Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Low Rated Board Games - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 17:47

hey everybody and welcome to my top 10 board games that are rated poorly on board game geek now to be honest i'm not normally one of those people who put a lot of stock or investment into board game geek rankings or ratings um however as a general rule and over the years i've come to learn that any games that are rated 6.5 or below on boardgamegeek normally turn out to be pretty bad now that is personal experience however all these games on this list are an exception to that rule and i think these games range from being decent to pretty damn excellent but before i get into my top 10 i want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kianda dot co dot uk we get a bunch of great games with some great um loyalty schemes and discounts so i highly encourage you check out their great website and use my link below to get five percent off your first order but without further ado let's get started with the list at number 10 i have mammoth which is a simple family weight set collection game but i think this one should be rated higher than the 6.3 that it is rated simply because of how unique it is so the way this game works at least in terms of the scoring is as you'd probably expect with a lot of set collection games where you want to have you know the most of these types of symbols all these types of symbols are worth you know x amount of points each or don't have the least of these symbols they're very simple stuff however the way that you collect these different icons and symbols is extremely interesting as at the start of the game or the round you're going to have a bunch of these different tokens in the center of the table and on your turn you can take as many of those tokens as you like into in in front of you to claim them as your

own then it will go to the next player who can do the same they can either take from the middle you know any any denomination they want or they can take all the um collections from another player and move it in front of them minus one token and they'll put that that spare token back into the center of the table so what will happen eventually is that everybody will kind of be satisfied by exchanging and removing one putting it back into the middle and they'll be satisfied to the point where you're happy with your little horde and then the points will be divided out you'll play that out of a certain number of rounds and then the winner will be the person with the most victory points that is pretty much the extent of mammoth but as i said i've never seen that kind of greedy mechanism being used before so yeah lots of things to consider here a bit of mental math that you need to balance out i think you know is he gaining more than me am i doing the best here i don't want to fall behind on this so it's actually a game that keeps you on the edge of your seat you know you need to really be on the ball and see what other people are doing to keep up with other players and some of the scoring criteria and you know what it's a pretty damn fun game that you can get played in 30 to 45 minutes and um to be honest the few things i've had of this one i've really enjoyed at number nine i have robber knights or expedition luxor depending on which version you have and this is an abstract tarp placement and kind of area control style game designed by rudiger dawn and this game actually uses the same mechanism that rudiger dawn is most known for um through his game's istanbul or genoa and this one you are essentially laying these tiles out every single round and then every now and then you will spawn these castles and these castles will let

you claim or take a bunch of your disks in a tower and then just like in istanbul you are moving from disk or from tile to tile depositing disks as you go and spreading out and basically you're trying to control these regions by the end of the game however as the game develops people can start overlapping your discs with their own to basically nullify your power in those regions and the different terrain types require different types of or a different amount of discs to go on them so it's a very abstract very blocky style game but there is some pretty interesting decisions here you know how are you going to pace yourself you don't want to commit too early because you're leaving leaving yourself vulnerable to be covered up by the other players um and again you want to lay out the ball to suit you you can put these kind of mountains down to block other people as well or make them waste a bunch of discs to get into your areas it's actually a very clever game and as i said i think if you if you enjoy abstracts i think there's a lot here that deserves your attention just to cast your eye over it because there is some pretty um it's pretty throat but some pretty interesting concepts here very simple rule set but it works for me and definitely think it deserves more than the 6.1 rating that it has on board game geek at number eight i have sunken city by wolfgang kramer and michael keisling and this is certainly one of kramer and kiesling's forgotten designs it's certainly been lost to the annals of time this is top going back 20 years or so ago when this one was released um but this is a unique game as you are trying to basically use your player piece to run around all these different um kind of

sunken cities and then collect the treasure from those cities and get back to your base to deposit them and it's basically a race to get all the different types of treasure from this huge chunky building blocks that you're putting on the board as you go however the twist on this game is that every round the there's a neptune token that's a neutral player piece that's going to run around on these different pathways and sync the pathways that you've already laid and if you have any treasure on you at that time when you're sunk then you're gonna lose all the treasure you captured so it's a kind of a pushy luck game you're gonna run and get a bunch of stuff and get back to your base safely you want to manipulate it so neptune's not near you and it's going to you towards your opponents and you know what it's a lot of silly fun and i really enjoy my time with this one um again it's very simple the way it works but there's some pretty clever card playing it as well because you have a fixed bunch of cards in your hand with different movement types on them and um you need to use those accordingly you know are you going to move this amount of spaces or are you going to save that higher movement card for later and you know what it's a really dynamic style game it does feel very different to anything else out there i'm not gonna say that it's a perfect game because it's not sometimes it can be quite frustrating because you've got a whole bunch of treasure but then someone syncs you but at the end of the day that's probably your fault for being a bit greedy and trying to get things done too quickly but a lot of fun to be had with sunken seti and i think it deserves more than the 6.2 racing it has on board game geek at number seven i have flea market by sid saxon this is actually the lowest rated game on this list with a pretty

poor rating of 5.5 out of 10. but i actually think this game is really clever and it's grown on me a lot since the time i've had this one in my own collection so this is a simple bidding style game however you have no control over your bids whatsoever you're gonna have a bunch of these items ranging from three all the way up to eighteen which corresponds to um you know the cumulative value of three dice being rolled then all you're gonna do is gonna rub those three dice the item corresponding to that daiso is gonna come up for auction and all people are gonna roll two dice of their own color and that that's going to determine the bids that you can use to buy the items come up for sale however the people who've rolled the highest value or the player who's rather highest is going to have first refusal on that item but are going to have to pay the value that they've rolled so again the higher roles are good because they give you first priority to buy things but it costs you more money and if it's refused it'll go down to the next player and so on the reason you want to collect these items is because if these like if these numbers ever rolled again then you will get a fixed sum of money and as the game goes on that money is going to increase so the kind of more commonly rolled numbers are a lot more valuable because they're going to get rolled more and more often but they're going to be more expensive to do so and if they come out for a resale again then people can actually buy them off you but give them money to you to um you know for them to obtain it so a really clever little back and forth game and very luck dependent but there is some good swings here that are actually really enjoyable and it's a nice quick 20 minute game that is a lot of fun and i really encourage you to give this game a bit of attention and if you like really aren't i mean talking

featherweight games then this one is right up there for me so that is flea market at number six i have celtus by reina kenitzia which is rated a 6.4 out of 10. so celtics is actually the board game version of one of kenitzy's most famous and most revered games lost cities however lost cities is a strictly two-player game this one can play up to four players and to be honest the dna the dna of these games is almost identical you're doing the same thing trying to build these runs of cards in different colors um but in this one instead of trying to um you know tot up your numbered amounts to score points this one you're trying to climb these different tracks associated to a different deck of cards and as you climb these tracks you're going to start acquiring more and more points and you can even get these little chain reaction bonuses where if you climb this track it will let you climb this track which will let you look on this track and you can take some pretty clever and satisfying turns so that's pretty much the extent of the game it's just managing your hand it could be frustrating at times as you're playing things in order you take a gap in that order and then all of a sudden you draw the card that you needed to get you kind of more life out of that tower but still a lot of fun to be had here it plays in about half an hour 45 minutes um if you like lost cities but you are you feel constrained by the two-player account this is certainly one for you to um at least get paid some attention to because it is a lot of fun to be had as well designed there's two variations of the board you can play the simple mode or you can play the more advanced mode and you know what i've enjoyed every single game i've had of celtics i think it's a lot of fun and um it should be rated

more highly number five i have the most recent game on this list this is splitter so splitter is actually a roll and right style game and i will have to say this is actually one of my favorite roll and write style games it's a very simple one and it kind of is a bit of a throwback to when rather my games were a bit more pure a bit easier to understand but i still think the decisions in this game are really interesting and the concept itself is a lot of fun so essentially you're going to have this sheet you're going to roll a pair of dice and on this pair of dice obviously you're going to have two numbers when you place one number you have to place the opposite number on like a mirrored image on the other side of your sheet and what you're trying to do is you're trying to create these different clusters of numbers um depending on the pit value so you want the one pit values on their own you want twos in pairs you want threes in you know in triples you want fours a group of four together and so on and as you do that you can get more and more points you've got these double bonuses as well if you get them if you get a completed set on the double marker and it's such a little restrictive puzzle that you need to map out you need to sometimes just roll the punches and do the best with a bad roll and you know what i've enjoyed every single game of this one as well you're talking about a 15 minute game it costs less than 10 pounds to buy very portable um you can teach this one to anybody and it's an absolute blast to play it has been a consistent hit since i've had this on my in my collection and hopefully this is going to be more widely distributed because i think some people are having trouble getting their hands on it i'm really surprised to see this has only rated a 6.4 on board game

deep because i thought this would be at least a seven because it is that accessible and that much fun so that is splitter definitely a recommendation from me if you enjoy your role and write style games and number four i have crossed words which is rated a 6.5 out of 10. now of all the games on this list this is probably what i can understand why people might not like it not because the game or anything wrong with the game at all but it just might not be people's tastes so crosswords is a word association style game as you have a bunch of these clues basically on the vertical and horizontal axes and where these cross over you need to give a clue that's resp that kind of correctly associates to both of those clues so it might be something like um maybe an animal on one axis and then the other one is like a superhero so all that you might want to put like black panther or something because again it's a superhero and an animal and so on so you can be very creative in the clues that you give with this sometimes the um the corresponding axes are very difficult for you to think of things but sometimes you just pull out the draw in your mind and you'll come out with an absolutely blinding answer and so yeah it gives you lots of room to be creative um and i just think this is a lovely experience a great party game that you can play in five minutes so it's literally set the game up set a timer for five minutes and you've got that much time to get all your clues down a lot of fun again if you like playing with words you like kind of um you know associating words together and tagging one word with another one then this is an absolute blast to play um one of my favorite parts games i think is

