Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 3 Board Game Plays of October 2026

Transcript 50:38

Hey, I'm Ryan. This is my brother Daniel and this is Over the Garden Wall and we are here, let's see, the day before Halloween is when we're filming this.

and what are you dressing up

What was that?

What are you dressing up as?

Uh

nothing. You know, my my wife and I put so much effort into our kids' costumes.

better question. What are your kids dressing up as?

Here here we go. You probably don't Here you probably don't know this reference, but there's an old Cartoon Network mini-series kind of became a cult classic called Over the Garden Wall. It's really It's really good, actually. There's probably Please please let us know, viewers, if you were in the demographic that is familiar with Over the Garden Wall. Well, my kids are the My boys are the perfect like height proportions to be the main two characters of Wirt and Greg in that. And then we were like, "Oh, little Twyla, she's, you know, 8 months now. She's going to be the bluebird. She's going to be Beatrice." Um and let's just say my wife like when when we get a vision like she's very, you know, obviously she's an artist and stuff, but she's very good with sewing, crafting. So, she basically built like perfect costumes for them of these. So,

Do they even know this reference or there are they just like are they just like what the heck are they wearing?

Yeah, no, we we watched it with them.

It's a really good like fall Halloween mini-series cuz it's got But I It's one that I have a hard time recommending like to other people's kids cuz like I know my kids like are pretty good with like they don't get really freaked out with like scary movie Like like not like horror movies, but like

But like Well, he Let me tell you, even like a lot of like classic Disney stuff is like pretty has like some pretty dark elements to it, you know, like you think like Little Mermaid or some of these things that it's like, "Wow, this is like darker than I remember as a child." But they've never really had issues with like that bothering them or nightmares or anything. So, I feel like most kids their age I probably wouldn't recommend Over the Garden Wall to cuz it is it does have this kind of like creepy element to it. Uh but very funny. There's so many quotable quotable lines from it. Uh it really is a good mini-series. So, who knows? Maybe I'll have the opportunity if you guys demand it in the comments, maybe I'll post some photos of their costumes.

if they demand.

Yeah, the demand really has to be there, you know.

Not just one.

But yeah, so I'm excited to you know, go out go out with them. Um I was going to ask about your kids, but at the same time we got to get this video done.

Yeah, yeah, we didn't get to that.

I can't hear you talk about it. Uh we I I don't even think we've said why we're here yet.

Why are we here?

End of the month, if you're regular on the channel, you know what that means. It means we need to talk about our top plays from the past month. What are the games game sessions specifically that stood out to us and we always enjoy hearing in the comments what your top plays recently were. You know, it's it's sometimes it's a game that you wouldn't expect, but you just had a really great session of it. I actually have one of those on my list.

love about these top plays. They can get games that maybe we don't talk about often, but if it just landed right, it's on.

Right situation. Yeah. Uh and these games maybe would land right for you as well, which is why we have links below in the description that you could check them out. Sports channel, too. Yeah, sports channel. Keeps the lights on.

Keeps the

This is I got a really big light right here.

just One of these videos like open with the lights off and be like, "You guys need to click more links."

Yeah,

yeah, sorry.

Silly income has been down a little bit. Guys, we need that $10 a month.

Please, come Uh it's good.

Uh well, for now the lights are on.

Um

Yeah. Is that you uh grabbing the segue to your number three?

speaking of a game with a dark theme. Uh there you go. Uh I don't know. This is one that um has uh is continuing its streak or maybe not streak, but uh uh racking up top plays of the month nominations. Um and it's because it's a game that is played in campaigns. And it's one that just has been a joy uh a joy to jump into. My number three goes to Arkham Horror: The Card Game. And

it is a streak at this point.

I mean, maybe not an unbroken streak. I can't remember if it was on it last month, but

It's a strong trend.

Strong trend, yeah, yeah, yeah.

And well, you know, what's kind of nice for the people is they get to hear the journey. Um and this game really is a journey. Uh you know, we're moving our way through the Path to Carcosa uh campaign right now. And you know, if people have been listening, we are dominating. This was the first time that we built our own characters, and I don't know if we just broke the game or what. Probably need to play I honestly I I don't know, what would you do, Ryan? Like, if you're playing a campaign, and let's say it's a, you know,

[clears throat]

eight eight-game campaign, roughly, and you're like three, four in, and you've every single time just like not

Which is interesting, cuz it's not common for this game.

I don't know if we're just getting lucky, or if we just figured out the secret sauce between our two characters. Um maybe we're cheating. That's always on the table.

It's always on the table.

So, I don't know what it is, um but I'm curious, Ryan, like, in that situation, three, four games in, you win super easily, would you consider upping the difficulty mid-campaign?

Cuz what difficulty are you on?

