Reacting to YOUR Spicy Board Game Opinions | Importance of Theme, Digital Board Games, and More
Transcript
theme doesn't matter. At the end of the day, it's all math with art.
No, that's wild.
Hello everybody. My name is Ilia
and my name is Tyler. Together, makeup call, a couple that loves to play board games.
And we love sharing those board games with you and the joy of this wonderful hobby.
We sure do.
Now, today we are going to react to some spicy board game takes.
Oh, okay.
We've asked if people have spicy takes over on our Discord, our Instagram. and we scoured the interwebs and found 10 hot spicy opinions.
10.
And we are going to react to them. Tyler has not seen these opinions.
Yeah, I was just going to say, but I have. But I'm saving all of my reactions for you.
Now, I will not be revealing who has these opinions for the sake of protection of these individuals cuz, you know, sometimes spicy opinions are just listed. And some some of these folks have just messaged us to recommend these spicy opinions, to talk about them. Now, all in all, this is all to have fun. It's to state our opinions, see where we stand, and also celebrate the diversity of opinions in this hobby because there's a lot of you. There's a lot of us.
There's a lot of
There's actually only two of us, but there's a lot of people out there that enjoy board games.
So, in a variety of ways.
Yeah, exactly. And everybody has their opinions, and you're allowed to, and that's fine. But my opinion is fact.
I can disagree with that too. So
Tyler often does. But without further ado, I have my handy dandy sheet of opinions.
Handy dandy sheet of opinions.
A spicy hot takes. So we will discuss each of them one by one. Are you ready?
Yeah.
First one. If a board game allows you to quarterback the entire game, it's not a good competitive cooperative game.
It's not a good Okay. I just agree with that.
You agree with that?
Yeah. I think that if you have one person quarterbacking the entire game, it's not a good cooperative game.
I vehematly disagree with that.
You think that it's a good game?
Well, if the game allows for one person to like, okay, first of all, let's rewind. When this person says quarterbacking game, we should probably explain that. It means one person takes over the entire game and tells everybody what to do.
So, that's bad.
It is bad. Quarterbacking is bad, but it's not it's not the game's fault when people quarterback. It is the group's fault and it's the people's fault.
There are many games that have that you have the capability to tell everybody what to do because it's open information. But those games are not bad,
right? I don't think I interpret that opinion as that. I just think that I'm I interpret the opinion of if there's a quarterback at the table and it's not that and it's a bad then it's not doesn't mean it's a good game.
Well, then the spicy take would be it's not a good player at the table. Not as a
Yeah. Okay. Yeah. So then that I guess that would be the thing is it's probably it probably could be a good cooperative game. But exactly that, you know, I think cooperative games now are afraid of that critique cuz I feel like that critique comes up a lot
that oh this game it can be quarterbacked where one person can run everything. But I think there's some creativity and there's a lot of players that would actually really like a game that you can kind of cooperatively figure out what to do.
But you're doing that if you're playing with the right people.
Exactly. So, I think that like it's I don't know if
but sometimes the games shield that like they give you hidden information or they make you decide on this, right?
But you also have to take every instance of the games that are like that and and understand like the decision there cuz you can take a guess at it, but you'll never know if it was like, oh, I'm worried about quarterbacking. Cuz if you were worried about quarterbacking, maybe that is something that people do as designers. I don't know. I'd have to ask some design friends. But at the same time, like I think it also pushes people forward to be at least conscious of the quarterbacking that may happen.
That's true. Or maybe it creates the conversation and helps you guide your friends. Exactly.
But your last thought, do you agree that if a game can be quarterbacked, it's not a good cooperative game.
Not necessarily.
I did not agree.
Okay.
And that is this spicy or I don't agree that it's I think it can be a good game.
So you have to state it. You think it could be a good game?
I think it could be a good game. Even if you even if one player has the ability, not necessarily you will quarterback the game.
That this one confuses me a little, but I do get it.
Okay, are you ready for the next one?
Yeah.
Oh, this one's spicy. Expansions make most game worse, not better.
I don't know.
You want me to start? I'll start.
Go ahead. Go ahead.
I agree wholeheartedly. I I can name like five expansions in my hand that have made the game better.
The rest I'm just like it doesn't need it. There's like there's no reason to have this. Like you're And a lot of it I think comes down to the capitalistic nature of
board games. Like if a game sells really well, you obviously want to create more content that sells more so you can essentially make money and make more games,
right?
But I don't think many games need expansions. And my hot take in this whole topic is
a hot take in a hot take.
A hot take and a spicy is what
I think that big boxes in games are coffins. I think as soon as you get a big box that stores everything like it's so hard to open that big box, decide what you're going to play, rearrange everything. There's not a lot of them that do that well. And I feel like every time we've gotten a big box to put things into, we've played that game less.
Uh, okay. I can see both sides. I don't know whether or not I agree with that statement that expansions make games worse because I know several expansions that I really enjoy playing with. That being said, expansions in the big box coffin are actually like they like
uh those are for people who are dedicated to that game. That's true.
So, they love that game. We definitely have some of those big boxes. We do not need them. I I agree. I think that we could get rid of them. um and just keep the base game. I I definitely agree there. But we're the type of people that play a lot of different games where there are people out there in the hobby that play specific games. So having an expansion keeps them in the hobby, keeps them invested in their game and like creates that like
replayability.
That's true. And if it is your favorite game, it is always exciting when there's more that gets added to your favorite game and more that gets. So I think from that perspective, I do agree. But I think generally
generally I would say that
it it doesn't necessarily make it better. It usually just complicates it a little bit more.
I do love expansions that just add extra stuff without rules.
I agree cards for a shuffle I can think of. Yeah. Uh anyways, uh what I was also going to say is that I think that the Kickstart or like not Kickstarters, but uh games that have uh ideas for expansions and then step back to make it like a more base type version, but then release it later, I think is also not great. I think that you should just include it in the box, but I don't know. Maybe the expansion is like that big.
The whole planning Yeah. Yeah, that's a good point. Are you ready for take number three?
Sure. I think you're we're both going to disagree with this one as a spoiler.
Okay,
theme doesn't matter. At the end of the day, it's all math with art.
No, that's wild. But I do appreciate it because there are those types of people that
I think there are people that just want to get into the puzzle of the game. But theme makes it so much better.
I think you get to and especially like exploring the different things that you have not like I've learned so much
from this hobby that I've not known before. even mostly through you folks when like we were talking about rival cities the other day.
Oh yeah. Somebody explains it to us in the comments and that's like super amazing. Like that's actually cool.
You learn a ton of stuff and I think that part is really fun. But there's also games where what you're doing actually feels like the theme of what you're trying to do and that's like extra 10 bonus points there.
I would say even a step further than that. I won't approach certain games if they are themes that I don't like. But if they're themes that I like, I will play them. And hopefully they're good. But if they aren't, then at least I can say I tried it. I I also think I'm more of a mechanically driven individual though. So like I definitely lean into games that play well mechanically. And there are some games that I can think of that are like that that I could care less about the theme.
Fair. So, yes, I'm going to be that person that like plays both sides, but
but I think it's really nice because now you know what mechanics you like, you know what themes you like, and with thousands of games out there, you can narrow down which game is for you. And I think that's what theme is all about is there's different aspects that will appeal to different people cuz not everybody wants to do a space, war, or kingdom type of game,
colonization.
Yeah, we don't need that in our lives. Uh the other thing that I would probably mention is the fact that like um when you are picking a theme and a mechanic together, there is something to be said. I think I even mentioned this is that it makes the mechanics a lot easier and then therefore the game is more approachable to some individuals and with a with how the hobby is right now with so many games out there, I think like bringing more people from the mass market space into the hobby space is something that we aim to do.
Yes. So, we're very like cognizant of that because it is an appealing piece to people.
Agreed. Number four,
spicy take.
Okay.
Player elimination is good. Actually, it gives player a way to bow out.
To bow out.
Yeah.
Okay. There's like two things there, I guess. I I agree. I think player elimination can be a lot of fun sometimes. And I think that it depends on the game. If we're talking like a 30 minute game, sure, somebody can get eliminated 15 minutes in and that's okay. But if we're talking like a threehour sitdown game, I can think of one in particular, um, Nemesis, for example, you can get eliminated in that game really quickly. And if that is your entire friend's like game night for the night, you're kind of just like sitting there doing nothing or you're maybe even leaving cuz like you don't know what's happening, right? Like uh I haven't experienced that myself, but like I've heard stories of people getting eliminated like really early in that game and then not being able to do anything. So it's like not
as fun. Bowing out is interesting because to me bowing out is like quitting the game. Like you're just giving up on the game. And I
I don't like that.
I think that that's different than player elimination.
I agree. I think I agree with you on player elimination. And I think it's all context and it depends. I think where it's intentional, it's harder. But I think in where in most cases where it's okay if it's like love letter,
like it's a card game where it's more like the intent of it. It's not kind of a long-term consequence type of thing.
Um,
in terms of bowing out, I think this one's so hard because I don't
The worst feeling is when one person is not into the game. they're not trying to win and they ruin the game for other people and like by and not even intentionally. It's more because like now they're a lot of games are designed that everyone's trying to win. So if one player all of a sudden is doing something chaotic and helping somebody else, it just ruins the state of the game.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
So I think from that perspect like I don't want to give games opportunity to bow. But I think that concept is really interesting of like how if I'm done with this game and no longer were to play it, how can you all still continue playing
and still having a good time? So from from that perspective, I can't think of a game that does that. Well,
what I would argue here is that if this is a game that somebody is not interested in playing and they've never play and they've played it before,
they already know that they don't want to play it, so they shouldn't even join the game in the first place.
I understand maybe getting stuck in that game, but then like
I'm sorry, but that was your choice. Finish the game.
Finish Finish the game for your friends.
Yeah. And if if this is your first time playing it and everybody's the first time playing it or at least majority of the people, I think you're obligated to stick around.
Yeah.
Yeah. Like you have to play the game out. Like one of the things in our household that we try to like uphold is that you play the game to win. Like it's not it we don't have to win. We we we like to win obviously,
but we don't have to win. as long as we're trying to win, I think that that creates like good tension around the table and that's how the game the game is meant to be experienced. I think if you allow people to bow out,
you the game entirely changes. So if there was a four-player game and one person's like, "No, I'm done."
That game changes completely. Spaces open up. You can't you don't have an AI that's like taking over, for example. So,
I will add though is I think it's okay to get a gut check, get a vibe check from the table cuz you
you're playing a three-hour game.
You might not be the only player that's feeling that way cuz even it's actually funny cuz this year is the first year
I can think of
where there was two games where I was just like I don't want to finish. We still finished.
One of them one of them we didn't we vibe checked the table.
One of them we didn't and the second one we shouldn't have.
But I remember in both those games I'm like I don't want to play this anymore. Like it is not there's stuff in here that makes me upset. It doesn't work. Aspects have not happened. And I think it's okay to like ask cuz like you can always frame it as hey I'm not having fun. We still have a little bit to go. I'm very happy to continue and try my best. But I just wanted to check how everyone else is feeling cuz we could use this time to play a different game if we want to.
But that is a lot easier when everybody at the table is new to the game.
That's true. That's very true. Next spicy take. Miniatures are a scam. Sandies do the same thing but cheaper.
I will not argue that Sandies are cheaper.
I actually agree with this. I think miniatures are amazing. I think miniatures are amazing. I think it's a different hobby. I think miniatures are a different hobby that um that actually like coexist really nicely with board games. So, if you're getting into the miniature space, it's almost like you are a collector of those or maybe you paint them, so you want to be able to use them in the game in that sense. I think sometimes when uh especially like I can think of like upgrades that you can get. I like when they offer the ability to stick with acrylic standes or whatever it might be or then upgrade to miniatures. I think that making everybody have those miniatures cuz they're not exactly cheap to make. No. um and having to pay for them. I think it's intentional because you're trying to speak to your audience, but I think for those who don't necessarily enjoy the miniatures or the collection or the painting aspect,
yeah,
I like the test of like a game comes out and it's kind of like its base form and if there's really big fans of that game, they maybe choose to upgrade different version. Am I going to do that? Probably not for most games cuz it's not something that really appeals to me. Tyler and I did start painting some a little bit. It's fun,
but I think I agree with Tyler. It's a very different hobby. And I think giving players the option to choose what suits them is very friendly.
Yeah. And I will say this right now, we have a stand of miniatures that are beautiful. I love them. And hopefully, I mean,
we'll paint them one day.
Maybe we'll paint through them one day.
We've done seven.
Yes. But we've gotten through um like that game is good. It's fine. Like we don't play it a lot, but I love those miniatures. To me, I'm collecting those miniatures, using them as a paint hobby, not as a need to play the game kind of thing.
But sometimes it is nice when those
coincide. Yes. Yes. Yes.
That's true.
Spicy take number
six.
Six or five.
That was number five.
Digital board games are better than physical ones. I will start with this one. I
was going to say you should just kick this off.
Jail. Immediately. Jail.
Yeah. Mhm.
Um I so
I have a bias because I I love video games and there's many video games I play, but I love board games and the tabletop hobby has really like the community that you get at the table is just unrivaled. Like looking up at somebody when they're about to make a move, sharing that contact, sharing snacks, like the community aspect of board games
is really strong. Yes. Um, I think digital board games have done a great job to take that tabletop experience and help spread it to our friends that don't live near us or if somebody is sick or someone is far away like it's a way for us to connect without having that tabletop medium.
I don't think it's a replacement and I usually dread playing them myself.
So, I will say I usually like I don't play a lot of any sort of online tabletop games. Um, but I see the value in it and I see the community in it and I think there's a lot of like potential in like play testing and forming the games and making them better as well. Uh, but tabletop games on the table are superior in all ways.
Yeah. Uh, two things for this. The extreme side of this, if the digital game is far superior than the board game, I personally think it shouldn't even be a board game in the first place. It should just be a It should just be a video game or something.
Do you have an example of this?
No.
Okay.
Maybe I might I'm choosing to not say. But to add to this though is I think there are certain games specifically on BGA because that's where I play most of my digital games that are really really smooth. Some of the administration for some of these big heavier games they are they are cleaned up on BGA and I think that is fantastic. I also think that that is a great way to like Ilia said play with friends who are not necessarily in the same city as you or region like you're never able to get together to play games asynchronous games specifically especially with hate. Yeah, he has opinions on that. But uh I enjoy being able to play some of the heavier games that I play with folks online through our Discord or for friends that I've met through this content creation space. I like being able to play like a turnbyturn thing and not worry about having to like sit there for a few hours and play it. I think that's fantastic. I don't think digital games are better than uh board games when it comes down to it though. I'd much rather be at a table with people. I just think the convenience of the online digital space is really really nice. But I would prefer to be like socially in the group of people like playing games.
Um because a lot of the games that I do play online are asynchronous. I don't actually talk often to the people that I'm playing with.
My my last insertion in this one and we can move on. One thing I don't like is we're so conditioned for video games to walk us through games
and like where we like walk and we like learn what we're doing. I think a lot of people have started doing that specifically on BGA where they'll jump into a game and they'll just like hope that they can figure out how the game works. And I think that has reflected negatively in a lot of games because you or people don't know the rules.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
But it's good that we disagree because there there's one of us for whatever side you're on. But I just I think and like I think I'm an extreme in this case too cuz even like we play Gloom Haven and everyone's like you should use Gloom Haven helper. I loved managing all those little things. I loved setting all of it up. That was my favorite thing. I was like no thank you. I don't need any app to help me anything. We will do everything the oldfashioned on the table way. Uh but that's just like my way of experiencing games and I like it.
Yeah. I mean I have nothing against them.
Next on our list we have all games should have simultaneous turns.
No. I can see where this person's coming from because simultaneous turns are fun and I think it helps that whole aspect of there's been a lot of games that have done them really well recently. But again, it's a context thing. If every game is simultaneous turns, it decreases innovation. It decreases creativity and it cuts out a lot of really good games that require the turn based interaction and strategy.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. No, I I agree. I think that it's a there's a time and place for all of these types of game uh games. Simultaneous actions are fantastic. I love that they typically speed up the game.
That being said, like yeah, they're exactly turn-based like you wait hoping that you're going to be able to take an action and then you can't take it because somebody blocked it for taking it. Now, that could get aggressive in my head if you're like fighting for worker placement spots. Obviously, I'm gonna make an extreme, but if you're fighting for worker placement spots, can you imagine simultaneous worker placement and you're like, "No." And then you like flick it off the table and you're like, "No, this is mine claimed kind of thing." So, you can get like these headbutting.
Could be a fun game. You flick other people's workers.
Sure. It could it could actually come you could come up with something like that. But I I I I agree to an extent. I think a a um mechanic needs to be put in front of all all blank games should be simultaneous play. I think a lot newer games have considered time as that resource and what we give to games. And I think a lot of them have developed ways to kind of speed things up or do things in maintenance that you wouldn't kind of notice kind of deal. And I think I think that's always really clever.
Ready for the next one?
Mhm.
This is number eight.
Games that don't fit in a Calix shouldn't exist.
I like this. Just games specifically. I actually think I agree. I I don't know. Okay. So So Okay. We have Callalax's like we that's what we store our games in. So like any game that
Do we have any Billies?
No. No. No. No. So I think that any game that we can't fit in here because of the collection we have is a little bit inconvenient. Um
also how big do you have to be to not like those Call Cubes are pretty big.
They are pretty big. Like the ones that I can see on our shelves right now are big box games. So like they know they they have multiple games, expansions and everything in there. Like that wouldn't work. And
but even those can fit like they're up there because it's just more fun for them to be up there.
So that makes sense to me. But I think like somehow someway and I'd be curious how this all happened. You talk to a board gamer and they know what a call is. So like it's almost a standard at this point. So
yeah. Do you know all the other IKEA furniture?
Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. So like people know that they we use callalaxes to store these things. I know there are other solutions but it's just such a common thing to hear us board gamers talk about and I think like
notes take notes kind of thing like don't what's the saying? Don't fix what's broken. No
what's not broken.
Yeah. Yeah.
Don't need to fix what's not broken. I think the spicier take is it is it call or kaix?
Oh yeah that's true. or I've seen people pronounce it different way like other ways as well. What is it truly? How do we find out?
We'll never know but we probably will. There's definitely a right way to say it.
Yeah, I'm sure there is.
Number nine. Are you ready?
Yes.
Table presence is sometimes more important than the game mechanics.
Sometimes more important. Uh this is sort of like the theme one that we were talking about. It
is. I think there's some similarities for sure
cuz I don't know uh if it has a good table presence. I'm intrigued initially right off the bat,
but I have to consider like am I going to come back to the game? Did it actually play well? And when it comes down to it, the mechanics are actually what will um keep me coming back. So, I like I'll play two sides. Table presence is really important in deciding whether or not I want to play or buy the game. mechanics and maintaining my um interest are more important when it comes to like future looking in the game. I think I have a spicy reaction to this one.
Okay.
So, I think what you said has sparked a thought where you said
the t if it has a really good table presence, you're intrigued and you're curious and you want to dive in
initially. Yeah.
So, I think that's a problem because if it has a glorious table presence, it looks so good and then you play it and it's very subpar. I think it gives a poor representation of what the table hobby can be. The tabletop hobby.
Right. So, you're suggesting that by having a table present, a really good table presence, if I play lacking a good mechanics,
and I play it, don't enjoy it, then the next time I walk by something that has a really good table presence, I might be like, "Oh, last time I did this, it didn't go well."
Yeah. And like maybe board games aren't for me,
but that's just like some kind of bias. I can't remember. Okay.
Yeah. Yeah. And and I think it 100% it is cuz like you the memory cuz it could be that person's first experience cuz like again the first day when I'm going to go and it's like what game do I want to play if I've never played any games I am going to gravitate to ones that look really cool on the table.
I want those g I want those games to have just as good mechanics as they look
and I think recently especially there's been a lot of games that look really good on the table but don't necessarily meet
they don't play as well as they look.
Yeah. Okay. Hold on. So then the question here in my opinion is would you rather a game be extremely low produced and mechanically good
or extremely high produced and mechanically not so great.
Low produced mechanically good.
Yeah.
Well because then you you have the memories and I think like if you really care about the game there's so many creative outlets to upgrade it yourself.
So like Etsy is a great place you can really like do all sort of stuff yourself creatively. And typically those games tend to do better that eventually they get a facelift.
Yeah, that's true. The ones that do good. Y
it's it's I almost kind of want to be like it's initial test. You can can't have miniatures, can have this like glorious 3D presence. Like try just doing at the table if your game sells really well. Let's do an upgrade.
I mean like the unfortunate thing about it is that there are so many board games out there that you as a company you have to be able to distinguish yourself. And I think that those are the things that distinguish the company. So, 100%. And the last spicy take we have that actually is a little bit related to what we just talked about.
Oh, okay.
I'd rather play Uno with good friends than terraforming Mars with boring people.
Uno with good friends.
I think 100%.
The people are what makes it fun. You can make any game like you. We can play six hours of Monopoly and if the crowd is good and we're all laughing and having a joyous time, that will be a better memory than me sitting through a game I really love with people I may not connect with. Yeah, listen. I play games that I don't like. Not often. Not often. I was going to say often, but I play games that I don't like because of the people that I'm playing with. Me,
I I will I will go through that. I don't I don't care. I love hanging out with the people that I'm with. I like that they enjoy it as well. So, there could be some games that maybe don't necessarily aren't my cup of tea, but I know everybody else at the table is enjoying it. Therefore, I'm enjoying it. Has nothing to do with the game. So I think 100% of the time I'm picking Uno with the right people.
And I think for me it's also like it's not the most it's not kind of like a I'm trying to think of sports where like
you're not competing to be the best.
Yeah. You're not being you're not competing to be the best in whatever game you're playing. Like and I and I think there's people that want to do that and 100% that's a very valid and fun way to do it. Like the fact that competitive board gaming exists that's fantastic. pretty cool.
It's very cool. Um, but for me, I just want to have fun. I want to have fun with friends, people I enjoy. I want to laugh. I want to make memories. I want to have grand moments. And I want to invite people back over and have them be excited to come back over as well. I don't want to have feuds
and rivalries. Except I have a lot.
Oh, mostly with me.
And that has been 10 hot takes. Holy moly.
Spicy.
Spicy. Spicy. Some of them weren't that spicy.
No, I mean the trouble is is when we both agree with our stance or we both agree with the take.
Well, maybe it'll get spicy in the comments.
That I mean that's that's
that's part of it.
Well, there are 10 hot takes. So, our question of the day here for you today is which of these do you most agree or disagree with?
Or both.
Or both. Exactly. Let us know in the comments down below. We'd love to continue the conversation. And if you enjoyed this video,
make sure you hit that thumbs up button, hit that subscribe button. If you're new here, cuz we love talking and teaching board games and doing different things with board games like this.
Exactly. And I was also going to say, and if you enjoyed this video, you can suggest us hot takes to react to in a part two.
Part two. Yeah. Did we miss a hot take? That's
We may have. Or maybe you just want to see us react to a wild sentence that you write down there.
I mean, make it board game related. Obviously.
Obviously.
Come on, people. Come on. But thank you so much for being here and we will catch you in the next one. Bye.