Board Game Highlights Episode 8: Mean Games Edition!
Transcript
Hello everyone. I'm Tally. This is Frell. And we're Border It. And welcome to Bord of Board Game Highlights episode 8.
So we're going to cover what we've been playing lately that was of particular interest to us and therefore hopefully you. And it could almost be called the cutthroat special as many of these games are exceptionally mean.
But then there are a few which break that rule. So we'll stop short of calling it that.
The partial cutthroat special.
Exactly. But we will begin with one of our most played and one of our favorite games, Root, and in particular the new expansion that has just come out. We've recently broken Routt back out and this is because of the new expansion, the Homeland expansion. So, this comes with three new factions and two new maps and also some new landmarks and other little bits. And uh I think we've had a great time playing it. So,
Routt is the famous at this point cutesy but brutal asymmetrical war game where every player has a completely unique faction that plays in a different way and scores points in a different way but follows some kind of few simple core basic rules. Uh but the complexity comes in that you really need to know what your opponents are doing because you need to know how to stop them. Yes.
Because if you don't stop the other players, then you can get runaway winners.
Mhm.
So yeah. Have you enjoyed playing the new factions?
Yes. Well, firstly, it was nice to have uh an excuse to get Route back out again. I would say it is one of our most played games, which is just surprising cuz sometimes there can be big lengths of time when we're not playing it, but then I feel like when we do get it back out because there's an expansion, then we're kind of playing it over and over.
So, A, very nice. B, yes, definitely enjoyed. Well, I only played one of the factions out of the three. Played it a couple of times. You played all three. Very much enjoyed them. So, I played as the lily pad. Daspora and yeah, it's an interesting challenge to navigate with them because there's kind of a cap on the amount of points that you can ever score per round. So I what I find with them the most is there's a real balancing act because they put out tokens on the board which are peaceful enclaves, but the enclaves can also turn militant and it kind of depends in what state they're in as to what else will happen. So it's easier to well you have they have to be militant to recruit more warriors for example but then you are scoring for the ones that are peaceful. So I found it quite difficult to navigate balancing that because there's ways you could go about it. You know just accept that you're not going to score many points in the beginning in the efforts to get more warriors out because they're militant. But then you might get behind because you can only score x amount per round. Or you could just try to keep everything peaceful with max chances of scoring for the peaceful enclaves, but then you're probably going to lose some points from like battling and yeah, you won't be able to get as many warriors out, so you're going to lose your pieces more easily. Real balancing act. So
could be frustrating is a bit the wrong word because it's still very enjoyable to play, but yeah, it was pretty tricky to go about it in the right way, I would say. But no, it's fun. Yeah, I think the thing with them, yeah, because their kind of main goal scoring is capped at four points per round and it is semi easy to be getting three or four from the beginning. Yeah.
But yeah, you really they're really dependent on getting some points from crafting, getting some points from destroying other people's buildings and tokens. And to do that, you're going to need Milton, which then obviously, like you said, you can't score. So it can be quite tricky to I I guess get ahead from other factions that have big turns.
Yeah.
So I played all three of them and the other two, the uh Twilight Council and the Naves of the Deepwood were both fun. So, the Twilight Council are a bit like a kind of peacekeeping force where they essentially want to be in control of the clearings and this allows them to have governing assemblies. So, they have assemblies and they're either closed or governing. And when they're governing, it restricts what other players can do in that region. So, it means they can't build stuff. They can't put tokens down and all this. Uh, which is quite interesting. But the trick is they need other players pieces to be there to score.
So it's a little bit of a game of making sure you have enemies where your buildings are, but making sure you're in control of that clearing. And it was kind of a very interesting balancing act. So they were good fun. Uh and I think they're kind of a nice more simple one because you're trying to build up a big force in a few like a couple of clearings. uh which is a more easy goal I think than some of the others. So they're a good starter one as well I would say.
Don't you think they're quite quite similar to the to the frogs in that regard, right? Where you could get some points here but then you can't do something else.
Yeah.
Do you know what I mean? There's always a a tradeoff.
Yeah. They're not really interested in in battling necessarily. And that there's an interesting trade-off in that they can probably craft fairly easily, but you don't want to because you kind of need the right cards to do a lot of what you want to do and you kind you either craft or you get to draw like cards.
Yeah.
So, it's a very interesting balance that you're restricting yourself one way or the other. Then, finally, the naves of the deepwood are a new vagabond faction essentially. Uh, so you can't play them if you're playing the Vagab Bond, but what they are is a set of three captains. The captains have special powers and they work like Vagab Bonds. So they exhaust items for actions. They're popping in and out of the forest. And essentially what you're doing with your team of skunk warriors is you're popping out, you're hitting people over the head, you're dragging them into the forest, and then you're scoring points from them. And you're also getting points from dropping tokens all over the board, bragging about how you did. Uh, I think they're a lot of fun to play, at least thematically. I probably found them the least interesting out of the three, but maybe that will change as more plays. Just that
it seemed like turn to turn it was more or less the same thing, whereas the others post more interesting considerations and problems.
Uh, but we'll see. So, yeah. And then there's also two new maps. One which is for more players, which we didn't get the most out of. When I say that, I mean like five, six players. Uh, and then there was a gorge which is a new more standard map and that was really brilliant. We really enjoyed that in how it changes up the considerations of I guess spatial positioning and also it looks really beautiful.
Agree.
So yeah, so that was the Homeland expansion. We're going to have or already have a review out if you want to hear more details about that. We also have Root a buyers guide if you want to know everything about Root essentially. Uh so go check those out and then we'll move on here to our next game.
Next up we have Gingham from Bitewing Games and this was a review copy from the publisher and it's for two to four players and from here on out we will refer to it as ants.
Yeah, it's just ants.
We call it ants.
Do you want to have a game of ants?
Exactly. Uh because gingham is is too much to say and ants describes it better. So what this is is a game of competing ant factions at picnic blanket. So essentially you have this board and it's a cloth mat that is a picnic blanket and you play competing factions of ants who are trying to gain the sweets that have been littered all over this picnic. And it's the most unhealthy picnic because it's full of cupcakes and lollipops and
cakes and pies.
Pies. Yeah, not really normal picnic food, but anyway. So, the way it works is that you have these four edges of the picnic blanket and there's a stitch running diagonal across the middle and whoever goes first in a round will essentially pick which of the four sides the players are on. And then you will put a queen down. You have two queens. Uh, so players will kind of take turns and you'll put your queen along a row and then you put an ant down on that row and no one else can go there for that round and you can't do the same side of the map twice in a row. So you're constantly moving around the picnic blanket.
And what you're trying to do is you're trying to make chains of ants connecting like sweets basically. So, you want to connect two lollipops together and then you'll score for as many answers that took essentially. Uh, you'll also score if you completely surround a stack of a candy because then you control it and you'll kind of score for how many's in that you'll get some endgame points if you have the biggest stack of that type of candy. Um, so I mean really that is it. It's about positioning but it's also very cutthroat. Would you like to say more about that? Ants, my arch nemesis game of 2026 for sure, if not beyond. Listen, I may have said that I hate this game upwards of 10 times while we were playing it
at least.
Not to say it's a bad game. No, I actually really like this game, but like you said, it is
I did not get that get that impression at all.
It's cutthroat because you can also move the other players ants essentially like really quite easily. And all that happens is the ant gets bumped out and uh you if your ant has been moved, you just get to place it in any open space. There's like a small benefit to you that you get to replace it.
It is quite good cuz usually so when you place in a column, you can't go past the stitch.
Yeah.
So, and it's kind of interesting because who goes first is kind of uh there's a star and like two corners of the board and whoever's closest to that goes first. Yeah. Yeah.
So, the turn order is really interesting this because
if I have the first two spaces next to the star
on that side of the board, then it means that not only do I get to go first, I get to pick the next edge of the picnic blanket we're playing on. And then because I'm the first two, I get the first two turns.
Yeah.
So, it is very interesting because you go Yeah. from this star outwards. So it can make for really interesting kind of shifts in rounds and abilities.
You can deliberately put the queen nearest the star if there's a space, not really wanting to go in that row because there's less spaces
because of the diagonal.
So the closer you go to the star, the less options there is, but you might just want to go there just to get the heads up on the next round and be able to go first.
So you could in theory have four turns in a row if you were last
and then become first. But yeah, you can move other players ants around very easily and it's quite infuriating to be honest. Um, I am just being very salty because I kept losing.
Yeah, I think ants is brilliant.
No, it is it is really good. is very tactical because you could also just put an ant somewhere. You know, your opponent might want to put one because they're quite clearly trying to make a connection between two suites. So, you might just go there just to be annoying knowing that they will then probably have to move you and then you get to place your ant anywhere. So, you could go down that way. So, you can play very very offensively. the famous example, and this wasn't offensive, but you moved my aunt at the end of the last game we played.
Yeah.
And then because I could put it anywhere, I ended up putting it where I needed this connection uh to to complete a connection. And then that connection was 10 long, so I scored 10 points. And then that took us over the threshold to end the game, and I ended up winning. And it's, you know, and it's like these kind of consequences from just getting to move an ant anywhere you want.
Yeah. Exactly. No, it is very, it is really good. It's a bit chesslike, right? Because you're trying to analyze what might be my best move here to try and make the biggest connection.
One thing that I really don't like about it, and I'm sure you disagree because you kept winning. Uh but it's the the game ends when someone reaches 40 points because you're ongoing kind of scoring these connections, but the score is hidden, let's say, on like a little score tracker per person. And just because you get to the 40 points doesn't mean that you're going to win because there's some endgame scoring. But for me, that's what was irritating me is that I had no idea really how close you were to those 40 points. So, I might be trying to line myself up for a big turn next time and then suddenly you've scored 10 and the game's over. And of course, I could mentally keep track of how much you're scoring as we go. But yeah, I don't really like that it's like hidden information because you might make some different decisions if you knew how close someone was to ending the game. So, that's some like something that I don't really I think that was the source of my frustration with this is that it was kind of like hidden information. Yeah, I think I I definitely can't argue against that because so for me it does not bother me at all in this game, but I've literally complained about that exact same thing in the past.
I think for me in this game, maybe it is cuz of one,
but
it's also I think because it's so short and snappy that for me it's like eh it I don't know, it just doesn't bother me. Whereas Dinosaur Island was famously one that I found that I really
Oh my god, you got really angry about mine.
I really didn't like that. Uh, basically these endgame triggers, it was like impossible to tell if other people were going to get them or not. And then that really changed that was like a 2hour game
and it was crazy to me that, you know, you could play an entire round completely differently if you knew it was going to end versus not. And
so yeah, I completely understand where you're coming from and why it annoys you. Yeah. Just this one for me, I think it's just so short. It doesn't
No, I get your point, but it's just how can I for me, I just feel like how can I play and make the best moves when there's information that might change my moves that is like is not available to me. So, I just personally found that why I didn't like it so I didn't like it. Is a good game.
Yeah. Well, I think it's brilliant. And I think it really captures a an almost rhythess of a very very simple action on your turn. You're putting a queen down. You're placing a single ant.
But the kind of mental board state is huge because
you know, like I said, if you surround piles of these candies, you can claim them. Then not only do you score, then you score at the end and then you score if you have the highest on top of that stack of that type of candy. And I find it quite interesting because, you know, there are ones that you might need one amp for, two ants for, or four ants for to surround depending where they are in the board.
Yes.
And if it's only one ant, that's really easy to control and get points, but then anyone can knock your ant out and take it over and get points
famously. Or, you know, you can do the one that takes four, which is a lot of effort, but then it's almost impossible for other players to take it from you.
That's true.
So, there's these trade-offs. There's a trade-off that you can go for really long chains, and like I said a bit before, you get 10 points and, you know, 40 is the score to end the game
from just one chain
uh of connecting two like suites. or you can just go and try and kind of claim a bunch of small piles and then get loads of endame points if the other players haven't been doing that.
So, I just find there's really a lot of game state and people win in different ways from going after different strategies.
Yeah, I think we found there was one game where you ended it because you got 40.
Yeah.
I was really far away from 40 so I was like for God's sake. But then I actually managed to catch up with you because I controlled all of the stock piles.
Yeah, I think it ended 45 to 44
cuz you had stocks.
Don't remind me.
Yeah, that's quite interesting as well.
So yeah, so uh Ants or
is I think it's a really great game. So, if you want something that's kind of quick, like 20, 30 minutes play time, something that's sharp, a bit a little bit abstract, a bit tactical, but with a lot of options coming from a small small rules kind of overhead, definitely check this out. Uh, I think this designer, Robert Bian, I'm probably not saying that right, apologies. uh is definitely becoming one of my favorite designers after BBOP and this and I think there's a lot of interesting stuff.
Yeah, for sure.
Uh that he's putting out. So, we'll go on to our next game.
Next up, we have Take Time. And we're not going to take too much time with this one because we
see what you did there
because we have a review out. Uh, but we just wanted to highlight it again briefly because we really enjoyed this one. And it's a cooperative card game for two to four players in the sense of games like The Crew, a trick taking game and also it's quite a lot like mind.
Yes.
And this also just say was a review copy from the Pulpa Show. And here it is asking you to play cards numbered 1 to 12 uh basically without communicating with the other players in order around a clock. So essentially you're going to have a clock with six points coming out of it. And at each one of these points you play cards, you know, one at a time going around the table. And generally you're plac playing playing them face down so the other players don't know what values you're putting down. And you have some basic rules to follow such as each segment must be tied or higher than the preceding one
and none of the segments can be greater than 24. So for example, you can't just dump all of your cards in the last one cuz it's highest.
So you also will have a bunch of little twists that will come as there are a lot of different clocks in this game. So it's kind of like a campaign in game in a sense where you have chapters which will have four different clocks uh following a general trend and then the next chapter will change things up and you know it might be like at this place you can't play any sevens, eights or nines or here you have to put the first card and here you have to put the second card you play or so on and so forth.
Uh we won't bore you with all the details but
you can't communicate. So what you have to do is you have to look at the clock when you before you look at what cards you have and you essentially will come up with a strategy and you'll have to talk it out and figure out how are you going to tackle this and then you execute it without talking and yeah as I said the cards have to be played face down but a handful can be played face up depending on if you failed or or not.
Exactly. And there's two decks, right? The light and the dark. So each one to 12. And each player gets four cards. So you might not be the only one with a 12, for example. So that's also a bit the twist.
Yeah.
But no, we had a great time with this one, I would say.
Yeah.
So yeah, it was really fun to talk about the strategy in the beginning based on whatever the clock was asking you to do and the different rules and twists with that one. and then trying to execute it, right? Which for the most part, well, sometimes it can work if it's very um if if the right cards come out because a lot of the cards are not in the game as well. That's also the twist.
Yeah, half the cards aren't in the game.
So, you might say, "Okay, if you have a 12 in your hand, we know that that needs to go in a certain position." When we go around the first time, if you've got a 12, put it down, even though we can't speak because then everyone will know that it was a 12. But the 12 might not be in there for a start. So it's always quite funny to talk about this and then in practicality it might not happen and then you go around and nobody's put that 12 down you're like uh okay
what now kind of thing. So yeah I think this was
it was really fun to play and we really enjoyed when we did fail it just going again and saying okay let's try a new strategy let's do it like this in a different way. So yeah
it's really fun. I really like the aesthetic of it as well. Oh, it looks really nice on the table.
I think the challenges per clock were really kind of fun to navigate and they get kind of
kind of progressively harder, let's say.
So, that was also fun to kind of work through it and then it get more challenging.
Yeah. So, I think it's it's a really brilliant cooperative game. It's really nice. Uh like I said, if if you've played the kind of games I'm talking about, then it will feel very familiar.
Yeah. I think it's really great at capturing what was fun about the mind, but putting more of a game to it of this
Exactly.
communication and trying to mentally push people to do what you think is best. Yeah.
And what I think really makes this game stand out compared to some of the other ones is it has this sense of arc and excitement building and tension because it can be really tough if you're the last person to get rid of a card and you kind of know that everything's in the right order,
but you don't know exactly the balance between, you know, this segment and that segment. and you have to play this last card somewhere and you think you should play it here or here
and it's like you know one might ruin the entire game and one might make you win it and having this such tension and then you go one by one and reveal the segments.
True. It's really fun.
It's it's really great. It has this great excitement at the end. Uh it's kind of quick to go through as well, so you're not spending too much time and then failing. I like the pacing of it if you win or lose. So, I just think there's a lot to recommend it if you like these cooperative card games, if you like the mind, if you like things like this basically. I would say check it out.
Definitely. And obviously with the with the mind like you can't really strategize. I don't know, maybe you could say don't after 10 seconds if no one's played something, can you have this like play? But like it might not work like that, right? You could definitely like strategize.
Well, I don't think you're allowed to talk at all about anything. So,
oh, even in the beginning. Yeah. Okay. So, then it's not the same.
That breaks the game if you just like make rules like that. I think
yeah that's true and you it is just luck in inverted commas whether you know you feel it's having the feeling whereas here you can actually try to make a strategy and then execute on it.
Yeah.
Um yeah even if it might not be right in the end with a little bit of like
read my thoughts as well.
Exactly.
It's definitely uh yeah more game like you said.
Yeah. So that was take time and we'll go to our next game. A feast for Odin now. And this was a game that I had my eye on for years, but it was out of stock for a long time.
Then we finally got round to getting it late last year,
but we only managed to play it once and then it's on the shelf for a while.
Last year really crazy. My goodness.
And then we have played it a bunch this year and we've really got into it. I think we both really enjoy it. Yes,
I know. Speaking for myself, I think it's it's brilliant. It was worth the wait, you could say.
And now we've just recently had a game with the Norwegians, which everyone says that you should get if you like the game because it makes it better. So yeah, Aie Rodin is a kind of worker placement mixed with polyomno game where you're sending out workers essentially fill up these player boards with all different shapes of tiles to cover up negative points and you'll also try and get some points from other places to score points essentially. But it kind of Yeah. One of its big selling points is it has this massive board of uh work placement spaces. There's like
if you play a four player game, there's like 60 something.
Wow.
Uh yeah. So, what do you think of Feast Froden?
Yeah, it is really great. And um what's the one that you're obsessed with? Um the sustenance farming.
A grip.
Yeah, exactly. So in that ballpark, right? But you I really like that game. You got very obsessed with it. But this for me is shining a lot more than that. Uh don't know why. I think it's the like resource conversion part here as well. So it's feeling very like you get some resources and you need to convert it into like food to feed your
troops workers. Yeah. But then you also need to use those same pieces. So like the food that you need to feed them at the end of the round could also be upgraded into pieces that can be put on your board. So you're always trying to kind of plan for the future to have enough pieces of food, but you you're then trading off using those things as tiles to cover up what's on your board.
And just the I guess breadth of different things that you can do here is a real highlight. So you can go in a few I don't want to say different directions because you still need to ultimately cover up the negative points on your board, but I guess there's just different ways of
Yeah, I would still say it feels that the mo most important thing is that it feels different because
yeah, you're completely right that in the end of the day you're still just getting tiles to cover up. But, you know, you can go into buying ships and you can go pillaging or whaling or you can go down the livestock route and get a bunch of cattle and horses and sheep if you have the expansion and kind of going and gain points that way. You can send people to immigrate to lower your food costs. You know, there's all like different elements that you can do. You can go and discover new lands to cover up those boards or you can just get a storehouse and throw a bunch of food in it.
I think it's the yeah the trade-offs cuz like you said, you can reduce the food costs but then if you don't have those ships anymore because you've sent them away then there's certain actions that you then can't take. So, it's just trying to navigate when to do what I would say to fulfill. Yeah. Filling the board, but also getting the most points and like keeping the cost down. And
yeah, it's just it's just really fun to navigate. It's kind of hard to put my finger on why exactly I like it so much over other similar games. actually.
Um, it's just I think I have a drive to go again at the end of it. Maybe a little bit more than other similar games because like you said, you can go in slightly different routes to get to the kind of same end result, but yeah, you want to just try again. I think what it does really well is that it has this economy where I think when you first play it, you'll like struggle to fill just your player board and you'll be like, what is the point of these extra boards you can get uh exploration boards? But then, you know, your second time you get an exploration board and you fill that up. And I think it has this nice balancing where
you say as good as you are, there's always more stuff
to like fill in. So it's not like Halatau which we played and we liked but the problem we had with it and we sold it after playing four times or something was that it felt like every game we were doing everything
and the point margins were like oh you got 120 and I got 118 because we did everything
and whereas here you can push it as far as you want to go.
So if you're really good there's still more stuff for you to fill in. You'll just get a higher score.
Yeah. So, I think it works really well in that regard and staying interesting. But because of that, you always feel like, oh, I just covered up my player board and this expiration board. Next time I want to try and get a third board or something.
Yeah, exactly. But the Norwegian's expansion, I thought it was great, but I have to say for me, I don't think it made it better. It added more stuff.
I think it opened up gameplay a lot more. At least like the livestock element of it.
Yeah. But it's just more for me and it's not to say that it's bad, but for me it was more of the same and I would happily like always play with it. But I actually didn't think there was anything wrong with the base game and I don't feel like this
I don't know if this is uh what people say but like fixed anything.
Yeah. Well, I think what people say is that with a feast for Odin, it's a game that you think is terrific and you don't know it's like not perfect until you play it with Norwegians and then it becomes perfect because it rebalances everything like changes the spaces to be
a bit like better or more balanced or
Yeah.
So, I mean, we only played with Norwegians once so I think neat to see that. But I liked how it opened up the game a bit more.
No, for sure. I liked it and again there was more to try which like we just said this is what we like about this game that there's like always more so it's only a good thing. It's just for me I didn't feel any like difference in making it better
but yeah let's see with repeated plays.
Yeah. So I think the only thing I'll say that I don't like is because you brought up a gricular which by the same designer and we always have this debate where in a gricular you find the occupation cards and the other cards they're like much of a muchness whereas I find them to be like really interesting and how they they change your strategy game to game. You lean into them. That's what I like in a gricola.
Yeah. Whereas here there's like a massive like all UA Rosenberg games there's a massive deck of like occupation cards and things and I find them all completely trash.
Disagree.
I disagree there. I really like the occupation cards.
Really? Yeah. I I find the occupation cards here. They're never interesting to me and they're so like they're so difficult. that's a bit stronger. They're so difficult to get into play and then like get in the one situation that will let you get any benefit of them.
Yeah.
I find them really like
I I just really I've never really found any that I like look at and I'm like this is quite interesting.
Yeah. Okay.
I mainly play them for points to be honest.
Yeah. Not to say that every single one of them is interesting or useful in the moment, but I find myself more engaged with them here than in
That's really funny. I find Yeah, I find them so like sounds really harsh, but try. I just really They just don't interest me.
Interesting.
Yeah, it is really interesting. Okay, well, that debate will go to our last game, which will cause far more debates. Finally, today we have June Uprising. Uh game that causes a lot of heavily contested moments, just like our last moment on A Feast for Odin. So, here
heavily contested. Yeah, it's a real
So,
point of contention.
We've actually we ended up playing this uh recently because a friend of ours, he's a big fan of June and he wanted to play the game. So, we showed it to him. It was tough going. We had a fourplay game. It was tough going because they're not heavy gamers. Uh and obviously if you're not that experienced, there's a lot going on here.
Yeah. We like, oh, you know, deck management, hand management, worker placement, and they're like, what
exactly? But it went as well as could be expected and it was a very close game for the most part. It was heavily contested and then basically uh our friend ended up winning. He got the worms out and there was no one really to challenge him in that round and yeah then then he kind of ran away with it basically. I think it ended up 10 points to nine or something like that
or or maybe even 11 to nine or something like that. But yeah,
but it it was really great cuz we haven't played this in a long time and it's won both of our favorites.
Yeah.
Uh Uprising specifically cuz we think it improves a lot on June Imperium. Uh mainly for me in the deck. I find the deck far more interesting than the original.
Uh so then the deck building element, which is a big part of the game, becomes more fun.
Yeah.
Yep. Any thoughts?
Yeah. No, I just really enjoyed this game and we played it like we said with the friends on Friday and I really wanted to get it out and play again because I didn't feel like I I think I lost the game against the two
Yeah. noobs.
New Yeah, it did. Right. Did I come dead last?
Embarrassing. So, um, I wanted to get it out again and have another crack. So, we ended up getting it out a couple of days later and having a go just the two of us with the
Rise of expansion.
Exactly. It's just it's just really fun to try and manage the hand like we said. Um, yeah. I don't know what else to say apart from I really enjoy it. Yeah, I'm really looking forward to to playing with those friends again. Uh I think there's something about this game. Yeah, when you have a full fourplayer game, how it goes. It's it's just so cutthroat and there's so many twists and turns and it's exciting and frustrating and
Exactly.
a range of emotions.
Yeah. Yeah.
And I think one of the things is this is a game that's not so great at two player
and we actually sometimes we do play cuz you have this kind of third player faction. Sometimes we play with them but sometimes we also don't. So we actually when we played it just ourselves we played twice and we played once um with the kind of AI player and then once without which you're not supposed to do but the thing is we're really not a fan of the AI player in terms of the upkeep. And also just in the way that
one thing I really hate about AI factions is when they get to do things that real players couldn't do.
Yeah.
Like it's like, you know, oh, on their first turn they go to of the game they go to the Highliner spot and jump five troops in the first battle, you know. It's like I really don't like or they go to
the the space with the most spice and steal it all, you know, and they've never got any wars. It's all this kind of stuff that um it's really frustrating, especially if it's only a two-player game. If you're having your big battle against them for points and then they just do some crap and get like 40 troops in there and and you're just like, "Okay, well,
yeah." Uh for me when we played without it the second time just us two like I get that the worker placement it for for some people might be more fun when it's tight because
people are taking the space and you have to navigate that and like go for an alternative plan. But I the reason that I like this game is more about like what you're able to do with your own deck and also kind of using the intrigue card and trying to get sneaky points. So, the fact that it's a bit looser for me, I just don't it it just doesn't bother me because I prefer the other parts of the game about different ways you can go to get points other than, oh, you took my spot, I can't go there anymore. So,
for me, I'm eh
because even in with the four player game,
I actually don't remember there being an instance or it didn't happen so much where other players were taking the spots that I need. I mean, obviously on the odd occasion, but it didn't.
And you have spies now as well in June Uprising where you can go,
I suppose. Yeah. But that's not the core fun part for me.
Yeah. I think
getting the most out of the hand that you're pulling and trying to get intrigue cards and pull those in. Yeah, I think the biggest argument is more that
it's when it comes to combat because you can get so many points that without having someone to balance
like in a three or four player game you always have someone bal or hopefully you have someone balancing because otherwise it's zero sum and that can get like really unbalanced
which I think our game was fine. like didn't really bother us and I can accept that. But at the same time, as we said, is there something about the AI player? It's too easy for them to get too many troops in
and
yeah,
it's like really frustrating when it's like your big time battle and you get 20 something strength and then they they've just ended up with like 40 or something
in an unrealistic web. Yeah.
And that's what's quite frustrating. So yeah, I mean uh I think it was completely fine as a game, but it it's just way better to be playing with three or four. And that's the thing. So that's why it's so nice to have people who want to play it.
I think the one thing that I'm still not sold on, this is like a common debate is the worms
because in Uprising you have the worms and they double points uh when or they double the reward from a combat which can often be points. So this becomes a game where you can have swings of four or five points potentially in a round and that can be half the points you need. So
yeah,
that can be a lot. And I mean I see both sides where there's an argument that you need to kind of counteract people getting the worms and they're not as powerful as they appear if you can block them off
and be ready. But it yeah, I think um it's a lot to ask of players who aren't really familiar with the game to combat that.
So I think I think I do slightly I prefer everything about uprising over Imperium maybe except for that part because
agree it for me it's when it's so tight and so tight and then suddenly somebody gets four points and it's like okay well they're on 12 points now. Yeah, agree. I think it I do personally think that's a bit anticlimactic and agree with you. It is more interesting when someone's moving up one, someone catches up moving up one and then when you could just clearly see that I think it's just those last conflict cards where you could end up with four points potentially.
I don't mind it the worms like doubling the rewards, but when it could be doubled from two to four points, it's such a big swing because only going up to 12. So that's quite a significant proportion of the points that you need.
I probably prefer it if the last conflict cards that kind of come out wouldn't be so powerful
and would only have one point and then some other rewards or
Yeah. Don't know.
Well, yeah. I think it's uh it can just be um Yeah, cuz you can also get lucky where one player is just manages to be unchallenged, which what happened in the final round. So, in the preceding round, I was set to win cuz I had worms in the battle, but then another player kind of went all out against me and we ended up tying. Uh, so I didn't get any points. But then in the next round, because everyone had spent all of their resources, this other player just kind of walked in, which I guess maybe is is our fault cuz obviously we're both trying to win. But yeah, anyway, that's just how Dune is, right? So that's part of the magic of the game that somebody takes an opportunity, which is very Dunelike. So
true.
Fair enough. But yeah, it was really great to get out. Hope to play it more in the future. Uh that'll be our last game of today. So if you enjoyed this video, really appreciate you watching, please consider subscribing if you haven't already. And if you have subscribed and you like the channel, you watch us for a while, we now have this YouTube membership thing where you can essentially just support the channel. It's not necessary if you don't want to, but we'll appreciate it. And then you can get perks such as kind of private shorts, early access to videos, voting on what videos we make or what games we feature and things like that. So, think about it, check it out. Uh, but most importantly, thank you for watching and we'll see you next time. Hi.