Skip to main content
Loading video...

River of Gold, Windmill Valley, Cities, Alpina, Aeolos Reviewed and Ranked

Transcript 22:24

hey everybody and welcome to another chairman of the board ranking video this is where I take a look at the last five new to me board games that I've played and I rank and review them in order of preference I have five very interesting games to talk about this time but before I get started on the games I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kendra. co.uk who are my go-to online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order at number five I have AOL Los now this is a game that flew under the radar from a year or two ago uh it's a very light Euro game that's card driven so you're playing cards out onto the board and there are cards of two different colors uh these cards are numbered from 1 to five I believe or 0 to five I should say and what you're going to do is you're going to overlap one of those existing cards and of course by doing that you're going to change the the value or the sum of those two numbers added together so for example if both of those added up to a number six then you'd get to sell your ship to the number six island and take the action assigned to that now all of these actions are very simple a lot of them allow you to collect gems which will add up for set collection bonuses at the end of the game the more different colors at the meria but there are limited supplies of those gems some of them will give you these wind tokens that will allow you to kind of mitigate

your card plays so you can kind of increase the value of those cards by one for each win token you cash in or of course decrease if you want to Additionally you can choose to boost your ships up these different kind of streams or these rivers with the aim of trying to get to these temples and if you get if you are the first to get to these temples or the sooner you do it the better uh because you will get more victory points or even different colored gems uh it's very simple stuff I suppose the main decision space is where to commit your ships to um because if you commit them to the river you're not being very efficient if you bring them back off of the river um because you want to keep on increasing their speed um and you need to keep doing that to get them to that promised land to get them to those temples um but you also need to be making sure that you are going to certain spots to put more ships onto the board or even building these little temples or these little shrines on the islands so you have a permanent presence there and you can take those actions without even having a ship there now I love the stripb nature of the game where all you do is you you know you play a card and you take that that action um in practice I think the decision space was pretty limited um this is a fairly one note game although I like the process and enjoyed the process of playing it um being honest with myself I knew that this game didn't have much legs in terms of getting back to the table because it was just a little bit too transparent a little bit too easy to do what you wanted to do and

yeah the the combos weren't quite there all the stuff you'd want from a real juice Euro was just a little bit lacking but I do like the premise of that simple card play system and just keeping it a strip back simple game but all in all for what I want now in a euro I want it to be a little bit more interesting and just a bit more going on and I don't think AOL Los quite cut it so that is AOL Los at number five at number four I have River of gold which is a game that's getting a bit of Buzz at the moment uh this is a you know a lightweight Euro a resource management style game as you are sailing these ships down uh this river which is this rather beautiful looking board when you get to the bottom of the river you'll simply teleport back to the top and keep on going down and wherever you stop your boat is going to determine the resources or the bonuses that you'll get so again you can collect resources which you'll be using to cash in to complete contracts and you'll be getting victory points you'll be getting influence at these different kind of factions that you can climb their tracks off getting bonuses as you go if you are the highest up these tracks at the end of the game then you'll get a healthy amount of victory points the core system in this game I really do enjoy where you are simply rolling a D6 and that D6 is going to determine what you can do but you can use that result in three different ways so as I said you can use it to move move down the river a number of spots equal to that D6 with some mitigation tools so

you can increase or decrease uh the value and you also have two boats on the board so you have a little bit more flexibility there about where you might land up uh so that's the first action you can do the second action is to build a building in the region that your dice shows and to do that you're going to Simply pay a kind of a fee for that bit of um bit of uh real estate really and then you'll put a tile on it which will give you some in influence to clam these tracks but it'll also give you um two bits of information number one is the information where you what your opponent will get in terms of bonus if they land at your building but the second piece of information is the bonus that you'll get if yourself or an opponent lands at that building uh the third bits of information is the idea of caching in these resources for these contracts because each of these customer cards has a number assigned to it um they might say you know you want two Ceramics and one rice and you'll cash that in you'll get an instant bonus you'll get an ongoing benefit and you'll often get an endgame scoring benefit as well these cards are fairly interesting in what they do so some of them might allow you to uh get cheaper purchases when it comes to building these buildings in certain regions some of them might double the yield or victory points you'll get by climbing those tracks um some of them will just simply uh give you other benefits for example if you whenever you loop around the board you'll get an extra an extra boost as well such as more victory points or more mitigation tokens Etc so

very simple system I like the way it's all held together through this dice system where you can use it in three different ways um and I do I've always lik that idea of building up the board as you go and when people use the stuff that you've invested in you'll get a benefit from that as well so this game almost feels like a a hybrid of say games like um Lords of Water Deep crossed over with a bit of like aizia through you the river system um I I liked the game and I can certainly see a lot of people enjoying it the problem for me is that it does feel a little bit a little bit rained in in terms of what you can actually do and each game feels fairly similar and the the decision space is fairly obvious on what you should do you know if you haven't got a a contract you can complete you can't afford a building then of course you're going to sell down the river and end up where you end up um of course you're going to try and avoid your opponent's buildings if you can but sometimes it might not be worth doing that you're going to try and land on your own buildings if you can and there are some public objectives to go for as well which might be an obvious choice and what to follow and it all just feels like it's kind of capped its own potential in what it should do now I'm looking at this game through um you know Through The Eyes of somebody who's played hundreds of Euro games so maybe that's somewhat tainting my view of this game because I feel like it could be more um but if I'm looking It Through The Eyes of someone who's just dipping their toes into the Euro genre and has enjoyed games like Lords of Water Deep

or maybe even isn't interested in the Lords of Water Deep theme you know the the dungeon and dragon thing and want something a bit bit a bit more attractive um and a bit more modern and this is a good substitute for that so I think this could be it could find its place in the hobby as being the new introductory Resource Management Euro game um if it doesn't find that Niche I think it's going to struggle to find its place because I don't think there's just enough strategy or enough depth to the game to really keep you coming back at least that's how I felt about it I'm sure some people will feel differently um again mechanically very smooth it gets out of its own way in terms of um you know rules bya very intuitive simple to play quite actually quite enjoyable to play um but yeah that that extra mild extra crunchiness and the decision space is just a little bit lacking for me and I've love have seen it just elevated that one step more so that is a river of gold at number four at number three I have Alpena this is a small little card game as you are building up this 5x5 grid of these animal cards you and your opponents are all contributing to that grid so it's not like you all have your own little playing area you are interacting with your opponent in what you build um once you've placed one of these animal CS you have the option to place one of your explorers on it and then unlock that scoring on that animal card for the end of the game so these cards might be

things such as score two points for every other Explorer below this card or score every a point for every frog in this row or every goat attached to this card and so on as you can imagine with these spatial puzzles this does a lot of the same stuff but the you know the thing that differentiates it is that you are trying to decide what to what to commit to in terms of your scoring because when you place that card yes you can commit the Builder or your Explorer to it straight away but later in the game if you build orthogonally to that card you can still grab it as maybe a more clear picture of the board state is starting to build up but of course your opponents are going to know the same things um I like the way that you can string your explorers together because you can make them kind of piggyback off each other in the way they score you can even piggyback off your opponent's actions and so on so I do like that extra little twist on the game and that kind of idea of pasting yourself but not leaving it too long with the spots that you kind of had your eye on will be taken by other players and of course you don't want to run out of time um because you can only place one worker per turn so yeah all in all is a very pleasant game very smooth only takes around 20 minutes to play it looks nice it doesn't look great like some of these other um nature themed games but it works for what it does um entirely in offensive I'm sure a lot of people will like it might get lost in the shuffle because there are a

lot of these again spatial puzzles a grid movement style games but this is a solid one that I would say if you you know like a small box filler game uh that's aesthetically pleasing easy to play easy to teach um but with an extra little wrinkle or two to keep it interesting then it could be worth taking a look at Alpena at number two I have cities now this is a familyfriendly weight game about trying to build cities of course uh this is designed by Steve Finn and Phil Walker Harding so two designers of great pedigree there and it's a very simple game mechanically as you are trying to build this 3x3 grid and populating it with these kind of features that will go in the Parks features that will go in the water as well as building buildings by stacking these plastic blocks on top of each other now the game play is super simple and it works a little bit like a worker placement game but more of a a drafting variant of that as you have four rows on the board with four different kind of components that will be added to your city so the first row is going to be a scoring card which will score you points based on different factors things like score one point for every Green Building at least one high or score um two you know one point for every two spaces in your biggest field these things we've seen before so that's the first segment the second segment is going to be the actual tiles or the foundation in which

you can build the things on um these might determine other objectives that you are trying to reach towards and the third row is going to be these features that you're going to be filling up with your you know your parks with benches and fountains and things the more different features you have in your Parks the more points you'll get so simple set collection and the final row is going to be these plastic buildings where you can stack them on the matching colored spots within your city so not only are you trying to build the city to of course tailor them to be um to contribute towards those scoring cards even objective that you've s drafted but there are also public objectives that you are racing to achieve and these public objectives are variable and there are quite a few of them in the game and they all are kind of assigned to a different phas a city in the world so for example the New York one will score you points based on your your biggest park or trying to get to a certain amount of Park as quickly as possible um to kind of represent you know Central Park you'll also score points based on skyscrapers so you want tall buildings and and also having like Avenues of the same buildings or having whole rows completed of buildings which is not an easy thing to achieve so again you're racing to get these objectives you might get some you know second place points or third place points if you are a little bit behind the other players but of course the points will be distributed accordingly so very simple stuff um it only takes well it only takes about half an hour to play and maybe even quicker

than that at two players because with the two player variant you are playing um four rounds instead of eight and you're placing double the amount of workers on the board each round now I like the idea of this one I like again how simple it is um and that you are tailoring your strategy as you go um and I do like I suppose the main the main feature of the game or the the main kind of feeling of the game was supposed to be that turn an what do you go for first because if you go for the scoring objective first then you're probably giving up Priority in taking one of the other ones um there's a real scarcity of what you want that you know that turn a really does shine through so you do need to factor in what do I need right now what can I maybe take a turn or two to get because although it's a really good card I don't think my opponent wants it so therefore I can put it behind on priority order so I do like the way that you have to prioritize which of these actions you want to take and you can't go there for a second time to take a second action so I really do like that factor there this real scarcity to get what you want sometimes that shines through stronger than other times because there might be times where you think you know I don't really care about going there anymore because I know that's mine anyway um and both of them are are fine I can make do with either of them so maybe it could have been the volume of that that turn next could have been turned up a little bit more at times because a lot of the time you times you can make do with what you have anyway and generally do all right but I

appreciate this this is who that game's designed for it is very introductory it is quite light um not only in terms of the rules but also in terms of the decision space and unfortunately although I I love how smooth the gaml is I love the potential of the game I think that maybe it's a little bit too light for me and the choices are a little bit too obvious a bit like River of gold I would have and even AOL loss I would have liked to have seen an extra wrinkle or two just to add a little bit more seasoning to the game to make it a little bit more interesting as it stands again objectively I can really sing its Praises it does a great job of doing what it should do kind of fits that King Domino Vibe um but for my collection and looking this more subjectively um I don't think it's going to quite cuss the cut the mustard to be a keeper within my collection uh it's a game that I would probably never turn down playing because it is very pleasant very enjoyable um but do does it deserve its space on my own shelves when space is a premium I don't quite think so and it's that's a narrow Miss as well so um unfortunately I want it to be a little bit more than it actually is and maybe that's me um yeah maybe me kind of fantasizing what it could be rather than what it actually is and what it's trying to be so that is cities at number two and finally at number one I have windmill Valley so

