Board Games I Got Rid Of (And Why) - Episode 27
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another episode of games I got rid of and why so in this series I take a look at a bunch of games that I used to have in my collection but for one reason or another no longer do and I tried to give an explanation as to why I came to the decision to part with them now before I get started on the 10 games here I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who I might go to online retailer when it comes to purchasing board games here and if used the link in the show notes all the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order okay so the first game I'm talking about here just so happens to be my favorite out of all of these and again I still rate very highly now this is fruticola now fruticula is a game that got next to no Fanfare despite having a successful Kickstarter campaign and being designed by Virginia Julie who is an amazing designer he's made some you know hugely popular and successful games but particular is a game that I think was number one a huge victim of its production so this game um had some of the worst and shoddiest quality of production I've ever seen you know the pieces would fall apart in your hands as you were playing them and assembling them um but the gameplay itself was actually very interesting and had multiple layers to it as well when it's essentially a worker placement game with a degree of commodity speculation and you're collecting these different fruits and converting them into jams and selling
the jams for profit essentially um but the was quite interesting because every round you'd play a card and this card would give you an ability for the rest of the round as well as determining the workers you have and they'd also have an initiative value on them as well so you could kind of have fewer workers but go quicker have more workers but go slower you'd even have different worker types which would have different strengths and weaknesses and you had to play them in order which added another layer of decisions into the mix there and this is one of those games that you could kind of build a bit of an engine up by collecting these towels and all of the tiles were very interesting there could be game breaking abilities and they all felt very powerful and really not subdued and I tend to like games that do that you might ask if I have so many good things to say about it why did I choose to remove it from my collection um and that's actually a difficult question to answer but I think the main reason was at the time I had this in my collection I think I acquired two new work placement games which I like even more than this one so I actually ended up buying kaylus and Russian railroads at around the same time which just by default pushed this one down the priority list and I just knew I wasn't going to get it played anytime soon so um yeah I did have to get rid of this one with quite a heavy heart um and I definitely feel like I'm in the minority here in terms of how I felt about it because it's not a terribly well rated game and obviously it wasn't popular but I still rate them probably like seven and a half or an eight out of ten and it was one of my favorite games of the year so it's just simply one of those matters of being a crowded genre
within my collection and I kind of like I kind of like a a mix of games I don't want a bunch of similar worker placement games so yeah maybe one day I would look at playing this one again um but I actually think the gameplay is great and if you can find a copy out there in the wild and you're probably going for pretty cheap and it is worth your time so a positive spin on why I got rid of a game there um simply because I have more games of the same type in my collection so that's particular the second game here is another one that I still speak highly of this is Kokopelli by Stefan Feld so Kokopelli is definitely unlike any other Stephen file game and it is purely card driven and what you're doing is you're playing these cards out in front of you which will give you game breaking abilities but if you play a number of the same type of card you can convert those abilities into points essentially now I love the variability here and the way the decks synergize with each other and my few issues with it that I thought the game was a little bit too long at times and much like reticular it had a lot of competition when it comes to card games in my collection um if I like these kind of variable clever card games I'll probably lean towards something like Capital Lux over this one um and this might sound silly but one of the big reasons I got rid of this one is because it came in a huge box or a big box when it really is just a card game so I would have loved to have seen like this one being kept dance down into a box half size I might even still have it in my collection then because space is of a premium to me and hence why there are so many good games on this list or this particular video because I
obviously had a a high amount of games in my collection at the time therefore I was even cutting good games from my collection so I think these first two were a victim of crowding essentially and whereas if um I had Infinite Space I'd probably still both be in my collection but that's why I got rid of Kokopelli um it fell down that priority list a little bit too long and um just other games I'd rather play instead of it but no ill reflection of the game is still very good and um you know quite a quirky design next up I have Gutenberg so Gutenberg was a game that I was very excited for at the time you know you don't really see this these many euros that look like this now and it had that more kind of throwback beige look to it and it gave it all about printing which I thought was quite cool it had a cool theme now this one you were essentially trying to collect these letters and fulfill these contracts it was all pretty basic in the way it worked and it didn't really do anything terribly new or Innovative but the one thing I did like about it more than anything was the initiative system where before you even took your actions you would program the kind of priority that you want by placing these different blocks and these little black cubes on your little board here and if you investors say in one particular phase of the game that means you go really early but that means you're probably going later in the other terms or the other the other phases and vice versa you can spread them out how you like it maybe you want to do okay and all other categories or really well in one category and so on so that was actually the one thing I really liked about this game but the rest of it was pretty bad pretty generic I really
wanted to like it as well because again I love the look of it I love the feel of it um and some of the production was really cool as well but this one I'm quite surprised well if you were to ask me when it came out I thought it might have some legs um but after I played it I thought this feels pretty generic and it's going to Fade Into Obscurity and sadly it has you know it's only been like a year or so this since this one came out um and nobody talks about it anymore and I think that's probably a quite an accurate reflection as to what this game is all about because it is quite generic so that is Gutenberg another game that came and went from a pretty successful publisher uh this is zapotec so zapotec was kind of advertised as a sister game to the T-Series by uh board and dice but this of course isn't a tea game because it begins with the Zed but this was by Fabio lupiano who I think is a great designer or definitely an interesting designer has made some games I really do enjoy um and I was intrigued about this one as you are managing this hand of cards or you're drafting these cards you up um using them to put presents down on the map and build these temples and go for these objectives and things but it had this cool twist where I think the last car that wasn't drafted would be the scoring category for the round um and you were just simply scoring based on a number of different things such as the temperature one or the type of terrain you're on um I don't remember a lot of the intricacies about it I have reviewed it in detail so be sure to check out that one out if you are interested if you want more information as to why I decided to why I didn't rate it too highly um ultimately I thought this was one of
those games where once you've played it you'd seen everything pretty quickly and it didn't have that hook to draw you back into it anymore it was almost like um yeah the longevity was next to nothing on this game and which is a shame really because I think a lot of the other board and dice games um had a huge incentive to go back to them because there was so much variability and things to try this one really did miss the mark in that aspect of things um yeah I definitely thought that was the case but it was fine you know I rate it about six out of ten definitely not a negative thoughts on it but it didn't quite cut the mustard in them you know it's such a competitive field in terms of Euro games I suppose the one the one redeeming feature about this one was that it did only take around 60 Minutes to play and which was great um but I actually had a quite a cool Resource Management thing as well um which did lead you down a bit of a path to keep spamming the same things but again check out my review if you want more details on it but um ultimately it wasn't a keeper didn't quite make the mark next up I have Knights of the Ninja this is a social deduction game with a degree of drafting if I remember correctly um and if you are going through this motion by going through all these cards in a particular order assassinating the different players and trying to be the last one standing I believe I've been getting points accordingly uh that's pretty much the gist of the game I only played this one a few times I think maybe I'm somewhat done with social deduction games I don't really feel the spark to play them that much more and they're Never As Good As the resistance in my opinion and this one was not as good as the resistance so it feels like it's kind of punching upwards it's not
really going to leave a mark on the Hobby and it feels like everything here has been done before I think it's quite well regarded and um you know some people do think highly of it but for me it's just not as good as some of the other ones already out there next up I have Trails of tucana which is a flip and right Style game as you are building these roots on this kind of hex grid now and you're trying to connect these different symbols together to start generating new points and connecting different camps to different camps to get even more points um it actually is quite restrictive in what you could do now there wasn't that much wiggle room to make too many mistakes and you have to be quite efficient you could play in two different game lengths but you could play a very fast game or you could play a bigger map and I actually think that the game didn't benefit at all from playing the larger map and it was always a much more fun experience and a faster experience of course if you were to play this the shorter map or the smaller map um and I like this one you know this is one of those games that's completely defensive it's a solid six six and a half out of ten and one that's not going to take up too much space on your shelf it has some reasonably interesting decisions but I would have appreciated more variability there's only those two maps they felt the same there was no kind of twists on the on the structure of the game and different things to make it a bit more interesting now I understand that since uh the base games come out there have been expansions which could potentially tweak the rules somewhat and make it you know add some interest to the game um but I think I've kind of done this when I played it quite a few times I'm enjoyed my time with it it's a solid
rolling right or a flipping right I'm in a saturated category but um but yeah ultimately it didn't quite earn it spot on my shelf for the long term I've despite me enjoying it short term so that is Trails of tucana next up I have Pagan at the fates of Roanoke now this is I believe it was a two-player only game where one player is like a Van Helsing vampire Hunter kind of character and the other one is more like a witch trying to complete this kind of ceremony or Seance whatever it is they're trying to do um and what you're trying to do as the Vampire Hunter is that you were trying to deduce who the witch could be by playing all these different I think it was cars and abilities oh I didn't play this game too much so forgive me if my memory is a little bit hazy the ultimate you were trying to wish things down in order to take a shot at the right character and and kill them essentially at the same time the other player was trying to build up the strength of all their their witch whatever it was in order to complete this um ceremony now the game had an amazing look to it it had this real kind of Haunting cartoony art which looked great um and the cars look fantastic but I always tend to find games like this where you have a good chance of taking a pop shot taking a shot in the dark um and just trying to attack a character and having a good chance of winning just on pure luck I find that those games tend to be a little bit anticlimactic for me and in the game or games I played of this one that was the case you know I didn't
