Forget Top 10s! Here Are the Number One Board Games for EVERY Mechanic
Transcript
Hey, you. I see you lurking in my bushes, watching them through my window, seeing me eat my tiny donuts, and playing board games. You're probably the type of person who likes to skip to the number one spot in every top 10 video. I should call the cops on you. But you know what? I'm going to reward your impatience. And today I'm going to give you five number one games in five different board game mechanics. Screw the other nine. So, why don't you come on in and maybe I might just give you a taste of one of my little donuts. Now, let's not waste any of my time or your time and just jump right into it with the best push your luck board game, which has to be Clank Catacombs. Plant Catacombs is a deck building toweling adventure board game where two to four players take the role of a thief.
Venture into the catacombs of an undead dragon, raising to steal artifacts and escape with your life. You play cards to move, fight monsters, and grow your deck. But every noisy action generates Clank, which if pushed too far will awaken a dragon and kill every last one of you for your insatiable greed. I was a huge fan of Clank and Space, but the modular map here just makes perfect thematic sense to the point where I I can't imagine ever going back. The tension and excitement of every tile flip dwarfs the experience of jumping onto a spaceship with a with a stagnant map. I think the added element of exploration provides this wonderful temptation, beckoning you to keep pushing despite the obvious danger. You think to yourself that if you if you just keep exploring, maybe the next room will be filled with prizes. But no, the dragon is waking up and you should probably leave and not be greedy. But but what's just around that corner?
Clank stands completely alone as a brilliant game that effortlessly manages to blend dungeon crawling, push your luck, and deck building. And the deck building here, it's it's pretty good. This isn't the type of deck builder that persuades you to simply pick up cards at the end of your turn, regardless of whether or not it fits cohesively into your deck, simply because you have the actions available. But curating that deck is part of the fun challenge. And you are facing multiple challenges in this game. Unruly decks, other players, enemies, the map itself, your own temptation and greed. The game is just loads and loads of fun and hard decisions. And those challenges force tough choices and great tension. Tension further aided by the fact that the journey through Clank's depths is not an entirely random affair. As you go deeper, you make noise, which gradually awakens the dragon as you pull more and more cubes out of the bag, crossing your fingers that the cubes that you're pulling out aren't yours. You assess risk over time, gauging what's left in the bag, cautiously gaining self-confidence while on your run, allowing you to determine if it's best to resurface with what you have or be brave and bold and continue your descent. Honestly, this wasn't even a contest. Malem and and Wonderland's War are great games, but they can't even stand toe-to-toe with Clank Catacombs.
I bet you're a Quax fan, aren't you? Disgusting. You know, I won't even feel bad for what happens next. While this one is a tough category, I believe the number one tableau builder of all time has to be Terraforming Mars. Terraforming Mars is a strategic board game for one to five players where corporations compete to make Mars habitable by raising its temperature, oxygen levels, and ocean coverage. Players manage resources, play project cards, and build their engine toward shared terraforming milestones and awards with the objective being the most efficient and highest contributing corporation to Earth's terraforming process. This really is the hardest choice to make because Arknova is brilliant. But when I think about how satisfying the tableau building and terraforming Mars is, I really can't pick anything else. There was so much variety in cards available and and many interact with each other and even your opponents in such interesting and creative ways, making the entire experience feel deeply rewarding when you perfectly execute your turn.
expertly leveraging those two actions you can perform to scoop the best spot for a city nestled between someone else's trees for points or increasing the temperature at just the right time to be the one to receive the bonus heat production. It feels incredibly good and provides a lot of strategic depth and consideration on every single turn. And these moments are everything to Terraforming Mars' engagement because the game it is largely a solo affair as most tableau builders are. Terrifying Mars, like Ark Nova, is a type of game that upon first play feels as though there are no other players sitting beside you. But the stronger you get at the game, the more interactive nuances sort of reveal themselves beyond the obvious race towards milestones and awards. Drafting between every round forces you to pay close attention to the tableau of your opponents or risk passing them a pivotal card for their engine. And nothing feels better in a board game than holding on to the minus six plant card and just waiting waiting the entire game for when your opponent finally builds up a bunch of plants and then you just come in at the last second and just destroy them all. I'm a vindictive person as you're about to learn. Terraforming Mars is a game that's generally difficult to summarize because it's it's not one mechanic or design element that makes the game. It's just sort of it's sort of everything crammed together in this like perfect package. Every turn, whether early or late game, feels deeply meaningful. And and despite hundreds of plays, I've never had a game feel the same as the last game I played. Hell,
the early game of Terraforming Mars with the Prelude expansion has me agonizing over starting corporations and cards, and is honestly, it's my favorite early game decision-making in any board game ever. And the game just started, and I'm already being asked to to to plan out my entire strategy. It's it's overwhelming for sure, but that's sort of the point, isn't it? Terrifying Mars doesn't hold your hand. It just it just throws you into the deep like a father who had few too many beers at the cabin. But but I love it for that. And my dad, despite the fact that I still can't swim, but at least I'm a highly skilled terraforming Mars player, and I'm I'm sure he would be very proud of that. And the best area control game is likely one that many of you have never played and given its length may never play.
Dominant Species. Oh, I forgot I promised you Mini Donuts. Here you go. It has chocolate inside. Oh, wait a second. Did you remember to subscribe to this video? Did you even join our Discord group or to a Patreon? You really are awful. You'll get what's coming to you soon. I I mean, Bonapetit Dominant Species is a heavy strategic board game set at the end of the ice age where two to six players each control an animal species, competing for survival as the planet freezes over. Players queue up actions each round, spending them to adapt their species, spread across the map, and dominate terrain tiles. I bet you thought I'd pick something like Blood Rage or Kemet or or Inis. Well, we are more civilized and classy in this house. So, obviously, my pick must include a game with abstract player pieces in the forms of cones and cubes. This is a dinosaur.
But listen, those other games are like child throwing pillow fists at a prime Mike Tyson compared to the sheer brutality of dominant species. This is a savagely aggressive game with an immense amount of depth and complex decision-making that demands you anticipate your opponent's actions while constantly balancing tactical short-term gains against long-term strategy. But at its core, this is an area control game, and the way control is established is generally creative. There are two available paths. You can have the most species on a region to score points for that tile, or you can achieve dominance through food, which lets you place a cone, claim a dominance card, and gain a powerful ability for your species. This dual control system feels a little strange at first and can certainly add to the bookkeeping, but the more you play it, the more it makes every other area control game feel incomplete because it has layers that other influence games just they just can't touch. But what's great about the game is that it's not really hard to understand. The entire game is condensed into a shared action board and every action is pretty intuitive because they all serve the theme. Through these actions, you are constantly evolving, shifting, and responding. The game feels it feels dynamic in its brutality as you struggle, dominate, evolve, and sometimes die, but continually crawl forward all at the same time. Even the abilities you acquire throughout the game sort of eb and flow in relevance.
Something you picked up early may feel overwhelmingly powerful, then lose all significance a few turns later, only to come roaring back in the endame. There is so much here to consider on any given turn that the whole experience genuinely feels as as epic as the entire passage of a species history should. And for a game that takes as long as this game takes, you need that feeling to continue being excited for your next turn. And I think Dominant Species accomplishes that beautifully. Hey, are you getting sleepy on me? You can't clock out just yet. We have a few more games to get through. Here, drink this. It goes great with my special donuts. Now, this is going to be the biggest upset on this list, but it's a hard truth for you lovers to swallow. The best worker placement game of all time is Tracaren. Hit me up in the comments section and find me. Tracarian Legends of Illusions is a two to four player heavy worker placement game where players take on the role of rival stage illusionists, each with their own strengths and special tricks. Magicians strive for fortune and fame by managing resources and performing tricks in a competition hosted by a legendary magician looking for a successor worthy of the mighty Tarian Stone. This game is fantastic because there is just so much more to consider on any given turn when analyzing the best location to place your worker. primarily because all of your placement is pre-programmed, meaning you have to select where you want to put your workers at the start of the round. This simple design decision adds this beautiful layer of engagement where I'm not just tactically adjusting my moves based on the decisions of of
others like most worker placement games. Instead, I'm actively anticipating the actions of my opponents and what their desired order would be during activation. It's interaction without direct conflict and it just adds an immense amount of depth to the game that elevates it above the rest. And Darion has my favorite worker placement mechanic, individual worker powers. You have three different specialists that not only dictate how well you can perform an action since some provide more action points than others, but they also have abilities that assist you in various actions. like the engineer who allows you to hold an extra trick and gives you more shards during your performances or the manager who allows you to gain bonus components. Dracarian is one of those games that's asking you to consider a lot on any given turn. And while I love games like Vida Culture for its simplicity as a worker placement game, I often gravitate towards games that that overwhelm me and demand a lot of me whenever I'm taking my turn. And that pull toward more complexity and depth is precisely why I love adding in every expansion for this game, many of which already come with the base game.
