Are These Board Games Still Worth Keeping? | Finspan, Flamecraft & More
Transcript
Hi, I'm Sarah.
And I'm Drew.
And we're back for another edition of Collection Curation. And we are on our seventh shelf this time. Today we have six games that we played. And we actually played a lot of these as a family.
Yeah, almost all of them.
And this this is a tough shelf. Like,
yeah,
not tough to play, but tough to think about getting rid of any because there were some real family favorites on this shelf.
Yeah, this this definitely is a shelf that contains a lot of ones that we really enjoy. There's just no way around it.
Yep. So, we're just going to get right into it. And as always, we're going to start with the games that we played as a full family. So, us and our two kids.
Okay. So, first up, we've got Flamecraft. And Flamecraft is a very cute little worker placement type. You're also gathering and managing your resources and fulfilling some orders. So, there's kind of a few different mechanisms going on. I think the biggest detraction from Flamecraft is that it's light. It's a pretty light game. But for us, we have a 10 and a 12year-old, and so that works really well. It's a pretty good family weight.
Yeah. And they they like the art and and the puns are cute and um you know, we've kind of
blinged it out a little bit and some stuff like that. So, it's kind of fun to to get out and play and like you said, order fulfillment and stuff like that, which we don't have tons of.
We don't. And it's Yeah, like we said, it's cute. The the deluxe components that we have upgrade the game for us a little bit, too.
And um for me, it's like almost unfortunate that the kids like to play this one because I think it plays really really well at two and it's just a lot snappier and you're doing this back and forth with your turns whereas at more players it kind of slows the game down a little bit and
Yeah. and that order fulfillment, somebody there's a better chance of somebody grabbing one of those orders before you. I know
we had that issue happen a few times. So,
but overall, I think this is one that the whole family really likes.
So, are we ready?
Yep.
One, two, three. Keep. This is definitely a keep game for us.
And and as kids age out and stuff like that, we it might leave eventually.
I don't know. I really like FL. So, I love the art. I love the Deluxe Components. I like that it's an easy game to table for us. We know the rules. We know how to set it up really quick. Um, and so it doesn't take a lot out of us at this point for this game.
Yeah. Yep.
So, it is sticking around.
Okay. Our next one is I'm just going to bundle them together here. Canvas with reflections. So, canvas is definitely one of those uh interesting, fun light games. It's got a big pole with, you know, what it does. And you're just have these acrylic clear cards with a little printing on them. You're trying to get certain arrangements made with the ribbons to score points.
Um,
yeah, each game has different uh different things that you need to achieve to score points. So, each each game the different ribbons are going to have different uh requirements that you need to fulfill in order to gain them and then to score at the end of the game.
Yeah, this was one that I think Road to Infamy. This is one of their big big kind of put them on the market a little bit bigger. Um I would say if you ever get canvas, really think about the reflections because being able to flip those cards and get both sides, it's so much better. It's so much fun.
It adds a little depth because you do have that choice of which side are you going to to use and which works better for your scoring. And I think um I I love the acrylic cards and I wish that that was something that more games use just because I think it's so cool and you can have so many different really cool combinations.
Yeah.
Um but I think our problem sometimes with canvas is that we either want to play for the creativity and making really cool paintings or you want to play to score points. And for this one, I think the whole family kind of just ends up really wanting to make really cool
Yeah.
cool paintings. And so we don't always really care about the scoring as much.
Yeah. And you know, sometimes that's okay. We we do it sometimes with Dixit or some stuff like this.
But to have a game game that is much more um essentially solo type. When you sit down and you're assembling, you're not interacting a whole lot with others.
That maybe isn't quite as as good. But
yeah, the interaction in this one just comes from the drafting where people are going to draft ahead of you. So maybe you're creating some juicy opportunities for somebody because you're placing these artistry tokens down. And so maybe they're going to really want that and take that card that maybe wasn't as
good for you. And so there is a little interaction in that, but it's definitely not a direct interaction.
The good thing is 30 minutes.
Yeah. Super fast play. But
are you ready?
Yep.
Okay. Three, two, one,
yeah,
I think that canvas is just a little too light for us at this point. Um, the kids after we were done playing, they played with the pieces for a long time, but as a game, I think we've just outgrown it.
Yeah, I think so. And it's, like I said, honestly, if you were just getting into gaming, if you played a couple, this would be super cool, especially if you got kids that are, you know, anywhere from six years old or up, you know. Um, it's just
we've moved on.
We've moved on. sad to see it go because it does have some really cool components and those acrylic cards are really really interesting. But again, it's just we've moved a little bit past it and it is on board game arena. If we ever get the the itch to play it again, we can play it there. So,
yep.
Canvas is moving on.
Um, next up is Millie Fury. And we played this one with our daughter. She's the 12-year-old in the in the family. And um Millie Fury is a game that sits on our shelf a lot because we love it. Yeah,
but it's not good at two.
