Skip to main content
Loading video...

Five New Small Box Games - Quick Reviews

Transcript 22:58

welcome to allies armies I'm Jess and I am Sean and today we are looking at five small box games that are all new for 2023 and small boxes have the bonus of being in a small box meaning they don't take up a lot of space and we are running out of space so it is a bonus if you can get a lot of game into an even smaller package yeah absolutely it's London tiny Flats there is no room at all but there's also no room right now for chitchat so let's get right to it the first game we want to talk about is Ela which is published by bombex and they've been doing a really great job of doing interesting card games that involve a little bit of engine building or set collection we really like seep salt and paper from last year and so in ela you are taken back to prehistoric times and you are sitting around a fire so all the cards are in a circle and then you try pick up a card and you get a certain amount of resources going on from that and it's like bone and fur berries typical like cave people type of resources and then you use those resources to play your cards but your cards interact in various ways some are just like really high point scoring cards other ones let you like cash extra resources on them for big points so you're always trying to maximize the interaction with the cards and how score

yeah it's I I really like to see Sol and paper I really like the look of Nar we were shown Nar which is Bomb X's next one but unfortunately we didn't get a chance to play that but it looks like it's in the same vein but Ela does do such a cool job of that that same sort of feel a little bit that we got in sea salt and paper except now instead of building that little bit and then gambling and then rebuilding here you're building for the whole game and and they they do they all interact in these interesting different ways where you're storing or it's like I want a lot of red cards but then maybe the red cards that are out like you can't afford them or they're not in a good place to get resources it's it's cool that there are so many different like levers to which card you're drawing each time that you're drawing it how does it work in my sets how many resources is it going to get can I pay for it with the resources that I've got all of that stuff yeah and because one of the key things is each card will have like a value of one to three for how many resources you get so it'll be often that you take a card just for the resources and you don't even want to use the card at all and if you can empty out a resource pile you get a bonus too so that might factor into what you're getting as well and every time we've played I felt like we've tried different things cuz we've tried to like really get a lot of storage stuff which is helpful cuz sometimes you can't keep all of the resources that you end up getting other times times it's been like

a mix of things we haven't found a winning strategy yet no well yeah I think we've we've won pretty much 50% of the time each and yeah and you're right every single time it's been different I noticed one game you totally crushed me with just the high point scoring cards that are also high cost and so the next game I tried that and then I got whooped by like a you just got like a million Reds and then a bunch of red scoring cards and so it it's hard to just copy the One path and so you really have to be like Dynamic for what cards are out um and how you're drafting them and then also that you really always want to be the one taking the last one off the piles cuz that extra resource is worth a lot in this game and there are two different like sides to the leaders you can play so the the first version which you probably only play on your first time which is no power but then there are four different leaders yeah and they're all asymmetric different powers and they seem fairly even yeah and it's just small little changes but you definitely try to play Into Your Leader power yeah so this this is one that we like a lot this was this has been a hit with us we've played this a bunch of times since we picked it up we got it just before Essen actually our friends have got it for us from France cuz it's not out here yet and then we were thrilled because there was an English rule book in it we thought we're going to have to stumble through the French we didn't have to um but yeah it's it's it's really good I I like this one a lot another one that we got recently was a Kickstarter that got delivered and that

is Moon and so moon is by Sinister fish and uh the same artist and designer for the trilogy that they did that starts with villagers and then streets and then Moon hawen hole Gardener and we actually played with him he taught us the game at ukge and he was a delight yeah he was really really lovely and I really like the Space theme I think the art in particular for m is really good I I really love the different space stations and it it every card's a little bit different but still with the same style that it translates across all of them really well it's really quirky they got really cool little buildings in it and in Moon you are building out your space station and it's a card drafting game and so we played at a UK games Expo with four players and then we've also played it a ton with two players since we've gotten it an interesting thing with the car drafting is each set of cards comes with a different like power ability so when you pass on your cards you're also passing on that ability so that plays in interestingly as well in terms of what card you might want to play but also what ability you'll have temporarily just for that turn only and like a lot of drafting games I think it does play quite differently across the player counts yeah it does we've mostly played this at two but the the card ability thing is really cool because you know what it's going to be cuz like there's only two or if three there's only three and you're always going to get that one

every three times cuz it's always going to come with that hands that hand of cards so you you know oh I'm going to get one that's going to give me a free resource so I I know that I'm going to be able to play that or I'm going to get one that lets me cash out a resource to get some hearts so I can have extra resources that'll be good so there is a little bit more planning ahead here because you know one card that's coming back to you every time and there's also just how the engine builds too so you've got one set of cards that gives you resources you've got one set of cards that gives you these like tags that get you points at the end of the round and then you've got cards that give you gameand points and cards that give you once around powers and all of that stuff interacts um like for only four different things I feel like there's a lot of variation within those four things yeah definitely cuz there is also the like share goals you're competing for as well that is going to be based on the types of C cards that you're collecting too and so that will mix it up as well and a lot of the cards will require a specific tag to get played or and if you can't play one of those or a resource you get these little like Rovers and you place those on the other people's cards to be able to use their tag or their resource meaning it can get you out of a situation if you're like oh I'm one short but I really want this card conceptually you place them just never places them because the other thing they do is if you have more than the other person you en tibr ERS for the between round tag goals and she will not give up a tiebreaker the one thing that

does bother me a bit though is for the components all of the tokens are double-sided so they have one on one side and three on the other side it's fine for the resources but with the hearts it's really easy to accidentally flip those and to lose track of exactly what you've got but how do you feel about Moon versus cuz now we got the trilogy and it feels like a Trilogy to me especially cuz I like that it moves forward in time too that you go V Village streets Moon how do you feel Moon fits with streets and Village well I really like Village uh villagers villagers I really like villagers I think that's my favorite one and noon moon is new so I am worried that like it's new and shiny right um but I right now I think it's second for me I do like the Drafting and I like the engine building but at two players I don't know if that's the best player count because like for those tags that you're competing against it's just two of you competing against it I think it would be more interesting at at three or even at 4 but because we primarily play at 2 I think I prefer villagers at two fair enough I will say though that for a card drafting game there are so few that can work it to this works totally totally F at two like if you're only going to play this at two I wouldn't shy away from it because as far as card drafting games go

at least um I think it does okay and this also had an at relase available expansion which is called Valkyrie and Valkyrie comes with these little spaceships and it gives you a way to get um it's these bonuses that you can get through the spaceships and then there's also some different cards different goals and that adds a little bit to it as well it's not like a huge amount it feels a bit like some of the um tiny epic kind of mini expansions when they first come out that don't like it's they don't add whole ton to the game but they just you know just just a little bit a little different way to play and I imagine we'll use it basically every time we play yeah I think so and like the other expansions from the trilogy it does fit in the base box and these base boxes are great at first we weren't too sure cuz it seems like such an odd shape we're like well where will we fit it and then it fits like perfectly in just the right slot I love these boxes yeah I I I could I could go for more of these boxes these are absolutely terrific so the next ones that we are going to talk about there's actually two and we may as well talk about these two kind of together they're both from Play for Keeps and they are both re-implementations of older games that I believe were previously only available in Japan and Play for Keeps is a UK company and they did Supply us with these review copies but they are my favorite things and string Railway and let's start with my favorite things yeah

