10 Board Games Ranked - Episode 25
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another 10 games ranked video so every now and then as soon as I play 10 new to me games then I release a video like this ranking these games from my least favorite up to my most favorite so as usual I have a big diverse range of games here old and new light and heavy at everything in between but before I get started on these 10 games I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go-to online retailer when it comes to purchasing board games here and if you use the link in my show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order but let's get on with the games at number 10 I have Castle Panic which I believe was one of the pioneers of the Cooperative genre in this one of course you are working together by managing this hand of cars to fight off these different fantasy threats who are attacking a castle or a tower in the center of the board every round these different Orcs and goblins and bosses will slowly encroach and you're playing these cars to try and repel them you're using Archer cards or night cards depending on the Range they are away from that central tower um I can see what they're trying to do here it definitely feels like a paint by numbers Co-op game and definitely a nice introduction to the idea of working together but for me the choices were fairly obvious you're just going to play as many cards as you can if you want to swap a card with your opponent you can do bear in mind that they might be within range when it comes to their turn
so you're trying to utilize those cards to the best of their ability and not waste them and but I found it pretty lucky and random you know you could just so happen to draw the wrong cards or the right cards things would happen you couldn't really plan for and to be honest yeah the decision space was lacking for me it was just you know kind of out of your hands how it was going to play out so that is Castle Panic at number Tech at number nine I have chosen which I believe I'm pronouncing correctly and this is a small box card game that only takes 10 to 20 minutes to play and it's one of those games where you have a different number of cars depending up depending on the different suits in the game too there's like two twos there's three threes four fours Etc you're trying to have the majority of those cards at the end of the game to get those points but in this one all those cards have different abilities which will let you kind of Steal cards off each other gain different ways getting points you know attacking cards Etc now I tend to like these quick little games that use cars in a clever way in this one I thought there was a little bit too much front loading and try to remember what everything did um to be completely transparent I have only played this one once so this is definitely uh the first impressions or some you know first impression comments that I'm giving here um but I must admit I wasn't blown away with it it was pretty much like I felt like I'd seen it before and I'd seen some more refined versions of games like this so it felt like one of those games that have just come and gone you know this is nearly 10 years old now nobody is really talking about it and I can see why so that is chosen at number nine at number eight I have if wishes were
fishes now this is a kind of Airy majority game with a little pinch of an economic kind of simulation going on here as you are trying to collect these fish cards and sell them when they're at their most expensive or when they when they're worth the most and you're gonna do that by drafting the cards not only for the fish types themselves but also for their dream ability or their wish ability which will let you manipulate the board state by moving these kind of meeples around this rondelle which will change and increase or decrease the values of the existing fish there and different things like that the way your drafting cards is fairly interesting you can using that incentive building mechanism where the further or the more cards you want to skip over you'd have to leave these worms on them and the worms are another way of cutting points and of course will give the player collecting those cars you've passed over more of those at their disposal which means they can in the future get cards that they want so I do like that kind of passing around economy of the different worms and trying to you know cash in the cars when they're worth the most and strike when the iron is hot I also don't do like the fact that these um you cannot keep spamming the same type of fish because there is a limited opportunity to sell each type of fish before the kind of market is closed I suppose and yes you can keep getting the points for doing that or the money but you'll start to kind of put the um the things that you've bid on onto this kind of separate pool which can give you negative points if you have the most there so I thought it was okay and maybe I'm being a little bit harsh by um rating it down here you know in eighth
spots I'll probably put it about a four or five out of ten at the moment and I might be low balling that but it's another game that I've only played once I was maybe expecting a little bit more from it but now I know what the game is all about maybe I'll enjoy it more on subsequent plays but that is if wishes were fishes at number eight number seven I have what came first so this is a mass-market party game where you are wagering on your own knowledge so you are going to get given um two different items of things from history and you have to guess which one was invented first so for example I think one of the questions is what came first the surfboard or the bikini and then you're putting either one two or three of these poker chips on there to see how well you do if you're wrong you'll go back that many spots if you're correct you'll go forward that many spots then it's going to be a race to get to a certain certain amount of points Tesla game in a nutshell I tend to like these very accessible games that you can play with anybody and this is one of those games that I'll never really reject playing I'm happy to play this anytime it's pretty quick um and you know there's even some interesting little facts and some trivia that you can learn along the way so if you like party games um don't overlook this one and you you know you want to learn something and have a little little bit of spice when it comes to wagering on how much you know now this is quite a good option so that is what came first at number six I have bits which is another simple puzzly Style game as you're placing these kind of domino tiles onto your personal player boards which are slanted meaning that when you put them down there
