Skip to main content
Loading video...

Herbaceous, Delicious, Floriferous, Whatnot Cabinet & Sunset Over Water Reviews - Pencil 1st Games

Transcript 19:10

hey everybody today I'm going to be taking a look at these five filler Games published by pencil first games these are all designed in some combination by Steve Finn Eduardo baraf Beth soell and Clementine cardu now before I get started on the reviews and ranking of these games I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kendra. do.uk who are my go-to online retailer and if you use the link in my show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order okay so I'm going to start with my least favorite and work my way up to my most favorite and I don't want that to sound overly negative because I actually like all of these games and if you watch my content regularly you might know that I do actually regularly get these games to the table so the first game here is in the biggest box of the five this is the what not cabinet now this is a t drafting game one to four players takes around 20 minutes to to play so it is ultra fast and this is a puzzly Style game as you are drafting these tiles and then placing them on your little bookshelf and trying to build patterns so you want to have kind of the same color or different colors in a row and columns as well as trying to achieve public objectives Now The Twist on this game and to be honest most of these games have this running theme that it plays with the kind of initiative order as well as the kind of control you have

over the game in relation to that initiative order so the way the game playay works here is that you'll be placing your little player porn on this action board here and the earlier you go in this action board it means you're going to get first turn but the less control you have so for example if you went right at the start here you'll simply draw I think three tiles from the bag blindly you'll keep two of them and discard the other one but the further you go down the line you might say fill up the common Supply and then get your free choice of taking two of those tiles again you have a lot more options and more flexibility at the sacrifice of an um initiative order which can be important because that public display of tiles can change by the time it gets to you in player order and you can even take a complete Punt and wipe the um the public display of tiles and hopefully get the exact one you want which can be useful towards the end of the game as your cabinet gets filled up as you can imagine um your options are quickly squeezed down and kind of one wrong placement in the wrong space can completely um hurt your scoring so this is a game of small margins um it's very light in terms of it game play again it's going to be a couple of points in between the winner and the loser in this one and it's all about getting that optimal um TS in the right places and sometimes even a bit of a push or luck mechanism um because you know if you're going to get all of the same color in a column then um that's not too easy to do but you are going to get more points for doing so or do you want to play a bit safer and try to go for one of each

maybe get all the same in a row instead and try to kind of cross-hatch that to work with all of the different rows um and columns again Ultra Breezy super quick and it is a pleasant game you now I have played quite a lot of games like this where you are arranging things you know games like my shelfy come to mind um but this one yeah it's kind of completely inoffensive it's not the best game on the market but it's completely fine you can teach this to non- Gamers um and you know I think it's enjoyable I'd happy play this one anytime anywhere really um do I think it has the claws and the grip to really hold its own in my collection long term I'm not quite sure it does you know right now I'm content with it I'll play it several more times but is it going to hold up to the great filler games that have that constant hook and engagement to keep you coming back and I'm not sold on that because it is so light and sometimes you are really dependent on the luck of the draw on the tiles but um if you regularly play games with non- Gamers and you like arranging things and you do have sometimes those exciting moments where you draw the right title at the right time that fits perfectly on your on your shelf and that happens more often than not actually or or happens quite regularly for those fun moments so um you know a very soft recommendation um to the right group again that lighter level um of game group that is the what not cabinet the next game on the ranking is sunset over water again one to four players 20 minutes to play um on average

now this is a kind of a set collection style game as you are navigating around this Big Grid um of these beautiful cars me the artwork in this game is quite um spectacular each player has their own kind of player piece and what you're trying to do is you're trying to collect these landscape cards which will have certain features on them and try to match them with these public contracts so some might say um you want an objective with a waterfall and a mountain on it and if you're the first to complete that by collecting those cards you'll cash them in for those victory points on that particular contract now much like um the whatnot cabinets and these other ones I'm going to mention initiative is very important with this one so the way the game works before anyone moves and collects their cards is that you're going to simultaneously select one of these kind of action cards which will have three different pieces of information on it so you can see here from the back of the box out here the first piece of information is the time and the earlier that time is bear in mind there's no duplicates at all in in the decks amongst all the players the earlier the time it means you get priority in initiative order and you can move and collect your cards before the other people do which is of course great if um if the other person is after the same card that you are um but the second piece of information is the directions that you can move in so sometimes they're more restrictive where you can only move orthogonally sometimes they are very free free where you can move diagonally and any way you want really and it even shows the amount of spaces

you can move so sometimes you can move quite far sometimes you can't move far at all and the final bit of information on these action cards is how many cards you can actually pick up so there really is a conflict between those and when to use the strongest cards at the right time you know if you need that final piece of your puzzle to get that big contract card completed then you might want to play your early card so that you beat everybody um to the punch and get that card before other people do so it's quite nice that you're all interacting on one grid here and you can snatch cards from each other and you know step on each other's toes passively um throughout the game there's a few extra wrinkles like for example there are public objectives where if you are the last player to do a certain thing on a turn or on a round of the game you'll get some bonus points and that could be things such as getting your play piece into the corner of the board or pick up a particular landscape card with a certain symbol on it and that can sway you at time times to uh to get or to divert your strategy or tactics to pick up an extra point or two and that's pretty much what the game inels you just play through the old kind of deck of action cards until you only have two left and then um and then you tot up your your score and hopefully You' collected the most points but this one um you know I've played quite a lot of these grid movement style games um this one is probably my favorite one because of that simultaneous um card system I love that conflict of how early you want to go in in initiative uh which direction you can move as well as how many cards you can pick up and it's just

yeah it's a really nice game wrapped up in a tight package and um I would say this one is probably about 6 and a half out of 10 for me maybe even a seven um on a good day next up I have delicious now out of all of these games I think this one feels the most different because it is more of a flip and right Style game you still have a ton of set collection going on here but it does just feels different the way it actually um way it actually plays but this one is a one to 100 player game as you know a lot of Roland rights are you're looking at 20 minutes again and the boxes for 14 plus years now in this one you are essentially going to try and fill up all of these kind of um Planters of different fruit and vegetable and you're going to do that each round by drawing two cards from this deck which will have the different fruits and veg on them however each one of these cards is assigned to either the top row of your player sheet or the bottom row of your player sheet and you have to put them in the corresponding spaces but the twist is that on your personal player sheets you have the options to um to draft these cards in different ways or use these cards in different ways so for example you have four opportunities to take a card and keep it exactly where it is again either that top row or that bottom row you have three opportunities to flip that around so you for example you could take take the bottom card but place it in the top row of Planters you got three options to take both cards and you have two options to

take both cards but place them anywhere you want there's also kind of extra mini games going on as as you take these cards there is a random token placed with these cards which will either have a tool on it or it will have a fruit on it now the fruit go in a completely different scoring category where you are trying to create rows and Columns of the same or different types of fruit and the tools allow you to break placement rules so for example if you are really missing a certain type of vegetable then you might want to use the tool to kind of break that rule and place what you want where those tools show but you can only use that once for each tool type on the on the player sheet itself now this is a very um kind of constricting game again your options very quickly run out and you have to know when to commit and know not when to commit um but essentially what you're trying to do is you're trying to collect either kind of pairs of different types all different types all the same type that kind of thing which again is a running theme in these games you have a few opportunities to make cards wild so if you are really in a bit of a conundrum and back yourself into a corner you can sacrifice that and make it into a wild but you have to use that quite carefully and make sure you use it to its maximum efficiency as well as having potential scoring for um each type of fruit or each type of vegetable of a specific type you have on your player sheet so it's I'm not going to say it's a massive diversion from a lot of other flip and right style games but

I like that kind of um restriction of this has to go in the top this has to go in the bottom but you have a few ways to overcome that and there's even even a little racing mechanism where if you are the first to fill up I think all of the top or bottom row of planter of of these Planters you can get some bonus points as well as each individual planter you'll get a bonus point if you are the first to complete it but yeah if you like your flip and rights I'm pretty sure you will like this one again it can be quite frustrating at times because you can have um you can have fruit or VCH coming up that you're just not able to place um but that doesn't really bother me because it is such a fast game and out of all of these games I think this one's been the most up and down for me now when I first played it I liked it but I wasn't really you know Mega impressed by it but each time I played it since I enjoy it a little bit more which is always a good sign uh for me especially in such a bloated Market of set collection games and flip and right style games so that is delicious um again you're venturing on a 6 and a half to maybe even a seven out of 10 for this one next up I have herbaceous I'm staying consistent with this one by being a one to four player game that takes around 20 minutes to play and out of all of these um this one is more of a traditional card game you know you're drafting cards and trying to build sets with them um very simple to play and I think this one is the lightest out of all of these which is saying something because they're all relatively light in

their own respect but this one um essentially what you're doing is that you are drawing these cards in a biblio style if you're familiar with that game um and you are one at a time you are choosing to put one of them in either the communal row kind of available to be drafted by not only yourself but also the other players and one of them in your private garden and what you're essentially trying to do in this game is you're trying to collect sets of cards according to these five different sorry four different um scoring cards that each player has so you are trying to create um collect all different types of these herbs all of the same types of these herbs different pairs and you even have this kind of bonus plant P where you can get some extra points by kind of straggler cards but what I really love about this is that you can only ever score um each of these scoring cards once per player so um if I ended up scoring my I don't know all of the same cards I can no longer score that again for the remainder of the game so it has this kind of chicken mechanism as each player is building up this communal um pool of cards but being cautious that yeah the points getting better and better but another player might jump in there and choose to commit to score one of these categories um and lock themselves out of it for the remainder of the game but could that have been the best time maybe or could they have waited longer to score even more points and I love that tension in this game it actually comes through really strongly for such a simple design that's pretty much what

the game entails but I do like the idea of um you know cards being worth different things to different people because I might have I don't know a ton of a certain type of Herb in my private garden and um if I'm trying to build towards a particular um scoring card for example the one that needs all of the same type then the the cards in the common pool they might not be that important to my opponents as they are to me so again it might be the time for me to pull that trigger and commit to that card at different times than my opponents but very simple stuff simple Cass set collection but that tension shines through um really well and yeah this one Breezy as it comes um I think it's this kind of Timeless feel to actually I think it's aged very well and it feels fresh as anything out there on the market very attractive uh to look at and again that you could almost turn your brain off to play um but still have a good time doing it um so again this one herbaceous I'd probably say 6.75 maybe even a seven um out of 10 and the final game I'm talking about today again one four players 20 minutes to play this is floriferous now I can quite confidently say that floriferous is my favorite game out of this bunch and again I do like them all uh this one is a kind of pure set collection style game as you're collecting all of these beautiful flower cards um according to these other cards that you're scoring so you're either scoring the cards or

drafting the cards themselves or the scoring cards that correspond to the cards that you've picked there are also public objectives where the earlier you do them the more points you'll get so for example it might say you want a a lily a daisy and maybe a ladyb bird if you do that then you'll get some extra points but what I love is how you draft the cards in this game and sadly the back of the box doesn't really show it too well but what you're going to do is that you are going to place all these cards in columns depending on the Play account there'll be more or fewer cards there and then in player order you will place your card or your player token on one of those cards and add it to your scoring Tableau but the Twist on this one is that the lower you go down in that column of drafting cards it means that you're going to go last in the next um draft so it has this kind of King Domino system but purely based on how the cards are laid out but the scoring cards themselves are always on the bottom so if you're going to want to um dive deep and get one of those scoring cards then you are going to go last in the next turn which of course could mean that all the best cards that correspond to your scoring cards have already being drafted so again that conflict of control versus initiative is what this game is all about um super Pleasant to play and there's just something about it there's like a little magic ingredient that works with this one and this has been a grower for me um over the years and when

I first played it I thought yeah this is this is simple stuff it's it's nice but it is what it is really but I think um the more I play it the more I'm seeing its charm the more I'm seeing how refined it really is and I do love that decision of you know when to hold back when to commit to going deeper and sacrifice at your next turn some additional scoring as well like for example this like bouquet cards which might give you particular cards to try and collect as well on top of the ones you're already getting so you have scoring within scoring here and synergizing scoring categories as well as collecting these little stones for some bonus points and even a little area control thing where you're trying to collect the most statues to get some extra points as well um sounds like there's a lot going on but this is ultra digestible I have taught this to non-gamers and it's resonated straight away and it's just um a game that anybody well you can make the decisions but the decisions are they're not obvious but the decisions that anybody can make and you don't have to be a gamer to understand the um you know the the levels here it's very simple stuff just trying to get the best but again when do you want to commit to um to giving up your next turn to get the card that you exactly want um it's a joy to play um I really do recommend it actually if you want a solid foundation of of um of filler games in your collection you want a a staple set collection game that you can get played Ultra quickly and teach to almost anybody as well as looking gorgeous on the table and floriferous kicks so so

many boxes and this one is definitely a 7 out of 10 maybe even a 7 and A2 out of 10 for me so there we have it that concludes uh the video this is the video I've been wanting to make for quite some time but just only just got around to doing it so apologies if you've been waiting uh for this one but hope this has given you what you want um again me ranking um these five really nice filler games um from a publisher that certainly has my attention and I will check out everything they put out because their um the quality control is very very high I know similar games here they have a a thread of DNA that's the same um but different enough to Warrant owning all of them in my opinion and I don't intend on parting with any of these at least just yet but hopefully you have enjoyed the video if you have please be sure to hit like And subscribe and check out my other content too and for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved