Restarting our Board Game Collections with $100 | What Games Would We Buy?
Transcript
how's it going everyone i'm dylan this is my cousin carlo this is all you can board and today we're doing a pretty fun video we got this idea from uh the folks over at board game barrage uh that i think they were the first ones we saw to do maybe someone else said before them i'm not sure but this is uh restarting your board game collection if you only had a hundred dollars to do so now the idea here is basically you know if we either lost all our games or we're just starting from from scratch and no board games that we owned whatsoever how would we kick off our collection if we were given 100 to spend to do so this is obviously 100 canadian uh which is uh surprisingly much more difficult than american prices because board games just cost more here so you you your 100 goes a lot it doesn't go as far as it does uh americans so we each have our own list and i think we each have our own approaches on how we uh uh you know got to those games and and what we you know the parameters were how we chose them so i think we'll kind of go over the parameters before we start but uh i'll throw it to you first yeah yeah sounds good and just so you guys know there's no no shipping costs or taxes or anything included and the way we picked our games and the prices is we went to boardgameoracle.com uh picked canada for our region and then any game we were interested in we just picked where it was cheap uh listed at the cheapest price um so yeah i'll just say for my criteria what i did was like there's so many of my favorite games of all time are available to play on board game arena and there's so many good games accessible on there that i tried as much as possible to leave out games that i can play elsewhere on board game arena or like on an app on my phone so i definitely lean towards games that like if i don't own it i'm probably not going to be able to play it much otherwise right whereas me i didn't consider board game arena at all and so mine is as if
uh you know you're playing games at the cabin and you have absolutely no internet connection how would you start a board game collection and yours is more like urban in the city i guess yeah in the real in the real world yeah so you gave yourself way more strict harsher circumstances without even realizing it yeah my collection went missing today and i had 100 and i was still living at home and everything was the same uh yeah so i'm gonna kick it right off i'm going to go from most expensive game to least expensive game so the first one on my list is modern art that comes in at uh 32.99 uh this is designed by ryder kenitzia one of my favorite games of all time i mean when we did our top 50 games of all time back in december i had it at number three i believe it was and a lot of the other games that are in my like top five top 10 are on board game arena this is one of the ones that's really high up on my list that i've played the least i've only played modern art maybe i don't know seven or eight times and it's just like as much as i kept thinking like oh it's you know it's a decent amount of money 32 and it's a third of the cost but like i can't envision a world where i don't own modern art like i can't if i just lost it like my collection went missing like you can't play it on board game arena it would not be the same playing on tabletop simulator you can't envision a worldwide monitor didn't you go many years without it being in your collection yeah but that's because i didn't know anything about it but now that it's like now that we have a taste of modern art how could i possibly go without it right it's like it's just such an amazing game and i feel like there's there's so many more like i could play this hundreds of times probably i just i can't go without it so and the fact that it's pretty affordable 32 bucks right um plays up to five players which is nice got a bit of flexibility there for going above four so yeah yeah it's just and and you know
it's a very interactive very social game i just i have a blast every time i play it and yeah i just i couldn't be without modern art it makes sense we'll get into like the rules and how plays we've talked about on the channel many many times before but uh yeah yeah i uh one of the most pure auction games out there i knew this was gonna be on your list i would have bet money on it i almost put it on mine but i thought uh you know you're gonna probably cover it uh enough yeah and i was having trouble squeezing on so yeah great pick cool all right next uh another one from the good doctor himself uh blue lagoon this one comes in at 29.99 and the reason so now we're up to a total of 62.98 from these two games so yeah basically 63 dollars out of my 100 is on two reiner canezia games um blue lagoon is falls in here because i wanted a tile laying game and my highest ranked titling game ever is carcassonne but i've played it like hundreds of times you can play it on board game arena anytime like there's apps there's so many ways to play carcassonne that i thought what's another tiling game and i wanted one that has not where you're tiling on your own board and everyone compares their score at the end i wanted like that shared kind of fighty tile lane game and this is the least like this is the least expensive one like you know there's games out there like tigers and euphrates and all these big more intense kind of fighty tiling games but for a 30 game that plays two to four players plays in like 45 minutes uh you can play it with a variety of different like levels of experience and gamers i think like the rules are like three four pages it has area control and network building or every majority i should say there's different scoring conditions like there's just so much to it and i feel like for the price point and
any like when i was thinking of what like you know we talk about like what is a board game versus like a card game or whatever this is the only one on my list i'll say right now that has an actual board but it's also the cheapest game i could think of that still gives me that board game feel where there's a communal space where all fighting over kind of things so right yeah that's how blue lagoon makes it into the list for me nice that's a good pick uh that's another one i thought you might have and i actually considered for mine as well uh but uh i didn't think you were gonna i thought you were gonna diversify a little bit and have to only one can eats a game and have to narrow it down and here's the thing and i i especially almost didn't lagoon because i think it's a lot better with three or four players like it's so it's still good with two but it's it doesn't shine with two and the fact that modern art doesn't even play with two players it made it tough to pick but again it was the the sweet spot of the price point with the kind of like how much game you get for it um yeah i don't know i just i couldn't pass it up makes it like a right the right pick here yep solid next up uh number three is arboretum so this is 16.99 so that brings my running total up to 79.97 uh so arboretum is a two to four player card game i've talked about on the channel before you can go check out my video where i mentioned that i think it plays best with four players this is just one of those games where like i wanted one of those kind of like games that's like basically just a deck of cards but you feel like you could play it for the rest of your life with all kinds of different people it's one of those games too where you could like i could see myself just like having an arboretum game night like not right you don't plan for it necessarily but one of those games or once you play people might say like oh let's play again and i could see myself just playing it over and over again i read them game night that's just the last time you game with those people because everyone just hates each other
yeah yeah that's yeah exactly exactly real real harsh stuff um and even though like i talked about it in the video right where i talked about how arboretum was i thought it's best with four it like as a two-player game i'm not super fond of it because i do think it plays better with three or four but because i'll just say right now i don't have two-player games like lost cities or battle line on my list which are two-player games that i love this would kind of fit that niche where it has a bit of the card counting a bit of the back and forth the hand management like so even though i like those more as a two-player game the fact that i could get kind of that experience with having an awesome three or four player card game that's really really mean it has a bit of tableau building too and it's just i've never played two games of arboretum to feel the same and it's just another one of those ones that there's nowhere online there's no app to play it and i i couldn't possibly uh continue living without being able to play to play arboretum like it's just wow sorry i'm not going to keep living without our in your collection but like how did you i would just when we were waiting for it to be delivered how did you survive like i did no but it's just one of those ones where like again if it disappeared from my collection like if my house burned down it went missing and there was no copies of our medium to find like i would just be devastated by not being able to play this game everything else like that it gets burned down though family photos okay so what do you what do you want on this insurance claim well top of the list for sure there's this game called arboretum we just probably start in the essentials is that just cards with numbers and colors can you just make it nope you can't you shut your mouth exactly yeah
probably make like a print and play version of it or something so maybe it's a silly pick but uh there's just there's so like i talked about this we talked about this game in our discord too with people were asking about games you could only play for the rest of your life and like arbitum is a game i could see myself playing when i'm like in my 70s in my 80s whatever like anyways yeah love love it um next up so this is gonna be the last kind of like full-sized game or bigger game on the list uh that is the crew mission deep sea so this is uh 13.99 which brings my total up to 93.96 which you're probably thinking oh that's probably done and how can you come up with another game so i'll just talk about the crew mission deep sea i actually haven't played mission deep sea yet i've only played the crew the quest for planet nine which i absolutely love but i know enough about the differences between the quest for planet nine and mission deep sea that if i was just starting over today i would just go buy mission deep sea uh it's scales a bit better for the the player counts there's a different more variety in the missions et cetera et cetera dylan has covered it on a video on her channel comparing the two games and the fact that i just haven't you know there are scenarios or missions or whatever and i haven't played mission dc yet so there's just more like for me to discover there too but um it just it covers like i would then have one cooperative game because i haven't picked any others uh there's the limited communication aspect and even though this one's on board game arena this of any other like we're talking other games that are also on board gaming that i could have picked board game arena has a more similar like you still get the feel of the game whereas for me playing the crew like with strangers on board game arena is not going to give me the same experience as
sitting around a table where you debrief with people after the round and go why didn't you play that or how come you put that like communication token what were you trying to tell me with that card or whatever right like yeah i think that's the one where like even though it's on board game arena i feel like i need to own a copy of it and similar to arboretum maybe even more than arboretum is i could see game nights being just the crew like you just played the crew over and over and over again can play it with different groups i think there's a lot of longevity and just like the bang for your buck is like there aren't a lot of games that give you that much bang for your buck for like a small box game for 14 bucks yeah and mission deep sea is the other two of your only if you're in a starter collection that's the one i would start with at this point too because more longevity more variety out of it you know there's less missions i think what you get with all the way those mission little uh mission cards whatever they're called yeah the objectives yeah whatever yeah they're way better in right mission deep sea so yeah good good pick one with that one i need to i need to guess i want to make a guess on what your last little thing is okay before you actually do it is it uh is it sleeves for arboretum oh my god it's funny you mentioned that because until it's something else but before that i was thinking sleeves for our freedom that's exactly what there's gonna be sleeves for arboretum and the crew because if i'm gonna keep these games forever right but then i was like gosh try to find a game so i started thinking i looked at my list when i had those four games and i thought what's the biggest like you know with a glitch like this you can't cover all your bases but what's the one thing that's kind of lacking and i thought two players like yes i can play arboretum with two players yes i can play blue lagoon with two players technically the crew plays the two players but none of those games are best at two
so i started digging and key forge age of ascension for quite some time now has had blowout sales for their decks normally a key forge deck is like 10 or 12 bucks currently a key forge age of ascension deck is 2.98 wow but getting one deck on its own wouldn't be like you can't play a key forge as a solo game but if i got two key forge age of ascension decks that's 5.96 me and the opponent could actually swap decks so it's like we have two decks each kind of sort of thing so that brings my running total up to 99 and 92 cents leaving only eight cents on the table so i really get my money's worth here plus i get an awesome two-player game key forge here obviously the one thing the one potential drawback is if you get two random decks and one's way better than the other there could be but then you just play with chains one person start with chains you draw fewer cards you write there's a way to balance it out kind of thing um but yeah i was really lacking like it was tough to leave games like battle line lost cities all kinds of games like this off my list even carcassonne which i love as a two-player game and this was like the perfect thing where i just needed something that was just a few dollars to fill that two-player niche and uh nice you know might get old after a while playing with the same two decks over and over but i think it still works yeah that's that's all i'm surprised you i wouldn't even have thought to do the the key forge decks but that's a solid solid plan and when i got up to 93 whatever it was at first i almost reworked my list and took a game off so i could fit in a different game and get close to that 100 mark but nice so yeah again just to recap real quick that is modern art blue
lagoon arboretum the crew mission deep sea and then two very on sale key forge decks from age of ascension nice okay solid uh solid picks uh sorry the games that uh almost made my list galaxy trucker was really close because especially the new edition is very inexpensive it's like 27 bucks i mentioned battle line already sprawl opolis i almost picked because it's like a 14 game ideal travel game and solo game i don't have any solo games on my list um biblios was a close one too but i have a feeling someone i know might have it so i might not need it it's not on my list okay okay uh and then all the a bunch of my favorites are on board gaming agricola race for the galaxy carcassonne i'm so lucky those three games are on innovation's another one i would have picked coloredo i almost picked for sale the travel edition but i can play these all in board game arena so okay uh so what's interesting here is i was so worried that we were going to have a bunch of crossovers because of like uh and even crossovers potentially with one of us or both of us with board game barrages picks and stuff because of things like biblios and arboretum so i tried from the very get-go i was like i want to be happy with my picks i want there to be reasons why i'm picking it but i want to try to think a little bit outside the box in what i'm picking and to like just make sure i'm differing to give people different options here so you might be surprised with some of mine but i would absolutely start a collection with these and be super pumped about this collection i have good reasons for them so i'm going to start with the most expensive game on my list and this one is 50 and 39 so it's half my budget uh right off the get-go and oh i think i
know what it is because i had it on my navy list before too maybe so it's winter kingdom uh and that's because i almost put kingdom builder but again i'm trying to think like maybe i'm gonna stick with just these games my collection for all and not expand it and winter winter kingdom has much more longevity there because it has more variety and even after like the limited play i have of it um it has the essence of what i love of kingdom builder but just more it's it's like as if i was able to get kingdom builder with expansions right like so not only does it have a lot more just in the rule set but we haven't played it anywhere near as much like there's so much to explore exactly so because of how much i enjoy a kingdom builder and how much longevity that has gotten and i'm willing to always play it i know winter kingdom is one of i'll have that kind of same feeling with and it would be a great one to start a collection with because if you only have limited games one of the problems the kingdom builder can have uh that we've talked about is that if i play it a lot and you've never played it and come in it's hard for you to be like you know compete right the skill difference yeah if i have a very limited collection when i have game nights and we're playing my games we're gonna be playing if i only have one big game and it's winter kingdom that's gonna be the one we gravitate towards maybe everyone's a little bit more in equal footing so uh yeah it's just kingdom builders great winter kingdom is sort of i was willing to spend the extra to get something that's going to last longer especially if i'm only going to have four games in my collection to start yeah so that was the reason to be at winter kingdom so i thought that was gonna be a bit more of a surprising pick compared to some of the bigger games but if i would have been with feast road and that was my entire budget it would have been like peace froden is my collection right yeah that winter get the awesome pick honestly that was it was one that i
it was it didn't quite make my short list because i crossed it off early only because of the price yeah i looked at it and i was like if i take winter kingdom there were too many others i'd have to leave off but in terms of games that like have a lot to explore like uh amazing pick okay sweet a little bit jealous of that one just play your copy yeah exactly that's that's the benefit of us both doing this technically we spent two hundred dollars yeah exactly uh okay so my second pick was 18.89 and this is twice as clever so i was looking for a game that i could play solo and play with up to a large player account as well which is covered in twice as clever but also one i guess my assumption here was what if i don't have the app again i'm like i'm the one to grill you i'm saying what about the app i'm the one i'm the one at the cabin with no phones and no reception or nothing um but also like it's a game that you know i wouldn't play the app version with like two or three or four players right so yeah so it functions as a game that i can sit down by myself i'm looking for something to do and play a game when i'm living off the grid with no television and video games electronics this is something i can play um and also it's just such a such a fun game to play with other people i almost went with uh that's pretty clever but me personally that's when i played more so i'll have more to explore and twice as clever than i would and that's pretty clever i'm surprised you didn't go with clever cube then because it's the one we played the least well it is the one i played the least well i played the app a bunch of times oh fair enough but but clever cubed is one that i haven't decided if i if i even like it but as much as twice as clever like i have to play both those more to know for sure
this is a bit of a safer a safer pick that way but i love rolling rights uh i love games that offer variety between like solo play and you know multiple players and are good at every player count and i think this is one of those games so this is one that'll be easy for me to teach to people i'll play on my own it'll never be one where i'm like i have four games and one of them just never hits the table right yeah so that is that's a good pick twice as clever what's your running total are you not keeping track uh my writing total is 68 69 basically 69 something somewhere around there yeah uh then i have so for uh 16.99 um i have enchanted plumes and that's because one enchanter plus plumes plays up to six so i have a game that now hits higher player counts so i if people come over and i have six people they don't have to say i don't have any games that we can play which is something that was important to me to have one it's an easy one to teach it plays well at two as well so it has a nice variety um and it has that uh again because i was trying to go outside the box there were other kenitse games and i will say right now i don't have a single kanita game on this list and and again that was part like i don't have any uva games in this list either that was mostly mostly intentional because i was trying to be a little bit you know different with my picks but enchanted plumes just i guess it's the closest feeling of a game i have to knit the game i think in that small package though we talked about how reminiscent it was of lost cities exactly games like that yeah so rather than pick lost cities which again i played so much that anyone who plays with me that hasn't already played it is going to feel like they're you know behind and also it's only two-player game i went with enchanted plumes that has that same feel plays up
to six it'll scratch that same itch for me it's a it's a small box i only have four games i like they don't have a huge calyx shelf so somewhere i can easily slide something on there besides lost cities can also be is on board gamereen i know you didn't plan for that but just be thankful that yes we have to remember i live off the grid with no electricity and no running water just with people coming over to play boardians uh so that was 16.99 which is my total to i guess like 85 ish or 80. basically my my end total comes out to 96.50 or something like that um so this is even just dollars on the table well hang on i can buy some like drinks and chocolate bars for the group i thought about the well-being games it's a gift card for you know what i'm saying we'll play it we'll play a game with the bottle caps or something like that okay uh my last pick um is i was having trouble finding something that i wanted to slot in for a small amount but i also wanted something on this list that i haven't personally played a bunch i've only played like say ones don't own that i could also have a game that i'm adding to my collection that i get to discover like more plays of it's not just what other people are introducing into and one game that i played only once and really really enjoyed and uh eventually in my collection is five two one one uh so it's only ten dollars i found it actually on sale for ten dollars because normally it's more expensive than it would have been able to fit on this list but it's a game that i really really enjoyed super easy to teach it is just another kind of simple card game like enchanted plumes but i feel like starting a collection with games that are accessible like that while i still have a large game like winter kingdom which still makes sense and it's a game that i would get to
explore a whole bunch more because i've only played at the one time really enjoyed it wanted anyways now i get to start with a game that's not in my collection so like out of these games winter kingdom and five two one one are in my collection so it'd be two games that i sort of get to you know have new games add to my collection and both enchanted plumes and twice as clever are but they're ones that i know i would come back to a lot so cool that brings my full total toy it's like 96 dollars in some cents so i have like three dollars and some to spare but uh i can buy a keyboard that's true i won the single agent of ascension deck just so i can like look at the cards maybe or maybe you'll get the sleeves or maybe i'll get something super rare sell the deck make like 30 bucks and then use that to buy games and then i can get modern art still that's actually okay you can't cancel it out so what i do with this last little bit is i buy an age of ascension deck i sell that for a profit then i buy modern art and then that's how i finish the line but how do you ensure that it's a valuable deck that will sell for more you don't have to put that let me worry about that the ones that uh i want i actually at different points had on this list and ended up bumping around uh where seven wonders duel i tried really hard to get that on the list but again part of what i ended up with me not putting on was that it was only two players um and it's one that i personally played so much already but it does it has lots of longevity it's one i it was the last thing i eliminated off this list for something yes on board gamer yeah a lot of these actually are castle burgundy's another one i consider the kingdom builder before i thought of winter kingdom patchwork um canisiu games in general santorini i thought of as well a century i thought of too it's just it's a little pricey because of the production value it's almost 40 bucks it's a big chunk of
your hundred dollars to put towards it but yeah and then i had it i had modern art as well um but i again i thought you were gonna have it on yours right so yeah i went a little bit more outside the box with mine but uh but you know at least it gives you two different flavors if you're someone who's watched this video because you specifically found a hundred dollars you're like i want to get into tabletop gaming now you can pick one of our lists if you want and i mean i guess if you're in canada and go and buy all these games yeah i'm a little yeah looking just at our both of our collections again here uh i don't really have like the the kind of big strategy game to like dig into over and over like over time right like you have with winter kingdom i think that's definitely a weakness in mind as well as again there's no solo game in mind right right or nothing that can even play solo at all i also don't have any party games and i think most i think yeah modern art and the crew mission deep sea go up to five players but i don't have anything that goes above five and you definitely have enchanted plumes up to six at least which is nice i mean i have i have two games that are essentially just card games so there's like there's different holes in each of ours and like yeah i have two card games a role in right and then a strategy game there's nothing really in between where you have sort of like the blue lagoon like uh middle level board games so it's hard to get encompass like everything you'd want to in an initial 100 collection yeah you kind of have to have a gap like i also don't i also don't have like a work replacement game which is something i would like is a crime i wouldn't have started those are usually pretty expensive unless you're getting like a very intro level one yeah i thought about like you have a co-op game i don't think so yeah and no party game either yeah no yeah there was other ones i considered as well i that i didn't write down uh for that like i thought about clank as a deck builder as well and and stuff i
thought about do i you know i don't own dominion do i get it so i have a deck builder as well but like i almost had the quest for el dorado but i was like honestly i already had modern art and blue lagoon i'm like i'm not putting three canezia games on here and i couldn't leave one of those off in favor for it but yeah yeah it's a really tough list to make yeah and those are our lists uh obviously with a video like this we are super uh interested how you guys would start uh collection 100 obviously use your own personal uh currency wherever you live let us know in the comments for a hundred dollars and it's a hard hundred dollars you can't go like a dollar over if you had a single hundred dollar bill unless you're a really good negotiator you're gonna like negotiate with your local game store but uh you then we're gonna need proof of that yes exactly we need it in writing let's say like in writing send us a letter that says yes i will allow this person to float one dollar until they earn it or something uh let us know in the comments how you would restart your collection with a hundred dollars uh what you think about the the picks we made if there's any like clear gaps uh how mad you are at me for not including the canezia game if uh how much shame i have to face for that i know and thank you very much put the game of thrones shame clipping oh yeah absolutely yeah exactly so yeah let us know in the comments otherwise uh let us know also if you like videos like this that are you know more a little bit like relaxed and just like kind of fun topics like this obviously we we enjoy making them we want to make sure you guys enjoy watching them um anything else you want to add no that's it it was a lot of fun thanks so much for watching and we'll see you next time