Skip to main content
Loading video...

2022 People's Choice Top 200 Solo Games | My Votes (5-1) Part 4

Transcript 34:59

foreign welcome back I'm Robert and today we're gonna pick up where we left off with 2022's People's Choice top 200 solo games today we've reached the finale where I'm gonna discuss my numbers 5 through number one let's get started all right so setting on number five we have the Lord of the Rings the card game this was the first lcg that I bought for Solitaire play in fact one of the first few games that I bought initially when I started the hobby within the first 20 games I believe that I bought and I bought it in 2020 which means that this was at the end of its uh live time as far as new product new products go they haven't released a new content for it uh pretty much since they have repackaged the Cycles though so even though this product has been around for a while this game has been around for a while uh there are some things in it that do show its age compared to newer lcgs this definitely taught the designers a lot and they have um this was like the template for the lcgs that we know uh the other two the Arkham and Marvel and it it shows how they have learned from this all right there even though it might show its age just a bit it's just an incredible solo game regardless and you don't need to

own everything I don't own everything although I have heard repeatedly from people that that own everything for this game that it just unlocks the the threshold once you reach a certain collection what did what it unlocks as far as the deck building possibilities and the replayability is pretty much infinite from what I've from what people say now um I don't think that I'm gonna be buying all the content for this game anytime soon because it's just gonna go on played I have the first uh three cycles and I've only played um the first one and I've only started the second one to be honest with you just because I've tried other I've been trying other games maybe one day when I settle and I know what I I figured out what I like and what I want to what I want to keep and I call my collection I'll focus more on this uh but I've played that first cycle a whole lot uh and I've just had a lot of fun and it's a best it's a better time than ever to get into this game because the packaging that they did for the core set it eliminates the need of buying multiple core sets which was a bit annoying not gonna lie and I had to do that at the time because I wanted my full copies of all the cards but um still uh you know with that with that repackaging and also I have to mention those uh pre-constructed Decks that they came out just beautiful products I just super enjoy that and I'll repeat this uh if you've heard my um my Star Wars

Destiny uh review from this list uh I don't enjoy the deck building aspects from these solo lcgs as much uh it's it's okay but it just doesn't scratch the same Edge that it it uh it does when I played magic and I know that a lot of people look for this these lcgs to scratch that magic Edge and as far as those Lord of the Rings by far is the best one if you want to have a pseudo Magic the Gathering solo game at home this is it uh however just maybe if I reach a certain point later with the expansions I'll feel like it it really scratches that edge but so far it just feels a bit tedious to be honest um uh and you know I'll do it because of the necessity like I have to construct my deck and figure out the puzzle it's just part of the game right uh and I still super love and enjoy the game but it's my least favorite part I'm just gonna be honest um but the pre-constructor decks fix that they feel uh op all right it feels like a power trip especially if you go against those earlier Cycles one thing that can fix that you can get the nightmare decks for those first couple Cycles where the designers had learned a bunch uh since and they'd um it just freshens those first cycles and it allows you to um play those OP decks against uh the first uh cycle right so I I've done that

and it's a lot of fun just if you happen to have access to those nightmare decks for the um the initial cycle try that with the precon Dex it's a nice environment there what that doesn't require that much like building and it's just fun also one thing that you need to keep in mind with this game is that it it doesn't play solo one just controlling one deck as well all right um You can but there are certain scenarios that are gonna feel a bit impossible and you're not the deck building is really restrained because you're gonna have to create a deck that does a bit of everything and I actually enjoy it more when I play two separate decks so that is one weakness that this has uh and you can play it one-handed okay like I said people strictly stick to that but I really feel that the deck construction aspect suffers I really like uh controlling two decks so that each can focus on different things so if you haven't and initially when I first played this game I just opposed to the idea of controlling two decks but once I did it really opened up a lot of possibilities for for me and it just basically doubled it essentially doubled the rep the replayability aspect of this of this game because that construction for uh pure solo is a different puzzle

versus when you control two decks all right so I would what I would do is each scenario I build you know I I have a goal of bidding it with a solo deck if possible there are certain scenarios that feel pretty um they feel pretty uh hopeless with just one deck but that's my goal that I uh check so bidding it with one deck and then also building a um a two a playing two-handed and betting it two-handed all right uh and I just found out that a lot a lot of fun I'm really glad I tried it and I recommend you do two if you haven't um and as as some people have pointed out this was the template for the other um lcg's Arkham Horror and um Marvel Champions and this definitely shows a bit of age but it really catapulted and uh helped the future designs be better so you really have to appreciate this it does show its age just a bit like I said but it's just an incredible game and it could be a lifestyle game like if you wanted to give one or two like a handful of games in your library and a big collection of this could be it as I also mentioned with Arkham Horror lcg so don't sleep on this uh I know that people that don't have a magic the Gathering or Trading Card Game background might be intimidated by the deck building and the

construction aspect and I really can't understand that like if I if I didn't have a deck construction aspect from Magic just wrapping my head around to hold that construction thing could be difficult but thank uh thankfully there's websites where you can just find deck lists all right and you can just go from there and in the in the prep in the new repackaged corset it even includes Decks that it recommends you build so uh just a great time to get started with this game if you haven't already I highly recommend it just stay fantastic uh card game and uh one thing I didn't mention also that I find it positive is that it's a a medieval fantasy theme which was one thing that I loved about magic Back In The Day Magic is a bit all over the place as far as theme these days as far as its identity uh back then it was you know it had a lot of medieval and DND tropes and uh this has this maintains that Spirit uh so it it's really it and if you're a Lord of the Rings fan to boot that is just the cherry on top okay uh so again just amazing solo card game if you want to scratch that edge and if you don't if you don't care for the construction aspect it's just fun to play period like the gameplay is just really amazing uh because I haven't really mentioned that already like the gameplay is just fun uh

and I think this is just a is is gonna stay stay in uh people's top list for years and years to come I think this is just a classic it's gonna is gonna remain a classic solo board game for years to come uh don't miss out on it moving on to number four we have Marvel Champions the card game so as someone else as far as solo lcgs go uh this trumps uh the Lord of the Rings on a couple aspects number one is uh the fact that it plays pure solo a lot better all right uh and number two the modularity is it Beggars belief how modular this game is and the mix and matching and the different possibilities it's just as you acquire More Heroes it's just endless now I prefer the theme of Lord of the Rings more I like superheroes alright I'm not like a Marvel movie not or anything like that I enjoy it okay some people are completely apathetic to the theme at least I'm glad I enjoy it to some extent um and I you know I love Spider-Man who doesn't so and the hero so there are certain Heroes that I really like that I'm happy that I can play as but the theme isn't why I play this game it's just it's just an amazing the card placing as is incredible and it essentially it kind of amounts to a uh it's kind of an engine builder in a way all right

uh and the it's super thematic by the way uh uh the uh and I don't care as much for things being thematic in more games so I do applaud it when they are but uh the whole aspect of switching between your alter ego and your hero uh part um and the how the cards are written how events happen how your Nemesis show up uh is it's very very thematic a great job on that but that's not why I play this game I just enjoy the card play um the deck construction is much more streamlined here so if you are afraid of deck construction this makes it a lot easier because half the back is half the deck is built for you already 15 hero cards and the double energy cards tend to be an auto include so that's 20 out of the 40 cards already picked for you so you just have to pick the other 20 and yet again if you don't care for the deck construction there are uh deck lists that you can find online and um contrary to the Lord of the Rings I have acquired every um every product for this lcg to date and I plan to uh for the foreseeable future and they really uh have been doing a killer job with uh the material that

they have been really releasing I really love that you can just buy a hero pack like you don't need to buy everything crazy enough even more so that in a lot of the Rings you don't need to buy everything for this game and I love that you can uh just buy a hero um and it's already a pre-constructed deck and I've been enjoying that like anything beyond the first couple Cycles I've just I haven't really integrated it um uh in general to my collection I just simply play the heroes to to try them out um I already have a lot to explore just from the first couple Cycles as far as the construction combinations there's lists that you can find online uh like a checklist where if you want to beat a hero uh uh with like building a hero with different aspects versus all the villains like like an achievement list basically that it'll always give you something to do all right so uh this is just and and I think this is gonna be a classic also from from for years to come as far as Solitaire board game lists go and it really shows how much they've learned from the first the Lord of the Rings as a template how much they've learned from it it does um the way that you pay for cards here it comes from the Arkham Horror lcg so it it shares some DNA with that as well and um I really really enjoy Also playing

two-handed all right so as I mentioned with Lord of the Rings uh you can play uh solo and I also suggest that you try to hand it because it expands your possibilities with that construction um assigning roles and letting certain decks focus on on one aspect versus the other deck can focus on thread control or Justice and one so yeah I really every now and then I mostly play Pure solo just because I enjoy how much more streamlined it is on how well it plays it can be swingy though uh those Advanced cards can't just be a bummer when they when they come out but you know setting up and playing again just takes a second sometimes playing two-handed can take too long uh I don't enjoy that to be honest it just takes way too long sometimes so I mostly play this one uh handed but uh do try to hand it I do like it every now and then all right so um just an incredible game and is is gonna I'll occupying everything for this uh for the foreseeable future and and I just can't wait to see what else they come up with to keep this uh fresh uh but yeah uh great game make sure you don't sleep on this if you've been thinking about buying this um oh and one really one thing I haven't mentioned uh the core set will keep you busy for quite a while all right there's a lot of content just in the corset and you can just buy a couple hero packs to

supplement that and you'll be happy for quite a while all right uh just a corset compared to Arkham Horror or Lord of the Rings this kicks those course corsets it kicks their asses all right so this corset just it feels a lot more fleshed out more full experience and with the modular sets and the villains and the heroes that it includes just a lot of fun there just very nice little environment that will keep you busy for a while all right uh so try try this game out if you haven't one of my favorites and and what inspired um uh what inspired the destiny one of the big big Inspirations for the destiny solo mode so you can thank this for that moving on to number three we have Spirit Island so I was a bit late to the party for uh this game as I mentioned in my horizons or Spirit Island review even though it's rated super highly I decided to wait um a bit long until I tried it and I think this is a masterpiece of a design and the one thing that I love about this is how modular it is because it can cater to almost any level of difficulty I it's just astonishing how they pull that off the theme is very interesting it's a reverse settler thing um I don't know of any other game that does it but this game does that very well it has some very interesting card play I love the illustrations

I love how it uses those uh element the element symbols it it has a pseudo like magic the Gathering Mana uh thing to it that I like that it kind of reminds me of playing Magic in a way I I just love how they those they use those elements uh elements right now uh unfortunately I think this game will plummet for me as far as ranking uh next time because I found that as as this is a 10 out of 10 I find almost no flaws with this game the problem is I've just found that I'd rather play other things to be honest because the brain burn in this game is real okay there's no other game that has given me a brain burn like this one and it's nice and it's satisfying but damn like I feel like I could fry an egg on my forehead like after I'm done with this this session like after I'm done with a session of this game it's just not the the the brain burn that this game gives you and you have to think like three turns in advance it's nuts and I've only played the base game content okay now that's obviously all of those things sound like uh positive points the thing is you know it kind of reduces the chances of me pulling this off the shelf right because I have to I have to be in the mood for it this is Never Gonna Leave my collection it's incredible don't get me wrong uh and I enjoy um as

I started the horizons review which I'll leave a link to um if you want a bit more relaxed um experience with streamlines uh spirits uh you can just grab that and that can keep you busy for for uh quite a bit all right it's a nice little package uh so I'll probably come back to you using those Spirits very often and the streamlined setup of that just because uh this game man the brain burn is inside and there are some people that say that they can um go by like 10 months or like a year and then come back and play this game because like rules wise they're easy to remember I unfortunately have not uh experienced that I have to use a turn tracker for this because um the turn structure I have like I have to make sure that I'm doing everything right like I could I feel all the time that I could miss things with this so I have to very carefully track every phase of the turn making sure I do everything in order right I'm not missing anything and I you know as far as coming and picking the game back up after uh like a few months I would have to reread the rules like pretty much relearn it so I have not experienced that ease of you know picking the game back up months later unfortunately but maybe it's just maybe it's just made um you know uh some like I said some people uh have mentioned that as a

positive I haven't experienced that unfortunately but yeah I think this will just drop out of my top 20 I think uh it's hard not to list it because it's just something such an incredible design everybody should try it at some point I will play it occasionally but yeah I just prefer playing other things this game the brain burn of this game is just absolutely insane um I don't think it's overrated some people say it's overrated I I don't agree at all again this game just it's a masterpiece and later with the expansions the the replayability and the depth of this is this is just one of those games that you could take to an island like if you had to keep one game I might this this would be on that handful of games that I might have to pick from if I if if I somebody asked me if you were left alone in an island in a deserted island with one game in your hand which one could it be this would be one of the contenders for that with all the expansions of course but yes just uh incredible game uh try it out and if you haven't I know that the horizons of spirit island has a bit of a has a couple years exclusivity to Target here in the United States but uh wherever you're from if if you want to wait for it to come out in uh out of the exclusivity aspect do try Horizons the spirit Island it is a nicer introductory product thanks to the streamlined spirits but uh great game uh keep it in you know keep it in mind don't let it go under your radar

moving on to number two we have gloomhaven jaws of the Lion damn uh I just can't say enough good things about this game God where do I start okay so first is the wave of this game slowly introduces the rules to you it's just masterful and I I've seen other games try to do that and fail miserably like this is the textbook of how you introduce your players to rules slowly you introduce them solely through scenarios and is it was just nuts like and it was one of my first I one of my first solo experiences too I bought it a few months shortly after I started the hobby it had come out uh to Target and everybody was going nuts about this game and I had never played a a fan a campaign game before so this was my first my introduction to Google haven and my introduction to the introduction to the whole Legacy board game thing so it blew my mind that because I didn't know that was a thing at the time like Legacy board games did not know that was like so it blew my mind on that aspect go my even already people praise it for how good that system is I know that it can be devices some people find it too dry or whatever I did really enjoy it a lot the puzzle here uh the gameplay um and I was just blown away by everything about this game and it's the

best campaign experience I've had to date uh nothing has been this for me the only unfortunate thing is that there's not much replayability in this but you know what I'm appreciating more and more lately games that are one and done experiences and I'm appreciating shorter games because to me this has the perfect length all right 20 scenarios and each of them at the bare minimum as a solo player bare minimum will be an hour age assuming that you don't have to repeat retry them because you lose okay so to me I would estimate this this is like a 25 to 30 hour minimum experience all right so that's a lot of gameplay and this and also you can repeat the cap well unless you control all four characters which I think it's insane I bit it with um the hatchet and the demolitionist so I one day do plan to bid it with the um red guard on the void warden so that's a completed and it's branching so when I bid it it's probably gonna play out different because you you do make choices there is some replayability to it uh but there just isn't enough other than playing with the two different characters to make it different but um yeah best Legacy campaign experience that I've had in in my life I've tried other Campaign gameses which are great but to me this is just a masterpiece and these days the fact that the MSRP when goes down to like 30 dollars in general like this goes on sale all the time like

there's no in my opinion there's no better like the the sound quality and the amount of gameplay that you get for per dollar this just blows everything most of everything out of the water honestly like just for those 30 dollars you're gonna get a like a masterfully crafted experience so if you haven't tried this if if you have been on the fence about this a place by God just just buy it just buy it already uh God what what an amazing game like I I just I'm just still Blown Away to this date uh to this day from when I experienced that like almost three years ago and I really and well one little side comment I'll I'll make right so I did buy Gloom Haven big box Gloom Haven after this I played a few scenarios but I just found the setup depressing as I saw the players sorry the setup in gloomhaven Big Box Gloom Haven is simply depressing it just takes too long okay so it's almost mandatory that you use an app and even with the app it's still a pain in the ass okay this game the way that it uses the spiral bound book for the scenarios just just got Chef's case just God Place more of this maybe one day they'll make an expansion for this all day or they'll make a streamlined version of frost Haven like this oh God please do that I

I'm just salivating thinking of that because no way that I'm buying Frost Haven I'm sorry because I read that it's even more there's even more upkeep than big box goom Haven what no just get out of here I think that they uh I read out one of the reviews saying that uh of frost Haven saying that uh Gom having is a system that needs to be streamed more streamlined not more blood bloated and adding more things to it I know that some Gamers like that and I can appreciate that but I think this shines so much because of how great of a job they did streamlining it so more of this place just just masterfully that plays again I can't say enough good things about this if you have not tried this no better value to me very few things match the value that this will give you for how much cheaper it is these days try this game out and finally arriving at number one we have Mage Knight one of the most influential games that defines this solo board gaming Hobby and that so many people compare other experiences too this was my second solo board game after fields of fire as I explained in one of my previous videos so I know that there's a big a common complaint about this game where people find the rule book as one person as one person has pointed out in a comment that I've read that I found funny they find it impenetrable the rulebook well as I

mentioned in my fields of fire commentary the fields of fire in as an introduction to solar board gaming that rulebook was extremely brutal so uh this being my second my follow-up game after fields of fire um this was a palette cleanser for me I actually had zero issues with this uh rulebook between this rulebook and Ricky Royals uh God bless Ricky Royal

let's play some major nights just God bless him his um tutorial videos plus this was more than enough and I had no problem just learning to play this game I did play some things uh wrong initially but even then I had a lot of fun and later on I ironed out those uh uh rules things that I was getting wrong but God damn man just everybody Compares everything to this game and I find it funny how some people find some kind of sadistically in the fact that um Spirit Island the throne this from the number one spot on the top 200 solo list listen um I'm sorry as amazing as of a designer Spirit island is I just don't think that that the sun is as influential as this one you have people making hand versions of this game 10 main versions of this game Steam adaptations and people trying to just emulate this design all the time and it's older uh by like six years compared to Spirit Island and it's aged like a fine wine all right it does have um it is a it is a bit of a barrier the rules just because I had that experience where I founded a palette cleanser I acknowledge that not everybody is going to have that experience and I do and I do acknowledge that there is a lot going on in this game okay so it'll take some time to grasp the rules but oh Christ man just the gameplay here

is just so satisfying the the puzzle is just so amazing and it is it is thematic to to some extent like the Explorer the exploration the leveling up like burning down a monastery or conquering a city uh just or finding allies along the journey ah it's just just beautiful beautiful design and one interesting thing that I didn't know this was inspired by Heroes of Mida magic which uh I saw my dad play as a kid I did watch him play that game I did not play myself I actually bought that game recently to try it out and I can see how people could just lose countless hours in that game and I I admire how Vlada tried to uh capture that with this game it it it makes me appreciate it even more um just what an incredible design and again it Bears repeating how this is so influential and how everybody just Compares this to others games how well does it feel like mention are there any other maze night like experiences to me this is the face of Solitaire board gaming uh I'm sorry like I I lost Spirit Island like I said uh and I I um it is unfortunate if for some people this game did not click but if I if I had to keep one game in my collection this would be a no doubt like absolutely just hands down I would not no here's my uh Mage Knight box goodbye collection

just this is what I would get all right just a base game there's an incredible amount of content replayability just from the base game it's just so pure and beautiful the last Legion expansion does um enrich the experience I really like what cares uh adding ball care and the extra the extra monster variety that it adds I I I enjoy that but it's not necessary uh initially you know you're gonna if you do if this ends up if you end up grasping the rules and enjoying it do get it for sure but just I did not really try the expansion content for a while uh and I bought the ultimate edition by the way that's why I'm putting the picture there I really love the dual color cards so I have not actually tried the shaders of Tesla content to date I just haven't felt a need to uh yet I just enjoy solar Conquest it's just so simple I know there's a bunch of other scenarios but just solo Conquest is just so simple and beautiful I oh God what are the side man what are the sign and I don't know that I mean I I guess again technically I guess that Spirit Island beat this uh to the number one spot not to me um not to me but uh I admire where Ireland as I've explained but to me this is the granddaddy of solo war games and it's this is gonna be really really really tough to bid for many years to come every time that I finish a session with this game got a the brain burn is great

but it it doesn't it almost like hurts when I place the spirit Island as I explained earlier when I play Spirit Island like I almost feel like I'm I'm overloading my brain here it just has that perfect balance that uh that that perfect that sweet spot of of brain burn where like and I've internalized the rules to to one extent where I can play this game like while watching while listening to YouTube videos or like a podcast like I've I've played it uh enough that I can just almost like multitask playing this game uh it's just lovely every I play this every year and this will never leave my collection I just it should for its age it it's just a testament it's it's from 2011 and it still gets it's so influential and it gets talked about today just such an incredible design and I I'm really I it's just so unfortunate that this doesn't click for so many people or that they find a rulebook impenetrable I was lucky in a way with my circumstances that I did not find that problem but God bless Ricky Royal play some nature for his tutorial videos if you haven't tried that try that and you know give it a shot please just what a design okay so now let's compare to last year and as you can see nothing much changed other than Spirit Island coming in and bumping numbers five through three one spot uh but but as I explained earlier I

think that Spirit Island will fall out significantly later for me in ranking uh so I don't expect numbers one through five to change much uh for a long time to come these are just some of my favorite games and they're just Classics as far as I'm concerned uh so I think there will be very little change on these numbers one through five but yeah that's it Okay so we've reached the end of my videos going through my top 20s from last year and if you made it this far thank you so much for listening to me rant about my favorite solo games if there are any significant changes for next year I'll make sure to do a new list and discuss it and if you enjoy this content please like And subscribe and I'll see you in the next one

thank you

Progress saved