Skip to main content
Loading video...

Which Board Games Survived | Wingspan, Sleeping Gods, & More

Transcript 17:15

Hi, I'm Sarah.

And I'm Drew.

And today we're back with another collection curation video. So this time we only have four games, but we call this the big boy shelf. And you'll see why here in a moment. Um, if you're not familiar with our collection curation project, it is where we are playing through all of our games shelf by shelf and really getting down to the nitty-gritty of what we will actually play

and what deserves to stay.

Yeah. Yeah.

So, um, let's just dig in.

Yeah.

First up, we're going to talk about Wingspan. We do have the nesting box and we do have every expansion

that is currently available. We do not have the pocket game yet. We do not have the Wingspan Pocket. So, that's not included in any of this.

Love that.

That I I'm sure we'll we'll end up getting it at some point in time.

This nesting box was actually my mother's day gift this last year because we found that

we love Wingspan first of all. Spoiler alert. Um, but we would just pull the base game off, right?

All the time. Every time just be like, "Okay, base game, base game."

And it usually it had some cards. No, it didn't.

No, I had everything separated out.

Oh, man. Yeah.

And so we were just playing the base game over and over again because you had to get two boxes out. You had to open them and sort them and push everything together.

Understand how setup was different sometimes and all that. Yeah.

So, um, this was the first time pulling this off the shelf as the nesting box. And I do think that it is making it easier to put those expansions in.

Definitely. Yeah.

And so it was easy for me to grab the cards I needed, smush them together into the deck, and then just hit the ground running.

Yep. Um, since we have played Wingspan base game so much, we skipped over that,

right? And we just

And European is just cards.

And so we combined that with the Oceanana.

And that adds in a different board that kind of pulls back on the egg production a little bit, but jumpst starts your food production a little bit better,

which I prefer.

And it also has a new resource that is nectar. That's use it or lose it. And then a little area majority when you use it. Yep. in your different um what environments, whatever, right?

Um

and we played that with our daughter. She loves Wingspan also.

And then we kept it out and we set up Asia

and we just did straight Asia, all the Asia cards, the Asia boards

and Asia is just a twoperson variant essentially. You get and it is different. It's definitely got some different uh mechanics in play. I mean, overall pretty much the same, but there's some an extra board again with scoring and things like that that are

So, yeah, I'll do um if you're doing the duet mode, you have these um tokens. Every time you play a bird, you're going to place those out and those are going to be basically your um between round scoring, your end round scoring conditions are going to be decided by that board.

And then you can also get some bonuses. So, if you place here, you get an extra card, you get extra food, stuff like that. Um, and then one aspect of that we have not played is there's a flock mode where you can play like six to seven players. I do not ever see us doing that. Um, that just sounds like way overwhelming. Yeah.

But you can there's a special board with the Asia that could do that as well.

Yeah.

Um, we have played America's. We played that fairly recently. We have a review up on our Instagram on that one that adds in hummingbirds as a new mechanism. And so those every turn you're going to do some I can't even remember. do something with your hummingbirds that's going to gain you um these gems that are kind of a track that you're trying to push up to get points and some of them give you extra bonuses too,

right? Yep. Exactly.

So, there's a lot there's a lot with Wingspan. Um we have decked out our copy with um player tokens and um the upgraded

resources except for nectar. That's on its way though. I did order that once we got Oceanana to the table again.

Yep. and we're in the market for a bird feeder. So, if you know a great um wooden, I think is what we'd prefer or 3D printed,

um hit us up because we would we're really looking to upgrade that next.

Well,

I don't think this is going to be a surprise, but are you ready?

Yep.

Three, two, one, keep

wingspan was one of our first games we got.

It's a top five. Probably top 10 easy for you. Um and it's up there for me. I prefer Finsspan.

Mhm. but not by much. Yeah.

So,

and our daughter really loves it.

When I ordered the nectar pieces, I also ordered player pieces for the kids. And I had asked my son like,

"Do you think you'll want to play?" And he was he was open to it. So, I definitely think this is one that's just going to be a family classic.

It's an evergreen, I think. Yep.

Yep. So, Wingspan, all of it is staying.

Okay. Next up is Last Light. So, Last Light was a kickstart. Um, Gray Fox Games, Roy Canada. Um, 4X. Um, basically you are going around the solar system trying to get light essentially the all the lights in the the galaxy or all the sun's uh stars are going out.

You're trying to get what you can uh to last as long as possible and whoever kind of has the most at the end wins. So, um, but again, it's that 4x. So, there's some some combat um you know, exploration. It's got all of those types of things in it. Um

I think when I backed this um it seemed like this could be, you know, I like a space theme. I like, you know, this that and the other

and we'd always heard 4X was fun, but it takes a long time. And this was like a very streamlined play and you could play more people in a quicker time. And so that that was appealing to us,

right? And so this what I didn't realize at the time was the two player variant, which again is what we're going to mostly play as two players, uh, kind of gets rid of one of the X's. You're not exploring in the same way you were before because those tokens, the mystery kind of the reason to explore is kind of removed and so now it's a race to get to the center so you can get more sun per turn, etc. Um, and I think that kind of ruined it.

Yeah. For us at least.

Yeah. Um,

we're just not, this type of game is just not going to hit the table at four for us because our kids are just not going to be as interested in it. Maybe when they're 20, 25, but we've got a long ways before we hit that. And I don't know that it's worth keeping something on the shelf that long. Yep.

In the off chance that it will get played then.

Yep. And um it's I I really I like the idea. I like so much about it, but at the end of the day, it's just it's not going to hit the ground, you know, hit the table at all.

So,

okay, are you ready?

Yeah.

Three, two, one,

um this was one that it would sit on the shelf and we would look at and be like, "We need to play that again. We need to play." But we wouldn't do it. We just wouldn't pull the trigger. We wouldn't set it up. I think that first play of it kind of soured us a little bit as far as like this just wasn't what I thought it was going to be. Y

we had bought into the hype on this one a little bit and the production is fantastic.

Amazing production.

Um so it just it just didn't quite hit our expectations and so um

at the end of the day

we don't want a shelf that we look at a game and we're like oh

yeah we need to play that again. Like we want oh yeah we get to play that again. So Last Light just needs to find a home that's going to appreciate it. And there are definitely a lot of people out there that love these types of games and this will be for a game group or you know whoever. This will be big. It's just it's not for us and we need to be honest at this point in our collection of over 400 games. If it's not for us, if it's not a slam dunk, it just

has to get off the shelf. So, Last Light is moving on. So, next up, we've got Tribes of the Wind. And Tribes of the Wind was a little bit of an impulse buy for me. I saw it on sale at Barnes & Noble. Thought it was worth a $15 chance on. And I'd always heard that it was really fun. So, I think I don't think it took us too long to get it to the table. And after I've posted about it a few times, I've had so many people say, "It's a fun game, but that rule book, I don't and I don't really have that big

No, I feel like it's really not a big deal."

Yeah. The one thing I was told was to download the player aids from BGG and put those in the box because I think that would have helped even this last time we played.

It was like our third or fourth time playing, but we so we're like, "Okay, how does this work and what does this mean?" And so it would be helpful to have just a player aid and I think we jump into it a lot faster than we did. We spent a lot of time looking stuff up.

Yeah. And just those little references, nothing huge or anything like that. And not like we had trouble finding it in the rule book. We just,

you know, whatever. I mean, it's it's really an interesting little maxim, you know, optimization type game.

Uh, Dut Tree's art is just stellar.

Yeah. So, so in Tribes of the Wind, everybody around the table has a hand of cards and you have to put them in these little holders so that everyone can see the backs of all your cards all the time because the um if you can take an action on a card or the um effectiveness of that action is going to be determined by the number of cards either in your hand of that type or around the table. If you have more than everybody else or if less than

or if everybody meets this threshold, like there's six or more of that kind around the table,

then your action's going to be a little stronger.

And you are trying to

reforest your um player board that is kind of this post-apocalyptic world

and then get your um wind riders to those tiles so you can flip them over and make cities. And you'll have different scoring conditions on your board. Every board is unique. It has different scoring conditions

and it has a little deck of cards that have different bonuses for each each player. So, that's kind of a fun choice. You kind of get to think about right at the beginning of the game.

Yeah. And then you also have bonuses that are out that are, you know, essentially whoever

wants them once they're able to get them and but those can be used either as endgame score or they can get you immediate effects like resources, etc. Um,

so there's a little decision space there as well. Um, are we just ready?

I I think so.

Okay. Three, two, one, keep.

This is one that has just been really fun for us. We enjoy getting this one out. It does something different.

Yeah.

Than any other game in our collection.

And for a game that has this kind There's definitely some thought involved of how what you want to draft to make certain cards function for you and maybe, you know, etc.

And the fact that it plays so quickly, too. I mean, you're talking about 45 minutes for the two of us tops.

Um, yeah, it's just it's a fun little game.

Yep. So, this one's sticking around.

Okay, the last one is Sleeping Gods. So, this is another one of those Red Raven Ryan Lockett. The world building he does is is amazing. The art that he does is amazing. I mean, it's hard to say anything bad about those types of things in any of his games. Um, but this one is a little more open world explanate or exploration. Um, so you're going from place to place trying to kind of connect the dots and get, you know, figuring out kind of what you're what you're supposed to be doing in the first place.

Um, so I really like some of that. That is really cool. I like that feel of trying this almost like it's a mystery you're trying to

to unravel. Um,

yeah. I don't know. I mean,

yeah. So, um, it's definitely one of those that you have to be cool with a narrative story that you're trying to follow. Um,

I will say that the thing that probably

dings this for us the most is the combat. It is so brutal and it takes you so long to recover from that that it just feels like it almost ends the game for you.

Um, and so that's a big thing that kind of dings this one for us. Um, it's also a lot. If you're playing two, everybody has four characters that they're controlling and so you're kind of trying to keep track of that.

And then the other thing is just the time commitment to a campaign on this one. It plays about 20 hours for one campaign. You're not going to see everything in that campaign, so you might want to play it again.

But for us where we are in our life right now, having something set up for that long Yeah. Or this is where we ran into problems with it was we play I think we set it out. We played two or three sessions. Yep.

And then we packed it up

and when I opened it back up to reset it, I don't think I packed it up exactly how I was supposed to.

I didn't remember really how to play. I didn't remember where we are.

Yeah.

Um it just was so overwhelming to me that

Yeah, it was a little rough in that in that respect. I think this is definitely one that would sh will shine if you get it

in a group and they want to play it every other week or something like that. You're you're going to it's one that if you can keep coming back to it.

Yeah.

So, I think you could really explore this a lot. Um because again, I think the the writing, the art, the so much behind it is super cool.

Are we ready?

I think so.

Okay. Three, two, one.

Cole. As much as it hurts my heart, um I think where we are as gamers right now is not ones that can commit to a huge campaign that we aren't able to get to all the time.

Yeah.

And we just have we have so many campaign games that we are going to have to really nail down the ones that excite us the most.

Yeah, I think so. And again, I I'm not even certain like I think the last straw honestly with this was the combat. I think if it's a con, you know, campaign, if you have to do a little this, a little that to reset and get going, that's one thing. But when the combat was so grueling,

and that's just not our favorite thing to do anyway. Like I can see if you are like a dungeon crawler person and you like that combat and you want to be a little more in-your-face about some of that stuff,

this might really appeal to you, but for us, that's not our favorite thing. And it's another one. If you play more often, if you craft certain things that are going to help you and come, but like we've talked about a lot, we don't want to have to play six, seven sessions, eight sessions until we start liking a game or feel like we can get a flow.

It's just that at that point, that's a job, not a a hobby, not a game. So

So, um, someone will really love this copy of Sleeping Gods, and I'm so excited to pass it on to them. And I'm also kind of relieved to make some space on the shelf for games that we really love. So, Sleeping Gods is moving on.

Okay, so that was shelf eight for our collection curation project. Um, this one was a hefty amount of games that we got rid of. We got rid of two out of the four, which is a 50% call rate on this one. And I think just being more honest with ourselves about who we are as gamers and where we are in our gaming life. Could I see when we retire in 2030 years getting Sleeping Gods back and like playing it in a week? Yeah, maybe.

Um but right now we just don't have the time to commit to that and leaving something out on the table that long.

Yep.

Um overall we have called 16. No. Is that right?

Yes. Y

overall we have called 16 out of 55 games that we've played from our collection and that is about a 29% call rate. So that's going to fluctuate. Yeah,

I would say 30 33% that's kind of my goal by the end of this.

Um we'll see if we make that or not.

Yeah.

And again, we're keeping in mind that this isn't a calling project. We are not specifically trying to make sure we call as much as possible. We are curating our collection. So, we are making sure the games that we have fit us, and if they don't, then it's time to say goodbye. But I'm not arbitrarily pulling a game to hit a number of games that we have in our collection. So,

um, if you enjoyed this video, make sure you're subscribed because we will have more of these. This was only shelf eight of probably like

a lot,

30 to 40 shelves of games that we have. And so, we'll have a lot of this coming up yet as well. Um, we also have uh a few other series where we're sharing some of our favorite, more recent games that we've played. Um, we have reviews that go live nearly every week on the channel as well. So, you'll want to make sure you're catching all of those. If you want to see more of our day-to-day gaming, um, we are on Instagram, Sarah always loses. So, thanks for watching and we'll see you at the table.

Progress saved