Skip to main content
Loading video...

Rate My Shelf - Keep or Cull - Board Games - Episode V

Transcript 19:16

thank you hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences we'll get on with the show in just a minute but first a quick word for my sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solution head down to my new sponsor kiander.co.uk kielder stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on ultra's over 30 pound further discounts on bulk purchases and even five percent of your spending refunded bacteria's points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get five percent discount on your first order over 60 pounds so let's make gaps in your collection a thing of the past get down to kinder and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it I'm sorry I'm sorry I'm sorry I cannot believe how long it's been since I've done one of these I said there was going to be a series and it is going to be a series I still want to do this but it was early July when I put out the last episode of this I cannot believe it's been two months and I haven't bothered to do another one of these I must have been so busy with like you know reviews and other content in the late district holiday in that oh my God I am sorry guys subtle this is basically where I go and choose a square on my calyx randomly and basically pull out all the games and give my thoughts on the games after I've played them enough times and they've been in my collection for ages and say whether they are Keepers for life or potential coals

should I need to make space for them not to say I'm gonna get rid of them immediately but more am I going to call them if the need arises and of course we'll try to focus more on this and not on everything that's going on down there because I am playing the hell out of the Lost ruins of aranak expansion for a future video and so well that's kind of taken up all the table space at the moment but this is a shelf in my study room over there you see it in the background whenever I've done the previous top 10 list although once I start doing more top 10 lists I'm actually going to start doing them in here now so uh you won't see that backdrop anymore but there's four games on the shelf and I must admit I don't go to the Shelf very often this one is one that kind of a gloss past with the exception of one game in here which I do like to pull out every now and again but the other three we have not been played in some considerable time and that's a little worrying but are they all potential coals well let's see so let's start off with Sheriff of Nottingham this is a dice tower essential Arcane wonders this is the first edition of it so I don't have the second edition version I've had this for years and it's basically a really cool social deduction blocking game you are basically Merchants trying to sneak stuff in past the sheriff and make money for goods but those goods could be legal they could be illegal and so you are essentially drawing cards and populating your little popper bag here with stuff in the goods and you're passing them to the sheriff and you're making your claim saying it's four chickens free bread whatever or you could even tell the truth and say there's conjure band in there if you're really that uh much of a gambler but what you're essentially hoping is that

the sheriff probably doesn't open your bag at least if you're trying to sneak stuff in they're not if you are telling truth and he looks in your bag then you get compensation and money which is great you're almost trying to go with the sheriff into opening your bag but if you are trying to sneak stuff through you're hoping the sheriff doesn't open yours and you open somebody else which might require you to bribe them lies me baby Jesus Christ the sort of idea I really enjoy now this has got the merry men expansion in it and I only really use one or two modules in the merry men expansion I mean it's a decent expansion overall and there are a couple of things like the laws and stuff that I do like to use but it's not an essential expansion if you haven't got merry men it really doesn't matter but you know I love these pop-up bags you know I love the artwork on these cards certainly use the house rule that I think I mentioned in my top 10 which is you only have one discard pile none of this garbage about two discard piles that's kind of nonsense and if you have the app on your phone introduce a timer you cannot have the sheriff phase drag on for ages otherwise you'll never finish this game you need to keep it on a timer now here's the problem and pulled this out in a while it's been a long time since I pulled it out and I don't know exactly why maybe it's because I haven't played a lot of social deduction games lately perhaps I was getting a little bit burnt out on the genre and decided I wanted to play other things that's probably a factor even though I still enjoy social production games but I certainly don't like to play subpar social deduction games now I mean certainly you won't catch me playing you know some of the you know old the old

like resistance ones and stuff which are decent enough social production games but I didn't know they just got a bit samey after a while I don't even play one night werewolf anymore I prefer wear words I still like deception murder in Hong Kong that's really good I still like this one um but I cannot stamp blood in the clock tower you know so there's it's kind of varying degrees of how much I like the genre now but I still really enjoy this game and I do want to bring it out again but it has been a while and it is a fragile game you can get people who you know play in a certain way or try to gamify it to much or just aren't expressive enough with the whole bribing aspect and they can sour the game a bit and maybe that's the problem maybe the fact that I there's too many people I know who probably would just make this game break apart but if you get the right group maybe have a drink or so play at a convention or something this is just a barrel of laughs so for me it's still a keeper but we're gonna have to like keep an eye on it maybe I'm gonna have to like get it to the table at some point soon in the sort of reassess that but I really enjoy this game it's still one I enjoy it but uh I don't know no no it's a keeper it's a keeper for now but we are going to uh do some research on this one here come the test results you are a horrible person so now we got the viral viral is a Hidden Gem really this one does not get talked about pretty much at all and yeah this is definitely the Arcane Wonder shelf now that I think about it and certainly The Dice Tower essential Shelf funny enough actually because that's Dice Tower

Essentials so is this and so is the next one well that was unexpected but basically viral is a game that I've touted the Praises off for a while you were basically viruses in a human system uh human body system and it's an area control mean like game so normally I don't like mean games but light mean games you know that are cutesy whatever you know I don't mind them I mean you'd give me something like barrage I'm gonna hate it's guts but that's like a three-hour dry dreary Euro that's mean as I'll get out this is just a harmless like you know one hour cutesy idea I mean yeah yeah your virus is in a human body for crying out loud it's cartoony and colorful and stuff so you're not meant to take it seriously the expansion I've put in here adds some cool way ways to sort of augment your virus which is cool I forget what it's called but uh you know I've shoved it in here and it's an easy fix but it's just a really cool like a cool concept because basically your viruses move around the system like you know different locations it's a majority control thing but you can get you can play cards onto your virus to kind of augment it with different abilities but your actions during the turn are essentially a hand management system of you know what actions do you want to do versus which location do you want to do them at and you can't spam the same location all the time so when you play cards in one particular cycle you've got to try and use other things before they get back to your hand so there is a little bit of planning involved so there's some clever aspects to this but the rules are super simple it's a good simple like game and one that I do like to bring out every now

and again it's just you know a clever system that never really got talked about nobody was talking about this even when dicero Central said we've got a new game coming out it's called viral and everyone was like who you know nobody heard of it and yet nobody was really gunning for it but honestly if you find this second hand bring them by and it's relatively cheap I mean certainly don't pay more than today's prices I mean somebody selling the second hand should not be selling it for more than 20 quid 25 tops but I would say 20 quid you find it for 20 quid I bring them by give it a shot it's just a really cool little game area control with some meanness but light meanness like you expect it in this game everybody's doing it to each other and it's even got a couple of systems where if somebody gets too powerful the doctors basically go you know stab you with a vaccine and go right you're getting too powerful boom let's bring you back down a notch so it's just it's cool it's clever it's a Hidden Gem it's a keeper for me though viral does the job for a light area control game and honestly have many area control games in the collection to my mind it's not one of my favorite mechanics so this one just seems to do it a little bit better than most all right Aquatica now this one's probably the more popular one of everything that's on my shelf on this one here and this has the expansion in it which I feel the cold water is Right which I feel this is a must buy because the goals in the first like base game are a bit meh whatever and they're not that interesting in the expansion you can replace them with these guilds that you can the tribes or whatever that you can

get which give you an ability and also are the end game timer but it mainly just adds a few more cards now you know Aquatica is you know one that had a bit of a Diffie rule book I must admit I had to print like reference guides in order to get the rulebook like firmly in my head it's not written very clearly and it's essentially a hand management game you get these little like manta rays that can give you bonuses and that and you're essentially almost a bit like I dare say the word Concordia using a hand management system where you play the cards and then at some point you've got to get them all back but you can acquire more cards as the game goes on it's fairly simple rules in terms of what you do with the cards but here's where the problem lies the meat of the game which is probably the more fun aspect is also its Achilles heel because you are essentially trying to complete as many of these locations as possible and I mean the artwork in this is gorgeous it looks really nice it's a well you know decent looking game but explaining how these locations work is very very fiddly and it's a big put off from this game you know I have to refresh myself with the rules because if I try to reference anything in the main rulebook I'm not going to succeed but trying to explain to people right okay so you know when you've got this in your like cool slide out board then this one lets you get an item this one there requires you to pay money this one gets you money when you do it but then by sliding this one up this means you get money but only for the next card that you're getting and this one gives you an instant push-up but it doesn't count as you're not what the hell are you talking about there's a lot of confusion with these and this becomes the like the biggest FAQ Madness

whenever I play this game because the iconography in this game is not intuitive and it's quite a fiddly system and it's kind of why I haven't brought this out in a while and I'm gonna say it I think this is a potential curl because I do enjoy the game but having to use this in order to relearn it all the time having to like go through a bit of fact to explain how the locations work and requiring the expansion to fix a problem with the base game on top does drop this a bit and I've been unwilling to bring It Off the Shelf in favor of other stuff now if other people want to play it and sort of teach it and just refresh my memory then I'll gladly jump in the game of this because I still think it's enjoyable but I forget what I gave it before probably like an 8 out of ten it's probably a seven at this point I still think it's good and I can recommend it but I do have some caveats with it and I just have not taken it off the shelf in a while in favor of other hand management style games despite it looking cool you know people will sort of compare this to Abyss they're nothing alike just because they're a water themed board games they are nothing alike and Abyss miles better anyway but yeah you know a subpar solo mode as well the solo Mode's not particularly interesting in this either so it's basically and 60 Minutes on the box yeah you wish you tried playing this in 60 minutes with four players that is not happening so it's variable time it's not a good solo it's got some fiddly rules it it they're all little things that put me off playing it so I still like it

