Looking back at Essen Spiel 2017: Games!!!
Transcript
hi i'm madame porter and this is my board gaming vlog and last week i got back from essence field 2017 the biggest convention in the world and i wanted to talk to you a little bit about the games that i saw and what i got up to at that convention now if you've watched my channel before you'll know that i don't tend to go for the same games as a lot of the other channels do and that's not really a deliberate thing it's just that my tastes seem to be a little bit offbeat compared to some of the other reviewers they like bigger more strategy type games are that small the family type games so there are a few of the sort of bigger releases that maybe I wouldn't have I wouldn't have picked up myself and I'll tell you some of the reasons why in fact you can see my sort of haul from Essen around me the games facing out front these are the ones that I picked up and some of them you may not recognize because they weren't that talked about at the convention so let's go through some of the big titles that I considered if I had all the money and and storage and everything else in the world then I would have got these games and Azul looks absolutely beautiful as an abstract game but I mean when I'm looking for games I'm looking for something very beautiful or I'm looking for something very new so a lot of really excellent solid games don't make it into my collection just because they don't fulfill one of those criteria that applies to things like miss fjord and river boats and Ottis and all manner of these sort of games that I'm sure I'm
absolutely certain at excellent games because I know the companies and I know they're there their previous games very very well equally it applies to some of the the big releases that were party games I mean when my dream looks very beautiful and Muse looks very beautiful I'm not sure I'm going to get a hugely different experience to some of the other games that I've played over the last few years so for now they're under two by one day sort of pile rather than by them immediately now something like charter stone I was really impressed by charter stone because I've enjoyed stigma stigmas games in the past and really liked viticulture I I thought it was a really fun interesting game but it looks so serious same thing as besides I've never played sighs it just looks so serious I like something with a bit of a lighter touch personally so so there's a lot of these things that that didn't quite make the cut things that look a bit silly or a bit lighter bunny Kingdom looks great kitchen rush looks great but they didn't quite make that into my suitcase so let's have a talk about the things that did well firstly let me show you untold adventures await in untold adventures away two players work together to tell a story in a five act structure inspired by rolling story cubes these are dice with icons which can be interpreted however you wish players begin by answering a few questions about their chosen setting and writing some notes they need to decide things like is
this past present or future where does the story take place and what is the tone is it comedy fantasy or high drama a tile is flipped to represent a dangerous dilemma players select story cubes to place onto the tile inspiring a location and a threat the tile dictates whether the threat is attacking or capturing or pursuing or accusing someone or something players now create their characters again they're filling out a short sheet and they're answering some questions they reroll and use the cubes to inspire them in this the board indicates that players can now collectively ask for questions about the scene and take four actions if they ask a question they take a question token they reroll the cubes and they use them to answer the question if a player takes an action they take an action token and they declare what they're trying to achieve they then turn over a card to indicate yes a success no a failure yes and which is an incredible success yes but which is success but with a price no and which is disastrous failure or no but which is unsuccessful but with an upside they may also be required to turn over a reaction card which shows the emotional impact on any one character of their choice and what's all actions and question tokens have been taken players turn over the next tile called the plot
thickens the cubes are placed to represent an evil ally or an evil master or a terrible secret or a dark agenda and the tiles indicate whether this is linked to the previous threat or to the previous personal thing that was under threat players now ask questions and they take tokens and then they move on to act 3 which is called an unheroic undertaking act 4 which is the truth revealed and then finally they wrap the story up in act 5 the final showdown each time they're selecting cubes they're asking questions and they're taking actions throughout the game each player can play tokens from their own supply to add an idea to another player's suggestion or to modify a role of a cube or to describe a flashback in time they can also flip their play pause card to force a timeout where all players discuss the direction of the story and whether they feel engaged with it when the story is complete players write some notes and decide whether this is a one-off adventure or whether the characters and settings they've created will become part of a bigger campaign I was blown away by this game when I played this game I it's incredible it's a few years ago I used to harp on about a game called I'll grab it here called winter tails this was released by Fantasy Flight after an initial sort of small print run Italian release very very few beautiful games storytelling game about a sort of twisted fairy tale world quite
hard to make it work though quite it takes quite a lot on the part of the players to kind of ensure that they collaborate and told that does that sorts it for you really it's got all sorts of mechanisms in there that brilliant thing where you can spend tokens to add ideas to other people's suggestions which means that you've only got two of those so if you're trying to have ideas all the time it becomes obvious and if a player hasn't really had any on input that's clear there on the you can see they haven't spent any tokens so let's give them a chance the opportunity to flip my card over and say write the whole time out you know I want to talk about this it's not quite working for me and explaining why brilliant I mean all sorts of things in there to control alpha players people who just want to take over some excellent storytelling mechanisms in there I'll probably make another video about untold because I was so inspired by it really but the the idea that the dice are color coded when you place them onto the tiles and so when you turn over a new tile it'll have a slot for a dice but it will have a colored border around it and this means you can either use a new dice or you can reincorporate a dice from a previous scene that that was in a similarly colored space I mean it the fact that there's only nine dice and they'll be on a common theme means that the story stays tight because the same sort of images come up time and again it doesn't go off into this meandering sort of mess of a story it stays tight it stays relevant things get reincorporated it's a tight beautiful structure really
gives you opportunity to look at all different types of stories as well in fact this is how inspired I was I got this parcel in the post this morning so here's me opening it up and this is pretty much the entire set of Rory story cubes that are available at this point I didn't buy some of the theme sets like the Moomins one or the doctor who set or the adventuretime set I went for Looney Tunes and scooby-doo because I know those worlds are a little bit better than the other the other worlds that the other sets had but I'm really looking forward to exploring all these different dice and what a beautiful component to use in a board game so I'm hoping it inspires some of my future designs as well talking of designs of course I had two of my own games out at the fair I had a doodle rush up here this is one of my designs and also Big Bazaar and I've shown those in different videos so you can go watch those if you're interested in those games other games that I picked up a divinity Darby so one of my favorite games is Harb and gute it's a stock and stock market sort of stocks and shares getting buying and selling stocks and by Carlo a Rossi that's been out of print for years only ever had a German release but it's a stellar game and it's because it's got two really unique mechanisms in it one of them is about shared information the other is about a sort of how much money you give in to charity you're not quite sure you can be eliminated from the final scoring divinity Darby is is a sort of development of that concept so here we
have mythical creatures racing around the board but we have a set of cuts to the right of us and a set of cards to the left of us and on our turn we can choose a card from the right and a card from the left but they're shared between myself and my neighbor on either side and one of the cards I play is going to be at full speed the other one is going to be at a reduced speed so I've got some control and some knowledge over how fast the creatures are going to go around the track and then we place bets and it plays out a bit like something like camel up I haven't played it yet but I think it looks great and if it's anything like carbon good I'm just glad to see something on that sort of system that's back in print from Aries games okay what else have we got we've got shuttles and let me show you shuttles in shuttles players represent Wizards literally tipping gnomes from a cup to send them out to do important jobs around the town the Cup has 15 gnomes in it and the player has one swift motion to tip out their desired number of gnomes the number of gnomes tipped out determines where on the board you can visit many of the locations are valuable you place a good onto a building and then you sell it the next time you roll that same numbered location in the meantime the goods increase in value whenever another player places are good on that same space but if you wait too long the good is discarded with no return at all some spaces force you to give money to other players or collect money from other players some force you to place money onto the board and
another location allows you to collect all the money that's been built up on the board what's all the storage spots for sold goods is filled up then the game ends and the player with the most money wins now if you've watched this channel before you'll know that I loves aqualad games and it's not because they're all brilliant games shuttle's has also of problems but the great thing is nobody who else would ever publish this and yet Jacques will do it what a great randomizer that it's throwing those things out of the cup there's a little bit of skill there but really you don't have that much control and that is the big problem in the game is that you're jumping about all over the board and you're trying to get one thing but which is really really good thing but actually you end up getting something that's a really really terrible thing and that's the thing that's usually funny about the game but also means that the game is extremely swingy you know you can win or lose the game based on a single turn a single toss of those gnomes across the board particularly towards the end of the game some of those spaces are so valuable and some of them are so terrible that that final toss of the gnomes will end the game for you potentially but it is also hilarious you know if I want the best possible space on the board I need to tip out 14 of those gnomes from the cup that means leave one in the cup but if I tip all of them out and get number 15 that's a terrible space to go to so we have these huge swings and I think it's most fun if you declare which space you're going for and then you tip the dice out and then we or the gnomes out and then we all laugh at whether you managed to achieve it or not I mean it's nonsense the whole thing but what a
great sort of experiment in a randomizer for a game I loved it I thought it was really really funny and had other games which look really great I haven't got to these yet there's a game called cafe fatal cafe fatal which are fatale which i think is not death cafe as I read it has it's cafe luck I suppose something along those lines this is by Brett Gilbert and trevor benjamin who are two friends of mine kimono is a remake of an old game but it's azog fur like a sort of prisoner's dilemma type game herbalism this is a deduction game from the same people who made kind of a cosy which was a great hit last year so I'm taking a chance on that sort of competitive deduction game got druids down here which is a trick-taking game or what else is around me here scribble time that's a little drawing game I've got sure this shiz that let me show you sureness shows that this is a really sort of imagining of no thanks it's exactly the same game is no it's just now coming from amigo spheal with this sort of obscene title sureness shizer and this great artwork so this is the cover of sureness shizer by amigo spyler the new version of no thanks and I wanted to show you the cards because I think that they're brilliantly Illustrated so here we have all sorts of awful things happening this man is being rescued but he's being rescued by the Titanic here there's a crocodile he's on the Treasure Island here there's a bird pecking at his hot-air balloon it's
