For the Emperor, Shobu, Butterfly Garden, Duck & Cover, Hey That's My Fish! - Ranked and Reviewed
Transcript
Hey everybody and welcome to another Chairman of the Board ranking video. This is where I take a look at the last five new to me board games that I've played and I rank and review them in order of preference. So I have five again very different games here today. But before I get started on these games, I want to give a shout out as usual to the show sponsor keyer.co.uk who are my go-to online retailer. And if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code, then you can get 5% off your first order. At number five, I have Shoo. So, Shoo is a two-player head-to-head abstract strategy game with a wonderful production kind of visual appeal as you have these kind of four rustic wooden boards and these lovely polished stones as the players pieces.
Now, the objective of the game is to try and clear one of these four boards of your opponent's pieces by pushing them off the board using your own pieces. Now, a player's turn is pretty simple. It's divided into two halves. The first half you're going to have to do what's called a passive move, and then the second one will be an aggressive move. Now, the passive move means you have to move one of your pieces either one or two spaces in a straight or diagonal line, but you cannot contact an an opponent's piece. Um, but then in the second half, you're going to have to replicate or mirror that move on a board of the opposite color with the aim again of trying to push your opponent's pieces off the board. Um, but of course, your opponent is trying to stop you from doing that and is trying to reverse it onto yourself as well. So, there are little tricks you can use here um when you are trying to kind of, you know, use other pieces of your own to try and support your other pieces to stop them getting pushed off because you can only move one piece at a time. And of course, you are trying to spin quite a few plates here um because you're fighting on four fronts basically. So you don't want to neglect any too much or maybe you can directly try and um you know deceive your opponent by thinking that you're weak here when actually you're trying to go for them here instead. So I thought the game was very clever. It was very clean game as you'd expect. Um but I have to say I think I didn't really enjoy it. I found it a little bit boring and a little bit a little bit plotting and maybe too dry, which is something for me to say really because I I know I do generally like dry games. But yeah, this one I just didn't it didn't really
spark any passion or really give me the itch to want to go and master it or get better at it, which I know is going to be blasphemy for a lot of um pure abstract-minded gamers because I know this one's highly um touted, very well spoken of. Um, and I I can't complain from a from an objective point of view. I think it's super welldesigned, very creative. Um, again, I love that idea of that delayed movement of moving here so I can attack you here. That's very cool. But for me, it didn't I didn't really um extract any enjoyment from it, which is why I do this. So, yes, I can appreciate the game, but I want to get fun from it, and this one didn't do that, sadly. But, you know, as a piece of design, full props. A lot of people are going to love it. A lot of people are going to really want to sink their teeth into it and learn those little tricks. Uh, for me, it's just not what I'm looking for. Um, so probably unfair to be this low because again, objectively, very solid.
Personally, just just not a good fit. So, that is Shobu at number five. At number four, I have Duck and Cover. So, this is a pretty silly bingo style game as you're trying to score as few points as possible by covering up ducks on your personal little grid. Um, as I said, it's a bingo style game. So, each turn and it's all done simultaneously. So, that's always something I appreciate. Um, you're going to flip the card. That card's going to show a certain number which will correspond to a duck on your little personal tableau. And then you can either use that duck to slide orthogonal onto one of the, you know, the four spaces around it and cover up an existing duck, which of course is good in terms of um covering up points that you don't want to score. Um or you can take that duck and move it somewhere else on an empty space next to another card to try and set yourself up for future turns. Now, the game has a good degree of pressure to it because of course, as you are going through these different numbers, moving and covering ducks. Um, sooner or later, people aren't going to be able to move any ducks because those ducks have been covered up. Um, meaning that this card goes into this kind of separate discard pile, which is kind of an end round counter really. And once there's a certain amount of cards in that pile, then the round will end. So, there's this pressure to try and cover up your ducks, but you want to cover up the highscoring ducks. and a further twist where if you want to try or if you can cover up everything perfectly and only
have one card remaining um I believe you will score those points as negative. So there's a way to catch up as well. But it's all about trying to dictate the pace. Um not to drag your heels too much where you're going to get caught off guard. Uh but not to go too fast either bec and cover up all your cards because you might be stuck with only a couple of numbers and those numbers aren't exactly um going to be called or drawn out of the deck very often and meaning that you're going to keep on wasting your turns. So there's a degree of card counting here you can do as well where you think you know the two fours have already come out so maybe next time I draw a nine I'll use that nine to cover the four then I can forget about the four and I can keep taking my turns. Um, but again, I like the way that the end of the round is dictated and determined by the other players. So, you're always kind of keeping an eye on other people's little displays so that you're keeping nose tonose with them and you're not going to get hit by a massive amount of points at the end of the round. So, uh, again, very simple stuff. I'm I'm not sure if there is a hidden strategy here.
