When a Board Game Stops Being a Game and Starts Being a Puzzle - Stella's Tabletop Diary
Transcript
it's one of Bohr gaming's great philosophical questions when does it stop being a game and start being a puzzle we discuss after this hi it's Tarrant and Stella from University welcome back to our tabletop diary sir in this episode we're talking about game puzzle same different and so on I just talk in bullet points here so challenge what make you think about this and then what is a game what is a puzzle and what are the games that is a puzzle maybe maybe not yeah I think I think all all games have an element of puzzle yeah most games maybe if it's more of a roleplay thematic less puzzle II but certainly most of the games we play have a deep element of puzzle but we we should coordinate yeah Jaguars tigers and you know stripe here anyways we do have this strife I'm distracting Terra he's a good guy yes yes where was I the game the game I think all I mean all
games have an element of puzzle yes but what brought this question to my mind was when we played co2 second chance and it's a co-op game and you have almost all the information at the start of the game not the fossil power yeah there's a couple of things yeah you you're technically not meant to know each other's cards although we because it was their first play we didn't adhere to that even so I think it would be difficult to strategize without revealing some sort of informational being able to sort of infer pretty easily there was what concentration of fossil fuel plant came out out of the deck it's been twenty Twenty twenty and twenty three forty it's hidden information but it's not you wouldn't change your strategy based on what's coming out you kind of you still do the same thing you just want to avoid them okay the only time it matters is once you get to stage four it tells you where where you want to overbilled plants to get rid of one of them and you can kind of pivot on that during the game so you sit what you see after round one pretty much tells you what to doing round two so that's almost perfect information so what's the definition of a puzzle rubble then again then so what's a game
what's a puzzle according to you yes I think like when we were playing co2 because all the information was there we could kind of map out every turn mm-hmm from the start almost and the game couldn't really do anything to us mm-hmm it couldn't fight back it didn't have anything there was no mechanism that made the game fight back and so I felt like we were collaborating on a big like a big pseudocode with game mechanics rather than competing against the game and it was the first time I really felt that playing a game doesn't mean it wasn't a good time but it felt yeah it felt like one big puzzle and like it still had the game mechanics and if we had you know we could have played it without communicating and gone through the actions and sort of played it in a more gamey way because then you would have had the uncertainties of of each other but the way we're doing it with full communication and seeing each other this car is all we did wrong maybe yeah we don't always see each other's car the other action cards are kind of like he didn't as well well yeah but at the same time I was saying I've got the card to do this action let me do this one alright okay yeah then maybe that's why but still beside that if we still hide
some informations is that a puzzle well he said less of a puzzle yeah I think as I think they're all puzzles I think the question is does it stop being a game and I was comparing it to pandemic and we you know we've played through season one we've played various other games of it there's a very mathematical puzzle element to that because at any given point in time you know what cards are in the top section of the deck if you had an epidemic you can work out what is worst and what is best and what is most likely and you can you can basically do like a full risk matrix and determine the optimal move very much which is very mattheum very puzzling but at the same time you don't know what the game's gonna throw at you it might do something else so is that means that does that mean it's still a game that uncertainty that luck base is that make a puzzle more like a game I think it makes it I think it still feels like a game because you've got the board acting as an opponent and because even in a in a multiplayer game if we're if we have if it's a worker placement game I can look at what you've got on the board I can work out how likely it is that you're gonna take the spot I want and whether I have to go in there so I'm
doing the same process I'm risk matrix sing everything out based on what I've got and then making the optimal choice and trying to fit together a sequence that's going to meet my objectives in a puzzle way that's you know that's all the same it still got that heavily puzzle element it's very much a game because we're both trying to fight for those Vantage's and I don't know what you're going to do I think that's the thing that made co2 feel very different for me is that the game didn't have anything that I could do to me I didn't have to pivot my strategy based on what happened I could work it all out from the start so would that means that the escape room type is there a puzzle there very much puzzles there's basically puzzle and I think in those cases they don't really have a mechanic sometimes there's a game mechanic thrown in I guess you look at games like the like the adventure game yeah he's like babe ii choose your own adventure adventure they have this little game mechanic in there but it is fundamentally puzzle yes so so Wendy what do you think where what do you thing in where a game starts becoming a puzzle or something stop becoming a game and a puzzle have you experienced that have you play co2 how you play a game that you think is more a puzzle than a game can you please write in the comment section feel alright because we want to
know you maybe wanna have a look into it again it doesn't mean that we don't like the puzzle it just means that that's a game for puzzle is you really cube a puzzle yes it's a thought that's a puzzle until it becomes an algorithm yeah well it's basically that's like a puzzle is like informations out there you tries to solve it and he just like a work way work your way to solve it well a game is like not on informations out there there's maybe boom escalation uncertainity bit a little bit lock base push your luck and so on and then you get to something you're going to a well-known game Dominion yeah and let's specifically think Dominion where there are no attack cards so you when you get in that situation it's almost multiplayer solitaire you're right you and a major part of your game is looking at what's going to score the most points and then trying to run that strategy and really the only interaction in a case like that is how quickly is someone chasing the end of the game and do you have to go fast or slow to meet that it feels a company a broken calm but yeah it still feels like a game and maybe is just because it's turn-based hmm but you other than the fact that
someone's action terminates the end of the game you could go to different room set the cards up in front of yourself and play for like a set number of turns and see who's got the most and then that would just be side by side puzzles almost I think I would I mean it always feels like a puzzle when you don't have other people sitting across from me but what come across mine this is not a puzzle Spirit Island mm-hmm a cooperative games that we like to play it's it's not it's a little bit like pandemic the game controls thought that you'd like depending on well depending on the cards that you ver feel like which one that the Explorer is going to build which ones they're gonna explore explore explore yeah you know what I mean by there's a lot of think II like a lot of hustle and falls as well there's a lot of puzzle in that one I was reflecting on that because you don't have perfect information but you have a lot of the information and when the explorers pop out that's where you start thinking about the bustle bit like it what are you going to do next in the next few turns yeah it's always what the game's throwing at me is I've got a couple of turns to react it doesn't have that immediacy that pandemic has maybe that's why I feel like pandemics more of a game because the game can just go wow outbreak no no no yeah it can like it can hit you immediately spirit island hits you slowly cuz you've always got two turns to prepare for the ravaging
Wainwright explorers pop out and so I think it fits somewhere between those two because I think you do have yeah the game doesn't feel like it's taking turns to mess me up yeah yeah it feels like it's setting in motion the puzzle that I have to solve so maybe that's yeah I think it's halfway between I still I still find it I'd still call it a game yeah I wouldn't say it's not a game we should play with other or different powers as well but that's true them yeah there are more immediate um there is more immediate thing we've mostly played bass so there's some immediate thing that comes with the weather other power ones yeah so that's it if you have anything SSA wrote in the comment sections below we'll check the game's tail we'll get back to you and if you enjoy our discussion if you like this video as usual please hit the like button it will help us and if you haven't subscribed to us let's consider some throne subscribing to our channel hit the maple in the corner as well and hit the bell so you want you won't miss anything from us I also share my boardgames journey on into them so hopefully I will see you there too until next time bye