Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Worker Placement Board Games of All Time - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 20:51

hey everybody today i'm talking about my top 10 worker placement board games so i actually made this list a few years ago now however i thought it needed a bit of a revamp and wanted to kind of kind of recalibrate my thoughts and give my definitive top 10. so um before i get into the top 10 list i just want to give a shout out to kianda.cody uk who are my go-to online retailer in the uk get some great games at some great prices um but let's get on to the list so i want to make it very clear that these games aren't necessarily ranked in my order from my you know least favorite to my most favorite i really wanted to put that emphasis on that worker placement part of the game where i think that part of the game shines through the strongest and most these games do cater towards that medium to heavier weight euro style game so bear that in mind as well but you know without further ado let's get started on the list at number 10 i have mimi's which i think is a criminally underrated game one that really has faded into obscurity over the years but i really think this one deserves a bit of a resurgence and if you see this one out in the world i would encourage you to pick this one up so this one is a game with a really cool theme and i'm not normally a massive suck of a theme but this one does it very well as you are running your own ant colony and you're doing that through the worker placement mechanism by placing your tokens onto your player board either creating new ants you've got a kind of exploring ants you've got combat ants and you're trying to harvest food because at the end of each round you kind of have to feed your force of ants otherwise you're going to suffer penalties you're trying to upgrade your colony to get bigger

benefits and to spread your pheromones faster and also fighting for public objectives with the other players as well as well as giving sometimes giving workers up and getting more workers in as well as you've got to have this constant juggling effect of keeping your colony thriving and this one has some really cool mechanisms i said particularly that um that farrowing mechanism where a certain spot allows you to go adventuring out onto the board and you're navigating the terrain and you're landing on a certain spot and leaving your pheromones and collecting resources that way so rather than the traditional worker placement formula by you know go here to get this resources you really do have to invest in these spots and it takes a bit longer to get them going but i think it works extremely well it's such a tight game with very little wriggle room in terms of making mistakes but i really do think that adds to the enjoyment and they keep things tight and keeps things tense and um you know get that small margin for error can really be where you are kind of hit or miss with this game but such a well tight design and i say maybe the reason why someone didn't make the upper echelons of the list is because a lot of the worker placement is kind of self-contained you're not so much worried about what the other people are doing and because most of those spots are on your personal board rather than on a communal board which of course where is a lot of the interaction normally shines through in work placement games but regardless of that still a wonderful work placement game that is mimi's at number 10.

at number nine i have another older game with lancaster uh by matthias kramer this one is set in england and it has that more traditional work placement filter as you're taking your workers putting them onto the board and trying to hold that position because sometimes people can knock you off by bidding more in terms of their workers strength because all your workers in this game are depicted by these knights and they range in value from strength one all the way to strength four and they're physically um different as well because your strength four and workers are much chunkier so you can look at the glass and see you know who's controlling that region and at what strength um but i love this jostling for position as you're claiming these different counties and cities on the board and say i bid a bit of three then it goes to my opponent and they can potentially knock me off by bidding four or boosting up their workers with these squires and you're basically trying to control these regions not only to get the benefit on them such as upgrading your nights or getting new nights into your fold so you've got more options but also by claiming these nobles and when you get these nobles you're going to add them to your banquet table and they are going to give you not only loads of points but they're also going to give you a lot of say when it comes to a particular phase in the game when you vote for laws to either pass or vote for them to kind of go into power or not out of power and you're using votes to do that and of course the more noble support you get the more kind of stroke you have such a cool design um again i love that interaction this game really tends to control those regions there's also an area of control part of the game where you're putting workers there in order to

contribute to these battles and the more you contribute the more points you're going to get or potentially going to suffer points if you don't contribute to these fights um you know through negative points uh what a game this one is i say again the only reason this one isn't higher on the list is because i think as times gone by i think this one would really benefit from a revamped edition where some of the housekeeping niggles and things could be smoothed out a little bit but the gameplay itself for that worker placement part of the game is up there with the best so that is lancaster at number nine at number eight i have early on now early on i suppose the first thing people take away from this game is that you might you might not think it's a worker placement game you might think it more for its bag building part of the game you know as you're collecting tokens and putting them into your bag and each round you're drawing tokens out and putting them on different spots an action board basically um but that for me is work replacement you're taking that token out you put it on a worker spot and take and triggering that action to get benefits however a lot of these worker placement spots don't need maybe one particular worker they might need several different workers and when you trigger once you trigger them they're going to go back into your bag ready to be used again um however they will let you kind of climb tracks and let you out travel around a map and pick up different resources and drop them off depending on if you've got the expansion or not you can use it to invest in getting more workers also like more things into your bag so when you draw them out you get more options and more flexibility i love this idea of should i trigger these things now or should i wait for them for the perfect time i like the way that you have to dedicate things to certain

action spots and if you haven't fulfilled all that criteria then they are potentially tied up for a few rounds until you get that final spot complete i really do love this mechanism but there's so much tension in this game as you really do have to know when to flip that switch in order to know when to start losing workers from your bag and adding them to a separate ball to get quite strong bonuses for doing so this game really does have it all i think is remarkably deep for how simple the rule set is and just drawing works for the bag add them to your board and potentially triggering those actions um but what a blast this one is a real fun factor i would say that the expansion of this game is mandatory it's essential we do the trade and intrigue expansion to really take it to that next level but regardless of that the gameplay is so strong and a big portion of that is because of that worker placement mechanism love this one that is only on at number eight at number seven i have another game that's really flown under the radar um maybe over the last year this is a game called fruticular so for tickler again a game that didn't get any fanfare whatsoever when it came out despite being from some pretty popular designers this one is a game about running a fruit orchard or trying to collect fruit and convert those fruit into jams to sell them at a market it has this commodity speculation and kind of a dynamic market to it as fruit is constantly fluctuating in price sometimes it goes up in value sometimes it goes down depending on the supply and demand um but it all goes back to a simple worker placement user interface um as you have two different types of

workers you've got workers and you've got farmers and each of those has their own strengths and benefits so when you go to certain spots um you might harvest fruit faster if you use a particular worker or some might give you more power in terms of converting fruit into jams a lot quicker and more efficiently um but just before you even start placing the workers onto the board you have to make some quite crucial decisions um because you have a hand of cards and those cards are going to dictate which workers you have for that following round so you could have say three farmers or you could have maybe three farmers and two workers in any different orders and the order is important because you have to place them in that order which could mean you change your priorities and want to do things at certain speeds and also each card has a initiative value based on it as well so that if you play a particular card with a low value you'll likely get those spots first and claim that spot before the other players do uh layers upon layers of strategy here despite being a medium light euro i love the commodity speculation love the potential for upgrading your engine in this game as you can collect these tiles which let you do game breaking things um very few spots but i don't think that's a negative for the game it just really does ramp up that tension um and i just love those extra wrinkles in terms of that card play in terms of being restricted in the order you play those workers and that really does again add that attention to that worker placement part of the game in order to get there before your opponents do to get bigger dividends uh wonderfully designed game i think one of the biggest issues with this game is its production it does certainly feel cheap uh the

cardboard is rubbish some design issues but the gameplay itself is rock solid and amongst one of the best worker placement games that i've played and for an hour experience i think that is two thumbs up from me so that is fruticular at number seven at number six i have barrage so this is pretty much polar opposite to a game like futica this one is an industrious a massive sprawling game as you're trying to be these energy tycoons trying to convert water into energy and you're doing this through this damn system as this board is made up of this basically a mountain scape and then it goes into the kind of planes and you're trying to collect water as it flows down this board capture it in dams convert that into energy through these conduits and to generate energy to get points etcetera um but the way this game operates is of course using a worker placement mechanism and i love the um simplicity of how those worker placement spots work in relation to the depth and scale of the game because this is a pretty involved a pretty cutthroat um confrontational and just a grand game in general but actually explaining it in terms of its worker placement system it actually does help massively i think um so all you're going to do on this game you're going to take workers and put them on these different spots which will either let you convert water into energy they'll let you build new dams new conduits new power stations but when you um when you build these things you're actually tying up resources for a prolonged period of time so you're not actually spending resources you're just dedicating them or

tying them up for a certain amount of time and one of those worker placement spots is to accelerate that to make sure that you get those resources back quicker than you normally would do which i think is fantastic um and i love the fact that the way this game is bounced in terms of you know there's generally quite a bit of flexibility in getting spaces in the action you want but if you're not quick enough you might have to end up spending more workers and of course not being as efficient for doing so and it costing you money as well so you generally do have options here and you're not so strictly locked out of these worker placement spots but being such an economic game every coin can be massive so i really do like the way this game is balanced i like the way it's boiled down into the simple systems but still having a ton of depth and a ton of player interaction one of my favorite games of all time um that is barrage at number six at number five i have underwater cities by vladimir suki this one is pretty much the definitive engine building game you have so much going on here in terms of constantly getting upgrades for this and for that making things cheaper i'm giving yourself unique abilities lots of different things you know anything you can think of relating to engine building this game delivers and of course the key system in the game is worker placement as you're taking your player marker adding it to a certain spot on the board and blocking other players from doing so but i love the fact that this is taken to the next level um because each worker placement spot goes hand in hand with some card play because each spot is related to a different color and when you place that worker down you can choose to play the matching colored card and get a follow-up bonus as well and that's it's cool because the more

powerful work-and-placement spots kind of go hand in hand with the weaker cards and vice versa so it really is about how you're going to manage those actions and how to manage your hand accordingly because you might not want to get rid of cards and when you go to those um certain spots so it really is about what's going to be the kind of net gain and what you're going to do um but this is a game about building underwater city as you've probably explained um we'll probably expect you're building kind of upgrades you're getting more income round and round and just trying to generate a points engine but again i haven't seen that system used before whenever you go to workplace and spot you can play a follow-up card and get that bonus as well which adds a whole new dimension to the game and it just works so so well so that is underwater cities at number five at number four i have marco polo 2 in service of the khan so this is a a game that uses dice as workers so at the start around you're going to roll i believe it's five or six dice and then you are going to dedicate them to spots on the board um and the pit values of these devices can be quite important because they are going to let you kind of travel around faster or let you collect different resources because some spots require higher pit values than others to go to um i like the tenseness of getting places before other people because again traveling is like a really valuable action and if you really want to make the most of that then you're going to have to get there first and if you go after it or if you follow another player by taking the same action sometimes you have to pay a fee for doing so and which can of course um add more player interaction to the game and make you race to those spots before the other

people do um some spots are open so anybody can go to some spots are purely locked for one person so all this just adds that worker placement tension that i love where you want to be the first to do something but prioritizing things is where the strategy and the decision space comes into the game i love the way that parts of this game go hand in hand where you need to collect resources with your workers in order to fulfill these contracts but you need to travel in order to get the contracts in the first place so it really is a well-balanced game that you need to try everything and i think that's probably one of the biggest parts or biggest reasons why marco polo 2 is on this list rather than the original i still love the original it's a bit tighter which you know maybe it's a positive or a negative for you um but i yeah i love all these things this game has to offer users die so so well i'm some good mitigation on that dice roll as well as you can spend camels to re-roll or flip them over um and i also love this idea that you can have these unique player powers which are really strong in what they do and make you very different to your opponents which of course will kind of put you on a path in which strategy you want to follow so yeah really well-rounded euro in fact one of the most well well-rounded euros i own i think in terms of being just there's nothing wrong with it at all it's just a fun experience that uses dice and worker placement um at its core so that is marco polo 2 in service of the khan at number three i have lorenzo ill magnifico so this is another workplacement game of course which uses dice as one of the key influencing factors however this game you're not

you're not rolling dice and allocating them to different spots you are rolling a bunch of dice and then they those colors of those um dice are going to correspond to a worker which you have and each player is going to have a worker of those matching types and the pip value of that dice is going to determine the strength of that worker so say the uh the white die rolled three that means everybody's white worker is strength three and you're going to use those workers in order to collect new cards in order to score points or give you engine building abilities um you can boost them up with these servants and you're all trying to build this kind of engine or row of cards where you go to a certain other engine another worker placement spot and you can run that engine from left to right and generate a whole bunch of resources at once and they kind of the longer you neglect these things you can take these kind of um these hinderances to make your dice less potent or your work is less potent when you take them so getting places first is so so important i love all the different things you can do in this game so many different paths to victory loads of different engine building potential and it's just a really satisfying game um and i love that worker placement system where you don't know what your workers are going to be strength they're going to be this round maybe you didn't build up enough servants to boost you up but everybody is singing from the same hymn sheet so you know luck is not really a factor so i really do love the way that works so an amazing euro that is lorenzo ill magnifico at number three at number two i have key flower so key flower certainly one of the most interactive games that i've ever played um this is a work placement

mixed with almost auction slash bidding um as you're trying to use these tiles but also bid on these tiles to add to your personal town and when you use these or the way you use every any action in this game is based on meeples so i believe you've got four different colored meeples you've got red your blues your greens and your yellows and um but every one of those colors isn't kind of relating to a particular player you know i could have some yellows this player can have some yellows and so on but as soon as you either bid for these tiles to add your player board then that particular color that you've used to do that is going to lock it in for all the other plays as well so if i've beard say one yellow to take this tile then all the other players can only bid and compete with yellows as well however you can also use or straight up use those tiles before they even claimed as their worker placement spot to either get your resources or convert resources to others or to move around your map um but i love the fact that when you use those worker placement spots if somebody bids it and wins that bid they're going to get all the workers that that have been bid on them and take them as their fold for the next round so it really does have this free-flowing economy and you'll be very careful when you use things and how you use them because it could really be benefiting other players and as you develop your town as the game goes on and you can either use your workers or your meeples on your own player board in order to get those benefits and make sure you keep them in in your area and keep them to be able to use it again and again or you can actually use other people's tiles which they've claimed previously but bearing in mind that once you use their tiles they are going to claim that

worker for the next round so i look and i love that economy so much depth in the interaction here um and that work placement is so so strong and it ties and synergizes so so well with that bidding system um a brilliant work placement game one of the best number two of all time that is key flower and finally my number one worker placement game is zulkin the mayan calendar so for me this one despite being one of the first worker placement games i've ever played is still my favorite of that particular genre um and the reason for that one is this one really does take the genre and turn it on its head as a whole new dimension to the game because not only are you kind of being wary about when you're taking workers off the board and putting them on the board but the timing of that comes into play as well because the longer you when you're placing these works on the board you're placing them on these gears and the longer you leave them on these gears they're going to start charging up round off the round and getting bigger and bigger rewards however you are forced to either place new workers or take them off the board each round and pacing yourself and kind of lining the timings up is really where this game does shine because sometimes you might think i'll place this worker here and then that'd be the end of my turn it'll rotate once and then i'll place one over here and then it'll do the same and and by the time it gets your third or fourth turn you might be ready to take this one off which will correspond to this action here and take a big powerful action all at once all based on that strategy and the way you again you chronologically place things on the board so so clever it's again a whole new dynamic to the game no other gamers even tried to

replicate this which is really surprising to me and because that for me that mechanism has so much scope but that work replacement system of just put things on the board or take them off the board um and how you're going to do that not leaving yourself backed into a corner so you're forced to take things off or force to put them on is just for nominal and it's on top of that i suppose the underlying factor is pretty standard stuff you know just collecting resources buying buildings i'm collecting these crystal skulls and deposit on on a different part of the map to get points um so it really is a kind of point salary engine building style game but tied together with that gear worker placement system just takes this game to a whole new dimension and it is utterly mind-blowing about how well this game is put together so that is my number one worker placement game of all time sulkin the mayan calendar so i really hope you've enjoyed this top 10. it's been a while since i've done one and i always enjoy doing top 10 so if you have enjoyed the list um please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too um additionally let me know what your favorite work placement game is and i'll be sure to reply to your comment in the um in the comments below um and of course as always i'm be sure to check out kianda.koda uk for some great board games in the uk so um for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye

Progress saved