10 Board Games We've "Cooled" On | The Games We Feel Differently About Now
Transcript
foreign hey how's it going everyone Carlo here from all you can board as always I'm here with my cousin Dylan and today we are doing a video called 10 games we've cooled on so we're basically going to be each we've each picked five games um and we specifically have picked games that we used to like a lot more than we currently do so this doesn't necessarily mean that we don't like the game anymore or that we still do whatever the whole point is we just wanted to pick the games that have the widest discrepancy between our you know an opinion we held on it in the past compared to how we feel about the game now so we've sort of very Loosely ranked them I think the games as we get you know further to the end of the video those are going to be the games that have the biggest discrepancy where we've really really cooled you know our opinion has lessened over time yep um but yeah I think we'll just kick it off right there I'm gonna throw it to you to make that first pick all right so the first one I'm going to talk about is uh I will preface this by saying there is a minuscule chance that I might even though I've cooled I might warm again yeah but yeah these are by no means full uh you know this isn't a full review of final opinion yeah but as of right now I definitely cool that I just haven't played this game a lot so it could change I don't think it will though and that is winter Kingdom so the the reason I'm putting this on here already even though I think we've only played two or three times is because I've I've played so when the first time I played winter Kingdom I was super super impressed and it was mostly because here's a game that's taking a game I love Kingdom Builder and
expanding on it adding a bunch of you know exciting new abilities and ways to interact with the board and just like new new and it was just really exciting and I enjoyed that first session the second session felt it didn't it didn't feel like it was a worse worse or different session than the first time I felt like we are playing another game winter Kingdom and for some reason it just hit me more in that session because I played Kingdom Builder recently a bunch on uh board game arena that I I gravitate more to what kingdom Builder does and the Simplicity of it and like maybe because I'm more familiar with the strategy or whatever that I'm finding winter Kingdom just there's too much going on for that type of game that I'm sitting down to play if I'm sitting down to play that I'm wanting the quicker like more streamlined tighter uh Kingdom Builder experience than I am this elaborate um one with winter Kingdom with all these extra abilities like as cool as that is I feel like there's enough games I've played that have like you know have expanded in in those kind of ways and added in a bunch of different abilities and wasted after the board all this stuff to think but that's not what I want from the Kingdom Builders so it's not so much that it's a bad game that's not I think for a lot of people it'll be like a really enjoyable game one that they might even play more than kingdom Builder but for me after playing it that second time it would take a really really special session for me to all of a sudden be like oh actually no now I'm flipping again like for me now I would just much rather sit down and play Kingdom Builder and I know we differ even on our
opinions the kingdom Builder now um somewhat based on just having how much we've played it but for me it just came to build there's always going to be a game that I really enjoy going back to and like can always I would always agree to a session have a good time or a winter Kingdom I feel like I I could see myself being like I just don't want to dedicate that much time to Planet would you play Kingdom Builder instead you know what I mean so that's where the cooling is happening for me I guess it's because of the comparisons to Kingdom Builder that's fair I will say uh the second time we played it was what I think a good two or three months after the first time and I had we had to basically do I had to reteach the game to you as well as teaching it to Braden yeah uh not like I can't really disagree with your opinion on this because I've felt the same two I think I've enjoyed winter Kingdom more than you and I think I am leaning more towards like I do think I'm gonna ultimately like it more than kingdom Builder right but I would would be lying if I said that I wasn't a little bit disappointed with that second session as well I think after we had that first one under our belt I was expecting to already feel like I I had to grasp better grasp what was going on and in the second one I still felt pretty overwhelmed yeah and how many more plays is it going to take for that overwhelming feeling to dissipate and for to feel the way we do when we play Kingdom Builder it's like hey I know what I'm doing now and now I can really focus on making those clever plays instead of feeling like I'm just grasp like uh trying to grasp what the rules basically so yeah I could say a lot more but uh we'll eventually do a kingdom Builder versus winter Kingdom video really comparing them in depth and uh yeah I'm actually even more Curious to do that now yeah no kidding uh hearing your opinion so we'll have to play a bunch more winter Kingdom soon yeah so that's winter Kingdom my first one cool
all right uh my first pick is going to be aeon's end so this is a Cooperative uh deck building game for one to four players was probably one of the first not like the first four or five games I bought but it was probably in the first 10 or 12 games I ever bought for my collection um and for a long time it was definitely a top 10 game for me like for years and years when I first had it I loved aeon's end I played all the time um I I've talked about it in detail of why I got rid of it in like one of my curating my collection videos I did recently apart from it uh with it from my collection um and part of that is just that it's the type of game where once you see a lot of what there is to see there's just less incentive to go back right I'm guessing you probably feel a similar way to an extent uh with Marvel Champions and if they weren't always releasing new packs like if you just bought let's say the starter set and you played through each of the heroes and you beat all the bosses or whatever after a while you'd feel less incentive to keep playing with the same Heroes and going back and maybe no I shouldn't speak on you because it's on my uh just just solo and if I wasn't getting any new cards and I already cracked my decks like I could see myself being like where is my incentive to come back and just play this villain again if I'm bringing new people in that haven't played before for sure I've been interacted with like me doing a two-player game with these two Heroes sure I think I feel like because there's so many heroes in the game there's more like right variety yeah yeah but I mean like if you were to play as like Spider-Man and Green Goblin or whatever you wouldn't be like next week being like Oh I'm gonna pick Spider-Man again and play against Green Goblin again yeah
and that's kind of that's just the like the uh essentially why I cooled on aeon's end because I had it for so long I mostly played it solo I played it quite a bit with two three and four players but I mentioned in my creating my collection video I think it works much better as either a solo or two player I don't really like it as much as a three or four player game wasn't getting to the table as much and it just felt like I had seen almost everything there was to see and it got to the point where you know there's there's some additional barriers with like the setup is very long the teardown you can lose really early on in the game and then you're like well I have to reset up but I might not want to set up with the exact same Market cards and the same thing because if I lost maybe want to try something different but maybe you played for 15 minutes to lose to now spend another 10 minutes 15 setting up the next thing it's just a lot and it felt like over time the experience was becoming less and less novel so I have a lot of respect for it I think it's a really well designed game but now it's nowhere near my top 50s so I've just crawled on it just because I've spent a lot of time playing and I really enjoyed my time with it but yeah just doesn't have a whole lot left to offer that's fair I only played a couple times but so I would still like I'm interested to like play again but it's never one that I've been like eager like I need to play this pen suggested right and it for a little bit it gave me some extra light I got some extra life out of it because I bought an expansion that came with some new Mages some new bosses but then I tried those beat them and then it was like I didn't want to keep holding on to this game to buy more expansions and more expansions I just thought yeah I've seen what I have to see from the system so I decided to move on but yeah great game and if you haven't tried it and you're especially if you're into deck
building I highly recommend it there's a lot of cool stuff that other games don't do uh yeah that is aeon's end sweet and there's a newer version coming out this year I think called Astro Knights or maybe it's next year which is like a slimmed down version with a slightly different theme cool so if anyone wants a more approachable version check out astronites right on uh all right so the one I'm gonna talk about next is one that I have a really cooled on because I don't like this game anymore and it's interesting because I don't know if I've actually I realized as I was picking this I was like I thought this for a while after playing out a few more times on BGA after all so I haven't played the physical version um and I don't think we've actually had the conversation so you might be caught up guard that I don't really enjoy this game much anymore and that is a knit of leer oh no you told me a while ago I do remember you mentioning that you had cooled or that you had thought like you didn't see what was all that special about it so you know and I know what it is so when I first played this game I was so I and I still do I really like the upgrading your coins that that is my favorite part of the game and I think the first time I played especially I was so caught up in the novelty of that and how much I enjoyed that mechanic and there was still other stuff that I thought was cool about what was going on with like the you know the the dwarves are they all dwarves though it was like they have the purple doors and the green doors and and you know the the the special characters that you can yeah the heroes yeah the heroes um that I think I was so distracted by the coins the other stuff I was just like oh it's good it's fine like this is a great game I like it a lot and The more I've played it on BGA especially the more I
just realized there's nothing inherently like bad about it something that's like wrong it's just for whatever reason I'm just not having fun playing it I I even the coin aspect like I've gotten over like it's still a novel thing I still like it but it's no longer just distracting me from the things that I just am not enjoying and it's hard for me to even pinpoint like what it specifically is maybe it's because you know that set collection aspect is I've played it in so many games that now I'm just not finding myself drawn to the way that uh Native Larry does it um or I don't even I don't even quite know I just know the last few times we've played I have not enjoyed my sessions of it and I haven't been like oh like maybe this is just a bad game or whatever and I think part of it is too I don't like that there's like the scores are so ridiculously high and there's such variety I do like it in games where like if we play similarly really well that our scores reflect that and are closer because then we can look and be like oh maybe by one point because we both played so efficiently whereas I find that like you can have a close game in Native layer and yet you can still have like a 20 or 30 point gap or whatever it is because that's just the way it is and it's harder to differentiate that it feels a little bit worse when you've lost by 30 even though it might be that really it was like you're only like five percent behind yeah whatever technology so there's just a few things about it that like it's not one of those games where I can be like here's what's bad about it here's why I don't like it it's more just that the sum of its parts and everything no longer interest me in the way that that first game did and I think it mostly was that I was being distracted by how much I really did like that upgrading coin system okay yeah how do you feel about
the aspect of drafting a card uh to go in a like drafting something that goes into your biggest column already because it's going to kind of exponentially give you points versus drafting what you don't have to make a line of five to get a hero like do you like that trade-off of like I technically I'm really getting a lot of orange points and taking that 2 orange would really multiply but if I get this I get to get a hero which can change is that something you do or don't like about the way you describe it like makes it sound like oh like there's all these interesting decisions and everything with it which for sure there are sometimes but at the same time when I played it the drafting aspect I liked to the first time I played but I feel like we've played enough games that have drafting in it that it no longer is one of those things where I'm like yeah sure I'm having fun but I also just like it better when it's done in these games where I find the drafting more interesting in these games ultimately the decisions of like yes like how am I gonna access these here as compared to like yeah this will get me that here but this is also just a better thing for the set I have going like yeah it's it's fine but also tons of games do that and I find that I've just enjoyed the other games that have been doing that more or are they even more memorable or whatever the case may be fairness for whatever reason an Innovative leader like I've never been intrigued by the same things that like you and Brayden are being intrigued by like the things you guys are talking about like about like having to make this decision between these two I've just been like yeah I make that same decision and even if I worked on my favor I'm not like I'm just like great like I don't know it's hard
