Complexity Vs Complication In Board Games
Transcript
Complex doesn't mean complicated. Nothing describes this better than Eric Barlow's TED Talk. So for me, a well-crafted baguette fresh out of the oven is complex, but a curry onion green olive poppy cheese bread is complicated. Interconnection in board games doesn't need to be complicated for it to be complex. And today, I'm talking about complexity, depth, and complication in the board games that we love to play. Okay, let's start by defining the terms. Complication for me means learning a large rule set and how difficult a board game is to learn. Board Game Geek uses a rating system from 1 to 5, with 5 being the heaviest, but weight often measures rules overhead more than it measures depth. Now to complexity, what does this mean for me?
Well, for starters, it means how many options I have on any given turn. It means how much does my little pea brain have to process? In a lot of my videos, you'll often hear me talk about decision trees. This is where, when you take one action, it leaves branching paths. And for me, this is where the real depth and complexity of a board game really lies. The more options I have, the bigger the decision tree, the more scrummy-dillyumptious choices that you get to make in the board game. But here is an important distinction. Just because a board game has got a branching decision tree, doesn't mean that it needs to be overrought with a complicated rule set. So with that, let's look at what the perfect balance between complication and complexity might look like. Let's start by looking at some easy games to play.
Tsar is one of my favorite abstract board games of all time. On your turn, you're going to take two actions that consist of moving one of your pieces. The aim of the game is simple. You're trying to wipe out one of the three types of different pieces your opponent has. Simple, right? Yeah, sure it is. All you're doing is moving a piece on your turn until you start to think, "Wait a minute. If I go there, then my opponent's going to go here." And then you realize every single action you take has so many consequences that you really need to be careful with what you do next, and you start to plan your turns ahead. And honestly, this is one of the main reasons why I love abstract so much. A super simple rule set that you can learn in a couple of minutes, but offer so much depth and complexity in any given turn. You'll often hear the phrase, "It's easy to learn and hard to master." And for me, this is the ethos of a well-designed board game. Ra is another game that springs to mind. It's a simple auction game in which you're going to be using set collection and a bit of push your luck to try and beat out all of your pesky opponents. What's really interesting is the forced pressure and timing involved on each bid, as you only get one opportunity per auction to bid. And this causes instant decision-making. One of the great things about Ra is every single time you do an auction, you're bidding for multiple different things. It's basically a decision tree in itself. You're not just
bidding for yourself, you're also bidding to stop other people. And this adds a ton of complexity and also social interaction as well. And this is why Ra is considered one of the easiest games to play that offers so much decision-making and complexity in its tiny rule set. And And this is not by mistake. Reiner Knizia is one of the greatest designers and always finds a way to make complicated and juicy decision-making choices in a really small rules package. He really is the master designer when it comes to this design philosophy. Right, let's take a look at the opposite now. Let's take at some games that have got a deep rule set, but just for the sake of it. It doesn't necessarily bring anything extra to the game and just makes it a nightmare to learn with too many things going on and complication for complication's sake. I'm going to start with Unconscious Mind. Now, by no means is Unconscious Minds a bad game. It's okay, but the rules overhead is just absolutely insane for the amount of complexity you actually get in the game.
All of the parts of the game work as a singular. When you mash every single mechanic together, it just makes a hodgepodge and a mess. I honestly believe you could take so much out of the game and it would be better for it and an easier experience without losing that much complexity. It's like the complete opposite of Ra. I feel like instead of battling my decision tree and my options and what I can do next by knowing everything that's going on with a clear, concise rule set, to more like fighting the rule system itself. Like there's just so many little rules and so many but ifs and so many different systems going on, it just makes everything complicated and difficult to know whether you're allowed to do it. And that's not from what the decision itself is, it's from the rule set itself. And that is just something which I fundamentally do not enjoy in board games. It feels like the kitchen sink mentality has been used for this board game. They've just thrown in every single different type of mechanic and went, "Here you go." And because of this, it's just not a cohesive experience. It feels lacking. It feels like there's too much and not enough at the same time. It just misses the point of what an excellent game should be.
Now, an really interesting caveat here, I was also going to use Anachrony as my second game which I thought was overrought with rules, but it had been a few years since I had played this game, so I wanted to get it onto the table again to make sure I felt the same way. And my gosh, am I glad that I did this, because I had a totally different experience. This game is actually so much smoother than I remember, and it has such an interesting span of choices and decisions to make on any given turn. It's incredibly tight. It's got so much theme for a heavy Euro game. It actually has completely blown me away. So So one thing it really made me think about was when I first played this game. When I first played Anachrony, I was a noob to the hobby. I hadn't really played that many heavy Euro board games before, so I didn't really have any sort of experience with this style of game. I remember being flooded with a ton of rules and stages and things where you have to do certain things at certain points and so many different ways to score that my brain was just flooded with too many decisions that it just shut down on itself. And because of that, I had a really lousy experience.
Now, it's been 4 or 5 years since I played it and I have played so many games that and I understand systems so much better that when I played Anachrony, I actually found it incredibly smooth. Every single action made sense. Every single rule that was there was there for an important reason. It It made the whole game that much fun and better to play. So it's really worth taking into note that and as you get older and more experienced within the the hobby and the game itself, what might have been complex for you might not be anymore. I recently played Feast for Odin with some of my friends and they hated the game the first time they played it. The second time they played it, they had a completely different experience with it. So one thing that's worth noting when it comes to complexity, especially complexity which is surrounded by a heavy rule set, is give the game a chance. Sometimes you might need to play the games once or twice to see that complexity shine through. And I'm really glad I did this with Anachrony, because I've missed so many good gaming experiences because I was afraid to go back to it because I thought the game was too much, when really that wasn't the case at all. I want to talk about co-op games really quickly. I've been playing a lot of Eternal Deck recently.
What this game does really well is every single time you play the game and you go to the next level, it adds an extra layer of complexity. It can be an extra rule, making the game more difficult, but every single time you play the game, it's going to change it slightly and give you an extra layer of decision-making or trying to use your brain in a different way by using the same system of the game itself, which is something I find really fascinating. You'll often see this with legacy games as well. Pandemic Legacy, for example. It starts off at the base level Pandemic game, but every single time you play, it adds an extra rule, a layer of complexity. So by game 7, 8, 9, 10, you've probably got nine or 10 different added rules, which makes the game so much more interesting, adds so much more storytelling, and gives it more character. Another game that does this fantastically well is Bombus Turris.
It's one of my family's favorite games. Another thing I'd like to quickly talk about with with a co-op board games as well is, sometimes you'll find like a weird rule in the game that doesn't necessarily make sense until you start playing it. And then you realize that rule's been added for thematic reasons. If a game can add in a couple of wonky rules to give me a more immersive thematic experience, then I'm totally, totally down with that. And it's something interesting that you'll normally only see in a cooperative experience. Finally, I want to talk about one of my favorite games of all time. This game is deep, complex, and complicated. Lisboa, a game built on layers and systems and complexities in which to complete something, you must do three things first. It has such a deep decision tree and every single thing you do will have consequences. The amount of complexity that this game has is through the roof. It's not often you'll find a game which is designed so well. Every single system is there for a reason and it makes every other system stronger. To to complete one thing, you'll have to do three other things first and each of those other things that you have to do will more than likely require you to do something else and this is why this game is fabulous because the mechanics of the game are not difficult to learn. On your turn, you're basically playing a card.
Where the difficulty of this game really arises is through the interconnection of every action that you need to do because it's not just simple as going to the spot and doing one thing. Before you can go to that spot, you have to do like three other things. Now, what's really interesting about this is it shows that you can have light design game, something like Raw, which is very easy to learn and has a lot of complexity. But on the other side, you can also have something which is incredibly difficult to learn but also offers that juicy decision making. It's really interesting. It doesn't necessarily mean that a game has to have X amount of rules overhead for it to have X amount of complexity. Another thing that's really worth taking into consideration when you're talking about complexity, depth and how difficult a game is to learn is length. I think the longer a game is, for me especially, the more I'm willing to learn. Look, if I'm going to sit down and learn an incredibly difficult game, I don't want it to be over in half an hour. I want to be able to at least get to explore the systems and the difficulty that I'm learning and be able to sit there for a couple of hours and actually get involved in the game. If I'm going to sit and learn a game for 45 minutes for it to be over in half an hour, then it just makes me completely uninterested and not really wanting to learn the game. If I'm investing time, I want my brain to be busy. And on the other hand, if I'm with some casual players, family, friends or I'm just having a social experience, I don't want any complexity in my games at all. And sometimes you just don't need
complexity. Complexity doesn't equal fun. Some of the best gaming experiences I've ever had are through games like Magical Athlete or Spots or Sizzling Sausages. These require no rules overhead. You're basically just throwing dice and seeing what happens. Now, look, what does this all mean? Well, for me, it means just because a game has a weight of four out of five on BoardGameGeek, doesn't mean that it does for everybody. You need to take your own experience into account. Something that feels easy for me might feel incredibly difficult for somebody else. So, what I want you to do is the next time you're going to ask somebody how heavy a game is, instead, I want you to ask them, is it complicated? Is it complex? Or is it actually deep? And that's it. That's the episode. Uh the hope hopefully you learned something. This is a really interesting thing to go into and it's really made me open my eyes on to the whole heavy system and how we rate games on complicated and the fact that games don't necessarily need to have a large rules overhead and a hodgepodge of mechanics for it to actually have an insane amount of complexity. I look forward to the next episode and I will see you guys on the next one. Cheers and let's go, baby. I know that's not say that. That's cringe. I'll see you on the next one and have a good one. Uh I'm hungry. I'm going to go get some food. I will see you later. Bye-bye.