Skip to main content
Loading video...

TDG: Cody's Top Ten Dice-Chucking Games (February 2026)

Transcript 17:39

Hello ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the discriminating gamer. I know you're all expecting a joke right now, but the only jokes I have are about unemployment and none of them work. Ladies and gentlemen, today we're going to go ahead and take a look at my top 10 dice chucking games of all time.

All right, ladies and gentlemen, my top 10 dice chucking games of all time. Now, I want to be very, very clear. I'm not ranking the games overall. I'm not saying these are objectively my favorite games in order. Rather, I'm focusing here on the dice rolling aspect. What what do I think are the best dice rolling aspects? And and even if they're very simple, you know, do what what joy do I get from rolling dice in this game? So, that's the criteria. I'm not necessarily saying these are objectively my favorite games, just these dice rolling aspects of the games. Okay, so we got that out of the way. Um, let's go ahead and jump into it. Uh, my number 10 is Gettysburg, a time from he a time for heroes. Uh, this is from Worththington. Gettysburg, A Time for Heroes. This builds on um Chancellor'sville, 1863, Freeman's Farm, 1777. Uh, a great game about the Battle of Gettysburg. um kind of pointto-point movement. But what I like here with the dice is in this game you have to roll doubles.

And depending on if you roll doubles, if you roll like double, you know, sixes, double fives, double sixes, you want these high roll high doubles, you can inflict damage. But if you roll low doubles, it kind of hurts you. And then if you roll like threes, I think you get to do a reroll. So there's a lot of kind of fun things here. But you I love trying to make the dice work for you in this game and trying to roll those doubles. It's an excellent game and it's an excellent dice mechanic, dice rolling mechanic here in Gettysburg at Time for Heroes. So that's why it is my number 10. That is from Warthingington Publishing. So my number nine is a game that I actually got about two nearly two years ago and I actually just played it last summer for the first time and I fell in love with it. This is Thunder Road Vendetta. Thunder Road Vendetta is a great kind of post-apocalyptic racing game. You got three cars that are trying to to to move along this wasteland.

And what's cool here is whenever cars occupy the same space, you put a car on top of a car and you're going to roll a couple of die and one die will say which car gets the effect, the car on top or the car on bottom. And then the second die will tell you what the effect is and you will it will determine, you know, what where you go, where you move to, what happens. So that's really a lot of fun. There's also some great combat. You're shooting at people here. a lot of fun stuff whether you hit a small car, a medium car, or a large car. I [clears throat] really like it. It's a very tense and fun game. It's and this is just all about the dice rolls. Really love Thunder Road Vendetta. That is why it is my number nine and that is from Restoration Games. My number eight is probably one of my top 10 games of all time. Uh it has been for years. Uh this is one of the big epic games based on an IP. I am talking of course about Star Wars Rebellion. Star Wars Rebellion is Star Wars in a box, the original trilogy of films. Um, you can add in the expansion, which I highly recommend, which brings in the Rogue One into it.

The DICE combat, the combat system is okay as such. The Rogue One really enhances the combat system overall, but it's just the general um missions that I like. You're trying to roll the successes there. you're you're essentially rolling dice for successes, but how you're getting the dice number is kind of based on these missions. Um, you select which commanders or which uh leaders are going on the different missions and then you're rolling the dice to get successes, but of course along the way other things can happen and and it's a one of the things I love about that game is it's just one of the great all-time dice rolling games. And depending on how the dice rolls out, you you're creating these almost kind of like alternate history scenarios within the original Star Wars trilogy, which I love. It's a great game. I'm always loving rolling the dice in this game.

So, that is Star Wars Rebellion. That is my number eight, and that is from Fantasy Flight Games. My number seven is another great epic IP game, and this just got a whole new um redo here recently, and this is Firefly the Board Game. Uh Firefly the Board Game, the anniversary edition. Firefly the Board Game is a great openw world sandbox game. Pick up and deliver. You can kind of choose which missions you're going to go on, what you're going to do, where you're going to go. It is so much fun. And I absolutely love love love that game. But frequently throughout the game, you've got to take these, you know, tests, right? You've got to pass these tests. And so you're collecting crew and other people and they have different abilities. You know, they have the mechanic ability or they have the fighting ability or they have the negotiation ability. And depending you're essentially you're going through and you're adding up on your crew and your ship and all your cards. How many of this ability do I have? And that's going to determine how many dice you're going to roll. And they're what you're rolling are part of these like stories and and you know the missions are stories and you can do the the uh misbehave deck which are kind of these other story aspects. And so it's so much fun to roll these roll these dice and kind of see how these stories progress uh based on your skill set. So I really like it. It feels very consequential uh and it's always a lot of fun. This is Firefly the board game that is from Gale Force 9. My number six is a game that is

also a fairly recent game. I think it came out about two years ago and it's based on an earlier game that I just played briefly and didn't really get into, but I got into this one and I freaking love it. This my number six is Dune War for Arachus. Dune War for Arachus is a great game. It has some great dice combat, but what I love here is the action dice. Essentially, you're rolling dice to determine what actions you can get. and you roll the dice and then you've got to determine where you are going to assign those dice and what actions you can do with them. Now, it's great because again there's a very there's a very narrative flow to this game. It's not I wouldn't say it's a very text heavy story game, but there's really a narrative flow and it really depends on the roles of your dice here.

I absolutely love that aspect of this game. This is one of those just great production games overall. and then it plays every bit as good as it looks. And a big part of that is this action dice roll system. I love rolling dice here. So that is uh my number six, Dune War for Mor Warer Aracus. And that's from Come on. Now my number five is from a family of games. And I could easily have chosen any of the of the games this one belongs to. Um this family it belongs to, but I'm gonna but this is probably my favorite in that family. Uh, and so I'm going to go ahead and say my number five is Memoir 44. Of course, it's part of the commands and colors family. Memoir 44 is all about dice combat. As you are moving along your center, your right flank, or your left flank, you're playing cards that activate units on those flanks. And it's World War II, Normandy, and your soldiers, of course, are rolling dice. Depending on the distance from their target, they're going to roll a number of dice. And if they hit those those enemies in the target, uh they will be uh destroyed. So you're trying to take them out. And every time you roll dice here, it's tense because if you're attacking infantry, you have to roll the infantry symbol. If you're attacking tanks, you got to roll the tank symbol. And if you roll the uh grenade, that's that's a wild that hits anything, right? So I it's just incredibly tense because so much of the game is about that. You got the card play, but the card play doesn't mean a

lot if the dice aren't in your favor. So, it's a very luck heavy game all the way around, but it is so much fun. I love the commands and colors games. I love all of them. I don't think I've ever played one I didn't like. I like some more than others. Uh, we had the Battle for Hoth recently came out, which is super, but Memoir 44 will always have a special place in my heart. I love love love Memoir 44. So, that is why it's my number five, and that's from Days of Wonder. My number four is probably my favorite deck building game of all time. And you don't really think of deck building and dice rolling. Occasionally you have a few that come out that do it, but I love the G.I. Joe deck building game. When I was a kid, I was a G.I. Joe kid. I had, you know, a lot of the toys from G.I. Joe. Really always love G.I.

Joe. And the GI Joe deck building game is great because of course you've got the cards that you're acrewing and every time you go on a mission, you're trying to defeat the story mission or defeat an officer or these other things. Uh in order to defeat them, you have to assign Joe's to the mission. Now, every Joe is automatically worth going to bring one diet, right? But if you have a skill set that says, you know, martial arts 4 and martial arts are on that specific skill set, uh, the story that you're going after, a card that you're going after, you get a roll four die for that. So, a big part of the game is trying to get the skill sets you need and the cards you need to have those skill sets in order to roll as many dice as you can. And so, you put that all together and then when you roll the die, you're looking for the successes. You're either going to roll blank, you're going to roll one success or two successes. and you are praying for those double successes, right? It is such a fun game. Every dice roll is incredibly incredibly uh tense because again, this is a story game and how you do on those dice rolls really determines the way the story plays out and ultimately your progression for success or failure. It is a cooperative game. So, everybody's working together. You are trying to share cards. are trying to share abilities to give people more dice or to give them, you know, dice rerolls or just automatic successes. Really fun stuff here. I absolutely love the GI Joe deck building game. More people need to play it. It is so good. And that is why the dice chucking aspect of that game makes this my number four. That is from

Renegade Game Studios. And my number three is one of the great horror Cthulhu games of all time. And it's one of the great kind of story games. You'll notice there's this connection for me between stories and dice rolling. And and this is Cthulhu Death May Die. Cthulhu Death May Die is such a great horror game. You got investigators, you got monsters coming out, but you got these great stories that are dragging you through there. And frequently you are having to roll dice to interact with things on the board and to fight monsters. But what's going on here is often times you're you're not just rolling dice that's going to help you and hurt your monsters. You're also rolling dice that may cause you to go insane. And you want to go a little insane because that helps you to level up. But if you go too insane, you're going to lose the game. And it's such a great balancing act with the dice and how you're you want the dice to work for you uh and not work too much against you when you play them. Great production all around. Great artwork, great minis, and the dice rolling aspect in this game and the story are just fantastic. So, that is why I love Cthulhu Death May Die.

That is my number three. Uh, it was Come on. I believe it is moving to Fantasy Flight games again. Number two is another game that's from a family of games and I could have picked a number of them, but I picked this one because it's probably if I had to pick out one say was my favorite, it's probably this one. Now, for me, dice rolling in this game is very personal because this is one of the games I've been playing this family of games since I was, you know, 11, 12 years old. I absolutely love it. I've talked about this on the channel. It's why I'm a military historian today. This is Axis and Allies, specifically Axis and Allies Anniversary Edition. Um, I love this game. It's a war game, but I love the system here where you're trying to roll low. every unit you have on the board, infantry, tanks, fighters, bombers, artillery, um, you know, you want to roll low. And an infantry that's attacking will only hit on a one. If he's defending, he'll hit on a two or a one. If you've got a tank, you know, it'll hit on a three, you know, and depending on whether it's attacking or defending. And so, I really like that system. And that's kind of one of my favorite dice rolling systems I've ever played to this day because I just like to be able to look at the board and say, "Okay, I need this many hits here.

I need this many hits here. This is what I have to do." And especially too now that that Renegade released the um uh Access Analysis hit dice, which are really cool. And that way you say, "Okay, so these guys roll at one. I grab to that number of one. I roll that number of, you know, twos, that number of threes, and I roll them all together. And I can see how they hit." Great fun. really really enjoy that. I've always loved playing Access and Allies and the dice rolling is a big big part of that. So that is Access and Allies Anniversary Edition. That is my number two. That's from Renegade Game Studios. Now I do very quickly have some honorable mentions. Uh first of all, uh Dead of Winter. This was a game that had shut up and sit down called it the crulest die in all of gamedom. It's the one die whenever you move a character from one location to another, you have to roll it and if they get bit, they're infected and that guy's as good as dead. uh Project Elite, which is a great kind of timed game where you're rolling the dice to kind of kill guys, but as you are rolling the dice, you're also moving them forward closer to you. That is fun.

And then, of course, uh Star Wars Outer Rim, which is a lot like Firefly in that you're rolling dice in order to overcome various kind of story, uh roadblocks and what have you and and and quests and doing. I really love that aspect of it, too. Again, it moves a story along and allows you to to to uh have some really fun adventures. So, I really like that one as well. All right, my number one dice checking game of all time. I nearly put Access and Allies as number one, but there's something about the dice rolls in this game that just man alive. I love it so much. It's another horror game. It's a cooperative game and again it's from a family of games and this is Zombie Side. Specifically, I'm going to say Marvel zombies. Um, but the way you roll dice, you're looking at your abilities, and you know, in other versions, you're getting weapons or whatnot. Uh, you're looking at your abilities and it's telling you how many dice you're going to roll. In Marvel Zombies, what's cool is you roll the dice and you may get hungry and you're, you know, your your hunger level goes up. And if you get too hungry, then you can't, you're limited on your the actions you can take. Um, but the more hungry you get, you you also do get some more abilities. you get to roll more dice. But it's just fun because you're trying to hit certain numbers and you're doing the math in your head and you're trying to calculate, okay, here I am and here they are. Best case scenario, I could take all these guys out, but I'm probably not going to. So, I got to figure out how I want to play it. But it's just fun in this game watching the

horde come at you, whether they're zombies or whether they're shield agents in Marvel Zombies, and what can I do to stop them? And how can I stop them? How can I best utilize my skills? What can I do to mitigate the damage? How can I use my dice the most effective way? I don't care. I'm just rolling them. You know, it's so much fun. It's so much fun. And um again, the more enemies you kill, you increase your your ability level, which lets you level up. And again, the game just has a good narrative flow every time you play it. And the dice make that. I love rolling dice and zombie side. It is so much fun. So, I'm going to go ahead and say zombie side. Marvel Zombies. That's my number one. And that is from Come on. Well, all right, ladies and gentlemen. What do you think? What are some of your favorite dice rolling games? Do you like the games on my list?

Do you not like the games on my list? Would you rank them differently? Please let me know what you think. I'm always eager to hear your opinions on uh the games I bring up here. So, please, please, please leave a comment here for us on YouTube, on Board Game Geek, on X, on Facebook. We'd love to hear back from you. Please like and subscribe to this video and channel. That means a lot to us. And if you do really like what you see here, I would humbly ask you to check out my other channel, that's Cody Carlson, PhD, where we talk about history, military history, things like that. I even post some of my lectures up there. It would mean the world to me if you would subscribe to that channel as well. And of course, ladies and gentlemen, if you do really like what we do here on the Discriminating Gamer, I would humbly ask you to click on the super thanks button and leave a tip. You know, originally I was going to be a farmer, but I chose the wrong field.

Please help me on my feet again. AND I DON'T KNOW WHERE I'M GOING. AND I don't know where I've been. Please help me on the ground. IT'S A LONG TIME AND I'LL BE DYING. Once a year I wind up in the fight, but I don't ever win. It's my life.

Oo, look at all them successes.

Progress saved