebody's dice you may want to buy a set of dice that they sell individually what is special they got seven sides they are Li not six no do they have special markings on they're not regular d6 is damn special icons don't me they're your icons come on all I gotta do is darken out some of the circles or connect the dots it can make the special you couldn't take some of those strike dice and do it if you want yeah I would I will when I get my Marti aters blue peg ping peg thank you I still haven't gotten my order in thank you did you know I got mine Rodney gave them to me at the house No I've got a bag of the stripe dice with my with my face on it as the the X so you see my face you die I know the feeling every other week a joke speaking of fog of love worse 2018 thank you starting up early no I mean I know we've already talked about on the past show did you think about it a little bit more or idea cuz after we reviewed it some people were making comments stuff to us and I did think
about are you are you going somewhere with this in particular not really had planned on going anywhere around I was just kind of curious if you thought about it it's like speaking of fall your love what do you think about oh nothing I just you know fall off yeah you know if you thought about it oh I've seen you or since uh since you got but I did get my um Lord of the Rings Rodney's putting out a video for Fargo love em I gotta say it say it did he play with himself I'm sorry guys
that tickled me right there so what are you saying about Lord of the Rings I'm still waiting on my book but I did get the PDF so I'm ready to do the one shot oh you did yeah okay so here's what I want to do I want to get you myself and whoever else wants to play can we just sit down and go through a character creation session and walk through that yeah well definitely because then then we kind of coordinate who wants to do what kind of character and see how that works and if we can kind of learn the base rules and then actually play the game I'm excited I'm excited yeah I figured that'll be part of our big birthday party oh that's a good idea yeah you and I could combine our birthdays this weekend this weekend this year and double do something like that yeah end of January we'll get that happening we'll make it go from there so I did play another game yeah what's that passport to culture I don't I know that what is it else you wouldn't know this okay think of it like a Trivial Pursuit type game where you're learning cultures of the world okay sure who makes it I don't know I just put you on the spot that means he's gonna go to BoardGameGeek and have to do so I was happy that I remembered while Google spins and tries to figure itself out basically you were moving around trying to fill up your passport with stamps from the various countries but unlike Trivial Pursuit where you are sitting there having to get your answer right to get one everybody's trying to guess the right answers I'll be honest it's a basic trivia game but some of the facts were kind of neat and so for instance you get three
choices a B or C so it's a multiple guessed type game which I appreciate a whole lot you know I don't have to come up with the answer off the top of my head but so for instance which continent has the most countries that speak Portuguese which continent which continent okay a South America B Europe C Africa and then you guess what it is well I would guess the obvious of Europe so I'm wrong what is it it's Africa really yeah who speaks Portuguese in Africa there were five countries to speak it I don't remember that all of the ones but that's the neat thing you flip it over and it gives you this flavor text it taught me stuff and that's scary why is that scary that's good the old dog can be taught new tricks I know I know I can but its passport to culture and we played it a couple times and we played with people a gentleman friends of ours who are in the bowling league with with us and they've he's lived in the Philippines he's lived in South America he's lived in Europe his wife and him can speak four languages there they have the culture thing down they killed me and Donna it was hilarious but it was it was kind of fun too to do that type of game just sit back and learn I was I was pleasantly surprised who makes it now would you please go on while I continue to look this up you gotta remember I gotta you oh my gosh what do you mean you got a new internets was like the old internet
just go over there and you do a search on BoardGameGeek you're you're hogging the bandwidth your face is hugging the family anything else you do this Christmas before we move on to whatever else we got planned for the show we're going to go under those survey results we are excited to have we got to have our first play of Gaia project from z-man games which is the I'm not spiritual successor but a wreath themed of Terra Mystica which is one of my favorite games of all time and we're going to do a scurry report on that coming up and in our next segment I am gonna get serious with a topic from an interview I read with Christian Petersen earlier this week from asthma day north HNH global howard levine thank you so it's as published by HNH global and the designers Howard Levine that is correct HNH two to six players well there you go from 2003 Wow that's an oldie but a goodie hey you know what how did how would you compare it to like um America actually I've tried to pull it out but I hadn't emptied that box and I hadn't found it yet it was it was America was was strike so how would I come here it I like America better okay I really and not just because there's only all in America I just like the style of America of the multiple guessing and close is good and then we played wits & wagers and so you know it was it was a trivia kind of night what by the way wits &
wagers with four people yeah not not good I enjoy that how much fun it is a lot more fun with more people especially if you got that new version which is like the Vegas version which is really cool and I do but this was the first time they were playing it so I kept it to the old version okay so yeah dude all the extra bedding and all that junk oh yeah exactly oh oh and also well after we got played guy a project I had to leave and y'all were playing and I know we're not gonna talk a lot about cuz you want me to get to play in but heaven and ale yes by a code Lord is who's on the spot well I respect is being published by Plan B games and it's it's from a grits peel I think that's it hey girl yeah it's the same people that did a great western trail huh I forgot yeah I forgot to take that off your shelf so yeah we got to play that we're gonna cover that in our next episode Tony because I want to play that again I really want you to sit down and play it this is a a game that everybody we played once and we go okay it's one of those games where you play it the first time and you go what wait a minute I I really don't know what the strategy should be and when you get to the end you kind of talk okay maybe I should do it this way the next time and I've heard like the multi next time multiple times you play it kind of clicks so I do want to get that table again so we're gonna be talking about that next episode but another game that we played right after you left was a game I was really excited about from FFG is called civilization new dawn now if
you'll remember FFG released a full big 4x board game of civilization back around 2010 this is a more streamlined version of the Civilization game takes about 90 minutes to play you got a map out there you've got some areas or a little cities that you haven't you try to spread out and collect resources and tray with people and you fight but the really cool thing about this was the mechanic of how of your actions selection in front of you you have a tableau with five slots on it okay and everybody has the same starts with the same sort of cards each one's a different tech like one is culture like one's military one is technology etc and what you do is they're lined up one through five and when on your turn you take one of those and take the action of the card the higher number slot that you picked it does more say for example if your military was in slot five when you do combat you get like a bonus of +5 okay or it may say that I'm gonna send out a caravan to trade with somebody and the higher slot means you can cover more different types of terrain like the number one slot you can only go through the plains but if you need to go over mountains you need to get your car to the number five slot after you take that action it slides down to the number one slot and every card slides up by one to the right so it goes up and one and that's the whole mechanic of the game and that was a really cool of man I really do this action right now but it's only a slot three I really need to get a slot for first and and then you can
upgrade those so all those start out at tech level one one of the things on one of your cards is you can upgrade your your cards and they go from each skill can go from one to four and so like if I was to get a level 2 card I go through my deck and I replace one of my level ones was level two well that's a little bit better so over the course of the game you're upgrading your cards and the whole goal of the game is guess what Tony I'm hoping based on that explanation is to get the most victory points victory points whatsoever all of us were going what a time for Tony believe we finally played a game they had no victory points at the beginning of the game there's three objective cards that are put out each card has two different objectives you have to get one of each of those objectives on the three cards the first person to do it wins the game so it may be you need to build two military wonders or you need to get all your cities built alright so there's different things to come out there and over the course of game you're trying to get a wonder from each of the cards done first person do it wins the game no points whatsoever alright so I'm gonna ask you I understand streamline yada-yada-yada cards all that good stuff compared to Mare Nostrum which had no victory points oh dude I know Maureen ah sorry not from there not from me okay it's one of the two right so one of us got it right that game is very special to me it's not nearly as good as that okay no no it's not nearly as good in fact this game I had a good time playing I don't like the combat in this game I
really don't like it a lot can't say at all I don't think it's that great kind of boring basically you have you have a modifier to your die based on what card you play you roll a die the defense rolls a die whoever hires wins hmm there wasn't a lot of military stuff going on okay there should have been if we play it more times there might because you could take over people's cities and take over their wonders but no dude if I was given the option between this and Mario Ostrom it'd be Martin Austin me all day long but but Martin Ostrom is like twice as long as it's okay so that thing that the benefit is hey you get like a little civvy type game in 90 minutes okay interesting was it neat it was neat it was okay I was that anxious to play again and it's funny I've been reading some reviews of other people and it's kind of all over the place some people like oh this is a nice little Yuri type Civ game and other people I read a review before we got on who are big sieve time video gamers couldn't stand it at all didn't like it at all it's like why did you even call this a sieve game this is nothing like the video game and they said if you want to play a good Civ game go play the 2010 version I'm like yeah but you were told this game it's like a streamlined version of CID that plays in a lot shorter time so you can't expect the complexity another full Civ game which could take five to six hours to play they say this is what it is and yet you're getting dinging them for not being that okay not being this doesn't make any sense to me I got a nail pop over there in that ceiling call your construction people no configure 30 day
walkthrough yeah like 30 days and go find out your nail polish my xbox not working squirrel and it comes on and it just doesn't show a picture Xbox 360 yeah it's the one that you and I bought a long time ago probably cost us like 10 years old dude I don't want to upgrade oh you should have upgraded over Christmas like we did they had those suckers on sale from 189 while the new Xbox one really yeah I missed actually there's one people like really bored right now Walmart has a special on sale right now for $1.99 you get that one s and a game okay $1.99 Walmart's open 24 hours window is a special go off I wonder if it's at midnight uh if not you can go order online and just pick it up there sometime I like the Xbox is kind of what we use now for Hulu and Amazon and Netflix which you cut the cable I cut my cable I am so excited about this everybody for years I have been wanting to cut cable and I finally did it over the holidays it was such a liberating feeling going to the cable company turning in my DVR to cable converters and said take this off my bill and what I did is I knocked my bill down a hundred bucks and replaced it with a $35 per month a subscription to DIRECTV now I get all the channels I have for $65 lest that means I go buy a new game each month so what are you doing for a local are you an antenna no locals built-in DirecTV now the Charlotte market has the local channels and the DirecTV now feed Oh interesting ok see I need to talk to you because the
community I moved in took a 10-year contract that comes up in 2019 with u-verse so we're going to have to start renegotiating that garbage because that right there sounds like a winner to me yeah the guy that sets up my AT&T u-verse on my TV and I'm you know I'm looking at it and I'm like there's something wrong here he goes no sir that's the correct picture and I go no it's not it's only 3/4 of the screen he goes yes sir that's that's how standard-definition works oh my god standard def I'm like well where's high def he says you didn't order high def that's $10 a month more I'm like in today's time you're charging for high def that's horrible dude I'll tell me about it yeah I will so we'll see how this fiber optic works and all that Anwar recording so if you hear any pauses is because of there's delays as I'm talking with Marty we're doing a focus because otherwise there were delays right there I was doing it on purpose you are like talking and then freezing it's like wait even I think I may have lost you so that was that pretty good hey you know what Tony we got a lot to cover this year we got the survey results we got Gaia project I'm gonna do a special 5-minute initiative with Vanessa we're gonna talk about the new game topiary from really gang games but next I do want to talk about this topic haven't you do with asthma day north and they're there Matt policy and a
comparison they had it to that something both you and I are very familiar with Tony remember in 2016 when asthma de North announced they're gonna have this new map the minimum advertised price where basically they're going to not allow online retailers to discount their products as much yeah I remember that 2016 isn't that where Chaz Marlon from paradise paradise had his literal cow when they announced all this of all the media people Chaz I think was the one most bothered by this whole map thing because asthma nade North did it Games Workshop kind of already has something like that place Seamon has announced they're doing it so don't II want yours mine favorite sites for getting news and everything is I see v2 and last year they did an interview with Christian Peterson and Steve Horvath from asthma de North and so they were asking them hey you know since you've implemented these changes and everything with the you know using just one distributor such as Alliance and the map and everything how's it going so they go into this discussion of how it's going how it was accepted and there's one quote here that I want to read Tommy that really kind of bothered me and that's what I want to kind of dig into so as he was answering this question Christian Peterson said and I quote I spent some time talking to people that compared the current hobby games market conditions to these sports cards
business several years ago sports cards used to be a thriving business you had had these shops selling cards trading cards and they would become a hub for a local community of collectors that would talk together open packs in the store talk sports with the store owner trade cards to complete collections meet new friends etc now Tony I can only assume he said several years ago but don't you think he's probably referring to the late and early 90s when the baseball card market was just exploding with a bunch of new people in it I can only assume this what he's talking about yes I was not there with him to dig into it but yeah I would agree with you yes he talked about you know there's all of stores you know collectors and stuff you don't see baseball card stores anymore we used to have them all over Charlotte yes we did and they're not there anymore that's right in the reason why I want to talk about this is because he goes on to say and I quote then the market entered the era of deep discounted case and box sales direct to consumers encouraged by these sports card publishers who saw resulting spikes and volume of course this practice decimated all the local shops in these sports cards business in the first few years for obvious reasons sport car collectors love getting these really cheap cases of cards but over time as the local stores and their communities were wiped out collectors didn't have a place to meet and trade with or talk to or share the hobby with and that made the Hobby less fun the result was it really hurt the
sport car community which has never recovered from this and then Steve Horvath says and their collections were devalued let me just say this Marty it from that whole comment that he just said that's bull don't use a peep now I know you have to beep it I did this let me mark at the 45 minutes 58 seconds more than a beep yeah here's the thing but in the in the 70s I was collecting baseball cards to the point where his whole premise is on this deep discount sir I'm sorry in the 70s 1978 was my first collection you could go and mail order from distributors cases as the general public you could do that mm-hmm yeah you didn't have it as advantage to you of seeing it on the internet as what much and as quickly and go and have a selection but you could that's how we ordered our sets for tops so once again throwing the flag and here's the thing I'm not talking about the map the whole purpose is this discussion is not to complain about the map and they're sitting the prices they can do what they want to do they said the prices however they want that the market will decide my problem with this is whoever he talked to I don't think fed the right information what he's trying to say is because you could get cheap cards from online that took away businesses from put took away business
from the local stores and they dried up that's not what happened and the fact Tony I did some research I want to make sure that had my facts right and I went through several websites looking at what caused the crash of the sports card market in the early 90s there's a as an author of a book called mint condition which talks about the crash of the baseball card market the question was asked to him why did the baseball card bubble burst he said and I quote I talked to an executive at FLIR who said that the downfall of the hobby was greed it was greed on the part of the card makers because they rolled out so much product that had diluted the power of the cards and killed the Golden Goose it was the greed on the part of the baseball Union because they sold a lot of rights and made a lot of royalties on those rights until they had too many card makers then you had greed on the part of the dealers surly gods who didn't care to talk to the nine-year-olds who came into their shops there were this there to sell cards and finally collectors were swallowing up everything thinking was gonna turn to gold everyone got their just desert in the end and the whole industry crashed what he's saying is the whole purpose of the crash was simple supply and demand there was a demand for cards manufacturers weigh ever produced cards to where everybody had 10 of every single card and the and the market fell out online discounted products was not one of the main reasons for local stores closing shop no and I mean I remember
one of our stores that we went to this old comic books and baseball cards I remember when he closed his store I looked and said so what is it is it the fact that people are you know there's just so much is it grating he said that has something to do with it he says but what's hurting me is eBay and people being able to go out and buy the singles and compete against me for the singles and it wasn't so much that he was being hurt by the mass retailers the Sam's and whatever selling him that wasn't it he was trying he bet he put hit all of his money on the fact that he was trying to capture that rare chase that gold cart and try to make his profit on that and then when eBay came in there that's what hurt him it was the fact I could go online in order from Potomac distribution and get a whole bunch of baseball cards that wasn't it and so what I think Christian Peterson was trying to say we don't want the same thing to happen in the board game industry that happened in a sports card industry and to me Tony I think you probably you're not saying the same thing it's apples and oranges yeah the local store did not dry up because I like you said I could go get it cheap online it dried up because baseball cards ever produced dropping the value and then there's and then everybody tried to sell the card and they won't worth anything hit you and I would buy Beckett which was the baseball card price got every month you and I was like oh we're gonna pay for a college with these cards and we've mentioned that on here before that just fell through so
this comparison to saying Fantasy Flight saying oh guess what we need to take away some of the discount of the online stores because we want to drive people to the local game stores I'm sorry that's not a comparison between the two the discount of games is not gonna keep people from going to the game stores the game stores are still places where people want to go to have tournaments to play with each other and have a community and also board games aren't collectible baseball cards were all about collectability it's two different types of hobbies one was an investment the other is just I want to board game to go play with somebody when I got into baseball cards Here I am playing baseball as a kid it was neat to have a card with the picture of the player because I didn't get to see all these players I got to see a picture of Roger Maris a tour of Harmon Killebrew those were what baseball cards were it was a way to relate to your heroes back then and then like you said the great kicked in in the 90s the air cards the jersey cards the the grading of the cards all of that stuff and then 20 makers of it the whole purpose of my thing was you want to implement a map that is a Oh doing you you want you you want to cut the discount that's fine but I think using the example of the sports card crash and the 90s as to what could happen here I personally I think it's off base it's just because Tony and I went
through that we saw exactly what happens with our collection we saw exactly it talked about every card maker jumping in making three four five sets every year it used to be one company making cards then it was - then it was three then it was four that each one of those would release multiple sets in a year too much glut of product drove down the price dried up all the local stores crash I don't believe the same thing what happened with the board in just a board game industry I just don't think it's relatable at all I see he's won't to drive people to the stores and the purpose of that is say if you can't get a big a discount on the line you'll go to the stores and buy it there but I don't think you can assume that crash the same sort of crash would happen because to me it's just totally different types of the hobbies organize play gets people to the stores you mentioned the magic thing and how you know people go to the stores to play magic booster dress I mean there's a prime example oh yeah magic okay that's a collectible card game I can go online and buy booster boxes all day long discounted is that killing the stores no because the stores is where you got to go to play this stuff and it's still the store so you can buy card singles you could buy singles online magic is what causes minigame stores to thrive but I can still buy magic at a discounted price online yeah I have no problem with the map either I've got no issues with it I understand drive to the store when they initiated this in 2016 so everybody was crying and
screaming and you know the world was on fire guess what things are still going on things are moving nicely we're still getting board games we're still having fun playing got no issues here just don't talk about the baseball card thing it's the beginning of the year which means for portal games in the next several weeks we're gonna have the big portal con I want to go I want to go he said we can stay at this place we just need to find a way to get it it's cold over there right there now isn't it it's not as cold as it is here that's good point so gonna be eleven freaking degrees tomorrow that's go what's it called the cyclone cyclone bomb that we're having right now order its color for take cycling why don't it's cold so he's gonna be announcing some new games but in the meantime cry havoc six panshin aftermath just came out which we're excited to try them on now finally pull cry have it back on off-the-shelf and try this and portal games has also started their next season of informant if you haven't watched this go check out the YouTube Tube channel where they're gonna post regular videos a behind the scene looked at portal games and how they design games and play test games and maybe they'll tease some new games that are coming out this year so you go to their YouTube channel to find that or go to their website at portal games dot PL / e in for English unless you're polish then it's /pl unless you're German then it's slash de
five minute initiative begins in three two one I am so excited in this five minute addition to have my wife Vanessa join me and I am very excited to be here for five minutes I can give you five minutes well that's interesting because the reason why we're here is to talk about a filler game and lots of times in this house we don't have a lot of times it's to play two and three hour games so we play a lot of filler games here so like you can only give me five minutes for this interview you can only give me fifteen to thirty to play a game that is correct in a game we that we just got that we're excited to talk about is a game from renegade games designed by Danny Devine called topiary and you know when you opened up the box I thought it was the cutest game the tiles are just so cute the topiaries are little swans and there's a dinosaur and they they're really just fun to look at yeah like the concept of the game where you go into a garden and you want to look down at the different topiaries exactly and there's a different type of topiary sculptures and there's one per tile but they're ranked one through five and they're ranked by size yeah so 1 through 5 meaning they're shorter with the shorter ones are one and the taller ones are five and to start the game out you have a 5 by 5 grid on the table with all the tiles face down except for the center and the goal over the course of the game is to reveal those tiles and put your meeples out on the edges where they're looking down a row or a column or
diagonal for the purpose of seeing as many topiaries as you can and that means you want to have the low numbers in front and the high numbers in the back and the first time we played it we actually played it with our older son and his girlfriend again when we play it's not just us but when family's over and birthday parties and again we tend to do party games but this game was a lot of fun and it was the first one that his girlfriend had played with us so it was a good little thinking game after we played it though we were like gosh there were just too many meeples out here and we were kind of falling all over each other and we really weren't sure about the game I'm not skipping my I'm saying that you were wrong you read the rules wrong I think your time is up there with the four player game you're only supposed to have five meeples that you're supposed to place and I gave everybody eight yeah so there was a reason it got long and difficult we were thinking whoa so as soon as we were finished and we saw where you had read it wrong we're all eager to play again yeah and we did and you and I played a two-player game which we really enjoy because it actually moved a whole lot quicker and the flow of the game is really simple at the beginning of the game everybody has also dealt three of those topiary tiles and on your turn you're gonna take one of your maples and putting them to the end of the row or end of a column and then you get to flip over one of those facedown tiles that you're looking down
and where the row or column or diagonal you pick it up you look at it and you can put down another one that's in your hand or the one you just picked up back in its place face-up obviously the goal is the closer the tile is to your meeple you want very low numbers and want higher numbers in the back and once the tile is face-up that's it it can't be changed any more mention about when in scoring if you have a set of the same so the way the thinkI part comes in is it's not just at the end of the game after you've placed all your meeples you're going to look down each row and basically count so if I see a number two and number three and number four I add up those values and I get that but also if they happen to be of the same sculpture so say there's two or more of the dinosaur the Swan I get one additional point but then there's another thing you also have tiles in your hand if you happen to be looking down a row and there is a higher value tile than the one in your hand you'll also score the point at that one in your hand so there's three ways to score and that's matching matching topiary your lower tile has to be the matching took one of the matching temporaries in the line so all of a sudden as you as you're going it's like wow there's a lot going on and you can block people you can flip over towel and block their line of sight so they don't get to see as much yeah we really enjoyed it and we'll definitely play it again and bring it out win members come over it's just another filler game but a little bit more thinking like we've said and it didn't look that way we thought this is just gonna be an easy out where he's gonna pass time playing 15 minutes all of a
sudden were like oh wow where does my meeple need to go this time because once the meeples put in a certain place and other people can't people can't be placed there right one little knock I have on the game is the fact that it can take time to figure out the scores at the end because you have to go around to each meeple look down each row each column or the diagonal count up the number of points see if there's any matching topiaries see if you can score the tiles in your hand and ask to go around for each individual person so the scoring element can't take a little bit time to resolve so everybody's kind of waiting around seeing who's gonna win but other than that if you're looking for a game that's easy to teach easy to play but has a little bit of fall to it then you need to check out topiary from renegade games it comes out January 10th so you can look for it online or at your local gaming store 5-minutes initiative is complete
as the great richard Dawson said that's right it's time to talk about the 2018 2017 our annual survey I get confused by that Marty we do the survey in December and then we talk about it in January uh-huh it is kind of confused it's kind of confused myself I get I'm uneasy to get confused nowadays so we ask no more than ten questions we try to keep it simple not so that we try to get difficult answers or anything it just makes it easy on us because it's all about us Wow Wow it's about the listeners yes it is about the listeners Tony I know it is but it's a good way for us to make sure we're staying on track you got to have metrics if anything I've learned at work you've got to have metrics because without metrics you don't know when you're going off the rails kind of like this show often does hey I agree all right the first question was we strive to keep the show under an hour and 30 minutes is this time still good does this work for you does it fit into the commute resounding sure it's about right and boy I try to stress it I try to make sure that we stay there I like an hour because I know my attention span did you just go to the answers I'm confused yeah I said it's about right 85% about right I don't need to go did you say 85% did you say that just a second ago yes okay dude you okay here's that you need to go get some new internet providers cuz you verse sucks why did you not hear a thing no I just thought it sound like you just
said it's about right that's all I heard that was one of the answers it was either too short about right or too long so 85% about right okay seven point seven percent too short and the rest is too long so see the majority who cares what the non majorities are which which reminds me since this is problem with those questions that we can probably knock out next year because we're pretty consistent here so we can replace this with something else okay I'll take a note of that somewhere I got it noted which this next question we could probably change next year too because I think we're okay here do you find participating in a contest through the year difficult 77.7% said no 17.4 said there were contests and the rest said yes so we do try to make the contest as easy as possible and we've had this question a few years and it tends to be about the same thing so I think we're doing good there so you'll need to find another question for a question umber to next year Tony I don't know sometimes you wonder so that because you know some people don't always like the social media ones so maybe we'll work something around that true or maybe we're gonna ask what type of cons what ways do they like to enter there you form social media there you go we'll tweak that and lighten like twelve months from now ago no what was that question we're going to ask I'll write it down I got mine like a sieve Oh what is this is it a sieve oh I thought you said zit seriously you verse get something else I can't there's only one option you verse I can do dial-up you
want me to do dialog might be better than this I may just need to drive over you do your house you still got a usually got the twenty eight eight modem I sure do the NIH's or maybe you got 256 K and you went all special I got my vic-20 sitting over there too nice alright so question number three and 2018 the show should have more designers forty-one percent of the people said we need some designers on there so not half of the respondents okay I can looks good good publishers 16% caveat the lowest from publisher but I should have put a caveat in there except ignosi and Stephen when Ozzy comes on I say he's a designer yeah he's a designer guest media 41% should we should have more guests medium we'll try to get a few more people on here that would they can just break away and I'd really like to get another chit chat on but like once again they won't answer our call and now they're part of like this Kickstarter deal and they're right like rolling in all this money we can't I mean what's the best thing we can offers maybe I'm not sure maybe if we can get the design right next question or not next question next answer this is surprising over yes most 59% well it was 59% other people said you should include old board games in the show I think that was the most interesting answer of this entire survey people want to hear old board game reviews I think that's exciting Tony because we feel as content creators we've always got to do the new if I
always got to do the latest and then we think oh we got to keep up cuz that's what people want to hear about they don't wanna hear about something from several years ago but yeah right here people say once you pull out an old board game and do it and do a review and you and I have actually talked about this and maybe this is a new way to do like a an old-timey five minute initiative where we do pull out a game and see does it stand the test of time you know again that we use to play years ago is it still relevant today is it still fun so consider that one done everybody Tony I are gonna get together we're gonna work on this old board game fuse is a great idea we're not gonna do a reroll no no and and I'm talking about games Tony from 6 7 8 maybe 10 years ago really old games - ok yeah I can break out monopoly well think about it pandemics 10 years old I know take it a ride so 11 maybe 12 yeah that's what I'm saying so these are all these old classic games worked up I'm sorry go ahead and the final one is 22% said recipes so we should have recipes on before designers I mean publishers publishers we're just having fun no offense teen publishers anyway question number four how did you find out the show was released and Tony I think this is one of these questions we can sunset to because I think we got a good feel thank goodness I don't understand half the answers here I know Twitter's 14% Facebook 14% RSS description 37 iTunes 40 so most people this is really exciting 77% of the
people subscribe to our show Tommy they subscribe to RSS they come through iTunes then 10% of BoardGameGeek 4% visit the website 3% Google+ and actually we had several people in the comments they said they get our show off the diced our network page if you got to the diced our network has a list of all the podcasts on the network and they go through there so this is probably no those questions we can sunset we feel that okay everybody's mainly getting it through iTunes through some sort of RSS subscription which would be through you know some sort of podcast app on your phone or laptop we are proud members of the diced our network do that suffice for a 20-18 plug that should do for at least 26 shows yeah okay I should be good till 29 so so I have a question that if seventeen if for only 4% visit the webpage mm-hmm can set the webpage no because that's that's where our episodes are stored and the RSS feed goes through the webpage so I don't have to do right up I think people like the timestamps I think on the bgg and people don't know this Tony does a fantastic job of time stamping each one of our episodes you know exactly when a segment starts and stops so you can know exactly what you may want to skip and so if we post that on our bgg Gilad every time you post a new episode on bgg i put in the timestamps from our web page so there's two places you can go find them all right next question what is the most important aspect of a review of a board game thirty-three percent says how it's played however eighty nine percent what is liked and disliked that's what they
won't hear do I need to repeat that for you no you don't because we had several comments that said by the way don't tell us how it's played don't get into it just tell us how I feel and and I'm the one Tony will have warned me before we start a review Marty don't tell them the rules don't tell though the rules and all of a sudden it's like well then you on your turn you pull out this and you got to do this it's for me it seems like everybody needs to understand how the game works before we could tell her that we liked it or or don't so no I will try to pull back on that on our five minute segments we've only got five minutes sounds like we need to spend more time about what we think about the game compared to others and less than the rules lesson learned keep me straight this year Tony I understand what you're trying to do is say hey this is why I like it and if they don't understand the concept like I like it because it has victory points as the winner you know yeah you know that's that's how yeah yeah yeah yeah we'll get that straight quality of the components eleven and a half percent like that the artwork only six and a half percent and I think Marty what that's telling me is oh the theme was 12% what that's telling me is I think those are you should mention them when they when they really standout other than that you don't really need to talk about it yeah a good or bad right right if the artwork is just well artwork just subject everything is subjective right if there's the theme you're not crazy about you are not crazy about the theme or if you really like it do that so yes lesson learned so I will try to
implement that this year next question do you find a 5 minute reviews beneficial and here's more I think we need to change the answers on 77.7% said yes and a lot of people on our comments said we really like the 5 minute initiative people like short chunks of information and not a long drawn out but just tell me whether you like or not and that's where the whole 5 min initiative is for to try to keep us on target lots of times we'll actually do a five-minute segment multiple times because we don't get said what we need to we want to there's some points we want to hit so we'll continue to work on that 15.8% said but would like a full review as well and tell me this is where I think we need to rephrase this because I don't know whether people are saying do a five minute review and a long review yeah ok I'll work on that so we've got a modified survey I'm with you and then only 6 percent said they'd like for reviews better only 6 percent that's amazing give him point hold on it's a very small pie chart point 5 percent said no that was kind of silly given I know okay all right next question what type of reviews do you find yourself using as as you decide on a game so in other words poorly worded question imagine that came from me basically how do you sound on whether or not you're going to decide that you were going to like a game 57% go to video reviews then we have 42% say video saying what they like or dislike and I was trying to capture here
Marty the like our good buddy Dan King doing where he pulls out his end and does the shortened up review that's why I was kind of interested in there's a leg row segment yeah 22% are around the written reviews on bgg that surprised me yeah very low yeah I read a lot of those thank goodness yeah like this one wasn't a set up a softball pitch podcast to talk about it present yeah nice and then of course I'm written reviews on other sites Amazon fund again in mnsure market cool stuff so forth only 6% there you know what when I go see it like Amazon reviews and I always wonder did or Yelp or whatever I'm like is that his brother no I totally agree I and lots of times it is a brother my resolution from 2018 is to produce more videos than I did last year Tony you got some ideas for videos how am I having guest on the show maybe that's a good way to talk to people and several people in the comments to said could you please produce more video content so we're cognizant of that Tony did just move he's gonna get set up I want to do some stuff here so we just got to get technically some stuff set up and that's one reason why we talked about starting up a pod pledge again because we want to maybe use some funds to get a few pieces equipment here to cut and make it look good I'm very much about quality around here I try to make this podcast sound as good as I can and if we do video I want to make it look as good and sound as good too so I just we
want to do it right so we do want to do something and just bear with us as we go through those bit of growing pains last question was are you a member of our bgg guild 75% yes well good because that means you're out we were automatically entered into the contest Facebook page 52% follow us on Twitter 58 follow us on Instagram 19.1 and some comments from this was several people said please post more stuff on Facebook that's another thing I'm gonna be cognizant I'm gonna try to do a little bit more there I do a lot on Twitter but I need to transfer that summer to Facebook because it is a good place to have discussions and a couple of people said can you put some more Instagram and I'll let Tommy answer that one sure I can take pictures of anything it doesn't be bored bag of chips Instagram that in a whole bag of chips come on Lord and pies I post pies out there you know host any from Christmas I don't remember however I do try to make it to every favorite game Friday post by our buddy Roy over at epic gaming he lets me contribute there when I have something to say along those lines and I hope to do more of those in the coming year little short set of in seconds I can manage that Marty also thank you so much for all the comments that were made we put that out there knowing we are probably going to get a lot of constructive criticism some negative feedback but Tony to be honest we didn't
get tons of negative feedback we got some things saying hey you know we got a couple people saying less cowbell we kind of overdid it on the last episode of counted it on purpose we're just gonna reserve the cowbell I'll thank Tony for just when there's a game that we really really like that both of us said this deserves a cowbell so we won't be ringing that all the time most were very very positive thank you so much for all those people that took time to say just the nicest things it really means a lot and I read these every night to put myself to sleep cuz it makes me feel good but there was more that didn't really make me laugh it's the head sorry Tony is too grumpy give him some pie to cheer him up you grumpy okay first off I held on will move the mantra can you see my sweatshirt it says grumpy's golf course seven fascinating holes yeah close enough so most so here's a little story here's no story so growing up come walking into the kitchen one morning and my mother looks at me and she goes wow cuz I was a tall boy growing up she goes man what was it Wow or man you got to get your story straight fine she looks at me and she goes there's seven dwarfs there and grumpies on top oh wow so then they went that Christmas and bomb here sure you know I used to be able to go to the mall and have the guys making the shirts oh yeah that and
airbrushing yes yes so they went and bought me a 3/4 sleeve shirt and it had all seven dwarves and there was a felt check mark that could stick so I could check which dwarf was on top at the time which made you you are happy you're sleepy you're a grumpy yes that's the grumpy was the first dwarf always listed oh my god every time my mom sees a grumpy t-shirt she buys it for me hey so that's just who you are right that's me I'm always happy somebody else toniest turn this Tony has turned the grumpy stick up to 11 when old man leave me alone oh hey hey I got a sprinkler system squirrel okay I'm gonna be paying out the wazoo for water oh that's why you got to be on a well like me it's free oh yeah maybe I can go do that I wonder if I could tap into it did you know that when a train goes through a crossing that it's a long too long whistles short whistle long whistle no well I found that out at 3:00 in the morning to say they get too long whistle too long whistles short whistle long whistle I didn't know that so there's a pattern every time they pass that do you have a crossing near you or something found that out one night the realtor didn't tell you this part oh by the way there's a railroad track about
half mile down the road I knew that there was a what is it called a model module module the little truck beds weird yes yes mark where's the shipping boy when I need him so there's one near the airport well it goes by I mean it's not every night but Wednesday for some odd reason a bunch of stuff moves through here it was 3:00 in the morning my first night here I was like oh we got a train nearby hey that should make you feel like we did in college you heard about our dorms right beside the ham trifle right it's like we knew exactly what time was oh there goes the 11:00 p.m. Oh any more comments that tickled your funny bone there I'm sure if I went through them there were again I've read through these multiple times and thank you so much for everybody that did these service it really does help us out a lot it really does show us that ok we're on track we're off track we'll tweak some of the questions next year to maybe fit something else we're looking for we are looking to implement some changes we are looking at doing some more YouTube I will try to make sure I don't go every every single rule I talk again it just meant a lot to us all the kind comments that you said and it gives us energy to get us through another year and you know when we released our video this past week I had a cute comment come back to me directly the video introducing our new logo introducing our new logo yeah I had a Q come and come back to me direct message it was from our buddy Matt Franz you know if cardboard car huh he sent me a note back he said when did the hipster and Baylor check start doing videos
whose Bella my ballot here's Belgian I was where are you because of the okay because of the sweatshirt yeah do comes in to do a video and what are you wearing those was shirt see this is why we need help people before we start doing into videos one thing that do is upgrade Tony's wardrobe good luck with that one I still got Duke power shirts Duke Energy hasn't been Duke power in almost 15 years maybe even longer oh Lord let's get out of here okay let hey I'm Nydia why don't we go here about Gaia Project which I was so excited to try and you well we'll see as I mentioned earlier in the show one of the biggest games I was looking forward to from last year's when they announced Gaia project which is a sci-fi version of Terra Mystica and as if people have listened to this show they know that Terra Mystica is one of my all-time favorite games so I was like so excited to get this to the table but this game is so big this means it's probably one of those that would be best suited for a story report and that's what exactly what we're doing here and it's typical we have our scurry report reporters I guess I says scurry report reporters named Evans and marquel thanks
for coming in guys hey what's going on hey Marty and Tony and Tony just sitting over there with his arms folded and I think I know why well I mean you got a point out here that Terra Mystica is one of the games that I enjoy playing but I play it so poorly it pisses me off it just absolutely irritates me to know in so you know in recent scurry reports I haven't been around so I thought the last one oh okay so what I thought I would do here for this one is do exactly what I did in the game I'm gonna sit back keep my arms crossed and watch you three talk about it because that's what it felt like to me Nate here hold the mic oh my gosh come on dude I mean at least you can interject though maybe why you are frustrated with it I will as y'all finish talking I'll come in chime in every once in a while I actually appreciate him being there with his arms folded because I wasn't I think we need to take a picture of Tony and put him on the box cover of a dry euro game where victory points do matter and that's all this game is about it's just how you get there so this game is designed by Ostertag and Drogo Mueller and I'm sorry I thought it totally butchered that which are the same two people that design Terra Mystica so I was very excited to see how this played and we're not gonna go in the details how the game is played because a lot of people have played Terra Mystica they kind of know how it works I really kind of want to focus on the differences in this game is this game better if I had to pick which one to play which one would it be except for one fact that I didn't realize before we started playing
today was that Nate has never played Terra Mystica somehow in my gaming career I have one of the all-time best games according to a lot of people it's like the top 5 of every serious gamer I know and I've completely whiffed on it so I'll be I'll be able to help in regards to like my impressions of Gaea project but not in comparing it to Terra Mystica well what you'll be able to interject is is have never played before do you think a game like this is worth the top spot on a lot of people's lists and I have played for Mystica before but I've played it maybe twice and I know the first time I played it I didn't care for but the first time I played it was at Moose Con and they broke it out at like 10 o'clock at night and I was tired and so I gave it you know the other chance and so I'm not a huge fan of it but I really like this game enough played tera Misco most a year ago but two words I don't know if I've ever played Terra Mystica I've won one the first time I played it I got to play the little Dwarfs that dug in the ground and all that but overall that was a little pretty much last time I really played it every other time I've just sat there at the table and sit there in same white am i doing wrong Terra Mystica Gaea project I was so excited space marty's space well that's why I thought you'd be into it because it's a sci-fi game it's a space game and you like your space games I enjoy my space games I was really excited with the hot type of board they were gonna have out where it's not a set static board like in the original and I was real excited about putting the plans together spinning it around and things like that I said this will be really neat that will add to the replayability but once again as we got into it for me
it seemed like I'm playing Terra Mystica in space until you realize that it still has a stupid little pellets that you have to put in the stupid little bowls that you the power pills that's one of the best mechanics of the game it's like why does it have to be in the special bowl but look and usually everybody starts out with a certain number of viagra and then we can move it around and as we play the totally like this game will call them gladiators to arena oh that's true then you call it balls it could be an arena ball they level up till they get to the grand Colosseum or maybe he likes it better as viagra pills I don't know I wouldn't know about that oh you might I do not but for me you could once again to me it felt like that game relies on people now Nate counter date me on this but I felt like if you're not controlling the power pills calls Nate win but Nate always wins you're going to get far behind the game but Nate had limited power pills and yet he decimated everybody well that's what I like about this game you don't have to say there's one strategy they're just gonna help you win it's not necessary because Iowa had a little power pill engine going I had power pills coming in I was moving around the board and spinning him like crazy and all it got me was first loser so let's talk about how this game differs from the other the power pills are still there that's one of the things that stays there Tony mentioned modular board I really like that because that was one of the issues I have a tear of Mistico was a set board every time and it didn't scale to the number of players
it was the same sized board regardless here you can scale the board based on the number of players and every time you play the game they have you a way that you can say okay here's kind of the base tiles you start with and then everybody kind of plays out the other tiles it's almost kind of like when we play forbidden stars you mean you put those tiles out and a certain way well we did go with the suggested way for the first game that was most balanced and if we ever played again I doubt we would I think we would do it the that advanced room it's forbidden stars one of those games that's been lost on your shelves for a while it's not lost I know exactly where it is now I'm anxious to play again but that's for a different segment okay because I mean you know I was just thought you were bringing in another game that I actually stand a chance at winning or this one oh I don't know that one house dies in this luck base you have a chance thank you thank you one of the big disses that a lot of people had on Terra Mystica was the sideboard which was the the priest board where he had the the priest going up the side and they had the different you know the air the water the ice and as you as you moved up that track you could get some more you can move some of your power pills around and and whatnot a lot of people felt was kind of like an add-on it was there you kind of had to pay attention to it because how you ranked or placed at the end of the game you got certain number points for each track the first place person got in this number point second places etc for each track here they kind of turned that on its ear and gave us a technology track now the sideboard is a is a set of technologies that are used to upgrade certain things during the game such as in the original
Terra Miss gang had navigation how far can I go between tiles before I build another before you build another building here is they have the navigation but it's on the tech track if you want to be able to jump across several planets or several spaces you need to go up on that tech track so what they've done is that is an integral part of the game or a lot of people before like felt like it was maybe just an add-on so Nate did you feel like it was integral cuz I I think I completely missed it maybe that's why I lost so poorly yeah I think that the tech track was the most interesting part of the game because for a couple of reasons first off that's really where you know about halfway through the game it felt like my faction was different from everybody else's faction in the way I advanced up the tech track some of the things I had gave me higher income than Mark had maybe I had you know a different terraforming costs and Tony did so that really customizes your strategy and then also the other cool thing that it does is some of the spaces that you go up on the tech track give you instant one-time bonuses other ones are more permanent and persistent effect but those instant win time bonuses let you combo actions on your turn basically so you know I can I could move up on this track and get to or and that's gonna let me next time upgrade my building which is gonna let me get another thing maybe even move up another tech track and I can combo some of those actions together and I I completely agree with the tech track I really enjoyed it and it's something that I really like to see in a game a board game or video game for that matter I think they did it well and it also
towards the end of the game it gives some tension in the game because those last spaces are very valuable and so you start kind of racing to see who can get up there first and you know it's not as simple as just moving you have to get this done before you can get up there but can you do it before Nate does it and so I think it added a whole lot of tension to the game yeah and like I said a lot of the things that used to be on the individual faction board such as increasing your navigation such as making it cheaper to terraform land that was built right into the faction board and you can see exactly what you need to do now that was actually on the tech tree board and as you moved up your pegs on each individual track that's how you made those better so that is a difference between the two speaking of terraforming remember in the original game you had all those circular tiles of all the different terrain and as you terraform the different spaces you put out the tiles showing the steps that you made a terraform to that certain space those terraforming tiles are now gone used to in the original game a Terra Mystica you could take steps she's like I'm going to terraform this space twice and just leave it because it's not to the space I need to to build a mine and then maybe I'll come back to it next time and do it here you had to terraform the entire way to your native color planet or whatever and then you could build a mine on it so no longer they had these little disks that you're actually putting down on the map which is good in the fact that's just less fiddly bits that you need to deal with over the course of the game but to me it did take away from the thing of somebody to partially terraforming a planet and then somebody coming in and stealing it from you well we don't have that much experience with
it unless Tony wants to talk about that holding the freakin mind there's no reason for me to be holding this mic today after playing this game I will play the game again it's it's a big thing key game I mean to listen to you guys talk about it 30 45 minutes after we finished you know and I'm sitting here trying to pack up the game you kept throwing bits at me I mean there's a ton of stuff here tons of factions yes I will play this game again will I be as disappointed in how I played it's not more than likely more than likely oh I didn't like my faction I didn't like how the board was set up it seemed like I couldn't ever get to the planets yeah I needed to go I should have recognized I need to go up that stupid Explorer exploration track so that I could didn't have to spend as much time trying to get to jump where was warp drive why did we not have warp drive in this that was one of the technologies that was and then whatever those little tesseract cubes way weak on the quick the queue I see you I see the quantum intelligence cubes with a ball even notice until Nate said he started called tesseract cubes because they looked exactly like the Tesla right from the Avengers I'm just like okay so and that is something we miss there is just so much just like the original Terra Mystica where you could probably figure out various strategies and as the board to
adjust I think that's what hurts on my side is that I was not able I had a set strategy in mind based on the power of my faction and I tried to implement that and when it got blown out of the water that's kind of like well how do I readjust and I think by the time I got to that point I was gone it was over I was dust I was I don't know pick some Star Trek little thing where people come and they decimate the planet or something that's where I'll be called the Death Star in Star Wars well when we talk about real science fiction so what you said at the beginning of that long rant was as a mark of a good game is where after we're putting the game away you know for the next 15 20 30 minutes were like you know I could have done this or if I had done that a little bit different I think I could have done a little better in the game so I think that's the mark of a good game and especially if you want to play it again to see if you can improve on what you did last time and to me also mark of a good game is the fact that there are multiple factions which is why I like Terra Mystica so you said you got a faction you couldn't figure out how to play it guess what the next time we play chances are it'll be a totally different faction which gives a lot of replayability to this game because each faction is tweaked just a little bit different to where you can't use the exact same strategy every time for example my guys were really good at taking credits and converting them into other things other types of resources everybody had that ability to do that with the power pills I was the only
faction that can actually do it with credits so in my case I should have been building a bunch of trading markets or MARTA whatever they're called trading station trading stations to generate a lot of income each turn that I could use to convert the things that I need yeah and speaking of replayability really the tiles drive all the replayability the faction is need to have that one special thing but if you think about it you only play with two of the six final scoring tiles throughout the game you should be building toward those scoring tiles that would definitely change the way you play the round scoring tiles are laid out and those are randomized so one round we were all going for mines the next round of his Federation's but it was too early so we ignored that then there the round boosters you would play with all the they're the tech tiles that randomized I mean this thing has reply was ooh is it the cousins because here we have kudzu so that's another thing that is like Terra Mystica you do have the different faction board you have the different in game scoring you do have the bonus round tiles where you draft you after you pass you takin you and it gives you like a little bility that at the beginning of the game you got all those tech tiles that you mentioned then there are the the Federation tokens they have the same sort of thing in the other game where you had to get the Federation tokens and to move up the tech track into the final spot you had to have one to be able to flip over to go into the final spot and now you also need one to be able to take an advanced technology which is different so that's another thing that that has changed now one thing I don't like about this and there's a small thing compared to Terra Mystica and Terra Mystica 4 you have extra bonus round tokens or tiles that are left after each round and when you had those whichever was left got one extra little resource token
making it more valuable over time they didn't do that in this I'm not sure why but I always liked that mechanic because it may drive somebody to take one of those just to get the extra credits even though you may not want that it's it's the Puerto Rico thing right a the roll that wasn't taken gets the extra token at the end I'm not sure why they took it out but they did yeah normally I like that mechanic but I didn't really see any round boosts or being neglected maybe that's because I wasn't paying attention but it seemed like they cycled through and they were maybe they changed fix that by making them all valuable at different parts of that's exactly what I was gonna say is if they're pretty much equal value then there's no need to put the the RAM marker or the additional coins but along those lines I mean certain ones for more value I kept waiting for you mark to pass so that because I knew that I wanted to build trading stations in the next round I'm like mark you got a pass and you kept delaying that and I'm like ok I can do one more thing but that's gonna hurt my resources mark are you going to pass hurry up and pass so I can have that in scoring for the next round so I can be ready for so I like that part of it now I mean once again the game if you enjoy Terra Mystica you're going to enjoy Gaea project it brings a lot more especially with the map for me though if I'm picking Marty between the two if you say which one do you want pick I will pick Gaea project simply because of the map that just variability of the very bill of the map and I do you know you mentioned the factions and their various things my favorite part of the whole game other than it's a page a first line you win by was the fact when you were
reading over your faction you goes oh my god this faction has over a paragraph or two paragraphs in one column I'm not going to play this one I'm gonna play the other one the simple one so each faction you gotta figure out what you want to do and then hopefully you can get the strategy that you need in order to maximize their special powers I definitely think that in my game that was one of my downfalls is I didn't use my ability enough but my ability was to downgrade a certain building which kept you from being able to upgrade to some of the bigger buildings so it just kind of seemed push-pull to me that you were losing one thing to gain another thing so I didn't use it quite as much but I think in another game just how we're talking I'm thinking about what we would do in the next game I think I have figured out a way I'd better use that ability yeah I was gonna say that brings up something I noticed on the faction special abilities that I thought was really cool it wasn't just sort of like a bonus thing that you're you know get one extra or every turn it's always a trade-off like Mark had the downgrade one Martis was spend money to get things and mine was mine was I get to place building mines on another person's colony which gives them potentially power points so it's always a trade-off it was never like just get a bonus something going back to the to the faction boards another thing that was different too is the different resources that you had such as or knowledge credits those were all basically tracked on a numerical track on the board which is different from Terra Mystica and Terra Mystica when you collected your resources at the beginning of the round you physically got one of each of those
little resources little wood and resources here you track them along the top now you didn't have the thing up oops I bumped it where were they we never really ran into that but it is less pieces that you have to deal with them during the game speaking of pieces this is a really high tech I kind of like it Terra Mystica is all little wooden euro type resources here all the buildings are plastic they look space-age e and cool there's no wooden bits they're all the nice acrylic and plastic bits so it gives it that sci-fi field that is different than Terra yeah and that and we haven't really talked about the art or or kind of the components too much but all things we don't talk about the art on this show cuz we just have no clue about art I actually have a comment on the art but go ahead mate compared to Terra Mystica five years yes so in terms of theme and components I definitely would prefer the plastic bits and this one to just having cubes that represent things the artwork I'm a little bit you know man especially the box cover and some of the artwork on the components I mean it kind of reminds me of a lot of z-man games the arts okay but it's not amazing it's not the high standard that we expect in today's game and that's what exactly we want to say I actually like the art on Terra Mystica better the fantasy art I don't know it just seems more indicative of what I expect to see the the art and the graphic design on the faction boards I'm not as crazy about as I am in the Terra Mystica I was still easy to read and everything but same with you I think the the box cover of Terra Mystica pops more to me than what it does for Gaea
project the art doesn't bother me too much I mean I'm not thrilled about a boss cover but once you're in the game and you know you're working off the Taos I think the the graphic design to lead you to learn how to play the game and what each thing does I think that did an outstanding job on would you have preferred a box cover that would have been shiny and black in a star field and say Gaea project across it or this would you pull it off the shelves I would prefer your dour face on the cover dry your I guess from uni I never I never go down with the art I didn't even i've looked past the art no it's just I'm just comparing the two once I'm into the game I ignore the art but if you go if I go and pull the faction boards for Terra Mystica and the ones for this the art of the factions themselves don't say and the factions in Terra Mystica don't say a lot to me there are these generic spaced names if I pull out two factions for Terra Mystica Giants elves dwarves merfolk I kind of get an idea of what they're going to do here you really have no clue if somebody tells you you're the if you're the xenos or the glans or the infants or the umbers that tells me nothing but on Terra Mystica if I was to see Giants or frost giants or something like that I'm gonna think oh okay I'll probably know what kind of terrain they're looking for not that big of a deal I'm just comparing the two in space what would you compare it to what name
would you need in order to build agreeance that's why I the Jubilee is for the ringgit planet look oh look at the gaseous Nations for me but or something for the ringed planet I'm sorry I was the pimple nation for the duper nation it's not Martians yeah that's trademark somewhere I'm sure some way aside from that that's just me probably theme-wise I do like fantasy better but let's just get back to this we just had our first game we had our first impressions Nate you've never played the game before does this game interest you enough does this game after hang all about Terra Mystica can you see the appeal behind it would you play it again or can you go like it's another game yes so without having played Terra Mystica based on what I've heard the changes that they made I'm all in favor for it sounds like they've streamlined it they got rid of bits they made it quicker it's not streamlined gameplay wise no to me I think this is probably more an in-depth game than Terra Mystica because that tech tree really adds some new thing key components to it the Terra Mystica didn't have yeah but I was thinking more in terms of the terraforming steps not having to put those out there the resources every time I'm not counting so many or and so many credits we tell people to turn their phone off while recording your marks not over those giving blinks and blinks and bloops where's this a mark no embarrassing yeah now you got to read it to the audience wasn't say it says so
where's motion at my front door video doorbells for Christmas yeah ramble the Jets okay okay so that's just kind of an in comparison to Terra Mystica but overall Gaea project I really enjoyed it it is definitely think II it takes forever to set up it takes forever to put away to explain the rules blah blah it's going to be tough to get to the table because it requires quite an investment as with any heavy euro it is hard to get to the table but I really enjoyed my time but but we did say it we're done we could probably knock this thing out in two hours we're four people know how to play I think we could play this thing in two hours I think so yeah I think we could do it was only lengthy to put away because Marty requires certain bags be filled with certain bits certain tokens that's the only reason why it's lazy because if it been up tomorrow oh it all been in one box I'll scatter it everywhere you find your own pieces let's go which is unusual for me I'm usually like putting everything in a single bag but they're all plastic but it's not your game you know come out they all have to go on the board it doesn't help you and Tony over here he was ready with a trash bag I thought there might be a dumpster fire at one point alright mark couldn't give us your your impression I really liked it without going back and playing Terra Mystica I don't really have a good comparison with it because it's been so long since I've played that and like I said the one play I didn't have a good impression of it but I did really like guy a project I would play it anytime you want to play it may even consider getting it so yes okay and for me they've been giving me a
