Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 15:30

Miniature Market has thousands of board games at discounted prices. Click the direct link below to see all those discounted games. Hello my friends, it's the Game Boy Geek here. Recently, I've been doing a series called re-imagined retro board game classics where we look at classic games like Monopoly and even Bingo and Connect 4 and things and we talk about more modern games that were inspired by that, use mechanisms of those games to now make bigger, more grandiose and more modern games. Today, we're looking at Clue, which is near and dear to my heart because it was my favorite game growing up as a kid. Uh, I was a science and math person. and I'm a I'm a degreed logical engineer and I just love logic and deduction. So, Clue was my favorite growing up. So, I have a soft spot for this. I'm going to give you a quick history of Clue and then talk about a lot of modern games that were inspired by it.

Now, the history of Clue goes back to like World War II where hold up in his home in Birmingham, England during air raids on the city during World War II, Anthony Pratt, an English musician and factory worker, recalled the murder mystery games played of some of his clients at pro private music gigs as well as detective fiction uh that was made popular at the time, mostly notable, you know, Agatha Christie. Now, in 1944, Pratt applied for a patent for his invention of a murder mystery themed game originally named Murder. Now, shortly thereafter, Pratt and his wife, who had helped the design, you know, part of it of the game, presented it to Wington's executive, Norman Watson, who immediately purchased it and provided its trademark. And then they named it Cludo, which was a play on Clue and Ludo, which is a Latin word for I play.

And it was the name for a popular board game based on uh Paciy which in the western world was later called Parchy. Uh and you know the the design house in the game based it on what was at the time the tutor Close Hotel. Now with early editions of the game being titled Murder at Tutor Close was the name of it because that's what it was after. Now, although the patent was granted in 1947, post uh post-war shortages postponed the game's official United Kingdom launch until 1949. Now, it was simultaneously licensed to Parker Brothers in the United States for publication where it was renamed Clue as the name Ludo that we just talked about was not widely known in the US and the Paci style games wasn't really known that well then and so they wanted other names to, you know, do well in that market. So that play on words wouldn't have really been generally understood. So there's a brief history of Clue. Uh let's talk about some of the more modern games. We're going to start with some older ones and work our way through history lane. Now in 1971, designed by the late great Sid Saxon, the grandfather of game design, came out with a game called Sleuth, which is a pretty good descendant of of Clue. I mean, essentially, you've got this logic puzzle. You're trying to find the the hidden which gem was stolen.

Very much cluesque. But what they did, what he did to this was took out the rolling and moving which which was not great. It's one of the parts of Clue I do not like and they sit section took that out and there was some randomness though because you have these cards and on those cards allow you to ask certain questions to people like how many double opals do you have and this and that. So you were randomly assigned four cards and you were limited to the questions that you could ask based upon that. But even still to this day, Sleuth, which came out again before I was born, is still one of the best straight logic pure deduction games out there. If you have not played Sleuth, you have to do this cuz essentially they took the best parts of Clue and streamlined out the rest. There is still a little bit of randomness in there, but it is a brain burner and it's fantastic. Much more streamlined than Clue. That's Sleuth. Now, speaking of those questions, those randomized questions in Sleuth, in 1995, Mr. the Abbey came out. I re they just recently reprinted this. Mojito Studios did uh and I just did a review of this like a week or two ago. And Mystery Abbey very clueike. You're moving around the abbey.

You're trying to figure out which monk killed, you know, which was the suspect that killed. But this unlike having a random set of questions, this went in the other direction and gave you complete open questioning. You could ask any question as long as the name wasn't one of the suspects. So, you could say, "Hey, the card I just passed you, um, look at the farther to the right of them on your sheet. Have you seen that one?" And it's interesting because everyone else has to be able to hear your question and the answer. And so, you're trying to come up with clever questions that give you information, but don't give other people information. And that was like mindboggling back in 1995. That game still holds up. parts of that game feel dated where you know there's some stealing lots of cards. There's some losser turns and stuff like that. But the open-ended question really took the aspect of clue which before you you know clue you ask the player to your left. If they show you something you turns over.

If they don't have something it goes to the next player and so on and so forth. Where here you could ask anyone. Kind of like in Sleuth you have the freedom of asking anyone but in Mystery the Abby you're asking them pretty much almost anything you want. Uh, in the 2000s, Mystery Express came out. And I always called this clue on steroids because in this game, you're you're you're using action selection to do different things to pass cards around to see cards. But the twist here, the reason why I called it clue on steroids because it's essentially kind of it's very clueish, but there's two of every card. And the cards get passed around and such a lot of times in between rounds. So, if you don't see the same suspect twice in the same round, when you see it later, you might not you probably won't be sure. Is this the one I saw before or is this a different one? You're trying to see two of the same suspects in the same round.

And it's really hard because then cards get passed, some cards are known that are passed, some cards are shown between rounds, and you're trying to like use all that to deduce, did I see both of them or not? And it really made it I love Mystery Express, but it made that really sort of like clue on steroids. And staying with sort of like pretty clueish games, you know, in 2020, one of my favorite uh clue- like games came out, Deduction Games, Search for Planet X. Now, this is a game that again is very clue- like, but did some a lot of really different things. For one, there was an app being used, and what that allowed you to do to play a two-player game of deduction and uh have it work really well and feel like you're playing with more players, but you could also play a solo game that made it feel like you were playing with a second player. So, it plays great with two, which a lot of deduction games don't do. And you can play a solo game that makes it feel, it really does feel like you're playing with two players. But in this game, you and here's another big thing this one did, and why it's one of the best of all time, uh, is when you ask a question, you ask the app. Everyone gets to know what you're asking, but you don't tell them the answer, and you're getting the correct answer. Because one of the biggest downfalls in any clue type game or deduction game, someone gives you a wrong answer by accident, it the game is broken. And that happens in a lot of deduction games. In this game, you cannot be broken. The game can't be broken unless you wrote it down wrong from the app. They give you the correct answer every time. And that was a huge step forward in deduction games. Sher Planet X also at certain times in the game, you're kind of saying you're giving sort of revelations or or theories of where you think something is or what is and like three rounds later,

you're finding out if you're right, and everyone's learning information, but you're getting points for doing so. This is an absolute masterpiece. Search for Planet X. Now, up until now, we're talking about very clue-based games that you're taking notes on notepads and this and that, looking at logic deduction. Now, I'm going to start talking about games that use deduction in different ways where like you don't take notes. Museum Suspects is an interesting one. It's more of a kids game, but adults like it too, where uh it's kind of like Guess Who a little bit, which also was, I'm sure, inspired by Clue. Uh but in this one you're the the twist here is someone stole something from the museum. But the bigger twist is it could be one suspect like normal and it likely is one suspect but it could be zero suspects. None of them could have done it or it could be up to three suspects have done it just depending on the randomization of which cards are in the game, which things are there, what happened. And that's amazing that every game you're not quite sure is there zero, one, two, or three suspects. Uh, another little twist here is there's like these numbered tokens that you're using to sort of bid or bet like to look at some clues and other people have to sort of outbid you to see that clue. So, there's some bluffing involved. You can like, "Oo, that clue was great." And other people going like, "Haha, I was just messing around." But those those tokens are actually also how you bid for who you think is the the person because at the end you flip over everyone's tokens on the suspects and they get that many points. So, a lot of different things here, but you don't have to take any notes in this game. Everything's just on the table. Another known note-taking game is a recent one called Deductto.

And in this game, you're putting a card and you can you can't see your suspect. Everyone has their own suspect they're trying to figure out. It's kind of like uh with headbands where like everyone else can see your your suspect except you. And you're basically playing a card and that card has an animal and a background on it and everyone else is just kind of telling you yes, either that thing has something similar to what you have. either it's the same background or the same character or the the you know the hat or the glasses or this or that uh or no and you're just putting it on one side of your board enough if it's a yes or no. So there's no note-taking. You're just saying, "Okay, all these things, at least one things are true. All of these cards, nothing's true." And it's really interesting. They take that clue astream it. No rolling and moving. No this. No turns. No, I mean, no like moving around. It's just like I'm going to play a card, you tell me yes or no. That's it. Super streamlined. No note-taking.

Deductive. Great version. Another no note-taking and uh caveat on this. There's no note-taking from the rules. It does say you can take notes, but they don't supply you with anything. And a lot of people play this without taking notes. Crypted. In this case, every person has a piece of information of where this crypted is you're trying to find out in the ocean somewhere or in the plains or in the desert. And you're basically trying to deduce based upon questioning. Again, you get to question anyone and you get to question any terrain and you're asking them, is their clue part of this? And they tell you yes or no. But everything is just tracked on the board. You just put a cube there. If it the answer is no. Uh you put something else, the answer is yes. And you don't have to use a deduction sheet. You can kind of look at the board, look at the clues, look at the terrains and say, "Oh, they couldn't have been in the desert. They couldn't have been three away from this structure. Personally, I still play this game with a notepad and because I just love the logic and deduction aspect of it, but you don't have to." And the rules say by default, you don't do it, but you can. So, this is one that many people play without rules, but it's fantastic. Crypted. Now, I'm going to start getting away from very Clue like games, but ones that were definitely inspired by Clue. One of them is a cooperative game called Decorum.

And in this game, you are roommates and you're trying to decorate the house and you might put a green painting in the upstairs green room and someone might say, "I hate that." And they swap it out for a different painting or they swap the sculpture out or they move it down to the bottom. Everyone has very specific rules of how they want the house to look. And so someone just will add something or swap something and the next player is going to go, "I like that." And they'll do something else. Or they'll go, "Oh, I hate that." And they'll swap it. And it's almost like a game like Mastermind, which also is probably inspired by Clue from like 1949 or 71, I think, actually. So, yeah, 71, I think it came out uh in Decor. So, in this game, you're you're you're making a change and you're waiting to see how people react and then you're like thinking there's no notes. You can't take notes. Actually, it says you can't take notes. And you're like, "Huh, okay, they moved that. Did they move it because it was they didn't want that in that room? Did they move it because they didn't want that thing or they didn't they not like that color?" Uh, but everything is just open. No note-taking.

You're just kind of going off what other people said. And another good sort of twist on the clue-l like deduction mechanism. Now the last couple are going to be very different from clue but similar in certain ways. You could say an entire genre of games social deduction games were inspired by clue because it's half of its deduction. The other half of it is social trying to figure out who's who. Deception murder in Hong Kong is one of my favorite uh deduction games. It is fantastic where you are trying to figure out who's the murderer. And in this case it's not Mr. Green or or you know Colonel Mustard. It's one of you at the table and one of you is picking a weapon and some evidence that you use that you left at the scene for it. One player gets to see who the murderer is. And if there's enough player, there's an accomplice as well that also gets to see the murder. And one player, the forensic scientist, gets to see who the murderer is and what was used to do it. And then they're giving silent clues as sort of a witness, a forensic scientist to the other player, to all players. And people are trying to pick out, huh, what cards in front of which people seem like it could have been the murder based upon the the clues the forensic scientist is giving us. But a lot of it's about sort of deceiving others and going, "No, no, it wasn't this. It could have been this.

Oh, sure. It could have been the the explosive thing you saw, but it could have been a fire over here as well." And this game is like, it's interesting because there's a murderer, but now it's one of you. and there's a weapon and there's some evidence left and you're trying to figure it out, but it's a lot of all of it's done above the table in the social setting. So, Clue even inspired an entire genre of games called social deduction. And this is one of my favorite ones and it's very clue- like in the way that you're trying to solve the murder. And the last one is probably the furthest from Clue, but it's also a cooperative game. It's also clue s because you're trying to cooperately find the suspect, the weapon, and the location. Sound like clue? Sure does to me. Uh, but in this game, one player is sort of like a ghost, and they're trying to give these beautiful cards. This is a an art interpretation game, similar to say Dixit, and there's a million other games out there have done this now, but one player knows the the crime. They can't talk, but they're handing players these interesting cards, and they're looking at the possible suspects or the possible locations or the possible weapons, and based upon the artwork in the card, they're trying to say which one they think it is. And you're trying to get everyone to get theirs right.

You're trying to get everyone to get their person, place, and and weapon right. And then you go to the if you get that far, you go to the end where you actually find you give clues for who is the real suspect, who is the real loca, uh real the location, what was the real real weapon based upon the ones that people had been given because only one of the the people actually had the right thing and only one player knows that. So there's some deduce there's some deductive aspects here. Um, but it's more about cards and colors and thinking outside the box in a weird abstract way, but in the end, it's a cooperative clue. Very interesting how many different types of games have been inspired by my favorite game clue. Well, I hope this has helped you uh find games that are similar to my favorite game as a childhood. Uh, you know, during my childhood, Clue or Cludo as some call it. And I hope this helped you maybe go off and find and play some of these different games. If you like logic and deduction, but you want to see things that are inspired by clue, it's still also very different in many ways.

I hope this has helped you. This is Game Boy Geek Geek. This has been a Game Boy Geek breaking down barriers growing relationship with board games by helping you find one you love. Game Toppers upgrades every game you play. and they just launched their 4.5 Kickstarter, which will introduce the new Galactic Microoft and Watson game toppers with interchangeable rail inlays, as well as new game mats, miniature gaming terrain packs, leg kit options, dining covers, accessories, and amazing package deals. Search for Game Toppers on Kickstarter or go to gameterslelc.com.

Progress saved