they'll slide to the bottom almost like a game of Tetris and then what you're trying to do is you're trying to position these different tiles to adhere to these different public objectives so some might say for every block of four of the same color you have you'll get a point or if you have a particular shape you'll get two points and every round a new objective will come available to you but the old ones will stay in play meaning you have different options you can go for it's pretty quick it's simple it's straightforward but I have to admit this game is terribly frustrating I'm not necessarily in a bad way because I do enjoy this one um but it seems no matter what you do you know you're waiting one tile to come out otherwise your plans are ruined and then that the one tile you don't need will will come out and everything is you know gone to gone to mark but you know this game is short enough and simple enough to roll with the punches and for that to be acceptable but and then yeah I like I tend I tend to like these kind of simple straightforward puzzly games uh the book shape and this one's a little bit awkward which is quite annoying as well um but um the game itself is fine you know I do quite enjoy it and it's very pleasant so that is bits at number six at number five I have circadians first light so this is a dice driven Euro as you are building up a bit of an engine by collecting these different tiles you're traveling around this map and by using Dyson a very cool mechanism actually where the pit value will determine the direction you're going and they'll also kind of improve or you know decrease the resources you're getting um you are trying to complete these public objectives and be the first to do that you are completing your own personal cards and getting benefits that way so it really is a lot of contract
fulfillment and Resource Management going on here now these dice driven Euros they are quite saturated at the moment there are a lot of them out there and to be honest I have played a lot of them because it's one of my favorite types of games now this one is a solid one I could I can definitely see why it's quite well regarded and there's some good fun things going on here particularly with that travel travel mechanism um but for me it didn't quite hit the highs of a lot of the great ones out there you know the ones from the board and dice you know the Marco polos that kind of thing this one isn't quite there for me despite being nothing overtly wrong with it so I would play this one some more but I'm not really salivating to do a deep dive into it because it's not quite as good as those other ones but still a solid game that is circadian's first light at number four I have icky uh iki is a bit of a cult favorite really with a lot of eurogamers so it's a kind of a rondelle game as you're traveling around visiting these different spots to collect resources but you also are visiting these different characters that not only yourself are putting down but the other players are as well and if you use your own character you can just use it but if you use someone else's character you'll improve their experience which will increase their income when it comes to certain points in the game so it's quite a nice little conundrum there we're thinking do I really want to use that character but it's also going to help my opponent so an interesting level of interaction you are trying to increase your ability to fight off these fires which will strike every now and then and can potentially um cause you to or force you to um just discard the characters you've invested in
collecting different tokens for set collection bonuses all these standard Euro things but I do love this initiative system as before you even move on the rondelle you have to put another meeple down on this track here which determines whether you're going to move one two three or four spaces around the rondelle and that really does play a big part because it's going to determine the initiative order as well so if you move fewer spaces it means you're actually going to go first which can be important because you will be you know you'll be disaligned with the other players or misaligned with the other players so even though you're going for different distances you might end up on the same space so it might mean you want to go fewer steps therefore you can take the better actions before your opponents get there and lots of different ways to get points here definitely um you know a buffet of options um yeah lots of paths to Victory and it's a very pleasant game so this one was kind of a quintessential near Miss for me and I say near Miss is in terms of I did enjoy it highly but it's just kind of missed out on a ranking spot for me you know I I wrote this probably about a six and a half maybe even a 6.75 um out of 10 when I tend to rank games from a seven plus so um yeah a solid Euro plays pretty quickly it definitely it doesn't take terribly long but I do think that in terms of the round structure it's maybe two or three rounds too long um but hey that's a nitpick there and the game itself again it's one of those there's nothing overtly wrong with it but I've played my games a bit I feel like I've got a good impression of it I could recommend it quite confidently to a lot of people but not one that I'm really itching to keep on my own collection because I have more that I enjoy of this kind of weight character
great but that is Icky um I don't want to sound negative because it's a very good game okay so let's get into the recommendations here so we have three games we're recommending um on this episode and the first of which at number three is the oldest game um on the entire list here this is Manhattan by Andrea safarth now that name might sound familiar to you because he's actually the designer of Puerto Rico but this game is completely different to a game like Puerto Rico it's much more family friendly and it's a simplistic area control area majority game as you're putting or building these skyscrapers um on this map by playing cards now all these cards will show is whereabouts in these I think it's like six different cities you can place your skyscrapers but the orientation is important because every player is kind of situated on a different side of the board and the cards will show where you can go in relation to where you're sitting so even though a card might say what might mean one thing for me it might mean something else for somebody else simply because of where they're sitting and all you're doing is you're trying to get the majority in these different cities you're trying to get the highest skyscraper you are trying to just get points by having pure coverage um Etc so very minimalistic straightforward scoring here but there is some interesting decisions particularly with how you manage your different buildings because they do come in different heights and in order to Trump somebody else because you can't actually build on top of other people's pieces you have to at least have the same quantity or the same kind of stories of buildings there so um
there can be a bit of back and forth it can be a little bit take that tea and can get a little bit you know again a little bit of feisty at times but it's all done in good spirit and it feels like a a real throwback actually a nice bridge between older games and newer designs as well because I think this does hold up for Market really well despite being released originally back in 1994 so nearly 30 years old uh this game so actually the more I'm playing this one the more I like it very easy to get to the table and a good introduction to area majority and area control games so that is Manhattan at number three at number two I have a bloxern also known as olinco now this is a card shedding game by cream and kiesling and all you're trying to do in this game is you're trying to get rid of all your cards because every card played is going to be worth a point at the end of the game and every card you have remaining in your hand by the time somebody has got rid of their cards is going to be worth negative points and you can what you can do with this game is you can play as many cards of an identical number as you like and of course if you have a bunch of eights say you had five eights that's five eighths down that's five cards done and Five Points essentially but if you have the same quantity of cards as in other players just played but the number is higher you can actually choose to pick up their cards and add them to your hand with the idea of hopefully building bigger sets in the future or you can simply force your opponent to pick them back up or even kind of um use a common pool to refill their hand and that that can actually create some good back and
forth because you know I might have say three twos in my hand um my opinion might have two twos down there I'll play two threes pick up his tutus and all of a sudden I have five twos and that's how it kind of works it does build up and build up until you can have this huge displays of cards and hopefully catch your opponent off guard and force them to lose another point at the end now I tend to like these Breezy card games with a little bit of cleverness to them and this one fits like category really well and if you tend to like games like Scout which is one that blew up recently and this is one that I'm pretty sure you'll enjoy because there is some shared DNA between the two just like the two being different enough they weren't having both so that is a bluxon or Linko at number two and finally my favorite game of the bunch at number one I have Jerusalem anno domini so this is a brand new game so we're going from old games right to uh the newest of the new here um and this is a pretty heavy Euro game by davia all about trying to sit next to Jesus and his disciples or Apostles um during the Last Supper so a very cool and fresh theme here at least I think it was and what you're doing is you're managing a hand of cars which have actions on them it has a kind of a top action which will show which resources your harness each time or even give you more kind of um ability to shift things from your personal player board onto the main map which gives you more capacity to store resources and then you'll have the follow-up actions which will be uh kind of collecting resources it could be
of sending people off to the Last Supper trying to score area control bonuses or even just bonus actions you're collecting these kind of parable tiles which are score your points and set collection um tons of different things you can do here you know the symbology at first is a little bit overwhelming but there are some great player AIDS and perform well not it doesn't take too long for the things to start digesting and things to start making sense but the decisions here are crunchy there's some good pre-planning good resource management good hand management a nice ramping up effect and competition for those end game points and it's just a pretty nice blend of mechanisms here so I'm not going to go too much into detail because um I am going to of course review this and it might even be out by the time um this video is released but I was actually very impressed with this one I wasn't really aware of it coming out and I just thought I saw it being released on on keanda so I thought I'd give it a look and um it seemed like the early feedback was good I tend to like stuff that devere puts out at least find it somewhat interesting and that concept of the actual setting I thought was you know something different and fresh so I'm so happy to say that the gameplay itself was rock solid as well and for me this did actually have a lot of similarities to um lacrimosa who which was also um released by Davian not too long ago but I think this game is better than lacrimosa in almost every category despite you know having a lot of similarities in terms of the area control and the Hand management and tying these kind of things together with the card play and the actual board state but yeah I'm actually quite excited to
show this guy this game to you um way better than I thought it was going to be I think everybody enjoyed it different ways to get points good competition um turn ax racing to get to things um lots of goodness here so if you like Euro games then this is a good one and it also has some um really cool wrinkles in terms of the audio play cards because you can get some nice swings of points for doing that which I'm not going to go into too much detail otherwise I'll be explaining the whole game but all you need to know is the game is very good and I'll be massively surprised if this doesn't make my top 10 of 2023 that's how much I thought of it so that is Jerusalem and Odom and I at number one so there we have it those are the 10 games uh for this video a big swing of games here the bottom half is pretty random and not normally the kind of games I talk about but these are not games I personally bought and games that my kind of my brother or my friends have bought and I thought I'd play them just by you know passively um but hopefully you have enjoyed the video if you have please be sure to hit like And subscribe to the channel and check out my other content too and for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye