Shelf of Shame Board Game Challenge 2025 | Wargames | Historical Gaming
Transcript
hi everybody I'm Zilla Blitz and welcome to the 2025 shelf of Shame challenge what is the shelf of Shame challenge you may ask this is the challenge where I try tried to play a subset of the rather large collection of board games tabletop historical War Games specifically that I have on my shelves that I have yet to play or fully play to my defense I was gone from tabletop wargaming and historical gaming for about 20 25 years when I get back into it I put aside a little bit of money to buy some of the iconic games that have come out in the past 20 years and a good number of them however are sitting still on the Shelf have yet to been played new games lots of excuses I could do all that but the goal here is to start making progress chipping away at those games on your shelves that have yet to be played with that in mind here's the plan I'm going to take 20 games on my historical board gaming my War gaming shelf of Shame and I'm going to put them in a spreadsheet and the goal is to play at least 10 of those games in the calendar year 20 25 that's roughly one a month with a month or so you know two months for kind of messing up completely to be fair I did try one of these challenges last year where I put 10 games on the Shelf of shame I started in late February March kind of thing I did manage to play three of them which is not really all that good but this year is going to be different this year I'm going to play all 10 or more now I'm going to play a lot of other games new games other games and things like that but this is a subset an absolute must subset of the shelf of
shame that I want to play in 2025 couple things about this too I'm going to name 15 of the 20 games but three of the spots are going to be People's Choice Awards so after you hear the games that I name and I know a lot of you know games I've played and haven't played over the past year two three years or so uh drop some suggestions Down Below in the comments and I'm going to pick three of those and add them to the list and I'm going to try to play at least two of the three People's Choice Awards here and then the last two spots I'm going to leave is what I call audibles so those are going to be choices that I can make along the way where I decide that I really want to play one of the iconic games on my shelves that I just didn't include in the list at the beginning of the year one last thing before we jump in and talk about the list of games this video is sponsored by Noble Knight games if you're if you like some of the games you hear in this list Noble Knight games from Wisconsin which ships all across the planet can be a great source of these games especially if they are older out of print games they often have pretty reasonable prices on some of the stuff that can be hard to find in places other than like eBay and such like that but they have a very wide selection of War games and if you do use the links down below to get something from the the site thank you very much as it uh it helps get a small percentage of that that purchase as it comes in so thank you to all the people that have done that in the past and continue to do it in the future also before we start I have a spreadsheet that's publicly viewable I'll put a link to it down below that's going to show my progress through the shelf of Shame challenge you'll notice in here the game names which I've deleted because I want to keep them secret for the moment uh and then some notes and then I've got a percentage played the idea is to play them roughly three times each until I feel like I've played the game game because the first time you play a war
game you you're just kind of fudging through the rules you don't have it down so I've generally got I have kind of unique CR criteria to qualify as a game as being played in The Challenge and I'll spec kind of build those out as we go through the challenge during the course of the Year all that being said let's walk through the 15 games that are on the Shelf of Shame challenge for 2025 first up dday at Omaha Beach this is one of the carryovers for last year I'm carrying over the games that I didn't play from last year so the first seven are those games uh this course is Iconic soliter Game World War II beach by John Butterfield I've played it a number of times but I haven't played it so my goal is to play it more times and get closer to winning I'm not sure if I will ever win against this game but I at least want to feel like I've really gotten much closer to winning second game pass of Glory World War I strategic level game point-to-point game that has a whole family of games underneath it I also want to try this one with Stuka joo's soliter system to be able to play this one here and I think I'm going to be playing a game uh with Nathan from legendary tactics who was on the channel the other day talking about his 10 war games of best war games of all time next up another hold over from last year fire in the lake I've played a good bit of coin over coin counterinsurgency games from GMT over the last couple years but fire in the lake is one of the iconic games in this series I've yet to play it so that one's on the list as well and kind of continuing on that theme of D-Day at Omaha Beach another iconic soloer game is enemy action ardens also by John Butterfield the classic World War II battle of the the Bulge game that's a two-player game and you can
play with kind of an AI opponent playing as the Germans or kind of your AI bot system playing as the Allies so many people have told me this is their favorite soliter game and it still lies unplayed on my shelf the shelf of Shame is so embarrassing next up was the People's Choice Award from The Mark simonic apostrophe XX series which is Holland 44 it's a carryover as well from last year the nice thing about this one is that they've come out with a new printing that's kind of updated some of the error not erors but some of the atata has been built into to it and I did was able to get that so I'll have the the latest version of Holland 44 to be able to play for this one the next two are the last two carryovers from last year and honestly they they probably are the most embarrassing games in the shelf of Shame challenge Empire of the Sun Mark Herman's classic World War II game I've seen people play it I've learned halfway through the game at a number of conventions and seen people play and watch gameplay and stuff such an iconic game with both solitire and two player I mean one of the the classic games in the wargaming category and yes I've yet to play it so this one is getting played for sure and another classic that often comes up in the soliter best soliter games conversation RAF Battle of Britain by decision games where you can play as either the German or the British Air Force for the Battle of Britain in this fantastic solit it plays two player as well but a fantastic soliter system recreating the entire campaign of the Battle of Britain that's the last hold hold over from last year now we're going into new games nominated for this year this new game on the Shelf of Shame challenge has such an Ardent Following on I've seen a number of game plays and I actually went to a session