We're just playing the standard. So, there's I think there's like easy, standard, and then there's two more harder difficulties. Uh or are you a like, nope, this is the standard, we're we're going standard. Uh is there any any advice, Ryan?

haven't I haven't been in these games. I don't know to what degree they've been, you know,

just say we love our cooperative games to be at least a fairly close ending, you know, with a little bit of suspense, some wondering, are we going to I don't know, it feels like we're just we're just rocking and not really having any any fears about about uh losing

to put like weaknesses in your deck, right? Like

Yes.

I'm trying to think of things that didn't go well with you.

know. I have I do have some egregious cheating examples of the past, but what's really been really fun about the character that I'm playing and I've mentioned this before is the I've I'm building to fail. Yeah, building to fail. Um I will say I'm the character with the dog. I forget the keys the cowboy guy. Um Duke is the best guy in the game. Like that I'm going to go on on record Correct me in the comments if you disagree. I think this is the best character in the game because you Duke is incredible. He can either He either has a great attack that he can do. Um or he also I believe has a an a way to like search as well. Do the investigate at a like really high level and you start with him every time. That is so huge in Arkham Horror the card game, a game where you're shuffling your deck and you don't always get those cards that you need.

You can just get to start the every single game with him.

Yeah.

Um is is pretty huge. So I have been loving him as a character and like you mentioned, I have been building out this kind of a fail to win thing where I have all of these cards that like oh, make the difficulty two harder, but you get a bonus you get some reward. But then I have things that like if you fail this and if you So I like it's like a win-win for me. I either succeed at the test or I go all in on the fail and I'm just getting tons of resources and stockpiling and it's just been a super cool character to play. So Um we are this one it was a fun fun scenario. You know, I don't want to spoil story-wise and whatnot of kind of what's happening, but overall it's been a it's been a fun Yeah, I think it's been my favorite of the stories so far and which has been engaging. But again, I feel like it's one that like I don't know.

The story is good, but it's not like oh my gosh, the story is so integral that I could never come back and play this uh again because all the surprises are gone. I don't know, which I actually appreciate that. Um it's good it's got a good theme that that you're moving through, but I feel like it's also one that could definitely definitely be replayed. So, I forget where we're at in this, maybe about halfway if I had to guess. So, I don't know, maybe I'm speaking to I I might be I might be speaking too soon on uh how uh easy things are and I'm going to come back and lick my wounds, but we will we will see, Ryan. But, it is I've really been loving it. It's really just been that collective, you know, that living card game kind of uh game for my collection. It's been really fun to get to experience that.

Yeah, I uh aspirationally was planning on playing a out of campaign to this. I would I had the friend of mine that we did the first little three-one, and we were going to do Dunwich, you know, life kind of ended up saying no.

It just was the further it went on, we kind of like there were some you know, weeks and stuff that went by months months that went by, and then we were just like, you know, at this point if we're going to if the two of us are going to get together to play games, it probably just makes sense to play other games.

You do need Yeah, for these kind of games, I mean, you get you do have to have a

In fact, cuz spoiler, my number one play of this month was with that friend. And maybe it's a game that we wouldn't have played if we uh Oh. It was with another person.

So, good thing you didn't.

It's a good thing that we gave up on Arkham.

But, what game

Someday.

play did you not like as much as that play?

So many questions. Um but I'm going to talk about my number three for now. The number one will come with good time here. Uh my number three, I think is the first time that this has ever happened to me. Where I have made the decision that I I I'm going to get rid of a game. Like I physically move it to my I have got my little other section of like outgoing games. Um and so it was there and literally a day later had a situation that we were trying to pick a game and it occurred to me that the that game actually

Wow.

might fit it better than anything else in my collection and it came back from the dead. Gosh, a resurrection. Resurrected and got played and had a it was had a great time. And this is actually Cascadia.

Wow.

talked about Cascadia. We've talked about how for our personal tastes, you know, we've always liked it. Harmony's kind of became this like, oh, for our taste this is just so we would want we would pick Harmony's every time. Um and so Cascadia was kind of in this weird place, but I have the expansion that lets it go to five to six players, which ended up being kind of the key piece here because we had we had five players. We wanted something that was, you know, it was end of the night. I'd gotten the kids down. So we want something pretty relaxing, but it was also a group that, you know, likes strategy or a little bit more. And so you're kind of starting to narrow into this five players cozy relaxing, but still got some strategy. We We talked about Cartographers and admittedly that one could have worked as well, though I would argue Cascadia is even like just the feel around the table when you play it is even a little bit more, yeah, laid back and and it's I dare I say a little more interactive?

The feel at the table is a little more interactive cuz you're all pulling from a shared thing. You're taking turns. Like Cartographers got the simultaneous play. And anytime you go into that simultaneous

play there is a certain element of everybody retreating into their your isolation Um And so it, you know, we played it and it was awesome. Like it was exactly everybody at the table was like that was exactly what we want, like the kind of experience we wanted. Um and you know, we played with I mixed up the scoring cards a little bit, used some of the original ones and some of the other ones. Um but had a great time playing this and and it's not like I didn't know that I enjoy Cascadia. And honestly, I don't think this play changed anything about how I feel about it personally. But it kind of revealed that like there still is a situation for me that this was like the best game for me to pull out. Now, does that mean it's going to stay a lot around forever?

I don't think so, if I'm being honest. I think it gets me thinking about what other games could fill that

So not a full resurrection, eh? Just a

It's Yeah, I think it's still it's heart is probably still numbered in the long

on life it's on life support?

But I would love to it's whole For now it holds that kind of spot until something can kind of replace it. Whereas I was literally going to get rid of it.

All right.

Um yeah, so kind of an interesting turn of events there.

That is interesting, Ryan. Well, you know what's funny is I thought I literally thought I sold Cascadia. And then I looked at my shelf and it's still there. So I don't I don't know what happened. Um but I don't know. Maybe it's a sign that like this I need to keep it around um potentially.

Yeah.

I mean, here's the thing. While it was like the best game for the situation, there still are some things that I I feel like I could find a game that could do it that situation even better. I mean, our game clocked in it cuz we just played the standard game with five players. Technically, there's like the the expansion adds these like rules where you have like this private pool of tiles and it speeds up the game because

Mhm.

it's not just taking turns. It's kind of hard to describe. But um we just played the standard game and so it was a little long. I would say it's longer than it should have, you know, I would want this. It was probably an hour and 15 minutes.

Oh, wow. Okay. Yeah, that is that is long for Cascadia.

Which is a little long for that. Now, it wasn't in this particular instance, it wasn't a problem. Like, it went great. But, if I'm thinking of like, what do I want for that, it's like I really want to be like 45. Yeah. Um, so I'll have my eye out, but it is interesting like the you get to five or six players support.

It rules out a lot of games in this. And then there are a lot of them that the way they achieve five or six players is they go to simultaneous play, which is is fine, but I'm feeling like, you know, in this particular situation, there was something nice about not just going to a simultaneous play game.

Yeah.

Um, so kudos to Cascadia.

Kudos to Cascadia.

I don't know how much it hasn't gotten played a lot in the past couple years for me. Um, but it came through for us.

That's awesome.

This month with just a really good play.

Yeah, I feel like it it's so encouraging when you when a game that doesn't get chosen often, but just nails it. And you're just

was funny cuz it like dawned on me cuz I was like, you know, going I wasn't like including it when I was considering, and then I was just like

And you looked in the corner.

Actually, Cascadia.

Ryan had an epiphany.

I did.

Uh, game that I might be having an epiphany right out, Ryan. Um, my number two is one that I'm not sure it's going to come to a full resurrection because this is a game I used to own. Left my collection. Do not own anymore. And yet, Ryan, I tell you what, a play of it this this last month got me questioning all of my life decisions.

Wow.

My number two goes to Scythe. And I got So, we had an opportunity to play a three-player game of Scythe. My buddy here owns it, brought it over. Um, and I tell you what, it was Now, let me preface this all with I had a fantastic game. Things went very well. So, maybe a little colored colored eyes on on my view of it, but man, I was just really loving the mechanics of it. Like the I mean, one, the game's beautiful. It It looks the board and everything looks amazing. I can't even imagine playing with the you know, flipping the board over and then putting two boards side by side and you're playing with like a double Have you seen that that you can do that? The board It's like if you flip it over, it's like half of the board and then I don't know. I guess you would have to buy like another copy or something or maybe that was in the deluxe thing, but um but the game just like it looks beautiful out there. I think it's got a cool theme and all of that, but this uh this blend of, you know, resource management, but it being out on an area control uh map and so you you know, the resources are yours as long as you own those and and all that. But I think the thing that was so satisfying for me was just like figuring out the chain of of what I need to do all kind of centered around uh you get a, you know, a faction kind of these two boards and they're uniquely paired. So, I love kind of the variable

variable thing there. Um but you're always uh you're always, you know, taking one of four actions um through there and doing the top and the bottom of it. Um and one Yeah, the uniqueness of that, but then figuring out the order of how you need to do things of like, "Okay, this turn I need to to optimize this all. I need to move and produce this thing and then okay, that'll set me up so that I can then build this thing here." And you're like moving all around and I don't know. I just felt like I was in this engine of optimization that was super fun. Um also love the how the game is, you know, again not It's not primarily a conflict game, but it's about those objectives and those trying to get stars to claim, you know, the first one to claim I forget how many wins you the game. In some ways it's kind of like Twilight Imperium in that sense of like it's it's about what do you need to do to get the objective and all of that.

So, you don't need to be a fighting machine, but if you can sneak out a victory, well, one of the objectives is win a battle, right? And and something like that. So, I love yeah, it kind of puts you in a similar similar just like really fine fine what are calculated moves that I can do to to get get an objective, get get a star up there, get up star up there. And so, this one it was super fun to play it again. I um again, I yeah, it's I don't know if uh I don't know if I would ever if I would ever own it again, you know, again, when someone nearby has it that kind of helps with with getting to play Andromeda's Edge kind of is in that space. I mean, they're very different games, but kind of in that similar hybrid type of game. So, I wish I enjoyed that one a lot, too, but I don't know, Ryan, this was I know I felt like we had also some not great plays of this one early on. Like, I don't know, I have a I have a memory at your old house of your our your friend just wiping the floor.

