Rank My Mind | Games with Beth Sobel Art
Transcript
Welcome to where there's a wheels,
there's a play.
I'm Ian, your makey casual gamer.
I'm Stacy. I'm your non- gamer gamer.
And today we are here with another edition of
Frank My Mind.
We This is fun little series that we started where we take five um games in a category randomly chosen by BG stats that we've played and we rank them for ourselves, then we rank them for each other and we see how well we do know each other. Um you started off really well. We were both three of five the first time we did this. And then um Stacy's done pretty well. She's done three of five and two of five since. And um
so you can you can kind of see here is the current standings. You can see I have not done very well the last couple times in the push your luck or party games. Uh today though we are changing it up a little bit. We are not going with a mechanic or a category. What are we going with today? We are going with an artist and we are going with games that we have both played by Beth Soil.
Yes, we are going with Beth Soil art games and we have 11 of them um that we've both played. There are more that um
solo games.
I've played solo, but there are 11 of them on this list that we have both played. So, we are going to get right into it and see what BG Stats selects. The first game is Herbaceious.
Good one. Good choice.
Herbaceious. The second game is knitting circle. Remember, we're we're doing the the gameplay, not the artwork. We're doing like the actual like how much we like the actual game.
I couldn't Yeah.
Cascadia Nocturn. This might as well just be a flatout games list almost. She has a very good relation of flatout games because a lot of these games on this list are flatout games. If we get another flatout game, that's going to be crazy because I think there's only one left. And Between Two Cities Essential Edition.
All right.
So, we're judging the game and not
We're judging the game. We're not judging the art. These are just games that Beth Soil has done the art for. Um, I think it would get a little too confusing because if we ever do designer or publisher, you can't really design. So, we're designing we're we're ranking how much we like the game in which Beth Sooul did art in. We aren't ranking the art. We would have to get all the games out and see
specific here,
but it's always been the game. It's rank. It's We're ranking the game. Okay,
we would have to get out all of the games and look at all the components to do the actual art. Okay. So, we'll be right back with our
ranking. All right, we are back. Uh, this one was tough.
Not feeling confident. Th this one was tough to rank it for myself and it was tough to rank it for you. I think
Well, I haven't played a lot of some of these,
right? We haven't played some of them in a while, so it was a little harder to remember. I
I will say my number one and my number five were pretty clear for me. And I think I hope the number four and number five that I gave to you were Slayer, but who knows? I may have them back. All right,
start us off. What do you think my number five? Because you're because you're you're kicking my butt here.
Reigning champion.
You're kicking my butt overall. Just overall.
Okay. I I'm not giving reasons of why I picked what I picked because
we'll talk we'll talk about what our top fives were or our five our ranking was later. Okay. So, what did you think my number five was?
I thought your number five was verbaceious.
Raw.
Knew it. I knew I should have picked it number four. Okay.
I think your number five is Cascadia.
Nope.
No, really.
I don't hate it that bad.
Oh, well, I I know, but I just don't Okay. Okay.
Dang. I wonder if I have four and five. I wonder if I have four and five backwards.
So confident.
Well, I know that you don't like that game. So,
it's not that I don't like it. I I do enjoy the game.
Okay.
It's just It's a little
The scoring is Okay.
Hate the scoring. All right.
Okay. Your number four. I'm coming in confident with this one.
Your number four is not turn.
No. Is this what it feels like to not get one right?
Yep. Your number four is between two cities essential dish.
You see, we're not very good at this. Those were the two that I thought I was pretty confident on.
You're number three. Meaning circle.
No.
Oh crap. Okay. Well, this is this is
your number you're number three. Herbaceious.
No.
Okay. Well, we're down to our top two.
We are doing pretty good.
Are we both going to go over?
No, we're getting your number one right at least.
Probably. You're probably getting my number one.
Who is this one?
Between Two Cities Essential Edition.
Two Cities.
Nope.
No. Oh crap sakes.
Oh, you're like, "Well, maybe I'm done."
I'm not used to this.
Your number two is Nocturn.
No.
No. Okay. Wow.
We are doing
Are we going over?
Your number one cuz I know you love this game.
Yes. Yes.
And it's in your If I had to pick my top 20 games of all time, this one's going to always be in my top 10. I don't. Wow. That was not what I sound like at home.
So, that was a gimme. That was an absolute right.
Yes. Yes. Yes. Your number one is knitting circle.
Yes.
Dang. Okay. Well, what was your number five?
So, starting at my number five was not true.
Really?
I don't really care. I I love the
Every time we play it, you see how much you like it. I'm shocked. Yeah, you do.
I'm shocked that that's number five. Okay. No,
I'm shocked that was below something else. My number five. This one's going to stun you. Between two cities.
What? I had that as your
Mhm.
I don't know. I
I like that game. I I I enjoy it and I like the two-player variant, but the actual way you're supposed to play where you're supposed to do two cities between two people,
I just not a fan of it.
Just not a fan of it.
Okay.
So,
I do like the two-player variant where you're building your own two cities. So, maybe I should have moved it up a little bit because of that, but I was thinking more of just the
I was thinking just the way that
Yeah. Yeah. I was I was thinking the way you're supposed So maybe it should have been a little higher, but I my brain kind of went to that and Okay,
so you were on number four.
Number four.
My number four was Cascadia.
Okay. I So I had your four and five flipped.
Yeah.
I just figured you you've you talk about how you don't like that one. So I had your four and five.
I hate the scoring on Cascadia. It just drives me. Especially with the Hawks. The Hawks have to be in line.
Oh, wait. No, I had I had your Oh, wait. No, that was your five. That was your four. Okay. Yep. Okay.
Trust me.
I didn't have your four and five slow. Okay. Okay.
Um my number four was Herbaceious.
Oh, really?
Yes. I think it's because we haven't played in a while and even we reviewed the rules. I I I enjoy it, but there's three that I think I like a little more. I actually flip-flopped a couple at the end.
Yeah, you can see where I
So, okay. You're number three.
My number three between two cities.
Okay. Nice.
I like that game. I I
the way we played it I liked it.
I think maybe so between two cities in her bases we haven't played for a while. So it was kind of like
yeah we did try it the other way where you had the dummy player and we tried to do it with the dummy player and I also tried playing solo and I and
I've never played it with more than two people with it but I don't think I could do it with
with the trying to build two things with two different people. It just doesn't work for me. Um, but yeah, that one probably could have been higher if I thought about the two-player variant only. Um, what are we on? Number three.
Number three.
My number three was Nocturn.
Noturn.
Yep.
Okay.
Yeah, I flip-flopped I actually flip-flopped um Herbaceous and Nocturn at the last minute.
Gotcha.
So, I think you would have
Well, no, because I had this as
you had four. Okay. Well, yeah. I had I had herbaceious three in Nocturn four at first and then I flip-fpped them.
Okay.
Oh, you had herbaceious five for me, though. Yeah, I do like it. Um I like the I like the trying to figure out where you're going to go to collect your sets and stuff. Um
yeah. Okay. Um your number two then?
My number two was Herbaceious.
Okay. Okay.
I do like this game. I like uh putting the pots out and trying to get your collection and yeah, it's just cute.
My number two was knitting circle.
Okay.
I really I I enjoy this game. I enjoy the rondelle and it um gives a little more freedom as to what you're selecting. I like trying to make the different
the different garments with the different patterns and stuff. So, I do really enjoy that one. I think it's a really good sequel. And then our our number ones. Oh, our number ones. We got, you know, I absolutely love Cascadia.
I absolutely love knitting circle.
So,
I love playing knitting circle. I love that they actually have the different stitches that you can knit and the pearls. And it's actually the like the truest to knitting that you can I can find. So, and I love that kitten,
but it's not based on artwork. It's just based on gameplay. Solely on gameplay. So,
yeah.
And I'm just going to update our graphic here.
Oh, we didn't I We only got one each.
Yep.
Well, I'm used to uh doing that clearly. Um I'm used to uh
I'm used to not doing that.
We got Sandera Tang on there still. Is that a best?
No. Yes, we do.
We were going to do Sandara Tang,
but we didn't have enough games and so last second we can't see this. Oh, they can't.
But I think at the beginning Yeah.
Yeah, we showed it at the beginning. But it's okay. Um,
we were we were we were we were gonna do Sindar Tang, but we realized that while we do have enough Zindar Tank games, some of them are not
played. But good catch because I probably would not have done that before I So, we're doing this on the fly so that you can see the updated
updated
Oh my gosh.
standings here. So, we're not even at half. So, we're not doing very well.
You're doing you're doing better than me.
I can't tell you how disappointed I am in myself with only getting one right. I am not used to that.
So, here are the updated standings. So, Stacy is nine out of 20. I am five out of 20 because, as you can see, I have not done very good the last three times we've done this.
I keep going downhill. So, my next one's going to be zero.
Well, I don't know. Anyway, so there you have it. There is our very silly series uh rank my mind where, you know, after the first one, I thought, hey, we might do pretty decent. And Stacy did for a while. Now, it's like I' I've just not been able to. Um, a lot harder than you think. I know games Stacy likes. Like, if I say she's going to like a game, I know she's going to like a game. And nine times out of 10, she does. Um, but putting five games in a category in order is a lot harder than uh we I think we got a curveball on the first the first one with the worker placement. The the the top three were or three of them were pretty easy. They were pretty obvious to place. So anyway, once again, this has been where there's wheels,
there's a play. I'm Ian.
I'm Stacy.
And we'll see you next time
at the table.