Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 166: Cosima Werner on Inclusion and German Gaming Culture

Transcript 1:02:32

it's adbreak time the Beyond soliter podcast is proudly sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations and as usual they are up to amazing things they recently concluded a successful campaign on backer kit for eyeball to eyeball a lar about the Cuban Missile Crisis late pledges should be available soon also just a quick plug for myself if you want to support the show and help keep it going uh please do go to patreon.com beond soliter which pays for all of my hosting and subscriptions associated with the podcast and channel uh thank you so much for listening and let's get on with the show hey Gamers this Liz Davidson from beond soliter and I'm here in the Pod this week with a very special guest this is Dr Kim M verer she is a postto in cultural geography at the University of ke how you doing today cosma I'm doing very fine how are you I'm doing great I'm so happy that we've managed to make this work across many time zones because you are in Germany right now right but it's noon for me it's early morning for you don't worry normal for me normal for me um but um you study America and Americans so could you give us a background on that and how that started in your academic life well um this is longer story so I've always been interested in geography so geography is my background I a geography by training I did my undergrad and master's program in geography and the first time I've been to the US was in 2012 and I did an exchange semester in Minnesota which was different but I then

I went also to Detroit and Detroit became my favorite place to be and still is so I'm very excited to be back in Detroit by end of the month which is great however um Detroit is fascinating for me as a geographer because you are in the city and you wonder what happened in that City and this was in 2012 before the city declared bankruptcy um so I'm now seeing the development of that City and um there's so much ongoing on social inequalities uh that is in your face it's so much showing how space and inequalities uh are connected and back in the day in the day I was focusing on Urban gardening and as many people may know Detroit is a perfect spot to for M gardeners uh so I've done this and then I realized that M gardeners have a problem with uh convenience stores which makes sense when you consider only the food consumption and the products that they serve to the communities however going to a convenience store is also being in a social uh social interconnection with the people and the people um dealing with the issues that they facing in their daily basis and they use convenience stores on so many different levels however I then focus on uh convenience stores and spend seven

months in convenience stores in Detroit and Chicago and did ethnographic research meaning uh participant participatory research and interviews and yeah this was my dissertation actually and then being confronted with the aspect of race so much I was interested in how I could continue the aspect of race but looking more into the German context and this is what I'm now doing and this is where the board games are coming in yeah I love it all right just just a quick convenience for question just because it's so much a part of American culture then we can get to more games so how do you participate in an ethnographic study of convenience stores like do you just go like eat the hot dogs and the bad Pizza like everybody and hang out or do you have to be more academic about it than that no so uh one person once suggested me I should rent a car and park in front of the convenience store and be able to escape at any time well I'm a white female person so I'm seen I can hide my Identity or anything uh and this is uh but I'm a stranger being a stranger in ethnographic research can has uh can have some some meaningful uh it's a meaningful position it can mean you have Advantage like you are stranger people trust you because you're a stranger and you're leaving with all the secret that they give you

or you're you are seen as an outsider and you never come close to them so both of it happens at the same time so some people like you some people don't H however uh doing it is means like being in the store con having conversation with the people uh I I've been to people's home um and in the Detroit I spent a lot of time at the parking lot in front of the convenience store and I went with the people to EV to music events and stuff and as soon as or as long as they were comfortable having me around I was comfortable with them as well and yeah we had uh a lot of exchange of thoughts and minds and cultural exchange and yeah that's it pry cool okay so it sounds like your experiences with convenience stories made you interested in the issue of race and how it impacts our spaces and our kind of little smaller cultural groups so how did that interest awaken for you and what is it in America that made it happen uh so America oh no I go from the German perspective Germany has a very different um position and very different debates on race and the meaning of race and the discussion heated up in 2021 in the or 20 20 in the

aftermath of the George Floy protests that also occurred in Germany so there was a lot of uh protesting against police violence um and also a shift in the debate like more and more afrer people uh raised the the voices and said this is happening to us as well maybe not as brutal when it comes to police violence but it happens here on the daily basis as well a racism is part of our everyday experiences um and uh and this is a very powerful voice that these people make um but still there's this denial of oh we are not in America this is different um look at America it's even worse in America so it's part of the American Social DNA you know but using this comparison you always deny that this is existing for us or we don't have to handle it because look at the Americans it's worse there I'm like this is not very nice and it's shy away the problem that we have and um I'm using actually a lot of the American debate to see how can we transfer this to the German context so I use terms of whiteness uh I use the terms of white fragility um and I I'm very much influenced by a lot of American Scholars

to see how this is transferable to the German context because what we also saw in the debate on uh on racism in Germany is that there there was a transaction of the concept of whiteness and racism one to one from the ger American context to German context but the empirical insights are missing the Empirical research is somehow missing um Germans tend to use research on migration or people with migration backgrounds uh we even have different terms so um but they always share a way to touch their own nose and say like how how is the German population like we have very difficult terms that I'm not like to use so I try to avoid it but how is the society that is living in Germany also uh participating or yeah opening up for new people coming in uh and migration is a story of Germany so it always existed lucky uh interestingly we have um there's a statistics on the German population count it's a governmental statistics and before the 1990s they even didn't consider foreigners uh listed in their statistics so uh they started after that uh to have have terms like foreigners in the third generation or foreign born or this kind

of uh difficult connotation that we use and yeah and I think whiteness is uh not so much covered in research at all in Germany um and we are always pointing on other people so there's a lot of othering so they don't integrate they don't speak the language they don't come up with the standards uh to reach in when it comes to income uh educational levels and so on it's always they and I'm not a fan of this so I thought about how do we as me i' I am a white person white middle class person so I can when I say we I I referring to German people who you know where I I'm the norm you know I I would be considered the norm I would be consider considered the standard so when I call when I say we I mean these people that are considered the standard in the German Society so and to research this I focus on hobbies and the hobbies that I'm looking at are board games and Hiking okay so basically like pretty pretty white Hobbies if we're being very stereotypical uh although obviously in the American board game scene we're really really trying to make that change so what Drew you to Hobbies as a way to kind of get at whiteness and as a way to study it so we have a lot of studies

that tell us that we have a lot of barriers in school in school education and how they are selected and how segregation is going on we have also studies on segregation in cities um and in these studies there's also they're Al always problematized so the segregated areas are problematize as uh being very poor where social statistics are relatively poor considered to other areas and so on same with uh educational levels um and I'm like yeah but there are also daily daily practices or spheres of the daily life where we don't have exchange with people of different um cultures or backgrounds or social backgrounds so the diversity is missing in a lot of bubbles so I'm referring to the term of bubbles um that is somehow a social space uh where people meet and I'm using Hobbies because officially everybody could join a hobby everybody can choose their own hobby when we read piu then we know it's a distinction of your social class and so on so it's even more it's a it tells you where you are in your social position uh but this understanding is not so prevalent in the Hobbies itself like everybody says like oh everybody

can join everybody can come to our uh board game night at that meeting at that cafe or whatever so everybody's like super open and I'm like yes you're promoting an openness but on the same way you are very homogeneous the heterogenity is Miss the diversity is missing the diversity of perspectives are missing so many times and I'm like yeah but everybody could join so why isn't that that people you know like to stay with their uh own people of Their Own Kind so because I I would say that that's a conversation that board gamers on all levels of the hobby n up at Academia you know have been having like well everybody could come the meet Up's public so this must be self- selecting like maybe other people just don't want to play board games or you know this happen you know I'm a woman in board gaming right so it's like maybe women just don't want to play board games maybe women just aren't interested in the kind of stuff board games are about but I mean if you go to larger conventions or look at other parts of the scene that's definitely not true so how do we end up with an inclusive yet exclusive situation in our hobby this is a historical perspective I think on one as so let's TR differently um when I use the term of a bubble so we can choose bubbles we can go to different bubbes we can't leave bubbes and so on and we do this all the time so people changing

Hobbies all the time yeah uh some stay some don't and it's be and hobbies are a bubble where you have positive experiences that you love that you have passion for that you enjoy so much and that you're giving um you're investing time you're investing money you are uh you're enthusiastic about it and so on so it's a very positive thing as soon as you don't like the people anymore you leave you go out or as soon as you know that's the perfect thing it's different with schools so it's a voluntary practice you do it because you love it uh and when you love it more and more you even become more like of these um Specialists that we have in the scene so so I think there is a making of such Bubbles and these makings could be rules or Customs or rituals or you know a way of language um a way of Social Capital a thing of um cultural capital and economic capital and so on so there's a kind of making of such Bubbles and and somehow new board gamers are and in these bubbles so I talk to uh board gamers um I've been to various conventions I've been to private uh board game groups I've been on the board

game cruise for four days and so on so I've been to VAR things for This research to to see like how do you become a board gamer so the story is usually the same maybe it's like oh my my parents had this closet full with sport games and we used to play a lot and my granny and so on they played with us a lot and then there's a somehow a gap uh because then they become adults or teenagers and then they may lose the interest or they have their friends with whom they can play magic cards or with whom they play extensively other games whatever usually settas or Katan is always mentioned as a turning point for most of the inter part Partners this is where everything changed and settlers of Katan or as it now called Katan uh is that the scene changed so much and the Publishers uh opened up for adults as a new group that they could Target on um so but we can look at the making of such Bubbles and uh and the making is like that we have in Germany uh de uh um game of the year which was announced two weeks ago a week ago um or in the 70s and 80s there was a lot of these instit institutionalization of um of the scene so we have we have

the Spiel as at the fair we have the Spiel theas we have various magazin that came up in the late 90s uh late sorry late 70s and and early 80s uh we had the um um play by post play by mail games as well that you know the purple review one of the first fan magazines was from this uh from this development same as in the US so uh Aaron TR he talks about the same uh processes in the US but he says it's much earlier like he starts in the 50s basically basally with white flight to suburbs um with the war game scene and the model train scene um I see some connection to the model train scene in Germany not so much to the war game scene because war games were not so much uh uh welcomed or you know promoted in uh world war after the World War 2 period in Germany so um and many many many people who have been active in the um in the um gaming scene in the 70s and 80s are coming from the peace movement so there was some resistance so it's very much like this it starts way later than in the US um or it skips some parts maybe like this um

but games have always been around like in every culture I think there's no culture that never developed any games um but yeah so it started much later and this starts like the 70s and then uh with the changes in the in the genre of the games of the Euro games or the German tabletop games uh it's changed so much and created so much more Community um and then with the online presence of board game gigs and so on it's um developed even or became much bigger and more diverse so we have to ask this question of diversity is a new question to the to the community um and I'm very excited to be in the middle of it to see how this is is going to develop yeah absolutely so when you are you know you mentioned you went to game nights you went to people's homes you went on cruises so are you playing or are you only observing the games so I'm playing but I'm not a board gamer I have to admit so my collection of board games is very limited it's like if it would be 20 would be already yeah would be a love a lot but uh the most games I got uh in the last uh last year actually so I people make them as a present to me uh so I get them or uh I was at the Berlin convention recently so I bought new two new games and my

brother is actually sometimes playing but he has also a small collection of maybe 30 games but uh so he I became his expert now because I'm now dealing with the new releases the new published games so I know oh let's check this out oh no this is too complicated for me so it's just a different one Al so we have more conversation on board games than I ever had my family yeah so I'm not a board gameer you're not a board gamer I'm not I'm I I so so I made some jokes so I've talked to one board gamer he has like 150 Plus plus games but he is selling a lot of games so he is one of my interviews and I keep him updated on how I develop as a board gamer which was like uh that I was sitting at my table and learning the rules of the the of a game and I invited people uh to my home to play with me the games um but the complexity of the game is very low so I tried spirit I tried Spirit Island I'm sorry it's too hard for me it was a three hours questioning of what can I do now how do I can play this now and what the heck do I have to do this right this and I'm like yeah so I have to develop more and more and uh would have invest much more time uh into it to become a board gamer

but I have my own Hobbies I have different obies that I white too so all right so here's the question then uh when you are asking people questions about the board gaming hobby to what extent do they know that you're interested in talking about gaming and whiteness or do you just ask like generic questions and see what they say and pull information from that so um this is a this is a good question so whiteness has using the term of whiteness has a tendency to explode the entire conversation yes that's what I want to know people can have the understanding that I'm researching racism or even worse that I would call them as a racist what I'm not doing um so and this is this has a potential for explosion and if an interview is taking place with such presum presumptions on what I'm going to talk their entire interview is um is invalid I can't use it or it might be you know to have have I have discussions with my interviews on you know how appropriate is to to exoticize people like in the game of Bor b or how appropriate it is to have Colonial practices in Santa Maria or Puerto Rico Mombasa you name it there so many around so I have this discussion

within the interviews yes but this is coming up after a while so usually it does differently um and what I I say and this is very much true I'm interested who is in The Hobby and then who is in The Hobby is also the question who is not in the Hobby and why is that and then you have a lot of discussions or people say like oh they come from a culture they where they don't play I'm like I'm not so sure or women are not interested in playing uh because is to you know I don't know you know these stereotypes maybe better than I do but there are a lot of stereotypes of but always like oh they they don't and instead of oh we are not opening enough or we have created a space where people might sense that whiteness is uh is um convenient or that being white is an entrance Point somehow of like so this is um I work with the concept of Sarah Ahmed uh the phenomen phenomenology of whiteness where she's actually stating that people create a social space where they have a high social uh motility which is a bodily ability to move freely and confident somehow confident uh in such spaces in new

spaces um it's a difference and she's uh this this point in her article um when a a person of color is in a space of a lot of white people it feels different for them and for a white person I feel it also feels different with the presence of people of color um or people I assume they could be Jewish or people who could be you know different uh we have this with man's talk in the locker room it's different when women come into such spaces so and this is what the argument basically is of Sarah ahed to point out that you know for social orientation and for for it's easier in the daily in on the daily Spa on the daily basis it's easier to have such space where I don't have to deal with irritations that might be very subtile so nobody's saying oh I don't like to have to hear people of color this is not what they say but there is a there is a subtile notion which might be uh in senses and feelings and uh how to communicate with others and that's very interesting because I'm white and the interview partner that I have most of them are white so as soon as I so for instance I've been to the German Masters Club there

were 38 teams I think and each team consists of four players 18% of them were women so not every team had one woman in their team uh and there were some people of color a handful um and I approached them I talked to them I've played with them I went to their home and I played with them it was a very lovely night um and yeah so we have this discussion a lot um I have it with them a lot especially how they feel in such spaces um and it's very interesting and these are people of color that are not uh necessarily black but they sometimes think oh am I not white so I'm like well in the German context you might you might be othered because they have a background that is uh not European so yeah so it sounds like what we're kind of getting at is that it's people find it more convenient sometimes to not have to be considerate of others and so when you have somebody join your group who you feel like you have to be sensitive to their feelings or mindful of what you say in a way that maybe you didn't think you had to in the locker room with all the Bros like suddenly people just kind of want to avoid that yeah and I think yeah I think

it's for when your hobby is about Joy and not about irritation not to think about of you know so board gamers have a tendency to focus on their board games and the mechanics so the social interactions are sometimes very limited so I have I know people that even don't know uh other people's name even after the second evening at the private home um and and when we go from this so this is very interesting uh I think it's it is super interesting to leave strangers to your home and most ball Gamers play at their homes so how do you decide to let people in your home so I have one female interview partner she is considering who how she's dealing with this so she has a daughter she is a single mom and she loves board gaming but she is more carefully on how she's organizing her the the gaming night at her space at her private space and she's thinking about the security of her child so no other interview partner especially not the man NE ever ever mention such issues so um but this aspect of security and having strangers at your home you know for most people my home is my castle uh it's about trust and familiarity and trustworthiness so um

and this is very subtle we so trust is a very interesting concept I think um to think about because it's so irrational so you know we have made experiences in our life that we barely can recall that tell us why we why we mistrust someone or why we are suspicious about someone or why we like someone or not it's you know we fell in love easily to people and trust them with everything and in the richual perspective we always can say oh trust wasn't reasonable to give because there was something you know but we do trust people all the time uh in the supermarket in the train station in buses and uh our work colleagues our families and friends so uh trust is very interesting and when you think about who's allowed to be in your private space at home is very who's is very interesting so the you have this Dimension but then there's also this other dimension which I really appreciate about board gaming is that your personal background does not matter so much meaning if you have a political controversial perspective on you you might be you know rightwing person or very conservative and you're sitting with a liberal person at one table you may not know because you all focus on the board game and you

leave um so to the board game conventions for instance I've been by my own which is interesting to be there by yourself because you know promoters won't explain you the game because you're by yourself but the last day I went with a person who is in a difficult mental state at moment and he agreed to join with me and it was perfect so we played uh we played botanicus um a new game and he and it didn't it didn't matter so you know I asked for the people's name who joined us to play so we were four people in the end and uh it was a lot of uh fun and nobody asked about his mental state which is problematic at moment for himself like it's not problematic that the people didn't ask but it's problematic that he is in this situation but nobody cared nobody asked for and this is also a good thing um and in the board gaming scene we have a lot of people who H who are neurologically diverse uh who deal with autism or other things um and what I experienced at the board game cruise with like 250 people there was no flirting and for me as a woman this was interesting it's not that I'm always engaged in flirts but um

where you didn't have to convince someone with your appearance or with your thoughts or with your minds or World perspective you didn't have to convince someone to like you which is somehow interesting I think and uh so it's social and unsocial in the same time and this is a very interesting Dynamic I think that the board game scene is offering so and it's open and closing also in the same moment so they say it's seems to be contradictionary but somehow it fits together oh that's really interesting thing about um you know actually I often recommend board games to people who are socially anxious because it's like well you don't have to do anything but play the game if you don't want to um but at the same time some of my very best friends now that I actually do share confidences with are people with whom I have played games for a long time um so in your chapter um that I fumbled through as well as I could um board games um create a sense of family how do you how do you get that kind of family feeling if you maybe don't even know the next person's name or don't necessarily care about people's personal lives play yeah this is interesting um and I think this is this sense of um oh there's this German term Goran height meaning uh there's this

warm feeling of oh everybody is so nice and everybody you know is respecting you and so on um so at this board game cruise for instance I have this one interview I interviewed him after uh after the board game truise and he organize a Bard game convention a little one and he's like all about it like he's super enthusiastic and this enthusiastic feeling is carrying him through for at least for a few weeks it's like it's resonating with him as harmut Rosa would call it so it's resonating in the way that he's like super enthusiastic about it and this is also connected to the people of the atmosphere to so he like what um what got him very much was that he was considered as someone explaining board games so he will become a I don't know how you say this in English a clair bear so he's a explaining bear at the convention and you know so it basically gives him a sense of of importance because people rely on him to teach yes and this and this is what teachers also experience a lot when PE when they feel like oh they understood what I said and then they tell you oh you did it very well so he was recruited for the next board game cruise to be the one who's going to explain the board games and uh he and he recall that

people always said like he's very good at it and this is so I wouldn't say man's planning but I know do so men explaining the world to someone is many times it's the men so but many men are also in the board gam so I'm not I don't want to dismiss the females uh in the hobby that do great work and also explaining other people games um but there's is this positive energy that they experience that they appreciated that they seen for the qualities that they have and that they can uh use their qualities uh in their in their hobby so some might be very good at designing board games others are very good in explaining them and so on others are very good in bringing people together so they have different skills that they can use in various formations so and this positive energy that they have with other people is very important to have the sense of goren height to have this sense of familiarity familiarity which is familiarity is a part of trust being familiar with your with the settings with the practices with uh other people and so on is very important to have this um this ability you know to organize a

convention to be confident enough uh to be welcomed in the uh in the scene and then this can easily lead to the sense of we are a family and The Bard gam creu they had a a shirt in their shop I don't know if they still have it that says we are family and uh nobody was wearing it uh on the on the cruise but there was this sense of familiarity and being within being with people of your own kind so it's same with the family uh fam is the ideal perspective of a family is that the people of Their Own Kind who are supportive who encourage you to do things and so it's a very ideal and romantic way of family it's has nothing to do with the uh realistic sense of family that a lot of people experience that family members can be also very challenging and critiquing you all the time and bullying you or you can have bad experiences families and so on so it's a very ideal and romantic way to that they from of a family that they use for their hobby so basically we have people who maybe are not wanting to even necessarily share too much of their personal lives in other environments getting affirmation and positive feedback from what they're able to contribute to board gaming so I can teach a game I have the coolest game I'm going to bring it everybody's gonna play with me um you know I'm good at games

and so you know when I play really well people give me a high five after and say that was a great move um and so there are some people who are constantly getting that like yes this is these are my people board game people are my people Vibes for board gaming all the time I would say that happens for me a good chunck of the time as well but when we think about people like us I kind of think of it as board game people or teachers and I would say that most I mean just to kind of clarify before we get into talk about how this always ends up being so many white people like do board gamers perceive people of Their Own Kind like well anybody who likes board games can play through do they perceive themselves as inclusive yes they do they so I have one interview he is a journalist he's he's a journalist for in south of Germany and he's so I'm not naming any people because they're my interview Partners so I keep them Anonymous um although you might find them easily and so on um but this is what people can do on their own and might think if I was talking about them or not however he was talking about his um his crowd that is coming together uh weekly on a weekly basis in his in not his but in Family Cafe where they play and um I asked him who's coming to your to this Cafe and he says oh normal PE or random people like everybody is coming

so you have uh people with uh special interests like autistic people uh you have a a lot of people who come from mathematics fields or in informatics or in computer studies and so on so a lot of uh a lot of academics and a lot of people from natural science so I'm a talkative person so I'm not a good fit for the academic uh for the to represent the academics in the field um and then he is saying like and then you have oh and and then he's saying it's very funny and then he says like oh and there are two women they are very normal women uh very normal people uh they also come I'm like yeah okay so this is interesting but if you think of who is listed or who is not listed it's very interesting so he's listing a lot of academics a lot of men and then he all a sudden oh there are also two women uh who are very normal apparently and autistic so there's a bunch of people who's not coming and I see this like a lot of board game may see yes there are a lot of men yes a lot of people have have an academic background and there a lot of them in natural science or Computer Science Tech studies and so on so there is somehow a connection to this um you actually you also have a lot of

people who work with children or who are working in church who work in community services or social work these this is also a big group that is basically not considered but there's a bunch of people who's interested in in board games as a social instrument for bringing people together um or helping people develop social skills and so on there's a lot of these people and there's a lot of discourses also academic discourses of the meaning of games in uh in learning social skills for instance but so so this interview partner coming back to him would say we are very open so a very diverse group and would somehow agree yes it's somehow a very diverse group but somehow it's not a very diverse group and and this diff this changes immediately as soon as you come to the organizational levels so if you look at who is podcasting who is blogging who is blogging who is organizing conventions who are the board game designers uh who are in the in the jury of the of all the awards that exists who is who is uh presenting a new prototype uh who is on stage um and on the world game convention there was a a a pup pup quiz so there were several podcasters uh

formed up in teams and they were uh competing against each other and then there were a lot of questions so like who won the game of the year award twice or who whatever so all these kind of um scen questions but none of these questions ever covered a female so that's no nobody asked for who was uh the publisher of wingspan or whatever you know so because they don't know and it's so many times it was very interesting the Berlin convention and I think there's a a live stream of this there was a debate on the hobby um of the inside of the Hobby and someone asked oh we need a female woman went up to the microphone and asked the uh the uh the plenum for more representation and diversity in the representation and um and then the discussion started oh yeah and there are females and then blank so someone of who was on stage couldn't name a female person uh who is big in the entire field so but everybody can name a ton of men who you know who won multiple Awards and so on and if you look and this is what I've done yesterday which is very interesting uh to look on the uh nominees and the the

award winners ofas since it's existed the first award was given I have to check it the first award was given to Susan McKinley um in 2011 and this relatively late so it is it's continues like this yeah if you look on who is uh doing the revisions on board games in if it's online or in magazines and so on there isn't a lot of diversity to be honest it it's different on the conventions yes I totally agree you have more people of color and you have uh homosexual people who you have uh and so on there a lot of stuff going on but in Germany it's also very German centered so uh German speaking centered so Germany became such an important market for board gamers internationally that a lot of international uh designers look at the German Market but the German Market is not so look so much looking on other spaces and then board games like what Rico will become very popular elsewhere like in the US and in in Canada and all the sudden there's a j Perez saying well there some difficulties with the games and did you ever think about the colonial uh the reproduction of the colonial practices not only references but practices that

appear in the game and this the game was existing for 20 years and nobody ever cared about it or not so prominent as as recently or like in the few few years and this is because of the more International Market I have I've interviewed someone he's a German board game designer but he lives in Indonesia uh he lives in Jakarta and we talked about the Indonesian board game scene and or I also uh had contact with a board game designer a female she created a game um cat Tua cat Tua means old city quarter which is a colonial City quarter uh in Jakarta so actually I have an interest in Indonesia very much so if I'm not in Detroit I'm in Indonesia so uh however we were talking about the scene there and they are looking at the German market and the Euro game styles uh and they copying it and yeah this is very interesting I think how they dealing with you know know when you have such a game like cat Tua you are dealing with Colonial narratives very much and how do they reproduce this or change it or how it this changing it's very interesting it's to completely fascinating but it's never going to be seen in the German Market ever or maybe in 10 years but yeah yeah there's so much more going on

internationally it's interesting well it's really interesting that you bring this up because I feel like a lot of times when we talk about Euro games in America you know games that are kind of of the more German style stereotypically uh that often do have these Colonial themes that are considered insensitive over here uh people say oh well you know just Europeans view it differently the Europeans perspective is just different um to what exent is that changing if at all uh in the wake of interactions with other markets so there was one incident last year at the German board game Masters Cup in boheim and I've been there uh and one of the games that was played was East Indian companies and yes this has very much a colonial uh continency and practices and so on so there are a lot of aspect that are problematized and for me as a research it's my task to problematize and criticize uh such continues um I cannot say oh it's not a problem it's I it's not my positionality um but um actually one of the participants he wrote his master thesis on board games and in Germany we have this huge debate if board Gap should become a cultural heritage uh if so it would mean some

benefits for the designers and so on and um and so we have this debate um and in his uh Master's thesis he was also pointing or mentioning the aspect of colonialism that appears in a lot of German published games and and he was critical about it and he sent to the organizers of the of the master Club he sent his master CES to say like U you may think about when you choose the games because it's not a vote of you know players vote the games but there's a committee who's selecting a team and they are um talking back to to clubs to board game clubs to think about what game could be played which is a good fit so it's up to them to choose the games it's not you know it's not oh the the crowds selected this game or whatever it's not like this um so the the the the author of this master thesis uh sent this thesis to the organizers and they pronounce announc this oh this might be a problematic is controversial we should come up with a controversial statement to this and he did uh so the organizers were saying oh well we have to think about it and thank you very much this thoughtful um and someone from the audience was yelling oh this is all so this is the German take so there is

this some people discuss it they at the edge I would say and then there are some people who completely deny the importance of the discussion and you even you're even not coming close to the to the discussion of why it could be problematic um it's not only that you have workers who might be slaves or uh but also the practices and then you have in so many more games where you don't have colonialism as such but the representation of local communities uh the exoti of others that's a continuous thing um because exoticism is a selling point for the German Publishers they're not locating a lot of these issues to the German context or european context because it's not exotic enough so there's a responsibility of the Publishers to make it interesting yeah so that's the task of the publishers that a German context or something different could be interesting so we have dogs we have you know fantasies and so uh we have daily things daily practices University could be a perfect problematic you know thing you could play have as a narrative in the board game um so but if you deny s so such a person who is yelling this is all is actually saying we don't

need to have this conversation because it's just a game and and people who talk about board games like you do and aan treml does or marcoo and so there are so many others who take it serious or Mary fandan and mik Jacobson and so they take it serious and say like oh it is a culture product and as such we have to treat it and we do the same with books and we do the same with uh music and with movies why don't we do this with board games so it has a it has a importance in daily life because it reproduces uh um Power structures and it reproduces stigmatizations it reproduces uh a lot of or it legitimizes a lot of practices uh that people are tired of and a lot a lot and suffering under it because of Oppression and so on yeah so feelings of family that some people are getting like they're not transferring to people who aren't allowed to be part of the conversation yeah it's um yes it is so when you have this in the family someone says like oh we don't discuss this anymore this is like this is a very old fashion uh attitude that you know this

was very popular until the 1970s after second world war to deny oh we don't talk about it we don't talk about problems and there is no need to discuss this and we shut this discussion down immediately and you find these comments similar comments uh also in the internet um there are so many you know reactions to Puerto Rico or the former version of Sky mindes which is Mombasa and so on there are so many comments um by ious people who say oh we don't need to have this discussion and it was never I never meant to do harm um and I think yes nobody wants to do harm but if someone steps on your foot and and say you are on my foot you better leave but if you remain standing you don't care and then you do harm and I think you have to really think about and to listen to people who criticizing it and it's not always black people it's also other people who have different P World Views and perspectives um yeah I can see that you that board gamers uh judge games for the mechanics I can see that many many times but it's this is a very yeah superficial argument I think

if you think about and I think it's Sabina Hara who speaks about identity terorism when you are a colonialist invading another country and you don't want to be the oppressed person you know you don't want to be the the losers and using quotation marks um you don't want to be the ones who you know are inferior because it's not so much fun you want to be the one who is Conquering and who is success eding and successful and that's more fun apparently because we want to deal with the Positive feelings in cases you've been so how do we get from you know everyone's welcome see I told everyone they were welcome to actual inclusivity like what is the path to get us from where we are now to like what we say we want to be I think there is a thing so whom are you letting to your house and then you ask oh how do I recruit new Gamers it starts on a very small circle start in your daily basis so um and I have a lot of people they they send around on eBay they send around messages and they asking for new or looking for new players sometimes they ask their neighbors or they ask the children their parents of their children's uh friends

and so on yeah so they asking people of Their Own Kind they're having cont they may have contact to people of different social backgrounds but they are not inviting them to their homes they are not creating relationships um with them so and I think we have to have we have to create relationships and then we can you know and to think about oh I know the person who's running a convenience store convenience stores are not stigmatized in Germany as much as they are in the US uh I know his person's name many times they from the Middle East or from Turkey but I don't know more and I'm not inviting them to my house I'm not asking them to be part of the board game round and there is a spot empty or open so someone couldn't fit in so who am I asking to join to fit that to fill that space and um and if we always think about people of Our Own Kind which is convenient uh for the daily basis uh I think we have to start there to think about how do we actually make relationships with people of different social backgrounds and do we invite them to our places and are we open you know you have to have a lot of openness um I have to have a lot of openness to to join other people's homes uh to invade

some of invading the board game scene at the moment uh to you know to be to become a part of the scene at moment which I'm doing um openness and uh I think is very helpful in general all right so with that I think it's a good place to stop the serious conversation we're gonna have a couple just little soft questions one I know you're not a board gamer although I'm I think anybody who plays games as a gamer I'm have an open definition of this what board game have you played during your research that you really really did

like I realized that I really hate bopi I played a couple of times again so I I I can see it now that it's really a shitty game or you know it's um they're better mechanics um what game have I played oh I have played I have played a children's game that I really really liked it's called I think mole hill it's about moles it's lovely it's the only game I won at the board game Cruise because four days I played games for four days I didn't win any game except this one so I had a very good relationship to this game I bought it for myself afterwards I played with my family so so it's a children's game so I go very basic I'm not into the EUR game so much because I I've I've played some games but I what I'm not a fan of is like you're by yourself and after two hours you look up and you count your points and realize okay your strategic plan didn't work out uh because you haven't considered so many things I can see that's intriguing and CH and interesting to see but um I'm more a social person yeah yes although what you describe sounds great to me because I'm a solo gamer but yeah I I I I played Cascadia in the

solo uh mode to be able to explain it to my brother yeah well maybe I haven't played the right game yet this is probably what the most listeners would say now oh you have to play this game uh this will change your mind completely yes yes it'll happen one day I te I Che um uh and then if people want to follow your work online uh where can you be found if anywhere um you can find me on LinkedIn uh looking for kimar Vera and you can always Google me and you will find my homepage of the University which is University minus ke.

deima I don't know exact actually but you can Google me there are not so many kuas around that uh do research on board games fair enough fair enough K thank you so much for coming on the show this been a much apprciate it same thanks and good luck for your continuing uh work and I think it's very meaningful to have also the academic perspective on board games working on it all right for everybody out there if you want to find me online I'm everywhere as on Soler uh and do please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy Ging

Progress saved