I'm not sure if I found it yet. It is a bit of a veneer really. definitely um you know skin deep in terms of its complexities and tactics and strategies, but it feels unique. It feels fun. And to be honest, I I like the game, but everyone I've played it with seems to have liked it more than I have, which is um quite interesting really. So maybe I'm not missing something, but maybe I'm underelling it um by trying to look for that depth rather than just enjoying the process and hoping not to get shafted with a bunch of points. But uh lovely looking game as well. I have to say the um the artwork on these cards is fantastic. Every single deck has a different theme to it where you've got these little rubber ducks with like fantasy armor on or from history and so on, you know, really well designed and um full props for that as well. So, if you want a quirky little filler one with, you know, limited brains brains capacity needed, Duck and Cover might be a good option for you if you're especially if you have higher player counts because I think the base game alone um tailers up to like six players or so. So that is duck and cover at at number four. At number three, I have Hey, that's my fish. So this is a classic abstract strategy game as you are using these penguins to maneuver around this big map of these hex tiles.
Each of these hex tiles has a different number of fish on them. And on your turn, you can move one of your penguins as far as you want in a straight line, landing on the next tile. And the tile you've just moved off is going to get removed from the board, put into your score pile, and of course the tiles with the more fish on them are worth more points essentially. But it's all about trying to uh you know maneuver around, keeping yourself in the game because of course more tiles are taken, the more voids are left on the map, meaning that the board becomes fragmented, our players become trapped on different smaller islands and so on. So there's kind of several things you're considering here. you know, not only getting the best fish, but what's going to suit you long term. You know, are you going to stay in the game longer if you go to this area instead of that area, preventing your opponent from moving, trying to force them onto tiny little islands so that they are well, they're out of the game essentially, uh, and so on. So, very simple stuff, but I do like how boiled down this game is into that one core mechanism really, but everything has a cost here. every move is important. The game scales remarkably well because you always play on the same sized grid, but if you're playing with fewer players, you simply use more penguins per player. So, the board is equally populated and busy. And with a game like this, you want that board to be busy and every turn to be important.
It's only about 15 minutes to play, which I think is is right on the money. Um, and my only kind of small nitpick about the game is that it's a little bit annoying to set up because you are putting several rows of these little hex tiles out there, which can sometimes take as long as playing the game. But still, game play sharp as attack. And, you know, I have played a lot of these abstract style games as you're maneuvering around um, grids in different movements and different patterns and so on, picking up cards and tiles as you go. This one, I think, is the cleanest and best version by far that I've played. Um, again, doesn't do anything that it shouldn't do, doesn't add on any silly rules or unnecessary rules, and it just stays true to what it is. So, um, this is an evergreen. No doubt it's an evergreen, and I'm looking forward to playing it more at the different player counts. Um, and it just it's just a tactical fun game that never really outstates its welcome. And even if you don't really like abstract games, this might be an exception to the rule because it's fun. You know, the fun fact is really high with, "Hey, that's my fish. At number two, I have For the Emperor. So, this is almost a micro card game in a very small box, very few uh components, and it's a tugof-war style game as you're competing for um these different kind of zones, I suppose by playing cards. Now, each player has an identical deck of cards, but at any time, I think you only have three in your hand uh to play with. So you are having to act somewhat tactically to the
cards available to you. Now the information on these cards um comes in in two different ways really. So you got the strength value which is going to be your influence of these particular zones. Um, but each card also has a unique power. And as you'd expect, normally the the higher strength cards come with weaker powers and maybe the the lower value or strength cards will come with a bit more of a manipulation skill and how to change things around into your favor when it comes to the current board state. So gameplay wise or the actual mechanisms wise, you're just simply playing cards and moving on to the next thing. Um, but there are several things to consider here. not you're not only exploiting the abilities of these cards, um, but also each of these different zones you're fighting over has a capacity on how many cards can be played there. And that concerns both of the players. And if I haven't mentioned so far, this is a two-player head-to-head game. Um, because some zones might say you can play four cards here. Um, but that could be four of my cards and none of yours. It could be two each. It could be three of mine and one of yours. Uh, and so on. But the the capacity of each of these zones is actually determined as the game goes on.
So for example, the the first zone to hit four cards will become the four card zone and then it'll be like the three cards and then there's like a couple of two cards and a few one cards as well. So you don't actually know what the most competitive regions are uh until maybe later in the game, but there are certain cards that can determine that earlier. Um and some of these abilities, some of these cards is is really fascinating. It might say, "Well, add the the capacity um volume of this particular zone to your strength." Or maybe it will let you pick cards back up you've already played and swap it with another one. Um and so on. So again, lots of little tricks and little a little guile you need to use here. A bit of skull duggery. Um and it's just very refined and it just seems to me like it's almost been like perfectly tweaked with what all these abilities can do. Um, with a lot of these games, one thing that normally concerns me is if there's too much of an information dump on those cards, um, where you just kind of it feels like a bit of a chore using the powers on them.
These ones are all very simple to resolve and easy to understand and grock and how to use them and exploit them and just, you know, they're all just oneliners, so you can very quickly see what this card does. And before you know it, even within a couple of games, you will have a good understanding of what your opponent can do and what cards they have or haven't used because you only get like 10 cards each, which is, you know, next to nothing. So, this one very impressive. I wasn't sure what to expect with it. I think if you like games like um like Hannah Makoji, you're going to really like this one. And even if you like games like Air, Land, and Sea, a little bit of Love Letter, this one just like it just kind of draws little things from all these different games and puts in this lovely little package. And I have to say, I was thoroughly thoroughly impressed. And I can see this one climbing. I'm not sure if the the strategy is super deep, but for a 10 to 15 minute game with some good little tricks, um the way the cards are bled into your hand and how to use them to the best of the ability, you can't always go into this game with the same plan because different cards going to be available to you. I think all of that works in its favor and it's just beautifully executed. And yeah, for this is definitely going to be a contender for surprise of the year for me. And um I think this one's going to be quality enough of a design that it's going to get a slow momentum and people are going to really start appreciating it. So I know there's a lot of fans out there of these little tugof-war two-player games.
This one is a super strong example of that. And hopefully um you know I've I've kind of spread the word a bit and can maybe put it on your radar to give it a try yourself. You know it's small, it's affordable and the gameplay is high quality. So that is for the emperor. Uh a welldeserved number two. And finally at number one I have butterfly garden by rhino kitsia. Now this is a reprinting I believe a carbon copy of the original indigo. Um the only thing that changed to my understanding is the you know the visuals and the production. I think the rules are exactly the same. So, this is a little track building, little root building style game as you are placing tiles onto this communal board, trying to guide these butterflies into your areas. So, the way you do that, again, simply put them onto the board. If you place your tile uh next to where a butterfly is, the butterfly will continue the track um and go onto your tile essentially. So, think of something like Zuro. This game works almost in the exact same way, but there's a bit more going on in the way that the scoring works because in this one, you're not just simply trying to, you know, last the longest. You are trying to guide those butterflies to your zones by building those tracks. And of course, some tracks are going to bleed into others and go on diversions and go different sides of the boards and so on.
I like the way this game is paced because all of the different butterflies come in different colors and are worth different points. The ones on the edges of the board are generally easier to manipulate into your zones, but are only worth, say, a point each. And all the butterflies in the middle are worth, say, two points each, apart from the final one, which is worth three points. And by the time that final butterfly comes out, there are so many networks that everyone's just trying to um, you know, stall or try and redirect certain pathways so they come to your uh, scoring zones. Now, a cool twist on this game is that each of the um the scoring areas at the edges of the board can actually accommodate more than one player. So, if you're playing with I think three or four players, um each zone will actually have two players um kind of scoring towards it. So, sometimes you will help others by trying to help yourself. Um and you have to factor in who's got the most butterflies here. You know, if a certain player is doing really well and you're sharing a zone with them, you might still want to try and stop them from getting them and divert it to your other scoring zone instead. Yes, it will help another player, but it means you're making up that ground. Very clear kind of victory and endame scoring here. You know, just scoring the butterflies and of course the game will end once that final butterfly has been taken, which will go hand inhand with the with the tile count. So, very punchy game. It's tactical, but you can try and set up some foundations to um you know force players to place certain tiles which
will end up in your zones anyway. So you can build up a bit of a network, but of course at the same time you can be creative and try and do these big diversions to try and send these butterflies off to the other side of the board. So again, pretty crazy stuff, but it's a lot of fun. It's very charming. And I have always been looking for uh a game of this mechanism for me. Um, I've had, you know, moderate success with the affforementioned surro, which again, I enjoy, but I thought is a little bit too tactical and I thought the games felt a little bit too throw away, you know, didn't really feel like you could sink your teeth into them. And also a game called Twisty Tracks, which I really liked. Um, but it was a little bit too multiplayer solitaire. This one, I think, takes the best parts of both of those um, and makes Butterfly Garden.
So, again, I like the way it's all a shared board. I like the scoring conditions and I just like the way the game feels and looks and it just it just plays in a really nice way. So, um this one again almost feels like an evergreen. I can't really see myself parting with this one. Maybe I could be lying on that. I'm not sure. You know, is very light, almost feather light really. Um but there's something about it and it's a game that I want to pull off my shelves and play because I just enjoy the process and just seeing how these paths build and watching those butterflies fly around uh the board. So, that is Butterfly Garden. Uh, another great Cania game. What can I say? He just seems to strike that perfect balance for me. Um, a welldeserved number one. So, there we have it. That concludes another ranking video. Hopefully, you've enjoyed it. If you have, please be sure to hit like and subscribe to the channel and check out my other content, too. But for everybody else, I'll see you next time on Chairman of the Board. Bye-bye.