Skip to main content
Loading video...

Everdell Expansions - Ranked From Worst to Best

Transcript 16:09

welcome to allies or enemies I'm Jess and I am Sean and today we are talking about all of the everdel expansions and ranking them from worst to best it was a few weeks ago that we got the complete collection which I am very excited about because this is my number one favorite game and already we've dove into it and have played it a ton replayed the expansions we already knew and played with the the new expansions that are included and speaking of the other stuff as well we're just gonna rank the big expansion so the five big main expansions um all of the other things the legendary cards the extra extra cards the through the seasons Farm cards uh we figured just put them in you may as well just throw them all in but for the most part they're it's it's just kind of a few more cards in an already very large deck so they're not going to make an enormous impact with these five expansions will make a big impact so let's start with our number five

number five is Miss word and what that allows you to do is play solo with a full League solo operated character called nightweave but you can also add it to a two-player game to make it feel a little bit more like three players now just as a caveat we have this one last because I'm I'm not a big solo player so for me it's probably going to be the expansion that I play with the least yeah it really is just a matter of for for the largest number of people this is probably the one that they're going to want the least because you're specifically just gonna want this for solo there is a way to bring nightwave into two player games and add an extra player and we have tried that as well and works fine but honestly we find the two player game fine so we didn't think it was really necessary and the upkeep although not a huge amount of upkeep was enough that we just felt like we probably aren't going to do that that much but if you do play solo it does add a lot of interesting elements it is a really full solo game because there's lots of different components that you can add in and play with so sometimes you might add a plan card or a plot card and different personalities and all of those are ways to mix it up a little bit so it's not always playing against the the same type of AI yeah it uses a deck of cards and the cards use kind of a primary and then a secondary if the primer is already filled action that nightweave is going to take and it is like a head-to-head as well so this isn't a best score solo mode this is a

you're trying to beat nightwift score and you can level that up as well so there's five or six different levels I think I think five maybe yeah we've beat it on three but just um just like uh by two points I think so it's it's definitely it's definitely tough and I think at the highest level you got to play an almost perfect game to beat night wave two so there is a real Challenge and it works with all of all of the expansions yeah it is interesting because it gives you the adjustments to make and then how the nightwees behavior would change or things you have to do if you're adding in Pearl brook or Belfair so it does let you add in any of the other expansions and play against the nightweave AI but even though we do like it it is number five on our overall list at number four we have got Pearl Brook and pearl Brook I will add the caveat when we first purchased Pro Brook we bought the retail version the retail version does this thing that really annoys me where they put it into the collector's edition box they use the same box for both and so you end up with like an 80 empty box with just a few things in it if they'd put it in a smaller box I probably would like it more but what it does is it adds a little kind of pond area and you get to use frogs that you add to whoever your characters are and so you're taking those frogs you're putting them out into the Pearl Brook area and that gets you pearls is obviously it also gets you

special cards which give you special powers and it changes out the four main goals on the board to make them wonders instead that you have to pay extra resources in order to buy and one of the key resources that it adds are are the pearls and the pearls look amazing amazing they're I like everything foreverdale it looks incredible and the way the board slots in too it joins it up so nicely so the production is great and then those pearls you're trying to collect because you have to collect a lot of resources a lot of the the short supply of pearls to purchase those really high point value wonders which will make a huge difference because I think the highest one is 20 points yeah something like that yeah but it it is I guess the tricky with pearl Brook is The Game's already a fairly tight Resource Management game and it gives you another place that you have to put quite a few of your resources into to get those points and it makes that rush for like the highest two wonders really really important and it takes out the standard goals which I do kind of like because I like just being able to to get rewarded for having sets of of the different colors of the different kinds of villagers so it does replace that but it's nice for for kind of a change of pace our number three is Spire Crest and Spire Crest slots in at the bottom of the board and it adds a little Expedition rabbit and so what you're doing is you are moving along each

season this this rabbit and as you go various things get added in first of all depending on what season it is there is going to be a restriction and that's part of the element that we don't like the most because we love being able to go where we want to go and that restriction might be that you collect one less of each of the resources or you can't go to certain spots so it does just make it a bit harder and then you also get to pick a really powerful card which is sometimes going to be these giant meeples that come with saddles so you can actually like slot in your own character meeples onto these giant animal ones and those are great yeah that is really the selling point is that you can have like a turtle riding a bear around and and it is really fun and they are fairly powerful too like they give you really cool one time a season effects for whoever whatever meeple is kind of locked in there that's now kind of a super meeple that goes out on onto the board which is great but yeah the the negative side of that the the the seasons weather cards that negatively affect you are a little bit tough and feel a smidge out of place in a game that otherwise is all kind of like a positive positive positive and then it's this little bit of restriction some people might love that and you can play without it uh although you're gonna end up with Oodles of stuff without that it's kind of the push-pull of it and speaking of the push-pull there is also an

expedition trail that you've got to fill and so that again like Pearl Brook is a way that you're using extra resources or that you really want to redirect your resources to that expedition yeah each season you collect a token that denotes what you think you're going to have at the end of the game and then you've got to progress through it in order so if the first one you have you get points maybe for having three berries for example but you have to make sure you have that to be able to do the next one so it does give you this pool of resources it's a mix of the typical resources and cards depending on which token you pick to trade in for points at the end so if you've mastered base game everdel then the Spire Crest Expedition is great because if you typically have leftover stuff this is a way of being able to trade that stuff in for points yeah and I think we've definitely found that we've gotten to the point where generally by the end of fall we can only fit one or two more buildings so it is nice to have another place to go outside of just getting rid of your cards for a few points which isn't the most fun way to to spend turns so it is nice to have these other things to do as well and it can be a bit of a challenge because the ones that are the more stuff to have at the end are worth the more most so you have to decide is it worth pushing your luck a little bit and think thinking that you can do it or take one of the easier ones that gets you less points that's our number three our number two is the other new one other than Miss Wood and that is new leaf and New Leaf it's probably the best looking of the expansion boards it adds

this cool train station it also adds three more Meadow cards that you put in to the new Leaf Meadow it also adds and this is probably the coolest thing is these little past I think they're called feathers visitor cards and those give you end game goals but their end game goals that you can work towards so whereas all of the other ones that are out on the boat all of the the different award cards are always once you've completed it you can race to it these are more of a thing that you're you're striving towards the personal goal element of it really makes it great because then it might steer you both in different directions in a way that isn't quite when you seen in the other game so the visitor cards definitely add a lot yeah and there's also because of the the train station element of it as well there's three different train cards and those give you bonus resource is when you take the cards on that board or when you take the visitors and then it adds even more things and one of the things that adds is a reservation token and so what that allows you to do is to take a card from from the meadow and to put it under your reservation token and that lets you build it for one less resource but you have to build it by the end of the season or you lose the card but having it be one resource cheaper is amazing it makes some of the other cards a little bit more doable and then the other aspect are the tickets and so the tickets is something that you can use twice in a game to move an already

placed worker so again it's just getting more stuff and being able to do more things and and it's got more regular deck cards than any of the other I think than all of the other expansions combined has got a ton of regular debt cards that it adds to the deck and a lot of those buildings give you a way to put any of the villagers or sometimes it'll be like any like Leaf villager or any book villager or whatever it might be into those different locations but you can only do it three times in a game you get three because special doors or they're like gold leaf doors that you can put out throughout the game and those let you just steal anybody which is really cool if you actually get the any one of the any flower one and then you can just like snatch up a queen or a king um which it's it's an interesting little wrinkle into it as well and if you're finding the cards don't turn over that much so it's hard to get the exact Critter that's needed very for a very particular building these cards help fix that by giving you those those three options to kind of broaden out about who can live there which is wonderful yeah it's a great way to be able to because that would really be the complaint of adding a ton of cards as this does to the deck is well now I'm never going to get a combination so it does make kind of an alternate way to make those combinations it does make it harder to make the combinations but if you've played everdale a ton and we've played it a ton you're a little tired of always matching those same cards to the same things over and over and over of putting the rabbit into the shop and putting the the what is it a hedgehog doctor into

the hospital all of those things you've gotten tired of it by now so it is nice to have that mix and that brings us to number one and number one is Belfair and what this adds to the game is more just kind of tightening and and improving the base game rather than a big giant thing so it's not adding the wonders of pearl brook or the Expedition of spire Crest but instead it it fixes a few little things that from the base game could use a little bit of improvement yeah it adds so it adds a board that goes onto the top and one of the cool things with the expansion is each one of them slots in to the main board and if you've got it all far out it does look really cool because they all lock in and just make this enormous part that you're gonna need a big big table for but Belfair what it adds is first of all it adds that board on the top and it changes the goals which I think was super important because those End Game Awards or end game goals in the original were all like getting Undertaker in like a barge Toad and you probably don't want both of those things they don't even lock together and it's so specific that it's really hard to get this makes it they just make a lot more sense where it's like have three greens and two purples or have six of whatever this thing is it also adds this large Market spot that gives you another way to get all of the different resources and more cards and part of the market action as well is it's a really kind of clever once you

take that action it moves to the bottom and then that lets you take it in an opposite way where you can spend those so near the end of the game if you have a lot of leftover cards a lot of leftover resources you can spend those for for points because it gives you coins to move it back up to the top which is which is great and it adds a 9 nice what is it called the garden award Garland Garland award so it's a random award that comes out in terms of who has the most of this particular type of building slash Critters and another of the the base game uh ones as well because it's like having each of the different types is one of the awards that you can you can go for the basic events and it's nice to have that option if you have a really Diversified Town yeah right the the harvest Ward and most importantly and we should have started with this it adds asymmetric Critter powers and so each of the critters has a little mini card and that card gives you some different thing they're all kind of very specific but they do change things up quite a bit and we just we love using all the different Critters that's one of the main reasons that we got the big box was because we hated that we didn't have the platypuses and the axolotls especially I think that's the tricky thing if you were to get Belfair on its own without the collector's edition and without having the rest of the Collector's Editions as well is seeing the cards from everybody that you don't have because before we had everybody we were using like the Axolotl card with like the squirrels I mean like we're

pretending but it's so much better just to have the meatballs yeah yeah it is actually I wouldn't do that though only just did that I refused I will only use the correct ones with the correct ones but Belfair the reason that it's number one even though it's actually it's the smallest box it's the least stuff in the Box we use it every single game it's the only one that I would say is just it's just an every time you just want to throw that in there right from the start it's like Carcassonne with the uh in the cathedrals where it's just you just think of that as part of the base game and that's totally how we think of Belfair any of the problems you had with the base game Belfair tweaks them just that little bit without it being too much without it feeling like an alternate version it just feels like a just a little bit of a cleaner version and that is it that is our ranking of all of the everdel expansions from five to one well the big box ones at least and we do like all of them but honestly number one is Belfair with a bullet although New Leaf is pretty close I was really impressed and we played it a few times already and really looking forward to playing it more that's a lot of great stuff but let us know what your favorite expansion is in the comments and please like subscribe and hopefully we'll see you for the next one

Progress saved