Maybe that was your only play of it.

the only time I've played it.

So, you know, I I almost feel like we didn't get a great impression of what this game could be. And I don't know, I felt like I got to

Potentially though, I know I also heard you say that you had repeatedly played it and felt like it just never quite

I know.

Well, I got over the hump. So, it's like what's it's hard to know like what's the

odds of getting a

I yeah, I guess honestly Well, I mean, and maybe that is a I don't know, you know, a downside of it is the winner feels amazing and the people who don't feel like they didn't get over the hump. I don't know.

Well, and that's actually something that's just true in general with race games, games that are a race to a certain thing,

is like you're left with uh the other people not getting to feed. That actually was one of my huge complaints with Viticulture.

Yeah, I was going to say you didn't like that about Viticulture.

has I mean I liked Viticulture, but I didn't love it.

You always talked about

Um in Viticulture, it's like a multi-stage process to kind of turn something into points cuz you got to grow the grapes and you got to do them into wine and age it or whatever. And so it's also a race, and so when somebody you'd have that last round where you realize somebody can go for it and they're going to get it.

Yeah.

And you'd look down and be like or you'd look at the other person and be like, oh, they're one stage behind. Like next the next turn they'd be able to make a bunch. And it's like such a bad feeling like to be like, well, I guess I'll squeak out some points in some different ways. Uh so it is an interesting thing with just racing games in general, like race to an objective.

and ones that require like multi- setting up of stuff, which this one has that too of you can't repeat, you know, so this taking the different actions you really are setting up the, you know, building and and producing of stuff.

No, cuz you compare it to something like an Age of Innovation, the Terraforming system where it's like there's six rounds, you know exactly how much time I mean even Agricola is this way like you know like it allows everybody to kind of like wrap up their plans on their own terms.

on you if you

Yeah, which is kind of nice.

Right, versus the like surprise of it.

Yeah.

Yeah, yeah.

I was like it was it was super fun to and I see why lots of people love this game. It was it was really cool to get it played again.

Man, two two like back from from the dead surprises there. Cascading inside.

It's good.

Um this next one does not continue that trend. This has been one that I've been really high on ever since getting it, and every time I get it played, I just have a great time. This is Innovation. Um I have the ultimate edition of it. It's actually been very fun to play repeat games of it and pick an expansion to throw in. You know, I I had a game I actually played a couple times this month. I had one that we threw in the new unseen expansion that um cuz cuz when you throw in an expansion in this, it literally doubles the cards in the game. Like you have every age has another deck from the new expansion and they're all unique innovations. So it's like suddenly there's twice as much

of shuffling in the setup that you have to do because of that?

There is a little bit cuz you have to shuffle you don't have you don't shuffle the expansions into the main deck which is nice so you don't have to do like separation later like a separate decks. But you do have to shuffle like if you're playing with the expansion, it's like okay, there's 11 eras and two decks for each era. Um but it's shuffling all of you know, 10 12 cards or whatever. Um but then the one that is going to be my second top play of month is the time that we played with the Echoes expansion which I have played with before. This was originally the first expansion that came out for Innovation. Add some cool things with these um echo effects. Well, first of all like you know how they have the icons and like that's a big part of the game is splaying and showing icons. Well, Echoes has some of the icons replaced with like little abilities and when you do the ability of your top card, you also get to do the ability of icons that are showing and if you have it splayed, you like start with the oldest one and go forward. So you can kind of like get these custom dogma effects because you've got these extra pieces attached to it. So that's interesting in and of itself, but then it has this whole concept of you can get cards into your forecast which is like okay, here's a card from an era that's coming up that you get to see. You get to know what's coming and put it down. But when you end up getting to that era, it's going to like auto play and auto trigger.

And like you can't decide you don't want it to. And so it's this really interesting thing of like cuz some of the effects in these games are just bonkers and sometimes you'll draw a card and you'll be like, I absolutely do not want that to happen. That would be horrible for and so you get, you know, one of these effects in your forecast and you're like, "Okay, I need to somehow do this so that will be like an advantage for me when this happens."

Right.

Um and it's and it can be a hugely powerful thing cuz you're getting like a free meld and action without having to take anything.

Mhm.

Um so, that's interesting and there's actually some cards in the new expansion decks that'll say like, "If forecasted, do a stronger effect." So, if you get those there, you can potentially pull off some really big crazy things. Which is fun in this game to pull off big crazy things.

Uh so, very fun to play with this that new stuff. Um this game ended in a way that many games of Innovation can can end, where I was leading in achievements. I was getting very close to getting the six achievements, which is often how the game ends, which often puts the other person in the position of just trying to hold you off and like race up the eras to try to find some Hail Mary backdoor into, you know, stealing the victory. And it's amazing how many times that actually does put pressure on the person that's ahead, um because um the other player he got up further and there started to just be some wild dangerous cards up there, even ones with with auto win conditions. Um but then he pulled a super clutch cuz I had all I had tons of points. I'm taking achievements. It's gets to that point where it's like, "If you don't do something, I'm going to just take the last two achievements."

