The Best and Worst Board Games of June 2023 - What I Played
Transcript
thank you hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences we'll get on with the show in just a minute but first a quick word for my sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solution head down to my new sponsor kiander.co.uk kielder stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on ultra's over 30 pound further discounts on bulk purchases and even five percent of your spending refunded bacteria's points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get five percent discount on your first order over 60 pounds so let's make gaps in your collection a thing of the past get down to kinder and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it so it's time for another Roundup of games that I've played recently and I'll be doing another video sort of akin to this one which will basically do a six month review of the year so far for 2023 but for now this is all about games I've played in June now I've played a lot of games in June partially because of the UK games Expo because that's the time when I get to play a lot of the games but I've also been playing a fair few games online board game arena has had a bit of a research in for me with some people and you know it's just been quite a plentiful month for games now I'm not going to talk about games that I've played which I've reviewed or going to review because that kind of defeats the purpose and now spend less time talking about ones that I've talked about on
other episodes that I can talk about something a little bit different but first I will mention inventions from vitala sorter this is a game that I talked about on a recent podcast episode I believe I talked about it on the UK games Expo review episode so by all means check that one out for more detail this is obviously getting a lot of Buzz it's vital the servers I didn't see no toll and obviously anything made by that pairing is going to get a lot of hyper months Euro Gamers sadly this one just ended up being a bit of a disappointment for me I played it with people I like in the industry you know people that get on well with and we had a good fun time but the game itself is just a bit lackluster the theme of inventions doesn't come through really at all it's the same kind of mechanics we've seen before the is nothing really new or Innovative here even the whole idea of chaining bonuses and having you know extra actions and that doesn't tend to come into play as often as you would like at least compared to some other games where you get to do that kind of thing a bit more often shall we say I think games like the gallerist did it a little bit better but yeah it just it looks fairly Bland on the table I mean yeah it's got you know tools artwork but it's not particularly vibrant or colorful you've got really dry stale mechanics like you put the you get these little hexagons when you do the card actions and then with these hexagons you put them on your little grid and for the most part it makes no difference where they go unless you have another tile that says score points if you get free of this type in a line it's it's really arbitrary and dry like where's the theme gone from this
you had stuff like kanban and The galleriston Vineyards that really paid homage to the theme that they were talking about and now recently with things like weather machine which I admit yeah okay fine it has a theme quote-unquote but only if you're in that specific sort of Market but even then that's not really dripping with it but this one just feels bone dry and for a vitaliser getting to be bone dry it's somewhat off-putting but it's not just the lack of the theme you know the mechanics as well just felt kind of bare you know just nothing really there to grip me onto you asked me what is the USP of this game what is it about the gallerists That's Unique well it's about kanban that's unique ask me what inventions is unique for I cannot think of a single thing that it is it's just another assertive which will mean it's a fine enough game to play but it's I don't see why it would go on anybody's shelf over any other sort of titles I give a lot more detail in my podcast episode but yeah for me this one was kind of like a five or a six one after I applied it I found it average above average at best it's just not one that I think people should be getting that excited over You Know Nothing Jon Snow so why don't we just continue that hate train with another little card game that I finally got to play in the open gaming section this is not a brand new game this is one that's been out for a little while it's got cutesy nature pictures of trees on it and I've heard mixed opinions on it some people like it some people don't but I wanted to give this one a try and it is Arboretum it's a small card game where you have a deck of cards in the middle and you're drawing a hand of these trees and you're playing
them out in front of you in whatever pattern you sort of feel like but the idea is that you're trying to create paths between the same type of tree and it's got to go in ascending uh ascending number order and the longer you can make the path the more points you get but there's a bit of a take that thing in here where people can obviously take trees that you want or not drop trees out of the hand that you want but then at the end of the game there's this really weird confusing system where if you have trees like card trees in your hand with numbers higher than what somebody else has in their hand they don't score for that particular color of tree it's really weird and I just found that really punishing and horrible because you play the whole game going oh I've got these trees and I've got these past and look it's like I mean it is luck of the draw what you get so it's not like I can plan ahead for it I have to just hope I get what's right in my hand and hope that when I end the game I have something higher than one of three other players at the table but you get to the end and all this stuff that you've been doing just suddenly becomes scorched Earth while like nothing scores apart from one or two lucky people and then they win by that means it just it dragged on it I thought this game was meant to end like 20 minutes ago and it didn't it's not quick enough to be a filler it just kind of didn't feel that exciting it's got pretty pictures but then you get to the end and it just feels like everything you do is a waste of time I really didn't like this you know this you know inventions I could play again this one I don't want to play again I actively thought that this was a bad game and I did not like my play of it you know yeah I can see why it's got
a divisive opinion on it and I know it's got its fans but for me yeah not a fan not playing this one again prepare to die all right now let's flip it on its head and talk about games that are a bit better and this is probably going to shock a few people because there's two on my shelf at the moment that I could give some props to although it might annoy some of you in other respects so this one first which I've got partially because I'm doing a top 10 rolling rights game soon um top 10 list well I say rolling right flipping right X and right whatever something and right I am going to do that top 10 soon especially once I caught up with all these reviews I'm doing I will start doing some more top 10 list people I promise but Roland writes I wanted to try out more of and so most people I know didn't have these and I couldn't get them as review copies so I figured you know what you know the patreons want me to do this list so I decided to grab these out of my own pocket and I grabbed a few just to try them out this is Dinosaur Island raw and right and this one is basically the Roland right version for Dinosaur Island there was always a dinosaur world which was kind of a spin-off I've never played that one I've heard mixed opinions mostly bad so I haven't really tried that but this one is meant to be more akin to that one in turn compared to Dinosaur Island and the idea with this one is for the box it's a bit big for what it is I mean you know you've got your sheets here and then that's all that's in the Box this is somewhat over package size wise for what you get in here just to fit a
few pads but you still get the cool Amber dice I love these things I love cool funky Dice and these are just glorious one of the best components in Dinosaur Island and I get them in a rolling right but the idea with this is that you essentially have two sheets you've got one sheet which is your Park and there is like buildings that you can grab in the dnas and the types of dinosaurs you can get and the other one is your Park which runs in a kind of phase sequence so you start off with the attractions then the specialist then your excitement level and then the death toll as they call it the audio my security was a little lackluster never mind but the idea with this rolling right is I've only played it solo so I have not played this multiplayer although to be honest there's not a lot of difference between the solo and the multiplayer version frankly but the idea is is that you you roll the dice you draft them in order to get the resources on them and then you put them on these little action spaces to make DNA make dinosaurs and all the like and you then draw them on your Grid in order to in order to space them in your Park but you also want to connect them up with roads because you can give little tours for more excitement points but other than that it kind of plays very much like Dinosaur Island and world you get the dinos they up your excitement level which gets you more bonuses but then if you up the excitement too high that's probably because you're getting carnivores and T-rexes and stuff which needs which UPS the Fret but then you've got to deal with that by getting some security you have unique buildings you can build you have unique Specialists you can hire free adult out in the start of each game there's free Basics but then you always have three unique of
buildings and Specialists and it's great that they just change up the game in a Solo mode all that happens is that basically you flip over a couple of cards and the AI just Nicks certain Dice from the road that you've just rolled and puts them on certain spaces to block you but you can go on those spaces but you have to add to your fret every time you do it's pretty straightforward even though there is quite a lot of rules in this game there's a lot of things triggers a lot of things that key off other things and so it will take you a while on your first game to get used to this there's certainly a lot of rules in here for a rolling right but I enjoyed this this is a solid game one I would actually consider playing multiplayer maybe not with the Full Count of players but there is a reason to have other people blocking your spaces and obviously you know do you want to jump on other players but even then the game itself is just good fun to the point where oh my God dinosaur Horizons not sitting on that shelf anymore it's because it's downstairs and contemplating culling it welcome because I haven't played Dinosaur Island in ages it's a big game two boxes ton of stuff in it and I just haven't brought it out to the table because of all that bloating it but then on top of that there were one or two things that have irked me over the years one of which being that hooligan bag I still think that mechanic's dumb as much as I love the game that is a stupid mechanic the idea that you draw the guests out and if you get the purple ones they don't pay and plug up space but it's entirely random when that happens so that just seems like really weird to put in a two to three hour Euro game this one doesn't have that mechanic but the feel of it
getting the dinosaurs playing them in your Park getting attractions excitement level death toll and all that even the cool Amber dice all of that's in this game so why do I need Dinosaur Island it just feels like this completely does 90 of the same game and dinosaur Island's almost a bit redundant at this point I can get this to the table a lot quicker and get the island one out and so I'm really contemplating cutting it this could be a keeper in my collection yeah this one just it's one of the more meaty roll and rights but not stupidly meaty it's not going quite as far as something like Hadrian's Wall or or I suppose Twilight and description for that matter this one kind of seems a little bit like the bar below that but it's still got a decent amount in it and yeah it just it just replicates so much of The Originals that I don't see why you would want the originals over this other than just to have some plastic pieces and chunky metal coins I can live without that I'd rather have the cool gameplay factor and of course I can't exactly say no to the Amber dice so yeah I've enjoyed my plays of this one where will it rank on my top ten yeah I have to see but yeah spoiler alert it will be on there I don't think any of us expected him to say that on the same note haha explore and draw this is another one that I grabbed purely to test it out and see if it would go on that top 10.
exploring drawer is the Isle of cats version now one thing that I do roll my eyes with in these kickstarters is when the Publishers say oh yeah we're bringing out this expansion to the game that you've played oh by the way here's our roll and right version because we just want to milk this franchise for everything that is worth and we know that everybody likes rolling rights all of a sudden it does seem that way it's starting to get a little Annoying although roaring right kind of replaces the big games this one pretty much does that with spades on it I mean this one explore and draw both have got dumb titles I hate these play on words like exploring draw and Roar and write this rubbish but you know this one is basically Isle of cats 95 it really is with this one you essentially have the same premise you are trying to get cats onto your ship and they come in Tetris sizes you have lesson cards but you have a cool dry erase sheet to just tick them off when you grab them you have the pens of the different colors of cats you have the cards with the cats on them and you have the lesson cards that you can grab as well you even got the same solo mode that you had in the big version which was that you flipped over these cards to see how many points the AI got same thing in here and in fact I swear it's like 100 the same solo mode practically you know it and it's a great solo mode but with this you you have a couple of special abilities it can use but the main difference here other than Cosmetics is that in the normal game you were drafting I think you were drafting the cards but you also had a bit more of a turnang stuff oh don't take that tile
before I grab it here you don't have that the cards are laid out in a column grid and you have to decide which uh like I think which column you have to grab and you have to use all the cards in it but you have a couple of special ways to tweak that during the game so there's no turn angst because you're not blocking other players and doing anything so this one doesn't really have any multiplayer interaction at all and unlike raw and right where you actually can potentially block people getting their way way here you can't so there's not much incentive for me to play this multiplayer other than the fact that it is a relatively straightforward game but it's 95 Isle of cats other cats is also on the coal pile now well all the cats was a great game and I love those pieces and it looks cool but it's a Boxer app this big plus the other box for the boat expansion on top which I've sold I've sold the bolt expansion already but um I've still got kittens and beasts in there but you've still got this massive box with bags of folded spacings there and all these like all these pieces all these cards I gotta shuffle all these other things I've got a dish out it's a beast to set up no pun intended it takes a while to play especially if you're dumb enough to play this with five or six players Jesus I saw a friend of mine at handycon play Isle of cat six player they took longer to play that than I took to play three games of azul Splendor and something else I can't remember but basically I managed to play all of those games before they finished one game of our cat and they hadn't even finished by the time I was done it took forever and they thought it was hell it is don't play it with a lot of players but really the
only difference between these two games is the Cosmetics do you want the tiles do you want to pull those tiles out the back yay or nay because that's literally it everything else you do here trying to put the cats in a certain sequence covering up the rooms covering up the cats getting the lesson tiles getting families of cats the solo mode everything is identical so why on Earth would I want to keep the original one other than I want the big funky tiles because there's no other reason this is much smaller to store much easier to bring out and because I mainly play the solo anyway this is an easy solo game for me to do it's a solid rolling right and honestly it's pretty much killed its big brother so as much as I've harped on rolling rights recently these two have shocked me as to how much they are you know doing a good job of not only being half decent games in themselves but also just really killing off their big Brethren you know sometimes maybe maybe my tastes are changing who knows maybe I'm starting to appreciate this genre more uh not so much it was still quite hot it was still quite tough to come come up with a top ten now I've got the list pretty much ready but uh yeah there are a lot of rolling rights out there that I couldn't give a monkeys about so maybe not quite that Resurgence but maybe these two were just two that I found in the lull that just happened to be pretty solid for me so yeah explore and draw it's a sweet game this calls for a celebration next one on the list is beast beast I
have mentioned briefly on a podcast episode I won't go into too much detail but this is a Kickstarter fulfillment that is basically supposed to be hidden movement 1V all one person plays this beast that's hunting around humans and stuff and the other ones are the hunters trying to grab it so I went into this thinking all right there's going to be another like Fury or Dracula some White Chapel that kind of thing or even Sniper Elite it's anything but in fact to call this a hidden movement game is kind of a bit misleading because you don't really stay hidden for most of the game it's so easy for the hunters to find you and most of the time you're just blipping in and out of existence in a sense like oh you you found me I'm here here I have a one turn I'm hidden you don't know where oh you found me never mind it's like right I'm hitting I'm I'm free again I'm hidden oh I'm free again oh I'm hit it's like it's just constantly in and out so this isn't really a stealth game this is just more of a you know a card drafting game you draft the action cards that you all use and I like this mechanic this where you draft them along with the other like both teams are drafting with each other and they've got the abilities for both players and the Beast so you're drafting hoping to not give the players a good card if you're the beast but then they're also trying not to give the Beast really powerful cards as well that system is cool but this game has a lot of other problems firstly it's quite a bit to setup there's quite a lot going on secondly there's a micro economy in here where you gotta play red and blue cards if you want to play two in a turn but it's mostly luck of the draft as to whether you have the courage to be able to do that and it's also just one
complication that the game didn't need this game could use a bit of streamlining in places and this is is one Element I just think why bother why don't you just say you can play up to two cards because it's not always good to play two cards you might want to just play one but why have that unnecessary restriction on it just doesn't seem necessary on top of that though there's a economy for leveling up your upgrades and the players particularly if they don't get a lot of their upgrade points or whatever it is I forget what the currency is then some of the players there are sitting the entire game with no upgrades and they feel like useless characters and some characters are way more powerful than others I'm sorry the balance in this game is not good you've got a couple of characters that are great if they're going one-on-one with a beast doesn't tend to happen much but then you've got characters like the Seer The Seer especially when upgraded is downright broken this thing this character when upgraded pretty much guaranteed you will never be hidden again in the game because it's so easy for them to figure out where you are or at least boil it down to a 50 50 guess it's just not really well balanced in that regard it just the game just kind of clunked along the rule book's not very good the rule book is very hard to reference things and the teach was not great either I just kind of burnt on this one on a burn I just rebounded off it and I was playing the Beast I was playing the character that I should be enjoying more and I was getting into that theme the theme strong ish but yeah I maybe I need to play a couple more times I don't know but the game took a while it was not a short game and I just
found it to be plunky not streamlined and just have a few things I know are going to irk me but also irk other players I mean I wasn't the only one who didn't like it somebody else there didn't like it either because they just weren't getting any upgrades or anything cool to do they were just kind of running around with the rest of the pack and how's that fun that doesn't feel fun so this one kind of has the Hallmarks of a typical Kickstarter by a new publisher it's you know got a cool premise it's gonna appeal to a few people but it's got too many things that needed streamlining more time more took more time on the ironing board yeah more time to develop the game rather than just bringing it out so this one was a bit of a Miss for me I'm afraid jakaris and then finally I just want to talk on a positive note actually about Dune Imperium Dune Imperium is again I reviewed I was a couple of years ago I think and at first I gave it an 8 out of ten I said it was a great game and at the time it was but I still had some issues with it I this is one of the reviews that I think I was wronged about because I think I should have given it a seven because those irks that I had were certainly big irks and the as I played it more those kinks in the armor started creating more and more I didn't like the fact that the deck building element felt like it was the tact on bit compared to the worker placement because you don't really feel like you're building a deck you're adding cards to it but it doesn't Shuffle that often there's no easy way to trash cards in the base game apart from one action space which is not easy
to go to and it just didn't feel like you know that bit was annoying but then it looks horrible the Aesthetics are bland and boring much like the movie oh yeah no that's going to trigger some people but the yeah it just there were some problems I had with it despite enjoying the tight Victory Point thing you know the the fact that it was quite a tight game it was a race to 10 points there was a good amount of variety in the characters in the car and some of the cards although there was a lot of cards that were just absolute garbage and you couldn't refresh the display it was like there so I should have really given that a seven rather than eight by the time it came to the expansions being released I'd rated it about a six said it was above average not one that I would give a seal of endorsement to and I felt it was overrated Beyond no get out and I still think it's overrated like crazy it should not be in the top 10 of BGG no way I feel like it's just June fandom at this point but I have played it more recently I played it a couple of times this month because players had the expansions and I said I will give you one more chance dude I'll give you another chance to wow me back with the expansions both of them at the same time I thought I will try it and I've played it twice now with both expansions included and the game is an improvement it's an improvement to the point where I would give it a 7 out of 10. but the 7 out of 10 I think it's probably as high as I would go I tended by an eight but I think seven is still as high it still gets a seal of endorsement from me though but I still think it's overrated
but I do think the expansions are a benefit here because more so the second expansion the second expansion gives you this like arbitrary leveling thing on a science Grid or whatever you get further along on the track and then you get to move along a Scarab track whatever that means and it gets you points and stuff I mean it's arbitrary tracks who cares tracks are boring but what it does give you is another set of cards to play from so you've got these like I forget what they're called I just call them science cards but I think they call them like telesio cards or something but I can't even pronounce it right so screw it but but these are the cards are like another set of cards you can buy for your deck and they've got new abilities some of them are powerful some of them are crap but yeah just like the other ones but it's cool that you use the currency to buy them is like people that you put on that board and also I like the grafting mechanic where you play it you play like two cards at once and some of the graft abilities give you benefits if you craft it with certain things that mechanic I like and in the expansion I think that's cool they also I don't know if it was the first or second expansion it gives you a way to reshuffle the display of cards sadly only once each though which is a bit weird you should be able to do it more often than that because that display can still get clogged up with rubbish and if you've got rubbish cards there there's no incentive to buy them because you're just bulking up your deck but you know at least it's something but I did notice that there was more ways to trash cards with these new editions the cards that have been added over these expansions do introduce more ways to either draw cards or trash ones on your deck and that's a good thing I mean the
first one I played was with this Lord character who actually had an ability to trash cards out of his deck by playing his ring ability or whatever or something like that I forget his name a Duke something but he was really cool and I actually enjoyed that game more than any other Doom game because I felt like I was doing more with the deck building part of it worker placement is worker placement it's fine it's whatever it does what it says even though again this is another problem I have with the game the fact that the worker placement is dictated by the cards you draw the random luck factor for a game that takes over two hours to play is quite high in this like I want to go do these spots here but I can't because the cards I drew happened to say I can only go to the green and yellow well whoa is me you get all the stuff this game has a high luck Factor people you gotta admit that but you know with that said the first expansion dreadnoughts whatever it's another way to use money the combat is still you know quite a prevalent thing in the game although I'm pleased to report that with the expansions it's no longer the be-all or end order it used to be in the base game I actually have won the game doing no combat whatsoever like I might have joined in one combat not won it and then I just said you know what I'm a pacifist the whole game and not doing any of the combats and I still obliterated the other players because I found an engine allowed me to get me a ton of Solari money and I was using that on a card in my deck as well as other opportunities to buy victory points while also getting up with the alliances on the other factions this enabled me to win the game pretty convincingly while the others were duking it out in the combat zone and great it was about time
that you could actually win without doing combat in this game so with all that said and done the game has improved to me to be a seven not enough for me to make a game I'd want to own and let's face it why do I need to own it pretty much everybody I know has got the freaking game hell it gets played every single week at my Portsmouth club without fail you know I swear they're just as obsessed with that as they are with blood in the clock tower although if I was going to pick one to burn and one for them to keep keep doing Imperium because then at least I can play that and enjoy it burn clock burn blood in the clock tower please that is so annoying now but the the game itself I'm enjoying I you know I thought like yeah what you've done it you've you've put out two expansions which don't fix every problem I have with you doing Imperial but it is a significant Improvement enough for me to say you know what I can recommend this game just not for the top 10 of BGG okay yeah it's still overrated but I can say that I enjoy it and if people want to play it and it's one of the choices on the table I'll be like cool if everybody knows what they're doing this game drags on way too long if you have a new player or anybody who's not quick at their turns we had that on the other session where I enjoyed the game but man the one slow player we had was grating me you know literally pretty much had to hand hold them the entire game and it's like seriously why did you jump into this game if this is if you're like takinokos the best thing you can handle it's like ah it really was dragging on to the point where I swear the game took an extra hour over what it should have done because of it get on with it yeah
so that's it for me on this episode of the broken people if you like what you see then please thumb it up on YouTube and let me know in the comments what you think about these games good bad comments things you disagree with thing you agree with let's be civil and talk about these in more detail of course don't forget to check out more content on the channel including all the smorgasborder reviews I've been doing since the board game Expo I'd love to get some more views for those so please check them out thumb them up check them out on Board Game Geek thumb up there as well I appreciate all the attention and engagement until next time remember regardless of whether you consider it to be overrated or not it's still only a game bye for now
foreign