This is definitely not an elegant game. Every piece of new content, be it the new player powers activated by shards, the individual magician powers, or the extra action cards you can use on your turn, all feel so incredibly broken. And yet, the balance of these items is in their brokenness. Everyone is constantly yelling that every power feels too intense and insane and then you slam down your worker and utilize your own powers. It really does feel like you're creating magic at the table. Tokarion isn't a game for new gamers and it's likely not one that will get high praise from a viewer who has only played it once or twice. But if you give it enough time, you'll see exactly what I mean when I say it is easily the best worker placement game. Plus, how many games have rope as a resource?
We'll be using this later. Just just one more game to talk about it. The best negotiation game is one I promise you've never heard of. And yet, nothing even comes close to how engaging Thief France 1429 truly is as a negotiation game. Thief France 1429 is a complex and dense negotiation game of dynasty ambition where three to six players are dropped into the chaotic political landscape of 15th century France where the lead noble families scheming their way towards power through military conquest, papacy maneuvering and marriage all while weaving in and out of alliances and betrayals. Thief is built around the understanding that no one player can reach the three victory points required to win on their own. And that scarcity of scoring opportunities means that your path to family dominance will require constant maneuvering, alliances, deceit, and maybe a marriage between families that ends with your wife laughing over your dead body because she orchestrated your assassination in attempt to seize the throne for her family. Thief is built around these subtle and savage Mavelian negotiations. One moment you're you're patting your friend on the back as brothers and the next you're attacking his lands with your army because well because he had previously crossed you and you must repay your debts to show dominance at the table.
And trust me when I say I always get my revenge. What raises thief to the top of the negotiation pile is that the negotiations here are not abstract like in many other games. You're you're trading votes to gain favor in religious elections. You're promising royal support for military protection. You're bribing the player who controls the poke to grant you an analment to dissolve a useless marriage alliance, but no deal here you make at the table is mechanically forcible. Which means you're free to lie and cheat all you want. And the only people holding you accountable are your friends at the table. And they all know it. which creates this like wicked atmosphere of paranoia and suspicion that looms over every single negotiation at the table. I have continually described this game as the one true board game that actually captures the Game of Thrones books because everything in this game is playerdriven, creating so many awesome moments facilitated through through negotiations and scheming. The events that occur in this game are not happening from from a dice roll or a random flip of the card. another player has actively decided to either age your family or destroy your family, which just creates so many great stories you can tell long after you and your friends are finished with the game. Now, obviously, this game isn't for everyone.
You already know that if you dislike negotiation and table talk, but for groups who lean into the negotiation and hopefully a bit of role playing, the chaos and human drama becomes comically entertaining. Oh, it looks like you're about to experience a bit of chaos yourself. Sweet dreams, YouTube video skipper. Sweet dreams. Oh, good. You're finally starting to wake up. That's great. Oh, don't don't hurt yourself. You are currently tied up in my basement. I kind of spiked the donut that you ate and the drink. You didn't think I'd reward such deviant YouTube behavior, did you? I can't have people just watching top 10 videos and skipping to the number one video, especially when my next video is going to be the top 10 most interactive board games video.
Mikey, no likey. Mikey angry. I Anyway, I'm just going to head on upstairs. Okay, feel free to like, comment, and subscribe. I I guess you can't do that anymore, but um I'm sure you agreed with every one of my picks. Anyway, I'm going to head on upstairs and going to grab the cooler and then you and I can try to fill it. Okay, I'll be back in like a couple of hours. You just hold tight. Bye.