Skip to main content
Loading video...

Unmatched Legacy - Interview with Iconic Designer Rob Daviau

Transcript 52:34

you are now the owner of Christmas morning's Christmas afternoons and birthday parties do you want to mess that up hello and welcome back to another episode of the cardboard Herald my chance to talk with creative gamers and game creators and returning to the show I am joined by our guest today Rob dabio welcome back to the show Rob thanks for having me yeah man well last time we talked about your history everything leading up to where you were about a year ago as well as some games that were coming out but I wanted to talk to you about your life as a pro game designer Rob first off man I feel like since we last talked or even just in 2019 alone you must have had like 10 games announced and/or come out so how do you manage your schedule when working on so many projects like do you just go with whatever you're feeling particularly passionate about at any given time or do you block specific time to work on specific projects like how do you spend so many plates diligence for the most part that's the thing about working for yourself right if you just decide you're not gonna work on a date no one tells you you can't other than your deadlines don't move and I did that yes it was like my first sort of just screw around day in 2019 do you find periods where you're like me and I'm just not feeling this project right now I know I I really need to work on this but this other thing is really excited and I want to chase this down while I'm

actually feeling the fire oh yeah yeah I mean so what I do and the answer to the larger questions I have a master to-do list that's good it's got stuff for home you know hey I got a call this plumber or something like that but mostly it's works it's mostly works though and it's big and it's between my original designs and restoration games and if I looked at that list all day I wouldn't know where to start and so what I realized was I keep that list on like a tab and at the usually at the end of every day I'd go through the list and I cross off everything that I did that day and then I add things that cropped up and if it's a good day I add fewer things than I crossed out but usually it's like a push right you finished something on a project and you're like well now there's the next thing on the project like I don't write down every single thing I need to do for a game it's sort of like what do I need to do next what are the next couple things on the event horizon and I take this master list of like 70 things and I copy the whole thing under my daily to-do list and I cut it down to no more than 20 and preferably 10 things that I want to do the next day and I don't look at the master list coz it's overwhelming and then I wake up the next day and I look at those 10 things and I do those 10 things most the time I it's about 15 or 20 but I try to do at least 10 things on a day and that doesn't include having meetings doing podcasts these are just like the move the game forward design stuff that I

need to do but when I'm making that list of like 15 things I'll say like oh I should really work on that no I'm not gonna have enough time that's like a real deep design thing where I need three or four hours of uninterrupted time and looking at my schedule tomorrow I got a bunch of meetings and a bunch of calls and I'm never gonna get in the zone so I will pick the 15 things that sort of match you know what I want to do and then comes the weekend which is great because I have no meetings and then I can actually do the deep dine to deep dive design stuff do you actually set aside time to think of new ideas like do you pencil in time like brainstorming for future projects that'll come to fruition all three years or is that just organically happening as you're working on another project you go aha this idea would be terrible for this project but I can put this down as something else to work on I haven't done that in years and it's in and it's not a bad thing to have with restoration games I'm sort of the chief creative person so I'm planning the line so I games will come up and things will happen so I'm sort of blocking out the next two or three years of games so we have a number of games that we sort of have on the horizon that we don't really have the rights for yet and I haven't thought about yet but there in my head is okay I'm gonna start thinking about this when I catch my breath they don't even in my master to-do list yet because it would be overwhelming for my original ideas I've been very fortunate the past couple years of being

in a place where publishers are seeking me out to ask to work on projects so instead of thinking of my own ideas I have a publisher come to me and usually say I have X game would you like to do a legacy version of it writing that's kind of what I'm known for and I keep waiting for people to stop sort of requesting that but it's still no not because like I just expect like okay what's next right like I like working on them and be in and so far the sales have been good enough that people are asking for it but I keep being surprised like oh we're still doing these okay I'll do another one and some I say yes to and some I say no to but it feels like every time that I get to a point where I can catch my breath and say well what do I want to do another one of these opportunities comes up in addition I have at least two but probably closer to five games that are basically done that for whatever reason the deal fell apart with the publisher then as soon as I catch my breath I'm gonna go back to those and either find another publisher for self publish them and I keep saying I'll get to that by summer fall winter right why can I keep finding these moments because when a publisher does come to me they usually have a schedule oh we want this game for a 2021 line and we talked back when I would have to be done in arrows ooh I have to start like in a month you know to hit your deadline and I try to say no to as many as I can but I also realized that like an author like a movie actor like a musician I have this very limited window where people want to work with me before they

move on to the next thing they want to work on so I try to do I try to balance between saying yes to too many things and getting burnt out and also saying no I'll work with you in a couple years and then having people move on to like the next thing so it's a constant balance of trying to find that that workload all of these things are show that I have a successful career so I can't complain about any of them sometimes I'm a little too busy and I feel like I don't want to think about a game again and then I take a weekend off and go watch a baseball game in cooking I'm ready to go back to work and but I'd like to dial it back a little bit to just I'd like weekends back or Sunday's Sundays would be good to have yeah that's the dream man just like having some time where you can unwind and you don't even have to think about all of the other things that you're working on yeah by me but to be fair I also know that um I mean especially if I don't have meetings like one two three o'clock is just in the afternoon is my downtime I have lunch in my brains like oh you're tired I get up at 7:00 in the morning usually I'm at work 7 to 8 and I'm ready to go boom boom boom look at this I'm gonna crush this list of 15 things by lunch I never do but I always think I do and I hit one o'clock I have a meal and I'm like oh I'm done and if I don't have meetings because I work for myself and again I'm just gonna read a book watch a TV show take a walk and here you are some other stuff 9:00 o'clock Eastern Time talking on a podcast with some guy

in Alaska you just don't stop yeah I try to leave my nights open but I recognize for things like podcasts people are in different time zones and a lot of people have day jobs so it kind of encroaches into my nights but that's the one thing I do try to protect is I get to about 5 o'clock at night and I'm done because I started at 7 I probably put in a 10 hour day maybe 8 hours if I took some hours here and there and I'm like I got nothing left cooking is my hobby I go cook I have glass of wine I watched some baseball and i recharged for the next day but even still sometimes I'll find myself on the couch go oh you have your laptop you're answering emails what are you doing you know you mentioned cooking twice now and we actually talked about it quite a bit last time like you were on the show and it's something that we have in common I see the things that you put online and I go like man I'd I would like to be able to cook the way it robbed avio cooks but or at least how it looks like it tastes how it looks i aw yeah yeah I always put up the stuff that looks good and you know and I take eight pictures to get it to look that good exactly exactly but I had this question set aside as something like man if we have some extra time I might as well ask this but hey we're here we've been talking about cooking what's the last meal that you had that like inspired you did you feel good was it leave was it something that kind of centered you or you know like what was the the lasting feeling that you had because I feel like this this interest in food has a greater impact on you than

just nourishment well there's really two of them cuz why give one answer when you can give two that's why podcasts exist man yeah on Sunday it was very hot here we had a heat wave on the East Coast it was like 92 degrees and my wife was out of town my daughter's like a grown up so it's just my son and me I thought I want to I want to barbecue which is kind of a weird thing to think when it's 95 degrees but I knew would be cool or like at 6:00 at night and I just had some potatoes leftover that's what started it that's that when you talk about original ideas I'm like what am I gonna do with those potatoes I'm like I want to grow um like do I want to grill something my son loves pork tenderloin so I'm like I'll grill a pork tenderloin and then I started thinking like well what do I want the flavor to be and I started backing up and I did like a hickory lightly hickory smoked charcoal grilled potatoes in pork tenderloin and and it's the middle of summer here so I have like rosemary bushes mint and all these things growing and I'm like cutting it and doing all sorts of stuff and I just kind of nailed that pork tenderloin just like the perfect blush of pink in the middle nice char on the outside kissed with smoke and then I got this new thing I do which is I um I take the meat off when I'm cooking it and let when you let it rest and note to everyone let your meat rest for a few minutes to many minutes depending on the size of it totally um I take a cutting board and I

just minced garlic and I chopped up rosemary and I put some smoked paprika cuz I'm a sucker for it and just made like a slurry on the board and then when I took the meat off to rest I put it on the board and just rolled it around in it and then when the juices kind of came out and went in it cooked the garlic just enough and sort of coated the whole thing in stuck oh yeah that's the secrets just leave a mess on your cutting board and when the meats doesn't roll it around in it don't let have raw meat on it but you know than that you're good to go and I sliced it my son took a bite and just a look on his face just a look of Oh like dad what did you make here like that was just a moment right cuz it was a perfect bite for him he just walked by and grabbed it and it was just this amazing thing now that being said I totally screwed up the potatoes but what are you gonna do hey well I got that good a tenderloin then who needs the potatoes yeah well I realized that the potatoes absorb too much smoke so they were a little ashtray think cuz potatoes take forever to cook in the extra time on the grill had too much smoke and I could see it coming so I was moving the VINs to try to do it but it's still too much so I pulled him early they weren't done but they were over smoke so I put him in the microwave finished him in the microwave and then I realized that a lot of recent barbecue has like pickles and stuff his acid can cut smoke mm-hmm so I made a really lime juice heavy mayonnaise and just kind of put the potatoes in there with some cilantro almost saved it not quite there's still a little smoky I'm

sure everyone who is watching this video or listening to the podcast is like damn I would eat those potatoes in a heartbeat yeah I got some left over so I'm in the morning I'm getting up every once in a while and heating him back up and putting like a real runny egg on him so that the yolk coats some Tuesdays that is the best like when you man getting like some potatoes in like a cast-iron skillet and then in the morning and just get a really runny egg on top of that yeah there's nothing better and yeah so that's like that cooking thing and and I said there were two answers the real quick one I won't waxes poetic cuz I happen to be in Las Angeles a couple weeks ago for work and I treated myself which I do about once a year to a really nice dinner so I went to Jose andreas he has a restaurant called the bazaar in Beverly Hills and got a 16 course tasting and if you go back on my Twitter feed you can see it I got it paired with wines and everything like that and I had a stipend because I was traveling for a client so I'm like this isn't costing me that much it's basically taking my entire stipend for three days and one day whatever and that that was a one of my favorite meals that was a sublime eeeh when you meet people who really know how to do anything paint cook make music make boredoms make board games like cobble a shoe like just people like put shrubs around your house to make a look at when you see someone who like takes real pride in and rises up like it's in this amazing moment to see a crafts personal you're like oh wow I never thought about this thing that

seems so mundane like eating a meal that someone could like it so much to bring it up to that level and it kind of applies to just a lot of things where someone gets passionate about making something or doing something do you ever view yourself in that same light that someone might be watching this video right now taking you know any sort of inspiration about the the things that you do the things that you create the passion that you have for the work that you do do you see yourself at that artisan level most of the time no because when you're in the middle of it it's just the journalists right it's the to-do list and another thing and how am I gonna make this deadline and can I do something interesting again and what is the audience want and I'm sure the people who made my meal at this restaurant felt the same way it was a Friday night otally and they made it and they're like and they had a bad day and it was another thing they did every once in a while and it happened sometime in the past couple weeks I'll get this moment where I'll kind of like someone will mention a game I did a while ago I'll go wait a minute I've done some cool games hey you know what I made an impact here I've done something cool and then it goes away right having a moment where I can sort of see it outside it's like wow anyway I got these emails answered what's that contract right and you go right back in the middle and I I try to enjoy it it's just when you're in the middle of the day-to-day stuff I hope I retire at some

point I live long enough to gain reflection on my entire life including my career and get a perspective and I'll be like I I did that well I didn't do that well I'd like to do that over but I'm certainly enjoying it so far hey that's the important part and hey you're also you know just coming out with non-stop interesting things I mean whether it's this collab that has resulting enormous Cthulhu miniature or your reviving things through restoration games I mean and the like you said earlier you're the the legacy guy your legacy is partially legacy games and that kind of in a lot of ways change a little landscape of tabletop gaming so I think you'll have a lot to reflect on but I wanted to get back to this this notion that publishers or other designers or other individuals clients are coming to you and pitching things to you what does that look like does someone just say hey I want to rob dabio project it doesn't matter what it is I just want a game or are they bringing you a theme or they even bring you like an outline of the type of game that they want and then leave it in your hand it's not an open blank check and I wouldn't want that right right right I mean I've had another publisher saying hey if you have any ideas please pitch them to us you know the type of work we do and I'm like okay that means I'm a professional successful designer so yeah I'll take that but what I'm talking about is for

example I've got machi Koro legacy coming out from panda soros next month and a couple years ago the publisher came said what do you think of a machi Koro legacy and I went I don't I don't know like that I don't I don't think so maybe like what's that like and I went back and I played the game again I went oh it's pretty straight forward which is what I look for in a legacy game right you start with something pretty straightforward and you can go in unexpected direction so like oh they have an expansion I play the experience like oh they've already started to push it in a few different ways but I wasn't quite sure and then Jr Honeycutt who's a co designer on it and I were talking about it and we just started riffing and we realized that if we didn't take it too seriously Ryan um if pandemic legacy I sometimes write things I'm like you're his theme and here is like literature and here is structure and here is I'm gonna put you in an emotional place where you are this person in this situation I was like well if you just get away from that and you go now this is kind of a fairy tale I mean you're just building these silly shops suddenly a whole bunch of design space opened up and and so what I usually say to a client or something if they if they do something that is because I've I've said yes to a project and then start working I realize I don't I don't have an idea I like I get a contract and the clock is ticking and you know it then it's like I work and I

work in a revise and revise it and I mean you know and then it's like really tough it's like if you had this idea and there was no client you go and wasn't a good idea and you'd move on but now I'm sort of shackled to a contract so what I say and I think I said it too much of course but let's not sign a contract just give me three or four weeks and if I feel like there's something worth pitching to I'll pitch it to you but then I still pitch it to them and if they're like yeah I like where that's going I think I would work I'm like yeah I've actually sort of played tested a game let's go to contract on it no I know a lot of the the games that you're working on or under contract but do you have any examples of games where you know either it was under contract or maybe it was your own personal project a while ago and you got to a point where you knew that you were stuck and you had to stop and then you kind of let it rest for a year or two or maybe even more than that and ended up kind of resurrecting the project with a new perspective yeah there's one I won't get into who the original person was because I just don't need to get into like sure sure situations but there was a licensed game I was working on and I was finished and I turned it over and after like a year and a half we realized it wasn't exactly what they wanted or some stuff had changed with the license and I said look just just give it back because I think it's a good game and I'm not quite sure where you are with this license but it doesn't seem to be the game for you

right now with the license away it is and then I kind of like said let it sit on my shelf for six months sort of been like a year and a half almost two years since I looked at it and I looked at at this spring I said it's a good game and I rethink it away from the license obviously and I brought it to like in and I played it a couple times and people really liked it and I noticed some flaws that I hadn't seen before and some things that I wanted to tweak like the normal development cycle like oh it's a co-op game and usually with a co-op game there's one way to win in multiple ways to lose which was true in here but only one of them was gonna trigger I said you'll never lose on these other three conditions right right you'll just always lose on this one and this is the one that you lose on really late so you always feel like you're about to win but you might have lost early and I say I need to get the other you know I need to rebalance a few things and then I had redeemed it with like a Norse theme and called it low key and then and then yellow put out like a kid's line called low key this summer or this spring right right I was like oh okay I had a plan B for a theme so I'm just gonna rithi MIT again to plan B like I was tor caught between this Norse thing and like a different idea and I was like well I'm gonna go with a different idea and my friend from high school helped me out on it so he's got like a little bit of a like design share and I'm supposed to see him and I'm gonna be like let's just make it sillier I feel like a lot of games take themselves seriously and I've had a lot

of fun lately so many games themselves dead seriously lately with like fireball Island and like giant kethu little miniatures and realize we're making toys and games right we can just loosen up a little bit and I take myself seriously sometimes so the Loki theme was very serious like there is you know Loki is playing mischief and you're all Vikings and I'm like I love these great minis and I still think it's a bad idea but like this other idea is just goofy mm-hmm I'm like I want to repaint this as a goofy idea and see if it just kind of loosens up a little bit gets a little less you know uptight about the whole thing you know that's an interesting thing I actually think about Richard Garfield here because of course he's known for being the creator of Magic the Gathering but I feel like every game that he's released since Magic has been a very silly or fun creative theme like that that is definitely not taking it so self seriously as I set of magic was I wonder if there's a degree of reaction to that that's interesting ought to make a note of that right like sometimes it can just be dumb fun and that's fine sometimes it should take itself seriously but I've been taking myself a bit too seriously like three or four years ago and I'd like to loosen up a bit well I think there is something artistic about that I mean you think about like for example the far side by Gary Larson I mean so much of that is just dumb absurdity put into single

panels but it holds up so incredibly well in almost like a profound way that Gary Larson would be ashamed to admit but you know you can do something just because it's fun not because it makes sense removing some artistic shackles I think so in a lot of the games that I'm I have coming out in the next year really embody that like we mentioned death may die with a giant Cthulhu figure yep Eric lang and I when we were designing it last year kind of said I think was Eric who pitched just like what if it was a 90s TV show that had been a competitor to x-files but get cancelled so we don't even call them scenarios we call them episodes and then there's a couple like Kickstarter exclusives or add-ons that I don't know if they're exclusive which are called like The Lost episodes where we deliberately wrote scenarios that are just nutty just not not serious at all where you're like oh no these were the ones like left on the cutting room floor right this is after the show got cancelled midseason but they you know we're like we might be able to sneak in a few extra episodes and they never really got the budget to finish them but you know this is what they what they hope to do eventually yeah so I started saying to people like oh it was a competitor to x-files who got cancelled after the second season Aaron's like oh that sounds great like cuz it just paints it as sort of I mean the quality of the miniatures are great in the art

is great but if you just kind of go into it with a vibe like oh it's a series you'd find on Netflix that sort of has a good can't be fun and shipshape that I have with Calliope has a draw pile that you can see into right on these big foam tiles and unmatched is anyone fighting anyone and machi Koro legacy is just whimsical fun so I've had fun lately just saying like let's just let's just have fun let's just play a game like well that's fun you know you mentioned that death may die the co.design with Eric Lang and over the last couple of years you've had some really amazing collaborative design projects I mean you also had pandemic legacy with good old leaky and hey I think I may have mentioned that in an interview with him I can't think of anyone who would go by that nickname less yeah yeah exactly now it's a it's a running joke my pandemic crew the people that I played legacy with through two seasons of legacy one one season of legacy two we they are diehard pandemic fans and they've affectionately referred to Matt Leacock as leaky anytime that they're like leaky got us on this one and so I just stuck yeah yeah sure yeah no word Matt and I are done this is the design

of season three you know it's it's with the publisher whoa okay Don it's not done there's a lot of Hoops to jump through before the game is done but we are now we have moved to reacting to the publisher the developer the art people everything else like starting to say what do you think about this and what do you think in like we're doing this and we don't get a final vote but they're they're kind enough to give us like input how much is season three influenced by reaction say to season two or for that matter how much of season 2 was reactionary to season one because I I know that from my perspective they're both great games I I love how different pandemic Legacy season 2 was but I know that the reaction to them was was different I think a lot of that is because the the landscape was different when pandemic Legacy season one came out versus when season two came out yeah um well we started season two before season one came out so it wasn't manipulated or influenced by it at all way so what do we think we did right now that we've what did we think we we had let's see it was April and we had finished like six months earlier like okay we've had six months perspective what you know now that it's all settled and we've read the files in the documents where do we think we went right went wrong we wrote it down or like we think we did more right than wrong so we feel pretty good about that but how do we just not do the same

thing again cuz people have just played 15 17 games a pandemic Howard how do we not give him 15 or 17 more with a different story yeah and then Season one came up when we were six months into season two and kind of about halfway done or had the big decisions made and I was like oh thank goodness we started this cuz I would have been heavily like oh what did we do right why is this happening right like and then we wouldn't have known where to start so one of the things we did do is on the second half of season 2 we looked at some of the things that people said like oh you know this was I didn't like this I like this and tried to change and sometimes it's little stuff like in season 1 there are 8 boxes that you can open and in there the dossiers and the dossiers start again at 1 through 8 and we made sure for season 2 and for like season 3 there's no duplicate numbers if we tell you to open box 3 there isn't also a door 3 yeah and there isn't a sticker 3 like everything has its unique number so you you can't mess it up like right we didn't think of that in the early half of season 2 before even sees one came out we said okay look this is probably gonna be a trilogy we should probably think of season three at this point so we can make to make sense with three right so that they it feels like it went together so we took like a day or two as like a diversion and did some very broad brushstrokes of what three would be like and then one okay well we'll figure that out in a couple years and then went back to two so when we started three fall of 2016 is almost three years ago we had some idea of what

we wanted to do of course most of ideas didn't quite pan out but the big broad brushstrokes of the time in the place and the plot actually held up and were in place but I think that it's gonna sound incredibly egotistical so forgive me but I feel like there's a there's an analogy where season 1 was like Star Wars and that people hadn't seen something like that before right in season 2 is like Empire Strikes Back was a little darker a little gritty er I think it's a better constructed game than season 1 but everyone's like oh yeah I saw that right like it didn't get the accolades and it didn't get the like attention that it did now some people can argue that season ones put together the better than season 2 and stuff like that but I think we knew it before it came Oh like how do you think this will do I'm like they've seen it right people will like it but it won't get the attention it won't get the awards it will just be more of a smoldering fire than a raging fire and that's exactly what happened I expect season 3 to be hopefully Return of the Jedi and not like Godfather 3 so you're saying there's going to be a walks in the pandemic legacy season 3 promising Ewoks I'm just saying there's a forest moon there we go perfect oh here it is populated by whoever you wanted to so I predict season 3 will be again quieter than the first two just by just by the necessity of how these things work right like it we tried to make three is different from two as two as one and

actually there's a lot of world building and a lot of story and everything but you just know at some point go go they still make in these things you know it's just the nature of it so on these projects these collabos that you do and even restoration games I mean by its very nature it like you you are always collaborating on these games that are coming out like how do you resolve conflict like when you're working with another designer and you feel opposed when it comes to a core game principle whether it's pandemic or you know it's definitely died or any number of things that you've worked on do you just kind of massage it until there's a compromise do you view one person as the lead designer on it that gets to make that kind of call do you just kind of antagonize the other person until they finally give in no that's not my style every game is different every partnership is different I like collaborating because I'm a talker no I get a lot of ideas yeah I get a lot of ideas by talking if you put me in front of a if I'm doing content development like story and writing and things like that I will definitely want some quiet time but if we're doing that early design of what it's supposed to be like and throwing around ideas I love talking them over I love sitting at a table and talking about it and writing notes down and putting pieces of paper on the board and things like that and and sort of making it happen so that's why I like

doing so many collaborations but every partnerships a little bit different like technically I'm the chief creative at restoration game so any game that comes out I can be a tiebreaker but I don't ever want to use that as a hammer so Isaac Childress and I are Co designing return to dark tower and we have a like justin is working on and we have developed this'll like twelve people working on this project but I always want to make sure if Isaac and I are in a different place on something that we're like okay let's just try it let's let the playtesters decide what they like or well I'll say like I don't I think this might be a little too complicated or I think this isn't quite working or he might say I think this is unbalanced or something and I'll just be like yeah it might be let's just let's just go now and play it now we're not done right it's not until things get done that you have to make those final decisions like just play the game have you ever been on a project and you decided like I've taken this as far as I can and you bring in someone else you're like man I need a co designer on this originally this was a Rob Johnny and now I need to bring someone else in for a different perspective or to kind of work their magic because you realize that it's someone else's realm of expertise anything like that oftentimes it's not as a co designer I like to do those from start but it's a developer so I would either bring someone in like man and I got this game I feel a sec on the verge of being great but I can't figure it out so if it's something casual like

I might be with Eric Lang at a convention but can I just pick your brain you know was before he was exclusive to C Mon but like you know can I just pick your brain as a professional that's a like I got this it's gotta be quite the playground to pick that I can't imagine what the inside of the the inner workings of the mind of your players you're signing up to be told your ideas bad and he's not always right I mean sometimes I'll disagree with him but often like it he'll say something in a big no-no you're not seeing and I was trying to do this and then then I like two days later I beg no he had a point there right and like you know buddy and he's just not gonna mince words about it he's not gonna be delicate about it which is something I've kind of picked up from him sometimes when I have to give feedback to so I'm like look I'm gonna give you some feedback and it's gonna be unblemished and I need you to just take it as it is um sometimes I'll hire a developer look can I give you some money for you to spend a week with it play it analyze it get back to me say I like this I don't like this you know why is his system in here where's your focus or I'll just it's like a game therapist but you pay someone to just be like why are you doing this what's the real motivation here and you have to lie don't make me self-analyze but I've never gotten to a point where games almost done and say I need a co designer cuz I really think that they'll never be a co designer there'll be a developer kind of write the game by that point is baked in and they're like oh I see what you did and then I see like no you the

ends too long and I'm doing that now in a way we have a game for restoration we hired some outside designers and um and every step of the way they're like we're gonna do this we're gonna like this is great this is great and I played early versions and then I'm in the middle now I'm like I got to do a deeper development past than I expected to no fault of theirs right I just had the time to be a different perspective and go in and I've gone back to him like I'm doing a deeper dive and they're like now let's meet on it maybe we'll back up and work on it together it's just there are so many games coming out and there's so many games that like the bell curve of bad - okay - really good is the same great games I guess but there's just more of them and so if you're cotton to like this game is okay you're not one of dozens or one of hundreds you're one of thousands and so I'm very stubborn that way I'll be like okay this game is fine like no one's gonna hate it but we got to stand out and so I will be a little relentless about the whole thing that's an interesting thing about the review world that I've been thinking about lately is that reviewers often get under criticism for like I guess liking so many games or like yeah this is a good game or you know and the general audience is like no tell us a games bad how can we trust that a game is actually good if you'd save like nine out of ten games are good the truth is is I had nine out of ten games that would end up on a reviewers

radar are probably decent games I mean and so do you say a game is bad compared to excellent or do you say a game is good because it is a good game it just doesn't happen to be excellent it's a very nuanced thing and it's challenging because really bad games like a game that you would you would be comfortable just saying like you know that this is kind of trash those don't really make it onto many people's radars let alone come out by the the big major publishers it happens sometimes right yeah but there there are just so many very good games that are coming out now that it is extremely hard to stand out and be that excellent game that that kind of landscape shaking game that that a lot of people are chasing after yeah I mean I will I'll ask myself I will ask other people at restoration or partners I'd be like why do people want to the people who play this game what is another game they would play that's like this and why would they play ours what is a review we're going to say that makes our game interesting not a gimmick but why is this gonna stand out but what is the art doing is the name good enough are the pieces good enough if you're walking by a table what's gonna make you stop and pay attention this game rather than the five games on a different table at a convention if you're playing it and you're learning the rules like what what is the thing you're gonna think of where you're like oh that's what I want to try on my first

turn if you finish win or lose what makes you want to play again I mean these are the constantly the things that I'm asking for and asking about and it's um it's a little tiring sometimes but the game world and like the book world like the movie world is filled with a lot of B minuses and I've made many in some games you would say I they would aspire to be by B minuses and they're far below it but if the entire world is doing C pluses and B minuses and B's and occasionally there's like how do you stand out in this world like where you can't say anything bad about him that's good would you play it again yeah you're gonna keep it now I'll probably give it away mm-hmm but you'd play it sure if someone else asks but I'm not gonna bring it out myself right I mean that's like a tough place to be yeah it's it's a weird landscape that's all I can say like every time I hear about like board game bubbles or you know that the the hobby and the industry is growing at a rate that's unsustainable because you know people get to a critical mass of games that they're just not going to buy anymore you know like I I try to not speculate too much on that kind of stuff because that's not my realm of expertise you know like if you wanted to talk about social work and foster kids and kids getting adopted you know that's where I put a lot of my life into studying the the hard facts on but as far as games and and and growth and the the landscape all I can do as you know a talking head

who's on podcasts who does reviews that kind of stuff as I can just kind of sit on the sidelines and go like games are really weird compared to where they were ten years ago in that a game that feels like a really good game a really interesting game can go completely completely unnoticed now whereas not just because of the the progression of time but where the the industry is at um I think it would make a much bigger splash ten years ago I totally agree and that puts up me a position me in a position or people like me like okay do I do more games a pretty good quality and hope one just gets lucky and breaks out or do I do fewer games to try to do great great quality knowing none of them may make it and then I haven't spread my bets around right right if I swing for the fences every time I'm more likely to strike out if I hit a lot of singles no one cares I also like baseball baseball and food man well it's a good thing that you have a game that people are really excited about and I would be remiss if I didn't take this opportunity to ask a couple unmatched questions before I let you go because we could just talk about this like deep philosophical stuff for ever because I just feel like we could do that but instead unmatched this was a unique opportunity for you because you are restoring a game you had involvement

in you the this is a design that you worked on previously and like in in restoring the I guess game system and rebranding it and making it modern for 2019 were there things that you went back to and you're like oh these were obviously ideas that were products of the time and I I would never want to have something like this in the current market and were there any ideas that you had that maybe we're more but grudgingly changed where you were like man I really love this aspect of the system but I gotta let it go I gotta let it go if I want the this new this new system under a new name to be you know something that works in today's gaming hobby more of the former than the latter but not a lot of it so first of all because I had worked on the original with Craig Van Ness as Star Wars epic tools in 2002 i recused myself from some of the restoration work and let Justin Jacobson the president of restoration game and Jo Honeycutt the design like you guys work on this for like six months pitch stuff to me but I don't want it cuz I'll just repeat the same thing and I'll be like oh this is how we do it right like I'm not gonna think I would think of some new ideas but I wanted radical new ideas not oh let me tweak this and make a four from a three so we kind of looked at it and mapped

out the problems they found you know they're on solutions and we went back and forth on it and then later in the process I started playtesting stuff and say oh yeah this is a different game let me do development work on it right and kind of get my hands dirty on it after had taken a journey through other people's hands Star Wars epic duels was designed to be a six-week opportunistic game that came out as a tie-in to attack of the clones for eight-year-olds that sounds reductive but accurate now so the question is you get that on your desk it has run the question is do you make a piece of crap or do you try to make the best game you can because you know that those eight-year-olds may grow up to be gamers and then you know I mean someday you might meet them and be like I played that with a kid as a kid with my dad and I loved it tremendously and my dad has since passed away and thank you for the memories of my childhood because I've gotten that conversation and you're like well thank goodness I did a good job right like you know like just because it's an opportunistic six-week thing for Attack of the Clones doesn't mean you go well I'm gonna give crap then right I take pride in my work so you look at some stuff there's a grid like a checkerboard grid and you're like well then that worked there because a kid would understand it in 2002 they understand but that doesn't make sense and then the one thing I think we didn't do a great job on is it's a it's a Dueling battling game and if the original one was anyone from Star Wars fights anyone else would start from Star Wars so you'd have Han and Chewie versus

Darth Vader and a bunch of stormtroopers and you can have these sidekicks like Chewie could diet and then it would just be Han and what do you do it was a deck of cards an asymmetric deck of cards like what do you do with the Chewbacca cards if he's dead and you're still in the game and I don't think we did a good job in the original I'm solving that and I remember talking to Craig how about this how about this how about this how about this really this is mine we're out of time so we did try to fix that in a couple different ways we wanted to make like ranged creatures attacked like a queen and chess because they were um it was like a checkerboard so once we changed that then how to range creatures people work I said I don't want to count I gave demands like it was time I don't want any line of sight I don't want to measure partial hex I don't want to miss your full hexes I don't want to measure like corners of walls like how do we get line of sight without having to do - cycles how is this a introductory level game where you can go how well that's cool I didn't have to wear this and that how do you play a game how do you play a skirmish game where you're you're not gonna forget any rules or if you forget when it's minor it doesn't stop the game at the end of game ago we were forgetting this rule but the game played fine how does it play fine without a couple of the little things that make it play great so with that in mind then we sat down and started looking at at the game itself and unn matches in a Star Wars license but it's still sort of anyone fights anyone and it's a partnership with mondo and they're

bringing not the general rule of thumbs but as we do unlicensed versions packs and they do license versions so they have Jurassic Park and Buffy and Bruce Lee all within the system and we have two sets that are coming out of Gen Con and one more that's been announced and so between all of these you have quite a robust little world all sharing the same rule system is there a IP a license that if you could get any to work within unmatched the the dream for you personally the selfish thing that you would pursue even if no one else in the world would appreciate it what is it well well yes and no like I was a big fan of like like I watched the TV show battle of the planets in the 1970s and I have a soft spot for it it doesn't mean it would make a good match for this like they were kind of non-combatants and no one under the age of 50 is gonna know what's talking about like and so like I'm when I say like oh if I could have a dream license like well that's not a dream license that's just me saying here's a TV show I liked as a kid right and then I put on the I put on the businessman hat I said well what's a good thing that kind of matches here that has combatants it has the like the widest marketing audience that fits and has a different fighter style for what we've done and the sculpts are good and right like if I put it through a different filter I come up with a different answer you know like there's a lot of things that I like that I go yeah but that wouldn't make a good set but we talk between the two companies we talk

about a bunch of outrageous licensing stuff to the point where the Monda license people like that's not how licensing works like you can't just save this thing and they're like have it work like I know we're just having fun the other thing that's interesting about licensing and you is restoration games and you you have to seek out these licenses so because I I want to have one last selfish question about restoration games is house Hero Quest coming along we get in that that's like a that's like in our top three most requested and I was up there and there's a couple others that are still on the on the wish list and Hero Quest and we're aware of it that was a game that was done by Milton Bradley and actually the guy who designed it I actually worked for him for like 10 years and has for like in the last decade but advanced your requests in particular used a lot I pee from Games Workshop so the long answer short is there's international companies co-owning pieces of exactly and then I think but I'm not even sure I think the name itself lapsed and that was owned by a French company doing an app or something so that's like another piece and also what even is that game if it were to come out today like how do you satisfy something that that works for modern audiences that that is in this same space that gloom Haven and Medora

and Star Wars Imperial assault and all these other games are playing in but also it satisfies the kid that's me that loved Hero Quest when I was playing with my older brother waiting for my dad to get home from work every day you know like that is got to be a challenging thing because dungeon crawlers have come a long way I would do my homework planner request figure out what it was play the other games you've mentioned see where they've come and say why did people like this did this lead to these in which point if we just aged it up like these we're just duplicating what makes this feel different from those but at the same time it's probably out of date so how do we make how do we keep the feel of this but modernize the stuff underneath and that's a lot of what I do is some very squishy stuff where I say how does this feel like fireball how does this feel like Dark Tower what are the moments that are gonna tickle that part of your brain where Yoho this is like I'm 10 again and even if you're like I don't know why I don't know why this just felt like I was a little kid again like that's what I'm trying to coax out and that's just that's a whole other podcast all right all right all right well as I said I could talk about a bajillion things but we're going on to save that for episode 3 of having you on the podcast so is there anything that you have right on the horizon that we haven't touched on that you feel super

excited about that you want people to know the only one I haven't really sort of we haven't talked about is there's a fireball at island expansion coming out at Gen Con or and then a little bit after called Spider Springs which is great because it's got spiders that leap up and it it's actually got a spring and a launcher and spiders and ball car vomit spiders out his mouth because there's a card called a rack nickel ism it's great you know I do not have the nostalgia for fireball Island I didn't even know about it until restoration games had it coming out which is interesting almost the same exact time as your request exactly exactly I had a weird childhood I was born in Manila Philippines I lived in New Delhi India for a while it was it was a different childhood I'm gonna interview you sometime about this yeah but I played fireball island with my son and I had zero nostalgia about it and he's he's young and it was a blast and it was one of the best parenting gaming experiences that I ever had so that alone thank you for not capturing my childhood but defining my parenthood as a gamer get me choked out this is this is why I do my job right I would give a speech to interns when they are there at Hasbro like oh we do this we this I put my hand on the shoulder I would sort of say a tongue-in-cheek but I'm like hey you are now the owner of Christmas mornings Christmas afternoons and birthday parties do you want to mess

that up it's true it means a lot it means a lot when I reflect on the moments of my life when you reflect on the moments of your life I mean there's profound experiences built around these things we play with seems like a good place to stop all right Rob well thank you so much for coming back onto the show and for everybody who is listening if you want to check out this as a video itself on the video channel thanks again for coming on to the show thank you if you enjoyed this video we have all kinds of other reviews interviews and recommendations via fighting podcasts and video here on our Channel and website cardboard Ericom our content is the audience supported so if you want to show your support please visit our patreon thank you so much for watching this has been the cardboard Harold

Progress saved