Skip to main content
Loading video...

Bruno Cathala on designing during a pandemic, solo gaming & the future of Cyclades - TCbH Interviews

Transcript 48:20

i began to work on the prototype types only if it works in my head i would love to live in your head for just about 10 minutes hello and welcome back to another episode of the cardboard herald my chance to talk with creative gamers and game creators and my guests today you know from designing or co-designing loads of hits including some of my favorite games ranging from cyclades to king domino to five tribes and about a bajillion other titles welcome back to the show bruno catala how you doing man fine fine i'm fine i'm happy to see you again yeah well last time that we had a chance to talk it was under very different world circumstances i mean we were still talking about board games and we were still talking about game design and also we talked about a bunch of other stuff cycling music but 2021 is uh is a very different world and one thing i wanted to know is as such an experienced and prolific game designer such as yourself has the the global pandemic impacted how you do business how you make games design games yes for sure because i had an impact on my job for sure uh first i fee i have to say that i was afraid

not not speaking about the covet itself but about how it would um change all these social relations because for me gaming means making creating social relations between people and as far as you are maybe alone at home how could we deal with that so i was afraid of the consequences of this pandemic with all the lockdown situation yeah of course so that means that immediately i've searched how to work differently that means that immediately i went on a tts a tabletop simulator to understand how it works and to put my prototypes on that kind of platform just to be able to go on to uh with my job development job with my co-designers because we were very we are very far and it was impossible to meet again so we had to find another way to meet and to play together and for sure for some games that kind of electronic device uh doesn't help if you make a party game in which you have to drive right around the table you cannot do it but if you make more strategical games it was a way to go on with my partners

and it was also a way to present prototypes to publishers and that's what i did during the first lockdown and during that period i signed free games just because i had time to develop them i had play tester at home because i was at home with my girlfriend which is a gamer and her daughter which is 11 and it's also a gamer that that helps i got people to play test i had tabletop simulator or other ways to play with my partners it was possible for me to present the game to publishers so at least it doesn't um created so much trouble for me from for my for my business but it created um how to say um frustration because for me like i said gaming is social relations and i had no more contact with gamers because this is something which is very important for me i'm making them for myself and then i want to share them but there was no game event all had been cancelled right right so it created frustration so i i try to find other way to share things with people with players so i i've always been quite present on social

medias but i imagine that maybe uh giving something that means offering print and play uh variations on some of my games could be a good way to stay to keep in touch with all these people that i couldn't see anymore so and that's what i did during all this period oh that that makes total sense and you mentioned something earlier that some games just don't logistically work out on something like tabletop simulator do you feel like any of those three games during that initial lockdown period were shaped based off of the limitations that you did have like did they come out maybe different in some way than had you not been in a pandemic not really because if you know my my games most of them are immediately adaptable on that kind of uh of platform so it does not change my mind in fact i i think that uh i try to find always solutions um for the the informatic to be on help and not to be uh something which will format my ideas how difficult was it to learn tabletop simulator because i know that i'm someone who ha i get lots of invites to check out games on tabletop simulator i have friends who play on tts and nonetheless i i hop on there and i feel like i'm completely inept and i have to relearn

it every time i do uh there are a lot of people who had to adapt to it over the the course of the pandemic was it easy intuitive for you or was it a bit of an uphill climb no it was it was quite easy but uh because um i had the support of some other uh players or game designers or publishers which still had an experiment with with that and if i was alone just with interface it would have been a nightmare it's not very user friendly it's right right just it's in between you know some things are very nice and some other things how to how to understand how it works so and you have also to imagine that all is in english which is not my native language we see which is for sure a little more difficult for me so but i had the chance that some friends i did still know the interface quite well and i spent some time with them by skype sharing stream and learning in maybe just half an hour i had all the major things i needed to do my job and it was then quite easy uh to make my first games on that but my my prototypes

on tabletop i have not uh nice i don't care i don't care to have something which is nice i just want to be able to play test and if i want to make something very nice i do it at home for myself not on that platform is that something that's changed over the course of your career because i know like some of the advice that a lot of experienced designers i've talked to have said exactly that don't worry about making your prototype nice make it functional something that you can use but you're not worried about making changes iterative changes as you go make adjustments because what you're likely playing isn't going to be the final version don't sweat the details just make sure you got the functional game was there a time where you were making your prototypes as nice as could possibly be no because i don't i don't like to waste time in fact so i'm and frankly speaking i think that it's a mistake to do it uh just because as game designer we have to focus on the engine right and the publisher will focus about making it nice and if i do the job of a publisher that means that i'm not focused on my real job that makes sense you know you also were talking about how games are such a fundamental social experience for you and something that i've thought about a lot of both in terms of just where we are as a hobby and in terms of the the um

covid pandemic is solo gaming solo gaming is so much more prevalent than it has been in the past uh and certainly so much more so than when you were releasing like shadows over camelot in 2005. what are your thoughts on solo gaming it's uh it's an interesting topic because for myself right i have no real uh wish to play solo i it's not my cup of tea if if i want to play alone i prefer to take my switch and play on my screen to make a video game for example yeah so that means it's not my taste but have i i'm looking at what is uh how the the gaming world is is moving and i can see that uh it's something which is becoming more and more important right so and what i don't like is to see solo variants which of my own games which have been developed by anyone which have posted them on bgg for example because my games are my games and uh and if i want to make a solo version i will develop it myself oh okay so yes i i don't like when there are whenever there are some unofficial uh add-on to my games that's

interesting i i don't think that i've met anyone who has that stance i can understand it for sure and i can explain why yeah tell me there is there is a reason for that but let's go on solo version that means that as far as i understand that it's something which is becoming important that means that i take care of trying to do something when it's possible sure and you have seen that during the pandemic we want one we have uh offer a printed play solo version of seven wonders duel which is excellent yes and which which won the price yeah she runs a bgg a golden medal so yeah the golden geek it's a well deserved prize exactly from golden gate that's it so that means that when it's possible now i'm focused on it but i do it myself i don't play a lot but i want something which is okay for me that means that for me a good solo version has to be um simple but it does not come to be more complicated about the the original game but that means that if you are always in front of situations but if then if then if then but if for me yes it can work but it makes no sense for me yeah some people can love that but but not nothing

it has to keep the same taste of the initial game that means because very often solo games are quite a different game and i don't like that because i want that it keeps the game experience i want to create yeah and the first thing is that you have to be you can lose you must have a possibility to lose it has not be just trying to make the best chorus possible because it makes no sense imagine you are lucky you play well and you make an incredible score you never want to play a game because you know that it's quite impossible to do it better so that means that it's like we are playing uh solitaire games the card game you want to play it a game because very often you are losing so you want to try again to try to beat the game so a good solo game has to has that inside for me what i am and that i try to create and what we did for example with a track 12. track 12 includes a solo mode and it keeps all these three patterns for me that's it so and you know i'm developing yet a game which is named original which will be published next year by a french publisher named catch up and the publisher asked us to develop a solo mod at first i say no

because i had no good id but at least it came and now we we have a slow mode which will be included inside so that means that as far as i'm in position to respect these three rules i said before i'm okay to do solo version well those sound like excellent rules that you would have for yourself and also as someone who has talked a lot about solo gaming in the past a year and a half those are a lot of the things that i look for in good solo games as well they should feel like good approximations of the multiplayer experience you should have a way of losing so that way you actually have some sort of variance from game to game i i think those are excellent design decisions but i i am interested to hear kind of your your thoughts on why you don't really like seeing fan variants because to me you know let's say i have a copy of five tribes which i do it's on my shelf it's one of my favorite games but if i have a copy of five tribes and then i had a game group but i've since moved to another community and i don't have that same game group and so i think about it i'm like man five tribes is one of my favorite games i wonder if i can figure out some way that i can have fun with this and enjoy it in a way that kind of approximates the feelings i have with it normally and then i go hey this kind of worked out i'm just going throw

it out there on bgg if anyone else wants to play it here's what i came up with i can see that as the the innocent version of what someone's doing and coming up with any sort of variant not just solo variants but variants that they come up with generally i'm against house rules when it comes to games um and solo variants are in a way a house rule but i i do want to hear kind of your perspective as the career game designer on authorial intent and and why you want official versions of the solo modes first i have to say than when people love my game so much that they want to add something from themselves inside i'm very happy i'm proud of that and i'm really uh and i agree that they do it for themselves to publish it and i will understand why in fact if um if i'm working on an expansion or of any add-on in one of my games first i have to develop it then i have to convict my publisher which can take time then it has to be it has you have to make the artwork the producer has to make the artwork then it has to be produced and released

that means that since my initial sparkling id and there it is it takes from one to two years okay during that time if you're on your side you are developing something you have your id you develop it you place it on the internet it's very fast for you and that means that i'm working on some things which can be quite close to yours and then when my ideas comes they could equal them as i have copied what you did i say and this is something which is very problematic for me i'm not comfortable with that that means that it's like people um they can't imagine that uh this way i could people could think that i'm just waiting for ideas and keeping them to publish them in fact and it's it's not an easy situation for us as game designers i've heard similar things in the past not within the specific context but actually when i used to be a really avid legend of the five rings card game player and i'm talking not the fantasy flight but back in the day with aeg the fan community was very dedicated but one of the things that anyone uh would say within the the community is if you have an idea for a card do not post it publicly because that will never

happen like aeg will officially say we cannot do this specific card or you know this idea because the risk the liability of being seen as taking someone else's uh information or you know if you actually have a suggestion then contact uh them directly you know and provide that as a suggestion um and i hadn't thought about that in years but it makes sense within this context i just try to explain my my point of view and and i can find people are free to do what they want and i won't never say them don't do that if you want to do that do it but don't use the official pictures don't use the logos of a game don't use the icons of the games because this is protected and this is as far as you what you are doing is not official don't take these images until you could have some problems in fact during this conversation we brought up a lot of games so far you've mentioned um track 12 and then we've also mentioned some uh examples shadow over camelot seven wonders duel you are someone who has worked collaboratively with so many game designers uh and some of your biggest hits are co-designed games when you are working on game ideas at what point do you say this would be a better code design to

work on with someone else or this is something that you want to take to completion yourself it depends from where the idea starts because very often the ideas are starting speaking with someone so if an id come when i i'm speaking with antoine or with bruno feduti or never for sure i want to develop the game with that person because it makes no sense for me to do it alone and that it depends of of the situation you know you know uh for me i still explain that creating means adopting and doubting alone is less comfortable but dating someone else yeah when i offer someone to make a co-design with me it's just because it's some someone i love and i want to do i want to share something special with him or her never mind and the the only situation where it was calculated is for dragomino because i wanted to do a kid version of king domino but i had no experiment for child games and wilfried and marie foreign which are famous french designers they

have something special with uh with child games for children and that's the reason why i met them on a game event and i went to them we had no relationship real relationship at this time just saying hello and i say i have this project in mind would you like to to go with me because i think i need your skills and then we work together but it's it's the only situation where it was calculated all the others it's just a question of friendship and it comes at what time that's it you know last time that we talked we talked about some of the games that really inspired you when you were a young designer and wanting to you know make your impact on the gaming world have there been games over the last couple of years where it's kind of changed your perspective on games or really made a profound impact on you i don't know if i spoke about this one last time we spoke together but i think the game would change something in my mind is risk legacy from rob the view oh yeah yeah it was changed everything yeah definitively and probably it had i didn't think of that before but probably it had an impact of what we did on track 12. it's it's not a legacy but you have some hidden content that

you will you will get more and more your progress it's not a legacy but it's something which is like that kind of a game experience in fact yes i think that uh definitively a world with his legacy system changed with all all the situation well let's talk about the the new game the new hotness trek 12 here uh and i i love hearing that uh this was a game that actually prompted me contacting you and being like bruno it's been a while we should talk about this uh the the game concept sounds great uh tell me about trek 12 what was the the genesis of this design the genesis of this design comes from more than 10 years ago wow reach it back you know now it's it will next year i will have been designing games for 20 years so that means that for sometimes i have sometimes some how to say i have to make some some meetings some some tokens in front of other people and very often when people ask me uh uh how to start a game i'm thinking about starting from the team starting from the mechanism of starting from the components which are the free starting point for me never uh losing in mind

but at the end which is important is the game experience and all of these three spots are only tools to create something and when i want to give an example for what is starting from a mechanism for years i was saying you roll two dice and then you can make for some you can multiplicate them you can take one or the other the highest value the lowest value you can make the difference etc and now this is a mechanism it's just other i had the mechanism in mind but i had no idea what to do with that but i kept that in mind and and we were in essen 18 i think probably or 19. the last lesson yes it was it was in uh 19. yeah pre-pandemic with uh with uh current algebra according to said ah i've played during the message i i've played a very nice small roll and right games we have to do how our run android games and and this reminds me my my mechanism and i say yes why not and we started to discuss with that and we found what to do with it and but at first it was only a mathematical game there was no story it was just mathematical and it was working very

well we presented it to lumberjack and he falled in love with a concept but he wanted absolutely to have a story and then it took us maybe three or four months to find a story which could work with this mathematical mathematical mechanism at first i really thought that there was no possibility that the game has to stay abstract and i'm happy that i changed my mind and suddenly i'm living in the mountains in in france and i imagine some albinism uh way etc yes that's it and immediately it worked and we developed a game like this and it has been quite quite successful here in france i don't know how it works in the other countries but uh yes and then the publisher asked us to go further to go and then we imagine to have this story with hidden content etc etc i i'm really glad that the theme actually worked in integrating into the existing design and that's something that i think a lot of people find surprising for even uh some of the most popular thematic games that they start with a mechanical origin or a different design like i i was doing a retrospective on the 1979

dune game which a lot of people hold up as one of the most thematic and immersive games to have existed or at least for a long time it was one of the most uh thematic and immersive games to have existed and some of the accolades that are given to the game are how well it represents the the written material but that game didn't actually start as a dune game it started as something else and then it was then pasted on th this term that's used as a as a i guess an insult to a lot of games these days oh i pasted on theme well dune was pasted onto this uh during development and it worked out beautifully um when you are designing a game is is it typical for you to start strictly with the mechanics or do you ever start from a thematic perspective and sometimes from the components for example kingdom you know the starting idea is to do a game with dominos there is no mechanism there was no theme at first it was just using the components this specific component to do something which is another way to to start something um for me i will say that um in in more than in quite 70 percent of of my starting points are coming from a mecha mechanism and then i'm thinking of

what kind of story could fit with that and immediately uh the story uh has consequences on the mechanism which has consequences of stories and and i try i'm not saying that i succeed each time but i tried to do that all seems to to be uh really uh going together since the beginning you are like you said coming up on 20 years of game design and as i started out this interview you've been very prolific and you also have some of the most notable games under your belt at this point do you ever feel in competition with yourself trying to outdo games that you've done in the past or feel like some of the designs that you come up with ideas for you end up scrapping because they're too close to any of the numerous games that you've already put out uh for for me it's absolutely not a competition it's not a competition with myself and it's not a competition with the other designers i just do it's quite selfish in fact i'm always working of a game i want to play myself and i'm designing games for my own taste and then i try to convict people to follow my path that's it and so so there is there is no competition it's just and i i don't need

to do a new game i want to do a new game which makes a difference that means that sincerity i think in what in what i'm doing is real uh if i don't have this sincerity i'm quite sure that people won't follow me because i don't know but how but they will feel that they will no i so since the beginning my way to work was the same and it was i'm designing the games i want to myself it's if i have not enough money with that i do something else aside and if the day where money will come in a sufficient way i will stop my flight job and it's what i did in fact four years i i made my own design and i was working in a game shop as a seller i was creating games for private companies for advertising i was making some some demonstrations extra a lot of small side job which gave me my money today i'm lucky enough to be able to focus only on my designs but i'm not doing them because i need to do one game more it's just because it's important to me it's my games are what i am in fact it's always a little of myself in the box so that's the reason why i'm

going on and without any competition feeling so they're games that you're passionate about what about the people in your home i mean you mentioned your your girlfriend's a gamer uh the 11 year old daughter in the home um do they always react positively to a game where you're like oh here's a new idea that i put together no not always for sure not but it's very important for me to have some sincerity at home right because i don't want them to say me hey you are genius i don't i don't need that i just need to have an objective point of view which i can agree or not but sometimes i'm doing games which are not focused to that kind of public so but but it's always interesting to me to have another side on my job there's the bruno catala who makes the the uh tons of small and delightful games the uh king dominoes the game of thrones hands of the kings of the world uh and then there's also the bruno catala who makes uh cyclades shadows over camelot cleopatra you know yamatai five tribes do you try to balance out the scale of games that you're designing or is it really just instinct whatever comes into your mind whatever you feel like playing and pursuing no it's exactly the second way that means that

at one at one time there is an idea which comes and which i i need to go on and never mind for me if it's a small or middle or a more heavy game i don't care it's what i want to do now so and i'm always for following this in this instinct speaking of cyclades i have to ask this comment just got like this big beautiful new edition you're holding something up in front of me and i gotta know more um cyclades was a a majorly impactful game on my own development as a gamer and becoming more interested in the world of uh game design and development and how games were made and it's also a very impactful game i think for many designs that have come subsequently a lot of people point to that game as a source of inspiration are are we kind of at a finishing stage for cyclades as it was would we see a new edition that consolidates or revamps cyclades in the future yes are we getting more expansions what what's the what's on the horizon for it it's a long story uh i started we started c-clades with matagots but with isham which was the owner of matagot at this time and for some different reasons

the society has split and isham is no more which was the creator of of matagot is now uh in a head a new company which is studio hash studio h so when there was a speaking we took or writes back just not not because any uh just because right this game was started with visham and we wanted to go ahead with him and that means that we also thought with a little bit that it was the time to reboot completely the game and what i was showing you is just a picture of a part of a new board because i'm working i've worked today deeply on that project and we are working to relaunch the game which will still be the secret as you know but with different boards etc because you know in cicadas there are a lot of things there was the basic box then the first expansion the second one with the titans and and some other small expansions extra all of this was modular but for us now all of this together is too much i agree and it's too much and i think that people don't really know what to take making their own choice etc it has been built like to be modular but but i think that most people

there are two situations they try to play all together which is too much or they don't know how what to choose and our vision is to try to do something we could name like the director's cut version of psychiatrists and we are working on it and we try uh we really try to to to boost the game that means that it has to be shorter you know at first it was not our intention but uh you have to to win you just need to build two metropoles right and uh hard gamers they don't want to build one and taking the risk to lose it so that means that they try to play being in position to get their two metropoles on the same turn and this goes to a game which is much more longer than what we wanted and that's the reason why we have changed some things inside just to have a game going very far to be more fast we want to play it in less than one one hour 45 minutes to one hour would be for us as a good target that is quite the consolidation especially with all the concepts going on but in a lot of ways this is some of the most exciting news that i've gotten uh in a while in gaming but it's also something that uh myself is someone who's played games for

ages at this point since i was a kid and mentioning legend of the five rings but uh also uh playing big box tabletop games i love seeing revamping new editions of some of my favorite games that maybe got expansions along the way but it could become a more cohesive experience if it were you know put out in this this new director's cut so this is this is exciting it do you have any thoughts on what kind of time frame this is looking at no because uh for us the game is the work is not finished yet as a game design situation so i think that we will have a version which will be fully designed for ludovic and me before end of the year and then it has to be decided how to publish it will it be a basic box will it be by kickstarter uh i don't know what my hope our new publisher is is planning for that we have a meeting next weekend because there is a game event in france uh we will be together and we will have discussion for that better i think you you have nothing to expect until end of next year or beginning of 2003 yes yep 2023 well that's about as exciting of a tease as i could possibly get and i could spend all this

time poking apart possible details on sick ladies but uh in the interest of time i i do want to hit on a couple other games that are right on the horizon we already covered trek 12 which is coming out before the end of this year if things are moving smoothly uh but then you also have king domino origins and nikki so tell me about these games so during the lockdown i published a print and played version which is kingdom innova court and it includes a way to use resource management into kingdom right but it would be too expensive to produce that kind of expansion and i love it because you know the game itself kingdom is not that expensive and to produce that kind of expansion the box will cost the same price as a basic burst that means that you won't sell anything but there is and i was hired to deal with the existing components and it creates a little unbalanced thing because some resources are coming on the small numbers which is an advantage and it breaks the way that that in kingdom you know when you take a small tile a small number you will have the first pick on the next turn but you you take something which is not very

useful and if you take the last one the highest number you will make a lot of points but you will take what is still there when it's your turn on the next time and the resources with the court breit broke a little that balance which is okay for printed print and play version but not for for a game on the market so i decided to uh to do a new kingdom from the beginning which is in a prehistoric atmosphere and to balance exactly the advertise the way i needed to include this resource management with small resources with small tokens like mammoths like silex like mushrooms which are coming on the tiles you can collect them you can spend them to recreate some characters you place on on the tiles and give you some extra extra points and it was also a way for me to introduce a new kind of of square of territory which is volcanoes and you know in prehistoric version there is no clones so the multiplying factor is fire okay i like it i like it it's promethium it's a fire war and sometimes are coming with fire but the volcano can project some fire and

you can increase the values of some specific territories with some extra fire tokens this way and this box is very interesting because it you have three different levels inside you can play it very very simply with family and childs without the resources just having the volcanoes spending some fires okay but if you add the resources when you have a second way to play which is a little more difficult but not not much which is just a mature you have a majority race on all the kind of resources and at least which is the most interesting but the most complicated you can use the connect versus and and use them to buy new elements to score points on it so in a single box you have three different ways to play and it's quite a complete and solid experience in my opinion and is there any sort of integration i know like queen domino there was the possibility of integrating with uh other games no no it's uh it's a completely standalone version and i know there won't be any expansion for that it's uh it's uh one shot it's got a bow tied on it then tell me about nicodemus i mean the name alone is alluring what's going on with nicodemus maybe you know a game which is named imaginarium oh yeah yeah so nicodemus is a pure two-player game

in the same team than nicodemus okay so it's also a game i designed with florence rx we made imaginarium together and then together we built a pure two-player game and at the end we were looking for for a team and yes but it was so evident that it could be the same story as the same kind of atmosphere as imaginarium it makes sense we presented it to our publisher and he said yes for sure we have to do it so it's a two-player game in the same atmosphere than imaginarium but it's a very different game it's not imaginarium for two players because imaginarium still works well right two players it's a different game in the same field in the same atmosphere that sounds awesome and both nicodemus and king domino origins are those both coming out before the end of 2021 yes the king domino is scheduled for beginning of october and nicodemus should be released something like end november do you ever sleep i i feel like over the course of the time in which it took to do this interview you probably came up with like six new ideas for board games or you could have in the same amount of time but you know an idea an id doesn't make a game i guess that's a good way to to leave it

because we've talked a lot about your output and you know that you have been so prolific uh but i think it's important for people to realize that you are a full-time game designer and for as many amazing games as have come out you've probably scrapped tons of games not so much not so much not so much i i that really surprises me frankly speaking i think that uh behind me i have probably since the beginning five prototypes for which are which have not been successful finding a publisher and how old are those prototypes sometimes 15 years or so that means that you're actually holding on to them in some ways right but you know it's it's it's connected to the way i'm working that means that before making something before working on a prototype i'm just thinking the most as possible when i have a sporting id how it could work and as far as i'm not in position to imagine very interesting gaming situation i don't start a prototype that means that probably some of my colleagues have more wasted prototype because just because immediately when they have an idea they begin to to build something i don't do that i prefer to focus on

imagining situation and i began to work on the prototype types only if it works in my head i would love to live in your head for just about 10 minutes well bruno i am so glad to have had you back on the cardboard harold you are looking happy and healthy and excited and in spite of all the things that are going on in the world right now you're still putting out games and i am loving it uh this has been such a pleasure and i'm looking forward to seeing everything on the horizon especially that psych ladies revamping that sounds so cool the director's cut thanks for coming on to the show bruno thank you very much if you enjoyed this video we have all kinds of other reviews interviews and recommendations via writing podcasts and video here on our channel and website cardboardherald.com our content is audience supported so if you want to show your support please visit our patreon thank you so much for watching this has been the cardboard herald

Progress saved