so my favorite things is a trick taking game where it is specifically about your favorite things so it's this interesting mechanic of when you start off you have to give someone a prompt of like list your favorite Pokémon for example whatever you might want it to be and then you pass them your cards and they have to put from 1 to five their list and one that they don't like and which is jinx and everybodyin creeps me out everybody is doing this at the same time so people are getting different prompts and making different lists and that's all simultaneous so hopefully you're not waiting too long for people to write their list although some people might struggle with thinking I it is so important to me that I get my list just right someone and it depends on the prompt too cuz I'll get like your favorite fruit and I'm like oh okay that's fine it's not but I will get like someone will be like your favorite Stanley kubri movies and I'm like this is like I'm bearing my soul to you I have to get this exactly right it's like can we just take 10 hours so I can rewatch these movies it's I think it's really going to vary person to person though I I think definitely and I think people will really gear towards liking a specific type of prompt versus another but that's only part one cuz then you get their cards back and you don't know what their ranking is it gets cover it up so all you have is you know what the prompt was you know that they filled it in but you don't know what value they gave so then it's a trick-taking game so

you are trying to win the tricks based on how well you can estimate what the person's answer was as well as what maybe you think they might be playing for you too like cuz you're trying to like it's almost a meta game of what everybody else is playing based on what number of value you think that might give it as well yeah yeah so it's I'm like does Jess know like polywhirl or does she think I only kind of like polywhirl or so it really is a I think she thinks I like Po worldl 3 but I like Po worldl 2 but I think she likes limes more than kiwis so I'm going to play lines and it is interesting that way that it's really like all in your brain cuz the actual game itself super simple it's just it's just the simplest trick-taking game where it's if I play a one and you play a two two I win cuz one's higher than two but the fun is really that it both it's fun to write lists I love I love writing lists but then also that what do they think I would think and what do I think they think and then you thought that like why did you do that that doesn't make any sense why would you choose things in that order why why do you think Doug Trio is an interesting Pokemon why would you choose them over Chespin that doesn't make any sense this does feel like it's more of a social game that you'd play with a group of friends maybe around some drinks as opposed to let's take this very seriously competitive trick taking game and it's really is

leading into the those conversations and debates about the lists you make yeah yeah this is 100% this is more of a conversation starter than it is anything else and and I think it's really one of these you'll know you'll know you'll look at this game and think yeah my group would love that we would love making lists and laughing about our lists or no my group like serious board games and we would not like that you will know that judgment right away from just what we showed you the other one from Play for Keeps is string Railway and again this is a remake of an older game and I believe again a game that you could only get the Japanese this one actually may have had an English edition but string Railway is this game where you're building the railway out of strings and it is actual strings you've got a pile of Str strings you got four shortish ones one longer one and you are putting them out and there are two different ways to play so there's one way that you can play where you're adding a location each time and then you're connecting strings anywhere that you want to connect strings you're kind of getting in each other's way and it's a fairly simple you're just putting it out and then you're getting some points each turn and then there's another way to play which is um string Railway cubed where you've got cubes on the map and this is more of a railway game and this I think was our preference of the two ways to play as well where you're putting out those strings and you are collecting up these cubes which

represent different sorts of I don't know stuff that you got to move with your train and you're trying to move that to the correct places the correct warehouses that are out on the board and then you're getting points from how you move that you're also upgrading your train there's a little bit more to that yeah it's interesting though because it starts off with this border that's also just done by string and so you just have this black border you've got a mountain in both of them you also have like this River in the those all strings everything is strings they're all string and it seems like such a big area so I remember the first turn that I played and I had to put my string out I thought well this isn't a problem because you don't want to overlap with people that's a negative and I thought this is a giant area these strings seem so short I'm sure we won't get in our way but then sure enough like as your string is coming out and your building the various areas you're definitely like overlapping you're filling up the various stations or you're emptying out the cubes depending on which version you're playing and it ended up being a lot trickier than I thought I know there was some like like we had to bring in the judge basically for like oh if i' stretch my string just like this does it touch just right it's not like we have to bring in a judge it's like Jess thinks if she stretches it perfectly taught that that counts when you let go and menes does it still touch them or does it not touch them anymore when it is at rest I think we can all agree those are official professional string rules there were some questionable moves

