Quick Thoughts on Spiel and Kennerspiel Das Jahres
Transcript
hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today in this episode I want to talk about my thoughts on the games that were announced for nomination uh for the spill desar this is the annual uh gaming award given out in Germany for games that are at the family weight and typically these games receive a lot of notoriety and are very popular after the nomination and especially if they win there's also the section the category of can Spiel which is slightly more advanced it probably ranges into the medium to potentially heavyweight types of games but usually they stay pretty light with this award and I'll go through those as well unfortunately I do not know and I won't spend time on the Kinder Spiel the games that are meant for children however perhaps in the future as my kids start to grow a little bit older I will start to pay more attention but first let's talk about the the spiel doar n minations the games that are nominated for this award so first is Captain flip now I've had the chance to try this game out because it is on board gamer Arena and so anyone can play it for free and try it out for themselves as well but Captain flip is a very lightweight family type game where you draw a tile from a bag it h you draw the tile and you place it face up in front of you you have the option to either keep the tile or to flip it over uh and and place it into to a slot onto
your board it's kind of like Tetris style where you start from the bottom and ofn note the different maps on other words that are included with the game uh allow for different configurations of where you can place these tiles and where they can slot into but you essentially draw a tile randomly from the bag either keep it face up or flip it and and Slot it into the slot that you have determined that you would like to place it and so there's a a little bit of actually a lot of bit of luck involved in this game uh not a lot of strategy and it kind of is like a Tetris type of push your luck type of game if I were to uh describe it it's not my favorite game I didn't feel like there was a lot of decisions to be made in this game the tiles themselves do have different ways of synergizing with other tiles and where they are placed as well to give you some points but the fact that you are drawing them randomly out of a bag and potentially flipping them over for a posture luck type of effect was not very appealing to me uh it is I think very appropriate for this award and for families to play I think it's a you know complex enough that it's not a children's game but because of the synergies and and plain tiles to synergize with each other but other you know beyond that uh the the individuality of some of those tiles I think this game is very straightforward but not very exciting to play if you enjoy heavier games next is in the
footsteps of Darwin this game is also a pretty light game that I have not played So based off of the description and what people have said about this game not to be confused with Darwin's Journey which I think came are out around the same time and I would often confuse the two uh you are openly drafting tiles to play onto your board essentially and so it's a a a drafting game where in in the setting of Darwin exploring the galpagos islands so I think this looks like a pretty solid game it's gotten great reviews so far an overall ranking of 7.4 out of 10 on Board Game Geek and so this one I think would be interesting to check out I think it it definitely would not feel similar to Darwin's Journey but in a in a similar sense you are collecting animals from the looks of it and uh building out your own Tableau to create synergies for points and and uh yeah so I think this would be an interesting game and then of course finally is Sky Team this game is also on board game arena and I've played this game extensively if I were to choose a game for the Victory and for the uh award this year I think it would be Sky team and I if you look at the for example golden geek awards that were uh released about a month ago Sky team did win a lot of those rewards and I think it deserves to win those I think it is a very fun fun two-player game cooperative game where you simulate flying a and
Landing a Plane by Rolling Dice and keeping those dice a secret from your uh co-pilot and you are assigning these values of dice onto a modu very modular board uh that is uh set up in increasing difficulty based off of the scenario and I've been progressing through those scenarios which are available on board game arena and so this game not only offers fun gameplay even from the base level of playing the game I think the uh the game itself is fun to play it works really well on board game arena because there's limited communication there anyway and you get to I I love the modularity of of this game where you get to add different parts to the game to make it increasingly difficult and it really spreads your dice thin and where you get to place them you have to uh really think ahead and uh there is an element of trying to communic what you may have left in your hand of the dice ruled to try to communicate and saying hey I I played this dice first I hope that you understand that that means I don't have anything higher or lower and therefore can try to communicate as well as you can and so this I think this the game really Nails a Cooperative limited communication genre type of a game in a in an excellent way you know all scenarios many different scenarios are being released for this on board game arena as we speak I feel like every couple weeks or so they are announcing one or two different modules which are based off of airports
in on in the world to the game and so I think it's well supported and established and I think that people I think people would agree that this game is deserving of a win here as well should just briefly look at some of the uh Spiel dear's recommended games games that I feel like are honorable mentions to the nominations for the award itself self uh some of these titles I do not know I think that for example uh past nicked is more of a card game along the same line as like six n and shots it if you can looks like a party game but some of these games are really notable such as harmonies I've uh reviewed that recently I think that one is a really good game and perhaps its similarities to Cascadia a past winner of the Spiel uh probably precludes it from getting a nomination unfortunately Phantom in Inc I think is a party game as well that includes some sort of uh limited communication and drawing uh aspect to and deduction uh to the party level and so that that would actually is something that I would want to try uh trekking through history I've heard a lot of good things about as well it is a open Drafting and set collection game that is very much at the family weight but it seems to be very engaging enough that even uh hardcore Gamers have said good things about it and finally Trio is a 2021 card game that is on board gamer Arena one that I have not played yet and
