Skip to main content
Loading video...

10 Game Mechanisms I Want More Of - Episode 1

Transcript 20:45

hey everybody today I'm going to be starting a brand new series talking about mechanisms that I would love to see more of so again these are very particular parts of games that I think are very compelling and I think they could be recycled in future designs because they are that clever now before I get started on the 10 games for this episode I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor kendra. co.uk who are my goto online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code code then you can get 5% off your first order and I should say before we begin that these games are in no particular order in terms of preference or anything like that but let's start at number 10 and at number 10 I have the slide puzzle mechanism from juicy fruits so juicy fruits very simple game little resource um management collection style game but the kind of core focus on the game is this kind of old traditional slide puzzle where you know you have this kind of tight little board where you're going to be moving little tokens as far as you want kind of horizontally or vertically and depending on how many spaces you skip over that's how many resources of a particular type that you'll get so you can kind of free up runways to get more efficient moves um but I think of the potential of this mechanism there are so many different things you could do with it so for example you could build the mechanism around what's revealed under those tokens or maybe wherever that token has hit that's for the resources you'll get

stuff like that so I really do think the potential for this mechanism is you know I think we' barely scratched the surface I do like what juicy fruits has done with it you know in terms of how far you move is how many you get but again there are so many ways you can invert that mechanism and make it different and as far as I'm aware and I I could be wrong on this there are no other games that have used that mechanism apart from juicy fruits at least nothing of significance and um I really do think and so much untapped potential there so that is the slide puzzle mechanism from juicy fruits and number nine I have the retreat mechanism that I've seen in a couple of different card games for example I've seen this appear in games like air land and sea and also a game called elements and I believe there are other games that have done this as well so what I mean by this Retreat mechanism is that you are incentivized to give up earlier in the round if you don't think things are going to go your own way so it has this kind of push your luck Chicken Star mechanism where you need to assess your state of play kind of really early in the game because you know if if you want to fight to The Bitter End and then you lose you are going to suffer a lot more kind of catastrophic consequences as compared to kind of reading the room reading the state of play and backing out early so I think the prime example of this is air Land and Sea where if you

again you don't like your bunch of cards maybe the first play isn't looking good for you you can say you know I'm going to pass the round I'm only going to suffer negative one point or only going to give my opponent one point compared to giving them six points as if I fight to The Bitter End so again I love that idea of the the mind games that can come into play here in terms of trying to intimidate your opponent by maybe playing really powerful cards at the beginning and the rest of your hand is rubbish so therefore they might kind of get the a misconception of what your actual state of play is or the reverse of that where you want to maybe play some weaker cards in terms of L with the aim of luring your opponent to play more cards and then hopefully stop playing your more powerful cards and then making or forcing them to stay in the game therefore you are going to get more points when you win so so clever it adds a whole kind of meta decision into the game um and it just yeah it really UPS tension for me especially when it comes to air Land and Sea so I'd love to see more of that every time I've seen it it has worked wonderfully so that is the retreat mechanism from AirLand and sea next up I have the worker programming mechanism from Vasco de GMA so Vasco de GMA pretty straightforward worker placement game but this programming mechanism completely throws the game on its Edge where you need to think ahead of how your workers are going to trigger and the do they trigger in so every single work in this game has an

initiative value assigned to it so you know one is going to trigger first and 20 is going to be the last one to trigger so you need to be making sure that you are placing your one say here um to collect the resources that you need for your say number seven worker and then you want your higher your higher valued workers which are going to be slower to be the last thing to trigger essentially um and put them in the relevant place but the fact that you have a race for the spots in the first place Because the actual worker placement slots are limited you are pulled in a lot of directions because you know you might have a really low initiative value um token but you might not need to place that yet because that you know that nobody else really wants to go to that particular Zone um very clever it is a brain burner it definitely makes you again think in a different dimension but um again I think the potential of this is completely untapped especially when you add in kind of layer to that mechanism where you can actually end up bidding for the workers in the first place so you know in vas the gamma for example you um have to use this little push your luck game in terms of getting the lower valued workers which the ones you really want um because they're going to be so fast to trigger but that comes at a risk and know you can make that a bidding mechanism you can do any kind of pushy Lu mechanism in terms of claiming those um so yeah surprised we haven't seen much more of this and again to my knowledge um I again I could be wrong um I think Vasco de gamma is the only one to really kind

of focus on that mechanism next up I'm talking about fome and in particular the deck delving mechanism as I like to call it where you are very carefully managing your hand of cards and the order in which you play these cards um and this has some similarity to similarities to a game like Concordia where you you're playing a bunch of cards and you're playing one card to pick up all all the cards you've already played in order to continue with the game but the Twist on F is that when you choose to pick your cards up I think it's only the first three of them are free and from then on you have to start paying to pick up more cards which means you have to be very careful about the order in which you play them because the early ones you play are going to be quite expensive to retrieve so what it means is that you might want to play your cards that you're not too fussed about keeping hold of because of course you're constantly deck building you're going to play them first so they they don't come at a premium to get your better cards back and you can't even skip over cards so you have to pick up every single card along the way again it makes the decision making so much crunchier so much more meaningful and I tend to like games that put a focus on the prioritization of certain actions rather than just doing what you want and hoping things work out you have to very meticulously plan what you want to do and when that comes hand in hand with a you know a Euro efficiency Style game it's just a wonderful blend of mechanisms so again never seen this mechanism used before I tend to like

games that put a focus on tiand management and F's kind of deck delving mechanism I think is a great example of unta potential so that is the deck delving mechanism in th next up I have a mechanism from one of my favorite designers but not one of my favorite games from this designer so this mechanism is featured in stefen feld's carp DM and the mechanism in particular I'm talking about is the scoring mechanism where at the start of the game you're going to have a ton of these variable objective cards which are going to be your scoring cards and you're going to be putting them I believe in a 3X3 grid and all these different scores will have cards will have different scoring criteria on them so you know x amount of points for doing this and this and this um but at the end of each round you can place your scoring token in between two of those cards and once that particular spot between two of those cards has been claimed nobody else can claim it for the remainder of the game so if you're really focusing on one thing you can try and score that first and then shift your priorities into something else um and and it does mean that the player interaction comes to the Forefront of the game because if your opponent is doing exceptionally well in one particular kind of field of the scoring then you might even be encouraged to hate draft them or hate score them by going to that particular spot to stop them from scoring it you know might not be great for yourself but the kind of

net gain or net loss might be beneficial to you to prevent your opponent from scoring that particular combination of cards again especially when you do have variable objectives it completely adds you know almost exponentially the uh the variability of the scoring and the replayability and the feel of the game in terms of the objectives that you are reaching for so again I'm surprised I don't see more of this mechanism um you know kpdm isn't actually a game I love I think it's a good game but I think that scoring mechanism is fantastic and I want to see uh more of it it really does up the tension when it comes to the scoring part so that is the adjacent scoring cards for KP DM next up I am talking about another mechanism from the great Stefan Feld and this mechanism I'm talking about is featured in games like Amsterdam uh or the original maau and the mechanism I'm talking about is the resource wheel now this is a fascinating and definitely a brain burner um style mechanism that forces you to think ahead so basically the idea I'm thinking about is when you draft resources or when you take resources the fewer resources you take means you'll access them earlier so the way it's implemented in the games I've mentioned is that when you draft a particular die um you're going to get resources assigned to that D color so for example you get if you draft black six you'll get six black resources if

you dra to black one you get one black resource but the Twist on the game is that if you take those six black resources you're going to put them on this resource wheel that will rotate once per round meaning that you will not get those six resources until six turns time and if you take four resources you'll get them in four rounds time and so on so if you as you can imag you are forced to think ahead if you're more of a tactical thinker you can only think one or two rounds ahead but you'll be getting fewer resources and therefore be less efficient by taking that particular route so you are you are forced almost pigeon hold at least if you want to be good at this game to think ahead and you know when you're reaching for certain goals you could imagine that if you take say six resources in this round and then in two rounds time you draft a four then those four resources are going to be on the same spot as those six resources were two rounds ago therefore you can line up kind of super turns um genius mechanism I've never seen it before um and it is so well implemented um I'm terrible at doing the mechanism but I'm it's kind of one of those mechanisms that makes me want to come back to a game and scratch that edge and try to almost conquer it and be better at it so great idea that is the resource Wheels um for Amsterdam or maau next up is a mechanism that I do try to talk about as much as possible um on the channel because this is a tragically underrated game uh this is the cache mechanism for

pergamon so pergamon very simple little kind of set collection style game but the money mechanism of the way you gain your currency is fascinating as you kind of have this greed style mechanism where every round you are going to have two cards and you not you're not quite sure what exactly is in or on the other side of those cards in terms of the money on them so you got these chests which will have the high amounts or these little bags that will have the lower amounts but I can't remember the exact figures but let's just say in those bags there might be somewhere between one or four coins and in the chest there might be somewhere between like four and eight coins something like that so you have a a kind of parameter of what could be in the bags but you don't know exactly and what you're going to do in turn order is you're going to repl placeing at your little worker on this track and on this track it will show how much money you are willing to take from the bag and if you go earlier as if you say I'll only take three coins from that bag then you will get the first Pickins when it comes to it but you could of course be quite greedy and say I want seven coins from the bag but every player before you is going to take from that bag before you and you'll be left with what's left if anything you know sometimes there'll be lower amounts they so going very low on that price priority order it might not be great in terms of the money you get but you might stop anybody else getting anything else so again it's all about how greedy you want to be sometimes it's going to pay off big by taking the remainder what's in the bag sometimes

you're going to get bitten by doing that but it's a really cool decision especially when you're planning ahead with what you want to buy is it worth taking a big gabble to have a massive turn or do you want to be a Steady Eddy you know be a bit more predictable and be satisfied with what you've got so yeah love that me M this is truly a unique mechanism that I've never seen before and it is uh kind of the the focus point of when I think about a game like pergamon it definitely does differentiate itself from so many other games of that weight caliber because of that sweet and unique mechanism um so that is the the cash or the currency mechanism for pergamon next up is a mechanism that I've seen in a couple of games now in particular games like tenis Trail or Carson City and I believe there are more games that have done this uh this is the idea of converting money into points more efficiently earlier in the game so this works really well again in kind of Euro or economic resource management style games where money is such a vital resource in the game but at certain checkpoints in the game you have the opportunity to get rid of your money to trade it in for victory points but you have to kind of strike that perfect balance of leaving enough money in your kitty so that you can actually progress in the game and keep buying what you need to buy but getting a better ratio by doing it early so you get kind of rewarded for taking a bit of a risk you

know do you want to cash in you know 50% of your currency even 75% of your currency to get a really good conversion of points but maybe leave yourself in a very tight and restrictive position in the future rounds where you're not quite sure that money you're going to get is going to come back or you know you haven't got that little Nest Egg to rely on now I particularly like this in tenis trail where the market is always in flux um and you even get better priority or you get better conversion rates based on the passing order as well so you do you want to pass early get a really great conversion rate um and go from there or do you want to again make sure you've got that little security blanket in terms of having the resources save them right to the end yes you can trade them all in at the end but you've missed out on a lot of points where you could have not done you didn't even need that money anyway so you could have converted it into victory points at a much better conversion rate um wonderful idea again it's it's one of those games that puts a whole different decision on you a kind of a longer thread of a decision in terms of a strategic choice so love that idea of that early conversion for better points ratios as compared to waiting until the very end next up I have a mechanism that was featured in a game called Shakespeare a kind of a lightweight Euro uh this is the idea of bidding workers uh in order to get turn priority so you are actually bidding to have fewer workers for the

round in order to go first so I believe in this game you have like five or six workers potentially um but you can say you know what I'm willing to only have two workers which of course is not great at all um in order to get first priority and this is great for like worker placement style games where there is a real scarce availability of taking certain actions and the cool thing about Shakespeare is that it's often a very viable choice to only take one you know two workers into the round as opposed to getting you know five or six subpart actions that you didn't exactly want yeah yeah you're getting a lot more for your turn but but you're not getting the exact spots that you needed um there's even different dimensions you turn on this one which the um the expansion for Shakespeare did explore where if you are saying I'm willing to take say two workers into the round that means the remaining four points I would have had of the four workers could be used for something else so you know are you willing to take six of this currency to take none of this one or two of this one to get four of this one and so on so there's different ways you can approach this but again I tend to love games that put a real focus on going first or ways you can manipulate or bid for for or you know interact with your opponents in order to get that initiative at priority and I think the Shakespeare mechanism is probably one of the best examples I've ever seen of a turn you know initiative mechanism being used to an excellent standard so that is the the bid or the bidding mechanism to take priority

actions in Shakespeare and the final mechanism I'm talking about today was featured in a game called cashar at Merchants of the sil Road and the mechanism I'm talking about is this Caravan mechanism where you have Columns of cards so you're going to start with I believe only three columns of two cards and whenever you play a card which has to be at the Forefront of one of these columns you're going to take that card and remove it to the back of that particular column and you're adding more cards to the columns as you go and what this means is that you have the kind of autonomy to line up sequences of actions perfectly so another game that really rewards strategic planning and you thinking ahead because you might want this card to trigger and then this one and then this one meaning that you want to bring certain cards to the Forefront to again activate that particular sequence of cards in the right order to be as efficient as possible so it kind of blows my mind that this this mechanism has not been you know mainstream it's not been widely implemented in many games considering how many deck building games there are out there for me this just seems like just infinite untapped potential this should be as common as de the deck building mechanism itself in my opinion especially when it comes to those conversion style games you know convert these resource into this resource or Le engine building style games is what I'm trying to say um again maybe I'm the person who has to do this because it seems like this is um just

getting crazy unexplored potential and I think it's a mechanism that anybody can latch on to considering how popular deck building games are and it's all in front of you I love that the idea that you can see your entire display of cards at all times um and you have a complete again autonomy and control over what you want to do so a really cool game I think it was sadly capped by a limited array of cards it could have done with more support in terms of expansion material but that mechanism is a work of art so that is the Caravan mechanism in cashar so there we have it that concludes the video I hopefully you have enjoyed it because I do have a few more of these to come now if you have enjoyed it please be sure to hit like And subscribe to the channel and check out my other content too uh but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved