Skip to main content
Loading video...

Games Leaving My Shelf | June 2021 | 7 Games I'm Getting Rid Of!

Transcript 24:00

how's it going everyone dylan here from all you can board and i've got a different kind of video today at least different for me carlo has done a video like this he called it curating my collection which is the alliteration in there is just so much better than mine which is just games leaving my shelf mine's a little more direct in that sense um it's basically the same thing though i obviously have a whole bunch of board games here i've got two calyx shelves one bigger one one smaller one and they are full to the brim so every so often it's just time to do a little bit of a purge and get rid of some games so it's always a little bit of a hard decision sometimes some are a little bit easier than others but when you get to this many titles sometimes you just have multiples that have you know some of the same mechanics or ones that just play similar or you just realize that out of everything you're just never going to choose to play this game there's a variety of reasons my situation is obviously more unique because i have so many i think if you're someone only has you know say like 10 games 20 games you have less reason or less incentive to get rid of some or if you are it's maybe a little bit of a tougher decision so um don't take these games that i'm gonna pick as sort of like that they're bad or like you should also get rid of them or anything like that this is very much in a vacuum in terms of like how like my situation compared to what yours may be or someone else's and it's just also preference like i could get rid of a game here that you would personally love and there's a few here that i know are hits and that people would i do enjoy or would enjoy playing it just for me personally they don't make a lot of sense anymore so let's jump right in with the very first game we're going to talk about which is lanterns so lanterns is a game i've actually had in my collection for a while and i do really enjoy this game i have played it a lot and one of the reasons i got it and one

of the reasons i enjoyed playing it so much was it's a game that people that don't play a lot of board games it's an easy one to get to the table and to have fun with um and a lot of the mechanics you know they are very simple but it does offer this thing that even when it's not your turn you're benefiting from some of the tiles being placed in terms of the cards you can draw and you can get a little tricky with that too where you know even though i'm drawing cards for these colors the colors that i'm giving to you i'm giving you specifically colors that the cards aren't available so the way the game plays is you know you're playing these square tiles to the board and every time you match colors on the tiles there's four colors one for each side you're drawing tiles based on where those colors are facing and if they're facing your opponent they're drawing colored cards as well so even when it's on your turn you're having to balance what cards you're drawing and what cards your opponent's drawing it's this little tug of war thing it's really neat because you can have the perfect tile to place and say i'm going to draw this color i need but i'm also giving them this color that they need but you can use it to your advantage and sometimes you know give them colors they don't need or ones that don't have any cards left and they don't get a draw so in that way the mechanics are really good um there's a little bit of complexity there so it's not too simple and you're basically just trying to make certain sets of colors or you know getting a matching of the same color and different things like that and you have these scoring tiles if you race to get the scoring tiles you get higher scores than if you achieve them later on so i do really like lanterns like i mentioned um i have enjoyed it every time i've played after multiple plays i find that i'm a little bit less enthused to play lanterns um games start to kind of feel the same

especially because i was playing lanterns often at two players i would say that often the flow would kind of go the same um depending on the tiles you drew it would end up being a race for the same one to start and then generally you know to catch up you have to get this one and then they are going to pull ahead with this one and the scores always end up close and someone just pulls a head based on the tiles they drew it had a little bit less interest there i'd say with three and four it's more interesting but the main reason i'm getting rid of it is because the function that is served in my collection was this niche that hey here's a game i can introduce to someone who might not be super into board games but this is a simple concept and we'll have some fun with it and it might introduce into the next stage and the fact is i have a lot better options now there's way more options that i go to before i go to lanterns in that regard um you know even a two-player count that games like jaipur and and seven wonders duel for even more complexity um you know if you really want to get to at the higher level of curious cargo and everything that's that's a little bit you know more complex but i have tons of options at two stellar is another great one um and now even at higher player counts you know sub-astral i just thought it was one that i would go to i think it's a little more simple but has you know um you know feels really good to play and it's sort of an introductory game in some ways um and there's a whole bunch of higher player counts like a zuul i have two versions of azul i'd go to both of those before i would go to lanterns if i'm introducing a game to someone patchwork's another two-player one like i have so many that i would just gravitate towards in terms of here's an easy game to introduce someone with basic rules that might you know serve as a gateway game to them that lanterns just never hits the table so it's a good game but ultimately i think

it's one that it's just been replaced in my collection and might be replaced in yours if you you know gravitate to a lot of these sort of gateway games or these you know simple but you know strategically fun games i think just eventually lanterns gets outpaced elisa did for me so that's the reason gabriel lanterds still a great game but just one that i personally don't play as much anymore so that is lanterns let's move on to the next one which is the resistance so i am a huge fan of these hidden role games um that's actually some of the first games i ever played that really got me into the tabletop gaming um not only but some of them were actually hit and roll games and even before that i remember playing mafia with my friends a lot with just playing cards it's i've always always enjoyed hitting role games i love it i love the aspect of having to deceive and lie and play a role um you know when you're discussing with your friends i think it really depends what group you have i think the group can really you know influence how good of an experience you have with a hidden role game if you know the people feel comfortable with them you need to be okay with lying and not taking it personally when people lie to you but if you can get into that groove it's just a lot of fun to just sort of play these different roles the reason i'm getting rid of the resistance is that honestly anytime i'm gonna i'm able to convince people to play hidden role gamer that's what we're planning to do we just have a lot more fun with the chaotic nature of one night ultimate werewolf especially because i have the expansion for it as well that ends up being more fun there's more laughter that the roles are a little bit more complex if you want them to be and they they tend to be a little bit more chaotic it just ends up being a little bit more of a frenzy which is kind of what i want i'm not looking for something you know competitive or you know taking it too seriously it's supposed to just be fun who cares

really at the end of the day who wins it like each round it's more just the experience we're doing as we get there the resistance is just one that always ends up not you know hitting the table for that reason or when it has we've played one night and resistance and everyone ends up saying let's just play another round one night um or we just sort of after the fact realize uh next time let's only play one ultimate werewolf that's just me personally i don't have the resistance avalon i know it's similar in many ways but um i know a lot of people swear by the resistance and that's sort of their favorite in my instance and i guess that with the people i'm playing the consensus even beyond me has always just been that they prefer one and ultimate werewolf so ultimately with a game that requires to play so many i have so many other people to play i kind of do have to go with the consensus a little bit and ultimately i haven't played this in years now because any time we get one of those to the table it ends up being one and ultimate werewolf so no knock on the game whatsoever and especially if you don't have a hidden roll game i think this is still a great one to buy and introduce to play to people and you'll have a ton of fun with it me personally it just doesn't hit the table anymore so that's why i'm getting rid of it next up we have dice city a little bit of a bigger box on this one so dice city is an interesting one um i've had this game for a while i've played a handful of times and i've had fun every time i've played it but the fact of the matter is there's a the games i prefer over it in that dice genre they're different but i always rather i think of those games more when i'm thinking of playing you know a dice heavy experience or a game where it involves you you know utilizing dice drafting dice um or whatever the case may be use them to

modify things on the board dice city is a lot of fun but i would much rather play games like you know even castles of burgundy which has a dice element to it uh coimbra um voyages of marco polo there's just way uh too many other dice games i would prefer to play over dice city that ultimately i never end up playing dice city when i like i shouldn't say never i have a handful of times but when i do i'm never left with an experience going oh i can't wait to play dice city again or the next time we're going to play or let's play another round if anything it sometimes makes me feel like oh you know that was it was fun but next time let's play for that reason that to scratch that itch let's play this one instead the games i've played with dice city have also been and it's weird because the i think they they list the time here is like 45 minutes or something yeah playing time 45 minutes um even though it plays one to four and i've never once had that be the experience and i don't know if that's just because i'm playing with people that we all play slow or what the case may be but when i played with four it's actually ended up being like a two two-hour game um you know i think that's happened twice now that i play with four players and it's ended up being a very long experience and even when i play with two players it's still crossing an hour usually and it ends up just feeling longer than it needs to be it ends up feeling like the game is dragging a little bit for me again it could just be we're playing slow it does say 45 minutes i don't know whether that's it's just my experience that that's that inaccurate or whether that's just in you know a an incorrect time listed on the box um i do appreciate that it plays solo and it has that option i think that if you're really in today's

city and into like um the mechanics that it brings being able to play solo on your own is a huge benefit and i do think that the artwork the theme and the way it's all put together is really fun like for those who don't know you basically have your own player board that has i think it's a five by five grid each one has a color associated to it and then on the top columns each one is the number of the six sided dice one to six and basically at the start of the game at the end of each round you're rolling dice and if you roll say a blue three you're looking at the blue row and then you're putting it into the three column and that's where you place your die you're doing that for all five of the colors and based on your turn you are choosing for each of those placements whether you want to use the die for the action space that's underneath it or you want to use it to say move another die to another spot or there's a whole bunch of other things you can do with it and then you're also upgrading the building so you're able to build from a common supply put new buildings on your board then you can activate on later turns with dice um if you're again anything with dice there isn't a luck component here but it's also a game where you can modify dice and move them around so you don't feel like you're too restricted there the mechanics are solid it's really fun there is a lot of player interaction which i think might be a reason that it's not always clicking with uh you know the people i'm playing with and i shouldn't say that i'm not saying that as if player interaction's a bad thing believe me it's a great thing but i find that this one's so direct sometimes because you're attacking other people's um locations on the board and then deactivating them essentially that sometimes they can just feel a little bit more mean than some people are expecting um i love player interactions but when it's very directed at a player and you have to you're playing with four and you're choosing to attack someone and

deactivate their building and slow them down it can get a little frustrating sometimes people are on the table i don't always play with very competitive tabletop gamers sometimes it's a mix you know some are competitive someone's more casual i find that the very direct attacks can sometimes be a turn off for some people and it doesn't it doesn't always just feel great in general the way it's executed i love the aspect of how you can choose what to do with the dice and and you know upgrading your buildings again it is a solid experience i have enjoyed it it's just not my go-to for dice games or of this nature where you're you know choosing how to utilize your dice changing values moving things around executing actions with it again i wouldn't and i always failed to to call castles of burgundy a dice game but even though dice are so heavily involved in it there's it's just never how i think of it but i'd much rather play castles of burgundy it's my favorite games but i'd much rather play queen but i'd much rather play you know a game like sagrada isn't you know it's very different in the way it uses its dice than than dice city but if i'm thinking of dice games that have an itch for it i just gravitate to a lot of gather games besides dice city so that's why it's leaving my collection i've had my fun with it and i've had some good times with it but ultimately it's time for it to go and there's going to be other games i'm going to play instead so that is dice city next up a game that carlo is going to kill me for for putting on this list but then again he owns it so if i really you know regret it i can just board off him or maybe he won't let me because he'll be like well you shouldn't have gotten rid of it uh that is hive so this is one of carlo's favorite games i think maybe i don't know overall but he really does love it a lot he's played a lot of it um me personally so i got hive because carlo had it i played it i think once

with him um and he talked it up a lot i and this is early on when i was buying tabletop games this is one of my first games i think i bought um and you know i had a really good time with it and so i got it and you know he was raving about it as well and i have enjoyed it i just haven't played it a lot and i've realized i i wondered for a while and i even asked myself why i wasn't playing hype a lot other people would suggest and it wasn't always i wasn't always enthused to play it and i've realized that it's not often that in abstract games like this you know i compare this sometimes to chess and that kind of abstract game where you know your each tile has its own purpose and can move it in a different way and and has its own ability whatever the case may be and you're having to utilize them it's not that i don't like that but it's not my favorite genre and it really has to be a solid game that utilizes those mechanics to hook me and the game i'll use to compare is santorini so santorini is a little bit different because you know it's not like you have a bunch of different pieces and each one has its own ability but it has its own kind of chess feel to your moving pieces around the god powers change what you can do and your opponent can do things differently i gravitate more to a game like santorini in its execution than i gravitate to hype so when i'm sitting down to play an abstract game right now i'm not choosing to play hive as a especially because like you play i play center and you have two players primarily and this is a two-player game if i'm convincing someone or they want to play an abstract game of that type or one that's played shorter we can play multiple rounds i'm just i'm not choosing hive and and i'm choosing santorini almost every single time instead so that contributes a lot to me getting rid of it the one benefit of hive in that regard is that and i know i think this is that carlos dumas and played this a lot in this way is that you can play hive as a travel game it

even comes with a bag in the box that i'll actually pull it up um it comes with a bag in the box that holds all the tiles see here right and you don't even have to bring the box with you it has an insert underneath that allows you to you know place all the tiles but the idea is you can pop that bag into your your backpack your travel bag whatever and you can play this on an airplane you can play this on a train you can play this on vacation in your hotel room it's a very easy game with no board it's just you know it's not as the board with the towels grows out large enough that it makes a little complicated but generally you can do it um and you know in that sense that's you're not pulling out santorini on a plane and playing it i mean hey if i looked over the next drone i saw someone playing santorini on the you know the little food table that you pulled down or whatever i would be damn impressed and i would be trying to you know trade seats next to them to go get in the game i would love it i'm not saying it's the most practical to carry all the components of santorini and all the bags of all the different towers and stacking up and hoping the towers don't fall over when you hit turbulence so not the most practical in that sense i think hive has a beat there but again for me personally i just i play center anymore i enjoy centering anymore and hive and as an abstract genre it's not my favorite to begin with so a game like hive for me just doesn't hit the table enough and again i'm also benefited that carlo does have it if i have the itch i can just ask carlo to throw out a game of hive and as long as he doesn't punish me too much for getting rid of mine i'm sure he'll say yes so that is why hive is leaving my collection next up this one is going to be one that i'm sure some people are going to really not like that i'm getting rid of i have to preface this by saying i do

really like this game um i'll let you know why i'm getting rid of it so that is time stories this is the base experience so time stories is a game that i had on my list to buy for a long time and just for whatever reason didn't or i couldn't find it the times i thought about buying it and i think it was last boxing day um it was on a massive sale on one of the canadian retailers and i picked it up so i finally played it with uh with carlo when we were at the cabin one weekend we played it it was great i had i had a great experience the problem for me with time stories is this is a game for those who don't know it's it's a legacy game but the idea is that you know are playing a scenario so let's use the scenario that came in here as an example you were exploring that scenario and you're basically on a bit of a time limit you're going to run out of time before you cannot do any more actions all these time agents are going to be pulled back because you're going to a different period of time for each scenario and you're basically going to have to have keep all that information that you have from what you explored remember that when you went to this location this happened when you went here that's how you got the key to open the skate whatever retain that information play and that's your that's the end of your session either immediately or next time you guys get together play again with all that retained knowledge and basically be able to move quicker so now you know i know where the key is for the skate so you can just do it right away instead of having to spend a bunch of time figuring that out and now you make it farther in the scenario and farther and eventually you'll be able to you know however many sessions it takes so you'll be able to complete the scenario with all the knowledge you're retaining it's a fantastic concept and i like the way it's executed in a board game but the fact of the matter is

if you are not playing consistently with the same group often enough to retain this knowledge or be able to refer to your notes and understand what happened if you're not doing that enough it's you're not going to get the full benefit of time stories it i it's been so long since me and carlo played if we went back now we would we would forget almost everything that happened we would basically be it would be like we were playing the first for the first time again that scenario maybe we remember a thing or two but that's how you have to approach time stories you have to be ready to meet consistently with you know or live with someone whatever the case may be and play it consistently to get the full benefit and if you do that it's probably going to be an amazing experience especially because there's all the scenarios you can add on you're probably gonna love it the problem is i could do that and get the group together but there's already games that i am doing that for and and when the pandemic's over and i'm gathering again gloomhaven my our scenario we were one scenario away from finishing that or two centers away from finishing that that's gonna be the first thing to get together on frost haven comes out later this year i'm gonna be doing a frost having group for god knows how long that was in the gloomhaven group for two years um i have earth sworn into the deepwood coming which is another one i'm going to get into you know i was playing tainted grail with a group before i already have so many of these games that i'm meeting regularly with groups where i honestly don't have room to meet with another a group to play time stories um if i did this would not believe my collection unless i had already finished the all the scenarios and i didn't have use for it anymore so that's literally the only reason it's leaving it has nothing to do with the quality of the game it's just i for me gloomhaven and frost statement take precedence oh sworn takes precedence and i'm sure that by the time i finish all those then

games like aridia will be out and i'll be you know playing that one i love campaign games i'm getting sleeping gods sometime soon so there's all these campaign games i'm getting that like i just don't have room for another legacy game like this unfortunately so that's the reason it's leaving don't fault me too much i know it's a great game i just personally don't have the the will power the fortitude to have another campaign group going that's the only reason it's leaving my collection all right let me look at my time here okay we're doing good um next one leaving my collection is another game i like but it's just been eclipsed by some other ones and that is cottage garden so cottage garden um is a polynomial game and it's by uva rosenberg it's part of the the set of um polyamino games that includes spring meadow and indian summer um patchwork i guess is also in there but that came first and it's you know uh i don't know if that's technically considered part of the the trilogy or the quadrilogy or jet whatever it's a great game out of spring meadow cottage garden and indian summer i actually think cottage garden is my favorite one it's it's definitely in if not it's second for sure um so i it's again this one where has nothing to do with the quality of the game it's more so that now with how many polyaminos i've accumulated in my collection i never play cottage garden there's other ones i just prefer to play i prefer to play new york zoo i really like new york zoo i prefer to play barron park and that baron park actually has a lot of similarities to cottage garden in terms of multiple polyamino boards that you're you know utilize instead of one giant one i prefer to play patchwork um so with two players i'm playing patchwork with anything above two players i'm playing barron park or new york zoo

my city is another one that you know the legacy version kept me busy for a long time but even the the version you're left with after the legacy version is a really simple polyamino to introduce to people um there's just there's way too many polyaminos that i'm playing over cottage i mean if i want a heavy experience i'm playing feast rodent even so it just it was a circumstance of i looked at it and i said when was the last time i played cottage garden can't remember when is the next time i'm gonna play cartridge garden no idea it just it won't get played for me personally i will say though if you haven't played cottage garden if you don't have a lot of polyamorous in your collection or you've just played you know very entry level ones or you play patchwork for instance i would really recommend actually checking cottage garden because i think it's a really great one and i've had a great time when i've played it and it has the perfect theme if you're going to the cabin or the cottage a lot and looking for these more laid-back games the theme matches the the gameplay matches it's a great choice so and i know people who still have it so i can still play cottage garden if i really get the itch but for me it's just other polyominous of the clip stick so that is cottage garden and last but not least uh maybe least is uh first martians adventures on the red planet so uh lots of controversy not controversy uh i would just say that you know it's been a very tepid response to to this game and i got it because it was on a massive sale and i thought you know what i'm going to play this game solo maybe and or with one other person and you know even if it's not the best experience for this price i'll enjoy it i uh was wrong i have not enjoyed it

and most of that is less to do with the gameplay and more to do with the complexity for how much you have to learn and how much you have to set up and how complicated it is and how many components there are the payoff is just not there it it's you know i'm not even going to get into what all the mechanics are because to be honest it's been so long since i played it i i really can't explain them too well um it just i remember setting it all up i remember learning all the rules and uh and i'm like almost finally have like you know like three quarters through learning them all and i'm realizing this is gonna have a steep hill to climb to pay off on how much work i'm putting into learning this game uh and it just didn't pay off for me i think i got i didn't even get through the full uh scenario or no i did i finished the first i finished i played one session of it and i think i started to do the second i was like why am i doing this i didn't enjoy the first and i kind of just like let myself off the hook there so for me i ended up being wrong i thought i'd end up liking it more than some people did um i didn't and that's the reason i'm getting rid of it uh i know some people do out there still do like it and i i imagine that if you you know have more of a tolerance for the if you don't have a lot of games that are very complex in your in your collection or you do have a lot and you're used to like studying and reading all these complex rules and you're willing to put in the time the payoff maybe is okay for you for me it just i have a limited time i'm already having a lot of complex games and a lot of games to cover for aycb the payoff just wasn't there and it wasn't as fun for me so this is the one in my collection of all of this the one i actually enjoyed the least that's the reason it's leaving my collection whereas the other ones i would say i enjoyed um they're just leaving for you know logistical reasons with other games but

first martians is going and i cannot say i would i'm going to miss it unfortunately all right this is the why did i stack them like this this is like the most precarious way to stack it i got the smallest box on the bottom and i got the biggest box on the top i'm gonna i'm gonna put a couple of these down so i don't have a an accident with all these games when i'm trying to potentially sell them and get rid of them let's just slide them out of here um so yeah that's all the games i'm getting rid of in my collection um let me know what you guys think of the comments uh which one of these games do you think i'm going to regret the most which one am i going to the soonest be like i wish i didn't get rid of that game and which one of these um do you agree with the most which one of you like i'm surprised you still had that in your collection get rid of that thing i'm surprised you bought it in the first place um first martians uh no but like let me know uh let me know what your list is like what are some games in the last month or two you've gotten rid of which ones have you parted with i'd love to hear in the comments i love discussing this stuff i hope you guys enjoyed the video um carlos series is titled obviously way better than mine curating my collection i love i'm going to try to do some time to time still though and i'm sure carlos as well so you're going to see some of this and get a feel for which ones leave our collection and why and which ones stay in our collection and you know um last the test of time here so hope you enjoyed the video thank you so much for watching we'll see you in the next one

Progress saved