so I probably should if they are recommending this game as well uh I'll give it a shot and see what it's like it's got a 7.3 out of 10 on Board Game Geek so not too bad we move on to the keniel nominations first Daybreak I've talked about Daybreak a bit on the uh Channel and podcast I think Daybreak is an excellent game from Matt Leck in The Cooperative line of games similar in vain to pandemic but in this we are combating the uh effects of negative effects of global change and climate change by trying to initiate different projects and and motives to make the world a better place and you do so using uh simultaneous action selection and with the ever ramping difficulty and and inreasing difficulty that is seen in games like pandemic and so this one is really fun it's on board game arena it probably doesn't play as well on board game arena especially turn-based because this game requires a lot of simultaneous coordination to make sure that the cards in your hand and on your Tableau are matching with the other players cards as well that you activate them in their right order to maximize the effects and benefits there so Daybreak is really good uh The Guild of merchant explorers by Matthew dunon and J Gilbert is something that I have talked about extensively on the podcast as well I've really enjoyed even my one play of it it this is one of the games that I want to
revisit again and hoping that this game for me it was a little bit more expensive than I feel like what it it should have been you know the the game itself is really fun it's not terribly complex it is more in that light to medium range of complexity but the Rolland right mechanism is really um embellished and and I guess taken to the next level because the uh your the goal of the game is to try to explore a map a shared map and to send an expedition out to different areas of that map and doing so and and exploring similar regions and kind of trying to explore as much as you can based off of objectives that you have gain you points but then in subsequent rounds you gain powers that are very powerful and they alter the game in at such a level a drastic level that it makes it feel like you can do anything and but everyone else can do ex you know extremely fun things as well and so it makes an excellent roll and right uh which plays pretty quickly uh feel very exciting and so I I love that game and then finally Ticket to Ride Legacy Legends of the West obviously I have played Ticket to Ride I enjoy it for what it is it's just a nice game to bring out with uh with family and friends who aren't as invested in the hobby it's a great entry way to seeing what modern board Gam games are like and the Legacy version I've heard has a lot of good things to offer a lot of uh modularity and you know additional mechanisms that make the base game of
Ticket to Ride shine even better and so I'm glad that it is here because it is a legacy game I do wonder if it would uh obtain the nomination I feel like Legacy games are great to play once and perhaps this game does offer a more eternal or continuous uh mode to play after you have finished the Legacy campaign but out of all of these games I'm going to think that Daybreak is going to win I think that one is a little bit newer The Guild of merchant explorers is a couple years old uh Daybreak I think is just a it's got a great theme I think that a lot of people can resonate with nowadays and it's obvious you know it's from Matt Le coock and so people really enjoy pandemic and the Cooperative system that it provides it's similar enough that I think people will latch on to Daybreak and really enjoy it then finally we have the recommended four other titles for the ker Spiel and the first game that I have played here that is on board game arena is for Shuffle an excellent card game and Tableau Builder where you are drafting cards uh from a large and individualized deck to play you know trees you have different types of cards you have trees that you can play onto your area and then animals that you can play to the top bottom left or right of those and each of these cards are multi-use in the sense that each uh card May either have a top or bottom half with the animal or a left or right portion of it as well and so I mean a lot of these cards are repetitious within the deck but they can offer um a
variety of ways to score points and and so it's it's a really fun card game that has gotten some um support as well in the form of an expansion which is available on board game arena so I do enjoy that game it's it's it's a really good game next on this list is a game that I had not heard about which is called beer pioneers and from the look of it and the description on Board Game Geek this looks like a worker placement and hand management game I think it it kind of looks like a combination of viticulture and distilled where you are utilizing cards from your hand and taking worker placement actions to brew beer and to sell it for for points and even the game end trigger is the same as vulture where one if one player reaches a certain VI point mark that signals the end of the game but it's got that pushy luck uh simulation or at least a mechanism that is found in games like distilled where you are brewing beer and I guess as it is in real life I I'm not a drinker but I feel like you can uh there there's a little bit of you know chance involved in brewing beer and sometimes it works out where you create a good product product and sometimes it doesn't and so I would be really interested in checking this game out it's weighted at a 3.35 at of five so yeah this one looks pretty interesting that and it was released in 2023 so it's a fairly new game 7.8 out of 10 as well so there might be something here that maybe we have uh or I have missed in the
last year next is botanicus this is a 2024 game rated an 8.2 out of 10 and its mechanisms as because I don't know about this game it's mechanisms listed on board game be or action drafting grid coverage and grid movement with the modular board so so it looks like it is a like light to medium weight Style game as well that I honestly haven't heard much about recently and so it has been receiving good praise according to those who have rated it there's 100 about almost 200 ratings on it as well so I'd be interested in checking this one out and then finally the last game on this list is ritual this is a 2 to six player game uh weighted pretty lightly at a 1.67 released in 2022 that has an an element of deduction and memory as well as a real-time play and so yeah so those are couple games that I haven't heard about but obviously they have some merits to it to be nominated or at least recommended for uh the Spiel do jars and and Kenner Spiel and so I'll have to look into some of these games that I haven't heard about and maybe give them a try and and perhaps uh if you have any input as well on games that some of these games that you might have played as well I'd love to hear your thoughts and and so you can do so in the comments down below but those are some quick thoughts on the uh Spiel games here that are nominated um so yeah there you go and uh hopefully I
can get back to uh some more regular content if if you have been following I've been pretty busy with vacationing and and things like that and enjoying some time with the family uh before I head back to work and so uh anyway thank you for listening and Consulting with me today and uh hope that you schedule an appointment with your board gaming doctor real soon take care