it's hard and I know part of it maybe I was gonna say part of it is the theme but I don't think it is either like I like the theme like I I don't I don't really know like for whatever reason something about the sum of those parts for that game just no longer resonates me it doesn't like it resonates with me doesn't get me excited and we're not playing I'm not having that much fun with it and I'm sure if I really dug into it I could try to figure out what that reason is but for some reason it's just no longer like something that that's fair I I'll say I've cooled on it a little bit like I think I liked it a lot when I first played it I still enjoy it quite a bit but now that a bit of the novelty is worn off like you said with the coin upgrading and the even just the way that you acquire the heroes like I still think it's a great game I still enjoy it quite a bit I think and I do think the thing of Lear expansion makes things a little more interesting without complicating the rules by giving you you know when you win the bid you can either pick the first one from the tavern where you can pick one of those items or people from the like a mercenary from the other spot so yeah there's some interesting stuff there but um yeah that's totally fair all right that's mine yeah okay uh all right my next one up here is a game called Seasons I've only ever played it on board game Marine I've only played the digital version but this is a game I tried for the first time maybe I don't know three years ago or so and I remember when I tried it and it's the only game I played by this designer I think uh Regis bonase he's also done a game called Lords of zidit which is also on board game arena that also sounds really interesting and I've started to realize that this guy okay before I get into the game I it strikes me as this guy is really really amazing ideas but
it feels like when he designs a game the development side whichever company is publishing or whatever it seems to have let him down in terms of at least that's what it applies with Seasons because it sounds like such an interesting game I really wanted to love this game and the first time I played it I did I remember thinking I might end up buying this game one day this could be a game and it has the feel of a game where um because it's so based on this intricate deck of very like unique cards it has that feel of games like you know race for the Galaxy res Arcana where you want to explore in all these different card combinations you feel like I could play this game so many times just to see everything you can do with these yeah um the basic way the game it works in I think three or four rounds and you're basically drafting cards at the start of the game you basically do a draft with this big deck of cards and there's cards that help just you but then there's cards that also can play off of your opponents once you've done the draft you have to choose I think you get nine cards and you choose three of those cards go in the first era three go in the second era and three go in the third era so you start the first arrow with only those first three cards so you want to put the better early game cards in there and then as the game goes on you get to like pick up your second Era cards and pick up your third Era cards so the draft and putting cards into the era is already like a super important early game decision where like that's gonna determine so much of your strategy yeah and even you know I love drafts Agricola drafting before the game resourcana so like this spoke to me so much but after playing every time I played the game I've enjoyed it a little bit less and part of it is I think um you're you're also like drafting dice
that give you these resources that you use to actually you spend resources to play cards and stuff like that but one of the main ways you get points is as the seasons change there's this little dial that kind of goes around and the different resources are worth like you can convert resources into just points okay and throughout the game if they fluctuate like one round yellow might only be worth one point but the next round it might be worth three points so you're waiting for the seasons to be in the most profitable you know you're you're trading in your your resources for points when they're in the most profitable season kind of thing while also taking advantage of when you're playing cards and on your turn you're either playing card or using something in play already so it's got kind of this Tableau building thing it's like even describing it now I'm like is the game better than I am I think like that but part of it is that some of the cards uh just aren't particularly interesting um and and because so many of the points come from that conversion of resources into points the cards ended up feeling good like they get a bit lost in the shuffle for me right it felt like even when I was doing better and better playing cards I was losing to people because of the efficiency of just converting this into that and that was the least interesting point of the game to me is just like okay I'm just going to convert this into points when it is most valuable and then whenever I can I'll also play cards so it seemed like there was a lot of potential there and it again when I played it I remember thinking like oh man Dylan would love this game too like card game all these unique cards there's a draft like it just sounded totally up our alley but I'm now at a point where like I don't even have the desire to play it on DGA anymore I showed it to a friend recently to see like maybe maybe this will Kindle
my you know interest in the game or whatever and he was like yeah it was fine and I was like no you're right it is just fine and it's just it's a shame I feel like I want to like the game a lot more than I do yeah I mean I've heard so much about it and I've heard it like it was I'm pretty sure on BGA it was like one of the more popular Ones been played for a while yeah never looked into it more than that never played it myself and I I remember you telling me you played it and now I feel like I have less incentive to even go to try it out and like again it's not like I think it's a bad game yeah like I went in originally thinking like this could be like a 9 out of 10 game like after a couple more play and now if I had to rate it it's probably like around a six or seven it was in the sense that like yeah it's fine I would happily like if someone wants to play it I would never turn down a game of it but yeah I definitely won't buy a copy and I'm never gonna be the one pushing to play it again even on board game so got it yeah that is seasons all right mine this one might be the one I get the most Flack for I would assume on my list uh because my next one is Dominion um so yeah so Dominion is an interesting one because I would still I want to start this by saying if someone's like had dominion and said we're gonna play dominion and like I don't I don't think I'll be disappointed to play it unless it was just the base game again because I play them a lot because there's a special expansion I think I would still play it again for me the biggest thing with Dominion is that there I've just played so many deck builders I've played deck building board games I've I mean we've played other card games that they're you know deck building whether it's like Marvel Champions and Magic Gathering and all that kind of stuff that for me just the pure pure deck
