Root, Blood Rage, & Inis vs. Avalon: The Riven Veil
Transcript
hello welcome to calou thank you for being here today I'm comparing and contrasting three of my favorite dudes on the map area control style board games with Avalon the Riven Veil from shadowborn games we're going to be taking a look at inish at root and at blood rage now I know there's a lot of other high scoring well regged area control board games out there on the market I mean we own in our Personal Collection things like Kemet and Cotes as well but I don't know them quite as well as I know these three and so I wanted to give you all a breakdown a little comparison between the things that I think stand out in each of these three titles and what stands out in combination with that here in Avalon I want to talk about things that you like in root that you'll find an Avalon that you'll enjoy as well or things that you don't like in root or things that you love in root that might not be here if you're looking for another game to give you that same environment or that same feeling I want to give you the highs and the lows and help you all make a critical decision ision because we are running out of time over on the kickstarter campaign they are about to cross $1 million funded or very very close to it I expect to see them cross it before the end of The Campaign which happens in like 16 hours or so and they have a ton of unlocks already so exclusive expansions Miniatures tons of deluxified and exclusive metal upgrade component set if you're looking for the fanciest sexiest version of the board game that you can get your hands on ever
and so hopefully this video gives you a little bit more context and contrast now remember if you don't have the $100 or you know more to put into Avalon right now you could back immediately to get the extra special access the pledge manager access and go ahead and put a dollar into the campaign or something along those lines so that you can back it at a full amount later on all that being said that's not the point of this video let's talk about and start contrasting Avalon with the other three games that I have here on the table I'm going to assume that you all watching this have a little bit of context for what Avalon is and what it's doing I'll give you a quick 30- second breakdown and then I want to start talking about the highlights in these other games Avalon is a victory Point scoring dudes on the map area control style board game where you're going to be conquering or exploring various different areas in Avalon that are hidden and submerged in the Mist revealing creatures that you can well uh partner with or I forget the actual term you can imbue them uh with with whatever your desires are and they become allies of yours including relics that you can add to your Heroes to give them extra strength or extra Buffs when it comes to the actual combat side of the game you're going to be scoring and controlling regions by having the most people there along with a battle system that could either be uh a little bit of a pressure luck system to give you some variability and some luck uh not quite dice rolling but drawing from a deck to try to match a certain number that you
have played from your hand or an alternative system that has no Randomness and no chance and no luck to it at all for those of you that like a clean I'm going to slaughter my enemies without them feeling like there's anything they could have done about it system or mode this game plays two to five players with the brand new fifth player expansion happening late in the campaign and the Fay look fantastic I only have four of the characters here to display so you should swing over there and take a nice close look at them as well the main objective of Avalon is to play through two or three seasons so the length of the game is also a little bit variable and score as many victory points as possible you'll be scoring these victory points from areas that you control on the board relics and monsters that you're able to acquire that have victory points attached to them quests that you're aiming at that you're able to achieve and complete and depending on the player faction that you're using and if you're playing asymmetric player powers you'll also score victory points based on a unique system for each character or each narrative that's journeying through this game there is a lot going on here and I could say that this is a highly complex game but to be honest the base game the simplified non-asymmetric have a catchup mechanic included version of the game is very accessible and very playable with a ton of scalability in between one of the reasons why I think it's fair toque or compare Avalon with so many other area control style titles is not that they
exist in the same genre but specifically because Avalon has so much variability and so much flexibility and how you as a player can approach it and bring it to the table meaning that in one version of it it matches up with root for instance if I'm playing asymmetric factions I have to take a look at the game that like defined that genre I know vast came before and a pile of other games thereafter but most of us have come into this version of this world through a game like route if I'm looking at deluxified beautiful components with big climactic battles and very very tight card play I have to take a look at blood rage right the deluxified Seamon game that now is way too expensive to buy third party off Amazon or not off Amazon off of eBay because everything's just hard to get your hands on and for those of you that are completionists like I am or at least have been before I had a tiny little baby boy I I me it's it it is it is hard even if you had the money to track down all the desperate pieces and components and if we want to look at something that gives you very interesting uh reset and grow systems a way to like you know establish your dwellings across the span of the board a shuffling Min maxing figuring out how you can utilize the card abilities that you have to get just the perfect amount of people in the right position to score you or win you the game then we have to look at a game like inish right and so depending on how you're playing this depending on the
systems that you have that create balance or create chaos depending on the systems that you have that create a cemetery and your own personal Journey or narrative that you're utilizing verse give you just a platform where everyone has an equal playing field and it's the best person who comes to the table wins then all these other games match or don't match in varying different ways the core mechanics of Avalon the Riven Veil are going to come down to the asymmetric player Powers if you're utilizing them and specifically a hand of cards that you will be drawing up and using now all of these cards have various different types of abilities you have cards that allow you to move play settlements out recruit and fight engage with combat and all of these cards are filled to the absolute brim full of hundreds of unique pieces of artwork they give you a thematic underlay lots and lots of Well story and text that give you the mechanics of each card and lots of unique abilities making this a highly variable game when it comes to the type of cards you have in your hand and how and when you utilize them they're used both as the marketplace for attack power and the marketplace for victory points at the end of a round and the marketplace for paying to use and utilize other abilities as well as they're used as a way to well do your basic actions across the board and so you have to be able to look at your hand understand the components that you have there and then decide how and when to spend those cards
or play those cards or hold on to those cards so you get the most bang for your buck the most value out of what you've done it's primarily a hand management style game with a emphasis and a focus on where you're positioned and where you have numbers on the board and what is going to pay off in the long run do I conquer this one area that's going to give me access to a relic that I'll be able to equip to one of my heroes that'll hopefully let me win the Holy Grail going into season 2 and season 3 do I Bank on the fact that I'm going to get the Green Knight to help me catch up a little bit and I focus more on how I spread myself across the board or how I upgrade some of my asymmetric Powers early on in the game do I go for early game victory points and a few quick relics and maybe a monster or two that's under my control so that by season 3 I am playing and conquering and holding down a large component or a large subsect of the board there's a lot at play here and a ton of cool things as you explore it so with that let's talk about how this matches up with some of other titles and I think the game that it matches the most closely to is going to have to be blood rage for those of you that have not played blood rage this is a Helter Skelter game where you're expanding upon Asgard I think that's the right term forgive me if I don't remember specific names of locations on boards that is one that I should probably have written down I never know what I need to remember until I'm in the middle of filming a video and then I'm like I should really be more confident
with that specific name that I'm utilizing here Jeffrey gets it everyone else is at a loss for words you're spreading your troops out on the board you're conquering and getting more and more upgrades and abilities on your own player map increasing your strength increasing your ability to recruit and place people out increasing your ability to spread and hold these locations at the end of every phase or end of every round you're going to be scoring these battles that are happening and if you win Victory you're be taking a ton of victory points home it's going to be a primarily hand management and drafting style board game the cards that you have are going to be the abilities that you can utilize the creatures that you can play they're going to be tricks that you can take and they open up a ton of different ways to explore and score in blood rage I think this game is defined by powerful surprising actions by monsters on the board that you've taken harborage of that have now been uh willed to your uh desires and I can't say controlled but at least directed towards your enemies above your yourself this game is also produced by seon way back in the day and it is beautiful right lots of fancy Miniatures lots of great artwork it's one of those games that really put SE on on the map when they were first coming out and putting out and learning how to use the crowdfunding area the crowdfunding space and has been a beloved game since arriving into backer's hands years and years and years ago so Avalon shares a lot of similarities here it has the powerful
nuanced specific card abilities these superpowered moments where you feel like you've really taken control of the game or or held on to the right card in order to make the most tactical careful play I don't think it's fair to say that Avalon has any type of drafting mechanic but I do think there's an argument to be had where I could convince you that it did you see blood rage and inish both have a beautiful drafting system where you're passing cards around the table and you're keeping the card that is going to be best for you and choosing what to hand off to other players Avalon doesn't have the part of the game where you're choosing what to hand off to other players the cards that you draw up or the cards are going to be sitting in your hand and I have to be honest I like drafting so much that that's kind of a let down for me right I like my favorite area control games are the games that give me drafting some of my favorite games in the entire genre of board gaming are the games that give me a little bit of drafting but Avalon has what I'm coining inhand or single person drafting because the cards that you have that you draw up are so wild and varied and powerful and you can choose what category you're drawing up into you can kind of direct the type of cards you're going to be bringing into your hand and then you have to make tactical decisions around how to utilize them like I said Avalon has a lot of different uses for the cards that you have they could be the resource to pay to play a different card and sometimes that is a must you have to spend cards to play other cards they could be utilized for some of your
special character abilities for basic actions for power in battle they could be saved until the very end of a phase very end of a season to give you as many victory points as you can get there's a lot of reasons to hold on and to spend to read cards carefully and to make really really careful decisions around when and how to utilize them and in some ways this feels similar to at least half of that drafting experience I'm looking at my hand deciding what I'm passing on what I'm not going to be utilizing myself and have to use for the sake of playing the game I'm not giving them to other players and so I'm not holding anything back there's no hate drafting or direct interaction with other people when it comes to the cards that I utilize however when it comes to what's in my mind there's a very similar feeling or experience as there is when drafting cards for inish and for blood rage it's at least half of that process again a very personal single player drafting game now the other big things that happen here is at the end of every season the end of every phase you're going to be fighting here on the game board and blood rage and Avalon have a lot of similarities when it comes to the way that your boards and your characters develop and the way that you actually resolve Combat on the Tableau like I said Avalon has a uh two different versions of combat systems that you could utilize you could utilize the one where you play a card indicating a highest number and then draw card from the top of a deck to try to achieve that number or get as close as possible to that number if you bust you then only
get half of the maximum or total value so if I was drawing to a nine and I hit a 10 I'd only get I think four I think it rounds down but I I can't be sure on that there's also a version where you don't have any Randomness or luck to it at all where you get the straightup number that's on your card that means that you could play this very similar to how you play Blood Rage with the abilities and effects of your cards manipulating the board the troops that you have face up publicly displayed and the card value or the card number that you're playing or however you get to maneuver things when it comes to the actual end res resolution of the game that is the only thing that gets to control or change the actual battle phase this gives you a very straight up especially if you're not playing with asymmetric factions a very straight up min max hold the right card back for the right moment get your troops as strong as possible and win victories by the skin of your teeth there's also a variety of different ways to score and winning victories while being a primary one sometimes isn't the main focus for instance with the Fay which is the fifth faction that's been introduced you might actually want to position battles so that they happen and you score second place so there's a lot of different ways that you approach the battle system and it's not as obvious as uh you know always coming out on top often times it is but not always along with that the Miniatures and the deluxified I would say above almost anyone else I say see producing stuff in this space I love the Dual plastic I love the color I love the fact that you
can go ahead and get these Miniatures washed for a very cheap very affordable price if you want to have them pre- rendered and prepainted ready to actually get to the table very very quickly and finally the last thing that I want to analyze and look at is just going to be the fact that this and everything that this is is very closely matched up with everything that blood rage was when it came into the space from seon deluxified upgraded produced for Kickstarter and produced very well for Kickstarter this is the type of board game that if you're a backer if you like all of the exclusives all of the extras the metal deluxified components and the Miniatures that people are scrambling for 5 years from now looking on eBay and paying way too much for then Avalon is one of those that you want to get your teeth into early should have round it all out I'll grab my notebook cuz I'm I'm not above actually trying to take notes so I can get everything as accurate as possible if you're looking for in Avalon powerful characters that get extra abilities that get equipment that upgrade them that get monsters that they can join forces with then this matches with blood rage very closely if you're looking for Epic Production right just a beautiful game to hit the table this is probably going to be better produced than blood rage was back in its day and if you're looking for a very similar combat system where you're squabbling to try to gain control and gain victory over a region on a board in order to
score as much as possible then Avalon as well matches with blood rage along with that after every season part of the board resets so you have this whole EB and flow this swell that happens on the table that then sinks back down into uh a reset and a reexploration phase for any area that don't currently have settlements out on the board now one of the ones that I think a lot of people are going to be very interested in is root rout of course is not necessarily an area control game while some could argue that it is you are positioning yourself controlling regions and trying your best to follow your faction's hierarchy or your faction scoring conditions in order to win the game it's a race to win system where hitting 30 victory points closes out the game for everyone the first to do that is the first to take home the trophy and I don't think base game Avalon has a lot of stuff to compare over to root but asymmetric Avalon I think has a ton and this is where I find Avalon to be such an interesting and compelling game because the asymmetry here isn't something that's necessary it's not something that needed to be added to the title for it to be as good as it is and I think it is a little bit more complex than some people are going to be ready to dive into I I highly recommend playing this base game with your game group quite a number of times before trying out the asymmetry but for me the asymmetry adds that extra layer of sweet something that's necessary for this game
to have lasting power staying power on my shelf I love a game that gives me story that adds new variables to the experience every time I play and Avalon gives you the opportunity to do that just in the similar way that root does now the thing that I love about the asymmetry in root is that each system has its own set of rules its own conditions that you have to follow to the best of your ability given the chaos of the board in order to score and win and if you follow your system better than everyone else follows their own personal system you'll likely come out the Victor Avalon is shockingly similar when it comes to asymmetry it's not quite as obvious because it is still more of a Helter Skelter straightforward scoring try to get as many victory points as possible you can't not follow the rules of the game but it twists the needle in a very interesting way and is probably more balanced than base rout is or natural root is without players adding their own balancing to the table so let's talk about this let's talk about how some of these factions compare to the as symmetry in root we have Once and Future King this is going to be the uh lovely gvir who's trying to collect and find I think it's gwi right yeah gwi who's trying to collect and find uh King Arthur himself and she is going on her own epic quests her game instruction basically dictates that she follows and completes objective quests and takes
over different regions of the world that have relics that she's looking for but she doesn't care about holding or harboring on to one location in particular so she functions a little bit more like the Vagabond exploring moving through the board trampling people in her way and trying her best to collect resource and collect strength until she becomes overpowered and King Arthur has joined forces with her and they just go on a uh absolute Rampage across the land we have Mor mored the ascended and mored this is the uh uh beautiful Undead who are doing their best to kind of conquer the entire board this is one of these big coin factions right like the birds the Erie or the Marquee the cat they are spreading across the board they are setting up their own little Network of settlements and they're trying to have influence in every single region and then surprise or shock with pure numbers strength or tactical card play that gives them control when it really really matters these are going to be these big beefy factions we have another big beefy faction which is the uh fomorians now the fomorians the Balor are going to be looking at using the ebbing and uh the ebbing of the tides on the edge of the board to control and direct their play very similar to how the Eerie for instance have to follow the hierarchy that they have they have high tide mid tide and low tide and as the game Cycles through those phases for this character they have different abilities and different powers that they can utilize
so timing is key and knowing when and how to utilize or take advantage of whatever abilities you have coming up is going to be a central portion for how they play a lot of careful tactical play a lot of timing your cards correctly and knowing when and how to use what you've been given like the Eerie sometimes you're given way too much and you can't summon a nest or place a roost or get a person out and everything falls apart and then finally we have Merlin Merlin operates a little bit more like chaos across the board a giant moving settlement a character that can pop in and pop out of different regions when he's fully built up The Druids are just Terrors and they're very similar to a faction like the Woodland Alliance or the corvid conspiracy they work by using subterfuge by not by you not knowing exactly where they're going to be or similar to the lizards by having an encampment that is so dang strong and powerful you don't want to deal with them and then finally the Fay is the fifth faction that's been released and the Fay work off of manipulating and actually maneuvering other players pieces around the board taking some off placing some in probably a lot of negotiation a lot of over the table conversation happening there similar maybe to the otter for for instance where you're utilizing other people's pieces to get the effect that you're looking to achieve or the corvid and other sort of conspiracy oriented factions where you're trying your best to make the board operate the way you
want it to operate which is just dissolve into chaos and uh benefit you the most when it does so so the asymmetry in Avalon is a more advanced possibly more balanced and maybe less straightforward version of the asymmetry in route if you want to play a game that feels like it has a narrative through line that gives you a journey or a story that you can go on and really lets you or encourages you to play high into the character that you've been given Avalon does that when you play on the asymmetric side it focuses in listen if I'm playing with Gwen air and I don't go hunting for King Arthur and everyone else is playing their faction specific roles or abilities then I might have a fun time but I'm probably not going to be overly competitive similar to root if I'm playing the you know Marquee the cat and I don't spread my Woodland Empire and my harvesting Empire across the board in the most effective way possible I think this is lovely and it also lets players do a similar thing to what you can do in route you can screw other people over by knowing how their factions play oh you really want to gain that uh Holy Grail there in the center well I'm not going to let you because if you do I know that's going to be the thing that allows you to flip your character giving you access to a more powerful unit letting you run away with the game it introduces the ability to read the table to understand the story that's happening and try your best to interrupt it while you achieve and
accomplish your own personal goals along with that there is very careful very tactical hand card play in this just like root so if you love the cards the deck of cards you get with root where you can get powers and abilities that let you upgrade specific uh or or have specific unlocks where you're able to get cards that let you maneuver or change actions or or or uh you know create environments on the board that other players aren't expecting you get the chance to go into a battle and you have a uh a block What's it actually called I'm I'm blanking what it's actually called in route but you have an ambush card in your hand and you're able to just screw people over it has that same nature now Avalon is a heavier game a more complex game in the core mechanic system but probably not as complex when it comes to the the learning of all the different asymmetric factions that exist here I think root is probably more complex when it comes to getting it up and running right off the bat whereas Avalon has a more complex rule set when you get into the depth uh and all of the systems that are operating and in play so if you're looking for a uh asymmetric win conditions asymmetric characters to play through this will be one that matches up very well if you're looking for a uh a lot of player interaction uh for some factions and not necessarily a ton of player interactions for other
factions if you're looking for a game that gives you different experiences for how to approach it and how to play it this will match up as well and if you're looking for a game that has thematic and tactical hand and card play this matches up very good if you like and rout a race to win system as opposed to straight victory points then Avalon of course is not offering you that if you like uh or don't like complex factions then I think Avalon factions are probably a little bit more complex than roots are again I think root is probably a little bit harder to get up and running initially but the depth of Avalon and the amount of rules that you have to learn as you get farther and farther into the weeds great game but lots and lots to learn and pick up I don't think if you're buying this you're going to be playing asymmetric factions right off the bat in the same way that you would be playing them right off the bat if you got root because it's the only option that you have if you're looking for um very very specific careful hand management as well this matches up very closely with root so an argument to be had at least a comparison can be made between those two games and the final one that I have here is going to be inish now inish for those of you that haven't played is a beautiful hand drafted card drafting hand management ability taking board game where the objective is to have control whether it's influence whether it's power whether it's control of other people's uh areas whether it's control of settlements you you need one core principle of control on the board in
order to claim victory and then secure victory at the end of a phase or a round it is not a victory Point scoring game it's also not necessarily a race to win game it is definitely a you know attack the King of the Hill Style game where everyone pays attention and close attention to whoever has positioned themsel in the best way possible with the most Advantage possible it's a game that has extremely powerful cards very very interesting abilities and gives you a lot of satisfying card play and a lot of satisfying timing play to figure out exactly how to squeeze out the best result for the set of cards that you've received or that you've chosen for yourself uh when it comes to inish it doesn't have a draft phase Avalon but like I said the card powers and the internalized sense of drafting certainly is there looking at your hand and deciding what you're going to use and what you're not going to use is highly highly competitive and highly variable and important to the game I have to make really good decisions around the cards and the card abilities that I've been given so that I can get the most out of this turn so that I can win as many regions as possible it has very tight numbers and positioning when it comes to trying to score for each of these regions and because the game resets and any region that doesn't have a settlement on it reshuffles different regions with different region Powers meaning relics and monsters and scoring
conditions and unlocks when you actually claim them come out onto the board very similar to how inish has its regions or zones that continue growing as the map evolves it's not quite a direct one to one I mean I think this is probably the least connected if I had to paint a picture between the various systems with blood rage being the most and the as asymmetric version of Avalon being uh fairly tight or fairly close or adjacent to root but inish definitely has its feeling and its fingers in this game I have to say though if what you like in inish is the Smart careful tactical play that results in a victory based on your positioning Avalon is more focused on those large scale Victory Point scoring that big swingy moment so there's that bit of nuance there when it comes to Tactical careful card play tactical careful positioning but it's for a different outcome it's for a different objective it's not quite as clean not quite as simple not quite as straightforward as inish is what did I write down here for the last things on inish it's got a very very true area control uh Focus has a board that resets and recycles does not have the same Victory condition is not as simple but gives you very satisfying card play moments and cardplay abilities and has a clear leader that starts defining themselves as the game goes on now there are catch-up mechanics and things that can happen but part of the nature of an
area control Style game like this is sometimes groups of people decide to focus their attention on another player that's something that's very similar to what happens in inish and if you have a runaway leader the other players at the table will do their best to kneecap them a little bit so they don't get too far ahead or get too close to that uh very very tasty scoring condition so there you have it a quick breakdown a rundown of three of my favorite dudes on the map area style board games are area control board games with a game that a lot of people have been talking and giving very high praise in this market and in this space thank you for watching thank you for being here let me know if you have any questions I'll do my best to answer them throughout the day so that if you have any other you know nitpicks or Design Concepts or ideas or or wondering about a mechanic and how it compares to Avalon in any of these three games or other games that you all are familiar with I'll do my best to respond whatever the case though whatever you do remember to do the important thing swing over there and at least get a dollar in the pledge manager because I think this is going to be one that a lot of people end up regretting not having gotten and so if anything you could buy like seven copies of them and sell them for like four times the profit on eBay and about about two years just throwing it out there I don't have the money to invest personally but it's probably not it's probably not a bad buy especially the cheap metal upgrades and the wash Miniatures they're offering I don't know that's I need to get into that business if anyone just just wants to like you know go in with
me and invest like you know this is there's a lot of kickstarters think think if you went neck deep in Kingdom Death when it first launched with those resins that were available or if you bought you know 10 copies of blood rage when it first came out I I'd have like seven Poodles by now I think that's what you do when you make a lot of money you just buy extra poodles it's like every extra you know $100,000 new poodle than so you get a Chihuahua out a million I don't know I've never been there whatever the case though whatever you do remember to do the important thing get out and play some games we'll see you next time bye