Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 5 games made better with house rules

Transcript 17:14

hey everybody welcome back to the dungeon dive Daniel here I hope you're doing well and if you're not I hope you are soon okay today on the dungeon dive we have a top five list and that is the top five games made better with house rules so a lot of the games that we enjoy at the dungeon dive are games that lend themselves well to house rules a lot of board games you don't want to play with house rules some of those real crunchy Euro games uh the games with a lot of strategy a games with uh with a lot of tactical decisions and competitive games you usually want to play those rules as written you want a Level Playing Field for everybody you want everybody to have access to the same uh list of rules so everybody can stay competitive and everybody is on the same page but a lot of the games that we play on the dungeon Di and that we like are games that are usually kind of Solo or co-op games that are more about the experience of playing it rather than the crunchy rules as written and so there are just a ton of games that I play with house rules and I know a lot of us do as a matter of fact I would be it would be very challenging for me to find to pick out a single game that I own that I play in any kind of consistent manner that I don't use at least one small house rule with I am a

huge proponent of house ruling and I think if you like it if there's a game that you somewhat like and there's just one little thing that you could change to make it better to make you like it more just make that change and a lot of the games that we play are kind of that kind of substitute for for a more of a a tabletop RPG experience and so those games also just lend themselves so easily to house ruling to modifying the game to customizing the game to make it exactly the game that we want to play at the time we want to play it so here are my top five games made better with house rules okay coming in uh first coming in at number five and that is runebound second edition so I have spent a lot of time and effort on the channel talking about runebound second edition and Third Edition uh Second Edition is one of my favorite games it's fantastic I also like Third Edition but I actually play Third Edition rules as written and I almost never play Second Edition rules as written even when I am playing with other people even when I am playing the game as a competitive game I almost always suggest at least a couple little house rules that help speed up the game and just make it a overall better experience so with room bound I love that kind of wide open sandbox nature of the game and the basic rules make it

very easy to modify and to change building upon those Core Concepts my favorite way to play the game are with it is with those fanmade card expansions that add various quests and encounters while you are exploring the hex crawl world I think think those decks of cards make the sandbox style gameplay more varied and more exciting those cards are available on artscow if you just Google runebound artscow you will find the runebound gallery on artscow and you can order them and when you play with those decks of cards it makes the game really feel like a big wide open kind of sandbox anything goes Style game and it does bring It uh closer to something like a solo RPG or a basic hex crawl and I just love the experience with those uh fan-made cards I also use a customized market system and I use some other rules for speeding up the gam such as faster leveling up if you want to see details of all of the way that I play runebound second edition you can check out my very detailed runebound playlist so that was number five runebound okay coming in at number four a game very similar to runebound but a little bit older and that is Talisman and I play Talisman second edition uh most of the time as a matter of fact that is I think that's

the only edition of Talisman that I own I own an incomplete copy of Third Edition but I love Talisman uh that goes without saying but a lot of that a lot of that love is pure Nostalgia and hey you know what that's okay it reminds me of a simpler time in my life I love that old school art and I like the way that the game makes makes me feel when I play it it's not a game I play for the mechanisms it's a game I play for the vibe for the adventure I think you could say hosman is a very simple game with a simple solid foundation and it is very easy to add rules to turn it into something um a little more engaging than rules as written so if you go to Talisman Island you will see tons uh Talisman island.com I think they're still open I think that's still a site you will see just hundreds and hundreds of fan-made expansions that people have made for Talisman it is insane there is a way you can play the game called super Talisman that uses dozens of boards it takes up four or five folding tables the long folding tables it's totally crazy there are so many fan-made expansions I don't play with a lot of fan-made expansions I play with rules that I think make the game more fun so I have released a detailed description of all of the house rules that I use to play Talisman on the dungeon dive patreon and I've demonstrated some of those rules in some videos on the channel so one of the things that I add is from later editions

and that is that fate token system basically a way that you can generate a currency that the players can spend in order to help mitigate luck I always like games that have a currency that you can spend to roll dice rolls or to avoid uh just to avoid bad luck things that help the player have more fun at the table uh I also use a deck of cards instead of rolling dice for movement and instead of rolling dice for combat I make a a custom deck of cards so I got this idea I think a long time ago people were talking about this on BGG and I just started playing the game like that and that is the only way I'll play now but you make a deck of cards uh depending on how many players you take uh numbers 1 through six and you make a deck of cards using cards one through six a playing cards and then you add a few jokers in which can be wild and you deal out a hand of six cards to each player and they have to spend those cards instead of rolling Dice and so it allows you to save some cards for combat and use certain cards for movement um I also play in any other situation you do have to roll the dice for any kind of like random roll on a card or anything like that and I also play a close enough rule where if you needed to get into those Corner spaces of the board on Talisman are the most important spaces on the board and so if you land adjacent to one of those Corner spaces in any region except for the middle region then

you can just move into that region and that does help speed up the game and there are also some ways that I uh play where it just makes the game Faster by being able to level up faster so a lot of the house rules for runebound and for Talisman are used to help make those games uh play faster because one of the major criticisms of those games that a lot of people have is that they are really long for what they are so number four is Talisman specifically Talisman second edition okay number three is uh Shadows of Brimstone and shadows of Brimstone I have spent a long long time talking about the house rules I use I have a a very very detailed uh playlist and within that playlist is a three episode series on how I play Shadows of Brimstone as a solo RPG hex crawl and when I play solo that is the only way that I will play Shadows of Brimstone now I am playing through the Vikings expansion the gates of ahalla with a group and with them I am playing uh rules as written sometimes when I'm playing with the group I will also introduce the hex crawl system to for so we can have a more kind of a complex campaign going on but when I I play solo I play with my own solo hex crawl system and I have so much fun with that so again I have a detailed series on how I do that but basically I play just the hex crawl mode uh combat is super

abstracted it's more like theater of the Mind in an RPG I don't use the tiles at all I just use the map cards for Dungeon diving and I generate open-ended questing using the hex crawl so it turns into this kind of big solo RPG hex crawl with a lot of cool components that I can use to help tell the stories so that was number three shadows of Brimstone okay coming in at number two is folklore the Affliction so the term RPG in a box is thrown around a lot in this sector of the tabletop gaming world we inhabit a lot of these games were indeed created to give that kind of feel and they were used to kind of scratch that itch when the group couldn't get together for a real RPG you know famously uh Tom Wham kind of designed mer wigs maze one of these prototypical adventure games to to be something that he could play when somebody in their D and D group was sick but something that was quick playing and something that would still scratch that Adventure game itch that the players around a D and D table would be looking for so folklore the Affliction is a game that gets really close to being an RPG in a box especially when you add that Adventure creation uh the farmers bundle the adventure creation uh expansion that makes it really really close to an RPG

and you could actually play the game as a traditional RPG with those rules however rules as written the game has way too much bookkeeping for me and it really is balanced for four different characters for four characters and I do not like playing folklore the Affliction with four characters it's just way too much for me to keep track of and I don't think it really works for two characters for fewer than four characters I should say and I like to play as two that's kind of my sweet spot with those kinds of games but um they do have some rules in the rule book for two Heroes and it just I don't think it really works so I've got a whole bunch of house rules that I use to play folklore the Affliction with only two characters and I have published those rules on the dungeon dive patreon so there are various things that I change when playing with two characters sometimes I completely ignore the stories in the campaign books I ignore the the the stories as written and I just play using the random Quest and event cards as a way to uh create a more open kind of sandbox feel to the game I've rebalanced a the number of hit points the enemies have to more properly scale down to two characters I've introduced a Target token system again this kind of like fate system this currency that you as the player can generate and spend in order to mitigate

bad luck I've introduced a a couple one extra action after a combat takes place on one of the battle maps so you as a player with only two characters have more chances to interact with the non- combat elements on the map I've also introduced a kind of catch your breath mechanism where after combat the players get to heal like a D3 worth of of either your life or I can't remember the other thing that you can heal in that game and I also use a modified market system to make it a little easier to find and buy the things that you need for your character build with those elements in place I think folklore the Affliction is a fantastic solo game using only two characters and I do have a lot of fun playing it and I it is a game that I really want to get back to the table soon so that was number two with folklore the Affliction okay and coming in at number one it's probably no surprise this is a game that I've been talking a lot about lately on the channel and that is heroquest either the original or the new version they are almost identical except for The Minis and some of the components so I've been talking a lot about heroquest U I've been talking more about heroquest the last year than I ever thought I would um it's a game that rules has written I don't really like I have no Nostalgia for it I've talked about that before on my super detailed video uh playlist and

so I have no Nostalgia for it and it just it's a game that I respect for its importance in drawing people into the hobby but it's just not a game that I would like like to play rules as written there are just better games out there now and there are better games at that complexity level however because the rules are so basic and because it comes with a lot of really inspiring stuff and it looks great on the table and it just it inspires your imagination to play in that world and because it's been around so long and has inspired lifelong fans who adored the game there are a ton of amazing house rules and created supplements out there with some of these I think heroquest is pretty damn great so I've gotone over a lot of these in great detail in previous videos so I won't be labor the point but to summarize if you're looking for something different it's probably already out there you probably don't need to create it yourself you don't need to reinvent the wheel just Google what you're looking for plus hero Quest and I bet you can find something that will get you very very close to being there if not not all the way there there are new Heroes there are new monsters there are new quests new rules new campaign rules new things to do in the Dungeons and things to do outside of the dungeons ways to connect your adventures together there are entirely new ways to play such as playing Co-op or solo and this is where I dwell this is my

wheelhouse playing these kinds of games solo there is the heroquest roleplay book which attempts to turn heroquest into a somewhat simplified Warhammer Quest and I think it does a pretty good job there are the solo Rules by the uh my mind just blank I'll flash his name up here by the Crater of Gloom of kill forth and I talked about those trist Hall I I talk about those in the video and those are available on Board Game Geek and then of course there are the amazing axian Quest cards which turn hero Quest into this amazing solo game of questing and Adventure by adding a random Quest mode a simple simplified campaign system new and exciting ways for Your Heroes to level up new ways to interact with all of that great dungeon furniture and tons of new artifacts and ways to balance those artifacts for when the heroes get too powerful so yeah so that's why heroquest is my number one game to play with house rules you really can tailor and customize that game to be the exact kind of great Dungeon Crawl you want to play on the table and it doesn't add a ton of rules it still keeps the game relatively simple so all right you guys I hope you enjoyed this top five games made better with house rules uh let me know what kind of house rules you like to play with what games do you think are better with house rules and what are some of the house rules that you use to make good games better

for you we'll talk to you later take it easy bye-bye

Progress saved