My Games Collection - Shelf by Shelf - #41 - The Broken Meeple
Transcript
hi everyone welcome to another show video on this sweltering day or in a middle of a heat wave at the moment and it's a no raining no nothing it's 25 degrees and it's hot very hot you know and that's it's good at saying this is summer probably my least favorite season of the year actually I don't know that's sacrilege to a lot of people but personally I like to go on holiday in the other months it's cheaper you can still go somewhere that's hot even in the middle of winter there will be somewhere in the world that's hot if you wanted personally I like to keep cool and you know cool and colder temperatures I actually prefer and just weird like that but on top of that you've got like like Christmas markets are a good time of the year to go you've got less kids it says kids running around during the autumn and spring times because they're at school in the summer everything's crowded they all get out and mainly just cuz I can't take the heat very well you know I mean granted I've been to the US a few times but my god do I have to take precautions when I go to the US because it is so hot I am there hunting down every last bit of air conditioning I can find because I just can't take the heat for too long so it's kind of a bit like that with me and oh and summer brings in hay fever ain't that nice so I get to swelter and I get to have eyes and sneezing every now and again so great for summer but anyway we're talking about games so we're moving on to Mayfair games I Mayfair games don't exist anymore but at the time they had they released some pretty decent games and granted some of them are still being released to this
day just by other publishers but we're gonna move on to I apologize for any noise outside I've got very noisy neighbors ready patchwork to play game and everybody knows patchwork right now if you're in the gaming industry this one I've kept mainly because it's one of those games where if somebody is gonna get into the gaming hobby it's a great one for me to be able to do so very straightforward you're basically building a quilt yeah okay theme wise it's not a no but with this you've got to baby be as polyominoes so I like that style game and this is kind of what Ruby Rosenberg was kind of made a name for himself at the moment doing polyomino games but you know going around this board deciding also a ring of tiles deciding what like Tara you want to pick from free that in front of you and as you move this pulling across to take a towel you take it and then that limits the options for the next player and it keeps going around in a circle all the while you're placing them on your board to try and get them as efficiently laid out as possible Tetris style but the coping with this is that the tiles have a timer symbol in it and a button income as it were the buttons you use in order to like by the various tiles so sometimes more expensive than others depending on what shape they are but there's also a time factor you take a really good big tile it might have a really high time factor in it and so you're moving around the second board in a kind of ring going inside to the center and depending on who's at the back it's their turn so you could take multiple turns in a row if
you're at the back and thus get more tiles if you can afford it but this is constant tug-of-war between the two players as you are vying for that turn order while trying to make the best use out of tiles you've got until you eventually reach the center it's it's nice complicated as I'm probably making it out to me but it's just a really solid two-player game and you're granted I've not played it in a while but sooner or later there'll be somebody who comes around and wants to try a game that they've never heard of before and they'll suggest patchwork it's one of those cool games all right Oh back still horrible right Oh sky I love sky no yes Alexander Pfister and I don't have the best relationship with his games I will admit but he's a great guy he's very friendly guy doesn't matter if you talk bad about games as long as you're willing to discuss he's actually a really cool person so you know what comes up but yes I don't have the best history with his games certainly not with his heavy stuff Maracaibo is in the other room but you know I kind of like it kind of have issues with it but don't like way crescent trail I've no interest in mombasa didn't like blackout new expression in a new day always around the doll you know just generally I don't go for a style kill him you're him now but this is the one where I turn up and say no no I do like in Alexander Pfister game and here it is I love sky this is a fully expanded we're going to that later but this is I think this is where Alexander does best when
he does lighter games his lighter stuff I've generally thought fine oh my goods as a decent little card game filler Jamie blow in it to make it an expedition a new day or but these like the ones I think are really good and so with this one you've got bitter like Carcassonne element you're building up a map of tiles but you're doing it by auctioning the tiles off in separate like kind of bidding round beforehand where you'll draw some tiles at the bag you'll ditch one but then the other two you have to auction off to everybody around the table you can put money on those in order to try and make it more expensive for them to take but if you don't take it you're gonna have to pay that money anyway but if they do take it then no no I got a fair bit of money for it of course the problem with that is you may not necessarily how many tiles and you can't leave the Tartar and then scoring in that it's a really cool system and cartographers stole the scoring mechanism out of this which is you score four different objectives during a game but you score two at once at varying different rounds so one round you've got to worry about two objectives and other round you might ignore those and go over to complete your different ones and then they mix and match it doesn't take too long I mean 60 minutes is pretty accurate for most players 90 minutes absolute max with five people who are going quite slow but this is just a really nice sort of cool little game it's kind of like a clone of Carcassonne with some extra meaty bits fred in what I had done in here though is that I have yes it's messy because I've thrown in the Druids expansion yes the new
expansion for this is actually pretty cool now I was probably a little bit messy after I turned upside down see what you make me do but I've got folded space insert in here so everything's arranged nice and neat and granted there's some spare cubby holes here because I think most stuff I put in this bag but it's a pretty decent insert providing like I said I don't turn it upside down which is why but druids is the expansion to get to this game I recommend it as non-essential expansion but certainly a must-have no that's the same thing all right a you want to get the first expansion frontiersman you should burn that in the dustbin and never look back and maybe you might want to explode the dustbin as well sad on food it's horrible it takes what was a really cool simple game and overcomplicates it to hem them back I can't think of anybody out there who prefers the game with that expansion thrown in most people don't even remember most people don't even remember the expansion exists that's how bad it was dudes however is a really good one it's a pretty simple one you you basically have an extra phase where you are drafting these additional tiles from the board and these tiles have got different scoring objectives on it and including stuff that links with your other ones but basically it's a way of using money to get up more tiles and there's more objectives and everything so basically just throws an extra phase in where you can get additional tiles but the tiles are interesting it's not very complicated at all and it adds a lot more variety to the game which is a
great plus so by the sky that is my pick for Alexander Pfister's line up alrighty let's get on to yes everybody his so things are so cool to hate on Catan I still like Catan ok now the reason I've got these two boxes is because I have the collection of Catan that I believe is the best way to play it in this boxes they set with seafarers and one or two modules from here the Harbormaster and the fishing the fishings really cool and the Harbormaster is great because they make the harbor spaces that much more useful so it balances it out with the rest of the game the other stuff from traitors and barbarians is fine but I can't remember if I even tried the caravan barian out of here but you've got some other little mini expansions in here that to throw an every now and again but if you don't have that then you must at least get seafarers this with basic katana is the way it should be played because now as well as the island you aren't at the start you now can go off the different islands and there's more scenarios and you might have lots of little archipelago style island so you might have one big item to go to it gives you an extra option of how to progress through the game and if you don't know what Catan is then where have you been where have you been if you have not heard of Catan the simplistic roll dice get resources based on what time's your occupying trade with other players a system which has not been replicated
as well as this does in a you know 60 minute time frame it's still a classic since 1995 when it won the Spill DRS then and this is my preferred way to play it and will still play basic Catan but I would much rather throw in seafarers at least and if I can a couple of bits from here but I should enjoy it I mean I won't do tournaments because I don't like anything in torment or format but you know I'll still happily sit down and teach new players how the play guitar probably would seafarers included because frankly it's not that then we got the throw in seafarers I mean what you have to do teach normals a guitar and then teach bunts yay that's it it's not exactly much of an edition is it but it just makes it more interesting when you play it and I still like the turn end of discussion and then finally now this one cool buddy this is going back a bit I finally managed to find a copy of the second hand and I will not sell it unless there's a revised version that comes out but Pillars of the Earth if anybody has the expansion to this game please let me know and give it to me because I want it I can't find it anywhere and I doubt I ever will this one by Michael Rennick is a really cool game now it says cosmos on here as well as Mayfair I put it with my Mayfair stuff I mean you can put it with either raw I'm trying to arrange my collection how I can but this isn't a really cool old like worker placement game like what a gateway level worker placement game I would say and this has one of the most beautiful boards I've ever seen I mean this is like my other boy two levels of gorgeousness look at
that board I mean this is a Oh God Michael Menzel dare I forget his name but he's done the board with lots of the least directs all through it and so much detail it's so beautiful in fact the cubes get in the way of it because you can't see the rest of the pictures but ah love this game for its artwork but it's also a fun worker placement game but simply it's a your basic resource management game you are collecting resources with these workers but these workers are used to get you need them for the resources and you need different amounts for different stuff but you're using them to populate these cards allow you to convert resources in the victory points it's a pretty straightforward though objective at the end of the day get resources put them on the cards convert them into points here's the cool thing with this the board has about from 20 odd locations on it and they resolve in an order a numerical order and they all do very different things but what happens is that the free workers you put on they're called master builders are drawn out of a bag and when they're drawn out of the bag there's a cost depending on when they're drawn out of the bag and you take your turn as it's drawn so they will go in and suddenly draw the blue pawn and the blue player thinks are fantastic I can go first I can get the space I really want ah you have to pay seven coins to do that so you have a choice pay the seven and do it or you leave it on the track and wait but then it's not going to act until they everybody else has gone from
six five four three two one so if I am I happy with it going last or do I want to spend the money it's kind of like sometimes you really want to go first and get that essential thing you need but you gotta pay for it sometimes you don't want your thing to be drawn out in the bag first it's like great tension yeah okay it's got a bit of a luck factor to it so sue me a lightweight euro game has a little bit of luck to it at least this one doesn't they three hours to play take about 60 or minute 75 tops yeah doesn't take very long at all but with that you know you've got this great thing all right then the yellow player goes next I don't want to pay six then green and then green again you know and don't pay five and then four again so you're managing your money for these turns but then you put your pawns out and then they resolve an order and it could be like collect more cards get more resource sieze you get even more powerful assistants to help you favorite for the king and it's all to build this cathedral which is like basically a bunch of like LEGO pieces in the middle of the board it's a really nice simple game God is it beautiful so beautiful not to scream quality there is nobody in the world who can paint a board better than Michael Menzel great grunted Ryan locket has done pretty well with empires of the boy too but if I'm gonna go by the entire lineup Brian locket would be a good second place but you can't beat Michael Menzel freeze or it's this oh good even if it's not my turn I would just stare at this and go a little cart there's guy
cat sitting in this tree it's so detailed I don't know where you get the pink brush small enough to do this but very simple I mean the it could have been a smaller box fair enough and cubes well but I pimp out with stone Myra treasure chest resources and it works brilliantly but yeah the masterbuilt is it good the cards are small they're gonna mean bigger I suppose but you then got this Lego piece here where you build it you essentially like build the cathedral from scratch so there's my Cathedral yeah it's totally stable it's totally a kaviyoor go - maybe not I'm an atheist but no mine and it's just like it's a really cool simple game but I think people are just kind of not play anymore means there's a bit of a magma I think with some of these old work of placement so they go Oh feels dated as I granted some games do feel dated I don't think there's the theme granted is dated I mean let's face it but then come on Lorenzo and various other these like these euros as I call them they're still using this dried-out phim and it still works for them this theme is kind of very similar to architects of the West Kingdom just without the virtue track and going to prison thing it's still building a cathedral at the end of the day and so yes the theme isn't important but silky smooth mechanics a turn order system which is not being replicated to this day and I don't know why I'm positive that that whole drawing the master build around the back then could be okay in a lightweight game really easily but nobody has done it but if you find a
copy of this for a reasonable price on a bring by sale or maybe that's a fee you might even be able to get it now because I think they reprinted it give it a look it is seriously needs more love it needs to be brought back into the line life all right and that's Mayfair so next up we have a mix of stronghold games slash atypia games because they kind of cohabited on a few of them as well as a porter game so it's going to be an interesting discussion that one but for now I'm off to get some dinner I'll see you soon take care stay safe and just continue having fun