by you as well where it was like just one quter to just another Corner we'll have to look at the photos but um but this obviously we did have fun with this I will say that this works better though at more players cuz at two players even though we are getting each other's way it's not as much as you would like I think this would be more fun cuz it's the same size area with four players when everyone's getting each other's way and the first method the one that doesn't have the cubes you have to play two each which is Never My favorite way to play but I think the people who will like this is it's very like it has such a like DIY like Indie feel to it and I think there's something to that like it's just a little out of the mainstream and I think there's there's a little like charm in that yeah it is a light game I would say very yeah this is a very light game so don't expect a lot of complexity or a lot of like strategy you know you only have five strings you're placing and you are just like connecting up stations or moving things around and like you said it is just Charming in how it looks I think if this was used at like a board game club or something that people would be interested in coming around to check it out yeah I think this is this is going to be one that appeals to new Gamers or to people who have it's going to be kind of two extremes either new Gamers or people who have a whole lot of games but are kind of searching for that like weird thing like that thing that's just kind of on the outskirts a little bit um but it is it's

it's quirky it's fun but it very very quick this is definitely a filler game just kind of a quick filler start of the evening kind of game the last game we want to talk about is the plot thickens and this was provided to us for review by brighte ey game games and it is a storytelling game there are a few different versions you can get the detectives is the newest one but there's also romance as well as science fiction and they come in these great boxes that look like books and open up so nicely and it is a group really just storytelling it plays for three to four players and so you someone starts It Off by telling their story they have a character they have to introduce and then you have a hand of cards of people plac thing and then anytime you say any of those words you get to play down your cards but what you're also trying to do is then once everybody has some of their cards played out is incorporate the things that they've talked about on their cards and use those words for continuing the story on yeah and the story is really short I think all of the examples in the book are like four or five sentences and I think that's probably how it works best so you're kind of passing it along so you say a few sentences and then you say meanwhile and then the next person picks it up and I think what tends to happen is it's kind of becomes this like um you're coming at the same story from the different angles it's like Pulp Fiction they're all equal quality to Pulp Fiction it's it's like that sort of idea

though so you're all coming at it from different angles into the same story and then everything's going to intertwine because you first do that one of putting down your own and when you put down your own you also get these little rocket ship things if you're doing space or magnif F glass if you're doing detective and so you collect those when you play out cards and you put them down when you play them on other people's cards and that's kind of the competitive part of the game is it's like how many of these do I want to build up so I can play them out and also that means now all these words are available for everyone to else to use which is fun for the story but bad if you're playing this competitively but this is this is not a competitive game yeah because if somebody's telling a story and it's not making sense you can call them on it and say writers lock and then they're supposed to spend a token to restart or their turn ends but it says in the rules you can be as competitive as you want with this right and when you play with Jess what happens is you say writer's black and then she immediately goes no no no and then just continues on like it never even happened which is funny well I felt like my story did make sense so I didn't agree with the judge um it says majority rules in the rules so you could decide how strict you want to be um but this is one I think that would be very specific to certain groups it would be people who feel very comfortable being silly uh using their imaginations I think you can get a lot of laughs out of the story that you're telling but if you have people that are

really reserved and don't feel comfortable being put on the spot I don't think it would be a game for them and depending on what genre you like that would influence the type of box you get so like if you really like film noirs and detectives would be right on your alley that's the one again get get detective maybe you want to go like the risque version and do romance I mean they don't have like super risky stuff they don't but it's it's for all of the the people places and things it would be tropes or tie-ins to those genres depending on what it is and that is it that is five small box games and if you are looking for just a solid two-player game or really just it's a solid board game I would recommend both eloa and moon but if you're looking for more of a social activity social game with the right group and that promotes conversation then my favorite things or the plot thickens might be a good fit and then string Railway is kind of the Oddball kind of the quirky Oddball in the bunch and if it's for you I think you're going to recognize that pretty much right away but I should have also said that my favorite things in string Railway are both coming to Kickstarter um I think in late October I'm not positive so if you're interested in those look that up but as usual thank you so much for watching please let us know in the comments if you've played any of these games or any great new small boox games that you've picked up and as usual please like subscribe and hopefully we'll see you next time for

another game

Progress saved