Skip to main content
Loading video...

Ironwood, Rebirth, Middle Ages, Klink, Passtally Ranked & Reviewed

Transcript 19:02

hey everybody and welcome to another chairman of the board ranking video this is where I take a look at the last five new to me board games that I've played and I rank and review them in order of preference now just to give this episode a bit more context all of these games are high quality none of them are bad at all there are just slight little things that make me prefer some over the others so even number five here is actually very good but before I get started on the list I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor k.c. who my goto online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order at number five I have Ironwood now this is a two-player only asymmetric game where one player is taking control of this kind of Woodland faction and the other one there iron or metal sty faction and you both have different objectives but you are competing for those objectives on the same board trying to block each other off and fight each other um and so on so so the Woodland objective is to try and kind of fight your way through the woods to find these particular locations based on this deck of cards um expose this totem and then use your troops to kind of carry that totem off to the edge of the board and you're trying to do that three times um and the iron or the yeah the iron characters are trying to build these forges on the edges of the board and by getting troops there building a foundation and then turning it into a forge now the the way that the board is

laid out is very interesting because the Woodland characters can only do that walk through the Woodland areas and the iron characters can move through the mountains but they you kind of have to cross each other's path to get to where you want to go um and you're playing these combat cards uh in order to fight your opponent uh the combat system is is pretty cool um it's a little bit swingy at times and basically you are weighing up the strength of your troops you can add these cards blindly if you want to in a kind of a know a simultaneous bid mechanism um you're competing against your defense value your attack value removing troops if you have any over spill and then you are trying to compete for your dominance what it's called each troop has a dominance value Whoever has the strongest force remaining will either kind of force them away or your opponent away or will of course completely eliminate them from the board entirely what I did like about this game is the fact that your most powerful combat cards are generally your most powerful action cards so it kind of reminded me of a game like War of the Ring where you need to be careful about how you use them um because and you want to be making sure that you have the best actions but also still winning a fair amount of these combats to keep your presence on the board um and all in all this is a very Dynamic game um it can feel a little bit plotting to begin with because you are building up a bit of a force a bit of an infrastructure um and you're not really achieving much so it does have some moments where you are grinding to a halt um but there are some cool elements of surprise and some cool little moves you can do is these cards

have clearly been very carefully thought out and well balanced and I suppose my biggest taking point from this game is how impressed I was with how digestible the rule set is despite it being asymmetric so one of my biggest kind of fears of these styles of games is that it's going to be a massive nightmare to teach because you are teaching two separate games with two different objectives but because those objectives are kind of anchored to the core Foundation of the game really easily or logically then it's actually quite easy for each each player to understand what they're trying to do because the again the two different um ways of winning of each faction make sense and they're they're actually not too much of a deviation from the from each other despite being so different if that makes sense so yeah really impressed with how condensed this game is with how it functions the production value is absolutely insane and not an EAS it Gorge to look at I love this unique style of artwork this kind of realistic cartoon um but the actual physical components are great as well because all of the the Woodland faction all their pieces are wood and all the um Iron faction all their pieces are metal and these are high quality pieces that look fantastic on the board um so this is more of a personal taste thing I can see this one doing extremely well when people get to play it um you know a lot of people who like games like you know like roots or kind of more car driven more Dynamic sty of games are going to

really enjoy this one for me the cards are a little bit too unpredictable you can't really understand what the other player is capable of um unless you play this dozens of times um and the yeah also the the combat is a little bit too again aha too many aha moments rather than being meticulously thought out which is again no fault of the game it's just my personal taste I like to a little bit more autonomy about who's going to win those combats and why um but still very impressive design maybe a little bit too long from what I want for a two-player game because you are looking at around an hour to play this one I kind of like half an hour or less with two play only games um so I knew if I kept hold of this one I would struggle to get it to the table but still design pedigree is very high on this one and if it's worth anything my girlfriend liked this one way more than I do she thoroughly enjoyed it and actually she loved it and her not being much of a gamer you know she's not played many games I think goes to show how easy these rules are to understand considering it is fairly complex and asymmetric but still she managed to Gro the rules very quickly and start to enjoy the game very quickly as well so again more praise there so that is Ironwood a great game but unfortunately not one for me at number four I have P tally so this is an abstract strategy kind of root building Style game that is highly um brain burner if that's a real word and where you are Plus in out these tiles on this communal board each of

these tiles has different roots on them and you are trying to connect two of your little markers on the extremities of this grid by passing through those lines the more tiles you pass through the better and also the higher those Stacks are the better again so you're going to get more and more points if you kind of double up on yourself and go through the highest stacks and it's a race to get to 50 points um super Dynamic of a game you know your everything is changing at all times at one single placement can completely you know derail what you had in mind and of course you and your opponents are playing on that same board so the cross-contamination is there what might help you might completely throw your opponent's plans off and so on um so I tend to like these styles of games where you you know flowing lanes and routes and so on connecting things together this one has that in space it's it's really crunchy as I said my only issue is that it is highly AP prone and you and also like you don't really have much to do when it's not your turn you're just going to sit back and watch your opponent take their turn and take their optimal move which can take some time because the board State can be quite intimidating and overwhelming um but still the Simplicity of the mechanisms is great because all you do is place a to or move your markers um and you are looking around half an hour to play this one maybe a little bit longer if you have very meticulous players um but I think despite me enjoying the experience and appreciating the game I think the

fun Factor might be a little bit lacking it's a little bit too zero some a little bit too transparent on all the different variables um and of course there is actually an optimal placement out there and it's just a matter of trying to find it um which is not the easiest thing to do and and again it can be very AP prone and time consuming so again maybe a little bit too much downtime a little bit too too much scope to lose engagement this one are very attractive but yeah one that I'm not probably going to come back to much more I feel like I've played this one as an experiment and had my fix and um I've probably going to move on from it from now so that is past tally at number four at number three I have clink now this is a party adjacent card game that if I had to describe it I would say is a hybrid between games like cockroach poker mixed with Cabo now this is certainly a contender for surprise of the Year for me because I wasn't sure what to expect with it um but it was tremendous fun so um very simple mechanically all you're going to do is you are going to draw two cards face down you can choose to look at one of those cards and then decide whether you want to keep them for yourself as scoring or pass them on to another player now the objective is to score as few points as possible but there are kind of twists on what you can do because if you end up Ever Getting two of the same number then those cards are going to cancel each other out and

worth be worth nothing so sometimes collecting a high number isn't bad as long as you can get a duplicate and of course eliminate those scorings and additionally if you get a run of three cards you could activate a special power which can completely mess with the other players or of course kind of help your situation um this is a game that where I kind of went in cold it was like I was teaching this to four other players and I could just see that they weren't terribly interested but by the end of it we're all having a tremendous time and I was highly impressed with how easy this was to explain and relay but also how much fun is in that little box so again this could have gone one of two ways because I I really dislike games like cockroach poker I think it's a terrible Design This one is just a complete I don't know reworking of that kind of idea but it adds a bit more game to it and there are some wrinkles because sometimes taking cards for yourself is even if it's not necessarily the best you know the best bunch of cards it can be great because you are in the power seat for the next round and you can decide whether to keep the next cards rather than being at the mercy of the other players because of course once it's gone around all the players and everybody's passed on those cards then the last player is going to be forced to keep those cards and as these scores start to become more and more apparent and people can see who's winning and who's losing uh you can start to kind of conspire with each other and force that player winning who's winning to take

those last cards which again could be bad or could be good for them so yeah this one um definitely going to be a forever keeper for me because there's always going to be a that kind of party situation where you've got kind of Gamers on the periphery of the hobby who've played some games but not not loads um this one's going to satisfy kind of Muggles but also you know more experienced Gamers like myself because there is again there are layers here but it is still built that Foundation of silliness and approach leness as well and even though it does have a little bit of a kind of a spicy vibe to this one because it is you know it's a little bit uh mean at times it doesn't ever feel malicious and it's just again just a real Ruckus fun time so that is clink at number three at number two I have Middle Ages so this is a super lightweight Euro I'd call it kind of an engine builder um As You Are draing in these tiles in a king Domino fashion where each round there's tiles equal to the number of players plus one out there these tiles have numbers on them and you know the higher number you go on will mean that you're lower in initiative value for the next row that you're drafting from so you can plan several turns ahead and try to get the exact tiles that you want uh when you take these tiles you're going to can add them to your little um little board you're going to get the activate the power of that particular tile and then you're going to get money based on how many of those Towes that you've collected at money being your points in this game now

the powers are fairly interesting because they do different things based on they might give you money based on different symbols in your entire kind of Kingdom some of them might let you attack other players based on um of how many tiles you have compared to some of their tiles which is probably one of the most polarizing mechanisms in the game because it can be a little bit destructive because you can't actually force people to um to remove tiles from their board but there are ways you can rebuild them back up um you can increase your engine further by increasing the yield of coins that each location gives you and so on so very condensed almost Gateway level engine building here but the time frame and the time investment is very good in this game I think and I think it's a gorgeous design this is like my tailor made style of artwork kind of has this kind of stained glass medieval look that suits the game perfectly um the component quality is very high everything fits together like a jigsaw puzzle and yeah all in all it's just um very enjoyable quite Charming again be prepared for a bit of take that um but it's fast enough not to really make me feel disgruntled when it happens to me and again there are ways to mitigate that by rebuilding those buildings um you are encouraged to diversify because you're going to lose points based on different tiles that you don't collect but at the same time you are encouraged to stock pile some of the same tiles because each time you do that you're going to really really build up the um the cash Supply that you get at the end of each turn so this is a

reworking of a previous Mark Andre design um I think it was called Majesty for the realm I never played that one so I'm not quite sure of the differences between the two um I think this one's been streamline further from my understanding but again I've not played the original so don't take that or don't don't listen to me I suppose um but yeah this one at the moment um everyone I've played it with has enjoyed it it's again it's super quick doesn't out stay as welcome um at all and I could see this one being an evergreen because it again it doesn't have any bells and whistles it doesn't have any fiddly rules um you can play it in 30 minutes the again the the game of play that you're getting in at 30 minutes is is high quality and the drafting is tense um and there just little wrinkles that you can play with um to interact with your opponents and so on so um it's kind of been a a quiet home run for me really I'm not going to say this is going to be top five of the Year for me but it's it might just breach the top 10 because it is a very pleasant uh game so that is Middle Ages at number two and finally at number one I have rebirth my oh my is this game fantastic so this is kenia's latest kind of root building Style game now if you watch my channel you might know that I'm a huge fan of that genre or style of game especially when the the doctor is is doing it and this one kind of cherry pick bits from his other designs like you know haval landi Babylonia through the desert um all these games but still

manages to make it feel distinct unique um and the quality of game design here is off the chart so definitely going to be a contender if not a shire for Game of the Year for me at this point um it is oh I was super super impressed with everything this game has to offer so gameplay wise super simple you have one time in your hand you can place it on the board on a matching um space or also a kind of a neutral space you are trying to surround these Castle areas the more of your pieces surrounding these castles you'll claim that castle for yourself which will be endgame scoring and you also trying to um kind of build chains of the same symbol because each time you do that they're going to Compound on each other and score you more and more points you're trying to score majorities by populating these towns and cities and if you have the majority you're going to score more points and so on I love the way that there's so much to do but you are pigeonholed to only being able to place one tile at a time now for me I really like that because there are so many different options at all times that having one tile is enough to mull over but I can see that some people might find that a little bit restrictive because you might really want say a population tile to fill up that last space in the city but you just can't draw one for you know just by pure luck I understand that frustration but there are so many other opportunities at all times that doesn't really bother me and it's just something you have to kind of configure into your decision- making and into your strategy now there are other

things going on at the same time through these kind of private or public objectives depending on which map side you're playing on so some might say you know control this particular Castle or know be on the edge of the board four times and so on and so there's so many different conflicting things you're going for and you just want to do everything all at once and despite the board being so open to start with before you know it everything is closed down and those opportunities will start to disappear um as I kind of alluded to before there are two sides of the uh the board here which do offer quite a different experience so you've got the um I think it's Scotland and Ireland I believe so the Scotland map is kind of the simpler of the two where a lot more of the spaces are um more restrictive on what you can do that's the one where you have your private objectives I say the Ireland board is a bit more gamey because there's a bit more free form on what you can do and also the competitive nature is up a little bit more because you are fighting for priority to get those objectives completed to get more points um but for me this is everything I want from ainia um I had high expectations and they superseded those expectations which is quite rare for me to say and dare I say this game has replaced some other kitas that I've I've had um games like hav aandy this one completely just destroys it it cuts his leg legs from underneath that game and I really like haval landi but this one does everything haval landi does but way better um and also games like Samurai it

it kind of reminds me of um as well as games like Babylonia of course so this one for me is like s tier Kia like the best of the best this is up there with the Babalon this is up there with the Raz um it is that good of a design and as I said probably going to be my game of the year could not recommend this one enough if you like the style of games that I do so that is rebirth I'm so happy to have this in my collection this is like the best of the best at number one so there we have it that concludes the video again a high high standard of games here from iWood up to rebirth all solid designs and in fact tremendous designs um if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to the channel and check out my other content too but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved