Do top 10 lists make sense? | Board Game Q&A
Transcript
hello everyone welcome to another watchet played Q&A show I'm Matthew and together with a bunch of your health let's answer all of the internet's burning Bard game questions our first question this month is how is it possible to compare no thanks to tigress and Euphrates top 100s make no sense correct you can't that is the answer to that question all ranking lists of board games even an aggregated list of sorts which is like the BGG rankings they're all still deeply personal subjective and warped by everything else that goes on in our lives don't get me wrong top lists top 10 US Bard Gamers we love them we really do I remember getting into into the hobby what did I do I watched a bunch of top 10 but the actual lists themselves how real are they how useful are they how can you judge this big game here got yellow Yan TIG and your freers how does that fair against these little games over here how can you really compare you can't but you can it's just your feeling I mean a game like Skull King which is a little trick-taking card game game where you've got to try and
bet on how many tricks you're going to win each round it's fantastic game I think Grandpa Becks make it now that's in my top 20 games of all time the reason being is because I've had numerous times in my life where I've played that and it's been the funniest thing that's ever happened at that time some of those amazing board game events like a weekend away and it's 3:00 in the morning and our version that we've got is an old Schmid version of the game and it only comes in German so everyone instead of going like one two three then betting cuz you put your fingers out to see how many tricks you're going to win everyone's going like Hine smacking on the table and stuff it's 3:00 people everyone else is angry that we're doing that but that's not the point just rockus laughter I've made friends playing that game so to me it's I rank it higher and that's all there is to it maybe there's another trick taking card game Wizard very similar game it's not my top 100 at all it's the things that we add to them I things that really Propel a lot of games in my personal top lists of all times are the Nostalgia of the game the emotional connections that the game had the those games in my collection I'll never get rid of because of the times I played that game with people and it means something to me and that elevates the game and is that what people are watching my list for maybe the top 10 games games that no I want to know what the best T placement games are
not the one that you feel something about which one's the best so that's going to be such a big part of it it's a bit ethereal almost the question that I normally try to answer though when we're being technical about a top 10 the best games of all time is try to add in a metric which kind of helps Elevate some of the smaller games into the lists because a lot of these get passed by the wayside and that is how fun is the game we're ranking board games that how fun was it to play how fun is it you know there's lots of things that go into it how easy is it to teach how quick are the rules how what the components like how beautiful is the artwork artwork is going to skew some ratings I tell you but how fun was it and that is something I really try to put into account when I'm making these lists you know tigers and Euphrates well for me yellow and yansi let's not go into the debate but for for yellow yansy is a top 10 game of all time it's thinky deep strategic tactical masterful simple to learn got great depth and wonderful balance of rules and the balance in the game in general it's just a perfectly wonderful game that I think also this version great artwork great components it's a beautiful game but on the other hand Fuji flush which is just here is hilarious and that's probably my top 20 games are they similar in any way shape
or form no so I think when we're doing this this is our top 10 even do even make sense I think you just have to really take into account the fact that we're all biased everything is subjective and for me a game that is a 10 out of 10 for you even though you can appreciate it's a decent game it's just never going to be there it's because we don't share the same experiences around that game how about you how do you judge a game do the small games that you love make it into your top 100 into top 10 is all these bigger grander Affairs that seem to be elevated in your estimation what games are in your top 10 that you just don't think are going to be in anyone else's top 10 because you have a connection to them I'd love to see that in the comments below the next question I think is brilliant it's what's the worst thing about the board game industry well well well I would say the worst thing I've got a list of things here and you know I think we're very lucky to have a great industry of board games I think it's full of wonderful people wonderful games that really its heart is all about trying to have as much fun as possible you know and hopefully you know the industry side of it makes some money along the way but a lot of people is trying to express themselves in a way that is going to bring joy to others and that's pretty wonderful when you think about an industry but I would like that if convention season could be a thing again convention season doesn't exist anymore convention season is all the time I
remember 10 years ago the GES The Hobby People go oh well it's the start of convention season and you know like I think it was Origins that maybe started convention season for a lot of people or maybe one of the BGG cons but now like Pax is in December you know there's a lot of extra little conventions smaller conventions airon you know it's a it's a great convention that just didn't exist 10 years ago and that's you know March convention season in the UK used to be UK games Expo around July then people might go to Essen and Essen who knows when ess's going to be nowadays I'd like a convention season to exist again so we can all just have some time off another thing I hatte a strong word but strongly dislike in a real way is the ball game industry is not a professional industry there are some fantastic professionals within this industry and obviously we have bigger Bolder conglomerate corporations in the industry as well as you know your mom and pop shop which has got a really cool game there's two people that work there you know and your brother's doing the artwork that type of thing and that's a fun Dynamic to sometimes uh navigate because we have in this industry sometimes a lack of professionalism which books me and of course I'm going to be just as guilty as anyone else at that because I'm grown to be more professional as the games as the day gone on right but I hope have I but