at SD hit Hon's winter convention where there was a demonstration on how to play so I feel like I've got a pretty good idea on what to do but I'm talking about Combat Commander Europe or or Pacific any one of the Combat Commander games let's do with that and I this is one I've been looking for to play it's also not incredibly difficult to jump into but such a wide and Ardent and devoted fan base I feel like I really want to play this one so I'm looking forward to having this one on the Shelf of Game Challenge next new game on the list so the other day when Nathan was talking about his top 10 war games of all time he mentioned ambush from Victory point games an older classic game and someone in the comments said that Ambush and combat are basically the same game same system same type of game I have that combat game from Compass games and I really really want to try it so I've put that one on the list instead of Ambush I'm probably going to get wailed on in the comments for doing this but I know there are a lot of people out there that say combat is incredibly awesome also soliter Game World War II individual Soldier level combat just a classic soliter game to explore and the third one is coming out sometime this year as well but I definitely want to get that into that played category next one gives a little bit of leeway here I'm calling it something leader so the first game I came back when I came back to wargaming was Sherman leader it was the game that got me back into the hobby I've since picked up a few of the other leader games but they with the campaigns they take a while to kind of get through and you want to kind of dig through and play a campaign but this year I want to play something one of the other leader games
that I have I'm leaning now towards kind of B7 leader but you could probably convince me to play a different one the next two games actually are a direct result of the conversation with Nathan from legendary tactics the other day this one is upfront the individual soldiers kind of squad level combat game with cards the classic game I recently did get this one actually from Noble Knight games it just came a few weeks ago so I'm really excited to dig in and learn this system and there is a local friend nearby who said he's played the game a ton so I think we're going to get together and play some two-player of this one soon also from the conversation with nathany his I've been wanting to play this one for a long time anyway but his conversation really made me realize that no I have I really want to play this one skies above the right I'm also giving myself the alternative to play skies above Britain one of those two games really want to play a campaign with those this year feel like it's a classic soliter game and the fact that I haven't played it yet is kind of embarrassing all of these are shelf of Shame right I me usually call it shelf of opportunity but this is yeah some of these I really need to play three more to go and the next one actually is going to have a special announcement video coming up pretty soon Advanced squad leader yes I played squad leader a long time ago and I've played some of the starter kit games um but I'm gonna dig in a little bit to advanc squad leader and and I don't want to make it the lifestyle game that it can be but I want to understand how to play it play it and play some Advanced squad leader and that's one of the goals for this year and this one one I'm pretty sure is a definite this one is going to happen this year for reasons I'll explain in
some other videos coming up later this month game number 14 is from Legion games it's their bestselling game Target for today uh which really is kind of an extension of the older I think B7 Queen of the Skies game with a little bit more detail a little bit more fleshed out heard so many people say good things about this one you basically control a World War II bomber and have a campaign series missions over mission of missions over Europe in World War II heard such fantastic things about it I really want to give it a shot and it's been staring at me on my shelf of Shame for way too long game number 15 is one that I know will come up in the comments if it wasn't put in this list uh the World War II W Warf Fighter game I only have one Warf Fighter game from daners and games so it has to be this one but I do have a World War II Warf Fighter game and I've seen people play it and I know I'm going to love it it has to go on the list that is my 15th game and there you have it there are five open slots on the Shelf of Shame challenge Down Below in the comments I'd be curious will you have a shelf of Shame chall this year if so tell me about it I'd love to hear about it because there's a lot of different ways to organize these and there might be ideas for how I might be able to modify mine or improve mine and things like that uh but I would also like to hear your suggestions for games I should add to this list many of these games I'm not sure if I will make video content on all of these games I certainly will be making video content on some of these games so by all means drop it down below what are your favorite games that you think I haven't played yet and uh you put put more than one put two put three I'd love to hear from you and then the last two spots again are going to be audibles that I can just say oh nope I'm going to put this one in and play it so if I can kind of spontaneous playing of
the shelf of Shame there thanks everybody for watching if you've enjoyed this video you may also enjoy some of the playthroughs on the channel I'm putting a link up here to the men of iron aent Court scenario that we played a long time ago is one of my favorite games to play one of my favorite soliter games because of the system there of course it's good two-player as well but uh there is a three-part series on the Battle of aent Court available on the channel you might enjoy watching that thanks for watching everybody have a great day