Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 3 Board Game Plays of November 2025

Transcript 44:50

Hey, I'm Ryan. This is my brother Daniel. And this is Rolls in the Family. And we are headed into November here, which is a great time to talk about what are the games we played in.

I'm headed into November.

Gosh dang it. I don't even know what we're leaving November. I tell you, time flies. Time flies. It's uh my birthday's coming up, actually.

Yeah. No. Uh yeah, you're right. We're headed in December,

but we are headed back into the memories of November.

The memories of November. November is on the mind, you know. Just had Thanksgiving, you know.

Oh, I'm still full.

Yep. And we're going to be talking about our top three board game plays from November 2025. If you'd like to leave in the comments below what your top plays in November were, that'd be great.

Yeah. Get any games around the Thanksgiving table?

Yeah. any Thanksgiving gaming. Looking at mine,

those aren't the ones that made the list for me, actually.

Wow. Bad Thanksgiving day for Ryan.

Yeah, it was very rough Thanksgiving. Yeah,

I got one got one from them.

It was good. It was good. We'll have links to all the games we talk about uh down in the description below. We also soon, probably quite soon, are going to be recording our annual ask us anything video, which we have a survey down in the description that you can submit questions for that video. It's also our survey where we uh ask just it's like a little pulse check on like what kind of content you like on the channel. So if you want to communicate to us, you know, what you like that we're doing, what you hate that we're doing, that's the place. This is your avenue. Wondering how to complain about the channel. This is the way we've given that.

Please file all complaints in the Google form below.

Uh

yeah, let let's jump into this. Daniel, I'm curious. I don't know that I know much about what your uh gaming was this month. Dude, I think I told you about every single one. Um, okay, Ryan. My number three, uh, is, uh, my wife and I got a, uh, got a little getaway this month. We got were gifted a be able to go to kind of a a stay overnight hotel place. And so, of course, brought some games. I mean, what else would you do? Um, and so, and uh, actually, funny enough, side story about this, Ryan. So, we get to the hotel and there's there's no tables any like I'm looking around. I'm like, "Okay, where can we There's nothing."

And so, I uh

So, you left a strongly worded review.

No. Well, I should have. I should have, but in like this back like place like the stairwell and there's just all of these like random things at the bottom of the stairwell. I found a folding table and so I borrowed the folding table and and set it up in our room and and we were able to play some games. So, I came through clutch um and it led it led to my number three play. This was the morning after my wife and I. We've played this one before uh but this was by far the best play that that we've had so far. This goes to Forest Shuffle and

yeah, so we have played this maybe a a couple times and uh Forest Shuffle very fun kind of card game. has a little bit of uh I think what we like about Race for the Galaxy of the whole when you're spending uh when you're playing something from your hand, the resources are also what's in your hand. Now, the only catch in this game is that those things are going then out to a shared center place where you can you or the person you're, you know, playing against can end up taking those cards. Um so there's also a little bit of, you know, tension around that. Um, but a game where you're playing these trees and then kind of in a cool way like cards have either, you know, an animal on the top or the bottom or the left and the right and you're choosing which side are you playing and you're sliding it behind the trees ultimately trying to build combos and score a ton of points. And this is a game where you can score a lot of points. In fact, they I think they have an app where you can just like scan it because it's a lot of math. But we like doing math in the language household. Ryan,

do you trust apps? Well, I will say Ryan, like the downside to a scoring app is you lose the whole just like what like seeing what how somebody got

like I like walking through and seeing, oh my gosh, you scored this much for that and this much for that. So

we we tallied it up and uh listen to this. My wife won 292 to 290.

Wow. Like that is it's just amazing a game that can score that high to have it that close. I was uh I was running with this combo of uh I was getting all these common toads which you can have two common toads on one tree. Um, and they they like score if a bonus if you have two common toads. And I think I got that on two different trees. But then the type of the common toad is like I think it's a reptile. And I had a bunch of these I want to say ants that scored like bonuses for how many reptiles I had. So I was just common toads reptiles going crazy.

Is toad a reptile?

I don't know. Toad is an maybe. Yeah. Yeah. That's probably Yeah. Not reptile. I was probably the expert, but

yes, we are we people do not come here for their biology knowledge.

Yes.

Um but anyways, whatever it is, the symbol for crawling thing on the ground. Um and so I scored a ridiculous amount of points just in that alone. Um but uh but my wife was able to yeah, pull off some pull off some good stuff. And um yeah, it's one that again the amount of comboing, you know, that happens in it um is kind of crazy. Um but also just always this tension of, you know, spending cards, but knowing you might be able to get it back, especially in a two-player game. I mean, there's only one person in between, you know, you and you going again, but then the risk of if the card row ever gets to over 10, it clears. So, kind of always navigating that. This one is really fun. I've not played it with more than two players yet, which I don't know if it would be better. It would, you know, kind of like a lot of games where you introduce more players, it starts to become a little more random in that

you

Yeah, especially with that car. Like, I feel like it's very strategic with two players, especially cuz you can be pretty in tune with what they're doing. Like I think we've we've compared this often to Lost Cities with that feeling of like putting things I was thinking of that's like that

but it because it has this element of you're putting things somewhere where either player could take it but

people's each player's valuation of things is different based on what they're doing. So it's like you know this is good for me but they if if it's two-player they know it's good for you. Um, which is really the big difference like if you went to three-player or four player um blocking somebody is a higher cost because it's not like this zero sum game,

right?

Um, but yeah, it can be kind of kind of cutthroat.

It can. It can, but quite fun. So, this was uh it was so great to like have a play of it and it really felt like this was the one that was like ah forest shuffle like that. This is a great one to have in in the collection and it gives me a little bit of that Race for the Galaxy itch that you know my wife uh hasn't well we don't even have that one anymore so I guess we're not going to play it but for Shuffle

delivered. Nice. There's supposed to be some good expansions for it.

I like expansions. I love expansions. Nice. My number three is a bigger game that hasn't uh been played in a while. um which often is the theme for a lot of the bigger games in my collection. You know, it's this slow cycle over the course of a year of, you know, what are the bigger games that's been the longest since I've played? Can I get them to the table?

Um so it was nice to get this one back. Played a two-player game with actually the friend of mine that I've played this the most with um two-player. So it was nice to be able to just like, you know, pretty much jump in.

Um and this is Underwater Cities.

Oh. Uh Underwater Cities. This is a it's an interesting game to talk about on a list like this because I've realized compared to like we've talked about one of its strengths is how tactical it is in that you have these three cards and you're trying to match the cards the color of the card to the action so you can get both but then you always get a new card and so it's always just like changing kind of what you can do and it's a lot of just like different tactical combinations of things. I've realized as a result, it's hard after a game of underwater cities, especially in a case like this where I played it at the beginning of the month to for it to be really memorable because there isn't like this really overarching,

oh, I did this really different strategy this game.

It's like, no, I did a bunch of little

tactical things differently to do a lot of the same things you usually do,

but the tactical things are so

fun. satisfying and so interesting that it's not really a complaint on the game.

Um it really is kind of this game strength. Um

but this particular game as I was trying to kind of like, you know, look back at my photos of it and remember kind of

how it went. Um I did have that. So we were playing with the uh new discoveries expansion content. One of the pieces there is you get a unique special assistant. I had like the shark. I like to be led by a shark as I build my like a intelligent shark. Oh,

okay. I It's got Yeah, I think it's got like a You know,

the theme in this game is very strong.

Very strong theme. Yes. I mean, you do build underwater cities. It's true.

True.

Um but his ability was I basically got to take a special card right away.

Mhm.

From like a choice of three or something. And so I got one of those islands that's just like really good production right away. Um which isn't like super common that you'll get an island like before all of the production rounds. Um, so that was really nice and I actually led me down a path of I did more special cards in this game that I think I've ever done in Underwater Cities. And part of that was there was one of those uh those like race objectives that the first person to achieve it gets the extra bonuses. And one of them was playing a certain amount of special cards. So that was like my opening strategy was okay, head hunter is going to start me with one. I'll just try to go hard on that. But then I also like it's very common in this game for everybody to forget about like the endgame scoring special cards until like the last round or two and then you realize oh there's literally one space where some where people can get special cards. So like

you can't all go get them at the end. Um, but this game I was way better about earlier on thinking about special cards and I ended up playing three of the endame scoring special cards which usually I play like one. Now granted it means I also like didn't score quite as high on them because I'm not doing less but

no I I did win this game. No one asked. It was it was one of these games where uh I was like I might be having one of my better games of this.

Uh like I was thinking I was maybe going to win by a lot, but it ended up being quite close. Like he made some pretty kind of big moves down the stretch. Um

but yeah, just a really really fun game that

has managed to Oh, Daniel disappeared.

My toesies are getting cold.

Oh man, grab a blanket.

Grab a blanket.

Danielle's out there in Minnesota. You know, it's

it's freezing out here, folks. I record as

Please support the channel so Daniel D's heat deal can be covered.

Y

um I was just going to say Underwater Cities is a game that has managed to despite being in the most competitive category in my collection of these kind of longer, heavier games carve out its own niche. And I think that tactical nature of it is a big part of it. like a lot of the other games in the same category don't have that same quite the same feel of just like that constant flow of

you know getting those cards and just the interesting how does this change how I approach the ride

in some ways it a little bit is what I like about like a great western trail too of that like constant just like okay three space like which one how am I going to max in front of me that one has a little bit more of the like bigger picture strategy type you know directions you can go but but I Love both those aspects in those games.

Yeah. Yeah. Yep. So, good to get this one played again. It's really good two-player. Good with the expansion content.

Mhm.

Fun stuff.

Fun stuff. Um, speaking of

two.

Oh, not fun stuff.

And also fun stuff.

Oh, man. Double

double, man. We just double segueed. Uh, we're going to go to my number two, which was played last night. Uh we got my wife's family over and uh so breaking out some games. And this game might win the award for

biggest box in my collection to most accessible.

And this ratio the ratio. Yes. And this goes to Dungeon Fighter and specifically we've played the collector's edition of Dungeon Fighter which both Ryan and I have and sing its praises cuz this game it's such an easy one to go to and want to bring out because in some ways it delivers a little bit more of a you know it's a it's a meteor experience rather than just a you know generic party game. like you're you're doing a little more you know there's more going on but it's not complex especially for like other people playing like the person like me like I just kind of like run the game but man like getting up and running in this game is super fast I mean you just deal out characters you just kind of explain some of what your you know what your characters do and whatnot and then the rest of it you can just kind of figure out as you go

everything's open information you're on a team

but I think that the thing about this one is first and we've said this before, but like the collector's edition, despite having so much content, delivers it in such a streamlined way. I mean, at no point in this game am I like, "Okay, I got to go, you know, find this thing." Like, it's just I you set out the trays and you just And they even streamlined like the whole dungeon system and now, you know, with just playing the cards and oh, we got this. Okay, I just reach over to the tray and I grab that thing. We've got the volcano. We've got the glass that you're looking through. Like

the way they just implemented all of that, it makes it so easy to inject a ton of variety uh into the game. And the variety just makes the game so like that's the fun of it is just all the crazy things that that you can encounter. And this is a game that I have found delivers a party like experience when you're like even though it is, you know, you're going through a dungeon, you're battling monsters, like you don't have to be someone that likes that type of game to like dungeon.

It's pretty goofy. It's a pretty goofy uh angle on the dungeon crawling theme.

Yeah, it's a goofy humorous. Well, and even what you're doing, right, throwing dice at a board and then having to do, you know, these crazy shots. And so, like yesterday, you know, one of my I I had a pretty sweet combo where uh I first got a weapon that was the uh like it was a fishing one. So, we had a little circular water thing and you have to bounce the die inside of the circle of water before going on a thing. I was like, "Okay, that's not bad. I can I can do that." I tell you what, Ryan, our years of dungeon fighter have paid off in the the skill skill side of it. So then we ended up getting an a a group item, you know, those ones that apply to everyone that if you ever use two weapons in the same attack, you get plus one damage.

So I'm like I'm like, "Okay, I've already got this one." So I end up getting the uh I think it was the ninja shot after that where you got a Yeah, you kind of the praying one. And so I was working it with this praying shot into the thing uh onto onto there. There was even a monster we faced where you had to have it bounce multiple times before it got onto the target. And so I'm like I can do this. So praying shot into the thing multiple times on um

it's just like such a fun game and we end up we we actually did pretty well. I mean, we got we end up winning and uh but but not I mean there were moments that were tough and like you know all it takes is like one monster that you know puts you in a tricky situation. You know we did I had to look up in the rules uh you know what happens when you literally have like two things that are impossible cuz we had the we had to you had to do a pinky shot. You had to hold in the pinkies but then the monster was you had to throw it off your elbow. Come on, Dad.

Well, so so the rules basically say like

you either have to like retreat back, which I guess like hurts you,

but or as a group basically decide what is the most legal way of like be creative. So, so we came up with, okay, you got to have a pinky on the, you know, put it on the elbow, put a pinky on. And so, like I don't know, this game is just a hoot. Uh, and you know, even for people like just starting like even just starting with the base, you know, second edition box would be a great place to start. I mean, obviously we love this cuz we've played it a ton, but

yeah, I am I this one just feels like it's going to be a forever forever game in the collection, you know?

Well, the ceiling for high moments in this game is just so high

like of what could happen.

A great great reminder, Ryan. how we finish. We're in the boss. And it wasn't to kill the boss because he had 11 health, but uh my uh uh brother-in-law uh no uh sister-in-law's husband, I don't know what that is. Um so,

please drop in the comments below.

Yeah, I don't know. I'm bad at that stuff. So, anyways, he 11 health left on the boss and we had the pendulum die. That's the other thing. All the different dies. the pendulum die. And so he's, you know, swinging it, swinging it, and he throws the pendulum die and lands it on a bullseye. And and so got him all the way down to one health. Uh it was it was pretty epic. Um so

dungeon fighter.

Yes. Yeah. I I've been playing this actually two-player with my my 5-year-old son. Um and he he loves it and it's great fun. We just had a play the other day where we got to throw the snow dye. I don't think I've ever thrown the snow dye before. Really big, light one,

fluffy one. And that thing does not like bounce like like I'm like there's like no way we're going to get on it. And we had to use it to try to save ourselves against a guy that was doing like the one where you have to hold the other person's hand.

So he's holding in his hand and I'm like trying to do it. And it was like we're going to lose if we don't get this and we, you know, I try to give enough momentum and it bounces and then it like

goes up on a quarter and just slowly drops like right on like a five. It was almost a bullseye, but it was just so fun. It was so uh dramatic the way that it

Have you played with the other targets? I've only ever this last time played with the

which one was it? The maybe the earth one or something. But that's another just silly thing that it's but it like does change the feel.

Uh whichever one we played with has the holes are much closer to the bullseye.

So it makes the bullseye area very dangerous like cuz Yeah. the doors are like actually quite different with like

um so it is fun. It's another thing you can just so good.

Nice. My number two is a game I've been pretty uh talked pretty positively about here in the uh first year or so of me having it and it continues to just land so well for me and just keep me excited about getting to the table more and this is innovation. um actually played this the same day as Underwater Cities with the same friend and this was what a day. Uh and he's also the friend that I've played Innovation the most with two-player um and so we were like now is maybe a great opportunity to try one of the expansions cuz we've played the base game multiple times.

Um so we used the Echoes of the Past expansion which

was for the original edition of the game that was the first expansion that came out. There's other expansions in this ultimate edition that you could use first. Um, but this adds some pretty interesting changes to the game. First of all, it adds it doubles the card count. Like literally for every deck in it, there's also an Echo deck that has like as many cards that you like put next to it or under it like as like another deck that's available. Um, and the way that you draw from that deck is anytime you would draw a card. So, say you would draw from like the three uh era or whatever they call it. If your current tableau has like you look at whatever your top highest top card is, which would be a three in this case cuz that's what determines what deck you go from. If you only have one three instead of like multiples of it, then you draw from the Echo deck. But then once you play another three, now you have multiple top cards that are the highest. Now you draw from the normal deck. And so it kind of just injects this like sometimes you're drawing from echo, sometimes you're drawn from the other. We're like we don't even know what you would want to be doing because we don't know what's in these decks. Um but just a great way to inject a bunch of new cards into the system in a way that doesn't completely throw off the pacing of the game. Um, but then these cards introduce some really cool new elements into it. So, one of the big things is it's called Echoes of the Past. There's in place of some of the icons on these cards,

there's these echo effects that are basically like the dogma effects. They're like text that does something

that now when you do the dogma of your top card, you also get to do any of those that are visible. And so this means that like once you start playing late in the game, you can have an echo effect from a previous card a long time ago, still contributing this like additional effect onto your current top card.

Um, so that's an interesting like mixup there. Um, there's also now some of the icons are replaced with like a victory point coin, which is very interesting because as long as it's visible, it contributes to your victory point total, which your victory point total in this game is very important because you're racing for those standard achievements that require you to have certain uh, you know, point values. In fact, I actually ended up winning the game at the end largely because I was able to get out a really big

point value on a card that got me high enough to grab my last achievement. Um, so that's interesting because again, like

now that's a decision when you cover things up. Like if I now play another card and cover this up, I'm covering up points that maybe I wanted visible. Um, so I liked that. That's a very like low rules overhead addition. But then there's this whole concept of forecasting. And so there are ways in the game that you might be able to forecast a card. So it might be like forecast a five or something. You would take a five card, you get to look at it and know what it is, but then you tuck it under the top of your uh little player aid and it's in your forecast area.

And basically it's like you know it's coming. So you can kind of like plan around it.

But it's going to be once you play a five like meld some other five. So you actually made it to era 5. You now will immediately get to play your forecasted five as like a free action, but you also must immediately trigger its dogma. So it's this interesting thing of like you can kind of like, okay, I know this is coming. Can I set it up that I could really get a powerful like one two punch of playing and then immediately triggering and doing this thing

um as part of forecasting. And then there's even cards in the Echo deck that have a win forecasted do this other effect. So if you can manage to get those in your forecast and get them out through do they call it promoting

um you would get this like mega effect effect potentially on it which is really hard to do cuz like the things that have to fall into place you have to get like that card into your forecast and then specifically work and then for and and promote it. But it's that type of thing that I love in this game of just like, yeah, that's for one of those given cards, you're not going to see that, but then you you play the game 20 times and finally for the first time see this particular card like trigger in this way.

And I think that's just a lot of what has me so excited about playing this game more is just

you're always going to be seeing new things every time you play this game, new ways that things combo together. And oh, like I never realized like this this dogma effect from era 2 that I was able to like keep on the top all the way to era 7 and now like it has a completely different dynamic of how it's affecting the game because plus it's just very funny thematically when somebody's over there still with like still working some old technology like um I forget what the one was that uh I don't know it's a very like unscientific medieval like approach to things and like you you could be way later in the game just still hitting it. Um, but yeah, this one I really enjoyed this first play of the expansion. It is a little bit of,

you know, you inject all these new cards in and that's going to be new cards that you're not familiar with when your opponent gets it and you're like, "Okay, what does that card do again?" Cuz the more you play this game, it does help that like you start to see a lot of the same cards and you don't it's not like every card has to be a read and understand what it does. Um, but yeah, this one's just a ton of fun. I mean, I could definitely see the more I play with like an experienced player like always wanting to mix in this or maybe mix in a different expansion or for feeling wild, mix in more than one expansion. Uh, and the Ultimate Edition really did a good job of making that all very clean and having a good like kind of combined rule book for all the expansions. Um,

so yeah, very positive first impression of the Echoes of the Past

expansion. Yeah, we are we are raving about uh all of these like ultimate editions, collector's editions. My gosh.

But we we will say to you, if you want to get Dungeon Fighter, just get the standard second edition. You can expand it with sets if you want. If you want to get innovation, they now have released after the ultimate edition. They released now I don't know if it's the fourth edition, but they released the new edition in a smaller set that and Innovation is definitely a game that you could just get the base game and be happy forever. I'm happy to have some of this um expansion stuff, but that would be my recommendation to people is just to get the uh the base game. But

you might be happy forever, but you'll be happier with more.

Yeah, happier. My number one isn't uh isn't an ultimate edition.

Oh, okay. Neither is mine.

Good.

Uh because

get off that train.

Get off that train. That bougie train and my number one, Ryan, I'm very excited to talk about this. Um because this is a game that uh one I don't own. Uh two is one that I think both of us have kind of had our eye on um for a while of just one that was like oh man that that one you know it's really highly I actually didn't realize how highly how high in the rankings it is on BG that actually when I went and looked I was like oh my goodness. But I totally understand why. Uh because I got a chance uh with a buddy of mine. He brought over Lost Runes of Arnack. Um and wow, that was a very very fun game. Um yeah, it was just such such a fun play. A lot of really cool things going on in this one. I'll start off. You can see it, you know, in the pictures here.

Um this game is beautiful. like the board just like when he put it out it's maybe a little bigger than it needs to be, you know, but it looks incredible on the table and so I was just like, "Wow, I you know, as much as maybe you could argue that like doesn't matter, it kind of does actually, you know, it it is fun to fun to play on something that looks great like that." But man, this one just has a lot of really cool things going on. I think a little bit earlier with we were talking about um you know what you were talking about with uh not Great Western Trail. What was the

underwater city

underwater cities of just like things kind of tactically comboing? It feels like this one just does that in like over and over and over. You know, you're kind of it's this interesting combination of it's both a like worker placement, although you only have two workers. So kind of there's and there's so this kind of section of the board where you're placing a worker out and there's some base locations that you can go to to get some resources or do kind of a simple conversion, but then ultimately you're like exploring out into these I think they're like caves. Um so you can like spend resources to go discover uh you know one of the and there's kind of a level one locations but then there's the like big level two ones further. Um, and whenever you so you spend and you go to a location and you draw a random uh, you know, location there, which is ultimately going to be a new action location for all players for the rest of the game. So, one cool thing about that is just like the order of like actions coming out is kind of randomized and when you go there, you get the ability or you get, you know, you receive the benefits of the action. Um, there's a another bonus you get for being the one that explored it, but then also there's a like big monster, you know, that comes out on the location and every turn you stay there without defeating it, you're going to get a fear, which is just a uh that's the other part of this game. This game is a deck builder um in that so you start off with but not like a big deck build. I mean, this is like a tight deck of cards. Um, but you're going to be

buying cards to add to the deck. But every turn that you're there with this, you know, monster, you have to add a fear into your deck, which is just a, you know, card. It's negative one at the end of the game, but also it's just clogging your deck. But there's ways you can, you know, get rid of that. Um, so you got all that going on and then there's like this whole kind of side track which is like the research um thing that you can be going up on and you've got two tokens on it and you always have to have your like eyeglass token be ahead of your notebook. Um, so you have to like move the eyeglass first and then your notebook and based off on each level whichever token gets there gets you different rewards and the first person to get to places will like get an extra bonus. there's a little bit of a race going on out there. And then at the top of the board, you have the uh the shop of cards coming out um that you're buying to, you know, spending resources to add to your deck. And what's interesting about that is at the start of the game, the shop is so it's like a think of like a row of I don't know if it's like seven cards or something like that, but at the start of the game, you've got like one and I don't know, they're they're special cards. I don't know if magic cards, something like that. But you start with one and then the other six cards are just regular item cards. But every round, this little marker moves to the right and more and more of the cards are going to become these like high power special cards and less and less will become items as they're filling in. Um, which I thought was just kind of a kind of interesting thing there. So, it's it's one of those games a little bit where you're like,

"Okay, there's a lot of different things I could do.

How do I know what the best one is?" Um, and I don't know, I just start going and hope.

Is there very much like variable setup that like would give you any kind of nudge?

So, in terms of what you like personally have, I'm trying to remember. I don't think there's anything um from like a personal

cuz I know the I know there's the expansion for the leaders or something and I know that adds basically variable player powers but I wasn't sure like if there was any other kind of like

I don't think it has it in the base game. Um you can correct me down below if I'm wrong on that but but yeah so a lot of the a lot of the variability then comes from just the way the actions are coming out. Um what you know the cards that you're buying for your deck. I ended up getting this really like and I got it early. This like incredible playing card that made it so that I could go when I go to like this the level two locations I could like go there for a you know huge discount in resources. Um and I was able to pull that one out multiple times which was massive uh for for exploring there. Um I don't know. I mean, you know, when you get in the zone of a game of just like, okay, so I get these resources, then I'm going to spend these resources to go over on the research track and go up, and that's going to get me this bonus, and then I'm going to like you just start getting in this like d like that one. I felt like I was just in that rhythm the whole game. Like it just it just kept going and going. This one was a ton of fun to the, you know, to the point where I had it on my kind of thinking about it list. And after playing it, I bumped it up to my kind of like, you know, either like or love to have. um cuz it was very very fun.

Um and obviously to have heard that a expansion for it is, you know, could add some of even that more variability around individual player powers. We love that kind of stuff. So

Ryan, I think you should uh I think you should keep your eye on this one.

Yeah, it's one of those ones. I mean, it's one of the more highly rated games that I haven't played and that I for whatever reason it had never like bumped onto my like next games to consider buying list. It It feels like one that I would love to be able to try. Um like on paper it so hits on a lot of things.

It doesn't do anything crazy like like there's nothing in it that I feel like there's not a lot in it that's like oh my gosh I've never seen that before in a board game. It's just the combination of the mechanics just work really well together. And so it's I wouldn't say it's like a like an experience that's totally out there, but man, it just felt so good what what it was delivering.

Yeah. Yeah. And I know when it first came out, it came out right around the same time as Dune Imperium. And the board game community really like latched on to like pitting these two against each other just because both have deck building and both have worker placement. And there weren't a lot of games that did that at the time

where it seems like the more I've learned about them like that like isn't like a really strong compar like they seem pretty different.

I think they they feel pretty different. Yeah. But I don't know if that's part of like the fact that I have and like Dune Imperium that has maybe like subconsciously made me not

they are in a similar sense of like you know in terms of like when you're choosing

it feels like those two

strategic weight and length of the game. Yeah.

But

um but yeah, especially now, you know, with the new expansion coming out that adds some some of the stuff that I know is directly in the lane of what I like in these types of games.

Um maybe I got to keep it keep it on my radar. Yeah, one of us will get it and then then we can try it together.

Yes. Perfect. You're you're that person, right? That's

just trying to make sure understanding this correctly.

Cool. Uh my number one is a game that I think two years now on our top 50 of all time. I've had to tragically say that I didn't get it to the table despite claiming it as one of my favorite games. But I finally made sure this one got played. This is a probably the most uh sprawling of any of the big kind of strategy games I have. This is a feast for Odin

and it had been over two years since I played this. Disgusting. And it was really it was really just a matter of circumstances that some of the groups that I like would play it with. Well, you and your wife obviously don't live here anymore. And your wife doesn't really like this game anymore. You guys ended up getting rid of

Yeah, it was too it was too sandboxy for

too sandboxy. Yeah. Um and it is it is definitely pushing a little bit more in that sandboxy direction. And honestly, if I had one complaint to this game, it's still that the cards don't quite

push as much as I want them to. And

like the Norwegians expansion is amazing, and we played with it,

but it adds this one thing that I don't love, which is,

you know, in the base game, it's like, oh, there's some randomness of who gets better cards. Well, they're like, well, to even this out, we'll make it that whenever you could play a card, you could just discard it and take a point token. So that way at least if you don't get good cards, you can get the point tokens. But my problem is like it's incentivizing you to do the less fun option. Like the more fun thing is to play the cards and try to use the abilities and do the things. But man, they these point bonuses is a lot of times you go like, am I going to get four or three points out of this card? Like probably not.

I don't know. I probably should just do it. And so like, you know, I ended up getting a bunch of point tokens and not cards. Now part of that was like I really just did not get cards that were matching what I was doing. It was like, man, I don't even I'd have to like so pivot to make this card possible.

Um, but yeah, I would just love if the

I almost love if it was reversed of you were like more incentivized to play more cards for, you know,

um, maybe I need to come up with some variant here. Um, but even with that, this game is just so unique and satisfying. I mean, there's just no game that combines quite the level of really big scope uh worker placement resource management. So, you're definitely in the Uve Rosenberg, you know, manage your resource, build up your engine type of um system, but the way it combines that with a spatial puzzle is just really fascinating where the resources you're getting are little shapes. And these little shapes can upgrade through these different levels of colors, and that's going to determine like which boards you can play them on. And ultimately, you're trying to fill in your board um and get around these restrictions. And so much of the game is about like how can I get pieces but then maybe upgrade them to be bigger or a better color so that I can use them this other way. But then those are also what you need to use to feed and the shape is relevant when you're feeding too cuz you're filling in the little track. You know, in this game we played with we were playing with the Norwegians expansion. So you get um a random artisan shed that when you go to build a shed, you could build a side of that, right? And I built the pigsty that very early on I was able to start producing the long slabs of meat that are like four long. And so that's huge for my feeding strategy cuz there are red which can break up the orange tiles you get from the harvest and it filled in really long. Um but yeah it just I don't know

there's really nothing even close to feeling like it for me. Um, and the whole like going and getting an eye and the way your income goes up in this game and there's kind of this pacing of, okay, I'm increasing my income on the main board, but then I might want to go get an island that I can, you know, move up, but then there's also these bonuses that if you surround them, which is like such a nice tension of like, I want to increase my income. The most efficient way to do that is just to like block in with big pieces. But do I want to cover these bonuses? Some of them are really good. On my uh island, I had a bonus that I started producing a blue tile of like the the like sea like antler piece that comes in the expansion, which is like a really good piece. That's like a five square blue piece. And I was able to start, you know, producing it. Um and the game just it feels very bountiful.

It's giving you you get those harvests just like built into the game that you get these harvests and as you get your income going you're just getting a lot to work with and it's how can I you know funnel that all to points.

Uh so it was so fun to get to play this one again.

Did you win?

I did win. I mean I was playing with two players that had never played it before which I mean that goes to show you that's that was the only way I was going to get this to the tables. I needed to teach it to somebody.

Toby and Theo.

Yeah. Yeah. So my children it's like boys it's time. Uh, no. And the new players actually did well, I think, for first time playing. I had probably one of my best games I I've had of this. Um, and so it wasn't particularly close.

Um, but fortunately, it's the type of game where you get a lot of satisfaction out of just doing your

thing. And because you get to see yourself fill

your own grid

that, you know, you you at least get some of that feeling even if if you're not as close in the score. I mean, I guess

here's my question, Ryan. Did you did you forge a lot? Like, isn't that where you go get those big uh

Yeah, so I did for I would say I Here's my uh uneducated thing. I see people who win way too often, it's that strategy. You go

forging and pillaging.

Forging and pillaging is the where

I think Yeah. And I think and that definitely was true for me this game. I think for it to be balanced, it kind of requires everybody to realize those are strong

because then at least keeps it like competitive. Like if you just let one person sit there and run one ore through to get these giant blue pieces, it still does feel a little bit like just almost too good of value.

Like there's that one space where you just spend one ore. It's a three worker space. you got to send a lot of workers,

but then you can just go take like, you know, I got like the anvil and it's like, you know, nine squares or whatever.

Now, I will say they designed those pieces like if you get one of those early,

they're all really obnoxious.

Yeah. With where the bonuses are on the like you like have to decide to cover things up and like they are awkward.

Um but it's still just like so much to fill in, right? Um, but yeah, it's it was nice to play it again. And you know, the more time that passes, the more you start to question things like, is this one of my I think it was in my top 15 or something.

Uh, and yeah, this this play of it made me go, no, this

I I love it and it's so different. Like, it really is one that I think is going to going to stay in my collection. Hopefully over the years I'll have people who will play it with me. Actually, this one I I didn't realize has a board game arena implementation, which is kind of wild with

Oh, wow.

this how crazy this game is. But maybe I'll have to try that sometime because it would be fun just to get to engage with the game a little bit more if I'm not getting to in person. Um

but yeah, it's uh it it stays in my uh Uve Rosenberg Call. It's uh there

as of right now. It's a Gricola, Fast Froen, and Howard Town.

There you go. What's going to be what's going to be the next one going into that? There uh news for news for

I don't know how you pronounce that one.

Yeah, that one has me intrigued. Yeah, let me know below what uh

what's the next game?

U Rosenberg game belongs with those three. Is it newsford? Cuz I think that's the one that I have.

Uh Glass Roads one I considered for a while. They actually made a new what is it? Black Forest or something. That's like a new version of it that uh

well it's

it's it's a it's very much inspired by Yeah. But it seemed like that got kind of mixed

mixed reviews and um but I've heard good things about

Fields of uh

Arla Arla. Yeah.

Yeah. I never played that one.

I got rid of that one too.

You got rid of it before I had the chance to play. You jerk.

No. But u you know there's a point where how many do you need? you know,

when you got around, do you really need another one?

And like they do really have to distinguish themselves and like fit a different scenario because it's like, well, I'm not really looking for a reason to not play these other game, you know, to play a different game instead.

That's the tension with these games. But, uh,

but yeah, Feast Road been in my colles spot. Great games, a great month, and a great opportunity to buy board games. It's the holiday season, folks. So, if uh one of these games inspired you to pick one up for uh your spouse so that you can play it, uh you can click the link below. Uh it supports the channel as well, which is kind of cool. Um, and we've got more videos right here.

Progress saved