criminally underrated and a hell of a lot of fun so that is crossed words at number four at number three i have strictly a two-player game with ka-ching which actually goes all the way back to the year 2001 so we're talking over 20 years old when this game was released however i still think this game holds up remarkably well and it almost feels like an evergreen because of how simple and pure it is because of the pure attention the game offers and just the complete streamlined beauty of it so this is a kind of a mathematical game as you're trying to get as much money as you can and you're gonna do that by drafting cards from these five columns of seven cards so these cards are only going to have a color associated to them and also a number and all you're going to do on your turn is you're going to do one of two things you're going to draft a card and add it to your hand and pay for it or you are going to combine a pair of matching colored cards and multiply the scores with one another or the number on them so if i draft a three i draft a six and then i spend my time to combine them together then i'm going to get 18 money back in return which will allow me to buy more cards and stuff going forward a very tight game one you have to be very conscious of the opportunities you're leaving your opponent and honestly i really can't find fault with this one i think this is an excellent two-player game and i think maybe it's been lost to the annuals of time but i think this one deserves a replay it deserves to be in more people's collection if only more people knew about it so highly highly encourage

you check out kaching and this is criminally rated at 6.4 i can't even understand that great game and up yeah highly recommend it at number two i have el caballero which is actually another wolfgang kramer game however this time it is not a co-design with michael kiesling it is actually with um with richard ullwick who just so happened to be the co-designer of the great el grande which just so happens to be my favorite game of all time and i think that might be one of the key reasons why this one isn't rated so highly is because it lives in the shadow of the great el grande however they are very different styles of games one is you know a pure area majority game this one is a more of a tile placement style game with some area control in it as well as you're placing tiles onto the board these tiles are gonna have a kind of a sea mass on them or a land mass and you are also donating these player um tiles of the board of your color which you can actually manipulate as the game goes on and all these different tiles can have different numbers on each kind of edge on them and you can increase them as you go to combat back and forth for control of these regions uh there's some additional rules you can add in as well to wrap up the complexity and i have to say this is probably one of my favorite top placement games out there it's in my collection and i enjoy it a lot i think maybe another reason why this one isn't rated so highly is because some of the rules are a little bit ambiguous not because they're not clear but because it doesn't give you a definitive set of rules to how to play the game optimally it kind of says things like if you're going to play this amount of rounds then you can do if you want to play with this rule then you can do i'd rather have a

concrete set of rules recommended by a great designer like wolfgang kramer to say this is how you play the best version of el caballero but i think once you find your groove with this one you are really going to enjoy it and criminally underrated though this is up there with the best car placement games and i adore it so that is el caballaro at number two and finally at number one i have verbunk so out of all these games this is the one that i absolutely cannot find any reason as to why it is rated as low as it is only 6.4 out of 10. that to me is baffling this is a fantastic almost like a party plus plus bluffing style game as you are trying to get as much money as you can and you're going to start this game with a bunch of these different tables in the big ring you're going to have your own player piece on it and all you do on this game is you start distributing money out onto these tables and then you play these cards in player order secretly they're either going to be to clean the money from one of these tables to trap another player who goes to that table so give someone last night table they've taken the money you trapped them then you're going to get all the money from them that they would have taken or you've got a pure bluffing card that does nothing that's all this game does i love the pacing of this one as i think in the first round you put a little bit of money down the second round you put a bit more the third round you put a bit more you've got bluffing you're double bluffing the trapping mechanism is great the win the player order works is great honestly as far as high player camp games go that you don't want a silly social deduction game or anything like that this is pretty much as good as it

gets if i have five or six players this is almost a banker every single time what a brilliant las vegas feeling style game and um honestly i couldn't recommend this one enough if you like interactive high stakes high energy style gameplay then the bank is fantastic and criminally underrated if people are putting this at a 6.4 out of 10. again i cannot even understand why that is so there we go those are my top 10 games that are rated poorly on board game geek hopefully there's something up here that has caught your attention something that you weren't so aware of probably because it is ranked so low um however i do get i do stand behind these games i think they're all really good rating too pretty damn excellent at the top end of that list so again i hope you've enjoyed it if you have please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too additionally if you want to go the extra step then i do have a patreon campaign which i'd obviously love you to uh to join in and be sure to check out the show sponsor kian.coda uk who are my go-to online retailer in the uk but for everybody else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye now

Progress saved