And he managed to get something that let him like trash or [snorts] junk most of the standard achievements.

Mhm.

Um and so, suddenly those achievements weren't available for me. And so, then it was this really interesting thing of like, "I'm at five achievements. I'm one away, but there's no standard achievements to get. I wasn't really close to any of the global achievements that are pretty like specific conditions. And now he's ahead of me on eras and he's got kind of the And so, it's kind of like, "But I was way ahead on points, so if he runs out the eras, it's going to score You score by points if you get all the way to the end." So, but he's potentially looking for a, you know, a different And so, there's a really interesting kind of twist in kind of this like, "Where am I going to get my, you know, last thing here?" And I ended up being able to pull off a very clever move. I had had a card earlier in the game called Seed Drill that has this ability, it like demands that the other player has to get rid of a card, return one of their top cards that's like three or less, but then it lets you junk either the I think it's the three, four, or five deck and like completely get rid of that deck. Um And then, after junking it, it lets you achieve a card from the junk pile.

And so, I'd used that earlier in the game, but it had gotten covered by multiple cards. It was like down in my deck, but it was it's like one of the only ways that I could like backdoor an achievement cuz I could like get an achievement from the junk pile. Well, I ended up getting the card Coal, which Coal's whole thing is you choose a color and you're going to you score the top card of that color twice, which means that those cards are going from that pile into your score pile. So, you're burning, you know, it's very thematic. You're burning them into points.

Makes sense.

Well, I was able to strategically use that to burn away exactly the two cards that were sitting on top of Seed Drill to reveal Seed Drill so that I could backdoor my sixth achievement out of the junk pile with no standard achievements left. You know, and it's those types of things in innovation that like are just so satisfying cuz it's such a unique com- like it was so unique to

this game

Yeah.

that this situation came up that the achievements are trashed, you know, I need one more. And then, to spot it. Like it would have been so easy for me to not see this move cuz I had to realize that I had Seed Drill covered up exactly down enough that Coal would be able to reveal it and cuz otherwise, Coal didn't make sense to me cuz I didn't need more points.

Right.

Um and so, it just there I feel like so consistently when I play this game there's interactions like this or turns where you you realize a way to use your two actions that's like, "Ah, that was just a really good way to, you know, position myself or whatever. Um So, very fun game. We in hindsight found that like, you know, if he, the other player, had just gotten you know, this other card from the top deck or whatever, he actually would have had a shot at an instant win condition. So, it like really did feel close down the stretch. Um but, yeah. I I say that every time I think I bring this game up that it just feels like a game that I'm not going to get tired of and that I could play this 100 times and still Um and every time I play, it just further confirms that feeling for me. I mean, I think the expansions, especially in this new fourth edition where I think they cleaned up some stuff and made the expansions easier to to integrate. It's great fun to sit down and be like, this time let's play with this one expansion.

And the whole game kind of feels a little different because of that one. And obviously, like I think seed drill was an expansion card. So, like this whole combo was only possible because we were playing with echoes. Um

Right.

So, yeah. It's It's so fun and satisfying. If there's one knock I have against the game, it's it's in that category of games that is so hard to predict how long it's going to take to play. I've games that take like, you can have like a half hour game if somebody kind of like

Yeah.

you know, get something quick. I've had games go over 2 hours because if you really are going toe-to-toe, if you, you know, have something like this that the achievements get junked or something. Now, they're amazing games. Like, I'm not There's no regret. But, it does make it hard to pull it off the shelf and be like,

do we have time for another game?

Maybe.

Right.

Kind of over budget.

Great fun.

Yeah, speaking of games that also I think share that uh who knows how long this will take. Um My number one, Ryan, is a game This was I think when you know, whenever we go through our top games of all time, which if you're new around here, we just did that, did our top 50 of all time. Um and every time we go through that, you know, we're very transparent with people about how much we play our games. Um you know, that's that's one of the things we value here. We are honest and so it this

like to get roasted for

to get roasted for not playing our favorite games. At least we actually posted it.

But this was one that when I saw that it had zero plays in the last year, it broke my heart, Ryan, because this is you look in the mirror and you go I'm not the man I thought I was. I thought I was. I realized my life needed a change and I needed to get this one to the table. And so I got my a group together, a group a new group. They had not actually No, two of two of them had one of them had played it before. The other two hadn't. And we got to play a four-player game of Eldritch Horror.

Oh, wow. That's right.

And Ryan, it was such a joy to get this game to the table again. Given that two of them, this was their first game, um and when you know, we keep track of all of our plays in BG Stats and so I can see what ancient ones have I played against and I actually had never played against, at least since I've been recording, against Azathoth.

we probably did way way back. Oh, yeah.

which and actually I specifically chose him because it was our first time playing and I didn't know if it was the things were going to be a little slower and he's the one where when he flips you just lose. So

Yeah, he just is more vanilla overall. His mysteries are a little more standard.

Right. So I felt like it maybe capped I did it more from a length perspective and whatnot. Um

Yeah.

But I tell you what, it was a wonderful game of Eldritch Horror. Like it just felt like it delivered exactly what we long for in Eldritch Horror. We came out of the gate and we were we were dominating. I mean, I I don't think I've played a game of Eldritch Horror I can't think of for a long time where the the doom track. We were we were fine. We the whole game. we weren't even close to to dropping on Doom. Uh we did have a couple people die um in very sudden uh instances. Which does drop Doom. Now, fortunately, we went back to their bodies and you know, did did the interaction. I think at least once was able to retrieve the Doom back up. There was another uh like item someone got that uh one of those, you know, where you uh collect things collect things on it and you flip. And so, he got like I think three on there and flipped and then we ended up like retrieving Doom, which is pretty sweet.

game of Eldritch, we won the game on someone flipping it with a bunch one of those with a bunch of stuff cuz it ended up being such a powerful effect.

Right.

Like I think it enhanced the mystery that we were on.

So, we we start off the game and and we are just like I'm I'm like, "Man, we're feeling good. Good start." You know, sometimes you start those games Eldritch and just everything falls apart right away. And then oh, we got hit with some brutal Mythos cards. Like and and with it, I think we had two rumors come out. Um at like so, we have like two rumors, which rumors are terrible and you got to try to figure out and they like um you know, so we're needing to try to get a bunch of clue tokens for them. We don't have clue tokens. The uh objective uh the Mythos that we're on not the Mythos, the uh yeah, objective

The mystery active mystery.

active mystery I think was defeating this monster who was way down in the corner and we were like not ready. So, the and then two of those died. I mean, so there was a moment of like everything's collapsing and oh my gosh. Um but again, our our Doom track was okay. The real threat in this game was the Mythos deck. Like we had some things that that moved the Mythos like made it uh um I don't know if it like made it discard an extra one or something like that. Um but that was what we as the game got close, we were having to count how many cards were left and we're like, "Okay, this is all we have left uh to try to to try to make this work." Um but but we were able to just make a big turnaround. We had some key moments. I mean, those rolls where it's like you need uh, you know, a one die and you and you get it the success and um, I feel like we had several of those moments down the stretch uh, that uh, that we ended up uh, pulling off.

But somehow we we got through that stretch. We we solved the rumors. We uh, you know, killed the guy down there. Um, and then we also had a really clutch moment. I think this was another one of those items where you can stack things on it and then choose to flip. Um, where it was one of those that lets you advance the mystery by one. And it was in a

what won us the game in the last game I played.

it's in a it was in a situation where we had like two of the three. But it was like um, and we're counting the cards. We're like, we have like four [snorts] rounds left and we're going to at least need two rounds to try to get this last one cuz we're not even close. And so to get it and be like, oh my gosh, we advanced the mystery. We've got a shot here. And got to the last one and and we were able to to pull it out. And so it just it hit what we wanted in Elder Tour. It was tight. There were moments of rejoicing. There were moments of sorrow. It was despair and yet we pulled through. Um, I felt like we just all walked away having had a blast with it. And I mean, it we say this all the time about the other Elder Tour, the sandbox of this game. I mean, it truly like you it's what even I could I would want to play it again right now because you you go into it and just all the things that happen and the different combinations of items and events and all of the different things just make it so fun. I think I said to you cuz we've kind of gone back and forth a little bit on you know, we have someone else read the card for a person um, which is a great way to keep everyone engaged. Um, but I think in the past we've had it where like we'll read the option that a person has and then we'll give a little like maybe a hint, a clue as to

I'd say the biggest gray area is it would there'd be a somebody fails a test and it's kind of like, "Should [snorts] I use rerolls? Should I use clue tokens?" And a lot of times the person would go, "You really want to pass this

Or even there's the ones where it's like you you could climb the climb this thing or do that but I think we would hint at like what skill check is it on each one? I'm completely out on that. I I because here's what I realized, does it make the game harder to not tell someone necessarily which one although sometimes you can intuitively guess but it's more fun. Like cuz you just tell them the thematic situation they're given with and they kind of look at their character and they think like, "Okay, what would my character want to do?" And sometimes they make the wrong choice and but sometimes they make the wrong choice and they roll a success and they still get through it and so it's it just made me realize like leaning into the the thematic craziness of the game and letting letting that be fun. I mean I did even follow your advice, Ryan. At one point I was considering like, "Okay, there's different myth tier difficulty mythos cards. Do you Do you make get a ratio, right? You know, do some ratio of easy, medium, hard, mix them together to try to create a more balanced thing. And I think I just realized you convinced me that part of the fun of Eldritch is anything can happen and the and leaning into that.

swingy randomness factors beyond the mythos deck and so like, you know, your dice rolling could be going really poorly and the the chance that there could actually be some more positive ones in the mythos could like balance it out. I mean there's just it's yeah, there there is a certain point where it's like this is the type of game. And now granted, there's things we like about Eldritch compared to Arkham. We like that Eldritch actually defines the mythos deck.

Right.

With it. Um but it's like how far do you want to go with trying to control

Right.

the beast that is Arkham or Eldritch.

say one more, and I'm just recalling this now, pivotal moment in the game. So, one of the guys got a dark pact, which for those of you don't know, that it has one does. You know, every every time there's a reckoning, you have to roll, and if you roll one, you're you flip it, and typically it is very very the worst possible thing that can happen to you. So, he has a dark pact, and he's surviving, he's surviving. Well, I end up getting a dark pact as well. And I very early roll, and it flips, and it's the one where you have to kill someone else. And so, I kill him because he has a dark pact. So, we were able to with like I considered it a success. Two dark pacts, and only one of one person died, that's honestly like we'll take that, right? And he ended up actually getting a character that that worked out pretty well down the stretch at the end.

So, the way all those dark pacts resolved actually ended up being being okay, but

Yeah.

I do like that with all the expansion content I got I have gotten over the years that every expansion I think has added more dark pacts, which is nice because now there's really a pretty big range of what could happen.

Cuz it used to be like either I'm dying or you're dying.

Someone's dying.

That's how I felt in the base game.

Right.

Whereas now I we've gotten some that are like, "Oh, I didn't know a dark pact could do that."

Yeah. Yeah, that's cool.

Which is fun that that's possible.

Right. So,

It was great, Ryan. It was great.

I'm proud of us after both of us, you know, having zero plays between our top games list, both of us have gotten it played now.

You know, Ryan, they say accountability is powerful. When you make yourself accountable to nearly 5,000 subscribers, and whoever else is watching, man, gets you to play the games that you need to play.

Yep. I feel like a better person. My number one play of the month that I teased at was with the friend that uh

Yeah. I was playing Arkham Horror card game with and actually this is his game. I do not own this game though I anticipate I will own this game. Um we got to play a three-player game of Lord of the Rings Fate of the Fellowship. And this is one that I had played once with him before but we had kind of gotten wrecked. We lost pretty early. We made a key error in our first game. So the the the board has tons of these paths where like you know the orcs are going to travel along and they kind of like lead towards some of these major strongholds in the in the Lord of the Rings universe. Um and so a big part of the game is trying to you know prevent them from getting to these strongholds where they're going to or these havens where they're going to take them over.

But we made a mistake of like you know there were a bunch of orcs going and we're like oh we'll stop them here not realizing that like once they move into you if they move again they just keep going. It's not like they stop because you're there fighting them.

Oh yeah.

And I think in our minds we were thinking as long as we get here like unless they kill us like we'll hold them off. But then they just like walked past us and then we scrambled and you know it ended up being a key mistake. Um but we went into this one two of us had played before one was new to the game and I feel like this we just got to have the full Fate of the Fellowship experience. And honestly like it's the closest the closest comparison and feeling I can give is to War of the Ring in terms of getting this huge alternate story of the Lord of the Rings you know with all of its scope and epic scale. Um but to get to do it in a cooperative game that isn't quite as long as War of the Ring is huge. Now granted we had a long game. We we clocked in almost at three hours and part of that was like we hadn't played the game a ton so we're still you know having to look up some stuff or whatever. Part of it is just though that if you get into a cooperative game where you're discussing options and alternatives, like you can, you know, have some long turns if you're really considering some different things.

Right.

But I just love how, you know, we love that in any cooperative game, that the discussion of what should we do whatever. And this is actually somewhat true of Eldritch. I love how in this game the things you're describing of what to do, they have such a strong thematic parallel of what you're talking about. It's like, "Do we, man, I had Eomer who's really good at like if he has some of his Rohan troops with him, he's really really good cuz he like cancels a damage to a Rohan troop." So he's really good in battle. And so it was like we had problems up north, like way up north in like the it was through Lorien up into the dwarven area. And I was like, "Man, do I trek up there with Eomer and an and an army to go fight this?" And and we're leaving Rohan a little bit, you know, undefended. And that's what we ended up doing and everything. And we're fighting up there.

And as the game went on, we ended up having Minas Tirith fall. And there was this big thing at the end coming back to Rohan and trying to like kind of bolster that. Um but I also love in this game how like there's a bunch of characters and everybody plays two. And it really does change the feel of the game depending on what characters I'm playing. I mean, I mentioned Eomer was a really big focus with some of our battles. Well, another one of the players had Gollum. And we hadn't had Gollum in the first game I played. But Gollum is such an interesting character here because if you can get him together with Frodo and Sam, it makes their travel so much easier because it like I think it cancels results on like a search roll or whatever. So you can be a little more risky with your movement, which is super thematic cuz Gollum ends up being like their guide to Mordor.

Mhm.

Um but he has these downsides to him of like if ever he and Frodo and Sam and another unit, friendly unit, are in the same place, you like lose a hope. So it's like you want Gollum with Frodo and Sam, but then they literally can never even like go through somewhere where other people are, so you have to kind of sneak and there's just some logistics with that that were challenging of like how do we, you know, get past these and stuff. Um but it ended up being super clutch down the stretch as we're getting to the final, you know, throwing the ring into Mount Doom. Like Gollum is so helpful um for all of that. Um and so I really love what this game is doing. Like it's got the core kind of Pandemic system with the cards and kind of the the enemy deck, though there's so much added on here that it doesn't feel like I'm playing Lord of the Rings Pandemic.

Like it does feel like a pretty uh like distinct game. Um but it still has a certain simplicity to it. Like with the cards and what you're doing. And so it really is this nice in between like it feels so epic. Like we have games in our collection that we talk about as like epic games and it's in that category, but it's not as long as most of those at least normally. And I imagine like as you play it more you get the the time down more. So I'm pretty high on this one and see [clears throat] it as one uh that I definitely anticipate um owning at some point. I mean some of I have notes here of some of the other just things that were happening. We had the ents come out and end up supporting um going down to Helm's Deep because Helm's Deep needed more defense there. We had actually as all that was happening um there was kind of like this surprise attack um group of, you know, enemies that ended up kind of back way back like going towards the Shire. And so suddenly it was like, oh my gosh, we're like completely undefended back here with these havens.

And And so then Gandalf ended up leading a charge with all these elves from Rivendell and went back and there was this big battle in Bree, which is like, you know, just outside the Shire. And it's like none of that. It's just so fun for fans of the source material to get to picture these alternate, you know, storylines that are happening. Yeah. Um and we did at the very end squeeze out a very close victory. And similar to your game, our biggest threat was the deck running out.

Mhm.

Um, and so it was kind of this thing where we count our turns and we're like, "Okay, like if we're throwing the ring in on your turn, like we have to do it this this in three turns or whatever, we're going to run out of cards." And so we planned this whole, you know, there's on your turn when you move somebody, you can move other people with you.

Mhm.

Um, and so you can come up with a lot of strategy of how to get people to different locations and being like, "Okay, if you move these people here and get them here and then this could pick them up and move them." But it's very hard to get into Mordor. Um, and so it was all just a very satisfying strategic ending on how we were able to kind of like set it up while we were holding off this big army in kind of like the Minas Tirith area and we got, I think, so it was like Frodo and Sam and Gollum, but I think uh, Faramir or Farmer went with them um, cuz he had some stuff that could help get them cuz I think he can ignore like an icon on a secret path. Like there's there's kind of shortcuts in the game that if you discard cards, you can use the shortcuts. And he had an ability that he could like ignore it, so he kind of could help them there.

So, all that to say, great game. I I mean, it really is and it's fun like War of the Ring's so hard to get to the table. Um, and even when you do, it's two-player head-to-head strategic. I mean, it's in that category almost something like Twilight Struggle. And that's a very different feel than getting around [clears throat] with a group of friends and getting to be a team of the, you know, the good guys and trying to still play through this epic story.

Yeah, I mean, this sure sounds like a game that I would consider ordering, doesn't it, Ryan?

Yeah. It's almost like I'm trying to think of how our video orders came out uh, where this one would be compared to a video where Dingle may have claimed that he uh, had played the Fellowship of the Ring.

I recorded that previous video, the game was ordered and I thought on the way um, but uh, it was taking a little longer than I than I was hoping to for it to ship. And with uh

Let's Let's be honest. That had no bearing on the decision.

Well, no, it did because if I would have gotten the game

Yeah, I get It had no bearing on the decision at that point. It could have prevented the decision from being necessary.

I And then it is a Game Nerd's uh they announced a big sale they're having in today. I'm We're about an hour 45 out and I decided to cancel my order, save my gift card that I that I had been given so I can just go crazy on Nerds Day. So, hopefully I can get

So, you know what I'm going to be doing in 2 hours is fielding Dingle's request of what games he should buy.

That's right.

But, yeah, I I think you would very much enjoy Fate of Fa. I mean, I think it hits on something you've been describing that you would like for your collection.

Mhm.

Um I honestly could see playing it solo. Um

You say that about every game, Ron.

I mean, yeah, it's this aspirational future where I'm playing more solo games.

alternate universe where I have time to play it solo.

You know, you know, it'll happen so. And that's like I want to do my top 10 solo games someday, but I I don't have 10. Cuz like I I don't like play that many and like I like to play the same ones a lot.

So, you're talking about something

Yeah, actually. I've never played it, but

Yeah.

I needed It's my favorite.

Counting down Ron's top seven.

Yeah, doesn't not as not as punchy.

Yeah, stay tuned, folks. Hey, if any of those games sounded particularly fun, you can check them out for yourself down in the description below. We've got lots of different content talking about board games on this channel. There's a few suggestions here that you could check out, and we will see you in the next one.

Progress saved