things like responding to emails following through with the things that were in the email reading the entirety of the email before asking questions that were answered in the email as per my previous message that type of thing we get a lot in this industry and it's just the fact of the matter and it happens in lots of Industries where instead of hiring someone we get my mate can do that and your mate might be the person you can afford but they aren't the person for the job that happens all the time so I'd love the industry to reach a more of a level of professionalism across the board without going too far there's some parts of this industry which I think are just I wouldn't want the industry to go that way another thing that I think damages the board game industry and I mean the content and publisher Dynamic and the way that that reacts with the the the audience and the consumer if you will is the just barefaced unwillingness for a lot of Publishers because everyone thinks Publishers aren't to blame in this but Publishers and content creators unwillingness to learn the difference between a review and a preview and this has been gone on adium with so many times by so many people but there is a real unwillingness for this to happen I mean obviously we want a transparency
that's one thing that I think is within the area of professionalism if someone's getting money for something somewhere really it's the law to tell people that that is the case first and foremost just because you know no one's watching these videos or there's only I mean you know it's only a small Channel and there small publisher it doesn't matter you've got to be clear you've got to be precise you've got to be legal you've got to be honest a lot of this isn't some kind of dupus backseat Arrangement where cash is being handed out it really is in my opinion I mean I don't know the Affairs of others but it really is a lack of understanding a lack of knowledge about how these things are meant to be done which comes to that professionalism in the industry as well I'd love to see a Summit held each year where content creators and some lawyers and some Publishers could all get together and have talks and conversations and stuff that'd be good I think that would improve the industry for everyone because sometimes I'll get asked to do a review but what they actually want is a preview and I have to say you want a preview because money is changing hands here so it cannot be a review yeah I think the difference between a preview and a review if I can nail one thing down in the industry that will probably be what it was and the final question we have is should games have a handicap I read this and thought Oh my gosh yes of course they should that's such a good idea sometimes you're playing a game with someone and they've played it 20
times and they're going to beat you but the person who has played 20 times wants an opponent who they can play and they want to play their best to their best ability they don't want to tie one hand behind their back is that where the word handicap comes from huh so setting some rules in place in games where there's like a strict handic you to do with all Gams but where there's like a handicap and you can say you know or if you're playing for instance not to be insulted but if you're playing with children you know you're playing a game and it's your kids can play along and stuff but you're going to beat them unless it's a dexterity game and they're going to beat you then you feel really bad about yourself you know a game that you're going to play kids just go you have to you have you know you have half the amount of time to take your turns that the kids have and it kind of balances itself out I think more games should do this I can't think of any games that do that if you have any ideas and any games examples put them below cuz I would love to see what they are but I can imagine in something like the castles of burgundy some of the boards that you can play with in that game are better than others some are going to probably get you more points over the course of the game the way the the the rules of the game you know a lot of it is if you finish areas earlier on in the game you get more points and some of these boards have lots of small areas to fill in so you can get a big jump start so I think you can balance castle bergundy out a little bit from a seasoned veteran of the game to a newcomer just by which board people play on I think there's
space in my life for that to exist it's really for people who play games a lot and also don't want not interested in enjoying just destroying someone for the sake of destroying them in a game I think handicaps in games would be a really smart idea for some games I mean if I'm playing Magic the Gathering and I've got a I only get to draw a hand of five that doesn't seem fair does it I don't want to do that at all that doesn't it seem fun so I think there'll be a balance to be had here yeah handicaps in games I am not against I think that's a good idea on a Case by case basis don't make I don't tell me that I get extra six extra gold at the start of the game because I'm a dumb dumb that's not going to I'm not going to go home feeling good I'd rather just lose fair and square honestly so maybe there's a balance to be had there let me know what do you think about handicaps in board games I think it's uh an idea that could be good thank you so much for being here for another month of Q&A here watch you played if you got any answers to any of the questions this month please put them down below so we can share and share some knowledge and I can learn a few things as well I'd love to see your comments and answers down below until next time everyone thanks so much for being here and I'll see you next month bye