Are we WRONG for Cheating in Gloomhaven?
Transcript
We just spent the majority of the weekend gaming, specifically playing Jaws the Lion, and we are so close to the finish line. But one problem or one question or one debate has kept popping up the entire course of the game.
When or when is it not okay to cheat in board games?
Now, cheating is a very aggressive term, and I don't even know if it's appropriate here. We're playing a cooperative game. Who are we cheating against?
You could say we're cheating against the ethics of the board game or the board game industry.
Theoretically, you could say that we're cheating the game itself or cheating ourselves out of the opportunity to have a clean victory. But here's the thing. Board games are supposed to be fun, right? Cooperative board games are a rag tag adventure. We're doing our best to survive, upgrade, level up, approach the end of the campaign so we can finally say we finished one of the many Gloom Haven games and then start it start again on the big box soon after.
So, am I cheating myself if I
I don't know make it possible to win?
But you didn't actually win. Are you winning if you conveniently flip the right card after you flip the wrong card? Are you winning if you change a dice roll? It's not winning. It's cheating the system that's in play that you have agreed to play against. You have taken out a contract with this game. You are going to play this game and follow its rules and then you conveniently switch them up at the right time.
We've already been losing every scenario once,
twice,
six times,
sometimes three times. But we never played one three times or six times because by the third time around, we've learned what we needed to learn about the puzzle we're playing. We've uh possibly had some good card flips, some bad card flips. Maybe we even lost tragically at the last minute and decided to give it another go just for the measure, for the sake of the game, for keeping the integrity of play. But now we're on game three or game four of the same scenario. And it's obvious that having that extra item or taking that extra three experience, which we could do just by playing another round is going to be kind of necessary. She's level seven. I'm level six. The enemies are too hard for me to defeat and so I need that little boost. Is that cheating or is that maintaining play? Is that continuing to have fun with something that's getting a little tiresome?
There's really two main reasons why I play a board game. I play a board game to have fun primarily. However, there's a secondary reason that I like the mental challenge. And like Jesse's saying, if we've figured out the puzzle, what we need to do when we enter the first room, the second room, the third room, what items we need to take, how fast we need to go, when we need to take our
mental challenge, you mean the narrative, the story, right? We're playing for the adventure, the heroism.
No, no story involved whatsoever. games are about strategy and tactics and the mechanics at play. So once you've figured all that out, it starts to become a drag when you're replaying the same scenario after scenario because you got the wrong card at the wrong time.
And I really dislike losing due to random chance, at least losing due to random chance at the very last moment of what otherwise has been a successful strategic game. And on top of that, a game that you have to beat in order to continue progressing. It's one of the complaints that I had about Nemesis. This game where you might end up being infected, having a hive pop out, and suddenly you've lost what otherwise was a perfect 4-hour strategy session. But at least in that game, a loss is just that. In Gloom Haven and many other campaign games, a loss means you're replaying the adventure.
And other times, a loss comes with a severe penalty or punishment for the loss of that episode. Now, we're only talking here about cooperative games. In a competitive game, it is never okay to cheat or fudge things even a little. But in cooperative games, you're playing together and you're trying to beat a game and the game sometimes has it out for you. So if you change something just a little bit to give you an edge up, a level up, could that be okay?
Here's the thing about competitive games. There is and are some instances where cheating is perfectly acceptable. There's, for instance, games that involve cheating as part of the core mechanics where you're trying to lie, bluff, or make sure you can swindle the goods past other players. There's games like, I believe, cheating Moth that comes from the same company that produced Cockroach Poker, where if you can get away with it, everything's fair game. And then there's also the context of uh house rules or fudging the dice to make sure that a seven-year-old who's playing with you doesn't just have a bad time. There's uh what's it called when someone has a slight advantage. Handicaps that give one player a slight advantage over others at the table who might have just a touch more experience.
And also, if you're playing a competitive game where there's a bit of take that, which our good friend Westy always likes to include, isn't ganging up on the most experienced or currently leading player at the table a little bit of house approved cheating?
And then sometimes you house rule to make the game a little bit harder for yourself. You're having just a little bit too much fun and it's a little too easy.
So, is that the game cheating against you?
Zombide. Take that one for example. We continuously make it harder for ourselves, add more abominations, make the enemies harder to beat because it's not fun if it's just too easy.
It's kind of like playing through a script and you know what the ending's going to be. What's What's the verdict? First off, is it cheating? If you fudge the rules on a cooperative game to make sure you can continue progressing with the story, is some degree of hedging things to make the game more fun for inexperienced or younger players okay and approved? Are house rules uh adaptions that you make to make the game more playable, or are they uh a sin against God, man, and the industry as a whole?
Most likely a sin. It's an open-ended conversation in some part because I'm curious where the audience is. But for us,
it's a conversation that we started to have over the weekend as we were like, well, if we play the same scenario five more times, then Jesse will have enough experience to level up to be the same level as me.
You'll be level 9, which is going to outbalance the game as well. I don't want that to happen. So, I fast forward by like 15 experience. I'm just not gaining as much as she is anymore. Yeah, you might have said that when I level up, you are just going to level up.
That's what we're doing at this point in the game because the cards
aren't leveling up anymore.
The cards that I have taken, we're level We're level seven now.
I just became eight.
We're both level eight.
I just became rightfully eight.
So, there's no more stronger enemies. There's only stronger scenarios. and your build of your uh mech, your your giant uh bastion of explosions, your demolitionist,
your card build just happens to be producing more victory points than my lovely
experience.
Same difference. My lovely little aggressive
hatchet
hatchet. So for us to maintain the fun of the game and continue moving forward, we were just kind of fudging some of the core mechanics. If the game rules were tighter, experience points were earned in a very very dedicated and purposeful way, or if we were playing Corebox Gloom Haven, where experiencing up too fast means you start back at a low-level new character,
this conversation, I think, would be very, very different.
Same thing with resources like coins. You can play a scenario five times and kill just enough enemies to get enough coins to then buy the item from the shop when if you know that you can do that if you just need a certain item taking that item onto the next run that
Why do I want to play the same scenario five more times?
Correct.
But we do have some hard and fast rules like we've never cheated to end in victory on the first game. No, we have played it at least twice, if not three times
because learning the strategy is important.
And if it came down to a single card draw at the very last moment when we were about to die, yes, you could have had that euphoric moment when you turned over that times two, but when you turn over that miss or even that minus two, it's crushing and you're like, well, then I have to play this whole episode one more time.
And I think that's a really important thing to factor in here. For instance, a crushing death roll in Kingdom Death Monster where the last survivor either could have had a heroic stand resulting in a beautiful Nat 10 that has a perfect crit hit and slaughters the line with a puncture through its windpipe or a crit fail that results in his legs getting ripped off and you returning home or not returning home with anything at all.
But even then, that's within the story of the game and you're playing within the narrative. But the important part there is you're not ever replaying
that same fight.
You're going into something new the next time with the story that came behind it with the memories of those warriors who tragically perished.
And I hate to see them die, but I think I hate replaying the same scenario four times just a little bit more. So, should board games avoid having you replay? Well, that's not an obvious answer either. Sometimes you need to learn something and sometimes you really do need to level up before you come into the next scenario. And so if it's going to take you playing that episode five times to level up because the next scenario is just that much harder, then you might have to do that.
Now, there is also a answer that the rule book gives us, which I'm left unsatisfied by for some reason. And that is you could make the entire level that you're fighting easier. We could go down some levels to mitigate how challenging it is. But my problem isn't actually with how difficult the scenario is. I want the puzzle. We play the game to solve it. Yes.
But once I've solved that puzzle and it's the last card flip or just that tiny little bit of extra resource between this fight and the next fight, well, that's where I'm okay starting to fudge the numbers. And that's my instinct. I want to move forward. I don't want to make it easier, but I do want to progress. Your instinct initially is
my instinct is to play it exactly how the rules are written and not to fudge a single thing
and to have such an unfun time that you maybe stop playing.
Correct. But then I have to remember and remind myself what is my goal here? My goal is to have fun to get through this entire game with
to establish your dominance by excelling and winning 100% of the games you ever encounter both competitive and cooperatively. Ultimately, games right now are our form of date night and they are to have fun and spend time together. And if it pushes me away from wanting to play the game and finish the game, then it's doing a disservice. And
so the only question I have remaining is how can I cheat effectively and efficiently at Cigrada Legacy
color better?
That's not cheating. It's not. I I got to figure I got to figure that one out. All right, I'll let you wrap it up. Tell the people what they need to hear. Ask him some final questions. Remind them that subscribing uh helps out the channel quite a bit.
You're casting a massive shadow over my face.
All right, that's a very a polite way to say that I'm
Whatever the case, whatever you do, remember to do the important thing. Get out and play some games. Have fun with those you love. And
just a little bit.
Achieve a crushing victory. We'll see you next time. Bye.