Top 5 Board Games BETTER than Everdell
Transcript
what's wrong with everdel why am i targeting everdel as the game that i want to find alternatives to there are so many specific gripes or like even minor complaints about the game and i want to share some other options some things that address a few of the game's weaknesses so what is the criteria for games that are on this list well first of all the only games that i'm going to share are games that address a specific weakness about everdel i could just make this five games that i like a lot but then why would i call the video five games that are better than everdell it has to address a specific thing about everdel that might make the game different or worth considering secondly it has to be a game that's available for purchase right now so any games that are out of print i just left them off the list but speaking of being available to purchase if you are interested in any of my recommendations can i ask that you use the affiliate links in the description i am building a web app and if you want to know more about that project then you can check out the link up above or also in the description but basically using those affiliate links helps generate the access to the api that i use for that web app and you can learn more about that down there just helps out a lot so thank you for that thirdly in the criteria it has to be a game that's approximately in the same category so i'm not going to choose any card games i'm not going to choose uh any cooperative games or games that
are like four hour role playing games anything that anything like that this is a kind of mid-level complexity competitive game and so all of the games on my list are comparable and that's in that regard so with that let's go ahead and get started the first gripe that i have about everdel is really the theme and uh it's a gorgeous game it has these lovely components but really the theme is mostly restricted to the artwork itself like when you take away the tree and when you take away the board evernote at its heart is really just a card game you're trading resources in order to buy cards to help you get more resources to buy more cards and the person who has the most points on cards wins like a lot of card games it has a lot of luck involved oftentimes you're waiting for the right card to be pulled out of the deck and then many other card games and everdell included lack meaning and really the theme of everdel which is animals building a city doesn't really come through in the game it comes through in the artwork for sure it definitely comes through its components but why why does uh why does a husband get three fruit in order to uh be constructed whereas a shopkeeper which is in here somewhere takes oh here innkeeper this one has one fruit like why this is a badger doesn't badgers eat more than a mouse i don't know a game that has a lot more meaning involved in fact a significant amount of meaning is the game suburbia which has been around for a while it's not as new and as flashy
as everdoe in suburbia you are also building a city and everything about suburbia makes a lot of sense like if you put a junkyard next to a residential area that's going to affect your reputation in a negative way and if you uh build a stadium then you're going to have more people move to your city or higher population like things really make sense and not only do they make sense when you build in your own city your actions make sense and how they affect other people's city it takes careful planning and even though there's a lot of text on cards that you have to read much like these have text on cards really i mean there's a lot of reading in this game um suburbia has a lot of reading too but it's much more there's much more intuition involved um industry gives you more income whereas residential housing gives you more people like these things make sense suburbia really solid game however not as new not as flashy as evernote so if you're looking for something that also has a strong theme strong meaning but a little bit newer a little flashier i recommend tang garden tin garden came out in 2020 it's a stunning game now it doesn't have as much meaning as suburbia but it still makes a lot of sense so basically uh in tan garden you're building a
garden and the ultimate objective at least i like to think is the garden needs to satisfy the people who visit that garden now in terms of what the people's tastes are that's a little arbitrary the hermit likes stones he likes to look at rocks why does the hermit like to look at rocks why does the emperor like to look at dragon artwork like i don't know people like what they like but when you're doing it you're like okay i'm doing this because i want to satisfy the empress or you know whatever it is um the way that things connect makes a lot of sense uh the the decorations like you have to grow the garden in order to create space for the decorations to go and if the decorations don't have space then you can't place the decorations and so you're always asking yourself how can i set up the board in order to place the decorations that i need in order to get the highest score it has a lot more intention behind it and i mean it's stunning i would even say prettier than everdell well i mean evernote is impressive right so those are two games with excellent themes excellent meaning let's talk a little bit about the element of luck in everdel so in everdel uh you know there are some ways that luck balances out but unfortunately with a card game like this you spend a lot of time waiting for the right card to come out and i've definitely played this game and it felt like gosh you know what like
the cards that you had were awesome the cards that i had sucked i couldn't have won it was impossible to win um they just bad luck in this game and that can spoil a game for me so i like to have a game that has more strategy and less luck now i do have a list i mean i think suburbia is another game that really has emphasized his strategy over luck but for a game that is beautiful and pure strategy check out photosynthesis photosynthesis you are planting trees in a forest and the trees have to grow and spread their seed in order to generate more trees and then all the while the sun is going around the forest and you have to grow trees in the sunlight in order to help them grow more and generate more energy which you use to plant more seeds to grow more trees and so you're competing with other people's trees and their shadows and so i mean the idea that like you know you're a small tree next to a big tree and when the sun's behind it the light doesn't shine on you makes perfect sense but there's absolutely no dice rolling there's no cards involved it's a game of pure strategy um which i really enjoy but it isn't always easy to find people who are willing to play a purely strategic game photosynthesis can actually almost be uh like depressing because you can tell
when you're getting crushed in photosynthesis it's completely a strategic game i really like games where the scoring takes place at the end of the game and you're you kind of like it's a surprise uh to see whether or not you've won which actually by the way evernote kind of has that too where you you kind of have a sense of who's doing better but you don't really know the score until the end of the game and i think that's a good thing about games it can make it really enjoyable but anyway this is my favorite game to lose by the way and it's also the highest rated game on board game geek but the game is concordia and 2014. it's been around for a while again it's more of a euro so it doesn't have as pretty of artwork but it's a much more involved game and actually um another thing about everdel is because uh each person's turn is pretty independent from everyone else you spend a lot of time waiting and not so much time paying attention to what other people are actually doing you kind of have your own plan concordia is a lot more involved and the way the cards get played out timing matters a lot there's less of a engine building element like everdell has but what i really like is in concordia you have a hand of cards you're holding your entire deck i guess you play your cards and for each turn you can't play your cards again until you play the card that lets you pick up all your cards so the timing of
when you pick up your cards to replay a card from your hand and also the way that uh the cards are played and affected by other people so you've got a board that you're sharing and people can kind of interfere with your plan so you have to anticipate and it's a much more involved game in that sense so that's concordia now lastly a game that uh one more that solves like one more problem with everdel and actually it's the only game except for photosynthesis that addresses this oh no actually concordia well here the complaint is there's a lot of reading in this and if you want to play a family game and you have younger kids kids can be bogged down by the amount of reading on all the text or they can say you know what well what does this card do what does that card do and that's not fun for the younger members of the family so a game that has a strategy that is accessible to everyone and has little to no reading involved at all also very pretty very attractive though is takanoko takanoko's been around since 2011 so a bit of an older game but i mean you've got a panda you've got a gardener you've got the little bamboo shoots the colors it's a beautiful game really accessible for all ages it doesn't have the same complexity as everdel which can be a good thing if you like complex games i probably
wouldn't recommend it but it's a great one to solve the problem of you know you like everdell but how can you play a game with your kids who really can't understand what the post office does so that's takanoko five games that solve some of the gripes about everdel not necessarily perfect games not necessarily better than everdell but if there are a few things about everedah that you're like i don't really like that so much uh definitely check out any of those five and again the links in the description if you would check those out that helps me a whole lot check out the uh the perfectboardgame.com if you'd like to look more into how i rate games and see how your game is rated and to even change those weights as well so if you like this video you know i make videos all the time about board games especially board games for families so if that's your thing go ahead and subscribe and i hope to see you next time thank you so much for watching bye