windmill Valley a game I've had on the on the back burner for some time I wasn't quite sure if I was going to take a punt on this one um because I thought you know Bard and dice have been hit on Miss recently I've not played any of the Danny Garcia games yet because they seem a little bit convoluted for me but as the months have gone by the more and more good things I'm hearing about this game so I thought you know let's give it a go and I'm really glad I did because I've been playing a lot of this game and enjoying it more and more so mechanically I love how simple this game is but it's it's still interesting in the way those me mechanisms work so basically you have this um resource wheel or this action wheel with two different cogs on them and these cogs are going to determine your actions and the the number of kind of rotations that these wheels make is up to the players you can choose to of keep the water level as it is or you can choose to increase that water level to give you more spins and the more you increase the water level you'll get some passive points that way as well um because you could potentially be helping the other players now what I do like about this game is that I think there's six separate actions or maybe even seven with the additional ones um that you can take and they are all very very simple in their own right simply draft a card draft an upgrade for your resource will and you know take um you place a windmill on the board and so on so all very easy to explain but the potential for comboing and synergizing actions

together really does come through so for example you might say I'll go here uh to place my windmill down that might contribute towards um you know a race objective that windmill will then unlock some further scoring on my player it will allow me to bury some tulips the Tulips will score me more endgame scoring points um when I place this tulip down it gave me some money and so on so again you can string these actions together to make very powerful and satisfying turns um the engine building is very interesting as you can literally upgrade your resource will to make the actions better and even if there's an action that you're not that interested in anymore you can completely overlap it with one of these upgrades and just do you know be gone with that particular action and focus Fus on something else um you know the game is fairly linear in what you want to do collect your lips place them in rows of the same type and different uh different types and columns um unlocking points that way um you can buy these characters which are really cool or even just draft these characters sorry which will either give you in-game benefits so for example that might say every time you um bury a tulip you you get a tulip and things like that which are very useful but more important Ely you can take them as endgame objectives so you can use them as two ways either in in-game engine building benefits or endgame scoring benefits and I think the game objectively I can't really fault too much with it I think the only criticism I have is that sometimes those

objectives on the characters can be a bit swingy um because on your turn you might not have any objectives that suit you but on your opponent's turn they have one that's going to double the points of all their tulips and they've already completed that row so therefore they're going to score another 15 points without putting much effort in at all and I've played this quite a few times already and that really does swing who wins the game or not so I might appreciated seeing those objectives maybe capped at a certain amount of points lower than what it is in the game of course I don't know the the maths behind that decision but it just feels a little bit wonky for me and then every time I've T this I've made that very clear that you want to be keeping an eye out for particular objectives that are fitting your strategy um but still despite that nitpick the rest of the game is highly enjoyable again combos Galore upgrading your player board is so much fun uh the game also moves at a very brisk Pace you can play a two-player game of this in 45 minutes to an hour um if you're teaching this at you know Fourplay game it's probably going to take more than an hour and a half maybe two hours for the first play um but it doesn't feel like you are sitting there doing nothing all the turns feel fun um and yeah it's just a lovely Euro that I can see staying around in my collection for some time because it's it's actually very easy to get to the table and to teach but it still hits all those sweet spots and what you want for a Euro so definitely

going to be a contender for a Euro of the Year for me um it might just fall short because some others I played out just a little bit better but still going to probably going to be in the top three um I I'd be surprised if this doesn't make the top 10 of the Year for me in overall 2024 releases yeah so all in all it's a quality design and it's maybe want to um maybe take a a closer look at some of those other Danny Garcia games that haven't quite grabbed my attention but if they're up to this quality then um I know they're going to be good so that is windmill Valley at number one so there we have it that concludes the video hope hopefully you have enjoyed it and found it useful as usual please be sure to hit like And subscribe to the channel uh also check out my own personal game that's coming out for release called Thalamus and if you follow the BGG page then you can stay updated uh with all the uh updates and news um for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved