Essen Spiel 2024 New Releases – 1st Impression Part 2
Transcript
hello and welcome to board games and coffee every year at Essen Fiel hundreds of brand new board games are released and it can be a bit overwhelming to figure out which one is the one for you to go for um I go to Essen Spiel every year or starting two years ago so this is my third time and the purpose of this video is to look over some of the brand new titles that are going to be released this October at Essen Spiel so you can get a sense of what about these particular games really stands out and whether or not I might recommend it according to my personal taste but of course mostly what I want to focus on is uh what are the key characteristics of these games so uh if you are watching this on YouTube I am taking requests any game that you would like me to look at go ahead and let me know in the comments and I'll be sure to go through the rule book and follow up with a later video um part three uh today though let me show you what I've covered so far or what I've read so far so these are the games that we've talked about the ones with the check marks are the ones that I talked about in part one uh today we're going to be looking at some of these so agree to disagree civil lution fishing smoothie Wars Tea Garden through ice and snow mesos Captain flip and castle combo um if you
want me to jump to any of these as we're going through those go ahead and let me know in the comments I'm happy to cover uh whatever you would like although I will probably keep this video at about 20 to 25 minutes so that maybe go over about six seven games spending about two or three minutes on each one uh lastly if you would like to uh listen to this as a podcast I will leave a link to the board game and coffee podcast in the description of this video so first G we want to look at today is civil lution so cilu uh I wanted to start with this one because at Essen there's usually a big heavy hitter popular game that's a heavy game and uh I really get into the heavy games so I like trying to find like what's what's going to be my favorite heavy game at ESS uh last year it was evacuation uh by Vladimir sui and this year I suspect it could be um civilan which is a Ste felt game so let me tell you a little bit about uh civil because this is a pretty complex game it took a long time to read through the rule book but really what I like about this is it's kind of like a cross between castles of burgundy and one of these games that's very big on individual player powers like know teram
mytica or something like that but what makes the game really stand out is unlike most board games where you start off with your unique player board and you your unique player power in cvoluion every player uh constructs their unique power over the course of the game so they can construct all of their um their strengths and weaknesses and their scor in criteria all of that is done during the course of the game as they add attributes to their uh their race or their civiliz civiliz civilization um but the driving mechanic of the game is a dice worker placement where dice are placed in pairs I really love games that have you placing dice in pairs because it gives a really nice um problem solving space um you're not just dealing with the role that you have but rather how you're going to pair up your dice to make your actions be performed and then like castles of burgundy there are a lot of different ways to augment your dice so add or subtract one to the value um several different kinds of tokens that you can earn during several many of the actions in the game but the big driving idea is that you are constructing these pillars of cards that describe ride both the uh objectives that you're going to pursue during the course of the game and the unique strengths that you're going to pursue in
this game so I think the replayability of the cvoluion is very unique I can imagine this game being very exciting to play once to develop a certain civil uh civilization and then after playing whether you win or lose wanting to play again just so you can take a completely different p and do something differently but I also really like the game because I I like how it kind of um it's a more indepth castles of burgundy and whereas I think castles of burgundy is a lot drier of a theme this one is very engaging very inviting so this is this is a this is one game that I might really really enjoy I at least want to try it maybe add that one to my collection uh the next three games that we're going to talk about are all requests uh from the previous video from part one so again if you'd like to for me to go over my impressions of a game go ahead and let me know in the comments and I will do it in a future video uh so the next one we'll talk about Captain flip so Captain flip this is definitely a family style board game in this game players have a pirate ship that they're adding crew to and there's a very easy um mechanic for this game you're just drawing a tile out of a bag and that tile has a pirate character on it and an
ability and you get to add that to your board and you can select where you place it so the board is essentially a grid although it's not a rectangular grid the um each I guess it's we call it a series of towers really in the artwork of the game um you're placing it on trees or masks things of varying Heights so maybe one Tower is four tiles high and another one is two tiles High um but from that grid you've got rows and columns and you're trying to place things in a way that they will score well based on what row they're in the column that they're in and the number of other tiles that you have so this is a lot like um Isle of sky for example where tiles are going to be you know have varying value for each player but what's interesting about the game is that each time you draw a tile if you don't like what you draw you have the option of flipping it over and playing the back side instead so there's two characters different characters on either side of the tile and when you draw you must draw so that you can only see one side and then it's up to you to flip and take the other side or keep what you see so it's exactly equivalent of being able to draw two cards one card fac face up and one card face down do you want what you see or do you want what is a complete surprise to you um in that regard I feel like it's fate
decides this game really you're you're complet taking a 100% risk On The Backs side of the uh the tile but what's cool is how you augment that risk by tile placement and the game comes with different player mats so there are a few different ways that you can uh change the game play this is a very very simple game uh I like the artwork a lot I think it's very attractive the question of whether or not this is one that I'm definitely going to seek out probably not one for me necessarily just because the innovation in this game is not creating uh a a a problem space that is very interesting to me the big question is do I want to Flip This Ti over or not I do like the problem space of how are you going to deal with the tile that you've drawn I think that's really cool but there are a lot of tile placement Gams I get excited when I see a mechanic that's that's very unique so this one doesn't excite me as much um but it would probably be very recommended if you've got younger kids or if you've got um if you if you're looking for a light game and again I do think that the character artwork is very Charming on this one so that's Captain flip and the next one we'll look at is castle combo so castle combo is a t building
game you're you're drawing nine tiles and each time you take a tile uh you have a choice of taking from either the top row of a a market of three cards in the top row did I say tile cards they're cards you're going to be constructing a tableau of nine cards and there are two markets top and bottom kind of like Splendor for example and the top row represents Castle cards and the bottom row represents I think Village cards and so on your turn you can Nei take one t one card from above or from below and these cards have different uh abilities that will play against each other so I think this game is it has a there's a lot of different cards and a lot of different ways that they're going to either give you coins for purchasing more cards or keys so those are the only two resources in the game you spend coins to buy the card or you spend a key to um to refresh the market and what's kind of cool about this guy I forgot to mention the two rows you don't always have the choice of buying from either row rather on your turn you can either buy from the bottom row or the top row you borrow from one and then at the end of your turn if you took a card with a I'll call it a switch indicator on it a switch indicator on it then then you
switch the available Row for the next player so maybe you buy a card and the and the effect of disc card is that the um is it there's a there's a playing piece that you use to show which roow players can currently take from so maybe this one that you've taken lets you move the playing piece up to the top row and next player must take from the top row depending on what they take you may be able to take from the top row or the bottom row it's always switching so if you have a key you have some agency there you can spend a key in order to switch the available row or you can spend a key to refresh the market either way you're going to be drawing from three cards you're going to add it to your Tableau you're only going to have nine cards in this game so it's a nine turn game I always really like that I like games especially when I'm playing with my kids that are designed to be short I enjoy that but oh and I would actually make a comparison between this game and farm club farm club is like a nine turn Cascadia so to speak so for me um because I have farm club and I really like farm club I don't know if this game is doing something very new and I kind of don't like the um I kind of don't like it when games just kind of have very arbitrary card effects what what they all do the artwork is cool I like the castle theme but um again I'm in a place where I'm not really seeing an innovation in this game that gets me very excited but can always use more like
quick games for families anyway that's that's the driving the driving mechanic in castle combo next game mesos mesos all right mesos is coming from from uh crano yeah cranial same designers as like barrage and um those games um so but this game is a lot lighter than a lot of other games that come from crano so what's this one all about um I wrote down that mezos could be likened to like a super Advanced King Domino so if you're familiar with King Domino I will give you an idea what uh mechanic I'm talking about so in this game players are are taking cards from a a market and again you've got two rows of cards just like uh just like castle combo so the top row are going to be brand new cards that have just been drawn from the deck and the bottom row are the leftover cards from the previous round so the cards that nobody took so so usually the top row is going to be more valuable than the bottom row
because no one's had a chance to take anything from the top row yet so maybe the good stuff is still up there anyway you want to take cards from the top row to the bottom row and again it's all kinds of different scoring things that's common for these kinds of Heroes um but uh how do you take these cards well you're going to it's kind of a programming Style game so you're going to place your worker on the turn order that you want to select cards from and you've got several spaces so the the first space is first and turn turn order but if you go first and turn order you don't get anything you just get food which is a resource that you can spend and then the second space is you could have one card you get to go you know the first person to take a card but you get one card from the bottom row and then the third space is going to be third in turn order but you get one card from the top row and then I and then I I think I'm I'm trying to do this by memory right as it goes on the next card you get two cards one from the bottom one from the top I think and then the next one is what's maybe it's like two from the top and so each one eventually you get three you can take three cards and it's one from from the bottom one from the top one from the bottom and it just gets better and better and better but when you take that later action you're going later and turn order so even though you're getting three cards you're getting the leftovers of what everybody else left behind and then at the end of the round after all of those cards are
taken some of those cards were never available to anybody in the first place because some cards that come out are event cards so the event cards are among all of these and the event cards tell you what's going to happen to everyone's tribe so you've got your tribe cards and then you're going to face the event and use your cards to kind of like deal with whatever good or bad thing happens and then the cards that no one took from the top row get moved down and then new set comes up and then again in the same turn in order you bed for the the following round so um I like that I I really like the mechanic of taking your your card or tile or whatever it is and determining turn order at the exact same time um that's that was first introduced to me through King Domino and now I see it in this game which I think is very cool um it reminds me a lot of another like a Paleolithic type game where you were man where did it come from I can't remember what I can't remember the name of the game but there was another Ice Age type game was that seems very similar to it um honestly again it's it's another card drafting game there's so many card drafting games and I and for me to get another card drafting game I want it to be very special so this one is not doing it for me not for me but I you know it's cool and if if you've never played teing Domino before um and you want something that's harder than it anyway I think this is a great choice so that's mzos
all right let's see what's next agree to disagree okay we've got agree to disagree is a party game and I I really like this I don't buy a lot of party games um mostly because I like to review board games on this channel but occasionally a really cool party game can be fun um and I'm sort of on the fence about this onec but not because it's not awesome but only because I don't play a lot of party games here's the idea uh the idea is you draw a card and it has a topic on it and so like the active player creates a controversial question about that topic and it can be all kinds of things like it could I don't know like is a is a taco a sandwich I I don't know that's probably a lame example or politic I mean it could be well actually I don't think it goes into politics I think most of the cards are like silly things like I don't know something you would never put in your carryon luggage or something you can you could think of something and you say Hey you know this is something you should never do and people make their opinions but here's the deal everybody makes their their opinion whether they agree or disagree with this player's completely madeup controversial statement and then they they do this privately and they have a unique little device and the way that this device works is that you've got two
sides of it and the two sides look identical but they're not because how they lock it's they're they're like puzzle pieces right how these two puzzle pieces lock in together depends on whether or not they are opposites so if one person said agree and the other person said disagree you can slide those two pieces together and it will be flush but if two people did agree and I'm oversimplifying it here with my hands then when you slide the pieces together it won't be flush and so because they'll be because it won't be flush you'll know that you don't agree but you're not revealing to the other players what you actually chose no one can tell what your choice is but they can tell whether you agree or disagree so if you find somebody who disagrees with you then I I think you get a point for that you're trying to find people that you disagree with and then you break off from the group and the next person tries to find somebody that they disagree with and people get elimin well they're not eliminated but like people are scoring points and as as information gets revealed about who's agreeing and with who finally there's one person left and then everybody places bids on whether the last two remaining people are going to agree or disagree whether they're right or they're wrong you get a point for that so it's neat because you've already learned something about everybody else based on how you've put your opinions together
but you might not know anything about the last person and you get to kind of take your bet on what they'll say which is a really cool idea and I think it would be really fun I do think that there might there might be a challenge in the game because the game is not does not include its own at least this is my understanding from the rule book it doesn't include its own controversial opinions it it presents a topic and then the the active player presents the controversial question you know that it requires some creativity there but I really like the the the sliding together of the two pieces I think it's really cool um all right I think we probably have time for one more and if you're joining us keep in mind you can share in the comments either while we're running or after the show gets published and tell me what you'd like to hear about in The Next Episode let's see what the last one is oh fishing oh I'm really glad fredman freeze I was so excited to see this game because he's the designer of Friday which is one of my favorite soliter games mind you I don't actually own a physical copy of this game play on my iPhone cuz it's soli there like why I don't need a physical coffee but I love the design of Friday so when I saw this it's a trick taking game by Freedman freeze I really wanted to look at the rule books so what is this game this is a trick taking deck builder trick taking deck builder doesn't that already sound cool it's a trick taking deck builder so
what do you got you you draw your hand and you're playing a trick and then the winner of the trick takes all the cards and adds them to their deck and then they you know you play out all of your cards and then you draw your next hand at the end of the round well once your deck Runs Out you take your discard pile you Shuffle It Up you put it over there so here's what's really neat if you're winning a trick you're winning it with the highest card right like your card is the best card and all of the other cards are presumably worse than yours unless they're off color off suit so you're getting your card back and then everybody's worst card and it's getting added to your deck so in a way as you're adding cards to your deck you're almost becoming weaker whereas people who are losing tricks earlier in the game they're losing tricks they're hand has less cards in it which is less points but at the end of the round after everyone's played out their entire hand if you've run out of cards in your draw pile and you don't have a lot of cards in your discard pile because you haven't won a lot of tricks cards from a brand new deck get dealt out to all the players who still need cards and the new cards are better than the first round cards so if you lost you get your deck replenished with better cards but you have fewer points if you won you have more points but you might have worse cards does does this make sense it's a really cool balance and it's such a cool catch-up mechanic because I really think it can go either way and then the best
thing about this game is in addition to that you can play a card for um like some of these cards have special abilities that can like mess with the results right so um trying to remember some of these abilities like one of them don't quote me right I'm this is all this is all my head I don't have it all memorized perfectly one of these cards is like you it's like the winner of the trick gets your card but you get everybody else's cards or another one can like switch the result or they they can all kind of screw with people and I think that's super fun so this is a trick ticking game that has some really clever uh decision making to do because you're like sluffing cards that that are bad to to hone your deck but you're losing points when you do that I just love it I think it's brilliant I definitely want this game I think it's awesome uh the two games so you know in summary the two games that I think are the coolest of this list are fishing and what was the other one civil I really think civil civil is going to be cool those are games that I've marked to go after all of these other ones none of these games are like you know bad I think they're I think they're clever I just I question whether or not there's something really new that's going to make me want to buy it all right well thank you very much for watching this video and U please leave me your requests in the comments and