building with like yeah for sure there's a theme but it's more just like everyone's doing their own thing and being efficient whatever and like you're watching everyone's doing their turns and stuff like I'm just so past that now that I I think that I've played so many other deck builders that like I need something else going on for me to be excited to sit down and like actively play that game and it's not that doesn't always happen to me in board games like it's not just like oh I get tired of a mechanic now I just want there to be more added on right but with deck building specifically because there's been so many cool and interesting ways of integrating stuff whether it be like you know integrating it with a board with with Clank or or like and I'm gonna struggle now to come up with other examples we've played so many deck building games that it just it's we've played the hunger which I haven't played yet right in the Hunger as well I just find that like I'm less excited and I've called a lot on just going in just doing the pure deck building with like the more bland theme and just you know I'm doing my own thing you're doing your own thing and we're not integrating or interacting but more beyond that besides what we're buying and stuff and who's buying like who goes for the the Estates and everything first provinces um beyond that like I'm just like there's not enough going on with all the players that it's just not as exciting to me anymore okay so I still like the game I just would I would definitely never buy it any again to have my collection and if like I said if I went to someone's place and they were like I want to play Dominion they were just gonna take out just the base game I would play it there would be a part of me that's like any chance you want to play something else you know what I mean but if someone at the same time someone like was gonna interest me it's like any of the new expansions I probably would be
interested just to see like oh what cards are in there like does that change it up whatever right like maybe there is something in one of the new expansions that shifts it enough that I'm excited to play it again yeah and I was I can't even remember I think you and I only played it together probably like a couple of times which is weird because I played the game so many times yeah I feel like we should have played it together more um maybe you just didn't get like a good Market setup of cards no I played a bunch and I played it on that website or whatever yeah yeah so okay so you've done your dude oh yeah like I for sure played it at least 20 to 30 times like I played it a bunch and it just I got like less it was like you I think after the first like 10 plays it just gradually became less exciting for me and I think it was because of starting to play other deck builders and realizing that like like even games like El Dorado excited me way more than dominion and and that is like way less a good deck building going on and yet I find it way more exciting because there's something else well and it's something tangible you're like I'm playing my cards because my goal is to get there rather than just like my goal is to have the most points it's kind of just this nebulous like how am I getting the points I'm buying the point cards and stuff yeah yeah so question or actually two-part question first off do you feel similarly about other deck builders like that that are like just deck building like hero Realms Star Realms that kind of thing like are you kind of honestly those as well honestly like hero Realms is one that because I haven't played it a lot like sorry like nowhere near as much as a minion I could see myself going back and playing it again and being a little bit
more excited but I did a quick quick setup small box game it's not quite the same but I did play Hero Realms I can't remember who it was with I did play it relatively recently in the last couple months and I remember leaving that going you know what this isn't hidden the same way as it did because when you I bought it because I played your copy I know it being like oh this is so good I loved it when I first played it too and I've also cooled a bit about hero it's just I think you're right I think in some ways I I if I'm looking for a deck building fix I'm looking for a little bit more out of it because of how many are out there because of my history of like I do I do deck building for fun with Marvel Champions like like I know that's not as a game but like I'm Deadpool in there we use the deck build Magic the Gathering a bunch of games we play have deck but it's going to be a mechanic that comes up in a lot of games we play going forward that I think I'm looking for a little bit more out of it than just the very pure I'm doing my own thing you're doing yours how efficient can you get points like I think I'm wanting a little bit more out of it and that's just me but yeah um what was the other thing I want to ask you something else about this was oh if let's say like Reiner Canadian or uve Rosenberg like was designing a deck building game or is there anything basically if someone is there anything out there that could make you be interested in a pure deck building game again I would try them all right excited about I think like yeah if you need the extra the board or some other thing that the deck building is for me to be excited about pure deck builder I would have to like have be really invested in the theme like the thing about it really excites me or the artwork or whatever or I have a designer attached to it that I'm like okay but I am interested in kinesia's spin on that yeah I was gonna say so if reinder kinesia does a Marvel deck building game You'll Play it but otherwise if Reiner
needs to just disappear deck the only game I'm in like fair enough to give it the it's time of day and see if it's good right cool yeah all right Dominion fair enough I'm gonna make you play again someday and make you change your mind okay number three on my list is oh finally I have an actual box which is I took this the next three year old games I took off Dylan's shelf by the way these people games cooling on all sorts of games you own oh no I know one of them is because I looked and it's gone I wonder if that's what you're grabbing yeah okay it is Teo tiwakan city of gods so this is co-designed by uh or no it's just Danielle Tashi we were talking about in that video today okay not cool designs right right yeah um so this is a game solo to or one to four players uh this is the next one kind of in the line after zulkin which you also have and you also uh introduce me to so this game it's a this is a conflicting pick for me because I do still think it's a pretty solid game and I would still happily play it like multiple times I would still enjoy it quite a bit but I think when I compare my first impression that I had this game I remember when you bought this game and we went over to your place I remember like we learned it together we were kind of going through the rule you had read the rules I remember we dove into this and I like I think part of it was the table presence part of it was I had never played I don't think when I first played this I don't think I'd ever played a game that had I don't know if this really counts as an official rondelle but like a board that you're going around in circles and the timing
of the actions and putting multiple workers I also hadn't played a whole lot of or maybe this was this might even been the first dice placement like I think I played this before Voyages of Marco Polo yeah so there were a lot of things when I played this game I was like well I've never seen this before and there's the track with the Valley of the dead and you're building up the pyramid and all this like visually the theme everything like I was so captured by this game uh and we played it we really really had a really good first impression yeah that playing as two players then we played it as a three-player game um and I play it back to back that time maybe I think maybe we did maybe we played twice back to back with us then we played a three-player game game like a couple weeks later I still really liked it and I you know obviously part of this might have something to do with playing on board game arena but even the first play that I went now that it's on board gaming I went and played it on there again and I was like yeah it's still pretty good but I've played it since another five or six times on there and it's the same thing to talk about these other games where every time I've played it I've enjoyed it a bit less part of it I think is that and I'm gonna compare it a little bit to uh zulkin even though they're very different games in the way that they play but zulkin to me felt like the more I played it the more I saw my options opening up being like whoa I haven't done this yet I haven't done a strategy where I get you know rushed this type of resource to buy that one building that gets you this advantage and then I can go on this spot on like there's spots on those different wheels that turn in zulkin that you don't even get to certain games like it really feels like when you've done a game of zulkin that there's a lot of things you haven't explored yet and in teoti wakan it feels like a lot of the time you see a lot of
what there is to see and I've seen almost every time the winner is the person who like contributes to the most or a lot to the pyramid it feels like if you ignore building the pyramid you just can't win right and the decisions because like the way you get a lot of resources at once is by having all three of your dice like having that third die or fourth die or whatever land on a spot and get like sometimes it just feels like well why would I not go to that spot where all my dice are and get like four stone or whatever like why would I go in this other spot and get like a couple of Coco only so I just feel like the decisions have become less interesting as I play it and I I feel like maybe I was tricked of it by the table presence or something I still like it quite a bit but it feels like it feels like zulkin should be the one that ages worse that has like it kind of has a gimmick in a way right the rotating wheels and yet I'm way more intrigued to revisit that than this even though this doesn't really have the gimmick but it just feels like the novelty wore off of this a lot quicker than zulkin so yeah I will say so good I'm just not like like eager to play it I'm not like before I was like I want my own copy of this game I'll play it any day and now I'm just like that's good I I would say that I've cooled on it as well but not like I still I can tell I I like it more than you still um but the biggest thing for me is that I will always prefer zulkin I think zulkin's a tighter experience and I think it's just more fun like you said there's more options and you can approach a little bit differently and it's tougher game I think to play for sure whereas yeah it also just is it's it's a more complicated setup there's to me it's more complicated rules for less for like there's not enough payoff for
the extra complications and stuff yeah and yeah and you're right like there's things about it like even as you're describing different areas I'm like oh yeah that's fine like I want to go back and play that but at the same time if I think about all that I'm like I'm gonna set up one of these games and I'm gonna play it I would just I own boat I would rather set up zulkin and there's been times where I I'm literally thinking of like I want to introduce one of these games and ultimately I'm like but who am I kid like I want to introduce Logan like this gimmick actually works I want people to experience it I want people to like you know have to have the thing of like when do I pull my my workers off to take the action how long do I leave them on and push my luck that way like it for me the biggest discrepancy or the biggest challenge is this in comparison to zulkin like that's the biggest reason for me like yeah of me cooling on it is just that I don't know when I'm going to suggest this over zulkin and so maybe it's just a problem with having both in my collection kind of thing yeah I think you've nailed it even the fact that they're both on board game arena I have found that's been a thing with me too is like should I go play and like I'd rather play zulkin instead yeah but some people do prefer this is okay yeah I think it comes down to place down like and it's funny because I love dice placements there's so many things working in his favor here I know and when the worker ascends and you can get a fourth word you'll get these different abilities and stuff but it just so many of the turns are move either one two or three spots and then either collect the resources that are there or pay the Coco to go like or or gain some cocoa based on the workers and it just feels like too many of the turns they're just like not exciting enough I don't know yeah no I I think it's a fair picture a lot of things to like about it but I've definitely cool on it quite a bit that is teotihuacan city of Gods Fair all
right my next one you I'm guessing you expected this one on the list but I could be wrong because this one was actually featured in a video I did a long time ago of my top five polynomial games of all time and now it's definitely not in my top five follow domino games and it is not one of my favorite games um and that is New York Zoo oh so yes you're surprised New York zoo I recently called it's no longer my collection I sold it um your zoo is a good game but it is one that like when I first started playing it I I think I even said to you like why it was in my top five polyamony because I said like this is one of my favorite Pokemon games like I love this game and I want to introduce some more um and the more that I played it just like you said the less I I had like fond memories of it and a lot of that just comes down to I love the race aspect of it I love that it's a polyamory game where whoever completes their board first wins because you always have the satisfaction of I fully completed my board and how efficient was I this and it was a very satisfying finish to that game and it often was close so there were the tension built as you went I love that aspect of it the animals being placed in the tiles was so cool a novel at the start but the more that I played that game the more it just felt like this unnecessary fiddly thing that I was doing there was a track there was the tracking from the parts of New York zoo that I liked just a cumbersome way to manage it's like a an administrative task that you don't want to be stuck with yeah and and like the essence of what you're doing with
them is cool but in execution it just felt like the least Fun by a long shot aspect of that game enough so that every time I played I was not looking forward to managing and handling that aspect that I ended up not wanting to play New York zoo and I think that that's really what ended up doing I mean it doesn't help that it has an awful rule book and like yes yes I know the rules but if I haven't come back to it for a while and I'm looking for like one thing navigating that rulebook is just horrible I really hate that rule book um and there is some confusing stuff with the way the animals with this I don't remember what the rules something about where the animal can go back to here but if you had an animal in this one spot you can swap it yeah there are intricacies like that that you have to kind of refer back to and so teaching that game also ends up being a challenges aspect like it's a step up for a polyamal game yeah maybe not it doesn't feel that like the satin the extra satisfaction of having this I still I wouldn't not I would not say it's a bad game like I still think it's a good game and I still do enjoy it it was just like there was no chance in a genre as saturated as polyaminos that I was ever going to suggest it again because and the comparison I made recently in another video was like I recently started playing Baron Park again and realizing how much I forgot I enjoyed Baron Park and how much more I enjoyed bearing Park compared to your zoo now yeah it was just a big eye-opener in that like yeah you know what in my polynomial games I don't necessarily want something as fiddly and complex as what's going on and it's not super complex but like what's going on with the animals it's not what I want out of a polynomial game because for me in my collection if I'm playing a polyamino game it is usually I want a relaxing experience I want a mellow
teach or I'm straight up introducing a game to like you know a first date or a a person who doesn't play games very often or whatever and I just want it to be like this like fun like you know easily understood experience and New York zoo is not fitting pretty much any of those boxes yeah that's fair so it has an incredible table presence oh yeah meeples it's a really really nice production but um yeah and honestly one of the the tiles the actual polynomial tiles one of the most satisfying like feels I don't know what it is I don't know how they built them but they are like solid Pollyanna tiles that feel really good as you place them together definitely so it does have some great aspects to it but for me it just yeah but one issue all the tiles being different shades of green like five different shades of green oh man slightly darker green right medium green slightly medium Darkness okay come on yeah they really stretch and green in there but uh yeah so anyways that's New York Zoo um it's one of the ones that cooled on the most and that's why I did get rid of it but I would still be open to planning in the future and I do still think it's a solid experience it's just not for me anymore cool yeah I I especially didn't enjoy when I played it as a four player game I think it took like an hour and a half and for that like relatively not complex polyamino game I think hour and a half is too long especially when you're like 75 of the time is downtime watching other players but yeah good pick New York Zoo all right next on my list here is this another one of mine uh yes but I haven't noticed you took off my show well I have the app I just don't have the physical version okay that is I didn't realize you called on
this okay here we go okay buckle up but here's the thing that so when we did our top 50 of all time last year this was I think number 49 I think it just barely made the list and I remember you even asked me at the time in the video like wait so this is your favorite Roland right and at the time it was it was ahead of Welcome two I would say it was probably my number two at the time yeah since we did that top 50 and we've I've talked about this game in other videos as well I've gone back to try and play it a couple times and um my opinion really has changed the game but it and you know it's not the game's fault it's basically my own fault for playing playing this game on the app during the pandemic at this like April 2020 you know I was like off work at home whatever I remember downloading the app I played so much of this game and not only that but when it's a game like this that's a rolling right that's a kind of like beat your own high score that has a good solo mode once I started getting really high scores even playing solo I felt like there was points where I had less incentive to go back because once you get a certain score it's it's really hard to get up there again kind of thing right and then you keep playing and playing and playing and if you play 10 20 times in a row and you're getting nowhere near that high score you really think you're going to be able to beat that high score are you just playing for the fun now kind of thing and that's really why I've cooled on it is that I don't think I'm going to be able to get near my high score anytime uh soon again and I've enjoyed this playing this most solo on the app and since then in the last few years so I've probably played this a couple times with the physical version and whenever I'm playing with other people whether I win lose whatever I just find I'm not invested in like
whether I'm beating the other players or not all I'm caring about is like my own score even if I yeah even if I won a game if my if the score that I won with is like 150 points lower than what my high score was I'm like I feel like I played poorly I'm like I can do better this I've scored well over this many many times before so yeah I just feel like I don't have much draw to go back to its solo because I'm probably not gonna reach the high score and again part of it is that I've played this like well over 100 times now right so yeah it's just a matter of I've played it to death kind of thing um but I'm still like you know I haven't cooled on the other ones in the series as much just because there's more for me to explore in those whereas this one I've just I've played it so much it's it's it's just that games that you know use a high score as one of their main motivating factors to come back or like is like you know an aspect of it that is supposed to be like largely why you're playing it or just tough to have a longevity because eventually you figure out the game and even if you have it's been a while since you've had that high score if you're a member you hit this like one of the highest achievable scores like where is your incentive to come back and like if you're not even ever getting achiever again right it's interesting that you say that when you play with other people they are still focused on your high score because me just in general across board games across video games everything I like rarely rarely ever encounter a game where I care about my high score and I where I rank I've just never quite had that mentality with like with even with arcade games and everything like I can think of like one time when I got really into like newest switch version Mario Tennis where I was like trying to climb like the Canadian rankings and I think I
was like high but like it's rare that that happens to me with a game and so when I play with actual people around the table that's when it's the most refreshing and engaging for me because I really don't care about how good my score is I'm just doing it in comparison to like the people around the table right and I and I I don't even remember like what score I'm trying to achieve my own and I have played the Apple a lot too but first for some reason there's that differentiation between like our way we'll approach a high score but yeah I I totally get like I've cooled on a little bit too for me what's gonna always keep it at like a certain level is that it's always just such an easy game to introduce to people who don't play games very often and I usually do enjoy playing with them for the first time and seeing them like you know get a good role whatever so I feel like there's a there's a you know people say there's a ceiling or something there's a floor on how much I can cool because it'll always it'll always land that way in my collection but I can understand like if you play it that much you've hit the side score like what what's drawing you back why yeah and that's if I hadn't played it so much solo because this is the only game I can think or this and the other um clever game where like a high score is something that I remember and I'm targeting to beat kind of thing yeah um and I think part of it too is that I don't like playing these games with more than two players I think there's way too much the last couple times I played this with four players I think it took almost an hour and like so much of it was just sitting watching other people take their turns right that's right and to play it as a two-player game which thinks is the best count anyone I'm playing with has played this like nowhere near the amount that I have so I always feel bad playing this as a two-player game with someone
when I have like 150 games so it just sits in a weird spot I think it's an excellent game but I've just I've just played it to death yes has not felt so clever all right my last one which is probably I put it here because I'm pretty sure it's the biggest discrepancy and I will even though even though knit of elyria's only when I like probably don't like I still like this game but I like it a lot less than when I first uh talked about it so I talked about this game in a comparison video early on and I I said I ranked a game both games very very close I think there's a huge gap now between them which is why I'm putting it uh here and that is castles of Tuscany so a lot of why this is on this list in this spot is because of how much I have played Castle burgundy since and like rekindled my I already I always loved it but like even rekindled in that fire even more is that it's hard for me to go back to Castle Tuscany now and not just feel like why am I not playing burgundy it it is a streamlined version in many ways of burgundy it does some cool stuff with the scoring that is really present in burgundy it's just it's represented a different way with this wheel here um where like you want to try to get a lot of points early on in the game and benefit from it it does a lot of cool stuff and and it is cool to have this more like you know streamlined different approach to the burgundy formula but for me because I can play a game of burgundy now pretty quickly especially at two players and especially if you're playing on BGA
all the reasons I would have originally said to go to Tuscany will still apply if maybe you haven't played burgundy or you just like consistently just want a streamlined approach but I just think that in every single facet even though this is still good burgundy is better and so it's really hard as I see that Gap um you know widening for me to have incentive to ever want to come back and play it so I've cooled out of necessity just because of how much I love burgundy like in many ways I feel like it would be the same thing for you if like if if and I'm guessing here because and because we haven't played it but like you could play caverna and you could like it but if you own both in your collection and with how much you love Agricola would you feel like when you're playing caperna you're just like really this is just making me feel like I want to go play bricklay you know what I mean like it's less because this game is bad and more just because I happen to be someone who just is falling more and more in love with burgundy the more I play they're like the discrepancy is wide yeah or you play your preferred game I thought I think I said in that comparison video like I will always own both because it's nice to have the option to be like oh we want to play a shorter experience like or a streamlined I'll play Tuscany I feel like now I feel like I'm I'm close to just getting rid of testing because I don't even want to have the option where someone's like well let's just play Dusky instead because I'm like no no burgundy is better let's play burgundy oh never mind for some reason I thought you were had gotten rid of this already or we're going to get rid of it no I think just put it in a video I haven't it I'm getting close to to getting rid of it I think I considered it for a calling video I was like maybe I'm not ready to get rid of it okay but I think I'm
getting closer just because I don't know when I'm gonna suggest I I know you have different you've only played this last but I know you've had different experiences with it I've only played it once I don't know like it more than me oh probably yeah yes but but I just like yeah it's tough for me like it's it's it's a different version of one of my favorite games and like it was neat and novel to see one of my favorite games done in a new light and and I enjoyed it but yeah like why would I go back to it now I just want to play burgundy yeah I did like the way that the the points you can accumulate the the points that kind of scale over from round to round and it just is interesting the fact that it uses cards primarily rather than dice so the way that it handles Randomness is like it's still there's Randomness but you're drawing from something whereas a die you can roll the same value over and over so I think this one gives you a little more flexibility in that regard like yeah I think there's like wild stuff and you can pick your different little abilities and stuff so there's cool stuff like honestly I want to play it again even just talking about it now I'm like uh I remember being impressed by it like I didn't think I was gonna enjoy it much when we played it I thought it was a pretty good game yeah it's still a good game it just the biggest turning point if you're wondering was when we did when the the tournament for Castle burgundy was run in our Discord yeah playing that many games of burgundy with that many different play styles with people who are playing it really well made me appreciate burgundy even more than I already did just from seeing how much flexibility there was and how much differentiation there was in boards and and how now if I get a board I approach the game very differently just knowing which board I'm saying like it's really because I plan what your opponents are doing stuff yeah burgundy is just a great game wait wait until you see how
it somehow climbed from its very high spot on my top 50 this year someone's gonna get a higher spot yeah that is nice pick I didn't see that one coming but yeah your reasoning all makes sense all right so last on my list is one that I think you're going to be disappointed to see here I don't know what is it seven wonders well to be fair I never really thought you were like in love with it from the start or anything I thought you enjoyed it and here's it's weird I've the very first time I played it um with you I think I just thought it was like okay yeah and then I didn't play it again for a long time and then I don't know how much time had gone by I played it again this is obviously the set the two player version of Seven Wonders and Seven Wonders the original the seven player game was like one of my favorite and one of my very first games that got me into the hobby so um this I think maybe that was why I like maybe put up a shield against this the first time he showed me I was like oh no it's not as good as the original right a couple years went by played it again and there was a point where I like truly loved this game when you showed it to me and then I was like oh wait a second it's on board game arena maybe I'll go play it on there I think I got in like 20 or 30 games in like this matter of two three days I think I did the same thing yeah and I remember I supposed to remember like messaging you too and saying like man Seven Wonders duel is like a lot better than I remember like it's a really good game yeah and then I don't know what happened it was like up those 20 25 30 plays or so I was like my enjoyment was increasing and then all all of a sudden I just there was just one day where I noticed like hey I haven't played Seven Wonders duel in a while I just like
there wasn't a conscious decision like I'm gonna stop playing it on there I just stopped having the desire to like queue up games and then I kind of forced myself to get back into I tried playing a couple times then like you said we had the tournament yep and the Discord for Seven Wonders duel and that was where it almost hit me that like even on board game arena where it's doing the calculations for me and all that the more I played the game the less and it's probably a common theme with a lot of the games that I talked about here in other videos before but it felt like the decisions became more obvious the longer the game goes on right and because because of the alternate win conditions and stuff like it's really interesting that you can win with science and win with military and do all these things but a lot of the time when you go for that route I found that there gets a point in the game where you're not gonna win by points and now you're like if you're already committed to military it's like you either have to go for that military win otherwise you just have to accept that you're gonna lose because there's no way you're gonna make up the points yeah and same with science it's like I have five symbols or whatever like why would I do anything other than going for the sixth symbol to get the science so sometimes it feels like at a certain point in this first second age your path is almost like laid out for you and it's like well now that I have all these blue cards that are going to build into other blue cards well of course I'm going to take the free blue cards and you know so it feels like any path you go down it's kind of pushing you further down that path and then I thought about playing the physical version and the idea of doing the calculations of all the cards in the pyramid and setting up the pyramid I just thought if I already have
cooled on it this much on board game arena I don't know if I'm going to want to play the physical version or like all gonna be all that excited to play something that has that much setup and it's just that two-player only games are very crowded field yeah and when we first when I was like at my peak of enjoyment with this game I remember thinking at one point like this is one of my favorite two-player games right now and now that I think about it if I was gonna pick like my top 10 two player only games like this wouldn't make the top ten I don't even know if it'd make the top 15 like that's why I just keep thinking of so many other games that I enjoy more than it and it's it's weird to me that I've it's had this much of a fall from me thinking like this is one of the best two-player games I've played to now like there are so many more two-player games I would rather play over it and the fact that I enjoy the BGA version so much more because of how everything's automated so yeah like it's funny because like for me I also played it like you know 20 30 40 times during the pandemic it felt like I'm just constantly queuing up games and then the tournament and and it's kind of the same thing as burgundy like it made me appreciate it more as I got into a comfortable area of being like I can be mean in this game now because I know how to be mean I know how to block someone yeah I know which wonders to take and I know when to do my you know double turn and stuff like doing all that was super fun and even though I hear what you're saying about like you know sometimes the the which Victory you're going for being obvious there were times where I'm essentially feigning going for one just to make the opponent feel they have to now jump in and prevent me so they start taking some science and that ends up getting me opportunities to be like now I can grab some blues and so I can use
that as almost just the way like to put pressure to pull them away to then go back over here which pulls them over there and like you want to have a one it's just felt fun and and I've got a lot of enjoyment of watching someone have to be like oh then now he's going now he's going for military and I need to push that oh now he's going for science I need to do this like there was just enough going on that like I feel like I know enough about how it plays that when I get in I have enough of a strategy that it's just really fun for me to try to execute that right and when I lose it it feels like you know they outplayed me which was I don't know for me it is I've also hit a ground level on it where I don't think that even if I Tire because I played it a lot it's not because I'm for me it's not because I'm cooling on it just like I've played too much of this I need to go gravitate something else now there's a there's a floor in how where my enjoyment's gonna stop because I just really really enjoy it that's fair but but I hear what you're saying like it's one of those games where I can tell as I'm playing is not for everyone even the aspect of sometimes I've had games decided on luck where like you you draw a card and what happens to flip over is like the three Shields and that wins in the game or something like that right that's frustrating at times but regardless of those things I just still really enjoy it and then having options to like play expansions to shake things up yeah well and that's what I was gonna say is I think I I've tried Pantheon and Agora only once each and I and I enjoyed what they both did I can't remember which I liked more if I think it's better than the base game or whatever yeah so maybe that's part of you enjoying it more than like you've definitely played the expansions more than me so maybe that's what I need to kind of breed some new life into this and get back to playing a little bit but it does kill me a little bit but that's okay I know and I felt bad because but like when I thought about it truly it's only because of how high my opinion was
of it before it's not like I think it's a bad game I think it's still a very solid game and I would you know there's not a lot of um like I wouldn't recommend it above tons of other two-player games necessarily but I know a lot of people who would really like this game and I think it is fairly well designed but just something about it doesn't do it for me anymore all right really cool I guess I can accept it I know it's uh I think last time we did our two player games it was your number one two player game right yeah I mean my top 50 I think it's number five or six last time here I am saying trash you're just doing this in retaliation for my race the galaxies well no any race to the Galaxy in a great Club wouldn't make it anyway because he never had respect for those games in the first place wow and with that shots fired moments those are the games we've cooled on uh this is a really interesting topic so we would love to hear in the comments like let us know which games you started off loving and now you don't like you start off loving it and you only like a little bit now like just tell us what games you've cooled on I think that's an interesting topic yeah and tell us why yeah exactly and I think we are going to end the future do the reverse um where we talk with the games that we started off not liking or not feeling you know being lukewarma and then all of a sudden it did grow over yeah because I think that's even more interesting in some ways because it takes a very specific situation to like not enjoy a game and then also be like now I do yeah and that made up your mind and then have to be open-minded you again say like hey actually maybe now that I play it that way and I already know which game's gonna be number one on my list for that and you you might notice I'm not going to say it but start guessing now which game is going to be the number one because I don't think it's Gonna Change like I've known which game is like like etched into that list as soon as as soon as you said it so start start ruminating start trying to figure out again but
anyways thank you so much for watching and for uh joining us in this video we will see you next foreign