Skip to main content
Loading video...

6 Small Box Game Reviews - Catan: On the Road, Quagmire, All-In & More!!!

Transcript 14:30

when you don't have 20 minutes to watch a full review when you're not looking for a how to play or an hourong play through. And let's be honest, when the interest is a little lower, too. That's why we have six small box games for you. Hey, I'm Alex from Board Gameco and this is my six small box game review series where I take a look at six smallbox games, give you my thoughts on them. Do I like them? Do I not? How do they fair? Honestly, this batch is not great. The highest rated one we have today is going to be a three. Most of them are 2.5s and then our lowest is going to be a 1.5 out of five. Some of these games really let me down unfortunately. Before we dive into this review, this channel is sponsored by Allplay. If you go to allplay.com, you can find a variety of games from AllPlay that are small boxes that are not quite the disappointments that most of these are. I'm sorry, most of these games I just didn't I didn't love most of these. This is not one of the um better roundups that I've done over here. But if you go to allplay.com, you can find games from themselves as well as their partner publishers and you can get them all for one low shipping price. But with that, let's go ahead and dive into these. Let's do this in um I guess I guess let's start with Katan.

Katan over here. Katan on the road. Is Katan on the road? It's basically katan where you draw from a deck of cards and build cities to draw more cards and then trade cards with other players. But if you have roads, you can like get better trades. Like it's basically katan distilled into less decision-making choices. is now if you've played katan you already know that katan can be a little light on the actual decisions you make or the feeling of decisions you make once you build up your initial network a lot of it is kind of the obvious thing to do all the time katan is like you know if you like the feeling of katan but you want it in a smaller package at a lower price point and theoretically you can play it on a plane theoretically I think plane is probably pushing it but on the road you can take it with you travel with it and play it but if you want even less decision space this one is for you I do not recommend it I think that if you are looking for travel games. There is a great smores board of travel games out there already.

Uh, and save Katan when you want to play it at home. I am a fan of Katan despite the lower amount decision space in base katan. I still think it is a surprisingly fun time. I think this gives you some of that feeling, but then it compromises on a lot of the elements. I think the hard the main audience for this is hardcore katan fans who don't really want to play other games. Like you can't even play this at two players. Like it's not even they said at least you can play this at two. It's still a three to four player game that's just a worse version of katan. There are a ton of excellent travel games if that's why you're getting this. And if you're getting it because you like katan, just play katan. A 2.5 out of five. Then from there, let's go ahead and dive into uh Kyoto no kako. This is based on Kyoto no. This is a Kyoto no Kako the kittens over here. It's got adorable little artwork. And if you look at the cards over here, you'll see that there's two sides to the cards. There's the eyes you can't see and then the cats you can see.

The reason that's relevant is because if you have this card over here, you might think there's only one cat. But in reality, there's two because some of their eyes are closed. Or you could have fully closed cats. Look at this. A whole bunch over here. You're basically playing a memory game over here where you're trying to get to a target number, but you're going to be looking at a grid of faceown cards and trying to choose which cards you want to flip. If you flip this card, there's at least three cats. But are there more than three cats? In this case, there's four cats. There's a variable number of cats. And the only piece of information you really have is A, whatever has been flipped already that you remember, and then B knowing that at least the number of eyes is the minimum pair of cats you can find. I guess that and a little card counting, you might be able to get a little bit ahead of the game. It's basically a memory game. Try to find a target number. That's really it. All you have like these over here, these little things over here that are going to be giving you the target numbers to go for as far as how many cats you're trying to flip to on your turn. Is there any real decision space outside of the memory aspect? Not really. Is it kind of fun?

It's cute. It's a cute game. Like, nothing wrong with it. I would say this is also a 2.5 out of five. Gameplaywise, it's very basic. Honestly, uh, gameplay-wise, I would say that a 2.5 almost feels generous. This is a memory game plus a minimum number and then trying to hit a target score through sheer luck. I would say as far as fun factor, I probably enjoyed it more than a 2.5 out of five. It was simple. I set it up. I played it. It was like cute artwork in a like a a game system that I like in theory. Like Ky Nok was a fun game. So like cute artwork made it accessible, but I mean the gameplay is really lacking. I'm going to give this another 2.5 out of five. Although again, probably deserves worse and I probably had more fun with it if that makes sense. Anyways, from there, let's go ahead and dive into Muster Raise the Banners. This is another game with adorably cute artwork. Let me see if I can open this so I can gather gather some cards. It's basically a lane battling game. Think games like Lost Cities. Like if you took Lost Cities and made the game experience worse in every way except for the artwork, that is basically what you get with Muster Raise the Banners. It's not a bad game system.

You're going to lay out a board over here. you're going to be drawing cars trying to put them onto your side trying to win the various lanes through having more icons on the cars, but you are working in terms of building ascending upwards. Like you can't go straight from a one to a four over here. You have to kind of work your way up there. So, it's got a little bit of that loss of these vibes as far as where do you choose to start building because you can't really build in the reverse direction and you can't really um you can't skip levels, so to speak. So, you're trying to be mindful as to when do you commit to a lane and what energy you putting into that and then when do you use some of like the rainbow bridges and the wizards to try to fill in the gaps and do like a few little extra abilities. But I would say that for the most part, the biggest problem I have with the game, the the best part about the game is easily the art. I love the art on the cars. I thought it was adorable. I thought it was cute. It made me wish that there was a better game behind this game because the art was so absolutely adorable. The problem is the game itself, it just doesn't really have a lot of decision space. Again, I just I every time I played this, I felt like I was just doing the obvious thing based on the cards that I had. And there never felt like there was any interesting tension going on as far as why I would do anything other than the obvious choice.

So like it like you're going to invest in the lanes you're winning. You're not going to waste your time in the lanes you're not. It did. You're going to draw the cards you draw and then play the cards and hope you draw into the right sequences. It really didn't feel like the decision space was present at all. Again, it's not a bad time. I'd give this another 2.5 out of five. I kind of played it and was like, "Okay, that didn't really feel like there was anything going on. Let's play it again." There still isn't anything anything interesting going on. It's just play cards until the game resolves. If you like games like War with the theme of Lost Cities and adorable artwork, then that game is for you. another 2.5 out of five. Then we have Machu Picchu over here. Machu Picchu continues the trend of games that are based on the real time reaction. So if you played games like Steal the Bacon or games like um what's it called? G cat cat goat cheese pizza. Any of those kinds of games, this is a real-time reaction game which players are going to be playing these llama cards onto the table in order to find various attributes and then trying to gather the cards to get rid. It's like slap the pile to get rid of your own cards. So you're looking for matching accessories on the cards and they're all so similar. So, you're trying to be like, is that actually the same headband? Are those the same glasses?

Maybe not. If two of the llamas share an accessory, you slap the pile trying to get rid of your cards. But also, cards also have on the top a machu pchu. And if at any point you go machu pu, you can slam the table as well to finish the phrase. And that will also be a good way of clearing the cards on the table. The last person doing so is the one who loses the cards and gets all the other cards. So, it's got that real-time freneticness. It's not bad. I don't think it's a bad time. My biggest issue is I think that there's a bunch of games that rely on this realtime reaction. Some of my favorites out there are going to be Steal the Bacon as well as Cat Go Cheese Pizza as well as um what's it called? What's that one? Um oh my gosh uh Jungle Speed. Jungle Speed is one of my favorites in out there. I think it's a phenomenal game. There are so many games that do this kind of cute vibe realtime reaction response that I just think that Machu Picchu didn't really bring anything super interesting to the table. The only thing it really did do that was interesting is the Machu Picchu, like that little finishing the phrase. Everything else other games do better. And Machu Picchu, honestly, doesn't come up enough in the game for that to be interesting enough. I would say like in an average game, it might happen once or twice. I'm sure I'll have people telling me, "No, it happens to us all the time. In our average games, it happens once or twice." Uh, making this kind of an anticlimactic, like the one thing it does differently. It's got cute art, no problem. But I would just recommend a lot of other games that do this before I would do this one. I'm going to give it another 2.5 out of five. My rating on this one might be a little harsher than it should be. I I am kind of being mindful of the greater ecosystem of games out there that already do this. Like, but if I was if this is the only game I've played in the genre, it would probably get a 3.5 out

of five. Honestly, I'm having a harder time separating that. Like, this is such a simple mechanic. Like, I try not to penalize random tangent over here. I try not to penalize games based on other games out there that already exist because if I do that, it's a constantly evolving rating system. And what do I do based on the fact that I'll play another 100 games this year, another 100 games next year, and I'm constantly learning more and adapting. I generally try not to penalize games based on the fact that other games are out there, I usually try to say, "Hey, this game's a 3.5, but there's just better games out there." I think when a game is so simple, though, when it's really like such a simple experience, and there's so many games available and in print that already do this, I think you have to step it up a little bit more. So perhaps it's a little inconsistent of me to try to like apply rating systems differently. I just I think this is too simple to give it more than a 2.5 when there are better games that do what this game is doing and this brought nothing new to the table and it's just a distilled set of mechanics. So again, it's probably deserves more than a 2.5. I just have a hard time giving it more than a 2.5 out of five, which means if you've been keeping track, we're down to the two left that are not 2.5 out of fives cuz I've just given out four 2.5s which means we have one three and one 1.5. We skipped the two, we went straight to a 1.5. So, let's go ahead and start with our three, which is Quagmire. Quagmire was fun over here. It was a fun game.

It's from Perplex. They did that um oh my gosh, that horse racing rolling dice game. I forget the name of it. I always forget the name of it, but it's a horse racing rolling dice game. Generally well received. I liked it. I I like per I like Quagmire in theory, but I don't like it quite as much. You're putting out 16 lily pad tiles, and then you have these little cards that are you're going to be playing. You have a hand of cards, and you're trying to choose how to move your various frogs in order to move them around the grid. to take actions basically in order to move your frogs around the grid and accomplish their goals to score points for them and then place them down in their point scoring pile which is variable based on number of players. But cards also have patterns in them and if you can play those while there are other cards on the table you'll also get points that way. So, there's a few ways to get points, but ultimately my biggest issue with Quagmire, it's kind of a clever abstract game that uses an interesting movement mechanic because your hand of frogs is kind of everything that you have access to as far as how you move things out.

But also, if you jump onto a lily frog in a way that knocks somebody else's frog, but you have perfect information at any point on the table, you can see all the frogs and their movement patterns that are in relation to the various players. And you can see, oh, this person, if he goes here, then there he'll be able to jump on my frog. So, in two turns, he can jump on my frog. So, I either need to move it or just make sure to be mindful as to when he's moving his frog. You have perfect information at all times when you play Quagmire. But, I mean, not what's in your hand, but the way the game works is actually pretty smart is you place your card down in your bay first. So, you kind of always have that heads up. You can't just people can't just surprise you with what with what's in their hand. Well, I guess they could to get positive points, but not to ambush your frogs. You basically play the game out until nobody has any legal moves and finish the round. Overall, um my biggest issue with it was that it becomes a little bit too deterministic and more importantly, it's a lot of constantly looking at everything on the table to try to see every movement pattern. Uh similar to things like muster over here. I didn't feel like there were a ton of interesting choices in the game. I felt like you played your frogs and then you were kind of at a victim of just analyzing the table again and again and again and hoping not to be caught unawares by missing something and then playing the obvious escape pattern and or threat pattern. So, uh, the idea of what Kagmar is doing, I love the idea of it. The actual execution felt more like a homework assignment of constantly reading the board. I still enjoyed it, which is why it's getting that slightly higher three out of five. I still had fun with it. I just felt that it was more of a clever idea and the gameplay was just a little bit too follow it through, so to speak. I mean, the most interesting part, honestly, was like trying to set up the board to score extra points with by playing a card and

scoring as many as four points from a single card. That was really satisfying the few times you got to do that. But outside of that, it was um a little too deterministic. Which brings us to the last one. All in from Next Move Games. All-in predictions. And I have to assume that I am in the minority in this one. I have to assume that other people like this one more than me. I just don't particularly like All-In Predictions. I really, really dislike it. I would say All-In Predictions to me feels like someone took a look at The Gang, which is a poker game from Cosmos, and they said, "How can we take what the gang did and just make it so much worse?" Like so much worse. Like, let's really just try to think of everything that made the gang fun and then copy that but make it not fun. I'm being so harsh here and I I have to imagine I'm alone in this. Like check out ratings in this one. See what you other people think because I think I'm probably in the minority in this one. But all in predictions basically has you building a poker hand. But unlike in the gang, the gang is kind of a cooperative game of trying to like feel out how good you feel your hand is.

There's lots of feeling information that can be a really fun experience. But in all in predictions, you have a hand of cards, then you play a card to do its abilities as you try to work your way towards a perfect hand. But then occasionally some of the abilities are like, "Oh, well, look at four cards in another's hand." Or somebody else has to tell you the highest hand that they have because you're also making predictions about who actually has the best hand in a way that kind of drips information out that doesn't feel like it has the charm or interest that the gang does. It just feels like build the best poker hand, but ultimately it's more about figuring out what other people's hands are. And also like you kind of have to make guesses anyway. and like it doesn't really feel collaborative. It's kind of like, you know, I guess I got it right. I've played this game a few times. I have lost. I have won. I have enjoyed neither. Uh it is not the most fun for me. I I really I really did not like it's one of those games where the reason sometimes the reason I play and it's it's always easier with shorter games.

When you have like a three-hour game that you didn't like, it's harder to dive in for a second play. Uh when you have a small box game that takes like 20 30 minutes to play, it's easier to be like, "Okay, that didn't work for me, but now that I understand what's happening, let me try it again and see if that was the issue." And no, it wasn't the issue. Not for me. This just wasn't fun. Nothing about the experience was fun to me. There was no point where I was like, "Yeah, I feel clever now. Yeah, this is this is this is really charming." Nothing ever did that. Um, it's going to get a 1.5 out of five for me. It is functionally a game. It worked in all senses, but I can't think of a world in which I would ever want to play it for a third time. But again, check other ratings. I am probably being harsher on this than the average rating out there. Um, and I wonder I wonder why that is, though. I actually haven't checked, so maybe I'm not being harsher than the average rating out there. Anyways, those are your six small mods game reviews. We have four 2.5s over here. Muster raise the banner, Katan on the road, Machu Picchu, and Kyoto No Ko.

Then we have Quagmire coming in at a respectable three out of five. And finally, we have uh next we have all-in predictions. Uh a game I thoroughly did not enjoy at a 1.5 out of five. Until next time, I'm Alex Radcliff from Board Gameco. Hope you enjoyed this video, and as always, I hope you have a good one.

Progress saved