about to fall off the cliff lion creeping up on him here squashed by an octopus going over a cliff some of these are really look at this one that's fishing and he's caught him on his hook he's effed some scissors inside him his wheels fallen off there's a fly in his medicine I mean some of these are really dreadful and sort of hilarious darkly hilarious look it's his pants have come off in the swimming pool a bird has ruined his ice cream let's say and here he's about to ruin his shoes here is satin some paint and so on so they're they're really really funny illustrations and what I particularly like is this is the the lowest numbered card in the deck and he's dreaming about a piano falling on his head and then the highest numbered card in the deck number 35 there's actually a piano falling on his head so this is no thanks by amigo spyler their style sureness shizer and the other game which i found I've been playing constantly since I got back from the convention is this little one here tokyo highway now one of the big games at the convention everyone was talking about was meeple circus a stacking game it looks so much fun people circus but there's some complications in that game you have to not only stack things you have to put them in certain you know you have to put a certain thing next to
another certain thing in order to score points there's lots of different opportunities and there's a bit of drafting involved and and I mean I think it looks great and everyone's Hellen me it's great but when I look for a dexterity game generally I look for simplicity and laughs and meeple surface another thing is the word meeple generally turns me off if isn't a title of a game some people circus mutant meatballs people war Terran meeples city all these things I just there's something about it that makes me cringe that word me people in the title of a game tokyo highway is a dexterity game but it's got a lot of positional sort of like an abstract strategy aspect to it as well but but not not heavy whatsoever and it looks stunning when you lay it all out let me show you in the two-player game tokyo highway each player has a collection of loads pillars junctions and cars the aim of the game is to be the first to get rid of all of your cars on a player's turn they place a new road they do this by first positioning a pillar it must have a height either one above their previous pillar or one below it they may never touch the opponent's roads or pillars if a player's Road crosses their opponent's road and importantly no other roads are already crossing it then the player can place a car onto the road and equally if a player places their road under an opponent's Road and no other roads are under it than they can place a car with really clever positioning sometimes a
player can place two or three cars in a single turn by putting their road under and over several of the opponent's roads in a single move junctions allow you to vary the height of your pillars without restriction and they also allow you to branch off in different directions but you only have three of these so use them sparingly if any roads are knocked over during construction they're rebuilt and the careless player gives pillars to their opponent as a penalty the game ends when one player uses their final car in this case they win or the game could also end when one player runs out of pillars and in this case they lose so I've shown you a couple of reprints there I've shown you well I suppose divinity Derby isn't a reprint but it's a reimagining of harbin good and then we've got the reprint of no thanks but the big really impressive reprint for me was tikal which is only available in the French language edition at the moment I don't think it's coming in in an English language version because Rio Grande they still have the rights locker this version of Tikal this is one of them well it is I think it's the most stunning board game I've ever seen and this is from super meatball I mean Mexico was amazing that the lovely resin pieces but this one with the stacking pieces and you compare it to the old one which was already really really nice the older version of Tikal this is an amazing achievement and I really and I cannot wait for Java next year from the same company and also their Mafia zu game looks good which is a reimagining of louis xiv i'm going to
hang on for an english version of that because i believe it's coming later in the year so i didn't pick up the french version albeit i think its language independent and if you're happy to sort of print off the rules from the internet is there anything else I need to tell you about s and spiel 2017 let me have a look around here and see we've got a few expansions I actually picked these up shortly before the fair but we've got the dream home expansion that's very good I played that now it doesn't make dream home heavy at all but it just gives a little bit more gamer II sort of set collection and and objectives to the game we've got the merry-men expansion for sheriff of nottingham which i think i mean i haven't played it but it seems to fix some of the issues that i had about the fact that if you always told the truth in Sheriff of Nottingham you could often win the game just by really not engaging with the core mechanic of the game which is lying and I think that's a problem with the game but merry-men fixes that because it's hugely incentivizes lying to the sheriff and there's an expansion here for Isle of Skye a la the Isle of Skye I looks quite a journey man now this one really does make the game a lot heavier haven't played it but I've read the rules and and there's a lot to be thinking about on your terms it's become a main event sort of game you know like a medium-weight euro rather than that sort of like medium thing that it was before and so I'm looking forward to trying that one out as well other recent games I've picked that London that was very good a remake of the old Martin Wallace game I'm sure there are others all the new I played the new catacombs and castles game catacombs nice reimagining of catacombs
I don't know adds a huge amount over the original game because it still got some complexity to it but it is shorter and it's sort of team-based so it's a nice variant on catacombs so anyway thank you very much for watching this video I hope you found it interesting I didn't mention the other thing that I was doing at essence fear which was meeting publishers I met many many publishers and it was fantastic probably 22 different publishers from all around the world and showing them different games so hopefully I'll have a few more things to show you over the next couple of years I know I've certainly got at least two coming up next year and yeah so I'll see you on the next video maybe I'll talk a little bit more about untold