hard time I would play the game anytime it's a little long it's a little long to explain I think for if you don't have the audience to sit down I mean he took us an hour to get through this thing to begin to start getting ramped up and going I would dread doing that again but I would sit down with you guys and play this anytime or anyone who's played Gaea project it's got it shortened up there's got to be a short shorten window on play time where I'm long two hours two hours and to me I've been the same thing I was saying I've said the same thing about Terra Mystica six rounds flies quick it feels like when I'm in round three or four like okay final I'm getting my engine going holy crap there's only two rounds left this has the exact same feeling this is not a slow grow I think you got to come out of the gate hopping well in the sixth round mark and I were sitting here checking our phones for video feeds from his doorbell while we're busy doing other things yeah I'm it I mean yeah if you got that engine really powered up on the 6th round you can drag out forever but once again I'm sorry yeah it's I'll play it just put it on the thing have it set up I'm ready to go again all right so from the Terra Mystica fan from the guy who loves Terra Mystica who has the expansion has the super nice insert over there if the two were placed in front of me today even though I prefer the fantasy thing more I would say Gaea project and it's strictly because of the technology tree board that they have now implemented and changed what used to be the sideboard on the Terra Mystica it just makes more
sense to me it has that tech tree field is not a civilization game by any means but it has that feel trying to go out to the tech tree to upgrade your stuff so that you can build make things cheaper so for me at this point in time I will pull out guy a project it sounds like everybody here after the first play their first impressions they would all play it again and if you're interested if you like Terra Mystica you must play this game if you've never played either Tony which would you recommend I almost might would say Terra Mystica I don't know I would go with the theme that you like science or fantasy science fiction or fantasy but don't ask a lexer to play science fiction music oh shoot she heard me no she did play some music and also wish that we got techno we got some hard rock we got some sort of orchestral stuff so anyway if you're interested in this game you stay tuned because at the end of this episode Tony and I have an extra copy of Gaia project to give away and we're gonna give away to one lucky winner so that's Gaia project from z-man games it will sit right beside it it's placed beside Terra Mystica even though it's not an F but a quarter because it's t energy but they'll still sit beside each other
all right I know I'll pushed at Christmas Marty that if you didn't know what get the gamer in your life get him an organizer I know I said that a couple times times I had to edit out several of them because you said it over and over and over again well I'll try to make a point so you've got that new board game you're ready to put it on the table you got a little extra spending cash because so and so didn't know what to get you take that cash go get you a nice new organizer from the broken token or any of their as many many accessories that they have over there be sure to check them out because you know they're ramping up for 2018 trying to catch up to all the games from 2017 you might find that organizer that you really need that's the broken token calm I want to give a couple more comments about Gaea project so do I I'm tired of this grumpy stuff I got a few more comments okay I wouldn't mention a couple things that I did not mention there and also I've played against since we recorded that we recorded that a few days ago with the guys Oscar report thank you Mark and Nate for so much for doing that we got to play again and we totally Widow we totally we totally tubular played with different factions this time because we want to throw out ones we'd already play just to see how the different ones play honestly every flippin faction just makes it so different so this time I happen to have a faction Toni that if I bail to built the biggest building under my special faction unlock each one of my power pills in the third bowl is now
worth - Oh whenever I spent them yeah that was huge meanwhile Nate had this whole thing going on on tech of course he killed us again but he was able to run up all all of his tech high enough to at least get points in every tech tree and just annihilated us that's what I love about that tech tree board it just adds his whole new element to the game that ah so good I'm glad y'all got to play again I hate I missed out on that opportunity cuz I know it came off sounding very negative from that no and I think it was not because I was pissy the game I was pissing pissy at myself because I like I said I really really like that game but when you play a game and you play it so poorly it just pisses you off it's ours the experience do i I'm there with you I can't remember I can't think of the game oh you know the last time I played gentes um you guys had played several times and then I got to play again I got destroyed and it was all set maybe this game isn't that great and it's just that it's just that instant it's like well you know this game in that great after all it's true if you don't play well it's ours the experience but I was thinking back during the whole time you never said the game suck you were just very upset with yourself but now that you've gotten away from it and and you've kind of cooled off let me ask you
this do you even want to play anymore just because you kept saying I don't know how to play it and for that reason do you even care about playing again oh no I will play it again okay I don't care that I almost got laughed in victory points and I still of that room it pisses me off that I couldn't figure it out and that's how I felt with Terra Mystica yeah I will figure this game out it will not defeat me I that's my ultimate goal I've got to score more than 20 victory points I know I scored more than that yeah you score a lot more than that to that point that's what I want to happen that's why I will play this game again but I will say you can keep Terra Mystica on the shelf and just bring out Gaia Project so you have probably much decided this guy you kind of want to focus on in order to in order to make it a better experience for you not Terra right you know and I think the reason for that is simply the the map I really like the modular man that's a huge difference and I forgot to mention this too there's a solo version in this game yeah because I actually taught myself how to play a solo so you played with yourself also yeah so the AI how the work the AI is kind of walkie to me it took a while to figure out the war how the AI works then how to play a game but that is the option in the game so if you want to get the game and play just to see how the mechanics work try out the different factions oh there was one other thing too I thought was weird Tony I don't know if you noticed this for some reason the faction boards of the version that we got the copy that we got warped they
were warping through the night and I thought maybe it was causing the humidity or something so I pulled out the Terra Mystica faction boards and set them right beside of them and left them there for a couple hours came back Terra Mystica perfectly flat Gaea project boards were warp interesting they may not have sealed them too good on the edges and there are longer boards so any little bit of warp will really be exaggerated but anyway I just thought that was kind of because we talked about the art in the game and stuff like that - I just thought component wise I thought that was interesting that these boards happen to warp so there you go we have talked about Gaia project enough it met all my expectations and Tony I'm glad you're willing to try again and I can't wait do it but more importantly and thanks for everybody hanging in there yeah so much for that hour-and-a-half mark yeah we have an important on another contest if you are interested in winning Gaia Project all you need to do is go out there fill out my quick little form that's on our web page and we will draw a lucky winner from that quickly get that out there two weeks that's it I'm gonna let it run for two weeks and then it's off the thing you'll have to answer put in an email so we can contact you and let us know would you prefer Terra Mystica due to the fantasy or Gaea for the science fiction thing just let us know easy answers we're gonna keep it simple but it doesn't matter which one you answer because if you ask for Terra Mystica you're still getting Gaia Project forget you yeah a game gotcha that's right and
unfortunately Tony it's a Gaea projects a big box it's a heavy game it'll have to be us only and one of the comments in our survey was please do mourn on or expand contest beyond the US which is why we did the gift card the 200 gift card because that's that's worldwide and we'll try to focus on more things that aren't product based but maybe a more gift card base so that we can get more things out to people maybe we get that guy Poland to hook us up oh maybe you could ship stuff from there oh that's not a bad ideas mhmmm send him some money make that have you go okay so yeah be sure to check out closes in two weeks we'll have that out there the link will be on the website wink will be able to be linked the link will be at BG Gil so be sure to fill that out and we will draw a lucky winner from that for your very own copy of Gaea project so there's our first episode of 2018 so much for keeping it within an hour and a half but we had been off for three weeks we had a lot to talk about we are excited about 2018 Tony and I are already putting together our squirrely Award nominations that episode will be coming up in the next month or so we're excited about that and before long Tony April will be here gonna be time for our big movie episode screening streaming or steaming I am so excited for that still haven't seen Star Wars yet do you see it I will I'm gonna go see it I'm so far behind on the movies the holiday anyway so keep rolling dice and taking names
thanks for listening everybody make sure to go join our guild at one five eight nine our twitter account is at Dyson names our Instagram is Dyson names join our Facebook page and if you weren't keeping count the meat count for this episode was three alright so here we go okay feeling them feeling the love can you feel the same emotion action with Beyonce as the baboon but what movie was that well they're making the love thing of The Lion King now that wasn't white I see I can't remember what's the only thing I remember from Lion King was Hakuna Matata you know that was can you feel the love to okay yes when Nala and Simba get funky okay fun again calm that's the place to go if you want any of the games you heard tonight I don't know if you'll be able to get passport to culture but that's alright there's plenty of other great games out there who's that by again H&H global oh look at you that's right thank you thank you so fun again calm they have all your gaming knees they got a ton of stuff in over the holidays they restock the shelves matter of fact Marty I think their words almost three pages of restocks being published and if I'm not mistaken some
new stuff is hitting real soon so be sure to go out there check out fun again calm get those pre-orders in or pick up that game that you got missed at under your tree or was not under your tree not miss you know what I meant sure you