it's still here for now but I'm gonna put this one on the cull section sorry sorry Aquatica we're sorry tribes of the wind the most recent game on the Shelf you gotta check out my review to see how much I have talked about this game in terms of being a Hidden Gem from last year's Essen this one had a lot of people interested in what it was like mainly because it looked gorgeous and had Vincent retreat's artwork all over it now I couldn't have cared lesser that had Vincent retreat's artwork on it yes he's a fantastic artist but he's not the reason I'd buy a game okay I didn't buy a game just because an artist had something to do with it you know but this one intrigued me because of its card system it kind of borrows a little bit from Hanabi but not entirely true so where's where's the cards I want to get yeah so I want to get these cards here to kind of showcase the idea is is simple premise and kind of think um if you're a Studio Ghibli fan think North soccer and the Valley of the win this one gave me a lot of Vibes for that from his artwork but the idea is is that you have a board and you're trying to build different locations on it and they're generic tiles it's basically tile placement but you can also put your little Villages and your little Villages and temples on it in order to gain special bonuses that's the Crux of what you're doing in the game and that may not sound interesting by itself but it's what you do to get there that's fun essentially what happens is you have all these different element cards so you've got water fire wind and you know forest and I'm sure heart would have been there but I guess they didn't want the five factions but the idea is is that all of

these cars have got different abilities on them and the the power of the ability is dictated by how many of these types of cards from the element you have and amoebers this is where the Hanabi bit kind of comes in there because you objectively have a stand and what you do is you place your cards face away from you so that you can see like the abilities obviously but everybody else can see your elements and so I might play a card here for example that says have I got two water nope well I can't play it then right can't play that card but then I've got one here that says uh for example do I have the least Forest amongst all me and my two neighbors well I've only got one Forest here he's got two he's got three I have the least so I get to do the main ability on this one to play a tile for a much cheaper and remove a cup of the pollution but that's what these cards are doing you're basically looking at the elements you have and your two neighbors so yeah four player and five player is not particularly useful in this game you're better off capping us at three players but it's this cool idea that is a very tactical game this is not strategy at all you have to basically look at the cards you've got think about what you're trying to do when you're bored but you're constantly reacting to what the uh your neighbors are doing because your neighbors might suddenly reset half their hand with a temple and now it's like ah great now they've changed their elements all over the place where does that put me but then you notice somebody's building up quite a bit of water and it's like well I got the water here that um allows me to do a lot for Neighbors having water I was gonna do that but you know what now is a good time to play this card you know and and so you get a lot of these opportunities

and I just find that so addictive it's easy to teach yes there's a lot of iconography but it's pretty intuitive as to how most of it works and it just is a really cool fun concept it's it feels like an Innovative Twist on the whole cards facing away mechanic and a good way to have the fact that you have two neighbors be meaningful yes the fourth player doesn't mean much and playing this with five is moronic I don't even know why they put it on the box it was a dumb idea stop it you're so stupid free player works great solar mode doesn't exist there is a fan made one on BGG but I've tried it it's not that great I wasn't a big fan so really this is a two to three player game ideally and that does limit it for me in some respects but I'd still play this with Forest if you've got to accept that that fourth player is kind of redundant but two player Works brilliantly in this because what happens is you and your opponent face each other but the display where you get these cards from are typically like five cards and you know on the thing like that the idea is is that this represents the dummy hand of another neighbor so you're looking at your opponent for a neighbor as well as this ever changing display and that's it that's how the two player system works and it's really cool you can play a good quick game of this as a two-player game I highly recommend it as such so trying to win was just a Hidden Gem I didn't know I would like it as much as I did I think I gave it a 10 out of 10 when I reviewed it now um 10 out of 10 maybe I mean I still

really really enjoy this game but maybe it's probably closer to a nine at this point I still would happily wholeheartedly give this a seal of Distinction I think it's that good of a game and one that needs to be played but maybe 10 was going a little bit too high perhaps I was just riding a high at that point but yeah I really enjoyed it of course it's a keeper I've played this many times I love showing it to people and as people sort of go oh this is quite cool yeah I'm enjoying this I'm liking this card player that's like yep got them in there you know is it perfect no no game ever is but I still think you need to give this one a look if you haven't already and you thought that card mechanic sounded good if you didn't like that sound of that card mechanic then well you're not gonna like the rest of this game so you know go by that means but by all means check out the review I did and watch me ride the buzz train for this one so there we go free Arcane Wonder Games tower Essentials and one boy did you European game free Keepers although one of them is a caveat and one car and yes don't worry I'm sorry I haven't been doing these episodes more regularly but despite the fact that uh midgard is literally this weekend and the fact that Essen is at the end of this month I will cater to get more of these episodes out so uh sorry guys sorry but I know you love them and I do love doing them as well because you know it's one thing to review games brand new to see oh this is the new hotness this is what I think of it pros and cons but it's sometimes good to just revisit stuff on your shelf and just have a think you know that you've had it for so long do you regret buying

it do you want to keep it what is it that's made it stay the test of time I find that that sort of stuff is a both interesting when I hear it on other videos but B also good for the consumer because a consumer wants to know if they're paying this much money for a game is it gonna stand the test of time and so you know it's all useful information so that's it for me on this video if you like what you see them please Thumb in that buyer on YouTube and let me know your comments on all four of those games do you like them do you love them do you hate them you know let me know your thoughts and any tips or whatever you've got for people who have bought these games like you know what expansions to get or how to play it or some BGG stuff then by all means let us know what you have to say so until next time remember regardless of whether you can make your decision on whether the keyboard or something it's still only a game so hurry up make up your mind take care and bye for now foreign

Progress saved