I've heard that the expansion helps that out just a little bit, but at two players, your scoring opportunities are so much more limited because you're not placing as many tiles out on the board. So, in Millie Fury, you have a hand of cards. You're going to choose secretly choose one of those cards and then you take your turns around and you'll place your tile in that section of the board. And some of them are like um you want a bigger area to score bigger. Some of them you want to get on a higher level of this tower to score. Some you want to sell more goods to score.
Yeah. Some you're moving along a track.
Very point salad.
Yeah. Yeah.
And very high scoring. It's a very high scoring game which kind of feels good.
Yeah. And the interesting thing is there is some because everybody's playing on the same, you know, areas and stuff. There is some of that interaction of, okay, if somebody else can place here, I can do this.
But you can't plan too far ahead because you're passing your deck of cards around that allow you to play.
Yeah. So, it's one of those drafting games where you're going to pass your hand at the end of your turn and you might choose a card, have this perfect plan, and then the player before you is going to put that put that token down and then you're like, "Oh, well, I guess it's not as good of a turn." But there are some really amazing combo turns that you get where you place your tile and you score pretty well and then you gain the bonus for having one of every kind in that section and then you score a bonus because you get to play another card. There are some huge turns.
Yeah, there was one I think I was down by 30 points to you two and within two turns I was right there.
Yeah, it's very swing. Keep that in mind too.
Um and so I think the challenge for us is if we will have the kids play with us in the future because our gaming group is pretty much just us at this point. So, us and the kids,
occasionally we make it to a con, but um that's who plays games with us at our house. And so, if we if the kids don't like the game, then we probably would get rid of it because it does not play well at two, like you said. But, are you ready?
Yep.
Three, two, one,
keep.
Our daughter really enjoyed this, too. She actually blew us both water. She like
first play and she just she did really well.
So, um I think she will definitely be willing to play this with us. And those tiles are really fun. The they're clear but colored and so they look really
it really and it it's got a good presence. Yeah,
it does. So this one's sticking around.
Okay, next that we played as a family together was Finsspan. So in the Wingspan universe basically a little bit different, a little bit maybe half a step back.
Yeah, it's a little more open as far as placement and stuff like that.
Um but it's super fun. Um really you're just uh grabbing those cards, getting you know any of the bonuses off them. You're diving down to activate those cards. Um you are, you know, all these types of things and trying to get eggs and hatchlings and schools and so yeah, I don't know. It's
Yeah, it's it is um you can tell that the bone the bones of the span game is in there, but it is quite a bit different as far as wingspan. So instead of going across your board, you're going to dive down. But you don't have to have cards in every spot. Like you have a little more flexibility where you place your cards. And some fish need to be higher on your board and some need to be lower on your board as far as where they live.
And they're multi-purpose cards. You use them and you keep your own discard. You can sometimes get those back. And yeah, there's I don't know, just a lot going on.
There's kind of a lot going on. But not so much that it's not a family game. Has played this with us several times. He he does just fine on that.
And so um are we ready then?
Oh yeah.
Okay. Three, two, one. Keep
keep
I think this has become our favorite of the spans. I know it's your favorite.
It's my favorite. Yeah.
I'm a little torn between this and wings span personally. Um but the art is really fun. The fish are cool to look at.
Yeah.
It was just one of those plays this last time where I was like somebody was getting all these shark cards. So they were had a shark I was getting all these rays like these manta rays. I was like, "Oh, I'm going to keep that because it's array and I've got all of them." Like, there was no reason to do that, but it's just fun.
Oh, yeah.
Pensan is sticking around.
Okay, next up we've got Explorers of Nooria. And this one we just played The Two of Us,
right?
Um, and we did play with the expansion. We have the Forgotten Lands expansion, which adds a section of the board and another deck of cards, right,
that you can draft and some another set of actions that you can take. So, what I think is really interesting with Explorers of Novoria is it's kind of this two-phase game play where in the beginning, you're drawing tokens out of the bag. You decide between one of those two um types of cards that you want to draft
and then you're going to draft that card to your tableau.
Right. Then in the second phase, any of those um tokens that got used, you're going to use those as workers to place in this town square area that are going to let you take more actions and get more resources. Then you're going to get some income, which is basically just scoring points. You also have a player board that is going to activate different actions for you. The more of your outposts you can get put out on these tracks that you're exploring. And what else am I missing? That's kind of where you keep your resources. You have to be a little bit careful about managing your resources so that you can activate the the areas that you want to.
Yeah. And um another one of those really interesting art. Um really bright.
Um I did think that that expansion does add just that extra little bit just to
bump that game up. Yeah.
Yep.
