Skip to main content
Loading video...

Jack's top 10 Games of the year - TCbH GOTY 2025 (And bonus giveaway)

Transcript 29:39

Ladies and gentlemen, 2025 was a banner year for gaming. There were so many bangers, like so many legit awesome releases in a time in which I was kind of feeling a little bit overwhelmed. Maybe not burnt out, but getting a little bit on the crispy side, a little bit jaded, and 2025 really revitalized a lot of my love for games. Now, here at the Cardboard Herald, if you've been following the channel for a while, you know that we have a few people who are contributing. And even though last year we were still on opposite ends of the continent, it was during a transitionary year. And we are now starting to figure out how best to approach some of our lists, some of our games. And given that Eric and I as the primary people bringing you content on Cardboard Herald don't get to play games that often together, it felt like this year the best thing to do would be to have separate lists. So, as such, right here, right now, this list is going to be my pure uncut, unadulterated top 10 games of 2025.

Not your top 10. Bear in mind, these are my personal top 10 of the games that I have played, which is a very important distinction because my god, so many games. I didn't get a chance to play or replay all of them to really cement their position and everything. And you'll see other videos of this ilk crop up on the channel in the days and weeks to come. So, with that said, let's go ahead and get started. All right, I got three honorable mentions upfront. Yeah, I know I said we're going to get started, but I didn't get started. I got started with honorable mentions, which makes sense because these are some games that I really enjoyed, but I didn't feel so good about having them in the top 10 itself because they are direct follow-ups to existing games that for the most part are just distillations of the concepts of those games. They are enough of a departure that I feel like they could [clears throat] be argued to be in this top 10, but this gives me a mechanism to talk about even more games.

So, we're reserving these three for honorable mentions. That being Park Edition, the White Castle Duel, and Flamecraft Duels, which are all fantastic games. I mean, Park Second Edition is just a better version of Parks, and I wasn't expecting to really fall in love with the aesthetic quite as much as I did at first. I had kind of some hesitation on it, but man, it really knocked it out of the parks, if you know what I mean. Uh, and then, uh, of course, The White Castle was our favorite game, not last year, but the year prior. And you know what? It's the White Castle Duel. I I don't know. I expected that The White Castle Duel would be a redundant game because you know what?

The White Castle is great on its own as a two-player game and you don't really need something else, but it takes the script, the concept, the overall best parts of the feeling of playing the White Castle and then does something completely different. And that's definitely worth checking out. And then Flamecraft DS is kind of the honorable mention of the sequel to a game that had the biggest uh hill to climb, the longest road to hoe, because Flamecraft is cute, but not a good game. And Flamecraft DS is cute and is a super good game, a game that I really enjoy. We have coverage of those games. You can check out more information. Those are the honorable mentions. Let's get to number 10.

If we had an award for the worst production of a game that I actually loved this year, it would go to El Paso, which yes, could kind of be in this zone of being a distillation of a broader game because it's based off of the core concepts of The Great Western Trail, but I feel like it's enough of a departure. It's been enough time since The Great Western Trail came out. And the Great Western Trail, while a good game, wasn't something that really stuck with me in the way that El Paso was. And this gives me the opportunity to kind of rag on the fact that it's production absolutely sucks and yet is still a really good game. You're going around the board. It's quasi worker placement, but really just action selection efficiency engine converting your deck building engine of collection of cows to go to show them at the end. cycle around again and again and again to get the cows of your dreams and the cowboys and the other workers that you want. It's a really hysterically bad production. Again, I know I've said it, but it deserves a third mention. Uh especially because there's things like the cardboard chits that are there to represent cubes. Like they couldn't even give you wooden cubes, so they shaded the cardboard chips as though they were cubes or cylinders. It's really bonkers that they went this distance. And yet, I'll still take this over Great Western Trail. And

yet, it is just a really, really great game. We've played it again and again and again. It's one that we've sought out a bunch, and it's one that we'll continue to play.

Number nine is Galactic Cruise. Maybe the exact polar opposite of uh El Paso when it comes to production because it is one of the most beautiful productions in games to come out last year. And it's just an allound great efficiency engine. you know, the the kind of things that we as board gamers love getting our hooks into, seeing how you can operate this vast network of different systems and trying to get them to wrench into exactly what you're trying to build momentum towards. I love that there's this long endeavor that you're going to launch these ships, these cruises several times throughout the game that kind of work as your benchmarks, but every sequence leading up to that feeds into that core larger loop. So, you can really break down the the overall uh objective, the the overall scheme of what you need to work towards into these small manageable parts. And it's those small manageable parts that really become the nuts and bolts of the best way of operating within the game.

