Skip to main content
Loading video...

Game Exceptions to Mechanisms We Usually Don’t Seek

Transcript 21:28

Hey, I'm Jamie from Stonemire Games and today I'm going to talk about exceptions to games that we and I'll explain who we is in a second that we typically don't seek out based on mechanisms. Today I'll do mechanisms first. Uh and yet these games are exceptions to those preferences.

We are still my ambassadors. So people who and including me, people who follow closely follow and support somewhere games and reply reply to a survey that I send out once a month and answer questions like what game what mechanism do you normally not seek out and yet there is a game that has that mechanism that you really enjoy. Um so I send out a survey like that. I also added my own responses to it. And originally I I've done a video I did a video like this years ago. I said uh it's like 13 glorious exceptions to my gaming preferences. um and I haven't explored it in a while. And I sent out the survey to ambassadors and I realized as I was going through the responses that there that some patterns were emerging that the games that many of the games that are exceptions to uh preferences about mechanisms, genres, and themes, those are the three categories I'll cover over three videos. Um, many of the answers were games that approached those mechanisms, genres, or themes with a twist, with something a little bit different than what a lot of other games in those using those mechanisms, genres, and themes have done that somehow make them more appealing to people who don't normally like those mechanisms, genres, and themes. And so, I actually think this is a really important consideration for game design. I I hadn't thought about it from this lens before, but um but I'm going to look at it through that lens today and through the other through the other videos in this series. What do they do? What do these games to do to break the mold of other games that use these mechanisms? And at least today,

we'll talk about mechanisms. So, I'm going to end up highlighting 10 games, but I will briefly mention a number of games throughout this list. And again, these are many of these are categories that the ambassadors picked. Some of these are mechanisms that I love and I don't need an exception to these rules. I'm actually drawn to many of these mechanisms. So anyway, with that introduction out of the way, let's start with area majority. And the picks from ambassadors for this category were Barrage, Blue Lagoon, and Star Wars Rebellion. It's been so long since I played Star Wars Rebellion that I can't quite remember what area majority refers to in this game, but at least one or two ambassadors picked Star Wars Rebellion for this category. Not going to go too deep in the area majority. I don't have much to say about that one, but I do have a lot to say about the next category, which is the mechanism of auctions.

And so the picks from ambassadors for this category and for me were QE, RAW, Isle of Sky, Power Grid, Scoville, and High Society. All of these games, I think, do something that many other auction games do not do. They they have a twist. They have they break the mold in some way. And the one that I wanted to highlight is QE because I think QE breaks the mold in a really interesting way. QE is an auction game where the twist is that every player can bid anything they want. They can write down any number and uh you you don't have full information at the table unless you're the auctioneer. If you're the auctioneer, you get to see what everyone has written down. All other players only get to see the winning bid. Um, and so there's this disparity information in information and just the flexibility in an auction game to bid anything. The way that the game reigns in this twist is that at the end of the game, the player who spent the most, the player who uh spent the most by by you spend money by actually winning the auction. So if you won a lot of auctions, worked on the set collection in a great way, but you spent more than any other player on those winning bids, you are not allowed to win. you are in ineligible for the victory. So that is a way to rein players in while still giving them the huge flexibility of this twist of being able to bid any amount. So I could probably do one of these for every game in the auction category, but I'm just going to focus on QE. That's the twist that QE offers that makes it more appealing to people who or at least some people who don't typically enjoy auction

games. Uh the next category is combat. Now, combat I I I don't know if combat is itself a mechanism, but um and I'll I'll approach it with uh the genre video as well um like combat games, but I did want to highlight one game here. There's one game picked by Ambassadors, and that is Andromeda's Edge. Uh the the predecessor, not the predecessor, the successor to Dwellings of Elder Veil. I have played Dwellings of Elder Elder. have not played um Andromeda's Edge, but I believe that they have a similar combat mechanism. I'm sure it's slightly different between the two games, but I wanted to highlight this one because one of the things I remember about Dwellings of Elder Veil, um and I really should just add it to the list, maybe I should have highlighted it here instead, is that losing combat isn't actually all that terrible. Um because when you lose combat, when you when you you can actually have some special powers in the game where you uh actually gain things when you lose combat. So you can build up those powers to to let you lose combat. Uh so I I I think this is really interesting. It actually ties into the game Blood Rage a little bit too that there are cards where it's actually better for you to lose combat than than to win. So I think that that little twist is really interesting. Hopefully I'm not remember. I've only played dwellings like twice, so hopefully I'm not misremembering that and misrepresenting it. But um this was the ambassador pick for for combat, the combat mechanism.

The next category I have is deck building. So deck building is a mechanism that I love, but I understand that some people aren't drawn to it. In fact, quite a few people said they typically aren't drawn to deck building, but there are exceptions to that. And the exceptions presented by ambassadors were Paperback, Century, Fort Clank, Legacy, and Valley of the Kings. Century, I don't know if I would quite call that deck building because there's no shuffling involved, but it is a close to it. It's like hand management, hand building. Um, but paperback is the example I wanted to feature today because I think paperback does something that many deck building games don't do. In many deck building games, there's the a very familiar flow where you are drawing five cards at the end of your turn. You're playing as many of those cards as possible and then you're discarding any extras and you rinse and repeat every turn. And games do this in wonderful ways, including Clank. I think Clank is one of my favorites because you are using those cards to move a mele around a dungeon and do cool things with that mele. But one of the very rare things that I think very few deck builders do, and what Paperback does, is that it actually lets you build something with that hand that you've drawn. In this case, you're building a word. you're building the word uh or well not any not any specific word uh but this player has built the word sheriff uh which seems quite impressive but I love that idea that you have this limited hand of cards and you're actually building something with that hand of cards rather than just playing as many as possible. I think that's unique. I think that's special. I think it makes paperback stand out as an exception for players who don't normally

like uh deck building. The next category, we have a few categories here. won't show any specific examples on the screen, but we have the category of dexterity and uh ambassadors highlighted the game's junk art and the fuzzies. I haven't played the fuzzies. I'm curious about that. Drafting. Players who don't typically like drafting apparently are drawn to Agricola. It's a wonderful world and blood rage. And with all these categories, even though I'm not going into much detail about these games, I think uh if if you don't like drafting games, I think this is a good chance to explore what these other games are. So, you could say, "Okay, I don't normally enjoy drafting, but Jamie just mentioned a gripple. That's a wonderful world. Blood Rage. Maybe I'll check those out." And as a designer, you might think about what makes those games work for someone who doesn't normally enjoy drafting. Uh the next category is hidden movement. I actually generally don't like hidden movement. I personally love the game Scotland Yard. I'm gonna add that to the list here uh because of its simplicity.

It does very little to get in the way of players just doing the the classic thing that Hidden Movement does and it is one of the classic games. But the ambassador picks were Letters from White Chapel and Escape from Aliens in Outer Space. We now at the category of Hidden Rolls and the picks here were Battlestar Galactica, Unfathomable, Time Bomb, and Molly House. And the game I wanted to feature here is Battlestar Galactica, which has been uh reborn as Unfathomable, but I play Battlestar Galactica more than Unfathomable. And the reason I think this is an exception, or one of the reasons I think this is an exception, two reasons actually. One is the twist that some players or one player, depends on the player count, may be a Sylon, a bad guy, a someone with a a hidden role, but they won't know it until midway through the game. There are a few hidden role games that do this.

Battlestar, I think, is maybe the first one that did it, where you don't know that you're a bad guy until midway through the game. So, I think that is a wonderful twist to a game like this. The other thing is uh that and there are a few hidden role games that do this, especially with a hidden trader. But the the way the skill test system in this game works where all players are cooperatively but secretly contributing cards to a shared pool. Um, players don't really know. A player, a bad player cannot completely mess up a skill check by themselves. It is oftent times multiple players who are contributing cards that they just may not may not have. And it's done in secret, so you really don't know who made a skill check skill check fail. I think that really helps a hidden role game where the hidden role player can't just completely fail something for all players in the game. I think that works really well in Balastar Galactica. along with that idea that you may not know that you're a Sylon until midway through the game.

So that is hidden rules as a category. Next up, we have memory. The memory mechanism in games. Uh this is something that I I think many gamers hear that there's a memory mechanism mechanism in the game and think, nope, that's that's just not for me. But I think there are exceptions to this. And the exceptions presented by ambassadors were Trip Lock, that's not a hat, Wilmont's Warehouse, Nana or Trio, two different names for the same game, Wandering Towers, and Memor. I have not played Trip Lock or Memor, but the other four I really enjoy those games. The one I'm going to highlight is uh is Wilmont's Warehouse because it's kind of a magic trick of a game. It's a fully cooperative memory game where you uh you were trying to remember where cards where all these they're essentially tiles, but they're cards where all of actually no maybe they are tiles in this game where all these tiles that you're placing on the board are at the end of the game. So you on your turn you are placing one of these tiles. See if I can see a player actually placing a tile. Um you're you're placing one of these tiles somewhere on the board. Uh each tile has this wacky art on it and uh you tell a story of what that thing is in relation to the other things and then um and then you flip it over to the the to the other side. So you you lose what it was, but you um you you you try to remember it. So you're you're building this story through images and

through things that you're saying to all the other players throughout the game. And then at the end of the game, you have to fully complete this um this memory game. However many cards tiles are out there, you have to try to remember all of them with all the other players. And you would think that you wouldn't be able to remember like 25 different tiles, however many it is. But because of the story and the memorable images on the cards or the tiles, you're actually able to do it. So, I think it's a a pretty special exception to this category where you're actually told to remember a lot of stuff, but because you're cooperating with other players and you're able to tell this story, um, it actually somehow works. So, that's Wilmont's Warehouse as my pick for the memory mechanism. Next up, we have Pick Up and Deliver. And I must say, this is a mechanism that just does not excite me as a as a gamer. I it is it's just not exciting to me to play pickup and deliver. But there are exceptions to it. Ambassadors picked Firefly and Explorers of the North Sea.

Neither of which I've played. I have Firefly on the shelf. It's been there for a while, but I haven't actually played it. And Explorers of the North Sea, I need to play it. I've heard I've heard the new version is excellent, but I also have not played that one. Player elimination. This is another one where I hear this and I think I'm why would I want to be eliminated in the game? Why would I choose to play a game and then get eliminated by it? And yet, there are games that do elimination in really interesting ways that actually make the game really exciting. Ambassador picks were Red Seven, Thunder Road Vendetta, Nemesis, Skull, Leaders of Euphoria, and Werewolf. I actually added Leaders of Euphoria to this list because I think it's worth highlighting um as a game here. I'll show you what Leaders of Euphoria works. So, this is a game that was made in collaboration with Stillmire Games, but it was designed and created by a different company. Um, and I actually think it does something really cool with player elimination that uh that makes it work really well. And that is that when you in this game you start off on one of three factions. I believe it's three. It's either Euphorians, the Subterrans, or the Icarites. Maybe it's just two of them, but I believe it's all three. And uh if you are eliminated, instead of truly being eliminated from the game, you are banished to a new faction that doesn't exist yet until someone is banished to it, the Wastelander faction. You're banished to that faction. And so you actually are part of a new team um instead of your original team if you are banished to

that faction. I think that's so clever. And it's a little bit like Nemesis where if you die in Nemesis, you actually take over the aliens on the ship. Um, but a new I I I really like how in this game, even with an elimination, you then have a still have a chance to win under a new team that you're forming and you're actually trying to probably get more players eliminated so they could join your team and you're and the Wastelanders can become more powerful. It is an ingenious way, I think, to have a uh have elimination in a uh in a game. And this is also a hidden role game. So, it ties to that category as well. That is leaders of euphoria in the um in the elimination mechanism category. Next up we have polyominos. I actually love polyominos as a mechanism in the game. Polyomino tiles like tetris shaped tiles and but and what but one ambassador was not a fan but they said that my city really worked for them. Um, programming. Programming is another mechanism that typically doesn't excite me just because while I like to think ahead about my turns in games, I don't like to be rigidly um, restricted or limited to what I've planned out to do.

I like to have a little bit of flexibility when I actually get to it. But, um, there are two exceptions to this. Colt Express and Mech versus Minions. and mech versus minions. While it is a pretty hard to find game right now, I think it is worth mentioning because this is a programming game uh where that is fully cooperative. And so the you you are pro each player is programming their own thing and and that is how the game addresses a lot of issues with cooperative games and that you have fully full control over your tableau. it's too much information for other players to help out with and there's no alpha player who can control all the things that you're doing because they're your cards and uh and and you program them. So, you actually don't have a lot of control once you are actually activating that programming. But the the reason I think it works so well is that it is cooperative and so when things go wrong, they go wrong in a memorable way for all players, not just for you as would be the case if this were a competitive game. And so I think uh having programming in a cooperative game is really really clever and uh that is what Max versus Minions does as an exception for this this gaming preference.

The next category is pusher luck. I love pusher luck but one of our ambassadors isn't a fan and they picked Mlem as a game that they enjoy despite the push your luck mechanism. I happen to love Mlem and so I thought it was a good highlight here. The reason why I think MLM is a good exception to those who don't normally enjoy push your luck is that you are pushing your luck in a way that impacts multiple players. So, not only are you pushing your own luck, but you're also pushing the luck for for all players who are on the ship each round. Uh, in MM all players decide one of their cats, their space astronaut cats to put on the ship. One player is the leader of that ship and they are the one who has the choice to keep rolling or not keep rolling. But the other player still have a choice. So, not only is the leader pushing the luck, their luck in terms of how often they're going to keep rolling, um, but the other players, including kind of the leader, their choice is when do they jump off the ship? Do they jump off the ship onto a moon, onto a planet? Do they wait till they get to get to to deep space? So, all players are pushing their luck as they are playing the game, but they're all on the ship together. So, this shared element of pusher luck, I think, works really, really well in MLM.

There's also, oh, I'm gonna blank on the game, but there is another game about airship that has a very similar mechanism. Um, but I think this is a neat twist to push your luck where it isn't just you pushing your own luck, but you're pushing luck for other players as well or pushing or you're involved in a decision that impacts all players for for pushing luck. That is malem for this category. Next up, we have uh just a few more categories. Here we have Tableau building. Another another mechanism that I really really love, but one ambassador isn't a fan, but they said that the game Earth is a game that they really enjoy the tableau building game, tableau building mechanism in this game. And one of the reasons I think that this is a worthy exception to those who maybe don't normally like Tableau building is that you are actively using the cards in your Tableau. And not just using them. I think that's the case in many tablet building games because they're also engine building games. But uh you are it feels like the cards are alive in Earth because of the two different types of tokens that you're putting on them. I actually forget the name of the cubes right now. Um I'm forgetting the names the names of both of these things, but they're like uh they're I believe growth tokens and one other type of token that I'm I'm forgetting the name of. Um but the these are tokens that you're actively putting on. You're growing these towers taller. Sometimes you're uh spending things you other type of token from these cards to play other cards or to activate other cards. So frequently you're putting things and taking things off the cards. This was uh a a major inspiration for my game Vantage. I wanted players to not only have this tableau, but actively be putting things

on and off the cards throughout the game to actively use that tableau, not just based on what's printed on the cards, but for the tokens and dice advantage that you're taking on and putting off the cards. Um, I think that is a a neat way to make a tableau come to life in a game like Earth. And, uh, the last category that I have an image for is trick taking. So, a number of people said that they don't normally gravitate towards trick- taking game games, but there are exceptions. Those exceptions mentioned in uh, from Ambassadors were Cat in the Box, Campy Creatures, The Crew, and Fellowship of the Ring. I found that I love trick- taking games, especially modern trick- taking games with a little twist. And one of my favorite games that has that twist. I've mentioned a number time a number of times on this channel, but that is the game uh Cat in the Box. The twist in Cat in the Box is that the cards don't have suits. You declare the suit of the card as you play it. Um and that number for that suit is then taken for the rest of the round because it's been played. Um I I think so. I think for most strict thinking games, if you have a really clever hook like that that makes the game feel different without overly without making the game too complex or too difficult um to understand, I think that is what makes uh what makes modern trick- taking games that stand out special even for those who t typically are not gravitating towards trick- taking games.

The last category here, I don't have a visual for it, and this is a category, this is one of my favorite mechanisms, worker placement. I love worker placement, but not everyone does. and a few ambassadors said that even though they don't typically like work workplacement, they love the games Laavra and or Laav and Creature Comforts. They love those two games. I've played them both, but it's been a little while for both of me for for those two games. Um, so I don't have a lot to say about them, but it is neat that there are some some workplacement games that even if you don't typically enjoy them that maybe you'll enjoy those games. So, I'd love to hear your thoughts. Is there a mechanism or mechanisms that whenever you hear that mechanism, you're like, you're just not into it. you don't get excited by it, but there are some exceptions to that. And why do you think those are the exceptions to that rule? What makes them the exception? I think that would be helpful for me to hear as a designer, maybe helpful for other designers to hear and helpful for other people who maybe feel the same way. They don't typically like X type of mechanism, but they like these games that have or they that there is this game that you enjoy that they might like despite not typically gravitating towards that mechanism. I'm going to do videos like this again for for genres and themes as well. and I look forward to uh to having those discussions with you later on.

Thanks.

Progress saved