Yep. I have played it solo once. Um and it's tough. I don't think I won that time that I played. I might have played a couple times now actually. Um, and this one is just so eye-catching. I will say the last since we played it, I've used some pictures from the game and a couple things on Instagram, and I always have people ask like, "What game is that in the background?"
And so, it definitely definitely catches your eye when you have it out on the table. So, are we ready?
Sure.
Okay. Three, two, one, keep.
I think Drew is a little more on the fence on this one.
I I like it just fine. I I don't have any there's it's definitely not one that I am going to like turn away from.
If I'm like, "Oh, I really want to play Explorers of Navore." You're not like, "Okay, fine."
Right. Right.
Like some of the games that we've had on the series and that fast. But
um I do I really love this game. I love the art. I love the mechanisms. I think it's really unique and it got panned a little bit when it first came out because people said it was too light, but I really don't think it's that light.
Yeah. I I'm not sure if you're And again, if you're one of those that I won't play anything above or less than a 3.0, you know, whatever,
but that's not what this game is. It's a solid um I would say midweight game.
Yeah, for us for sure. So, um Explorers of Neora is
All right, last one for this shelf was Atlantis Rising. So, we played with our daughter on this one. This is a 100% co-op game. Uh, you've got different roles and basically you are trying to assemble all the artifacts you can uh to get them all complete so you can open the portal and get off Atlantis before it sinks into the sea.
Yeah.
So, I think in the past we've always played this on the easiest level and I did bump us up to the second level this time and you could tell it was a little bit tougher.
Yeah, it got Yeah, it got a little more. The the toughest part of this game is you place your workers before the island starts to sink. And so you are trying to balance this risk of if I go out too far on the island and that section sinks, then I don't get that action this turn. And that can really hurt.
But if it doesn't sink, the farther out you go, the better the, you know, rewards are for taking the risk.
To to gain those rewards, you usually have to roll a dieice. And that's another thing that can be kind of tough. I think I had two turns in a row where I got no resources because I just wasn't rolling my dice very well. Y
and um
so the higher the closer to the middle you go with your worker, the higher usually you have to roll to be able to get that resource. And then you're going to use those resources to assemble the artifacts. The artifacts usually either have a onetime bonus on them that is right away when you build it or it has some worker placements or worker placement spots. Yeah. Some good bonus type. Yep.
And you're gaining more workers as you go. And so it does feel like even though it's tough.
Yeah.
As that island starts to sink and that ramps up pretty fast, too, but you also can do a little bit more on your turns as you go along just because you do have those more you have more workers every turn.
Yeah. Yeah. It never feels like you're out of it or can't can't do anything. I mean, sometimes the roles don't go your way,
but outside of that, Yeah. I don't ever feel like it's horribly tough or anything, which is good for families.
It's a good production. The tiles are really nice. The components, like the resources are
um really nice also. So, I'm trying to think. They're resin. I think most of them are. So,
um are we ready?
I think so.
Okay. Three, two, one, keep.
This definitely I feel like still offers us a challenge when we want a little more challenging of a co-op. Um, and I'm excited maybe next time to even ramp it up a little bit further.
Yeah, I think we definitely could. Um, it's it's just it's an interesting game and I think it's kind of fun to play.
One thing to keep in mind if you mostly play with two, it does have a little bit of a two-player variant where you play with a third kind of dummy player, but you kind of pass it. Well, no. I think you go through the tiles like you draw two
and you get to choose which one you're going to use as far as the the abilities. So like you have your main person and then every other turn you're going to draw an extra one and use that just on that turn. And so it gets a little funky when you just play at two. Just as a side note to keep in mind.
Yeah. I would say three or four is probably a pretty good
I wouldn't play more than that because I think you're going to start sinking your island pretty quickly.
I know.
So um but Atlanta's Rising is sticking around. So, that was our seventh shelf for collection curation, and that was a really good shelf.
Yeah, it was
like some absolute of our family favorites were on that shelf. So, I don't feel too bad that we only called one out of those six, which is only about a 17%
call rate on that one.
But, um, I do have to remind myself this whole project isn't about making myself coal games. It's about making sure we love every game that we have. and that shelf. We loved Yeah. All of those games.
That's just it. So, agreed.
I don't want to force myself to get rid of a game I love just to meet some sort of arbitrary metric. So, overall, we have called 14 of the 51 games that we've played. And that puts us at about 27%. So, we've dropped a little bit.
Yeah.
Over the past,
you know, honestly, again, this one
our last shelf was a lot of family favorites as well.
Yeah. And and I, as I look, you know, they're going to go up and down like that. That's just how it works.
It is. Um, and so we are excited to keep going and hopefully you'll stick around and see what Shelf 8 brings for us. Thanks for watching. If you want to find more of our day-to-day um, gaming adventures, you can find us on Instagram at Sarah Always Loses. Until next time, we'll see you at the table.