There's also some really great ways in which there's some interactivity that I haven't always seen in games and the sort of investment not just in your own stuff, but the investment in the board is really satisfying, too. Number eight. Well, I am a sucker for a gimmick and my kid loves marble, so you know, like I I'm personally a little bit biased towards it, but 12 Rivers is just a really good game. Maybe a little more expensive and a little bit more lavish production than the way a game actually deserves, but I don't know, whatever. It's just a great game that has a killer table presence, a cool way of using gravity and marbles as a different currency. I mean, yes, we have games like gizmos, which is a favorite in this household, and using marbles as currency, but here, using the gravity itself as a way of feeding them into your possession and positioning yourself with a sort of speculatory nature, hoping to be able to get the best pick without having to sacrifice as many cards. And then all of that feeding into collecting villagers and successfully selling those marbles to villagers. The quasi Miyazaki artwork is also really charming if a little indistinct on its own. There's an effort for some sort of

worldb building. It feels like here like this is a license IP to a license that doesn't exist, but it doesn't really go a lot of lengths to define that. But yet, the game itself is just beautifully packaged, beautifully presented, and a novel concept. It's been fun every time that I've played it. And something that after playing it, when Eric got a copy, I was like, man, I got to go buy a copy myself. And that's that's what I did. It's that good. Number seven, I'm happy to put on this list because it's kind of a a hidden gem, a diamond in the rough as I put in the review coverage of it, and that's Aether Spire. A fully cooperative tower building, tower defending game. It's not quite tower defense if you were thinking about tower defense in the traditional uh description of that as a genre video or board game, but you are trying to build these pillars to conquer the elements and using some triedand-true cooperative gaming mechanics that may feel a little bit familiar, but in some interesting spatial arrangement ways.

It's a little bit deceptive. It makes you think that it might be a dexterity game or that balance comes into play because you're building these large towers that get a little bit more precarious as you go. But nonetheless, it is a cold hard strategy game with a lot of great table presence, a lot of pizzazz. And uh Phase Shift Games is uh one of these companies that is out there doing it, making great games, but they're a very small company. And I have a feeling that a lot of people are going to pass on this because of the box art, because of the aesthetic. There are some criticisms that I put towards the game itself in the review video, which again I recommend that you check out, but it's a game that I played and then immediately wanted to play again and immediately wanted to play again and have done so again and again telling my friends like, "Yo, you like Quadre games, you got to check this out."

There's a lot of really cool stuff that you could do, especially with that magic system that I would love to see replicated in other games, you know, combining the different magic as a resource and converting the enemies into the magic that becomes a resource. It's just it's really cool. Comes together great. Huge fan. Hey, there Spy. All right, number six is kind of a weird blending of years because The Lord of the Rings, The Fellowship of the Ring, the Trick Taken game, came out at the tail end of 2024, but it didn't really have its full retail release until 2025. So, we didn't really put it on our list last year, but it really was a 2024 game. And then they repeated the same thing with the two towers tricktaken game which was available at packs unplugged this year at 2025 but wasn't really widely available till 2026. So this is a spot that is going to account for the Lord of the Rings the fellowship of the ring slash the two towers the tricktaken game whichever one that we really want to call coming out in 2025 because they are damn good cooperative trickt taking games. There's a lot of thematic potency that Brian Bormuer has imbued in these games, capturing some of the best parts of the Lord of the Rings material, bringing a lot of that to life in

interesting ways with a simple trick-taking engine. It's something that's indelibly interesting, something that's easy to teach and pick up and is very attractive. I've had lots of people who aren't normally trick-taking players get deep into this game and I've also had a lot of friends who are really tricktaking masterminds who want to play and just see the escalation of the difficulty which goes on and on and on up and up and especially Two Towers starts out assuming you got your Olivant together like it is yo we're not going to put you on the training wheels. Number five, did I say trick-Taken game?

Because Origin Story is my number five game of the year, which [snorts] is in my opinion probably the best, most cohesive package that Stonem Games has put out since Wingspan, which is one of my favorite Stonem games or just games of all time. origin story is a great riff on tricktaking and tableau building uh with just a couple really interesting decisions. Now I I think we might be in one of those trick taking bubbles right now like everyone is doing trick taking and is starting to see adaptation into other genres of games in the way that deck building was in the past. There are fewer and fewer just straight up tricktakers and more. This is tableau building with trick taking or this is arcs a game that's uh tricktaking action selection mechanism within a kind of dudes on the map uh conquest game. Well, the origin story is a trick taking game through and through, but you're doing it with the acquisition of these developing superpowers.

The artwork is fantastic. This kind of drippy watercolor art style that isn't something that I typically associate with comic book superhero stuff, which has really been done to death. And it's another game that I didn't really expect to take to as much as I did. I also find the sort of agency that you have in flipping yourself to hero versus villain on any given round is not only thematically potent, but it also gives you a hand in reacting to what you're planning on doing with your hand. That's not the first trick taking game to give you a way of kind of anticipating how many tricks that you're going to win, but it is a good way of just kind of combining that into a thematic resonance that isn't something that you normally uh associate with tricktaking games.

Number four is Tend the enormous gargantuan IV Studios monstrosity of xeno fararmming with an interesting interstellar theme that is really riffing on some of the things that I love most about Stardew Valley. Far more successful of a Stardew Valley type game than the Stardew Valley board game. And I don't mean that in the cozy [clears throat] nice just kind of hang out and do a couple things type of association some people may have to Stardew Valley. No, I'm talking about cold hard economic engines. This game gives you so many tools to explore the world around you and harness that into farming, into mining, into wood cutting and construction of new equipment in a insane layered system that I just love coming back to again and again. There is a part of this I find is difficult to market to people because of the and right nature.

You're working with disposable sheets here as opposed to permanent sheets. But having those damn stamp markers, everyone just wants to play with those and are interested in what you're doing with them. And there are so many levers to play that you could dive into this solo exclusively and still just be reaping the benefits, the challenge, the exploration of those systems again and again and again. It is by far my favorite IV Studios game. Is one of my favorite and right games to date and it is just one of my favorite solo games to have come out all year, but I also really like playing it multiplayer. Now, the top three, starting with number three. There's commonality among all of them that isn't initially there, but you'll have to pick up on it as we go.

So, number three is Reicside Legacy. And oh man, yes, this is another one of those sequels in that Reicide is a pre-existing game, but it's a game that you can play with a 52 deck of cards, you know, like the standard deck of cards. Reocside Legacy takes that amazing game that Badgers from Mars developed and then instead says, "What if we make a full-on campaign cooperative legacy game with an evolving deck and systems and that kind of stuff?" And it is one of the most fun, challenging experiences of gaming that I've ever had. It doesn't have all the baggage of uh massive branching uh openw world sort of campaign games. It does lead you on an overall pretty linear uh campaign where you're doing each mission in sequence. But the sort of choices that you do get to make in the inter room feel potent. They feel powerful.

You start looking at the consequences not only of your decisions but also the mishaps that happen along the way and it is ultimately so freaking challenging. Like my family has been playing through this together and we have gotten to be so good at Reicside as a whole and Regside Legacy with our evolving deck. But there are missions where everything has to be handled critically perfectly to be able to thread the needle. And that can often lead into not very fun situations, right, in other games where you feel like everything is riding on the line. But the way that this is packaged, the way that it's presented, the sort of uh uh quick fast-paced nature of this makes it so if you lose because of a crucial decision that wasn't followed at a given point, it just makes you want to play it again.

It's easy to set up, easy to play. Uh, I get it that it is a very expensive game for something that people associate Reicside with being free or the cost of a deck of cards, but Reicside Legacy to me is an achievement and is one of the best campaign cooperative games that I've played in ages. Number two is Fate of the Fellowship, which is another surprise to me because there was a little bit of a hesitation going into this thinking, well, is it just going to be pandemic except Lord of the Rings? And that it is not. It is more akin to a clockwork war game that is happening that you get to influence as you go and then use your heroic characters after positioning and delaying the armies of the free peoples of the west against the invading forces of the shadow of Mordor. You then use your heroes to complete these events, these missions, and then ultimately fulfill the the requirements of the Lord of the Rings, which is casting the ring into Mount Doom. in having this all done in a single session that has so many variables, the different characters, the different quests that you could be playing with, the the different parameters, how the forces move about

the board. It's really an achievement that it all comes together so fluidly. It's not without its faults. like especially some of the component choices, particularly in my mind, having the map be something that is hard to read, especially if you're trying to flow all of the forces of evil as a march at the end of a turn. Uh it seems like it could have been done as a sepia toned map to really highlight the colored paths going about, but you know, whatever. Um, it is a beautiful production. It has incredible systems that do hint at that echo the amazing work that Matt Leok did with Pandemic so many years ago, but bringing it to Matt Leok as a much more experienced designer now. taking one of the most beloved properties and creating essentially a dudes on a map type game like War of the Ring type of game except saying what if we automate a lot of the systems that are here and then make it fully cooperative. It's so smart. It's surprising. It is climactic. It has a lot of edgier seat moments. And the more that I played it over the course of the year, which now I've played it, I think 11 or 12 times, uh, I've realized that there are so many smart things that you can be doing early on in the game,

investing in yourself to be able to handle some of the more difficult things or the lols that may come up later on in the game if you haven't appropriately prepared. It's awesome. I love it. it it's so much more than Lord of the Rings Pandemic. Uh, and that makes sense that it's my second favorite game of the year. Now, number one veering towards originality in that uh any of the games really on this list, but especially the top three could have taken the number one slot. But Kinfire Council is not a just adaptation of a pre-existing system in the way that you could argue that Fate of the Fellowship is. It's not just a sequel, an expansion of concepts in the way that you could argue that Reicside Legacy is. No, Kinfire Council takes the original setting that uh has been developed by Incredible Dream with their Kinfire series and then puts it into what to me is an amazing logistics, political worker placement game that stretches kind of the bounds of what I would normally expect of a worker placement game in a fantasy setting.

That gives me a little bit of a touch of what I love about something like Lords of Water Deep in the past, but oh so modern. I also love that this game has a lot of pressures that are put upon the players that create this sort of semi-ooperative nature. something that I often find is fumbled in games, but here relies on cold, hard mechanical levers to make it so players are imposed, compelled to work collaboratively, if not fully cooperatively, and then leaving room for the sort of deception or heel turn to join the cult, which could be an adversarial relationship in the game. And all of this is true of the game as sold in the base game before I even knew that there was a simultaneously released expansion that had the solo mode and the fully cooperative mode. Now, I'm talking about this in our review of the expansion, the cooperative mode that I'm kind of fawning about, but the scoop is that I normally do not think that games that have a competitive and a cooperative and a solo and maybe some other variants typically are very good because they have a hard time accounting for all of those different feelings in one core system. you either end up leaving so much material in the box and

it becomes a desperate experience with all these modules or it just becomes kind of like a a wet fart of an experience that doesn't really hit on the reason you come to cooperative games or competitive games. I usually find that when something is the designer's intent as presented, it is the best. I love Kimfire Council before I ever played the cooperative game. Playing the cooperative mode makes me think I might like it even more as a cooperative game. And it's uniquely situated to do this because the nature of the game, where the enemies at the gates are constantly putting pressures on you, where the political upheaval in the city, the needs of supplies that need to be delivered that you capitalize on, but also will influence the the turning tides of people in disarray going over to the cult if you do not fulfill those needs. the tower that's being created, the cult mechanisms that exist there. It feels like you are constantly bombarded with these different pressures, these different needs, these crises, much in the way that you normally expect in a cooperative game. And I also love the sort of thematic lift that happens when you go to fully cooperative. In competitive mode, you're politicians who

are vying for the most power in this city. Sure, you might be working collaboratively, but it is ultimately about me. And it may be something about the world right now where I wish we had more politicians who truly were all about us. The cooperative mode really takes a look at the logistics of protecting a albeit fantasy city and the denisens within and saying how do we make sure that all of us as representatives of this populace are benefiting as much as we can so that way we are all still above the threshold of what this evil cult is doing. And if so, we win the game. And if any one of us fails to be above that, then all of us lose. It's kind of a beautiful picture of intersectionality and collaborative problem solving that I absolutely love.

There are a couple twists in that cooperative mode, but bottom line, I I think that the combination of my love for the competitive and the cooperative mode and the solo mode have cemented this as one of my favorite games of all time at this point and easily my favorite game of 2025. Hey everyone, editor Jack here. Just hopping in to say we got a giveaway for you. Because Kimfire Council was such a big hit for us, Incredible Dream has generously agreed to support the channel by giving away a copy of Kimfire Council to you US addresses only. But anyone who comments on this video, either being the game of the year video or our review of the Winds of Change video that is the expansion to Kfire Council, by the end of January, we'll be entered to win. I'll respond to your comment and then we'll sort out the details from there. But basically, just comment with your favorite games of 2025 and you'll be entered to win. Good luck and I'll talk to you then. And that's our list of the Cardboard Heralds Jack's favorite games of 2025. But what are yours? What do you want to see in games out of 2026? And what are some of the ones that I missed in here? Maybe [singing] I didn't play them or maybe I played them and they just didn't rate in the same way. Maybe you saw some of the games that are on this list and you think they aren't for you.

Put it in the comments. Let's have some great discussion. And as always, thanks for watching. Thanks for supporting. Thanks for being a great community and doing all the things that help us grow as a channel and continue to give you this coverage from the likes, the subscribes, the sharing everywhere, the saying nice things about us on places like Reddit and BGG. And of course going to our Patreon, signing up there. You can get some free games. You can also just really support us being able to continue doing this. So, with all that said, thank you for watching and thanks for giving a great year. I've been Jack for the cardboard Harold.

Progress saved