really have great information and I was the vampire hunter character and I shot one character and killed them and won the game without really thinking too hard about it and I understand the odds aren't great for doing that but when it's possible um I don't know it just doesn't quite sit right for me and it feels like I don't know what we're doing is just going through the motions where I think you know what let's just let's just take a shot here let's go for it and potentially win instantly and that's what happened so maybe I was left with a um a skewed view or a you know a bad view of the game because of that um that left a dampened impression on me but it's not my style of game really and um there's just a bit too much going on there's tons of expansions and stuff that became a bit um you know it's a bit cumbersome to feel your way through it all but ultimately I think this has got his audience I know some people like it um but it wasn't one for me the next game I'm talking about is one called mouse cheese cat cucumber I might be getting that wrong but it was something like that now this was a kind of an asymmetric game where each player has one of those different roles and they all have a different winning condition now um I think I only played this one once so I was I think I was the um the mouse character I was trying to go through all these little holes and get to the cheese um these kind of modular map is always shifting and changing to block people off I'm very chaotic very confusing at times I thought the rules didn't quite sit right with me um it was a little bit unintuitive or counter-intuitive at times and just a bit of a mess of the game did not like this one at all and hence why I probably
don't don't remember too much about it and try to uh you know forget about it really so I had a very small box you know literally took up next no space in on your shelving but the gameplay still wasn't worth it I just did not like I did not get on with it at one bit so that is mouse cheese cat cucumber next up I have Fiesta Mexicana now this is a kind of a set collection and bidding game however all your bids are fixed on this huge ball that each player has and it actually had quite a cool idea and some interesting Concepts here that I hadn't seen before but what you're essentially trying to do is you were collecting these food items and trying to build patterns on your board you know when you want a certain bed you would put them on these cards on this bed to contribute towards that pattern but whatever you would bid you or successfully win the bid you would just shift your board around which would be a new range or a new lot of bits that you could you could play with and I did quite like the way that works you didn't want to use all your bids early because all your best bits early because you don't beat up with the worst ones and so on and I did like that idea of you can't bid what you want you can only bid what's available to you so I think that's actually a mechanism that could be explored further there's tons of potential to be looked at there but I don't think this was the game to utilize that mechanism because the rest of it was fairly paid by numbers it was a bit restrictive at times where you wouldn't really want any of the things up for auction um and yeah it was pretty pedestrian in the way that it scored but that one bidding mechanism was super cool and I'd
love to see that taken further and developed but this was not the game for it and the final game I'm talking about today is God's love dinosaurs now what a cool idea this game is and I cannot think of any direct comparison in terms of a game it's like this is a game where you are very delicately balancing this ecosystem I suppose as you have a bunch of Critters who will eat certain types of terrain then you'll have these kind of hunters who will eat the critters and then you're creating these dinosaurs who will eat the Predators uh and again they all have that need and every now and then they'll need to eat otherwise they're going to die and not only will you have to balance the kind of quantities of these different animals to keep it as even as possible so everything has something to eat you'll also need to manage the spatial puzzle because the all the hunters and the dinosaurs can only move so many spaces before they die and they need to find their prey within that time so again you do need to make sure you're keeping all those levels just right in order to keep everything satisfied and then what you're doing is you're getting points for every time I believe the dinosaurs eat the Predators but again you've got to have these printers on the board otherwise the dinosaurs are going to die so I did like the way the game worked and I love the concept and to be honest I think I think I found the game more interesting from a kind of an experimental and concept perspective rather than the game itself because you know it's definitely a Fresh Approach again there's nothing else quite like it um it's quite interesting the way it scales up and get bouncing all these
different things but did I find it particularly fun or particularly taxing I'm not quite sure I did so I actually really wanted to like this game it had a good table presence you know all the meeples look great and I definitely think there's some people who would really get a lot from this one um but for me it's not one that I found terribly fun despite finding it interesting and of course I want my games to be fun and um yeah I think it was we're somewhat related reluctant to get to remove this one from the collection but now that it has gone I must admit I don't really regret it at all I don't have a niche to go back to it because I've seen what it does and no despite looking back at it with some fond memories and thinking it's a cool concept it's ultimately not a game that I'm looking to play anymore hence why it had to go so that is God's love dinosaurs so there you have it that's another 10 games that have left my collection um some really good ones here and some pretty bad ones as well but hopefully you've uh enjoyed the video if you have please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye